Тёмный

Is Going to College Worth it?: VICE Podcast 031 

VICE
Подписаться 19 млн
Просмотров 226 тыс.
50% 1

This week on the VICE Podcast, Reihan Salam sits down with Anya Kamenetz, a Schwartz fellow at New America, journalist, and author of Generation Debt, DIY U, and the forthcoming The Test. Reihan has an in-depth discussion with Anya about the current state of higher education in America.
Watch more VICE Podcasts here: bit.ly/VICE-Pod...
Check out the VICE podcast on iTunes here: itunes.apple.c...
Subscribe to VICE here! bit.ly/Subscrib...
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/VICE-Videos
Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com
Like VICE on Facebook: vice
Follow VICE on Twitter: / vice
Read our tumblr: / vicemag

Опубликовано:

 

5 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 735   
@razerxrob964
@razerxrob964 10 лет назад
youtube has been a better educator to me than 99% of the teachers ive had throughout my public education years and my 2 years at CC
@marieokoin3230
@marieokoin3230 6 лет назад
razerxrob yep
@markedwardspezenosky5814
@markedwardspezenosky5814 4 года назад
U tube is the alternative best eye opening..educator
@infamouscrusader3363
@infamouscrusader3363 4 года назад
Right.
@tennektrey5227
@tennektrey5227 4 года назад
razerxrob yeah try putting that on a resume.
@ihatemyjob9502
@ihatemyjob9502 3 года назад
@@tennektrey5227 lmao
@errollowe7603
@errollowe7603 9 лет назад
I've noticed that no one seems to discuss the fact that our education system is based on an obsolete Prussian model from the early 19th century. The German model was intended to teach students to become compliant citizens/soldiers that would be subservient to the State. It's entire function was to promote conformity and repress creativity and critical thinking. It's no wonder students from K-12 to colleges are not finding the education experience very helpful. It does not promote individuality or independent thinking. And so many of us have been conditioned to believe that we must go through this indoctrination process in order to be 'successful' - whatever that means. And to add insult to injury we incur huge debt for all this. Even doctors who need degrees need to use independent thinking to approach cures and schools don't always train this. And now it's all about getting paid. The entire education system needs an overhaul.
@errollowe7603
@errollowe7603 9 лет назад
+Paul Langton-Rogers As long as you're attending an institution that has tests, exams, schedules, pre-defined metrics and a pre-defined curriculum which you can't create or modify then you're still within the Prussian paradigm. Being given a select number of options without the option to create your own without restrictions, is the illusion of free thinking. You're still living within an open corral...
@vanhoot2234
@vanhoot2234 9 лет назад
+Errol Lowe And yet the German model has evolved since to provide there students with a much more effective and cheap education system. I am from Canada so the cost-benefit analysis is more more in favour of getting educated then the US model CURRENTLY. With that being said we have over 60-70% of our population that is graduating with a college degree, and currently with older generations living longer and working longer we have run into a bottle neck in the pipeline of people trying to get into the workplace. You see people with full on degrees working at Starbucks as a barista. I have been saying this for a while now. Some teachers are naturally gifted, however all teachers should learn how to teach (university level). As a university professor you are required to produce research each year, so your incentive/job security isn't primarily based on your ability to teach your students. Lastly, college is a place where people learn how to think differently, but we have changed how it is done. We used to learn philosophy and then go into a specific subject area of interest. We now learn a particular school of thought without going to the foundations of how to learn. I absolutely agree with your statement that, "The entire education system needs an overhaul". We need more hands on learning to teach soft and hard skills. I honestly think that college degrees should be decreased in price and they should be structured in a way that gear you into a 4 year degree more regularly. It sort of exists but its growing and probably not fast enough.
@errollowe7603
@errollowe7603 9 лет назад
+vanhoot2234 Agreed. The current system teaches what to think but not how to think.
@Artan102
@Artan102 9 лет назад
+Errol Lowe I agree that they didn't discuss the Prussian model but they did discuss a lot of good points; mainly that the people behind the education system are not university graduates or professors; and their purpose is to serve the interest of Universities and colleges which is to profit from the masses and masses of students. Its not about educating students and improving their lives; its about the ruling class ruling over the lower class
@JoeHeine
@JoeHeine 8 лет назад
+Errol Lowe Well said.
@Simoss13
@Simoss13 9 лет назад
From my years in the workplace I have come to realise this: Experience and skills outweigh degrees. Period!
@clydemacauley1554
@clydemacauley1554 9 лет назад
*Always*..
@clydemacauley1554
@clydemacauley1554 9 лет назад
Tuition should be free for everyone.......buts that's wishful thinking 😕
@clydemacauley1554
@clydemacauley1554 9 лет назад
wbl2012 was that at me??
@gregc4562
@gregc4562 9 лет назад
Simoss13 Duh. Everyone has to start somewhere, though. Eventually, most people will have to have a college education just to have a decent job. Working your way up from the bottom is becoming less common.
@hannibal1319ify
@hannibal1319ify 9 лет назад
G Money ha!! WhWho told you that? My boy had to become a cop because he couldn't find a job
@itsrelativ3967
@itsrelativ3967 8 лет назад
When the majority of college grads can't even pay off loans within 20 years then HELL NO IT'S NOT WORTH IT!!!!!!
@binzsta86
@binzsta86 5 лет назад
@Jimmy Strudel I should slap both ya for making slave wages.
@TheMsnitish
@TheMsnitish 4 года назад
depends on the major you choose !
@itsrelativ3967
@itsrelativ3967 4 года назад
​@@TheMsnitish Get into an apprenticeship. Then years later maybe 2-4 later go to college partially financed by the employer. I am totally against 17 and 18 year olds going straight to college. It's been a bigger gamble for Gen-Y and Gen-Z. Parents who don't do any financial debt/career assesment research and just want their children out the house are doing them a big disservice. Another alternative can be the military.
@GenXstacker
@GenXstacker 10 лет назад
My college career was as follows: 3 years in local community college 3 years undergrad at major university 3 years grad school at major university My suggestion to people who simply want the skills and credentials to get a decent job--do it at the community college level. Universities are much more expensive and do not offer anything substantially superior to what you can get at the community college level. As a matter of fact, community college instructors are often better teachers than university professors. Most of the time at university you will interact with grad student instructors rather than the professors themselves, and even the grad student instructors tend to be better teachers than the professors. Summary = save money and have a better educational experience by getting your degree at the local community college.
@jglobetrotter2830
@jglobetrotter2830 5 лет назад
Community college classes are nearly always smaller too. Would you rather be in a class in a giant lecture hall with 200 other students and have your papers graded by TAs and never interact with your professor, or a class of 30 people where you can ask questions and talk with your teacher after class if you have questions?
@jfiazy
@jfiazy 10 лет назад
"Students who acquire large debt putting themselves through school are unlikely to think about changing society. When you trap people in a system of debt they can't afford the time to think. Tuition fee increases are a 'disciplinary technique' and, by the time the students graduate, they are not only loaded with debt, but have internalized the 'disciplinary culture'. This makes them efficient components of the consumer economy" -Noam Chomsky
@Jessinking
@Jessinking 10 лет назад
wow
@luke-fh9gf
@luke-fh9gf 4 года назад
@@Jessinking very wow
@GTVAS
@GTVAS 10 лет назад
So basically if I go to College, I'm fucked. If I don't go to college, I'm also fucked. Well this sucks....
@bringthepain4419
@bringthepain4419 10 лет назад
lmao
@tarasshevchenko8917
@tarasshevchenko8917 7 лет назад
omfgwtfbbqpizza Good point.
@Robertolopezbriones
@Robertolopezbriones 8 лет назад
Internet is my college
@mysteriousworld8880
@mysteriousworld8880 7 лет назад
well said
@richardscathouse
@richardscathouse 6 лет назад
Roberto Lopez-Briones times when you could get a good programming job on talent alone are over everyone expects a degree even from a fleabag Bancock diploma mill
@stevej1287
@stevej1287 8 лет назад
I went to grad school at Berkeley. The place is more like a corporation than institution of research and higher education... I love college and education, but the way they are run today is corrupt. If you're a go getter, I'd say go to college, but if you're waiting for someone to guide you somewhere.. don't go. Get a job and work your way up.
@GermantownFamily
@GermantownFamily 7 лет назад
SNHU is worst.
@alfredmunoz466
@alfredmunoz466 8 лет назад
I studied at UCLA and now I work at Target. I make minimum wage and have 30gs in debt. loved the college experience!
