I watched nayyab yesterday and loveed it. Loved the looks of Yumna zaidi in this as close to reality . Also all performances were amazing.there were some unnecessary scence but still it grabbed attention
U did right thing..don’t listen to their review…it’s an amazing movie. A classic in my opinion! Direction is superb. Yumna did great. M fawad khan was actually the hero of the movie. Usama was great too. Each and everyone acted great.👌
I already watched it.despite their review Nayab already collected nearly 3crore money.despite Nayab is women based story.so many film realised in last 4month in Pakistan none can do business for 70lak.so it's really slapped from yumna zaidi fan and from the audience to all the critics like them.one more thing Hasan thousand movie based sports in India and hollywood.so if you says it's drama story ,it's totally wrong
I already watched in London vue.yumna ki fan prove kor Diya abroad mein we can celebrate yumna success.because we were waiting for her screen play so long after tere bin
With all due respect the highest lifetime collection of the recent time pak movies are 0.75cr .Nayab has surpassed all the recent movies which are released in pak (still it's not released in overseas & stil it's running in the theatres) Yumna shouldered the entire movie, you need not promote her (as everyone will have their personal preference) but let not discourage her from picking up more female centric scripts
Anything will run in the theaters honestly 😂 because there is nothing to show in cinemas, that's why Maula Jatt is still running even after 1.4 years of the movie
This entire comment section is "Yumna is the best actress BUT" ,"Yumna is the versatile actress BUT" .This 'BUT' is our perception of how actresses have to be present in certain way, which has been ingrained into our minds over the years. Don't worry eventually even Yumna will be FORCED to leave these critical acclaimed scripts & resort to start doing commercial movies even then she will have some ppl coming after her saying "Such a normal commercial heroine role, never expected Yumna to take up such kind of role tsk tsk"😂 Girl Yumna you do you 😊❤️.Lots of love❤️
People already criticized yumna a lot for taking up the commercial role in tere bin.all other actresses can do commercial movies but yumna is not allowed to do a commercial drama.they only want to see her in serious roles.fans of other actresses were also mad because they didn't expect yumna to do so well in a commercial drama like tere bin.some people have a vendetta against her because of the popularity of tere bin.and then our critics at SH are comparing nayab to commercial movies like SOTY and the fast and the furious.they aren't even reviewing a performance-oriented movie like nayab properly and asking yumna to look "glamorous" while playing cricket.sad state of affairs overall.people are never happy whatever she does
honestly i really feel bad for yumna. I Don't know why i feel bad for her. After Movie premiere her friends did not showing up. that's was actually very bad incident. continually social media trolling.Now this review will definitely destroyed her confidence.people should kind wher they putting their opinion. I know she is strong but Strong people also break sometimes. They just pick up their broken pieces and learn to move on.
Yes ,you are right why these people don't give review about other movies like gunjal, vakhari they are just targeting nayab and it's just two weeks of its releasing and these people are giving that type of review atleast give sometime it's so sad
People saying that Yumna should have looked glamorous, I mean, seriously? This is the movie that is bound to be appreciated by critics and I am shocked to see critics condemning the film for the lack of glamour. Unbelievable! The Pakistani film industry is lacking not just because of the films but also because of critics like you.
@@leeme474 its not hate but its a bias.. which people have towards some. and personally I don't like violence movies and that is why I don't like Maula jut which i have not seen it and just heard its too much violence
@@hinanaqvi9075 feel free to show your bias, but without bringing any other movie down, calling a movie stupid isn’t a constructive term, but quite vague, if you don’t like it then it’s not your cup of tea, but by no means “stupid”. would you be okay with me calling DIL Na umeed to nahi aur nayab stupid, just because i don’t like the themes it depicts or the tone of the drama specially when i haven’t even watched them….
As far styling of yumna is concerned,did you guys expect Nayab to play gaali ka cricket with make up on or something,with well made hairstyles ? Really? Nayab is a de-glamourized role & no one other than yumna would have had the guts to take such scripts for their debut
Totally agreed, people saying that Yumna should have looked glamorous, I mean, seriously? This is the movie that is bound to be appreciated by critics and I am shocked to see critics condemning the film for the lack of glamour. Unbelievable! The Pakistani film industry is lacking not just because of the films but also because of critics like you.
Agree with u she her self said that she was styled like that n the clothes that she was wearing that was supposed to look like old not very new and plus it was gaali cricket not glamorous girl playing cricket in the ground
@@ammatravels6577 Yumna might not have looked glamorous but she was definitely looking pretty. Moreover, this film is about a girl playing cricket on the streets. Do you honestly think a girl in India or Pakistan would try and look glamorous while playing on the streets? The film depicts the character realistically which should be praised by critics but these critics are condemning it for the same!! How???
@@Truxygg Let’s keep the styling aside, there is still a certain something thats done different in film, a stylist would be able to guide best in this regard. Point being, they felt that element was missing, and it’s not like they didn’t praise her for her acting. And definitely made a point to not point fingers at her while judging the poor storyline and screenplay.
