Is Pakistan on the Verge of Collapse? - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi | Abbas Haidar | ViewPoint #50 

Ma-Shaa-ALLAH ! ! ! Well needed Q & A Session with Ustad Javaid Ahmad GHAMIDI حفظہ اللہ . Keep on doing Dawat-e-HAQ of ISLAM without Firqawariyat. May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !

How lucky r u to talk with the man of the century in our Islamic world… You snatched words from my heart while expressing gratitude to the Ustaaz

Mr. Abbas Haider I admire the reasonable and rational tone of your videos. People may or may not agree with your guests but how you enable your guests to open up and elaborate on their viewpoint is admirable.

اُردو تو خود ہی ایک بہترین اور خوبصورت زبان ہے اُس کے اوپر سے آپ کا تجزیہ بھی مزا آگیا ۔

Your last sentences were really heart touching. Ghamidi sb has indeed educated an entire generation of Pakistanis. We owe him a lot.

Hello I am Lenin Bansal from India... Javed Ahmad Ghamidi ji ko main lambe time se sun raha hun...Javed Sahab sabhi Muslim Scholars ☪️ me se sabse logical baaten rakhte hain... I am fan of him... Javed sahab Islam ki baato ka jo tarjuma pesh karte hain wo agar Islam ☪️ me lagu ho jaye then I think muslim community ki 95% problems khatam ho jaye... because every human system needs reform... And Abbas Bhai aap lakho me ek wo journalist hain jo samne wale ko apni baat rakhne ka sahi main ek platform provide karwa rahe hain... because you have a lot of patience and manners... You are doing a Great Job... Well Done 👏 ✔️ 👍🏻 👌🏻

جب تک ملاں کو مسجد تک اور أرمی کو بیرکوں تک محدود نہیں کیا جائے گا اس وقت تک کسی بہتری کا تصور بھی ناممکن ہے۔ مذہب کا ریاستی معاملات میں کوئی بھی عمل دخل نہیں ہونا چاہئے ۔

شاید میری زندگی کا یوٹیوب پر کسی ویڈیو پہ پہلا کومنٹ ہے۔ آپ کو زیادہ نہیں سنا۔ غامدی صاحب کا انٹرویو تھا اس لیے سنا لیکن آپ نے جس طریقے سے غامدی صاحب کا شکریہ ادا کیا اور جس محبت کا اظہار کیا مجھے اس انداز کی وجہ سے آپ سے محبت ہوئی۔ اللہ پاک آپ کو کامیاب کرے۔ اور دعا ہیکہ خدا مجھے بھی غامدی صاحب سے ایک ملاقات کا شرف بخش دے۔ آمین

If a country treat its citizens inequality that country won't last long

Pakistan was created because jinna knew Hindus were more progressive and educated where Muslims were not. They knew in democracy Hindus would end up with power, business and influence because of their progressive mindset. He was correct. We see pak clearly today.

Sorry to say Sir Ghamandi sahab talk about islamic state, but people should know why he left pakistan. The answer will tell every thing..

Very good interview Please do more interviews with Ghamdi sb. Thank you Abass Haider

One of the most intellectual personality of our era. Thank you for having him

India should build a temple for Jinnah in every city....thank god he created pak and amputated india of this gangrene.

Lies feed desperation, and desperation feeds despair. Ideological desperation to build a separate identity, birthed a lie called Pakistan, glued only, and kept together by more Lies.

غدامی صاحب کا تعلق لاھوری گروپ سے وابستہ ھے لہٰذا ان سے ھوشیار رھیں

Ghamdi sahib is my ideal.If I ever want myself to become someone it would be ghamdi sahib.He changed my life ,he thought us our deen in very real way.I loved him as my ustad.Thank you ghamdi sahib for everything.

Thank you Mr Abbas Haider. This interview answers most queries. No person can match Ghamidi sahib in the contemporary time. Also your concluding words were really marvelous.

If nothing you, Haider Abbas, are educating your qom to use civilized language, listening attitude, tolerance in ideas and always pleasant when talking or interviewing your guests. Not only I am watching I am forwarding to everyone…even to those who don’t agree with me.

غامدی صاحب کا سوْ فیصد درست تجزیہ، اللہ تعالیٰ اس ملک پر رحم کرے اور ملک کے حقیقی حکمرانوں یعنی قابض قوتوں کو عقل و فہم اور ہداہت نصیب فرمائے آمین۔

Our Pakistan must be declared as secular Nation. Being Muslim, we feel ashamed. It hard to defend nonsenses logic of Islam before Non-Muslims.

