Damn! 2 hours 42 minutes gako chal nai payena. Nice one! Amidst all the biased digital opinions spreading like wildfires, it was liberating to hear 3 youths having a neutral discussion. Keep going!
These people only want freedom without responsibility. Guff garera hami jasto viewer bata paisa pairacha. This country is facing identity crisis and might not exist in the near future( or might be left in condition where it is impossible to grow). Face the harsh reality and work in doing something productive than giving sutta wala guff
Feels like dream come true to see these two people together, And specially congrats to you brother with these type of content. There are some parts where you can improve, like when you are questioning, it feels like you weren’t really able to ask the questions with what your intentions were, still I am really happy to see someone like you trying to cover up there’s topics. Congrats to you brother, and I am sure that you will gradually improve and I wish you the best❤️
Good to see youngsters are getting together to express most aspects of Nepal and Nepali as it is a federal democratic republic system but still lacks to vocal for those Nepalis who have never been allowed to voice and exercise freedom upon their faiths, traditions and culture even it is a Nepal and Nepalis civilisation!
Hats off to the Dipesh bro @thenepalicomment for your perception, ideas, understanding & so on that you demonstrate in this podcast. Highly appreciative & broadly explained. Keep up the good work👍
माफ गर्नुहोला तर तीन जना चिया पसल वा भट्टि बसेर गफ गर्दैछ्न कि राजाको पालामा बोल्न पाइदैन थियो।अरु केही छैन येस्मा Hijo ra aaja ko kura garda..i mean two system of govermance ko kura garda...National sovereignty,unity, economy,foreign policy,geo politics ,rule of law,accountibility,democratic values,religion and culture,border,defence,infrastructure, identity,military,taxation जस्ता कुराहरु मा निहित रहेर ब्याख्या गर्नु पर्नी हैन।
exactly. ma ni ehi sochdai thye. research bata data collection matrai gare jasto lagx, jun narmaro ta hain, tara bibhinna aspects haru ko critical analysis pugena jasto laagx. But these guys are doing good as of now.
indepth story he cannot think outside the box he is not in a reality how elites think function and runs societies countries and the world...he is very good for his audience...nepali comment he has a fantastic knowledge and very rational thinking he will be awesome in next 5years
Thank you so much for the podcast from where we got to see both of the inspiring personalities sharing their views,perceptions and recommendations together in a same platform. I am a regular viewer of both of their contents and i am glad to attain the knowledge delivered by them which are authentic and comprehensive.❤
I so agreed with Dipesh bro when he said Durga Prasai always says he’s got the proof right on his phone or he’s got the paper of evidence with him against the accused politicians about their dirty works but he’s been saying that for so long, where the hell are those evidences? Khoi ta chhan bin gareko tesmaathi?? 🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
Timi haru ra tapiharulai eauta maya k dinxu bhanda, sabai ko content worthy xa, aahile ko podcast creator, In depth team re Nepali comment team, i follow all, please keeo up the good work, voliko din ma youtube le yo dui channel purchase garnu parne vaye pani ma ready
In politics you seems totally biase on one sided if you're talking as a content creator than you should be rational..this is my suggestion to all 3 of you guys.. And best of luck for your future plan. Thanks for doing this kind of things🎉🎉🎉
Nepal le ta proper democracy ko taste nai pako chaina ahile hamilai raja haina democracy mai naya Change ra system chaiyeko ho. Aaba durga Prasai chai loan na tirna sakeko baula ho, raja aayo vane hune kai haina tei ho last ma pehri andolan huncha. Hamilai raja haina system chaiyeko ho. Prachanda ra deuba ani oli tapai ra maile garda nai ahile power ma ho lets vote for a change. #2084 hamile nai ahile bhako haru lai vote deko ho hamrai galti ho,dhoodh le dhuleko na pamla tara atleast thikthak ta paula ni. “A nation's leader is a reflection of nations citizens”.
