@@Hiptoys It just depends on my "losing". But I kinda agree with you, I couldn't understand how Israel still hasn't fully capture a single day in like more than 5 months
See about the start of ramadan all offensives stopped. No official reason but probably pressure from USA. Now Ramadan is over lets see what happens.@@StarterOffical-Jousha-lf6ig
You write about Israeli governent loosing support of citizens, yet you neglect to mention most if them still want war to continue, just with different leadership.
@@originalchunky300They definitely don't want more humanitarian aid to go to gaza, as they've been blocking themselves the passage of aid trucks through the Kerem Shalom crossing
"The 3 hostages that were mistakenly killed by the IDF" were literally holding white flags as they were heading to the idf soldiers, they were met but multiple gun shots.
The reason for that was because of recurring method of Terrorists luring troops by acting like they're hostages obviously nobody wanted this but it's just the cynical way of terrorists to conduct war
I really don't know how an individual could support the IDF when they do this. This is such a clear point of evidence that they do not give a care to the civilian death toll and their military is incredibly undisciplined. Regardless of your position on Palestinian nationhood, this shit is inexcusable especially since this is definitely not an isolated case.
I don't think you realize how urban warfare works. Especially not against a ter ror organization that does not adhere to international law, and most of it strategies are based on war crimes. Did you even read the investigation?
@@KommandantAegis because it's an army that retaliated to invasion to it's ground and murder of 1400 people including civilians and babies you only see the bad things in the media because that's where your bias stand at
No it's not. He is doing that because he knows the public opinion is against Israel and war crimes but when he would be in power he won't do a thing to help
@@ahiaamrosi5459 I'm not saying anything, even though he was the last president and the biggest financial supporter of Israel than any other president though.
@@ethandouro4334 that's not even true... Biden gave Israel a lot of help which demnish trump support (which is obvious because during trump presidency there wasnt such a war in Israel.) You are just wrong
Why would he be facing criminal charges. He's unpopular because he's slowing the war down not because he's warring. Most Israelites want an invasion of Rafah because it's the only way to win
@@PeterPeter-pr2hiIt's about people wanting simply solutions to difficult problems. But difficult problems are difficult because there are no simple solutions.
@@christianbolisca1493 It seems like maybe violently suppressing the right through a state apparatus might be necessary low key and not constant capitulation in service of the imaginary center.
Israel is not losing the PR, it is just the world is starting to understand the nature of the Israeli society. Israel is just a colonial society that have to be fascist to survive.
@@jacquotalexandre3804 Israel was made by resettling Zionist from Europe to Palestine by force under the British mandate of Palestine. Thank you for your comment.
I'm not mad, I don't care what they do. Let them fight eachother and leave us out of it. Muslims and Jews need to sort their shit out and stop dragging us into it.
@@wheres_bears1378 not only for now. You underestimate the will of israel fighting wars despite bad diplomacies. Israel's history is rich with critisicm and boycotts during wars but they kept on going and finished with the upper hand.
Israel's style of public relations: 1. We haven't heard reports of deaths, will check into it; 2. The people were killed, but by a faulty Palestinian rocket/bomb; 3. OK we killed them, but they were terrorists; 4. OK they were civilians, but they were being used as human shields; 5. OK there were no fighters in the area, so it was our mistake. But we kill civilians by accident, they do it on purpose; 6. OK we kill far more civilians than they do, but look at how terrible other countries are! 7. Why are you still talking about Israel? Are you some kind of anti-semite? Test this against the next interview you hear or watch. Adam Johannes, Secretary, Stop the War Coalition
You're a clown. The day you'll have an armed militia that doesn't recognize your right to live and your country to exist, you're welcome to demand your government to stop the war.
palestinians- "we dont have any bunkers under el shifa". bunker under al shifa . "israel built it in the 1980s". even though israel handed the gaza city to the PLO in 1993,comletely withdrew from the strip in 2005,and the buidling on top of the bonquer is a newer donation from qatar(no one noticed it while digging for foundations...) and they built a recent cars shed over the entry...palestinian explanations...😂
@@iamagirl9938palestinians- "we dont have any bunkers under el shifa". bunker under al shifa . "israel built it in the 1980s". even though israel handed the gaza city to the PLO in 1993,comletely withdrew from the strip in 2005,and the buidling on top of the bonquer is a newer donation from qatar(no one noticed it while digging for foundations...) and they built a recent cars shed over the entry...palestinian explanations...😂 and if you question their version -shame on you islamophobe!
palestinians- "we dont have any bunkers under el shifa". bunker under al shifa . "israel built it in the 1980s". even though israel handed the gaza city to the PLO in 1993,comletely withdrew from the strip in 2005,and the buidling on top of the bonquer is a newer donation from qatar(no one noticed it while digging for foundations...) and they built a recent cars shed over the entry...palestinian explanations...😂 and if you question their version -shame on you islamophobe!