Aamna suggesting Yumna to have played a bimbo like Alia in her debut film is so lame. Yumna is not here to copy anyone/anything especially when it’s as terrible as Alia’s debut in Student of the year!! Lots of love for Yumna from 🇮🇳
Also, Alia played a bimbo in her debut role because she didn’t know any better at the time. It’s humiliating to expect that kind of a role from an established actor like Yumna!
I think you should not say that Why they had done lots of promotions or create lots of hype of their movie ? I know that movie doesn't click you but it doesn't mean that from the fear of failure you didn't enjoy your present time. She is just enjoying her promotions and did her best in movie. This was her debut film. I think you should welcome new people in industry if you want that industry make progress. And i remember when you see "Inkarr" you said that this actress has no screen presence but she proved you and played a phenomenal characters. So just relax and hope that she brings the best for silver screen. It's just her first step towards big screen. So courage her instead of saying that she will not do a movie because it just give you a drama vibes. After she gave you 2 or 3 movies of same type then you will say this.
Their defense for this review would be that it's a global practice. This doesn't seem to apply to promotions for them though. Promotions are intense in both bollywood n hollywood.
In all industries including Lollywood, the scale of promotions is based on BO potential. Nayab producers spent at least 1.5-2 crore at promotions. But it looks like the BO will not even recover the production budget. If a film is niche or intended to make 67 lakhs in week 1, no producer will spent 1.5-2 crore on its promotions. Producers invest this much because they expect a return. Producers can decide what they they want to do but people will comment if it is out of industry norms and standards. If Chikkar was promoted like this and made 70 lakhs at BO, everyone would ask the same question.
I m happy that Nayyab is a positive movie and Yumna did her best... She z a brilliant and beautiful actress.. Even if it dont work well on box office it will be remembered as a good project..
Even srk and salman go to colleges and drama sets to promote their movies.Dunno why you are questioning the promotions of nayab.our films need all the marketing and visibility they can get
@@annie-ql9ks I have seen salman and sonam promoting extensively for prdp.visiting colleges and festivals.even srk visiting colleges.they also come for promotions on the highly rated dramas for an episode
You guys just had to drop this with two days before the international release right? Coincidence? I think not....Still hoping Nayab will work better, because Yumna deserves it
@@08ayushmaanthe film is not even released yet man , the pak cinemas industry is almost dead & most of the movie rely on the international release a lot these days
If you have Alia Bhatt debuting with a SOTY, then you also have a Kareena who debuted with a Refugee or a Vidya Balan debuting with a Parineeta. Kangana Ranaut (vile she maybe now but she was once respected as an actress) started her career doing edgy, performance-oriented roles like Gangster and Woh Lamhe. Yumna has already established a reputation of doing strong author backed characters. It would be strange for her to play a glamorous bimbo as her first film role. It's a different matter that Nayab doesn't seem to be well made, but I don't think the concept of the movie itself was the problem. If it had been more sports-related and have those highs in the script, it might have generated good WOM and performed better at the box office.
I also couldn't understand why aamna brings style into everything and bringing Alia's debut film soty into this conversation is totally absurd. I really think it's a bad debut for a talent like alia Bhatt. I mean your debut performance need not to be glamour at all.like you said it shown be like vidya kangana or kareena. Aamna needs to get out of her style reviews and do the movie review from a broad perspective.
#miashah1654 I very much agree with everything you said and kudos for putting together all the points so well with some great examples. I also believe making a debut by playing a bimbo in it is such a let down, Alia was able to survive because she always had backing from Karan Johar. Personally, I don’t think Alia bhatt’s acting is anywhere close to Deepika, Kareena, Kangana etc. P.S. Kanagana Ranaut is still a very much respected actor keeping aside the controversies.
@@Truxygg What's Deepika Padukone up to in her recent movies besides dancing in bikinis? As for Kangana Ranaut, her films have been consistently underperforming, due to her overconfidence.
@@iman.k8316 Yes, lately Deepika is going through a dull phase in her career and she is just not getting the roles that justify her talent. But she has already proved her acting prowess multiple times and therefore she will always be a great actor for me. The same goes for Kangana, she is pure talent and beauty but because of her anti-nepotism stance, the biggies of Bollywood have been indirectly pulling her down. Box office success is not proportional to an artists skills and talent!
They are talking about her style but if she would do a glamours role people will start bashing her that she is like other actresses most of the people call her paindu but when she is styled good they call her like others
Yumna might not have looked glamorous but she was definitely looking pretty. Moreover, this film is about a girl playing cricket on the streets. Do you honestly think a girl in India or Pakistan would try and look glamorous while playing on the streets? The film depicts the character realistically which should be praised by critics but these critics are condemning it for the same!! How??? Lots of love for Yumna though ❤️🇮🇳
Have u seen Mary Kom? watch & see how glamorous is the sports character without makeup & glittery clothes. Glamour doesn't mean layer of makeup & funky clothes
@@madmudd100 Ok, she could have looked prettier or more glamorous but instead she looked closer to reality. Shouldn’t this be appreciated by the “critics”?
