Is Hindu hatred the reason of Indo-Pak Partition? Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed and Shakil Chaudhary  

Stay blessed

Really love u sir

Rightly so.

👌👌👌

Tunhji héndú dhi khy yahan chacha

But very least Muslims are good with Hindus. This is the diffrence

Whats the use though? At the end of the day do atleast muslims like u would come in defense of the hindus in areas where they are minority? NO u simply need/want ur hindu neighbours to be good to u where they are majority but simply wouldnt fight against the injustices commited towards hindus by muslims in areas where they have majority. Why is muslim educated, elite and even the so called peaceful population so complicit and spineless to put a simple resistance against something which is wrong? Im jusf curious, is it the fear of being killed by muslim mobs or simple moral bankruptcy?

Ummah matters not regions or Boundries

Reverse is not true.

@@ramakantpanchal1536 exactly.

Wonderful people, great to hear them discuss in a civil manner, compared to cacophony elsewhere. Thank you Tahir ji.

Very informative

Reading the comments by Indians shows that partition was worth it. Pakistan has to stand on its own feet. With imran khan, this may be possible.

@@hassanazad4627 same attitude what these intelligent people were lamenting about. Looks like everything went over your head.

Yaar main soch raha tha k inn musalmano se Pakistan k 4 soobey nahi sambhalte To agar inko india ko sambhalna pada to 27 soobe kaise sambhalenge🤣🤣🙏

Sorry Pakistanis can never change their mind for India.

*Zohaib saheb, afsos, ki aap ke jaisey log pak mein ek **_endangered species_** hain. Matlab itney kam hain ki aapki bat ki koi sunwai hi nahin hai wahan!*

@Zohaib Ghauri, Thanks.

@@ShakilChaudhary Sir I am very thankful for you, Dr Ishtiaq sir, Tahir Gora sir and all guests on your platform and TAG TV for educating and enlightening us about the reality of Pakistan and India relations, conflicts, history and it's amplications. Greetings from Lahore Pakistan

@@shreedadarwala7650 you are right brother but you see the only way forward for pakistan is to completely eliminate it's anti hindu mindset in it's state narrative and genral masses and have normal ties with India.

Totally agree with you Rahul . nobody can reach to the level of Understanding that Dr Ambedkar had regarding Hindu -Muslim and India and Pak and Psyche of sub continent ✌️

@@akshatgoyal96 yes Bhai the great leader he never even thought about SC ST nation or OBC but asked for betterment of them through education and that is why i believe in education and ambedkar in the level of God

Its the most clear thaught expressing and reality check book on partition.

as a brahmin I deeply respect Dr Ambedkar he was very sensed about islamism and psudo secularism of nehru and gandhi when he converted he choosed to accept budhism not leaving the dharmic fold instead of converting into abrahamic faith.

Very intlectual discussion.but I regret to note that very basic and primary reason of enmity between both is typical interpretation of Koran in pak.

True it is a garison state.

@A B S S: Thanks for your words of appreciation.

⁰⁰⁰

Hum bhi Rajasthani 🙏

Hello 😊☺️❤️

Bhai you forgot one thing , the most important one, the root cause, Islam

It was Zia Ul Haq who sowed the seeds of the Pakistan crisis today . In the 1980s, he brought in religious nationalism as the identity for Pakistan. This has made real issues of modern education, health, security , economy get overlooked and go out of the window.

@The Journey- Voyage of Life for the most part, I agree.

​@@trilokyamohanchakra6351You are right, Islam is the root cause, its time for it to answer for Numerous sins committed by its followers in the name of religion

Soon Modi will stiffle Pakistan by squeezing these five rivers...

In this Situation we can not Trust on You All the Time Pakistani Govt Poke Nife in the Back of India

Send the Pakistani army back to the barracks to solve the problems

And Tahir Sir is at his gentlemanly best.

Prof need to know the political ideology of Islam (Muslims)that threatens Hindus on Hindus prospective. His recent trip to Bharat miserably failed. In which world he is living I don't know. Prophably he might have cell difficiancy in his brain.

Prof. Ishtiaq is data-driven & does factual analysis on history. But, He's too much idealistic & Eutopian for current era.

But the sad part is majority of the Pakistani population don't listen to these gems. And don't pay any heed. Their discussion heals all the wounds of past and melt us, but the reality is different. Pakistani Punjabi Sunni Muslim have immense hatred for Hindus and India. And this is 💯 truth.