Yes. But Israel didnt start it. If Cuba or Nicaragua shoots thousands of rockets and invades US(whatever be the bad things ) you think US will twiddle their thumb and sit quiet?
a russian communist comes to hungary. "you here for work or pleasure?" "you have pleasure here? you were part of the warsaw pact!" the hunagrian border guard"occupation?" the russian communist "you know what,i will let you pick one for youtself. but only this time!" but russia talking about occupation ...
Imagine being backed up by the USA, spending billions of dollars on arms, having thousands of soldiers who are part-time tiktokers and losing the war against one of the poorest and densely populated places in the middle east.
Much more the Bashar el Assad and rest Islamic states... think how many of those 41K were Hamas militants and how many civilians were assisting them with hiding their rocket lunches and kept hostages from 7th october
In 4:35 you mentioned Gantz being Netanyahu's main rival but showed a poll graph of Netanyahu vs Lapid from a few years ago... You should've used a more recent clip.
I have to commend you for being able to touch on basically all of the political issues going on here in the most concise and objective manner I've seen - WAY better than legacy media coverage.
It is breathtaking that you can count the number of hostages directly saved by the IDF on one hand, and that it's the same as the number the IDF has itself directly _killed,_ and yet after months of this there are people clinging to the idea that they're of any use in getting the hostages back.
It is not a war. These two American doctors returned from Gaza European hospital. Dr Mark Perlmutter Dr Feroze Sidhwa It is genocide. The aim is ethnic cleansing. Calling it a war is a comforting lie. It minimizes complicity, it normalises the dehumanisation of gazan civilians.
No one thinks the IDF on their own will get hostages... The IDF is a negotiation tool for a deal with Hamas to free the hostages (which is the only plausible way they can come back alive). Israelis know that, hence they protest for the government to actually do right and **bring them home**.
You pretend hamas was not forced to release many hostages. But you have to declare a nation fighting back against one of the worst attacks as evil. You are mad Israel itself does not give up and die.
Victory? Isreal never achieved their goal in gaza. Hostages still there and never reached El-Sinwar or el-daif or finding any significant headquarters as they said before launching the war.
Well considering Israel basically just explained why the holocaust happened through the way they have acted the last half year, it is a loss, even if they win the war, everybody wants them dead now, well everybody with a soul at least
@BestPrezz they already achieved their goal f$cked israel on 7th October and taking hostages for negotiations to end gaza +16 year of being a concentration camp. + obstacles the saudi-israeli normalization process.
Militarily, Israel can invade Rafah tomorrow and theoretically "win." The real question is reputation. It's the "I've won, but at what cost?" situation. Reputation issues are bad enough now, they're going to get way worse in a few more months. And it's not like Israel can puff up its chest and say they can continue on their own without international support on anything.
@@glitch9065 yes every people living in the land was called palestinian before 1947. Then arabs claimed the name “Palestinian” in 1964 when they fprmed PLO. Look up when the palestine flag was founded.
"Every time anyone says that Israel is our only friend in the Middle East, I can't help but think that before Israel, we had no enemies in the Middle East."--------Father John Sheehan
@@MissionControlTet Muslims had better, larger and more durable civilization. 20% of earth pop. are muslims from different ethnicities. Yet how is yours by the way.
@laithmughrabi8990 "MUSLIMS HAVE BETTER CIVILIZATION" LMAOOOO SO THAT'S WHY MUSLIMS ARE TRYING SO HARD TO MOVE TO THE WEST?? TO THE SHITHOLE COUNTRIES? WHY DON'T YOU ALL LEAVE?
Remember that they said on TV "Ramadan is the best time to ~unalive~ them (in Rafah) while they are still weak from fasting. Why should we comply with Biden?"
no, Ramadan is actually the best time for Hamas, because it makes them ideologically strong. They believe that Ramadan is the time for fighting, because that is what their religion teaches. This is why there was an ISIS attack in Russia. Ramadan is the time for Jihad. Also it is not your idea of fasting. They have two huge meals at night and early in the morning. So they are not hungry. It's like when you skip meals, a fasting without starving.
