Is David Tao still the king of Mando-pop R&B in 2023? 

經典要超越太難，因為在心裡記憶太深刻，第一次聽這版時，我覺得舊版還是比較好，不過多聽幾次之後，居然比較喜歡新版了，陶喆真的太厲害了

23版流沙很豐富，口琴與樂器的部分遠比97年版的處裡的還要好，但是我必須說這恰好證明97年版的流沙是一個跨時代的音樂作品。

完全同意 - 原版更悲伤更青涩 是男孩初恋的心事 新版是年纪渐长 经历了很多以后 对爱对自己的理解 和解 和温柔

真的好作品。听那么多年，新版本，依旧有味道又多了点新味道。这才是音乐的真谛和魅力！唉，此刻，我也想到了李玟。她也将手中的爱当成流沙吧。愿歌后在更好的世界尽情唱歌！一首陶喆的流沙，让我们想到的是自己听歌时的曾经！你呢，依旧心境年轻吗？祝大家开心过活！流沙，劝的就是要放手！加油！

Thanks Joe. Always enjoy your intimate interpretation and understanding of the songs 👍

流沙,除了動聽之外，陶喆人聲感情豐厚,口琴聲,清爽甜美，加上伴奏樂器音色，定位其準，結像力已達經典級數，更別說感染力之深，足以讓聽者不能自已.

Amazing analysis video. I really like it!

This brings me back to the memories like 20ish years ago when I first listened to David Tao and fell in love with his music right away. Liu Sha was not the first batch of songs I listened to because he has already got several albums by then. Listening to this new version, I still got the same sad feelings I used to have, which is great.

Great Job sharing the review

I really like your viewpoint about appreciating the musics. I learn a lot from you.

Joe, you're so cool! Thank you for this review.

舊版新版我都喜歡，謝謝Joe專業的分享。♥♥♥

Great comments Also like your new look without the beard!

What a amazing in-deep analysis of a piece of music!

Great review. Sounds super on my phone, so I imagine itd be awesome on headphones!

Old Song, new production, new vibe, new vision, new meaning and awesome review.

希望Joe可以做一期 ''小宇 宋念宇 ''的，一个很值得受到更多关注的实力创作者。

Joe對音樂的体悟總是非常敏銳深刻, 分析細膩用詞精準, 太棒了! 感謝你的分享與分析, 流沙真是一首很好聽+耐聽的歌♥

This is really good song from david Tao, and you make a nice comment in place, i love it,thanks for share

你的講解非常到味清楚❤

the classic, signature "oh baby" hits Joe again haha

Like ❤ ur new look!

the finest production❤

谢谢你的音乐解析 陶喆的歌真的太好听

新版的多了一種隨著年紀增長 而看得越開的豁達

Like your analogy.. Great!

真的多了一種溫暖太陽下在沙漠看風吹沙在流動的感覺

omg, that bass .... great lines all throughout.

謝謝你的分享

This whole new arrangement gave me an eargasm… Woot! 🥰

Thanks joe, you are the first English language music talk RU-vidr I subscribe. Through your channel, I hope to know more about how the western community talks about pop music and you can tell us more about how they produce pop music in the UK and US🙂

到現在去唱歌都還是會點沙灘，還是喜歡他那時候的舊歌，輕輕淡淡卻很深的情感。

講解的很專業，很棒👍

喜歡Joe的評論❤

陶喆真是很成熟 之前的版本就很成熟 现在陶喆根本就是把歌曲当作艺术品来创作 画面的配色质感很高级 声音有穿透力还很温暖 这么多年了 没有吃老本 一直再进步 太喜欢了 看看同时期的某人的歌词 越来越幼稚

想看Joe聽A-Lin《摯友 Best Friend》的反應，很好聽的歌!!我女神剛得金曲獎!!瞭解這首歌曲背後的故事之後哭慘!! I want to see Joe's reaction to A-Lin's "Best Friend". It's a great song!! My goddess just won the Golden Melody Award!! After learning the story behind this song, I cried a lot!!

舊版比較能打動我的心，新版本純欣賞

That's an interesting take on the meaning. I always imagined it as love slowly slipping away through one's fingers despite one's best attempts, hence the sad and forlorn musical arrangement.

so warm

WOW! You look much much younger with thin beard but the comments of the music still as good as before

其實任何大師級的創作者都會面臨一樣的問題 已經很經典的東西 過了2～30年後來重看 一定很想添一些當時覺得想做沒作到的東西進去 但是現在的自己 已經不是當時的年輕人 想要精進的心情也許一樣 但當年的風格已經回不去了 時代的風味 是任憑大師都難以完整留住的 它只會一直前進 時代氛圍的影響就是如此大 譬如金庸晚年的改版 讀者感想也是好壞參半..

Splendid review! I prefer the new version by a long mile.

從16到41歲的我，我聽的懂新版的心情，從愛情的無奈到成熟了

陶喆的音樂超棒的❤

新版也超好聽 陶喆真的太屌了

舊版聽起來有點憂鬱感 ，新版反而有點輕鬆感覺。感覺合切現在年輕新一代撇脫。 新舊版都好喜歡❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉。 Joe的評價也很專業。 ❤❤❤❤❤

Joe, after shave, looks handsome and young. 😂😂 Btw I like the new version, a new version more romantic feel 🥰

要火了 要火了 ❤

陶喆的 飛機場的10：30 超美旋律，歌詞也很棒❤❤

兩個版本我都喜歡😊

這首最近聽到，很讚吔!