@angelique6746
@angelique6746 7 лет назад
Alfred Munoz what'd you major in
@binzsta86
@binzsta86 5 лет назад
@@angelique6746 gender studies.
@Missioneer
@Missioneer 10 лет назад
If a student doesn't understand the teacher and the teacher doesn't change their way of teaching in order to help this student then there is something severely wrong with the education system. My money is being wasted on stuck up teachers that refuse to change their ways of teaching, because _they_ think I should be paying a tutor to help me understand things when already I am paying THOUSANDS for the teachers to _teach_ me. A teacher fails at being a teacher the moment they choose to leave a student behind...
@jglobetrotter2830
@jglobetrotter2830 5 лет назад
Please do explain to me exactly how a teacher can individualize how they teach to hundreds or even thousands of students.
@richardbowers3647
@richardbowers3647 4 года назад
You're close! The best (great) teachers I've known were outstanding in their profession! Their words & style exposed my thinking to the classes subject! They knew things. They didn't have to search out the students! The students had to apply themselves.
@ricardofranco7419
@ricardofranco7419 9 лет назад
I'll save you 58 minutes by answering no.
@garrettoverby9940
@garrettoverby9940 8 лет назад
+Ricardo Franco thanks bro!
@DigitalFire5000
@DigitalFire5000 8 лет назад
+Ricardo Franco Lolz xD
@lyte3339
@lyte3339 7 лет назад
Ricardo Franco I think that I just fell in love! Thanks!
@ShidaiTaino
@ShidaiTaino 5 лет назад
Ricardo Franco you didn’t watch the video
@detroitmetro101
@detroitmetro101 5 лет назад
@@ShidaiTaino i wonder if she, or he, would have any credibility without their college degrees. there is something very hypocritical about college educated elites telling others that college is not worth it, which pisses me off, because they are not asking the right question, that being, does college prepare one for the job market? that depends on the degree and field, but mostly, no colleges dont prepare students for the job market, they do, however, open doors to interviews, networks, and resources, which is what college is really about. so, fuck them, and their question, and the narrative they are trying to push. if you want to go to college, and have the grades, and the discipline, and the money, to go, go, but make that effort count, milk the experience for everything its worth.
@lsas123
@lsas123 10 лет назад
Most people go to university having no idea what they want to do afterwards and so end up just studying for exams and never truly learning anything they're truly interested and can later on apply in their lives. I think there is too much pressure on 18 year olds rushing them into university. Many students should take they're time learn about life and its ups and downs, and then later on when more mature enter higher education with a greater focus.
@TheRedemptionRain
@TheRedemptionRain 10 лет назад
College is for med-students and engineers....after that your pretty much wasting your time and money
@psnisy1234
@psnisy1234 10 лет назад
I sort of knew college would be a scam even before watching so many documentaries on it. When I got into the real world after high school looking for a job I realized that high school didn't teach me nothing. I didn't know anything about a resume, cover letter, and real world experience. Fast forward 2 years later I know a lot about the workforce, different ways to make income, and so many other important things that I need. I will admit that many times I did(and still do) have the back and forth in my mind on whether I should go to college, but i'm thankful to finally have work experience and a job.
@solarflare907
@solarflare907 8 лет назад
I spent a year in college.....just more high school. Joined the Army, helped build houses from the ground up, was a carpenter helper, electrician, plummer, heavy equipment operator, anyone that has the internet and a quest for knowledge and a will to work will be successful. Schools give you certification not qualification. Do you want to follow a 2nd Lt Fresh outta west point or a NCO that's been there done that.
@Tyler41617
@Tyler41617 10 лет назад
from my experience, the only people who complain about having to further their education are one of three people. (this also, in a way, applies to people that complain about the education system) 1. too lazy to do the work 2. not smart enough to do the work. 3. truly not interested in college (perhaps they want to follow a dream that requires hard work and no degree) if you fall under any of these reasons, you have no room to bash someone that chooses to go to college. if they fail out of college that is their own fault, not the university.
@autobot69000
@autobot69000 10 лет назад
Reihan Salam is a damn good reprieve from all of Vice's other more hipsterish, pretentious tendencies. The guy actually attempts to extract pertinent information without coming off like a dick. These podcasts are fantastic. Anya Kamenetz was really interesting.
@xBenji1x
@xBenji1x 10 лет назад
He comes across as really professional and thoughtful. If the narrator from the 'Ocean Garbage' documentary had been doing this he would have most likely tried to hook up with Anya then end with some cheesy tag line. Probably along the lines of "The lesson I learned today was... that love is the greatest education."
@autobot69000
@autobot69000 10 лет назад
KASPER. Definitely, some of the other "correspondents" try so hard to be cool and edgy and come off cringeworthy and lame. The best ones seem to be Ryan Duffy and Shane Smith as well as the short skinny nerd. The girl who did the piece about the indonesian tribal blood festival thing was pretty good too.
@saltyseedog
@saltyseedog 10 лет назад
KASPER. rofl
@JasonCtutorials
@JasonCtutorials 10 лет назад
Basically, non-profit means for profit. Except taxed differently.
@jasdilo7680
@jasdilo7680 8 лет назад
Ladies and gentlemen, in order to make a middle class salary, YOU NEED TO KNOW PEOPLE. Getting into debt all for a stamped piece of paper is not worth it in todays' economy. It's all about who you surround yourself with and your attitude and ambitions toward something you want.
@katrinaumana2127
@katrinaumana2127 8 лет назад
This was boring. I needed to see some graphs or pie charts. Oh wait I already know college isn't worth it unless you get a STEM degree. I'm teaching my kids to goto a trade school or get an apretenship.
@PedroHernandez-uj9oz
@PedroHernandez-uj9oz 8 лет назад
I wish my parents had the mentality you have they dont understand now a degree is not good as it use to be. College does not guaranteed success anymore. Like if It was my choice I go become eletrician or a welder or both. Continue to learn different trades and I will never be poor
@katrinaumana2127
@katrinaumana2127 8 лет назад
Here is my advice show them the data. Show them the student loan horror stories. Off the top of my head I remember Student Loan Debt Forgiveness (yeah their are Millennials complaining and wanting their Art History degree or other fluff degree forgiven), but from 2000-2014 the average cost of college tuition at State schools increased by 80%, in contrast real wages actually fell by 07%. A college degree isn't a key out of poverty into the middle class. In fact some students end up with a mortgage without the house🏡. Take for example, myself I took out $14,082 in student loans getting a Master's degree in teaching from GWU. My employer DCPS was so desperate for special education teachers they paid for my Master's degree except 2 classes. My husband and I saved up about $35,000 in a little over 5 years living in his nephew's basement apartment. We then bought a house🏡 for $105,000 it's small just 894 sq ft, but it's home. I then concentrated on paying off our minivan 🚙. We then were able for me to stop working as he is a plumber and ain't no Shane in my game he made more money then me. Especially since people are flushing baby wipes down the toilet 🚽 he sometimes has to disconnect the toilet to fix the issue. Sorry I rambled but find a career that you like to do and also research it's earning potential, college or trade school should be viewed as a business investment so you should calculate the college costs versus the degree/trade certification earning potential as your overall Return On Investment. 👊👌✌
@nickys5578
@nickys5578 7 лет назад
Nope even with STEM you have tons of competition and don't get shit unless you are a PhD and have published and if you try to get a normal job that pay better they see your degree and you are throw out for being over qualified I have publish 3 papers have been co author of more and have STEM degree and can;t get a job anywhere yet my sister a highschool drop out is making more than out mother who has another STEM degree and has been in the workforce for years Oh and that high school drop out is working for walmart
@boyar1978
@boyar1978 7 лет назад
My college said I needed remedial math and refused to put me into a college algebra class. I transferred to another college when college algebra was the only course I needed and easily got a B
@uchenna419
@uchenna419 10 лет назад
This debate just boils down to one common fact in life. When something becomes mainstream or popular, it begins to lose it's credibility as the lie they told you about it begins to come out.This theory applies to college too. The Idea of going to college was that you are going to make more money and get ahead in life, This made it become a system. But the system is no longer working. College is not really worth it anymore, because everyone is going to college, but not everyone can get a good job. These means that the people who went to college, did everything the institution wanted and don't make it even become very salty about it, because there where lied too. At some point in time, the college system will stop, as people are beginning to see it's no longer working for them, but in a world built around higher education, it's hard to see that changing too. But yet again what do i know i am still a kid in this fucked up world. just leave your life everyone and do what makes you happy.