I warned in October in this channel about the possibility of Israel losing their main goal in the hunger of revenge. The futher the October 7th goes and much more Israel is unable to show some concrete good results of this war in comparison to the damage they caused, Israel has little hope to end this war in their terms.
That all depends on the real goals of the operation. If your goal is to push the Palestinians out of Gaza, the IDF is doing fairly well at it. Netanyahu has never been shy about his desire to have settlements throughout the area, and you have Kushner in the US talking about beachside resorts in Gaza. I remain unconvinced that this wasn't the Israeli government's goal all along.
Israel will 100% end this war in their terms. The question is what percentage of their goals will they achieve. If they don't approach this with more importance they won't completely end Hamas. Now, they've already crippled the organisation possibly beyond repair. And they've already decimated Gaza.
@@sinocte they aren’t? They are returning to there neighborhoods (yeah it’s completely destroyed but it’s in Gaza) military wise this hasn’t been a success at all
In the 1st 30 seconds I heard a falsehood. Hamas has stated that there are fewer than 40 hostages alive in Gaza. There are not more than 100 hostages missing, there are more than 60 hostages who are dead.
Ukraine has been at war for several years now, something like 17 journalist died there so far. Israel has killed more than 100 journalist in 6 months. Nevermind aid workers.
Israel would end every life in Gaza in order to get their families back. And I would too, if another country kidnapped my family. I fully support them. Hamas needs to release the hostages so this can end.
Indiscriminately bombarding civilian areas, killing more than 30 000 as mere collateral damage and calling it a PR problem is also kind of missing the forest for the trees, isn't it.
This is a little click baity imo. They are def losing the pr war but they don’t care as they now view Hamas as existential threat more then anything else which hurts pr. Militarily tho they’re def completing objectives as they currently control like 80% of strip, rockets fired by Hamas have stopped, and they’re only operational in Rafah. Two very diff questions imo and vary on importance depending on who you ask
PR is extremely important in war, especially domestic and that of allies that supply you. Bad PR is the sole reason why the US lost in Vietnam and Afghanistan.
@@jascrandom9855 That would be domestic PR you’re talking about, quite a different thing from international pressure. It took like three years for anyone to do anything about Yugoslavia? And the international community basically just let the Rwandan genocide burn itself out. I don’t think the current situation in Gaza is quite to that level of escalation/brutality mind you, but just pointing out that the international community isn’t actually all that important. If your cause still has strong, domestic support, a more recent example would be Russia and Ukraine.
@@videogamebot1211 oh come on bud that’s a bad faith argument. It’s fallen to basically single digits per day and only mainly to the evacuated towns next to border. The original rates were hundreds to thousands per day reaching Tel Aviv constantly. There’s been a lot of graphs and stats showing how much it stopped since early days of fighting
@@jascrandom9855 that’s different an not comparable and as the other commentator said was home pr. All polls show in Israel is that across spectrum support for war is super high. Afghanistan for example was continents away and lasted for 20 years without much change of the population attitude to democracy and was viewed as just a waste of resources and people for a cause that no longer mattered. if Afghanistan was launching countless rockets and attacks for years and bordered USA major cities I guarantee you the result would’ve been very different. As for international pr like ya it matters but is a bit overrated as seen for the most unpopular countries in world rn(Iran and North Korea) who still survive and get their objectives met a lot while Israel which is a lot less isolated and more advanced should be able to level any backlash if they needed to. Its a Palestinian pipe dream that an international force will come and invade Israel to help them esp since Israel is a nuclear power
They are absolutely, absolutely losing the PR war. It’s hard to get people to empathize with Hamas because Hamas clearly sucks, but Israel is managing to do just that
Having all islamist dictators sending their medias against them, not surprising. RU-vid too is full of islamist propaganda, including extremist ones promoting terrorism, pedophilia, nakba, farhud and nazis without repercussion.
This is a war. Wars are not pretty. I am not on board 100% with everything Israel is doing, but seriously what people expected to happened? How Germany and Japan looked in 1945??? Do the US should negociate with Hitler and General Toho just for the sake of peace?
we dont pour billions into woke universities like qatar and kuwait and brunei do. our support in america is from american jews and evangelists,and of course they are a uniformed block within america(and many american jews are aftually influenced by the same woke left). the left has made pact with islamism and sadly we dont manage our PR sources correctly to expose it . millions of people have died to to islamism and pan arabsim in the last 2 centuries,we are the most secular nation in the middle east,but sure. we dont know how to manage PR campaign and we are left with the likes of piers morgan. at least he has some brains left to say to mohammad hijab "ww2 wasnt a genocide against germans even if german civilians died".
