🔥How I make my videos: aff.vidello.co... Asalamu Alikum if you are new to my channel, Welcome! In this channel, I post a Hadith every week and not just any Hadith I have to make sure the *Hadith is sahih meaning it is not weak*.
@@shahbazkhan7130 exactly. Guess that will make people think. Furthermore, if a dog is not pure/unclean/whatever, what about chickens? Chickens will eat ANYTHING. Even exctements....and they are o.k.
@@jgappy5643 Islam is kinda weird, how are cats considered clean animals while they litterally hunt and eat the most disgusting animals like rats(who carry diseases) and mouse etc.
I am a former dog trainer who does not keep dogs at home. After seeing this society and how much crime is out there. I am finding more knowledge so I can insha Allah keep a dog at my place to protect my home. I know first hand how easy robbers disarm security system but avoid any home with a security animal. House pets do not deter any real criminal but a security service animal is a working unit.
so where do you keep your security dog , how far from your house , outside in the elements or in a enclosed kennell. Alot of people may not have a large property. How does this dog protect you if it is outside your house.A robbery breaks into your house , he is safe inside your house your security dog can not hurt him. If I was a robber and looked inside a house and saw a dog I would move on.
@donaldmason7081 I'm planning an entire house build that will allow me to keep the Dog in a halal way that will also keep the dog happy. Just keeping a family pet outside is mean and I don't want to miss my few prayers because of presence of Dog. I am planning to build a nice chicken coop and have a German shepherd for pure guardian purposes.
Assalamu Alaykum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh brother. I have 4 dogs which are 1 pure breed German shepherd and 3 mixed German shepherd and Malinois (6 months old). We live in the deep rural areas in Italy where there are many wild boars and wolves. Hence I had to get the 3 pups because 1 German shepherd will not be able to guard the whole territory against wolves not even a group of wild boars. My 3 pups are female and since they have a mix of 2 most protective blood, they are super protective to the point they do not allow any living being enter their zone (they are nice to cats though). Is there any tips to fix this. I would not want this to be later dangerous for friends and family to come over. Barak Allãhu Feek
@submittereverythingforhim2306 socialize them immediately! If a dog seems too stubborn then make them sweat and work. You can take a scooter or cycle and make them work one morning! An exhausted dog feels like they have worked and can regulate their emotions. A dog that has pent up energy will be more aggressive. If available to you put in classes.
I believe the story at the end was about a prostitute feeding a dog water. I do find this topic very controversial. I do love dogs as I grew up next door to a German Shepard and pretty much looked after him outdoors. I guess perhaps back then dogs were mostly rabid dogs or used mainly for hunting /guarding. I don't think they would have domesticated dogs to the extent they are now. This is why I wonder if it is actually possible to keep dogs. Guide dogs for the blind is surely allowed? It's a tough one but for now I am happy with my 🐱
The Quran says nothing about not having a dog in a house or as a pet. It is the Hadith that makes an issue of it. Lets not forget that if the Quran does not say its forbidden then the Hadith has no value. Or are the sayings of the Prophet more important or valuable than the Quran? Furthermore, the dog has proven his value to humans over and over again. More than humans have among eachother.
Not the prophet SAW, but people who heard the Prophet say ……. And narrated the Hadith. I have 5 dogs and live on a farm. The 4 big ones stay outside, my small one in the house with me. If I’m wrong, then Allah please forgive me for loving your creation who loves me back UNCONDITIONALLY.
@@khalidsarang1574 l have two large German shepherds in my house. They sleep in my bedroom. May Allah forgive me too for loving his creation that brings me more joy and loves me so unconditionally like no human can
At the time in history rabies was a major concern. Prophet Muhammad judgement was kill all stray dog's. To lesson risk of infection and attack human or other animal. Rabies is not a concern like it was and it's only right not to have packs of stray dog's running round, especially Africa India, south America had problems with packs attaching humans trying to eat them. I don't understand why people complicate dean 😔
So basically if you're child has physical disabilities and mental disability. The dog is allowed to the humans as a service. Like hunting and gard dog. And service dog. It's just not allowed as a pet for fun. 😮
Today's society dog is once more required one's home. How you keep said dog your home is up to you. No point it being outside and vulnerable to attack. You inside 😄🙏😄 best place for your dog to be is at your side.
If the prophet said it, so be it. If I read "So-and-so said that the Prophet (pbuh) said..." it is hearsay. We cannot point with certainty and faith that, on the one hand, the Quran is is immutable, unchangeable, not translate-able, and then allow any and every Imam in the desert to come along and make his own commentary about what the prophet write or did not write, and worse WHAT HE MEANT. There is NOTHING in the Quran that requires us to deal with dogs in the ways that many of the commentators in the hadith order. The men who grant authority to the Hadith are those that wrote it, not the Prophet (Pbuh). It is the same in all three Abrahamic religions. The message is distorted by man through endless discussion by self-important teachers. There are verses about eating camels...and yet plenty of Muslims eat camels, most of them in a nation that spawned Wahabism.
There are people out there that just have a natural aversion to dogs and try to spin what the hadith says to make it seem like dogs are haram in all situations.