@nizzyhuzzle123
@nizzyhuzzle123 10 лет назад
this comment is 10/10 bro
@54CFC
@54CFC 9 лет назад
But, but, but, a college graduate WILL earn a DECAMILLION more dollars in their lifetime than someone with only a high school diploma!!!!
@clydemacauley1554
@clydemacauley1554 9 лет назад
Nickolas RW that is also true...
@uchenna419
@uchenna419 8 лет назад
+Nickolas RW.I liked the way u said a college graduate, which means not all college graduates, so there is really no guarantee success, which means its a gamble, but u are paying for that gamble with student loans and huge expenses which may end up damaging your future. so the question is.......is it truely worth? "But, but, but, a college graduate WILL earn a DECAMILLION more dollars in their lifetime than someone with only a high school diploma" yeah, so would rappers, artist, business man, fashion designers, and fighters, so wats your point, because it definitey not about money? go and tell that to mayweather
@richardscathouse
@richardscathouse 6 лет назад
Freshtanner ibez all good jobs are being offshored! And the rest are being filled with H1 marginal scum low skilled low, IQ many can barely speak English god help if want a report from one!
@ncimq
@ncimq 10 лет назад
why do people hate this guy? I think he's one of the best interviewers
@domoxxoox1
@domoxxoox1 10 лет назад
I mean i don't know interview wise but I've seen him on Bill maher, i think the hate comes more so from his political stand points. I can't remember exactly but I do remember disagreeing with some of the things he had to say. Not all but some things i can remember thinking BS.
@jl4102
@jl4102 10 лет назад
Probably because they're homophobic. He's a great interviewer.
@OMGmyFACE
@OMGmyFACE 10 лет назад
JL Apparently, it's possible to hate someone for being annoying or unintelligent without also hating them for being different. For example, I think what you said was stupid and I have no idea what race or gender you are.
@jl4102
@jl4102 10 лет назад
OMGmyFACE Feel free to give an example of how he's annoying or unintelligent.
@jl4102
@jl4102 10 лет назад
Seriously, I'm all ears. I only know him really from his interviews on this Vice channel… and yes I made a blanket statement, and I probably shouldn't have. But a lot of the hate for him is definitely homophobic in nature if you look at comments on his videos.
@ARTOFWAR2008
@ARTOFWAR2008 10 лет назад
My boss has never set foot in a college class room. He started with nothing. His homes, and cars are payed for. He has college grads working for him, and he puts them though hell. Cheers from Austin.
@jglobetrotter2830
@jglobetrotter2830 5 лет назад
And what is the likelihood that any non-college-grad is promoted to your boss's position when he retires? Nil.
@TheJapanChannelDcom
@TheJapanChannelDcom 10 лет назад
American education? What is wrong with these sentences? "I got bit by a dog." "Where are you at?" "You did good." (In relation to achieving a goal.)
@lordlucius1341
@lordlucius1341 6 лет назад
TheJapanChannelDcom I'm guessing I was bit by a dog. Where are you? You did great. Don't even care if I'm right on all three I'm the only guy to answer this after all this time so I win bigly😏!
@tyson1chicken
@tyson1chicken 6 лет назад
Fail... Correct versions are I was bitten by a dog Where are you You did well
@drumrco
@drumrco 6 лет назад
Grammar is not education. What education actually is, is this: wisdom and learning a subject that not only improves oneself but has the capability to help you improve society.
@Misshughestrm
@Misshughestrm 6 лет назад
I was bitten by a dog.... Where are you?
@rjamesstephens
@rjamesstephens 10 лет назад
Vice podcast continues to be as entertaining and enlightening as ever. This one is probably personal favourite.
@filthywishdragon
@filthywishdragon 10 лет назад
Is there nothing to be said about what they are teaching is wrong in most cases. Physics, electricity and all the things I studied at college was a joke. Electrical Engineering models taught in school havent changed since 1898. And physics is still stuck in pre 1950 symmetry in mathematics. If you are just going for a job, then youll be satisfied. If you are learning because you have a passion for it, especially in those fields, you leave feeling you were taken advantage of. College isnt about learning anymore. Its about tuition.
@54CFC
@54CFC 9 лет назад
I agree...colleges are a business!
@PedroHernandez-uj9oz
@PedroHernandez-uj9oz 7 лет назад
To be honest most people should not go to university but a trade school, or community college to learn a skill set to get a job. Studying sociology or liberal arts job opportunity is just as good as a teen working at Mcdonalds. Just going to college does not mean anything anymore. People nee to make wise and conscious decisions especially if your taking loans and borrowing money. Heck if your going take a loan use that to buy a buisness and invest in real estate something that can make you money.
@charlietian9843
@charlietian9843 7 лет назад
you clearly don't understand pedagogy. classical physics is useful and still used in engineering lmao. gravitational waves are not used anywhere, and most people are engineers. furthermore you cant teach higher level concepts without first teaching higher level approximations first that are useful but fail to get some more granularity of detail that higher technology has given as for your EE experience that shouldnt be the norm
@RunRobbenRun
@RunRobbenRun 10 лет назад
Community College and Trade School is better option then the big name universities.
@03chrisv
@03chrisv 10 лет назад
College is a waste. I took vey little from the experience, and what I know now (computer science major 2003 - 2007) is outdated and no longer practical for today. I'm unemployed in the traditional sense and have a nasty debt that I can't pay right now... So what am I doing? Starting a business in high end products targeting high end clients. I have investors who paid for the production equipment and inventory and my future for the first time in a long time is looking bright. While I have little money outside of the startup business I am confident that will change soon. Did I need college to do this? No. I would have been much better off if I never attended. If you're going to be a doctor, nurse, lawyer, or architect, then sure college is for you. If not, you can go to much cheaper trade schools that are more focused and tailored for your passion, or skip school altogether.
@FeedEgg
@FeedEgg 10 лет назад
Yay a $70,000 piece of paper that says i know stuff!
@54CFC
@54CFC 9 лет назад
That's right! Did you know that a college graduate will earn a DECAMILLION MORE dollars over the course of their lifetime versus just being a high school graduate! (I'm kidding of course) :D
@colleenschwab
@colleenschwab 10 лет назад
The American public school system is a joke. I would never put a child in one.
@AxelLeJeff
@AxelLeJeff 10 лет назад
It differs from state to state and county to county. What's more of a joke is how private and charter schools are poorly regulated, again, this is state by state and county by county, but tends to have far less oversight in any official capacity. I spent a year in a private school where a portion of the curriculum was devoted to praying TO, not FOR, George W. Bush. I had teachers actively telling students we lived in the end times and that the then president of the United States would herald only 'true christians' through the apocalypse. This wasn't some camp in the hills, this was a K-12 private school, smack dab in the middle of California's central coast.
@BreaktimeTraveler
@BreaktimeTraveler 10 лет назад
Jeffman12 whats the schools name?
@AxelLeJeff
@AxelLeJeff 10 лет назад
Pacific Christian(Orcutt, CA) mind you, this was in 2000/2001, they may have improved, but from what I hear of the two sane teachers I had, one was fired after coming out of the atheist closet, and the other quit because, while still Christian, she was offered a better job at a private school that wouldn't compromise science and health education for a religious agenda. I heard the following year that a girl came back pregnant from the annual class trip to DC, not having understood the biological process she had undergone, she briefly believed the event to be immaculate conception, until she and the father were taught that sticking a penis into a vagina tends to do that. It just so happens that was the year, and location, in which I adopted the handle I use today.
@BreaktimeTraveler
@BreaktimeTraveler 10 лет назад
I'm also in CA and know how appalling public schools can be but wow!
@AxelLeJeff
@AxelLeJeff 10 лет назад
Not to say I never had a problem with public schools, the one I had problems with might actually have been worse than that, but I only spent about a month there.
@facfortiaetpatere4287
@facfortiaetpatere4287 5 лет назад
One of the best discussions on this topic that I've seen
@kevjtnbtmglr
@kevjtnbtmglr 10 лет назад
I'v always thought of university to be for learning science and math; everything else is pointsless to learn in university as its not quantifiable.