Subhanallah- Mr Ghamdhi is the greatest Mujadid and reformer of modern times . May God bless him and bless us all . Thanks

The best interview of on this channel! Ghamidi shb is a true gem. We need more people like him in our country.

Ghamidi sir was no holds barred and laid smackdowns on everyone. Loved it. We need some more harsh home truths by this man. Maybe we can listen, learn and understand!!

This was an eye opener discussion. 🇮🇳 India can also learn from this. Hope our Govt and people listen this.

Wow...Hard to believe Pakistan still has such enlightened religious scholars like him. Thanks Abbas...

0:48 Is there an issue with Pakistan? 2:30 Nation state vs religious state 5:11 Nation state or religious state by Quaid-e-Azam's view? 7:28 Religion in a nation state? 9:04 Why history is important? 11:00 Why separate religion from the state? (Religious state vs Islamic state) 14:33 Why should we believe an individual's view against the majority's view? 16:40 Is there a fault in your reasoning that not even 10% Muslims follow it? 18:36 Why Quran doesn't have definitive verses on Governance and state? 19:52 Why Ulma (clerics) have difference views if Quran has clearly explained everything? 21:26 Why establishment is different in India and Pakistan despite having same roots? 24:33 Blaming establishment for everything, isn't it a biased approach? 26:44 Is establishment "Power Hungry" or "Genuinely Care" for the state? 28:33 Were politicians better than establishment for running a state after 1971? 30:08 What about Benazir Bhutto as a politician? 32:57 Why politicians put up with establishment despite being powerless? 35:45 What is currently happening in Pakistan? 36:52 Did Imran Khan visited you before creating PTI? 39:20 Why can't we present our views or do discussions or contradict in an ethical way? 41:31 Why there's no democracy among us? and why we have so much religious intolerance? 46:18 Role of judiciary in the history of Pakistan 48:28 Why judiciary plays along with establishment? 50:09 Role of "Media" in Pakistan 53:17 Are the solutions easy to implement to solve our problems? 55:14 How'd we implement it since we can't get along on any point? 56:18 What should a commoner do to solve Pakistan's problems? 57:02 Do we still have the time to resolve the problems? 58:18 Who'd you vote for? Who should we all vote for? 1:00:03 Concluding remarks

MashaAllah best ever landmark interview n guidelines given by ustaz javid ahmed ghamde to look into gross flaws in our policies we adopted to make our relationship tense with neighbours after which our establishment has made our future insecure with malicious designs There is now check n balance. There is dirty competition who loots the country more In the circumstances last hope is still with lmran khan who if permitted to survive will enable the country to survive inshaallah

One of the best scholar of Islam ☪️ . May Allah bless him. Welldone Abbass bhai .,

Best analysis I have ever listened on Pakistan. Ghamidi sir thank you so much. Stay blessed.

Very well discussion but could you please do a favor for Hindi speaking listener? I know you single handedly does all this but just do 1 favor. Note down atleast 10 tough Urdu words and write down it's meaning in English in description box. It will beneficial for both - Urdu language and Listener.

Abbas is such well spoken, polite and professional interviewer. Such a pleasure!

As per him since Hindus are in majority in India, it should be a Hindu riyasat.

Such a great and benevolent discussion may Allah give ghamdi long life,we need him so much.

Practically there is no difference between islamic Nation and majhabi nation both create their law on the basis of sharia .

You left me in tears at the end. Much needed session with ustad e mohtaram. Keep up the good work. ❤️

Pakistan 🇵🇰 got 35 % of BritishIndianArmy (consisted of particularly West Pakistani muslims) but only 17 % of resources and with very little or poor political leadership, so it was bound to become a Garrison or Security state.

Javed ghamidi just love it Allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti all time great for me I don't think any another better prayer than this prayer Allah qabool farmaye aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤️ ♥️

Very good and informative discussion with intellectual people 👍

جزاک اللہ خیرا ❤

The End of the Interview brought me to tears...May Allah forgive us all...and protect us from the coming catastrophe and calamity

ماشاءاللہ کمال کی گفتگو کی گئی ہے

One of the best podcast I ever watched. Ghamdi Sahab is always a river of knowledge. I appreciate you also Abbas bahi for asking these questions. Lots of love ❤️ last part was really emotional

Mashallah. Excellent session. What a great scholar and humble personality Ghamidi sahib is! Allah Ghamidi Sb ko salamat rakhay. Pakistan paindahbaad.

You bring gem after gem. Thanks to you for such an intellectually stimulating interview.