There is difference between राजतन्त्र and राजसंस्था. Rajtantra is about king having absolute power like before 2047.After 2047 king became constutional which means king had power like that of president. Even when there was king, Nepal was a democratic country. King coming back won't make Nepal undemocratic. Nobody wants rajtantra, they want rajsanstha in place of president. Now president represents the party he is from so he is biased and political parties have nobody to fear and can change the constitution as they wish. So king could be a component to balance political power. Even developed countries like UK, Norway, Spain, Belgium, Denmark, portugal, Monaco, Netherland, Sweden etc have constitutional monarchy. So these 3 people are talking about absolute monarchy while the demand of public is constutional monarchy. Absolute monarchy is a big No but constitutional monarchy can be a good choice for Nepal..
I agree there is a stark difference between constitutional monarchy and absolute monarchy. All the developed nations that have constitutional monarchy, you pointed out, have a handful of things in common - strong/stable democratic institutions, law and order, and strong judicial system. You are right that post 2047, there was constitutional monarchy in Nepal and the country was democratic, but the country lacked stable/strong democratic institutions, judicial system, and law and order. At the nascent stages of the democracy, public institutions (judicial branch, schools, police and military, etc.) weren’t strengthened enough to make them free of political entanglements. Democracy is an experiment/idea and evolution is an integral part of it. The most powerful and democratic nation in the world, US, also didn’t have a perfect democracy but it evolved over time and is still evolving. Democracy in Nepal should also evolve. Learn from the past, throw out the cons and build on the pros. Strengthen public institutions and free them from political affiliations. Democracy gave a ray of hope to millions and it’s an experiment/idea. This nascent democracy needs to evolve just like how a thought/idea evolves with time. What country needs is a strong/stable institution that enforces and/or respects law and order. “Raja aau desh bachau” is not the solution. There needs to be transparency with everything - how and why are policies instituted, who are the stakeholders, and who are the beneficiaries of such policies. “Raja aau desh bachau” should be replaced with “no one is above the law”. Institute policies that demand ethics, transparency from everyone (politicians, business people, educators, employers, every citizen, etc.) Everyone should respect the law and order. Investigate everyone who benefitted from corruptions, freeze their assets, take them to court. Nepal needs an institution or a branch of government that presides over and has authority over executive branch: MPs, president, prime minister and even the judicial branch. Hypothetically, let’s say this movement falters. What’s a new “nara” then, “Raja hatau desh bachau” Directing energy and motivation towards strengthening existing anti-corruption/government watchdog institutions and instituting strict law and order where everyone is treated, judged, and/or punished (if found guilty) equally is the right path forward. Nepal needs strong public institutions with accountability not hindu, muslim, buddhist, nor christian rastra…help strengthen public institutions & law and order (justice system: Supreme Court & Police, and environmental regulations and policies). Monarchy is unsustainable and why should a single family or a person lucky to be born in that family inherit the entire nation and pass the inheritance to their kids. - isn’t this the exact definition of nepotism. Yet in Nepal, everyone cries “kehi kaam hudaina or paudaina” because nepotism or having right connections ruined the society. There is an article in The Guardian titled, “Nepal’s king seeks escape amid probe into wealth” - if they were the true guardians of the nation (which itself is a ridiculous idea) then why invest in profiteering businesses. Why didn’t they invest in public infrastructures - government schools, roads, pavements, river corridor or reform schools and privatization of education in Nepal. Balen is Shah but not the “raja” family Shah. He has shown/proven that a person with right vision and principle can be as or if not more influential than raja. All we need is people with good ethics and principles in politics and a strict watchdog institution. Implement strict law and order. Everyone (janta hoos ya mantri) must get equal treatment and protection under the law and everyone should have a level playing field based on qualifications, knowledge, skills, and abilities. perpetrators must be held accountable and punished as per the law and constitution. Weak law and order and people not abiding by ethical code are the weakest cogs in the democratic wheel