@@Truxygg one doesn’t have to be nude or hiding under makeup to look glamorous. To make the character glamorous is directors job not the actor. Yumna has done good job but treatment of film is poor. Try to put actor & director in two different boxes. I’m writing again, glamour is not nude, short clothes glitter, red lips or long eye lashes with thick liner. The character has to be glamourised by the camera angle, background music & certain other things that can’t be taught to audience on RU-vid. I hope u understand the glamor is not fashion freak look.
Damn I really hope Yumna doens't take these negativity & hatred to her heart. I feel bad for her, girl came to premier even after she mother being hospitalized to fulfill her responsibility.Then there is this drama going on with the premier itself. Hope she takes some time off , waiting for her dramas 👍
@@isratsarker7930 I'm talking about the other drama where many ptv media pages are posting about Nayab premiere fiasco & ppl are bashing Yumna as if it's her mistake 🤷🤦
Its Yumnas first time, and i think she will eventually work this out. This wasnt a big production, with a seasoned director or with an established male lead, where she was going to be the wallflower, and i respect that choice. I appreciate she takes the path less travelled. And with most of our lead actresses, their first movies did not fare too well (Saba Qamar-Manto, Mahira Khan-Bol) i think if we even do a ratio of all Pakidtani movies produced to those that recoveted the cost of productions, the numbers would be sad. Films in Pakistan are a very risky business, We talk about Maula Jatt a lot, but nobody seems to remember that this film was 10 years in the making, so despite the numbers it did, it's not exactly a successful model to build films on.
correction: Bol was a very big hit. The state of Pakistani box office is very sad and even breaking even is next to impossible. But for a movie to not even recover its promotions budget is another level of fail. Producers don't market a movie like Nayab the way they did if it was expected to make only 67 lakh in week 1. So it would be fair to say Nayab underperformed even relative to the low BO expectations. This doesn't mean Nayab is not a great film. It is one. But box office is about $$$. High quality movies flop all the time. P.S. Waar was Bilal Lashari's first film and TLOMJ his second. Whether a director is seasoned or not has not much to do with whether film is good bad, hit or flop. Imtiaz Ali initial movies are way better quality than his latter endeavors for instance.
No thing I have seen in recent times is Pakistani & ptv industry & audience are really being unreasonably critical about Yumna, like what's the reason? She has one of the sweetest & humble personality ,when people can give a lot of relaxations to other actresses in the industry why not extend the same courtesy for Yumna too? Just asking 🤷
I don’t personally feel they have a secret vengeance against her out of all the actresses that we have, they even straight out said it wasn’t her brilliant acting, but the screenplay and story which did her bad.
That is true. People pick on her unnecessarily and she’s one of the very few people who doesn’t have a single controversial aspect to her. People who do criticize her, criticize her based on their assumptions. She’s here to work, and she’s honest with that. I don’t think she’s trying to make a statement or trying to win any competition with others. Her passion shows through the efforts that she puts forth. Maybe because she didn’t work in India or she doesn’t have any deep rooted connections that people find it easy to target her.
@@leeme474 it's not vengeance or something, I don't know how to word it properly but I have come across a lot of ptv audience saying they 'miss the underrated Yumna' ,like why? Why would you not want a versatile actress like her to get her due credit, I have been told Yumna has completed 11years in entertainment industry, she definitely didn't reach here overnight
Wow. Harsh criticism. I loved this movie. If you make it just about cricket it will become boring. Agree that it could have been slightly shorter and agree with the opening scene being less relevant, however this movie was about a girl’s dream in a city that is fraught with danger and other challenges. The characters were multilayered, from the girl to her brother to her father. I left the cinema with tears and smiles and it was unfortunate timing to be right behind 22 Qadam and have unavoidable similarities. This was the first Pakistani film I watched in America and I was delighted that it came here.
Promotion se iska taluk nahi hai.. ye galat kaha hai ki promote sochke kare.. let her promote the film ya. its her first film she will do promotions of course! Also, you should have reviewed this film a bit later so that film can grab some attention and make money 💰 Do not compare Yumna with Alia please!
Amazing movie!! I’m surprised how come Amna didn’t like it!! Even if u didn’t like u shouldn’t have given the review at this time! All Pakistanis should go and watch this movie!! A classic!!Very Well directed, Zabardast acting!! 👌👏🏻😊
Yumnazaidi already proved herself as a top star full of talent so please ye un ki frist film hai don’t compare with Aliya kun k ap apni industry ko bollywood se compare na Kare yumnazaidi drama industry ki queen hai ❤❤
In the US, so going to go see it this weekend to support Yumna. I am curious if my opinion will be the same as yours as well. All the best with the merchandise store.