Dogs are dirty, their saliva and other liquids, they lick and rub things all the time, there is no amount of cleaning that can keep up with this especially since we're told to clean things 7 times if a dog licked it, so it should be outside and have a purpose and not just because it's cute...
I have a question. Am I allowed to have a guard dog that I keep in the closed veranda that is attached to the house? He wont enter the house but he can go there when it rains, at night and cold?
Why do you have to follow the hadith of scholars, imams & mullah over the words of the QURAN the words of ALLAH. MAY I ASK ANYBODY OR ANY MUSLIM WHOM ARE YOU GOING TO FOLLOW THE ORDERS OF YOUR GOD OR THE ORDERS OF MAN LOGIC
I agree. I'm a Muslim and l follow what is stated in the Qur'an. I refuse to follow rules written by old scholars of centuries ago. I have always had dogs and mine are indoors as part of the family. When my dog barks people outside the front door ask what dog l have as 'he sounds big'......hes not big he's 'huge'. Currently my boy is sprawled out on the sofa next to my son... l will treat my dogs the way my head and heart tells me to.
QURAN IS THE BOOK OF PREHISTORY AND OTHER'S TOO,TODAY IT IS THE HIGHLY SCIENTIFIC PERIOD OF ZOOLOGY AND VETERINARY AND FORESTOLOGY,IT IS 21ST CENTURY EVEN YESTERDAYS NEWSPAPER IS TOO EXPIRED OF 21ST CENTURY AND EVERYTHING IS NOT EDITED IN HOLY TEXTS AND MANY ARE FABRICATED TOO AND WHEN WE SAY "ANIMAL RIGHTS",THIS TERM ITSELF INCLUDE PETTING,PITTING,CARING,LOVING ETC A HINT OF THE LIGHT IS ALL THE STARS NOT JUST A LIT AND SUFI THOUGHT OF SCHOOL,DIRECT INTUITIONALISTS AND THEIR HISTORY IS FULL OF PETTING,PITTING,CARING ETC ETC ETC ETC IN ONE TERM ANIMAL RIGHTS
Alhamdulillah, I was born in a Muslim-majority country which is wayy less secular than the others, almost free from western & secular impurities ideas. So I found no problem following this order (which surprised me after reading the comments in other yt videos). May Allah make us easier to follow his orders (knowing life is a harder test than just getting a very high GPA in a prestigious university)
Brother, what’s your advice to someone (who’s a kid) who has a pet dog in his house but there’s nothing he or the family can do. Like, he can’t put the dog on the streets as it’s domesticated and would be killed. He can’t sell it as the price of dogs is impermissible, he can’t give it away to others as that would be contributing in their Haram. So what should he do? Keeping in mind he also likes his dog but doesn’t want to disobey Allah. Should he leave the situation as it is and just not get another dog in the future? The family was unaware of the rulings when getting the dog. Thank you.
Asallamu Alikum brother, you are right about your thinking. So there are many options to do but they really depend on where you live. So you can keep the dog outside in its own shelter in your yard if you have one and the weather outdoors is suitable for that dog. You can also give the dog to a non-Muslim or an animal shelter.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته اخي A very good video which has cleared all my doubts about keeping dogs as pets. In my previous visit to Turkey I saw many muslums kissing dogs like the European. I guess in Hanafi Madhab it's allowed.
i think the reasen why you will loose 2 qirats everyday for keeping a dog indoors is that its cruel and evil and damaging to the dog. a healthy dog is a working dog not a dog who has nothing to do but to walk around looking cute.
Not just a working, but mainly a dog who exercice. Most animals need to move constantly to be healty, unless you own a snake I guess. And dogs need a lot of excercice and space. I don't thnk it's wrong if they're in the house like if it rain or snow. But they shouldn't be trapped inside a house all the time.
@@HadithWeekly In a country like India dogs are very important cos Muslims are always attacked BY BJP and Police so at least they will run once they see dog
salam .. i have a question please!? mujhy Dog Chahiye Ghar ke hifazat k liye lekin agar me puppy lelu Or usy ghar me raklu Jab tak wo barha na hojaye or usy sahi sy train krlu saaf rklu cheezo ka khyal rku Or jab wo barha hojaye usy ghar k bahir rk lu then Kia ussy bhi farishte nai ayengy ghar me?
Why would an angel be afraid of dogs? Are dogs stronger then angels for them to be scared of dogs? Can a dog unalive angels? Just how weak are your angels?
The Ahadith that teach us that two sinners (the prostitute and evil man) were forgiven by Allah by giving water to a dog shows us that the Almighty has created these creatures for a reason. The Quran further emphasizes the conditions in which a dog can be kept. I think the creator of the video has explained things very well and he should be appreciated for making reference to all Quranic references. Comments like yours are disrespectful. Please do not make such comments. Rather, if you have an objection, please support it with evidence from the Quran and Sunnah.
I also have 6 dogs as pets that protects us during nigth time ever since i didnor consider dogs as haram coz there no surah that says dogs are haram period.i dont care what the useless hadith says