of Nepal. Mr. Prasai has good points and some bad points. His ideas of reform and reshuffling of public institutions are points to be noted. Where he loses support is his extremist views of “raja tantra and hindu rastra” as the saviours of the country in peril. If he has so much dirt on all the perpetrators who benefited from corruption why doesn’t he release all evidences - open the floodgates - with Nepali version of panama papers. Why is he using monarchy - an archaic, divisive institution - to promote his ideas/agendas and using hinduism to rile up people to join his base. Religion - also a social construct/idea - creates division and using nara “hindu” rastra is extremism, doesn’t promote inclusiveness. Nepal has rich cultural heritage and religion, and they are not in danger of becoming extinct. Religion shouldn’t be used to unite or rile up the base. Environment and natural resources are at risk. Proper management of environmental and natural resources is where everyone should be fixated. Why not use “environmentalism: preservation, conservation, and proper management” as a “nara” to bring all Nepalese together and push forward his agenda. I personally detest monarchy for the history of atrocities. British monarchy profited from Atlantic Slave Trade. Economic policy enacted by Rana dynasty profited from “Kamaiyah”. Subsequent generations of “people in bonded labour system” are still reeling from the generational traumas. Monarchy be it absolute or constitutional may make sense in a feudal Nepal (maybe), but not in today’s environment and political biosphere. Who’s to say that another hatya kanda - “singhadurbar hatya kanda” won’t happen in the future as the history has shown even the constitutional monarch and his families were wiped out in the democratic country. If the country had strong judicial branch, law and order and enforcer of law and order (allegiance to welfare of the county and to none) back then, may be darbar kanda could have been prevented. I don’t know who the perpetrator is but if the country didn’t have a strong judicial branch back then, would instituting “constitutional monarchy” cure this in a heartbeat and who’s to say post “singhadurbar hatya kanda” (it’s hypothetical) Nepal won’t fall into authoritarianism and those on the streets with new nara “Raja hatau desh bachau” won’t suffer the same fate as the 4 great martyrs of the past.
@@swarajthapa5798 history has shown time and again, and even fantasy novel like the game of thrones - power corrupts. Same thing happened to the so called netas. Power corrupted them. Why not implement strict law and order as in China ? If found guilty of corruption and heinous crime - capital punishment. May be that will instill fear. These netas treated Nepali Janta like 🐑 and sold a dream of “Nepal lai arko Singapore banauchu” instead of properly managing natural resources and environment which Nepal has abundance of and didn’t focus on job creation and growth opportunities. Prime examples are “yarsagumba harvest” and “gravel and sand mining from rivers” it’s like Wild-West out there, maan pari cha. If these resources are properly managed and regulated may be they will provide sustainable industries. Today, Kathmandu is becoming a most unliveable city and the other metropolitan cities are also heading towards the same direction because of air and water pollution. Not too long ago, some cities in US were also dumping their waste into rivers and lakes. A river in Ohio caught on fire in 1969. The US enacted several federal policies to protect rivers and fresh water systems one such act is Clean Water Act. All is needed is a political will and public outcry. Strong democratic institutions is all we need. An institution that offers checks and balances to the executive branch and is willing to hold them accountable. It has to be a top down approach. Bottom up approach doesn’t work in the context of Nepal because of power, nepotism, and politics. Lastly, Nepal doesn’t need a demigod = raja nor a demagogue = Mr. Prasai.
They know the difference between absolute Monarchy and Constuitional monarchy but they won't talk fair about it because they are directed not to talk about it... Did they had gut to talk about Nepal Army Size minimisation proposed by SWARNIM,SUMANA,BIMALA??.
Eloquent and precise. Constitutional monarchy always had a sense of ownership towards Nepal. Now, it's totally different. No body truly takes ownership of our country and musical chair of deuba, prachanda and oli is just their to feed their families and coparceners.
In the name of change, a nation faces many challenges from different political and economic factions which could threaten its stability and unity. To prevent this, the country needs a strong and central authority that can maintain order and harmony. Sometimes, democracy is not enough to ensure the common good and the national interest. What Nepal needs is more discipline and loyalty. Jai Nepal !!!