@BaalKlezmerTov
@BaalKlezmerTov 10 лет назад
the modern concept of university is wrong, what you call university is a technological institute..... university (from latin Universum, aprox. the whole of the knowledge) was not to obtain a grade rather to obtain a knowledge... but everything is business today
@QuickSaveTV
@QuickSaveTV 10 лет назад
David Martin Bassail Which makes sense because people see the university as this sort of a gate-opener to their future careers. If it was just the whole of knowledge it would be basically a library that would not be able to sustain itself (?). Perceiving different things as potential businesses is the way to go IMO, because it provides the needed motivation to youth (myself included) to try and establish our careers in the area that we want (be that new industry (Social Media) or an old industry (Accounting); not really industries but I hope you see my point). The problem thus, IMO, is not what the university is, but rather what the university offers to its students and how its approaching the educational process (does University care? Is it interested in people being successful?)
@ff2e
@ff2e 10 лет назад
To make this statement of value, you have used an argument that is unquantifiable and exists only in your intuition. Pointlessness in itself is entirely subjective as I could, with a line of reasoning, also make quantifiable subjects like math and logic, seem entirely pointless. The arts of quantifiable reasoning are only tools to abstract reality into a workable media for the mind, and are often incorrect and rely on broad generalizations of categories and what it means to be a thig. One of the things you learn in a philosophy degree, is that tautological systems, while being absolutely quantifiable (and you learn how to quantify them), solve almost nothing other than the how. They can be 100% mathematically and logically sound, but when applied to actual time and space, the predicates used in the arguments are somewhat useless for the questions humanity would like to answer with them. They can allow you to peel away ideologies that are unfounded and illogical, but they also can not provide any answers. Learning is for a lot more than providing the ability for humanity to obtain more material wealth and conveniences. With no context, or reasons why were moving in a given direction, or valuing the creation of technologies, progress can not be considered progress.
@QuickSaveTV
@QuickSaveTV 10 лет назад
letheal "Learning is for a lot more" - You're very vague. A lot more as in what is it? "With no context, or reasons why were moving in a given direction, or valuing the creation of technologies, progress can not be considered progress" - But there is context, the context of what we knew, how we communicated or what were the priorities before and today. Just because I've not brought the "bar" by which we shall compare does not invalidate my argument. Trying to say that a moving car is not moving until we establish the correlation with another object is a little silly don't you think?
@jglobetrotter2830
@jglobetrotter2830 5 лет назад
@@QuickSaveTV "What was educationally significant and hard to measure has been replaced by what is educationally insignificant and easy to measure. So now we measure how well we taught what wasn't worth learning." The argument that what is easy to measure on a bubble test is worthwhile and what is hard to measure on a bubble test is worthless is the belief most harmful to education today. You would make our math and engineering graduates mindless lemmings incapable of doing anything but repeating information while simultaneously trying to devalue arts and humanities.
@kaz9781
@kaz9781 8 лет назад
Maybe some people dont go because they cant afford it.
@incubus_the_man
@incubus_the_man 8 лет назад
Pell grants with loans make it possible for many.
@incubus_the_man
@incubus_the_man 8 лет назад
This is very true for 4 year degrees and some 2 year programs. The Pell grant is just enough or the 2 year institutions where I live. Many of which train for trades in the fields of electrical technology and nursing. Those two fields generally yield high success rates among graduates.
@richardscathouse
@richardscathouse 6 лет назад
kaz9781 After 12 years of hell I knew so-called higher education wasn't for me! Truck drivers rarely starve
@drumrco
@drumrco 6 лет назад
University of the People is a legit American accredited college. It’s tuition free & they have transfer partnerships with UC Berkeley & NYU for top students.
@xenogryph7169
@xenogryph7169 6 лет назад
Truck drivers in my state make good money but have no care about the cost they do to homeowners to the property they destroy and the companies they work for have their hands in so many pockets that no sanctity of government want anything to do with it because any argument will cost money so financially its easier to let the public pay for their property repairs than to pay for it them selves. And the public cannot defend themselves against industrial deformation.
@AeroAngle
@AeroAngle 9 лет назад
I believe students should be free to choose their curriculum and build our own knowledge as they go through without taking those classes doesn't satisfy them
@Theguitarwhiz
@Theguitarwhiz 10 лет назад
My parents are adamant on me going to college always have been always will be, I don't know if it's really the road for me.. my goal in life is to be successful, that's all i've ever wanted to be financially successful is a major thing for me, I want to start up my own business and I don't think college is right for me.
@Theguitarwhiz
@Theguitarwhiz 9 лет назад
Ellery The sole two reasons I would go to college are 1- to get a degree that would be of use to me in business and 2-to build contacts. For whatever reason I've never really been interested in that college mentality of drink till you can't stand up.. But I can definitely see where you are coming from, that college can of course be useful but there is no guarantee. You really have to ask yourself, would you be where you are now without your degree or contacts that you got in college?
@Theguitarwhiz
@Theguitarwhiz 9 лет назад
Ellery In the end both parties are striving for the same goal, so long as you don't cross one another it is easy to work as a unit to get to where you want
@notbigtony
@notbigtony 9 лет назад
your parents are so adamant because they are helplessly brainwashed. Starting a profilable business is a lot easier than people make it out to be.Especially with the internet and kickstarter. The cost of failure has never been less. And if it turns out that you aren't meant to be successful entrepenuer, then you can still get a $4000 comp sci or finance degree from uopeople.edu (first ever non profit online university thats also 501c3 non profit) This is all coming from a 19 year old who is self sufficient from doing computer work with no college degree. Not going to college has been the best decision ever for me! And now I have so much more time to learn and grow on my own, using the internet.
@endezeichengrimm
@endezeichengrimm 9 лет назад
Tell them to pay for it.
@Theguitarwhiz
@Theguitarwhiz 9 лет назад
Endezeichen Grimm the cost of college is free where im from living expenses etc are not
@lesliehutchinson5899
@lesliehutchinson5899 9 лет назад
Only certain majors are profitable in 4 year college such as accounting, teacher education, nursing only certain branches of engineering . The trend seems to be going blue collar like air conditioning, plumbing, auto mechanics, surgical tech basically most things at community college or trade school.
@patrickthotho2996
@patrickthotho2996 9 лет назад
what about international relations
@JoeHeine
@JoeHeine 8 лет назад
+patrick Thotho My major was International Security, very similar to International Relations. Unfortunately, unless you are already connected, i.e. your parents are Diplomats, you are in Skull & Bones, etc. You are not going to be taken seriously in that field.
@jdstep97
@jdstep97 8 лет назад
+patrick ThothoThotho I second what Joe Heine said. An ex-boss' wife had an MA in International Affairs, but she could not use that degree at all. She does quite well now, as an interior decorator. As for me, I got an MA in International Affairs. Not using it. Thank God I had a law degree and was in the right place at the right time to be offered an administrative law job for a state government. I was already working for the state in a very non-law, under-appreciated, non-International Affairs position. The need arose for someone to fill the administrative law position ASAP. My supervisor with the state, put in a good word for me with the other state supervisor, the one who was doing the hiring. That did it. But I sometimes wonder if the "new" supervisor was really just so amazed that I had been working as hard as I had (with all my education), and for so little, that she had to give me a chance. I don't think I would have gotten that if not already on "the inside". But if you really think you'd like to do International Affairs, and you have a plan, go for it; but maybe have it as a minor, or do a double major with something else, like engineering. Or, work fulltime somewhere and pay your way through school part-time, so when you finish, you'll not have a lot of debt. Maybe the place where you had been working while in school can put in a good word for you some place where you can actually put your degree to use. Nothing like a good reference.
@ticks4ticks4
@ticks4ticks4 8 лет назад
+patrick Thotho Not worth it! Unless you double major (e.g. Accounting).
@michaelyim3119
@michaelyim3119 8 лет назад
+Leslie Hutchinson Agree! Don't complain that you're in debt and can't get a job if you major in something worthless, like gender study, theater, etc... Even business is iffy and their unemployment is around 9%, which is huge. I would only recommend business if you have huge connection from your parents. So many people get business degrees that it is almost worthless nowadays. Even in engineering, only some are worth getting while others are worthless and won't get you a job. Go to college if you are 100% sure that you want to major in biology going into pre-med or pre-health or to become a lawyer. That will get you a job instantly right after grad school.
@michelvec
@michelvec 10 лет назад
Reihan Salam is way better than Charlie Rose ;) Great job!
@snikerdoodles856
@snikerdoodles856 10 лет назад
I feel that going to college is almost necessary if you plan on having a stable life. Yes, you can go to trade schools which are almost just as important (someones gotta fix cars or be a plumber, no shame in that). Unfortunately, the amount of money college costs is absolutely outrageous. I shouldnt have to be feeling like im giving an arm and a leg to be in a lecture hall where professors give absolutely 0 fucks about their students. At least thats what ive been through so far.
