I’m 69...I agree with you 100%. It’s the experience and the memories the songs bring back. He is a living treasure...the most successful Songwriter in History!!I was watching the Ed Sullivan Show on February 9, 1964. The Beatles lifted the spirit of our Country after the assassination of President Kennedy in November last... I also took my Daughter to see Ringo and his All Star Band in 2010. She knew the words to almost every song of the various artists. Keep up the GREAT Work!!!
I definitely agree that absolutely NOBODY can tell you when to stop doing what you really love doing, mainly, being yourself. I saw him on the "Driving Rain" tour in 2002, and it was THE best concert I've ever seen. At 80, Paul sounds better than many schmucks I've seen in their 30s. So there.
I cannot begin to weigh up and measure the amount of wonder, pleasure and sheer joy that Paul’s music has brought into my life. Time takes us all on... we all grow old...if we are fortunate to do so...lets show some Love and Respect. How many times in our lives are we going to see a genuine musical legend ?
The answer to all this negativity in the world at the moment is Paul McCartney. His voice may be showing it's age but his attitude to life is still 100% positive and he projects this in his concerts. This not a question of nostalgia, this is what the world needs for the future.
I lived near Sir Paul in Sussex, we met him and Linda many times and had nice chats. He is a lovely man, very much a family man. He is probably the greatest bass player ever and a fantastic songwriter ever.yes, he is super rich and lives on an estate that is massive. He has given his life to music, the public and at 80, is still functioning like a 30 year old. Yes, his voice has deteriorated but he still has an aura and was a Beatle. His live shows bring tears to the eye, now, that is awesome. Thank you Sir Paul, you are still the man.
You speak the truth my friend.Who cares if his voice isnt what it was?Hes Macca .He was my reason for picking up a bass at age 14 in 1966,and still is (crowding 70 now)In my day anyone over 30 was well past it.But 80,and still rocking?Wow,what guy and what an example to us all.
"Paul McCartney is one of the few things to hang on." I have to thank you for that Video. Im 38 and i was not even a Beatles Fan for a long time. I respected them but they were before my time. But Paul is here since i was born. He is a constant in this chaotic world for me. Like for british people the Queen is. The longer i live the more i recognize what geniuses these four guys were and are. Especially Paul. Watching videos of him brings joy to my life. And allthough he is rich as f*** he at least seems to be a pretty grounded person and a akwardly funny guy. And boy what a young mind this old guy has. He is like an 25 year old man in a 80 year old body. I met him only 2 times in person and he is a show on its own. I have massive respect for this guy. Friends of mine actually met him at a ordinary restaurant. They couldn't believe it. Now i admit its hard to see the worsening of the voice since at least 10 years but its the experience which matters. To see him is like getting to see a glimpse of a long gone romanticized time. Its throws you back to the good old days even if you were to young to have lived through this time. So beautiful what you have said man. Thank you again. PS: I love Pauls "silly love songs" .. and i do not mean the song. ;-)
I saw him in 2013 and he was great. If you haven't seen him and can afford it go see him. If you have seen him before, hold on to your memories of Paul at his peak and skip this one. That is my plan. Bless him and how much he has added to our world. He has been super human for a long time.
I saw him 3 years ago and it was my favorite concert . Paul made it fun . he told lots of stories. He doesnt have to do this anymore . He loves playing live and he loves his fans.
Saw Paul in concert last night in Los Angeles. Whike his voice isn’t as strong it used to be, he was amazing! It was one of the best shows of my life. And I’m 63 years old! So, he could certainly stood the test of time. Go see Paul McCartney. He will not be sorry!
Music is a people's game and people vote with their wallets. People have and continue to overwhelming vote yes on Macca. My Father used to say, be a fountain not a drain and Sir Paul continues to be a wonderful fountain.
The people who don’t want to hear him don’t have to but he brings people joy and he knows it. I think that’s why he doesn’t quit. I love his later work so much. He sings his newer works just fine. Maybe it is suited to smaller venues. When he sang “I Want To Hold Your Hand” he spoke directly to my 12 year old heart in a profound way. McCartney 3 speaks directly to my 70 year old heart. It is exactly what that old heart needs. Personally his music helps me deal with the ugliness in this world. Thank you and all the other RU-vidrs who share clips of music and interviews and old pics. Thank you for you for sharing your thoughts.