Yeah yeah, so your on the side of Hammas terrorists. No nation on Earth would accept what Hammas did to the Israelis. I can give a recent example, America on 9/11.
I'm an Israeli and I disavow my racist, extremist and war mongering government and the policies of disregarding civilian casualties (both outside Israel and within) that rival American behaviour in Afghanistan and Pakistan.
With the US firmly supporting Isreal, I dont see Israel losing in any way. Even if the war continues on until the last of the Palestinians, sadly, the world will just let it happen. Yes, they know it is wrong, and many will pity the plight of the Palestinians, but no country can risk being isolated by the US and the West. So short answer: Israel is winning resoundingly over the Palestinians.
@@justryaneyeah you’re right, most of us don’t know about that because most countries don’t do it. Of course an Israel supporter such as yourself would be an expert in that field 😂😂
Wars can be won militarily. But if they aren't won fast, diplomacy will dominate and eventually decided the winner (or stalemate) E.g. WW1 &2, Korean, Vietnam, Afghan, US independence & Civil War, Napoleonic Wars.
The Foreign Assistance Act bars assistance to any country that “prohibits or otherwise restricts, directly or indirectly, the transport or delivery of United States humanitarian assistance.”
Very true.🎉 but no matter how Israel approached this war, people would still be criticizing Israel. Because the Deaths would still be in the thousands🤦♂️
@@harlowida against Hamas whos hiding in tunnels civilian clothing civilian population. No matter how Israel approached this war there would be thousands of Deaths.
The problem is that Hamas has a great propaganda team, The civilian death count is coming from Hamas which is one of the waring parties which is not a reliable source and of course is super biased. Its weird that everyone knows to not use Ukraine or Russia death count numbers but when it comes to this conflict its ok to use Hamas's, Most people don't know much about this conflict and its history and just follow which ever side they see the best propaganda from and currently Hamas has the best propaganda.
Of course it's biased, but what choice do they have? You'd expect them to name every one of those civilian, that are trapped under rubble, splattered by missiles, fired by tanks, snipers, heck they even besieged a hospital, rotting corpses? . Even journalists and aid workers are being targeted to the extend of killing their own hostages. I'm not saying Hamas is good, but when you are against an army thats that careless and ruthless, are you going to believe them?
@@adamdurrani1071if you didn’t care about civilian casualties you wouldn’t use missiles, you’d copy Russia and use artillery barrages. The cost of a targeted missile is much higher than a shells. It is not that the Israelis are careless, this is the reality of war. And this is why hamas are so disgustingly evil, they provoked war that they knew would do this to their people. And they did it in such a way to guarantee that this war goes on as long as possible
You seem very poorly informed. Israel AND the US confirmed these numbers were "more or less accurate" previously, and the numbers have only gone up since then, those numbers are definetly in the lowest end of the real number of dead. Israel has lied constantly during this conflict and been caught in lie after lie, each time their lies have been reported uncritically by western media, only for the media to lose interest once the lies have been exposed, just to move on to the next israeli fabrication. Its hillarious you somehow claim the israelis are neutral in this
The exact numbers don't matter, just see the footage of what has happened to gaza and thats proof enough that thousands of civilians have been killed. Also there are hundreds of testimonies from Palestinian victims of Israeli war crimes, describing the conditions they were kept. Having exact statistics is irrelevant in this level of catastrophic event
Israel's 'killed Hamas fighters' numbers always seems suspiciously similar to the Gazan health ministry's numbers of total adult men killed. Which is a number we know includes large numbers of doctors, aid workers, the disabled, senior citizens, bakers, etc.
Also, they couldn't have accounted for many that are trapped within rubbles so these deaths are just estimate, the total civilian casualties might as well closer to 40k
Of course its a war, its just one army is armed with scraps and thought it could stand toe to toe with a technologically superior opponent. Hamas being delusional does not make them non combatants
@@V-O-V/ I mean their land and homes are being occupied, when your country is victim of imperealism (dont worry it wont ever happen to you, your American), then youll get it
@@V-O-Vremember during that war , Israel tons of military assistance from USA and west Europe while hamas didnt get a single help or assistance, its something to consider.