واہ غامدی صاحب کیا حقیقت بیان کی کھلے عام ماشاء اللّٰہ❤❤❤

Fir to Hindustan mai bhi majority Hindus have righta to respect its relegion and live as per Hindu tradition. Why hue and cry on Hidutwa?

Great Ostad e Muharam Javed Ghamdi Sahab ❤️❤️ Abbas Haider you make us emotional at the end. Love you

Sir, ye sahab kyaa bol rahe hai ki Bharat wajood me 1947 aaya ?. pls correct him.

Mr Abbas….I am not well versed with Urdu, tried to get essences of you discussion. I watched your podcast with Muzzamil as well. Your last words were very heart wrenching. Out of curiosity, I was watching videos about Pakistan. Many a times it was euphoria about being nuclear bomb powered nation and blaming india about many things. But after listening to many scholars on your platform, you have people who knows where the rot it. Military and Mullah. They focused on bleeding india by thousand cuts. Wasted precious resources of both the countries. Especially pak forgot about nation building and now landed in this mess. May God show path of progress to your nation and save common man. Relatively you are having less complexities as compared to India. And if we can do it why not you. All the best

पाकिस्तान का मतलब क्या.........पाकिस्तान का मसला क्या........... पाकिस्तान के इस अर्थ में ही इसका मसला है। A religious nation state is a contradiction in itself.

Sheikh Mujib should be the prime minister of the whole of our country.

The guest speaks so fluently in Urdu. Intelligent discussion.

Isse zyada kch ni hai ke akhri 3 mint me Abbas Bhai Apne hum jaise logo ke Dil ki tarjumani ki hai...Allah Ghamidi sb ko hmary upar qaim rkhy Aameen

Good to see discussion... I don't know why the comments r negetive

I really appreciate the interviewer who, despite having so much admiration for Javed Ghamidi sb, did not show any leniency or bias in putting question across the Islamic scholar. Only at the end of the interview, it appeared that he admires him. It is rare of a journalist to hide his bias towards someone while putting questions to him/her. Hats off to you dear. Finally, JAG is one of the gems the Muslim world has produced in 21st Century. May ALLAH guide all of us

It is always pleasure to watch javed Gamdi sir.

Abbas sahb hats off. Allah ap k safar ko mazeed ba barkat bnaye. Ustaz imam ghamidi sahb.. Allah apki tashreehaat aur araa ko hmare lye ba barkat bnaein.

Indonesia and Pakistan got their independence at the same juncture of the history. Today Indonesia is the President of the G20 and Pakistan is begging from door to door. In Indonesia religious organizations such as NU and Muhammadiyah was society centric while in Pakistan they were state centric. In Pakistan the debate was to Islamize the state while in Indonesia it was all about Islamizing the society and the Islamic organizations were more focused on social development and character building of the people in the light of the Islamic teachings. These were the most important lessons Pakistan could learn from Indonesia. (Khursheed Nadeem)

جزاک اللہ۔اللہ پاک آپکو اور غامدی صاحب دونوں کو اپنے خصوصی فضل و کرم سے نوازے۔آپ بہت اچھا کام کر رہے ہیں۔

Aap ko 75 saal se mulk mila hua hai, fir bhi ek musalman dusre muslman ki gardan kaat raha hai. Sunni, Shiya, Barelvi, Devbandi, Ahmedi, Ahle Hadis sab aapas me pyar se kyon nahi rahty ho?

end main rula he dia... Long Live Ustaz Ghamidi sbb

Ghamidi sahab is the genius man of this era ⭐

Only light I have seen so far amongst intellectuals is Pervaiz Hoodbhoy…a real undiscovered gem that’s being wasted in the sea of religious ignorance…

No words to praise this discussion, Most importantly not a single hope left. ان للہ وانا الیہ راجعون May Allah keep Ghamidi sb in good health and accept his struggle

"Pakistan ka masla kya, La illah ha ilallah"

God bless you Mr AHaider for letting us have the opportunity to have hope & light in the darkness from the learned intellectual allama JAGhamidi sb . Thanks & be blessed

Pakistan ka masala is Jinnah.. He didn’t had any vision for new state he created!!! Couldn’t even write a page how it should be 🤣People still fight over his speech he said tht he said this!! When base is not strong and u keep building its inevitable tht it will collapse!!!

Masha Allah .. ghamdi shb aaj ap ke har bt k haqiqat ab khul k samney aa rhen hn

Islam is the root of all problems along with Christianity. The rising tide of Dharma will raise all things. If you let it.