@@Vk-sk7nm Can relations between the two countries improve or normalise now? If not, the reason? To me, the three panelists have pointed at them but not stated bluntly. The panelists have agreed that the two nation theory has failed and that Pakistan was created on the basis of hatred. But there are two more reasons which go along with these. First, the elites and politicians of Pakistan have painted Bharat as their enemy no.1 and towards this end they have made Hindus as enemies of Islam. Second, the elites and politicians of Pakistan have foisted on the Pakistani madarsa system of education. This has stunted the rationale thinking of the Pakistanis. Third, again, the elites and politicians of Pakistan have allowed the fringe to become the mainstream. These three ailments have afflicted the muslim intelligentsia of Bharat too. Sadly, Bharat is following suit in one aspect (I am talking of Hinndus). The fringe in Bharat is, more and more, asserting as the mainstream. I shudder to think of the consequences for Bharat if this trend continues for 10 years.

I have never accepted Jinnah's. pathetic EXCUSE for Partition! Beyond that I even suspect Jinnah's plot to marry his friend;'s daughter and how he set his friend up to surrender Rattna Bai!

Rattan Bai!

Bengalis punjabis have suffered partition. Not all india. Kashmiris are still suffering. Hindu muslim is not a problem, problem is poverty , colonization, British

Muslims learnt thatThey were born to dominate and enslave Hindus.That is thew driving force that led to their notions of Muslim superiority buttressed by their sense of having ruled "India" for 700+/- over Hindus.Really fooling themselves as History and current state of Pk shows.Jinnah was a narrow-minded fool!

Agreed, but almost all Pakistani awaam follow and reflect on their elite's narrative. Elites are just 1-2% of any given nations population, who control majority resources and assets of the nation, but problem with Pakistan is no one is ready to stand up against their elites's rule. Even after realising that "this is not true".

shakil chaudhary is a gem of a person..you must follow his youtube channel with same name

the critical patriot is the name of shakils sahabs youtube channel

@@ishanbhardwaj3256 Thanks

@@ishanbhardwaj3256 Thanks

@Jyalmen Sidhho, Thanks for your compliment. Let me introduce the Five Rivers Friendship Forum to you and other friends. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5K6ceO3ZG7Q.html

What is the use?

Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued. Quran 9:29

Join #Sachwala .

Rajesh भाई ये discussions हो रही है क्यूंकि पाकिस्तान की fatti पडी है. पाकिस्तान को aaj China का साथ khulkar मिल जाए तो यहीं RU-vidr intellectual नहीं kahunga इनको यहीं China का gungan kar rahe होते.

@@donaldtramp38 yeh log Pakistan Liberals hai

@@rishavkumar1250 ghante के Liberal

@@donaldtramp38 Tujhe aisa लगता hoga, Muslim विरुद्ध hote होते ab toh common sense ke विरुद्ध bhi ho gaye 😂

I don’t have any

Main problem is : Is**l*am. Wherever this is there , there is no peace and only poverty, violence.

No hope for Pakistan and Islam...

You'll not find Muslims leadership which is as calm as this group

Indian social media is far better and vast. Watch jaipur dialogue channel on RU-vid

Those lucky souls stay abroad.

Lol, Pakistanis are very good at showing their best face forwards and do the best talks. Don't take them at face value.

Use the word "Religion" and your eyes will be opened automatically

Try living there and you will know.

@@YogeshSharma-zy8uz I don't have to live anywhere, to understand minds. People like you will find Hitler an evil man, but there has been not a single leader in the history of mankind who could convert a nation from the very bottom to the power which could advance in every sphere, just in a span of a decade or less. But, people like you have a closed mind.

Please correct me if I’m wrong how23%hindus come 1% 428 temples during partition comes to 10th at also in ruins

Sikkim is integral part of India ❤ land of Dhamma

What a highly intelectual discussion and extremely fair, pleasure to participate

Cheema ko bhi bulawo yaha

@@RAVI22ize Arrest karke ?

@@RAVI22ize wo aajkal rana ayuub ko date kar raha hai.

@@sourav2124 😄😄😄😄😄

@@sourav2124 😂😂😂😂

History books are all lies whitewashing congress.

Why are you proud? What is your achievement? Listening to them?

@@1aarora भाई मूर्ख जाहिल हिंदू ऐसे ही होते हैं।

@@1aarora Deep down… the speakers love Pakistan and are having this discussion for the benefit of Pakistan and not India. I think he meant he is proud of India, which is fine.

@@Pearls103 how kind that you want to interpret someone else’s statement for me. I think I’m fine in the field of reading comprehension. Is he under 18 yrs of age and not responsible for his actions that you feel the need to clarify his statement. Pride/being proud, is a very strong subjective feeling. Should one be proud (Hindi-Ghamandi) at all? If yes, then only of one’s achievements. How can one be proud of someone else’s achievements remains a mystery to me.

@@1aarora Arora sahib, thora thand rakhiye