I just finished watching your entire review/discussion of the Nayab movie. Honestly, I felt you were a bit too critical. While I've only seen a handful of your Pakistani movie reviews, this one came across as a bit harsh. No offense meant, just sharing my observation. 😐
I can relate to only one of all the problems that you described in the film, and that is that the director tried to incorporate everything in one film & hence it became lengthy. im an avid drama viewer since many years but due to lack of interest in films overall, i haven’t really watched any movie in the cinema. so i have never experienced that “larger than life” experience that hassan talks about. Nayab was one notch above an average drama viewing experience and it was fine for me. i wished to see usama more. the songs were the best part. Acc to me it had the right balance of commercial and artsy film thus i enjoyed it 👍
Hi Aamna Hassan, you guys should watch 12th Fail. Not all movies need to be fancy and larger than life. The story and the way its told should-be gripping. Not all films are big budget like RARKPK and Animal. Vidhu vinod chopra has made a low budget film 12th Fail and it is so critically acclaimed. A must watch. Btw I love your reviews and this year has started with some amazing drams. Khaie, Akhara (didn’t like the next blow), Ishq Murshid, Jaan e Jahan, stand up girl (the family dynamic is just❤) Please finish breaking news, its awesome and the pace is fantastic. I cried so hard for Hassan in mid episodes. No spoilers, hope you understand when you see further.
It's their job; they invest their money and time to watch the film. If it's not good, it's not. Additionally, in Hollywood/Bollywood, the reviews from critics come before the film's release, yet they still waited for a few days.
Lol another week. Amna made a negative tweet about the movie even before it was released. I hope they never get invited to the premiers of any upcoming movies
With due respect Hasan and Aamna i cant believe you guys consume foreign content!!! Do you think hollywood movies are judged based on larger than life stories, scenes and especially hero and heroine's glamourous looks?? Havent you watched oscar winning Room, my left foot and so much more... they didnt have a larger than life execution but but rather a super realistic one... I agree with Aamna that the story and performances were great but the execution was the problem, but not throughout the whole movie... I disagree with Hasan that it is a sports movie it was never promoted as a sports movie the cast has always said that it is Nayab's story and the ppl connected to her, so looking at it that way i quite liked it, and didnt feel it wasnt made for cinema. It surely didnt have the larger than life treatment but certainly did feel like a film and not a drama at all... and again Aamna wt is with being glamorous in films, the type of actor Yumna is, had she chosen a glamorous role for her film debut i wouldve been extremely disappointed... for her to be in that awful attire sweaty and all bare face for her roles should be commended by critics like you (if not the audience) not bash her for her guts to show her dhula hoa moo, dont you guys urselves demand the content to be diverse and different overall in out film and drama industry??? As a Marvel fan and having watched all their movies in the theatre, NAYAB was my first Pak film i watched in cinema, and i have to say it is not flawless but i loved the concept the acting the whole story and also the losses as it was extremely relatable in so many ways and levels, and Relatability is Nayab's strongest point apart from solid top notch performances which maked relate with almost every character and feel for all of them ❤ One more thing, i really dont know wht's with Hasan saying not to go watch it (really shocking to hear) or the promotions were too much even before the movie released... Pyaare Hasan promoting a movie is their right and i believe everyone should be idealizing Nayab's promotions, if Nayab can do it then why cant the rest of the film makers... all over the world ppl promote their films even Marvel movies that do comparatively better in terms of profits their stars promote excessively, according to Hasan's logic "that promotions utni hi karni thien jis tarha ki film bani hai" then Mulan, batman(george clooney), justice league, 47 Ronin and others shouldnt have promoted their movies as they were flops of big stars?! The bottom line is ppl need to understand not every film can and should be glamorous, PNJG or a ghissi pitti love story... i as a content consumer want diverse roles on my screen either tv or cinema.. BTW would you guys do a sitting with Yumna and ask her opinion about the film personally, it would be exciting to know how an actor feels after their movie screens and the feedback starts coming in... Respects and regards
I agree, if I were in Yumna’s place, i wouldn’t sit with them. This review was really brutal, Hassan telling people “not to go and watch it”.. I think they went too far here. Something haute used Nayab and Yumna’s popularity. They did a haute bites on Nayab premier, they invited Yumna and Usama, that video got good views. Then Aamna did her Fashion Fortnightly videos on Yumna and Usama’s looks on Nayab’s promotions. And yet, after milking the whole thing, they are being hyper-critical and going as far as suggesting not to go and watch the movie. They have gone too far here.