It's up to educated youth like these guys to inform the false narrative that's being spread now by Rajawadis, which says that monarchy will solve everything and that monarchy is the only alternative to corrupt politics, thus creating a false dichotomy, and in the process fooling the people just like the current bunch of corrupt politicians. We can use the current system to give a better alternative by joining politics and thus transform the country. We, the common people regardless of our background can do it and democracy enables us to do it, and not some hereditary institution. No kings, no masters, power to the people!
Monarchy often highlight stability, continuity, and a unifying symbol as perks. Monarchies may also have ceremonial roles, preserving cultural heritage, while avoiding the partisan nature of elected leaders in a republic. However, opinions on governance structures vary, and each system has its strengths and weaknesses. Stability and Continuity: Monarchies can offer long-term stability, as the leadership typically passes through hereditary lines. This can prevent frequent changes in leadership and policies, providing a sense of continuity. Symbolic Unification: Monarchs can serve as unifying symbols for a nation, embodying its history, traditions, and values. This can foster a sense of national identity and pride among citizens. Ceremonial Role: Monarchs often perform ceremonial duties, representing the state at important events. This can help preserve cultural heritage and traditions without being directly involved in the day-to-day politics. Non-partisan Leadership: Monarchs are not elected and, therefore, may be seen as above the political fray. This can potentially reduce the influence of partisan politics and allow for more impartial decision-making. Focus on Long-term Goals: Monarchs, with their lifetime commitment to the role, may have the luxury of thinking beyond short-term political cycles. This could lead to a focus on long-term national interests without the pressure of re-election concerns.
@@ujjwalkhadka3824 The problem is you need a monarch that actually places values in these aspects and one the people can trust. The Shah family simply cannot provide this, and this really shows. While they were given power in different systems for so long, they failed to deliver on developing and improving the country. Maybe there were one or two kings that had made some good decisions, but overall look at the end result. We are still a poor country that struggles.
The alternative for bad should be good not worse. Just imagine, how backward our mentality is-we are resorting ourselves to even have a conversation to restore a system that does no good for anyone except for its family and their servants. The veteran reporter publicly said with proofs that Gyanendra is clearly the key player who executed the massacre of his own brother’s entire family. And forget him for a second because he is old and will die anytime soon then who will be his replacement??? His drug addict son??? Criminal replacing another criminal replacing another criminal…. This is Nepal.
@@shankarbasnet2382 I would rather have someone like Honorable Kulman Ghising who unlike any of these corrupt politicians does the work efficiently. But you guys are no good either. Matter of fact you guys are even worse. You called other names while you yourself run after a drug addict and a thug who have scammed millions from Banks.
Of course change should be progressive, but that should not undermine the history and national identity. Perhaps, some people lack common sense, but same people play judge and delivering a verdict, come on. You don't have to imagine, go to Tribhuvan Airport (for the change-agents this name might pick) and you can see how ruined the country is. This is the "CHANGE" for you. The agent of terror and corrupt bureaucrats has turned Nepal into "a guinea pig". This is the "CHANGE" for you. And there are idealists (like you) who believe the current system will do wonders, over time. Perhaps, those are dreams or people who needs help. Of course, this is not Nepal, its New-Nepal period.
1:07:00 It is really true, Internet ko exposure Ani foreign influence nikai nai badheko xa, people are believing in external things rather than internal. People even cannot write Nepali words properly Ani Aafno desh vitra ko kura ko priority is decreasing with the time.
creator who produces informational content by simplifying complex topics in a visually engaging way through his RU-vid Channel, namely, The Nepali Comment. He has covered informational content on Nepali Politics, History, Finances and Rise and Fall of Business in an unbiased manner. Sudip Bhai Subedi is a Nepali RU-vid informational content creator, a podcaster and the founder of the channels, In-Depth Story and IDS Podcast. He is passionate about uncovering the hidden narratives and addressing the topics that often go unexplored.