@justinsaunders9358
@justinsaunders9358 9 лет назад
The problem here is people are expecting too much, yes, too much from College. Contrary to what these two have said College does not promise you anything. You choose to apply to college, you choose to go or not go to classes, you choose what to do. What college does is provide you with the opportunity and then it's up to you to decide what you want o do with that opportunity. If you don't graduate from College it is your fault and that's it. You cannot blame the college or the system because they can easily say well look at all the other students that graduated. I believe that the value of the experience and wisdom that college gives you if you apply yourself is severely underrated College is an excellent transition from High School to life because it teaches you that if you don't get yourself together then you're going to suffer, some people just want everything handed to them and that's just not how it is.
@SeanP7195
@SeanP7195 8 лет назад
+Justin Saunders When you are charging 300 for a 9 dollar book your whole argument is voided.
@allanmolina6130
@allanmolina6130 8 лет назад
+Justin Saunders i agree with you but you can not get a job in he field you want unless you have a degree and that really sucks
@getnorgetout9425
@getnorgetout9425 9 лет назад
Don't go to college unless you are absolutely sure you're okay with what you face in your job
@getnorgetout9425
@getnorgetout9425 9 лет назад
I went to college, got the degree, got the job I wanted, and while I was good at it and enjoyed the work, there were other aspects of it that I didn't know about until I started the job, making me realize that I would have never gone into this line of work if I'd known what it entails. Now I do it as a hobby as I used to
@cdm386
@cdm386 9 лет назад
even If you are sue about your degree, its important to see the data of unemployment in your chosen field of studies. If you go for arts, criminal justice or human development.....you are fucked.
@cdm386
@cdm386 9 лет назад
LoL. I mean, cops make good fucking money in the states but if you wanna be a cop your beat bet is to join the army. It will give you a way better shot at becoming a cop/fbi agent instead of going deep in debt for a useless crim. Justice degree.
@Artan102
@Artan102 9 лет назад
Why is it that University degrees are four years long? Why can't we improve and shorten the length of our curriculum without compromising the quality and high standards that real education demands. We don't need the sports, the music and University coaches being paid millions of dollars to push students and sports to profits. We don't need the expensive stadiums that costs too much because that is being paid by students. We as individuals can learn music, do sports and other non educational things on our own or go to private institutes. The focus should be on Math, Physics, Science, Literature, History and other important, relevant subjects. But it should be done in 1 to 2 years
@jdawgbiggums7683
@jdawgbiggums7683 9 лет назад
+Hassan Artan Because they want to get as much money from you as possible hence why Gen Ed course are mandatory.
@BassForever44
@BassForever44 10 лет назад
In an ideal world people DOESN'T go college in order to get a job, you go to college to do major specialization and research. If you just want a job you better go to a trade school. End of the story.
@SuperDimi111
@SuperDimi111 10 лет назад
i been asking myself the same question. im out of college and finding a job is a bitch. im forced to compete against people that have worked the entire time i was in college and end up being my boss because they have more experience. fucking world is very twisted
@Missioneer
@Missioneer 10 лет назад
I'm kind of in the same situation. I always ask the question; how is a person suppose to get hired if they don't have any work experience? How is one to get a job if they can't even put together enough material for a resumé? Also, how is one to get any work experience in the first place if they can't get a job to begin with? We live in a world where it is very hard not to be pessimistic, but we live on anyways.
@SuperDimi111
@SuperDimi111 10 лет назад
yup, im just thankful and blessed i dont have school debt unlike so many poor souls.
@Missioneer
@Missioneer 10 лет назад
SuperDimi111 Saaame.
@hillbill7016
@hillbill7016 10 лет назад
Missioneer You get experience from internships or working for family friend. I had 3 internships at several blue chip companies. It was a turn off, so I just started up a company and plan to sell off once I hit my numbers. It is just one huge rat race.
@hillbill7016
@hillbill7016 10 лет назад
Missioneer You get experience from internships or working for family friend. I had 3 internships at several blue chip companies. It was a turn off, so I just started up a company and plan to sell off once I hit my numbers. It is just one huge rat race.
@livingstonem10
@livingstonem10 10 лет назад
Reihan is a good interviewer.
@b4804514
@b4804514 10 лет назад
IMO Education & learning has not caught up to the times - educating yourself and learning is so much easier today with access to the internet - information is available to everyone. We need a new qualification standard other than a college degree- unfortunately change threatens a lot of jobs and antiquated systems that still have perceived value
@anewlow23
@anewlow23 10 лет назад
I hear them debating college but why not really debate high school hell even middle school and much of grade school? What does one really get with a high school diploma as far as a job is concerned? Nothing so why go? So from this perspective high school is entirely pointless Just skip it and go directly to community college. So it's not colleges that are failing it's a systemic problem of primary education. High schools and even grade schools should be responsible for finding and educating children about REAL employment options and the REAL world.
@robertstevenson3214
@robertstevenson3214 10 лет назад
... a voice of reason.... our entire academic system is garbage. The goal shouldn't be graduating more people with useless 'liberal arts degrees'. The idea that college and liberal arts degrees "teach you how to learn" is ridiculous. Want to teach yourself how to learn? Go get a library card and have at at it... The idea that you can go through 13 years of public school and still not have the skills for a job that pays more than $7.50 is insane. Tack on four more years of "liberal arts education" and $50-$200K in debt and you still aren't worth more than minimum wage. Advice... If you aren't majoring in something related to science, tech, engineering, or math - save yourself four years and a few hundred thousand dollars....just go apply for that job at Starbucks or Applebee's right now. College should be about obtaining an employable SKILL. Not filling your head with theoretical garbage.
@anewlow23
@anewlow23 10 лет назад
***** Like what?
@robertstevenson3214
@robertstevenson3214 10 лет назад
***** Exactly... higher education should be about obtaining an employable SKILL.
@JK20239
@JK20239 6 лет назад
Robert Stevenson the STEM myth is dead. Flood the market with STEM and still no job
@HE360
@HE360 8 лет назад
I have a degree and have benefited greatly from it. I used to work in a grocery store, but now have an easier job and make a pretty decent living and most people that I know from my co-workers to family has benefited as well. None regret it. So, I wouldn't say that college is not worth it. On the other hand, I had scholarships and grants that helped me get through after diligently searching for them night after night. So, I got through without incurring much debt. 'But, I agree that the possibility of incurring piles of debt is something to consider before going.
@Zara_Luna
@Zara_Luna 8 лет назад
hi HE360, Congratulations for staying motivated to get your degree. I cannot agree more about the incurring piles of debt is increasing. I would love to hear from you where are the best places to find scholarships? What extra activities helped you win the scholarships? thank you for taking the time to read this!
@HE360
@HE360 8 лет назад
Hey Anonymous, I got my part of my tuition paid for through the FAFSA Federal Pell Grant which gave me a great majority of the money that I needed. The FAFSA was given based on my income at the time. Since I wasn't making that much while working in a grocery store, they gave me more money. I did my first two years at a community college where tuition was dirt cheap. I spent two years there where my tuition was around $600 per semester or less and that was paid for again by the Pell Grant. Then, when I transferred to a university, not only did the Pell Grant continue to help me, I got music scholarships each year. I played the Tuba and I was given around $500 each semester to play in the band. Finally, after a bit of searching, asking around and referrals, I got Jazz scholarships through a musician union's organization. Well, they gave me about $1000 the first time and then they gave me from $500-$100 each year afterwards. All I had to do was ask for it each time. That organization is no longer around (at least I don't think they are), but all of the above made it so that a good 90% of my undergrad college tuition was paid for. The other 10% was paid for by me working at FedEx whose tuition program took care of my last two semesters. Finally, when I started working as a teacher, my job paid for me to finish my Master's degree. Thus, above was the way that I get through college without great expenses.
@Zara_Luna
@Zara_Luna 8 лет назад
wow, HE360, thank you for replying quickly and sharing your helpful tips. I am also using the Pell grant and WIA and hope it covers but I am staying in dorms which I believe is a rip. i can not play any instruments but i should ask around for other scholarships. so the key is to network and find a job with tuition reimbursement. great advice :)
@illsologamer
@illsologamer 10 лет назад
There has never been or ever will be a price on knowledge, therefore education should always be free. There has been doctors, engineers, lawyers, etc who have never set foot in a college but they became the best at what they did because they gathered knowledge through books and experiences. I am not saying not to go to college, I am just saying its never the best option; just a direct one.