The perseverance and resistance of the Palestinians is somthing out of legends. Not many people realise this but whats happening now and what happend in gaza will be mentioned a lot in history
This is our homeland and we are native to this land just as the Palestinaians are. Israelis and arabs in Israel are trying to discuss this issue in Israel, while foreigners such as you just bring more heat to the already existing fire... mind your own business.
They were warned about this from the very beginning. The conventional army loses if it does not win. The guerrilla wins if he does not lose. Israel was told that complete defeat of Hamas was impossible and they went on with it anyways. What made the situation 100 times worse was Israel disregard for civilian life if they were at least a little more careful they would be in a better position today.
It was never a war. It was never about retaliation or rescue. Oct 7 was just the pretext used to justify crimes against humanity that were always the goal. Read the statements of their own leaders since the beginning of their national project.
That won't change anything, the USSR recognized Palestine back in 1988, and that was a major global power - did that change anything on the ground? No.
@@FictionHubZA it's true that gaza has been under attack for a long time but those attacks are literally nothing compared to what's happening currently.
@@FictionHubZA*Gaza have attacked for most of their existence. And not really. Gaza has existed since 1948, which is a lot of time... Most of that time was peaceful.
@@guydht1 So, if people from the Middle East went to Europe and carved out their own state in, let say the UK. They might claim around 40% of the land area. Wouldn't it be justified not to want that? That is basically what you're trying to defend here.
Nah, it'll be fine in like two years. International community has the memory of a bird. And if they remember, then they can be ignored and go around every sanction imposed, just like before.
This isnt a war. The palestinian resistance is split on two fronts and only has the ability to resist israel in Gaza. The killings on the west bank (not judea and samaria) and attacks in jerusalem are still happening and are getting worse. Israel is a nuclear power supplied by some of the most high tech millitary equipment. Palestine doesnt have an army except Hamas, a millitia group severely limited by decades of blockade.
US was not militarily defeated in neither Nam or Stan. Both were political and strategic defeats. Israel has dealt with worse and they've never lost militarily or politically, so I doubt that'll change much this time around.
@@MartinLeong25If the US committed 100% of their military force towards Vietnam, Vietnam would have got fucked. Of course the popularity of sending troops was low, causing outcry and political failure.
@@MartinLeong25Literally yes. The NVA and VC were in shambles and hadn't managed to land a significant victory against the US in over 5 years. They didn't invade the south again, renigging on the armistice, until the vast majority of US forces had already left. Afghanistan was under total occupation for a decade and at no point did the Taliban come even close to securing power through military action. It's not coping, it's actually knowing historical context instead of parroting revisionist propaganda.
Rape is not a form of resistance. kidnapping is not a form of resistance massacring kibbuzim is not a form of resistance Who the fuck are you resisting against? Allah? Islam? any morality code ever?
@@davidblair9877 they are not, you overestimate the political impact, couplde months/years after this war, itll be back to business. Just look at Crimea, Hong Kong,..
Ngl I think superimposing presumably gazan ruins with "you feel like the world isn't terribly safe" (the beginning of an ad-read, right after TLDR talking about gazans returning to "what's left of the[ir homes]") is pretty tone-deaf and even repulsive… I support your work, and you should get sponsors, but this specific editing decision is very bad.
5 месяцев назад
Is it tone deaf? Since they copy-paste their ads I consider them as completely unrelated statements.
@ What is read out loud is always the same but right of the beginning of the ad reads they show different (topical) footage for different videos to make the transition more seamless or whatever… (in the last video on Javier Milei, it was footage of him campaigning, for example… this time it was gazan ruins 💀 which is just too tragic to voice the beginning of an ad read over)
Could you guys please make a video about the recent beef between Elon Musk and the Brazilian government/supreme court? The media in Brazil is very biased and I would like to know how the world is seeing this situation
@@crocodileguy4319 I'm not a fan of him, but I don't think he's totally wrong in this one. Supreme court judge Alexandre de Moraes has been abusing his power for a long time at this point imo, even before this beef with Musk happened (I'm not right wing or a Bolsonaro supporter btw)
Welcome to modern journalism, the sensational headline is just so you would get lured to see their ad and they can cash in. It's not about the truth anymore, it's about clicks.
@@MichaelDavis-mk4me What? can't just read and watch events directly from the sources and make up your own mind? Always need someone to tell you how you should feel? Everything in this video is selective secondhand info slapped together to paint a sensational narrative.