@@HBZ17and hasan is the same guy who has been praising the misogynistic trash animal like it is some oscar-worthy movie.the irony!I think he enjoys sex and violence on screen.female-oriented, performance-driven movies are not for these guys!They didn't even review gunjal which was based on the excellent topic of child labour and minority rights helmed by ahmed ali akbar.these critics only want sex and glamour on screens, unfortunately
You want yumna to do a flower pot role like Alia.Please!Alia is a nepo baby who just survived because of kjo.Yumna is here only because of her hard work and determination.She has no backing or connections in this industry.There is no comparison whatsoever!Please dont bring bollywood here.They are running due to item songs and glam and we dont want that here in Pakistan.Instead of appreciating yumna for taking up a female-oriented, non-glam role that showcases her acting skills, you are discouraging her.Just terrible!Yumna is not alia.She can be compared to someone like vidya balan or tabu in bollywood, who have always taken up performance-oriented roles and made their mark.Atleast appreciate her for picking a female-oriented movie in the risky pakistani industry as critics.You guys should just stick to bollywood if you are only looking for glam dolls, models and item songs.Female-oriented, performance driven films are not for you
Stop criticizing yumnas style all the time.maybe sometimes her style is off but most of the times she looks great.even in terebin or other dramas also her style was on point.amna ko to always yumna ka style problem hai.i mean tired of hearing ths frm u
Guyysss!!! One more thing, u said that u expected it to be a sports film and thus electrifying environment and all that , Who told u guys that it is one ? Hassan u may have forgotten that u interviewed Yumna and she said that it is not just cricket rather it is maily about family values and relations. Did u guys see the posters of the film by any chance ? If u have then u would know there r three posters and in no poster Yumna is shown to be batting or playing cricket. In The family poster the cricket kit is there near Yumna's leg and on her solo poster she has that kit on her back...portraying a fearless and brave girl and in the other one there is no kit. Cricket is A PART and it's the girl's dream which could be anything like becoming a doctor or painter or anything. Choosing cricket is definitely a brave move by the writers as well as Yumna.
22 Qadam k time aap log khe rahe the k ye drama nahi movie huti to acha huta ab us typ ki movie ayi hai to AP khe rahe hai drama jaisa lag raha hai ?????? 😂😂
These is your opinion. I have watched other reviews and they broke it down into detail by areas. It is not as bad. All I have to say is will wait and see what the WW views are.
I think Pak cinema right now only depends on masala movies for its revival but it does not mean Nayab is a bad movie (yeah it might be a drag at some point but concept and performances r good acc to most of reviews). Non glamorous roles also create huge impact n I think Yumna as an actor prefers story first.
It’s a bad movie because of its plot and its execution. People pay to see these films. You need suspense and heart in these films for their success, something Pakistani films seem to lack.
Bht buri baat hai k abhi film ko cinema Mai release huye 2 weeks ni huye and ap aisa review Dy rhy hn...it's unfair for all persons whose putted their effects in starting to ending. All film makers should take standard to reviewing on their films. Jo Alia ko Acha actor kahta hy unnki choice to good and bad actress hum logu ky smny hy😮.
There r 1000s of Alia Bhatts in India (talent wise) who r not recognised yet bcz they don't have a KJo. Alia is definitely the best actress with some stellar performances like in Gangubai, RRPK ,etc but she would not have been what ahe is today without being a nepo kid. Not everyone has that luck...but in her case it was definitely deserved. Is their any Godfather to Yumna ? Let alone Godfather nobody even had the time to attend the premiere.
That's the problem.yumna doesn't have a Godfather or any connections in this industry.that is why it took her so long to be recognised.and now the industry barely supported her at her film's premiere after she give such a massive hit.she is the underdog in this industry.she barely has any friends or supporters.she is all alone.hope that she can still manage to shine ❤️
@@AmyP-zn9dz Before worrying about the demise of Bollywood. Try and have a proper movie industry first. So called lollywood is not an industry per se. It's just a group of people doing whatever they feel like haphazardly. Meanwhile enjoy the magnanimous box office collection of Nayab.. The parking collection of RRPK is many times more than the collection of Nayab.😂
I just saw the movie, and waited to see this review till I saw the movie, and I’m glad I did cause I feel it would’ve ruined it for me. I feel this review video could’ve waited a few more days as it just released internationally. I didn’t go in expecting much but wanted to give my support to Pakistan and did enjoy it. I would recommend the movie overall for those that can see it with ease. It’s not as bad as this review is saying but it is okay to see on as well. Spoilers ahead- The movie isn’t bad but it does have issues of not being as grandeur, having a weak start and some disconnect in scenes. I agree with the end regarding Akbar, he was my favorite and one I could connect to, his story was sudden change and too close to the end to take that turn. I didn’t get either why Akbar couldn’t get back to cricket after the incident and the uncle being found, it shouldn’t have stopped him from going back. Styling was fine cause not every character cares abt their hair and clothes and have a certain taste and budget. I think she was glammed enough for her character. She looked completely fine to me. Yumna was perfect. Acting was great and it’s def not a 22 Qadam in my opinion except two women wanting to play cricket. If you’re going to talk about stories I was about to say Animol didn’t have one- it was crazy entertainment. Aamna seems to give fair criticism but I don’t what happens to Hassan. Whenever anyone is sharing a positive take on a movie he didn’t like he won’t let them finish and be like “but how/why?!” He did the same with the Dunki review- and the other day on Jaane Jahan-he doesn’t let the other speak without getting so caught up on them for disagreeing with him. He has the right to disagree and not like something but allow someone else to like it without interrogating them for that choice. Aamna critiques calmly- and points out correctly the reasons. Only agreeing with Hassan on Rocky Rani ki Prem Kahani even in the cinema I couldn’t handle some parts. Again, I would recommend the movie overall for those that can see it with ease.