Very good knowledge thanks 👍

ہمارے ملک کی یہ بڑی بدقسمتی ہے کہ غامدی صاحب جیسے لوگ ملک چهوڑ کر میدان خادم رضوی، حافظ سعید، زید حامد اور اوریا مقبول جان کے لیے خالی کر دیتے ہیں۔

Javed Ahmad Ghamidi is just love 💕, may Allah give him good health

Words of wisdom and high-intellect always come from Ghamidi Sb. May Allah bless us all to learn from him!

Dear Mr. Haider, there is no duller islamist scholar than this Ghamidi.

Blessed to be living in the age where ppl like ghamidi sb are alive so we can hear and learn from his intellect. Brilliant as always 👏

اسلام میں قومی ریاستوں کا تصور نہیں نہ ھی قومی فخر پر اقتدار جاٸز ھے اسلامی عمرانیات کو سمجھنے کےلیے قومی تعصب سے مبرإ ھونا پڑے گا

Pakistan has always been a puppet state.even the Pakistan ka Matlab kya is foreign, not native. Sovereignty doesn't come with hired, rented or forced identities.that's the truth rest is poetry.

دردِ دل سے تجزیہ

I live in a Christian majority secular state, I feel secure and respected. I think it is not relevant that what denomination state proclaim but weather state can provide its citizens security and respect .

Buhat Shukria Abbas bhai. I have been listening to your views for last one month and believe me i have learned a lot. Keep educating us.

Ghamidi's attraction shows how desperate some people are to find some way, ANY absurd way, to keep calling themselves Muslims.

Ameen. Great scholar.May Allah give Ghamdi sb long live and healthy life.

Tears in my eyes at the last part. Thinking Pakistanis are crying inside looking at the state of our nation.

Ghamdi sahib, is a scholar, philosopher and a reformer of highest calibre. All his opinions, naratives, religous interpretations and teachings are based on strong logic and reasonings.

Baaton ki jalebiyan kaise banai jaati h,aaj sikh gaye in bhaisaab se.

Frequently I see Pakistanis saying on TV that Islam comes first and only then Pakistan while for Indian Hindus and so many indian Muslims religion comes only after mother India. This approach tells the whole story.

that last bit from abbas where he expresses his love for ghamidi sahab made me emotional. 😭

مذہبی ریاست کا سربراہ جہاں ضرورت پڑے وقتی ضرورت کے تحت قرآن کے حکم کو پس پشت ڈال سکتا ہے مگر اسلامی ریاست میں جہاں قرآن ریاست کے سربراہ کو رکے وہاں رک جائے

Mr. Javed Ahmad ko Ex Muslim Sahil, Adam, Munna Bhai, Faiz, Sulemani Jalebiyan, Sameer, Sachwala aur waki sabhi talib-e-ilm se classes lena chahiye. Insan ban jayenge.

You are great sir. You have done your part, Allah bless us.

There's a saying powerful people come from powerful places upto some extent it's true: Mahatma Gandhi comes from Gujarat but he used to say ( when someone slaps you keep your another cheeks infront of him & it was due to him Indian was divided & Pakistan was created )... Jinnah comes Gujrat his ancestors were hindu & he too his early life he was hindu but some. Social injustice made his mind to convert to islam & he was the culprit of making porkistan 😡 Narendra Modi comes from Gujarat worlds most influential politician He says if some one slaps you in one cheek in response to that slap the same person on his both cheeks with more power then he did & A Gujrati Who is looking For akhand BHARAT 🇮🇳 salute to him

ماشاءاللہ ❤❤❤

Excellent 👍👍👍

Best interview ever. God bless Ghamdhi Sahib

I was gonna say and writing it anyway that, see the difference of a “baghair darhi ka alim”. But it eventually comes down to humility. Unfortunately, our so called mullahs or alims doesn’t seem humble enough to learn or could tolerate criticism and tend to react violently. Whereas, in discouraging criticism, they’re actually equating themselves to prophets which ultimately fuel their arrogance and ego.

عباس بھائی بہت ہی منفرد۔۔

Very informative & Frank discussion.

غامدی صاحب کی شخصیت ہی ایسی ہے کہ انسان حسن ظن سے سنے تو بہت متاثر ہوتا ہے❤❤❤❤

The guest is rather difficult to comprehend. His belief that India has not yet accepted existence of Pakistan, puts him in the category of people with questionable intellectual level. He is just a typical Muslim. To put it simply, Pakistan's problem is Islam. "Pakistan ka nara kya", is a slogan raised very often and replied to very enthusiastically. If the slogan raised is changed to "Pakistan ka masla kya", reply would still be the same. Anchor's effort is commendable.