@655432655432
@655432655432 10 лет назад
The main problem to me is that in today's world, going to college isn't the most effective way to learn and master anything, people go there most of the time to socialize thinking that all they need is a diploma to get a job and work, almost nothing is learned in 4 years and that's bad.
@illsologamer
@illsologamer 10 лет назад
llllllllllll You said a mouth full there and I completely agree with you. I went to college for about 2 years until I dropped out. I was taking unnecessary yet mandatory classes, it felt like I was repeating high school again and to be honest I learned almost nothing. The only thing there that would teach me something I wanted to study about was the books and tutorials on websites. To me (in my opinion), college is a waste of time if you are not allowed to accomplish anything in the span of 2 years.
@araibbaddarbadaarmahmoodkh624
@araibbaddarbadaarmahmoodkh624 10 лет назад
LOL "there have been doctors, engineers, lawyers etc.. who have never set foot in college" not sure if your being serious. In the modern era every doctor and lawyer has been to college. College is only useless if A) you or your parents can't afford college B) You are a lazy kid with very little ambition C) You decide to attend a prestigious university but major in a useless degree, like art. D) You are ambitious and come from a rich family who can financially support you.
@illsologamer
@illsologamer 10 лет назад
LOL "In the modern era every doctor and lawyer has been to college" That is a very vague and cliche statement. Now that would be almost 100% true if you knew every lawyer and doctor and verified their educational origins across the globe. Like I've said before there is no price on knowledge and that is now more universal than ever in this era. Anyways my point is that there are many other ways to go about getting in a desired field, college is one of them but its not the only option.
@mechaike
@mechaike 10 лет назад
illsologamer The majority of doctors, engineers, and lawyers have gone to college to hone their skills. You can check the statistical data. For such individuals, it is very obvious that universities are the best place to hone their skills. I agree with you that education should be free. It will be then not so easy to fool people into making horrible decisions.
@PrimaveraP
@PrimaveraP 10 лет назад
great podcast- as a recent graduate of the higher education industry this information really resonated with me. Thank you for posting.
@krsvbg1989
@krsvbg1989 10 лет назад
Yes! Absolutely, indisputably, indubitably, YES! Education opens many more doors. Some employers won't even consider you unless you have post-secondary education. Additionally, you'll be a better, smarter, and more skilled individual. I got my Bachelor's degree from Miami U for less than 27K without loans or grants. Regional campuses cost significantly less. Working smart > working hard.
@ArrecBarrwin
@ArrecBarrwin 10 лет назад
I think they should probably modify the question to: "Is going to college worth it... for Everybody?". Because I do agree that for those who can really take advantage of the gained knowledge and perspective of a "higher end" education (as compared to HS, CC, etc.), it is more often than not a good investment, both personally and for the economy as a whole. But for others, the cost may outweigh the benefit if they aren't able to extract the full benefit of a post-secondary education, but are merely going because "that's what you do after high school".
@Gufberg
@Gufberg 10 лет назад
I'm in the process of getting my degree from Aarhus University for free with a state provided income, so i don't have to work too much and subsidized housing. But then i live in a social democratic Welfare State. It makes me eager to get my degree and 'pay back' to society because they're giving me so much and i want the next generation to have the same options. This is how a humane system should work.
@ivanivanov2160
@ivanivanov2160 10 лет назад
Yeah I also don't get these complains about the cost. I went to community college and then I went to a public school and studied engineering. I paid all my tuition costs in less than a year when I started my career. The problem is that college is being industrialized...... I personally think its not demanding enough and its too easy to get a diploma. Also more practical skills should be thought and employers should be active in training students and not just expecting the college to do all the work for them.
@MsMikuHatsume
@MsMikuHatsume 9 лет назад
Kris Vladimirov >Some employers won't even consider you unless you have post-secondary education. Those employers are idiots. Who gives a shit you learned a bunch of theoretical nonsense from college? Work experience and marketable skills triumph a degree every time. And college does not make you a smarter and more skilled individual. The amount of debt you accumulate from college nullifies any of the advantages college gives you. You spend 4 years learning a bunch of nonsense. You spend 4 years learning stuff that you could easily find on Google. You spend tens of thousands of dollars learning stuff that you can learn for free online. That sounds like a GREAT deal. Are you kidding me? College is a rip off.
@krsvbg1989
@krsvbg1989 9 лет назад
AmandaNerdBot You have a negative attitude and a severe lack of understanding of what a college experience is. You may THINK you're "learning a bunch of nonsense." I thought my experience was very rewarding and enriching. That's the difference between you and me. That's the difference between the educated and the uneducated.
@sayavaya6722
@sayavaya6722 7 лет назад
Screw college get a trade no debt and it pays well
@kichansilva
@kichansilva 10 лет назад
As a current college student, this is simply amazing. Just amazing!!
@DennisChaves
@DennisChaves 10 лет назад
This is a great podcast! Raihan Salam is a younger, browner Charlie Rose.
@FLAMESMINISTRY
@FLAMESMINISTRY 10 лет назад
We are in the information age-things are changing rapidly. Our College system is becoming obsolete in the times we are living.
@KateLove21
@KateLove21 10 лет назад
When they are talking about people expecting to graduate just because they have entered a university, do they actually believe that this is a ''right''? How many people haven't graduated and have debt, but didn't even study seriously? How many dropped out on their own free will? University isn't supposed to be for everyone and isn't for everyone it's supposed to differentiate you from others, right? So why would you think just because you signed up you're automatically guaranteed a degree? ...
@cpkinnally
@cpkinnally 10 лет назад
Thank you for stating this. Why do people think they are entitled to a degree? The flip side is that colleges ought to be more careful about their admissions and use a system that selects students who are driven to succeed
@inquisitive871
@inquisitive871 10 лет назад
I hate teaser introductions.
@EDTHEWATERGUY
@EDTHEWATERGUY 8 лет назад
Based on the current cost benefit analysis of higher education it would far wiser right now for most high school graduates to just buy a really cheap house with a basic job and an average income.And if they have parents who can help them with a deposit and even help them pay for it,that would be even better.Most would be much better off in the long run having a house paid off by the time they are 28 than to have a degree with lots of debt and maybe (a big maybe) a better paying job. A tip that always stuck with me that was told to me when I was in high school was "it's not what you make,it's what you keep". What consumes most peoples income? Housing. Eliminate having a mortgage or any debt and you automatically give yourself at minimum a 50% raise.
@trilltrey8427
@trilltrey8427 8 лет назад
would this still apply if you were to buy an rv and live in it full time??
@EDTHEWATERGUY
@EDTHEWATERGUY 8 лет назад
trill trey Yes for some people but for many it's a bit too inconvenient.You have to find somewhere to park it,hookup water etc. and while it is even cheaper than a small house it's a lower quality lifestyle and would be better served as a temporary situation.
@1995Benzo
@1995Benzo 8 лет назад
I don't care how cheap the how is, with a basic job, How do you expect that these individuals will be able to pay off a house by the time they are 28? Also, if the house is REALLY cheap, there is a %100 chance that they'll have to put money into it to make it at least comfortable. With a basic job, how do they accomplish this AND pay off this money pit by the time they are 28? EXPLAIN!
@EDTHEWATERGUY
@EDTHEWATERGUY 8 лет назад
1995Benzo Interest rates on a 15 year loans are less than 3% right now.If someone buys a house that needs some TLC for around $150,000 that would cost around $1000 a month.(still cheaper than most rents) With food,electricity,auto costs and insurance most people should be able to earn the couple of grand needed a month working almost anywhere.Even if it means two part time jobs. And you wouldn't have to do it for 15 years either. If the price of the house appreciates anytime in that 15 year loan period you could always sell it for a gain and use the profits to pay down the next fixer upper or just keep the profits in the bank.
@ArchaicStigma
@ArchaicStigma 9 лет назад
There's a huge difference between not graduating in 4 years and not graduating.
@abdinoorful
@abdinoorful 10 лет назад
in the modern world keys to success- Being a great manipulator -Motivated -Have no empathy(almost psychopathic) and use and dispose of people, flat out realism brudha.
@TheHargrave21
@TheHargrave21 10 лет назад
Its not a scam its just horrendously dis-proportionate in terms of equality
@genma986
@genma986 10 лет назад
***** Allot of textbook authors seems to be paid per word rather than content, maybe that's the reason they seem to like to cram as much crap into the books as possible.
@TheHargrave21
@TheHargrave21 10 лет назад
***** It's just a shame that the US educational system is churning out a broken educated class. They either need to bring the loan repayment system in line with how other states manage their repayments. IE the UK or as stated in the video no degree no fee simples.