Alia’s so called glamorous debut SOTY was pathetic n I hated it. Her actual debut was highway non glamorous real movie which brought her in the limelight. Even Karan Johar has admitted it. We shud stop enabling glamorous roles for actors and push real issues in movies n tv everywhere even here in India 🇮🇳
Inko to bas nangi heroins hi achi lagri hai yumna jesi talent in se or ess industry se hazam ni horahi all of them are getting insecure of her ethna harsh review apne show ko chlane k chakkr mai de rahe hai. We love her nd will support her she's strong nd very talented.
Nangi heroin yumna Ki dressing bhi koi decent Nahi Hai and they are right Film star or tv star Mai farq hota Hai and no doubt she's phenomenal actress usmy koi Shaq Nahi Hai but Nayab movie was boring based on cricket but cricket ke ilawa Baki sab kuch Tha cricket ke scenes kam thy society family issues woh toh hum dramo Mai bhi dekh lety Hain in movie itna drag Nahi Karna chahiye
22 Qadam proved to be kryptonite for Nayab. The unique story of a girl facing the hardships of society to pursue the sport she loves is already explored thoroughly. Hard luck for Yumna 💔.
22 qadam was shot before Nayab, and as far as I can remember (I could be wrong), but the shooting for Nayab began just after 22 qadam came on air, the promos for 22 qadam were already out, so it’s not like the team of Nayab didn’t know about 22 qadam’s storyline. Also Wahaj and Yumna are good friends, I’m sure Nayab as a project was discussed and so there is no way the Nayab team didn’t know about 22 qadam’s storyline. Maybe they felt that they would be able to portray something different as one medium is television through a series of episodes and another is portraying a similar story in a film format
Very funny 22qudam not much impressive, plus nothing Girl struggling, but half story practice n Coach and gal flirty only, other episodes as usual family drama inbt love tension n accident 😂, last two episodes like the Winning Match 😅😅 super bored Show 😂😂😂😂. Are u compared with Nayab, I know 22 qudam shoot bf, but after Nayab shoot done only show started 😅, narrative stared on Lockdown time no one konw about 22Qudam😂😊
It’s been three days, and the world premiere hasn’t even begun. The billions of views that TB got was from all over the world. I think we should wait a couple of weeks before there’s any final judgement on it.
It will not the movie isn't an exception we all already know the story nothing surprising at all . Movie should carry a unique aspect of a new concept which appeals audiences to watch it .
I feel with time Yumna's fans are being extremely toxic, they don't allow anyone to talk about her or say anything critical about her projects... These two Amna and hussan are the only people, who called out yumna's colleagues hypocrisy of not attending her film's premier, despite of the fact that she attended all her friend's premiers... Atleast let people talk guys, I have gotten brutally character assassinated and abused on Instagram for talking about the irresponsibility of people like Yumna to take up toxicity glorifying scripts like tere bin,and also how flawed it was,when ever I said anything about her as an observation which was not trolling,(i agree she's a great actress) but not some greek god, I sensed some humility lacking in her and I got brutal comments...
This review should have been done after international viewing. You literally just took away so much business from them. The movie could have been crappy but the team still worked hard on it.
Yes all in bad taste. I normally like Hassan and Aamna talk but here I am very disappointed with them and now saying this at this time just before worldwide release is killing the sales. Instead of promoting our movies for good content and realistic performances and appearances you are bashing it for lack of glamour. Common please talk responsibly.
@@NausheenHasan-e4jye shi hai jab wo yumna ki tareef karte hai tu sab ko acha lagta hai aur jab constructive criticism tu bura lagta hai wow halanke unho ne ab bhi performances ko bura nhi kaha boring aur poor story telling ko kaha ahi
And then people of Pakistan say that their movie industry is not growing.. but if you stop the economy like this how will you expect cash flow. And without cash flow how do you expect movie industry to florish. It's like cutting the branch you're sitting on.
@@kanikasharma4558 It's weird that I as an Indian love something haute reviews and Amna Apa & Hasan Bhai but at times I feel they are too critical..constructive criticism is absolutely fine but sometimes being critical can ruin the impact for other movie goers and therefore their own faternity. I mean we in India vouch for realistic movies and not movies like Animal or SOTY and that's one of the reason why we love watching Pakistani dramas because they are not extravagantly unrealistic but in Pakistan I feel it's otherwise.
