#HUDATV Huda TV ... A Light in Every home ＳＵＢＳＣＲＩＢＥ To our channel : www.youtube.co... Join us on our official pages for Huda Tv on: / huda.tv , / hudatvchannel , www.google.com... , / hudasatellitetv , / hudatv , www.huda.tv .
@@InTheDarknessOfWorld you must be south asian . Just fyi not all muslims consider crabs are not permitted . In southeast asia, middle east and africa crabs are permitted for muslims
@@newbabies923 I am south Asian but I eat crabs (my favorite food. The issue is some Sunnis do not eat crab but the more correct opinion is that crabs are halal.
@@syedtalha351 my usthad told the crab which is living both in land and water is haram , and the one which is living only in water is halal , Allahu a'alam
To those who mock Hanafi school of thought, do you know the man Imam Abu Hanifa? Do you know his blessings? Do you know his interaction with the prophet (pbuh)? Imam Abu Hanifa's school of thought is the earliest and his interaction when compiling his understanding were with the Sahabas directly. You and me will never be of the standing of such a man and his wisdom, so don't speak ill and instead say you take the understanding from a different school of thought. We haven't been created to take the easiest choices but the correct choices, so don't think strict is bad or soon you'll fall in to the modern mindset of accepting modern culture ahead of Qur'an and sunnah. Btw I do not follow a particular school of thought and respect the 4 main school of thought, they are the most respected and accepted when compiling the largest collection of hadeeth and understanding of all aspects of a Muslims life and conduct.
@@gulz4u All the 4 imams said "if any of my fatwa goes against the sunnah, throw my fatwa on the wall" So in this case we need to check it up with the hadith. If it matches then the fatwa is valid
Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) died in 632 AD, while Imam Abu Hanifa (R) was born in 699 AD or 80 AH. So how did he meet the Prothet (Sm)? he directly interacted with the generation after the sahaba if im correct. Please don't spread misinformation. Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.
That is excellent clarification about Seafood. Unfortunately, my in Hanafi mathhab which I am belong to, some sheikhs saying that crabs, lobsters etc are Haram. I believe my dear Arab sheikhs are more trustworthy in these case, because they live close to seas, not our Hanafi sheikhs who live in areas where there are no seas, and make weak or none sense reasoning.
To hunt and to eat the food of the sea is made lawful for you, a provision for you and for seafarers; but to hunt on land is forbidden you so long as ye are on the pilgrimage. Be mindful of your duty to Allah, unto Whom ye will be gathered. (Al-Quran 5:96) So yeah, game of sea is permissible
@@PRINCE-ci8mc all it shows u is that people are ignorant because it clearly says in Quran "Lawful to you is game from the sea and its food as provision for you "
Its not difficult tho the shias says that if the fish doesn't have a scale its haram.. the sunni say which fish can live without water is haram. So just to be safe eat a fish that lives only in water and has scale!
@@hadi-bp2mz you explain why not ? Don't be stupid wahabi! Be real muslim when i said that i say about fish! For example crabs or octopus are not fish they are mullusk.. To be more specific, crabs are invertebrates while fish are vertebrates.. eating something thats not fish and don't have scale is like eating Cockroaches If you didn't understand then stfu and move on!
Umm in southeast asia (Indonesia,Malaysia,Brunei) we eat those . Except turtle and jellyfish, but we do eat all kind of seafood and it considered halal by our ulamas and also Syafii school
Adhikansh seafood hallal hai kuch cheso ko chodka. Crab bilkul hallal food. No doubt. Shark,whale,shrimp,prawn Sab halal hai.Jo harmful nehi hai o halal hai.
I agree with Sheikh Mohammed Al-Hillil.. there are clearly sea foods that are not halal, like shrimp, prawns and crab. These are like sea version of the pork and cochroaches. Its too bad that there is not a unified stance on this in Islam, and i wonder why. 🤔
Some RU-vid channel has a list of haram animals and crabs, sea horses and sharks are put in the haram list and it also said that clams are makrooh. I think it was getting some shia rulings or was stealing stuff from the jews
@@fballarmy35f halal means that good says that food is allowed to be consumed by us muslims haram means the opposite meaning that allah has forbidden that particular food like pig or any carnivorous animals besides carnivorous fish
All sea food are halal according to the 3 schools of fiqh ( maliki, shafi3i and hanbali) but the school of abu hanifa says that only fish is allowed to eat and any other sea animals are haram. But the majority of scholars say it's permissible to eat all sea animals including crabs, octopus, lobsters, shrimps... Etc
Yup or better makrooh. Any animal that eats another animal is not permissable to be consumed because in this case it would be halal to eat lions and all sorts of wild animals.
I prefer the rulings of the mujtahid imams who were among the true pious predecessors. They were closer to the time of the Prophet (pbuh) and ruled with true ijtihad and by observing Sahaba or those who had met Sahaba. Not from books. As for who do you follow? Just one. Not pick and choose as you please. This person goes on about obeying the Qur'an and sunnah. Yet they ignore the fact we were commanded not to follow our desires. If a madhab was already chosen for us through birth and we choose to change, the first question to ask is why. If the reason is based on what we desire then that in itself is wrong.
Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “… Allaah intends for you ease, and He does not want to make things difficult for you…” [al-Baqarah 2:185].
Even for Hanafis, it isn't haram. It's makruh at best. No matter how great the scholar, he can't make haram into halal and halal into haram. Stop spreading misinformation, this is a gray matter and the multiple differences of opinion are all correct.