@genma986
@genma986 10 лет назад
That would be a start, the loans should be low rates and goverment loans aswell.
@senjinblack5199
@senjinblack5199 10 лет назад
Until society starts using character and aptitude as the major factors in selecting people for employment colleges will be able to take advantage of potential students. It's easy to beat up on the educational system of a society, but ultimately will not solve the problem. We're really good at addressing the symptoms instead of the diseases and we remain perpetually sick. The problem isn't the collegiate system itself, it's that society mandates to even be considered for the top level jobs you need to have a degree. This creates a condition, much like healthcare, of a MUST HAVE situation. Because of this colleges will profiteer and charge more and more money so that people can get the credentials in order to advance in society.
@jonniekang
@jonniekang 10 лет назад
My advice is DONT GO TO COLLEGE if you're going into the tech industry. Work hard and learn more skills.
@cdcVintage
@cdcVintage 5 лет назад
I've done 4 years of research on the eduction bubble. Too many people try to sugar coat this. All this debt for a piece of paper...glad I dodged this bullet.
@ns81
@ns81 10 лет назад
Ok I've been listening to this off and on for a few days and I basically think the following. In Asia, there are all the same competitive pressures. It's even worse. Without a college degree you're practically worthless in the work force, so students kill themselves to get into college. I think two things are going to happen. College degrees are already too expensive for the value they provide, and a new generation of students is going to get hip to that. That probably portends bad things, but not if we improve primary and secondary education. With crappy primary and secondary education, not only are your chances of getting into college lower, but so are your chances of thriving and graduating. My pie-in-the-sky dream is to see a system where things are "niched down" a lot - where somebody who would benefit from a degree has multiple options (hopefully because the gild of prestige is off the lily), and where primary and secondary ed is high quality enough that people who want to be entrepreneurs and don't feel college is worth the money have enough basic skills to to that. I'm an optimist, so I see things going that way. The tier that's always to first to die off is the overpriced mediocre schools, and good riddance.
@araibbaddarbadaarmahmoodkh624
@araibbaddarbadaarmahmoodkh624 10 лет назад
Huh "college degrees are already too expensive for the value they prove". Tell that to any IB analyst making 70k base salary and a bonus of 20-40k. First year post undergrad. Degrees are only useless if you major in a useless topic.
@ns81
@ns81 10 лет назад
Araib Baddar Badaar Mahmood Khalid Sardar Man. Do What You Do. If that works for you, great. If you're an IB analyst than you're probably a free market guy like me, right? So, the market will set the value of these degrees. If people get a good ROI on that degree program, it's not overpriced. The only thing I'm arguing is college has kind of been in this ivory tower where it's been insulated from market pressures, and I see that dissolving, and I think that's a positive thing.
@Misshughestrm
@Misshughestrm 6 лет назад
if colleges only got paid for students who graduated they would be much more invested in preventing drop outs
@cosmicgiggle5942
@cosmicgiggle5942 10 лет назад
Follow the path to where "tuitions" are truely paid. Follow the path to where "scholarships" are beinging "granted". The promise for "good" education is a infomercial away.
@ianboelts
@ianboelts 10 лет назад
really great interview if you have the patience to watch it through until the end!
@mrsmephisty
@mrsmephisty 10 лет назад
Mr Salam is a great host, I very much enjoy these Podcasts. Very interesting piece.
@incubated
@incubated 10 лет назад
first things first, ask yourself do you want to be an employee or do you want to work for yourself. if you answer the latter, higher education is a less restrictive option. right now, it makes absolutely no sense, i mean blind shit crazy, to go to college/university to study a subject you like. do that on your own. you go to college for the piece of paper that gives return on your investment which is both time and money. search for what's in demand. search for what is realistically within your abilities, and push yourself.
@JaaProductionss
@JaaProductionss 10 лет назад
true purpose of a university is to teach history and expand on pre-existing factual knowledge in an attempt to create future progression in the overall educated human populations' intelligence. but philosophy is awesome; being a quality writer is a mandatory skill in understanding and communicating language sufficiently, theories are what answer the questions of our past. Going to college I've just been amazed at the amount of people who simply don't belong in a learning environment. most people lack these basic aspects of early educational teachings and simply can't grasp anything other than factual material from books that they have difficulty reading through. Half of my classes have open note tests, how does that teach you anything? mind boggling... Teachers with passion, that's what makes a college education worth it. forget what you're trying to make of your life and focus on what's important: keep an open mind, because the information will be pouring in
@TheFanatical1
@TheFanatical1 8 лет назад
America must be a really shitty place right now if you actually have to ask this question
@SeanP7195
@SeanP7195 8 лет назад
+TheFanatical1 Ehh, its getting there man. Still a great place to make money but it is getting stupid.
@TheLouis3877
@TheLouis3877 8 лет назад
+TheFanatical1 i don't think so. Every person should be asking themselves this question, most people get degrees and go into the real world with nobody wanting to hire them. unless you want to work in medicine or something like that college wont help you but will leave you with debt that you can't pay for because you wont be able to find a decent job because you don't have any experience because........ if we keep going any further the world will collapse on itself.
@fungalinthekitchen
@fungalinthekitchen 10 лет назад
this is a little off topic but another one of the huge factors of cost is the inflation prices of textbooks for students. I just bought a stack of papers as a textbook from my school this last semester for $120. It was not even the whole textbook.
@randynickless4012
@randynickless4012 4 года назад
Potential college students out of high school - get out, intern, or get employed in business or industry that interests you. Make sure first it's a viable market and that it is interesting to you, then go to MOOC or Flex program. It's difficult right out of high school to figure out what you want to do with your work-life. Or start a business and hustle.
@Judicial78
@Judicial78 10 лет назад
Part of the problem is the amount of liberal arts degrees. We need more people getting involved in STEM. Without STEM a country and thus a people stagnate.
@theuntergroundman
@theuntergroundman 10 лет назад
If STEM degrees were as common as liberal arts degrees, computer programmers and engineers would be making $25,000/year.
@MrZanderito
@MrZanderito 10 лет назад
James Saunder I was one of the those Algebra 1 guys. Had to take Algebra 2 for four straight quarters (3 repeats) in college just to get a passing grade. Two years later I couldn't tell you a single thing about it.
@gary_beniford
@gary_beniford 10 лет назад
Alexander Wilson I failed algebra two my junior year then I went to summer school had a great teacher and passed with a 94
@5am_mills
@5am_mills 7 лет назад
If students do not graduate, there needs to be a guarantee for money back or something
@tiiarautavesi2449
@tiiarautavesi2449 6 лет назад
Blessed to be Finnish now; university is free and the school gets money only when and if I graduate.
@Foreverflynick
@Foreverflynick 10 лет назад
college is not for everybody, i'm part of that remedial statistic. hopefully i graduate
@gloriadiaz6400
@gloriadiaz6400 5 лет назад
Good luck! Don't give up!
@alexxkinney
@alexxkinney 8 лет назад
This fuckin government ripped me off when it comes to college. They ripped me off bad.
@kevinshukla9606
@kevinshukla9606 9 лет назад
If you want to make it big and be self actualized like Bill Gates, then going to college is as useful as a vegetarian in a steak house. Think about it, millions of people have graduated but only a small fraction of them actually make millionaire status. The ONLY way to reach the big leagues is by doing something astronomically intuitive like creating the pet rock. That guy made so much off that brilliant idea and it must have taken him a long time to come up with something like THAT. Do colleges teach you how to come up with pet rocks? NOOOOOO! They teach you how to find the slope of Lebron James's hairline and also how to get the individuality and life sucked right out of you. Did college teach Warren Buffet how to predict the success of stocks? Nah. So all of you AP scholars or College grads who made it on the Dean's list, enjoy your six figure salaries that won't even land you your dream homes and can barely assist you in retiring your parents while I self educate myself towards software development and excel to make millions. Come at me.
@kevinshukla9606
@kevinshukla9606 9 лет назад
+Paul Harmon Writing this comment, I had no chill whatsoever haha.