येही सिस्टाम, येही पार्टीहरु, येही नेताहरु भैरहने हो भने नेपालीको भबिस्य पनि प्यालिस्तनीहरुको जस्तै हुन्छ I देशबिनाको नागरिक I अब को १०-१५ वर्षमा नेपालको सबै ठुलो पदमा भारतीयहरु हुन्छ। नेपाली त अहिलेको ठुला नेताकै छोराछोरि त बिदेशी नागरिकता लिसके भनेपछि को चै बाकी रहला र I
Guests are really nice❤️ and props to the work of host too.if host could cross question more using simple ancent i think it would be more nice of podcast to listen..good luck brother.
Yes we are struggling with the current system of nepal but it doesnt mean we have to again go back to Monarchy instantly… Yes there are some loopholes in our system, yes we are being ruled by wrong people but it may not be the fault of democracy!! It may be us who are continuously choosing same wrong people time and again and expecting good things from them .Democracy we are practicing today is not a complete form of democracy . It is not transparent enough .Its just partial. There are some things to get upgraded .There are some systems like direct president electoral system , laws like right to reject and right to recall .These laws are still left to get practiced to make democracy more transparent and public oriented. So lets focus on advanced form of democracy . Lets focus on choosing new leaders whose main motto will be something to bring positive change in this system. Lets move forward to filter out the flaws that we’ve been facing in this system. Going back is not only the option. How many years are we again trying to be like a pendulum?( moving back and forth but reaching nowhere!!) .We can see lots of demagogue at this time . But lets act wise. 🙏🇳🇵 After all this , if we dont get the expected outcome, then we can think about Monarchy . But now , i dont think its the right time to rush into it. Doing something in hurry cant be healthy. Yes we have got an option of Monarchy but lets keep it at last. First lets try to reform this current system through new laws and modification in constitution. At last ,one thing is real .And that is-"We are in need of change!".
Oe new generation ko chapri,hajur yini jhole bata manipualte hunu hudaixa,Raja le 2046 ma democracy ta diya thiye ni but maobadi lai desh khatam garnu thiyo tesaile raja hataya ho
They know the difference between absolute Monarchy and Constuitional monarchy but they won't talk fair about it because they are directed not to talk about it... Did they had gut to talk about Nepal Army Size minimisation proposed by SWARNIM,SUMANA,BIMALA?? एकात्मक राजतन्त्र हुदा नेपाल पन्चायत कालमा नेपाल विकास भएकै हो, संवैधानीक राजसंस्था चै देश कम्तीमा भोली विखन्डन नहोस् भनेर मात्र हो र विकास जनताकै छोरा कार्यकारी भएर गर्ने हो।। अनि democracy र राजसंस्था दुइ धुर्व हुन् र? डेमोक्रेसी को नाम मा जनताको मत लाइ विदेशी को स्वार्थ का प्रयोग गरे पछि मात्र राजाले हस्तछेप गरे को इतिहास हो॥ भ्रम नछर!!!
King is an old concept. All constitutional monarchies will slowly die off too. There's no better system than a liberal democracy with proper check and balance of power. Max two terms for the PM or president.
2:39:22 देश बन्नुपर्छ तर मैले हैन अरु कसैले बनाईदिनु पर्छ। हामी आफैले पनि जिम्मेदारी लिन् सिक्नुपर्छ। People get the government they deserve. In democracy, it is the duty of every citizen to maintain the freedom of the society. For this, citizen votes to ensure a responsible government to execute the will of the people. But due to problem of commons and human rationality, citizens ignore their duty and hope that 'others' will do the needful. When nobody does the 'needful', society loses its freedom and democracy is strangled. Reverse scenario from dictatorship to democracy can also explained in a similar manner. Thus, people get the government they deserve. Always.
I just loved the podcast. The question were also humourous as well as intellectual. Carry on bro❤ But I think the interviewer lacks some knowledge as compare to both the speaker. You were just asking the question. You was unknown how deep the questions were. So I think you need more practice ❤ carry on❤