Do you know the man Imam Abu Hanifa? Do you know his blessings? Do you know his interaction with the prophet (pbuh)? Imam Abu Hanifa's school of thought is the earliest and his interaction when compiling his understanding were with the Sahabas directly and he met the prophet (pbuh). You and me will never be of the standing of such a man and his wisdom, so don't speak ill and instead say you take the understanding from a different school of thought. We haven't been created to take the easiest choices but the correct choices, so don't think strict is bad or soon you'll fall in to the modern mindset of accepting modern culture ahead of Qur'an and sunnah
Shit I am asian and we eat everyday outputs now I am currently in Tokyo before I was lived in vitamin.. I am confused all the times can I eat or nor ... do diffclut to beginner musilm
@@PRINCE-ci8mc i joked..... Noting else.... Animals which eats other animals are Haram(as per my knowledge). So in that way sharks are also not permissible to eat.... The previous reply was just a sence of humor, nothing elas.....
Yes it is halal to eat shark 🦈, I would like to increase your little bit of knowledge from my knowledge 🙂 so take it positively. brother, every single fish eat other small fish and other creatures in sea ( not grass 🙂🙃 ) so if we apply your logic all fish will become haram , so I hope you will understand and your confusion will be gone 👍
@@Danishqazi009 the fish who have scales and fins are halal. Not all FYI. But wahabis eat that. The followers of Imam Abu Hanifa will eat only the fish with scales. Shark is not halal at all. Even the carbs, squid, octopus etc are haram
Maybe your talking about stone crabs coz stone crabs are scavengers of land But i never see a crab scavange but a stone crab did But not the crabs from the sea
But before you eat crab you have to boil it alive, Allah SWA forbade us from torturing the animal before eating it, such as slaughtering the sheep for example in a way he doesn't doesn't feel the pain. Wa Allaho aaalam
@Crystal Rodriguez I assume that wouldn't be zibiyah ( slaughter) the only other thing we know that we can have dead animals ( no slaughter). without this method is fish and locus .....I think the hanafi's have a strong and valid reason why they abstain from this kind of food .....and it's fine for other schools of thought and how they derive their opinion.
Crabs is haram is for this reason and another reason is because it is an animal that eats other animals so not permissable to consume. You are to consume animals that are herbivores aka that consume plant or grass or seeds.
You don't have to boil it alive. You can use a knife and impale it through it's brain. You can also just put live crabs in the freezer. They will just go to sleep.
I would cut the crab first in a way that ends its life quickly, then proceed to cook it inshaAllah. There are a lot of videos on youtube about how to properly cut and cook seafood.
edward kent there was no need for that m8 was it? Its absolutely fine to have your own ideology and religion but to disrespect is another thing! Enjoy your life and seek peace
@@PRINCE-ci8mc What disrespect ? I have no ideolgy and i disrespect no person, i think some people call it kharma ?......It's just a funny joke bro, like this ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-P8JEm4d6Wu4.html
If it cannot survive without water and also not poisonous, then its halal. And if poisonous and you know how to get rid the poison that its halal. If it can survive in and without water, then its haram. Like crab, there are two types of crab. The one that live both in land and water, haram. The other one, it cannot survive without water thus halal. And this is accoring to Imam Syafie
@@saadc10 you are wrong. Please don't speak without knowledge. In sahib muslim 1935a it is stated that prophet salallahu alayhiwasalam consumed whale meat. Allah's Messenger (may peace he upon him) sent us (on an expedition) and appointed Abu 'Ubaida our chief that we might intercept a caravan of the Quraish and provided us with a bag of dates. And he found for us nothing besides it. Abu Ubaida gave each of us one date (everyday). I (Abu Zubair, one of the narrators) said: What did you do with that? He said: We sucked that just as a baby sucks and then drank water over that, and it sufficed us for the day until night. We beat off leaves with the help of our staffs, then drenched them with water and ate them. We then went to the coast of the sea, and there rose before us on the coast of the sea something like a big mound. We came near that and we found that it was a beast, called al-'Anbar (spermaceti whale). Abu 'Ubaida said. It is dead. He then said: No (but it does not matter), we have been sent by the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) in the path of Allah and you are hard pressed (on account of the scarcity of food), so you eat that. We three hundred in number stayed there for a month, until we grew bulky. He (Jabir) said: I saw how we extracted pitcher after pitcher full of fat from the cavity of its eye, and sliced from it compact piece of meat equal to a bull or like a bull. Abu 'Ubaida called forth thirteen men from us and he made them sit in the cavity of its eye, and he took hold of one of the ribs of its chest and made it stand and then saddled the biggest of the camels we had with us and it passed under it (the arched rib), and we provided ourselves with pieces of boiled meat (especially for use in our journey). When we came back to Medina, we went to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and made a mention of that to him, whereupon he said: That was a provision which Allah had brought forth for you. Is there any piece of meat (left) with you, so tnat you give to us that? He (Jabir) said: We sent to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) tome of that (a piece of meat) and he ate it.
Listen in Islam it is haram to suffer the animal to die there's a way to make them die we have to make sure that the animal suffer less when it slaughtered
Leviticus 11:10 And all that have not fins and scales in the seas, and in the rivers, of all that move in the waters, and of any living thing which is in the waters, they shall be an abomination unto you: God does not lower his standards. Allah is not God Almighty. The Heavenly Father is God and God alone
This ruling was for the Israelites not the whole of Mankind ignorant foolish person SMH go look into the Noahide law/covenant identical to Islamic shariah(Law) see you in the hereafter rejector lost soul