@kevinshukla9606
@kevinshukla9606 8 лет назад
+joshdj12 You're like the voice of reason, haha. Especially with your views of networking and other branches of computer science. It's just that I like to think that making millions of dollars is not as hard as people make it out to be. With my example of the pet rock, you can see that it doesn't take a genius to make millions, but rather just a creative mind. Colleges shove information down your throat and even for useful degrees like CPU science. What I usually urge people to do is just learn CPU science by themselves so they won't be in debt, and they can start coding in seconds. Apps are the trend nowadays, so just get a good idea, and make a successful app. It can be simple like snapchat, which is one of the most successful apps today. Snapchat is nothing but sharing pictures, it didn't take a zuckerberg or some kind of innovator to come up with that. I can conclude by saying bravo to you for understanding what's useful and what isn't.
@XolisykeswifeX
@XolisykeswifeX 8 лет назад
+Kevin Shukla I actually have the pet rock lol
@XolisykeswifeX
@XolisykeswifeX 8 лет назад
+kevin shukla you can get one at think geek lol
@Dakrazialbo
@Dakrazialbo 8 лет назад
+Kevin Shukla Totally, formal education is overrated. Especially now, i mean you can seriously Google anything and find an answer within minutes.
@saltybatch29
@saltybatch29 10 лет назад
These folks having this conversation are obviously well-educated. Is higher education expensive? Yes. Is it still necessary? Arguably, yes. This is a valid conversation (discussion) to have. I just don't believe a high school education is sufficient. Learning a trade has always been a smart way to go.
@emilys8890
@emilys8890 6 лет назад
College is definitely important but I don't think it's needed for a lot of careers. It also never takes 2 or 4 years. Even a community 2-year college takes more time. Especially for people who work and can't take full time. You need 60 credits to graduate. 2 years is four semesters +2 Summer semesters, 15 credits a semester (not with summer) it's hard to be able to complete it that fast when you have so many other things in your life. Especially hard when you in university spending so much money. Experience is so important. I have a cousin who dropped out of community college, started working at an insurance company AS A RECEPTIONIST...but was able to rise the ranks (the company gave her free classes for the job) and now she's making a good amount of money...lives in a nice house and is able to get a new/used car every 3-6 years if she wants. Some jobs/careers definitely need a good amount of school and it's good to get an associate...but maybe getting into a $40,000 debt is not the best for a lot.
@tennektrey5227
@tennektrey5227 4 года назад
Hiring managers prefer employees who have a degree. Why? College teaches to work with others, teaches you time management, and shows you how to solve issues. It’ll show how you can adapt and overcome to obstacles in life. Good luck being a physician or an attorney from watching RU-vid. BTW, you’ll always be in debt in some way shape or form. If you can’t afford a payment of $50 a month, then you’ve got money management issues.
@PhraseAnother
@PhraseAnother 10 лет назад
Society puts the belief that EVERYONE should go to college, or, at least, expect for you to go. College isn't for everyone, and it shouldn't be, which is why we have kids with $50k+ debt and can't land a job fulfilling their major. Soon the tuition rates are going to be insane, and I can't imagine how much it'd be 20 years from now. We're going to have kids with hundreds of thousands of debt for life if this continues.
@gdemetruliasjr
@gdemetruliasjr 10 лет назад
Really, the problem is two fold. One, the cost is astronomical. I will say that students aren't getting what they pay for (and now, I will embellish this point). Two, the reason for attending college should be self-arbitrated extensively. Don't go to college on the presumption that your life will be somehow magically better by just going to classes and doing your homework. Mainly, don't waste your time. Go with a reason to go, like professional studies (doctor, lawyer, journalist, field academic, engineer, etc). Don't waste your money and time on some ideal that life will piece itself together. I will say that bachelor degrees are yesterday's HS diplomas or GEDs. Yes, there was a time not too long ago where a HS diploma was an accomplishment. Now, it's not even a blip on the radar. To surmise, have an "end game" going into it. Also, don't do it for anyone else but you. Not your parents, family, friends, no one. Have a higher purpose for yourself and not anyone else. On that note alone, be selfish and use that as a motivating factor to push yourself to grow beyond academia to the world beyond those halls.
@mikemacaulay84
@mikemacaulay84 10 лет назад
The answer to this video is no
@johnsebastianbach
@johnsebastianbach 10 лет назад
I've worked in factories for five years since graduating High School and am just now working on my College education. I don't regret taking the time to find what I wanted to go for. However I think an education is very important if you don't want to work menial jobs for the rest of your life. I just hope after I graduate my degree is actually worth something.
@KateLove21
@KateLove21 10 лет назад
It takes on average 5 years to graduate university for a lot of people. But honestly this has a lot to do with the fact that many people are 18 or 19 when they enter and take their party lifestyle more seriously than the education aspect. Many people don't realize college isn't just a high school atmosphere with alcohol and abuse that and neglect their studies so you can't really blame the school for ''stealing your money''. Also now an undergrad is like a H.S diploma.
@ThisisRubbishlo
@ThisisRubbishlo 10 лет назад
Gone are there days when people went to college University purely out of curiously and the pursuit of knowledge. It's the karaoke generation we have today. Over prescribed courses with maybe a 15% to 30% chance of being employed in your chosen degree.
@depthoffield4744
@depthoffield4744 9 лет назад
Who needs college when you have Wikipedia?
@joquettahummons783
@joquettahummons783 8 лет назад
+4727csy and youtube
@lorfetti9422
@lorfetti9422 8 лет назад
Udemy
@ticks4ticks4
@ticks4ticks4 8 лет назад
+Lor fetti & Coursera; Khan Academy; others.
@robertstevenson3214
@robertstevenson3214 8 лет назад
+DepthOfField I hope this is your attempt at irony. Wikipedia is good to spark your interest in a subject. Depth is found in online courses and books.
@depthoffield4744
@depthoffield4744 8 лет назад
Robert Stevenson Depth is found in internal links.
@vidmojo
@vidmojo 10 лет назад
Debt for a B.S.:35-50 thousand USD...... Salary IF you get ANY work after: 16k-32k USD.... The stupidly of those economics when you factor conservative living expenses in 2014: Priceless
@Eng1neering
@Eng1neering 10 лет назад
You can easily learn all the theory that you would learn in college, online. But the labs that force you to apply that theory is something that you cannot do at home with a lot of discipline.
@4rnorthwest
@4rnorthwest 3 года назад
I run two businesses. Never went to college. College is for people that don’t want to earn a living TODAY!🙂
@dudewhyfi
@dudewhyfi 10 лет назад
I just graduated from a top 20 college with a degree but if I could go back to 2009, I'd have taken the construction worker job that I'd been offered back then. Real talk.
@Eng1neering
@Eng1neering 10 лет назад
As many others have said; higher education here is not bad at all provided you choose the right area of study.
@richardramfire3971
@richardramfire3971 3 года назад
I do agree that in many cases college is a waste of time but so many companies are requiring them for even entry level positions. It’s crazy
@promiseanyanwu
@promiseanyanwu 7 лет назад
If this Vice thing doesn't work out - boy does this guy have a future in audio book narrating.
@hansblitz7770
@hansblitz7770 10 лет назад
Being a con-artist is good business in Murrica.
@bvannie93
@bvannie93 10 лет назад
I think it's the last business left.
@giannizamora7247
@giannizamora7247 9 лет назад
I was offered positions over candidates that had degrees because I had experience and was self-taught. I'm 20 by the way. "Some people graduate but be still stupid" - kanye
@Lifeafter40
@Lifeafter40 9 лет назад
+Gianni Zamora the cream will rise until it sours. After you get to a higher level within your organization you will not rise anymore until you get a degree. The more you wait the harder it will be. If you are 20 begin to prepare for that and attend college part-time.
@giannizamora7247
@giannizamora7247 9 лет назад
+TheMorfin2011 that's understandable but my ambition isn't to rise a corporate ladder. I would rather create passive income by investing in different opportunities.
@Lifeafter40
@Lifeafter40 9 лет назад
***** Don't underestimate the connections that could be made and the knowledge that you gain through school. Licenses and other knowledge are useful in the pursue of passive income specially in real estate and financial investments, or to get to the venture capitalist that will fund your next project. If you are young take your time experimenting and if you see the need or the value later you are smart and will know when its time. Good luck on your journey!
Далее
Why College Is So Expensive In America
18:05
Просмотров 5 млн
How College Broke the Labor Market
28:59
Просмотров 1 млн
ANDDD STILL 😤 #UFC307
00:22
Просмотров 321 тыс.
The Harvard Scam: How Elite Schools Steal From You
17:18
Is a University Degree a Waste of Money?
14:39
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Zadie Smith on Populists, Frauds and Flip Phones
1:12:03
The First Post-Affirmative Action Class Enters College
30:03
Mark Kleiman on Regulating Weed: VICE Podcast 022
56:25