Amna I fully agree with you about styling!!! The heroine should be looking good and stylish. Does not mean Rich!! I strongly feel Yumna Zaidi needs a good stylist! Yumna has no style of her own, even in Tere Bin she wore most below average, Paindo type clothes! Whereas Wahaj stole the show in Tere Bin. Especially cinema needs glamour! Cause it’s a big screen demand. But pls stop comparing Bollywood movies as their industry is far ahead and developed while our film industry is just taking baby steps!!
I wonder how Slumdog Millionaire won Oscars. It wasnt glamorous or anything special yet had a story. Nayab may not be Glam. It wasn't meant to be. The main idea was the story. 🎉
Good conversation on Pakistani cinema as a whole .. As a neutral viewer I feel the industry don’t invest on stories and celebrities that are currently popular - why not cast yumhaj in a larger than life love story for the movies - something like the yashraj … I’m sure that will gain many viewers… also there are enough examples of what the audience don’t like in story telling - abuse toxicity etc .. I’m sure all these learning processes will make the industry better …
I respect your opinion, but honestly, you can not tell people what they should or shouldn't do. If you didn't like the film, it is fine, but don't tell audiences to avoid the film. That is not your place to do so. Who knows, someone else might like it if they give it a chance.
Exactly , could have waited for the movie to launch internationally prior to giving such a critical review. This is only going to sabotage the movie at the international Box Office
I agree they shouldn’t have given their review at this time. Rather than promoting our cinema they are dissuading people by their comments. Very disappointing Hasan and Amna
Inspirational movie me glamar deke kya karengii app log🐸....aise socho ki bajacee pak kii cinemas kii aisa halat🤭...agar glamar de kar film judge karna hain to duniya baar ke acche acche inspirational and non- glamorous movie flop hota.....
I agree with Aamna what she said the other day that we can enjoy drama that seems like a movie but can't enjoy a movie that looks like a drama. Unfortunately Nayaab's timing was just after 22 qadam ended.
Well talking about glamorous movies Amna you mentioned Alia bhatt I don’t think it was a great debut and honestly I didn’t even watch her first few movies up until now Gangu bai ,if you talk about Gangu baii then look at that movie it’s not glamorous but she aced it and there are many other shabana azmi , Vidhiya balan no glamour at all are hit on box office,so movie doesn’t have to be glamorous it’s the storyline and the execution for sure!!! But for yumna I think she always plays safe so for her this was a great character and she is a great and smart actress so definitely in future she will hopefully figure out how to pick the right movie for herself.
I think the issue with Pakistani films is that you don't have "film stars" most apart from a handful work across both mediums. You can't compare Yumna to Aliya as she made her name on the big screen. Based on this conversation I totally get why Fawad Khan doesn't do Pakistani TV that is free to air.
Asalam o alikum hassan and amna hope you guys will be doing great. My comment might be a little lengthy, but I really want you guys to answer it. It will be highly appreciated . When I pick a movie to watch i go see the imdb rating and if it's above 7, I go for the movie and watch it . Nayab rating on imdb is 8.3( right now might decrease), and maula jatt has 8.7 . So what's the criteria of seeing movie ratings because most of the time imdb rating is opposite what the people are saying. I live in US was eagerly waiting for nayab release because I am a huge yumna fan and I am continuously checking imdb. But I am in a doubt because you guys are right movie should be paisa wasool and hero heroin romance . So how authentic is imdb rating. My question might be dumb but if you guys answer it will be highly appreciative. Thank you so much.
I don't understand why the Pakistani film industry continues to produce films. Of all the films they've made or that I've seen, only "Maula Jatt" and perhaps "Teefa in Trouble" were watchable. The stories of other films were quite lackluster. Or why not take the stories which are made for cinema and make it into a drama? It brings in new topics, addressing the complaint that dramas lack fresh stories.
My sister and niece watched it in Philadelphia's theater. My sister being a die hard KARACHIITE ,was lyrical about how the directer of the movie has made the city its main character. I am so happy that so much hard work has paid off
I would rather watch nayab than 22 qadam because that drama didn’t wrap up in 13 episodes 😅it had more than that and in India also people have made these kind of movies , about cricket and challenge that a person face But I agree on styling , they should have given more nice look to her on wedding scene at least 😊
And yumna fans are always crying that industry didn’t supported her can u plz reel me how many celebs were spotted at Ahmed Akbar premier ? Almost every actor posted in insta
A ticket is 800 in Pakistan ??? 3 people can watch a movie in that price in india. Single screen tickets are about 250 for a big film and multiplex is 300. For a smaller film it’s much lesser
The value of money is different in India and Pakistan. Every one inr is equal to 30 pnr. So if a ticket costs 1000rs in Pakistan it means it costs 300rs in India.