我过了一段时间再听 发现新版真的更好听！

改的很豐富👍

天啊！舊版超愛，新版超讚，無法抉擇，陶喆真的是R&B之王，無人能超越

what a improvement of your Chinese too.🎉

可以聽得出他老歌新唱的企圖心，不管是演唱的技巧和音質都更提升～但失去了最純真的感動！

Go and listen to his newest song, titled 'Song for the world', it's equally awesome and written by him too 😌🎶👏

5:24 💯

Hi Joe , 很想聽你評論動力火車😉

wow young baby joe😂

Yes, He is!!!

初聽真的不太喜歡，但是認真聽了幾次覺得陶喆用堅決跟簡單的語氣與電鋼琴製造出溫暖的氛圍，像是回頭看年輕時的流沙，有一種豁達的心境，也有一點跟自己擁抱、和解的意思（以編曲調和較直接的唱腔不再追求太多轉音，畢竟喉嚨狀態也不允許了😢）

r&b教父宝刀未老❤❤❤

Hi Joe，希望有机会听你说说方大同的歌，Thanks！

听完新版的，就觉得不太得劲，特意又回去听了原版的，感觉还是原版的比较好听 就像joe说的，原版的编曲比较简单，但就是这种简单，感觉才和这首歌更契合 我认真的感受，第一段甚至能够让我想到一个人走在街上，路边只有一盏昏黄的路灯的那种寂寥和失落 新版的有些太丰富了，明明是首失落的歌，编曲却又有种向上轻快的感觉 个别字原版只是平淡的唱了过去，新版的加了假音或者升了调 给我一种林俊杰唱起风了那首歌的感觉 就是太多太炫了...

There is a live version of this song. Go search for it

Joe, strongly propose to listen to 飛機場的10：30

我最喜欢的一首

03:00 跟讀 06:38. 雙輔音。 Absolutely pleasure on the ear that A Plea

Joe感觉你中毒了，哈哈哈哈哈哈

只能说陶喆的歌永不过时，几十年后再拿来编曲重唱又是一首流行歌曲

新版更加有穿透力，这是不容置疑的。

Shall we do some reaction of songs written and sang by Dayou LUO ? He is one of the first generation of most famous and productive singer-songwriters and a singer who sings with soul. Strongly recommend his songs “你的样子”, “鹿港小镇”, “追梦人 “,”之乎者也”等 . ❤ I bet you ‘ll love that. Wish you would see this comment 🎉

是重錄嗎？還是唱的部份再編輯過

非常喜欢陶喆这首歌。了不起的乐评人，对中国文化隐喻的理解，比我还要独到和深刻。

Hey Joe,留着你的胡子por favor!!!

老版：我就是blue， 我就是任其放生，頹廢或死我都接受 這深深影響了一個人。它代表，在感情上越努力，可能是越失敗

台灣的歌手製作人真的太優秀

it sounded like he is having a recap of the age long sadness

听听方大同！！！

WTH! So cute without beard!

陶喆很棒..方大同的也很棒

小時候第一次聽陶喆 他都音樂真的很新 就是… 和當時台灣音樂市場 截然不同的那種

I don't understand but Listening brother's songs combining music, Love from Northeast India, state Arunachal pradesh means Land of raising sun.

許願 陶喆 - Melody

雖然是冷飯熱炒，但新版比起舊版聽起來真的更爽一點，每次聽舊版總覺得少了些什麼，新版都把他補足了

江蕙 Taiwanese Queen,I always wondering what's ur comment after listening? Please take some time google and eujoy it😊 Trust me,that would be the new field for you

依然是的

希望你能聽聽蔡健雅的“letting go”

老師可以聽聽 張震嶽 的歌

強到爆

陶喆 new album 2023 coming soon, he say ardy

Hi Joe, great review! I really like this song and I’d say I LOVE this new version. It sounds so angelic and almost make me cry. Really want a high quality headphone to listen to this song hahahaha🤣 Anyway if it’s possible can you please make a review video of 时代少年团《抬起头来》? I think they’re young boy group that has so much potential. Although this song has only three vocalists of the group, they might interest you and you can check the rest of their songs out! Ps. one of these guys is a big fan of David Tao and R&B music! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-z5iWZujQ-Ek.html

真快😂 果然是迷上陶喆了

shaved off your beard, you look so young😁

新版流沙，感覺從撒哈拉變成熱帶海灘了。 輕鬆愜意隨他去

胡彥斌 Tiger Hu - 你要的全拿走 Take Everything You Want

新版無疑在编曲，配樂，人聲樂器的混合協調，以致整體的聽覺享受上都要比97舊版高出一個檔次 但97版情感更真切，配樂编曲等其他技術層面也是雞旦也挑不出骨頭來 只能說97 23兩個版本都是絕對的timeless經典

You look different andYour voice sounds brighter who are you?

把oh baby， 改成old baby~