What about Animal movie? When is that discussion coming? And also please discuss on rocky aur rani... I loved that movie. Enjoyed it a lot. Why didn't you guys enjoyed?
I went to see may London Nahi jawounga in theatre in Chicago, i took an Indian friend along, what a disappointment…. It was drama in a movie, same actors just wearing bright clothes and dancing. What impressed me was 128wa, maybe because i liked the concept from a women’s point of view. Pakistani film industry needs to produce artist outside the tv… like before, just my thoughts
why are we pushing for soulless commercial fare like avengers and fast and furious to be made rather than actually meaningful and emotionally resonant stories? we should be criticizing nayaab's screenplay that felt like a first draft, instead of the fact that it wasn't a corporate blockbuster taking zero risks. you guys literally care more about how attractive the protagonist looks rather than her arc or development or depth. a review/discussion of a film and barely any criticism of the technical aspects of filmmaking.
@@imanahsan63 exactly!! i wish they went this hard on those god-awful falaana nahi jaunga movies or JPNA or a lot of the horrible stuff that gets made.
@@maheen8869 in their opinions, those movies should be okay since they are “larger than life”, whatever hell that means. So many understated movies made in Hollywood that have even won awards, and these people here are stuck in marvel mode.
Oh my gosh!! Can’t agree more with all of you guys, you are spot on! These critics like trashy things and condemn good efforts and then they have the audacity to complain that good content is not being made 😒😒😒
I want to ask all these ppl on the comment section did u watch it urself.. I dont think yumna only has 10/12 k fans.. Its already a week.. They can review now..
Waalikumassalam. Just to inform you . Waiter scene from Ishq Murshid also inspired to Pyar ke Sadqey. Yumna did same act in episode 1 of Pyar Ke sadqey.
YUMNA ZAIDI IS NOT FOR FILMS.….SHE shouldnt have had done film in the first place. She can play heroine’s sister/friend or hero’s sister but not the.…… unfortunately that is a harsh truth. Remember Rohi Bano ? Brilliant actress but not for movies. YUMNA IS A TALENTED, BEAUTIFUL, SKILLED ACTOR AND SHOULD CONCENTRATE ON HER WORK AND NOT GET DISAPPOINTED WITH THE FAILURE OF NAYAB.
Its not a very good comparison to put fast and furious against a pakistani movie. The audience of fast and furious are mostly people who can afford it and also have that tendency to run after trends and do things because everyone else is. I know people who watch the avengers to be able to put up a story. Pakistani films have to somehow grab that audience and make their film a “trend” to be able to do more business. Because people who maybe want to watch nayab for either yumna or even the content might not be able to because of money constraints or even ghar ka mahol not letting young girls go to the cinema. T
I think there’s a lot missing from our film industry. We need a deeper dive into the psyche of our film makers. They don’t know how to edit a movie, don’t how to get proper sound quality, and don’t know how to frame or project the story. Not every story is for the big screen. Not every film has to be released whenever. Producers and directors need to think about the release schedule, promotional material, the stars, the media hype and the overall story and its impact.
We need better movies and these small budget movies aren't doing anything for Pakistani cinema instead it's causing more damage. I agree with all your points, we need larger than life cinema like TLOMJ, QEAZ and PNJ. It's time these directors come back because we only have them and they can only sustain this industry.
My two cents on the matter would be that our film industry needs to take their craft seriously. I can bet if Animal gets released today in Pakistan, the theatres will be flooded. Simple as that, good films will catch viewership.
Animal is just pure misogynistic, violent trash.wouldnt call it a "good" film.sex and violence sells, just like it did with animal.but popularity doesn't equate to quality
When yumna is easily accessible on my iPhone or tv y would I go n watch her on big screen?? Period. I live in Toronto. Lots of theatres are playing this movie, which is great but unfortunately I have no motivation to go n watch her on big screen.
Hassan I want to disagree wid u dt only large landscape and glamorous role give true cinematic experience. I should recommend you to watch 12th fail recent bolly fim ..it has done a great business (sleeper hit) with no such elements, on the other side other high budget films are struggling. As an Indian I also found 12th fail more interesting. So it depends on industry state too. Pak cinema is itself in struggling phase, hence it is difficult for it to support such movies.
We watched it in the US, only me n my husband were there in the movie hall. We went for yumna. The movie had a good story but very very poorly executed. Story telling could have been so so better
Guys, what do u want? This is a film review and they have complete right to say what they thought about the film. just bcoz Yumna is a great great actress or many people liked it does not mean they have to like it too. And review are harsh all over the world. Just bcoz your industry is small and is trying to thrive does not mean we have to treat it like babies and se haye mela bacha boht acha kaam kia hay aur try karo. The critics have to be professional.
Totally agree & understand all your conversation.. I think Pak mei films ki ticket prize kam honi chahiye, Jitni bhi bari Film ya cast ho banda apna Budget daikhna hota hai so please kindly Ticket prize kam honi chahiye🙏