I saw his tour opener in Spokane. It was the best concert I have ever seen. Was he in top voice? I don't really care. No one is going to sing as well as he did from 1972-1980. It was probably my one and only chance to see a Beatle live, and it was worth every penny.
I saw him in 89 and 2007..both were amazing and I feel blessed. My daughter saw him last year..i declined to go..she cried thru the whole show because it is honestly a religious experience...i will always love him
I am with you on this.....In general our society has lost its capability to have and show respect, manners, grace and a whole host of other positive attributes toward other people and things. It is sad and needs to change or I fear our society in general is lost.
I had the same thoughts about Ian Anderson of Jethro Tull. Music was great. Energy level 100% But his vocals were very bad. But I still enjoyed the show. And, yes it is very sad to see these music legends pass away. Doesn't seem to me that there is anyone to replace them. 🤔
I don't know if he's too old to do anything, but his Rock Bona fides are solidified. The man could do nothing but Opera for the rest of Eternity and he is a rock God
Thanks. I a.gree with your point of view. We have Paul alive, performing, making our dreams real even after all these years. Lets enjoy it while we can. No he doesn't have the voice he once had, but you do all the singing he's done over eighty years and see how you hang on. If people have a problem with his voice don't go, don't listen. It is still Paul freakin' McCartney. Where else are you going to get that level of everything he represents. Thanks. It needed to be said.
You made a great point man. I totally agree with you. We just need to appreciate their presence. These folks who made a history in contemporary music and who's influence hard to overestimate and they all are gradually varnishing. So what's the point of being unhappy that some of them are still around and kicking? Regardless.
Paul keeps on singing and playing, not because he needs to. People buys ticket to see him, not because they don't have other choice. So bravo, historian!
Thank u for the most passionate heart felt rant i think i ever heard. Bottom line :yes enjoy the old folks while they last (all ages really) soak up all their stories & pass them on!!!
I live in St. Pauli wich is a rough place in Hamburg. Paul Mc Cartney knows this place very well. He can do what he wants and his last record was great. But I want to tell you something. The Beatles were the first Pop Band ever. This is what makes them special. They have made the first Punk, the first Psychodelic and even the first Rap. All combined with Classical influence. They have been the first "Boygroup" ever and their cultural impact has changed the world. A Rock Band is something else.
You are spot on to what you are saying. You are correct about the soapbox society trying to rule our perspective! Sir Paul is one of the greatest, respect and dignity should be given to all. And especially to one who paved the way musically to many past and current artists. Rock on Sir Paul!
Curse my parents but I was born with a love for the rockers of their generation but born too late to see them in their prime. It wasn't till 2018 when I was a high schooler that I went to my first concert, Billy Joel, and then the next year to Paul McCartney. I'm going to the Fenway show in less than a month and cannot wait. I'm familiar with how Paul sounds on this tour and that doesn't bother me. What matters most to me is seeing a BEATLE play before 30,000 people in one of America's most revered stadiums and the experience and magic of those moments.
Great video, lots of truth. I grew up with The Beatles. When you're one of the world's most beloved musicians, you go out and play until you no longer can.
I’m 47. I’ve always loved Paul and The Beatles, but I’ve learned to love and appreciate them more now than when I was a kid. Going to see Paul for the 1st time next month. I’ve heard how he sounds from fan videos of this tour posted on RU-vid. Of course it’s not the same, but in the end it doesn’t matter to me. I’m going to see the man himself and it’s going to be great.
the guy is 80 years old please we dont have many performers like him let's just enjoy perhaps his last years there's nothing wrong with that c'mon along with other rock heroes
I think you make some good points. I saw Bob Dylan a few years ago. I like a lot of Bob's early stuff. Of course this was not that Bob. I don't like his voice as much now, but at the same time, like you said, he was out there and there is something to be said for that. I am glad I got to see him live even though he only sang one of his old songs, She Belongs to Me, which I sang along with. I still enjoyed the concert. As to musicians that have died, 2 of my favorites died earlier this year. Wayne Shorter of Weather Report died March 2, 2023. Weather Report was a band I was into in the mid/late 70s. I got to see them once in 78 or so and it was a great concert even though one of the reviewers said they had an off night(!) He and Joe Zawinul worked really well together and made some amazing music. The other is Jeff Beck who died on January 10, 2023. I saw him twice, both probably within the last 7 years. He played a lot of of the jazz at both concerts which I LOVED! He was on my short list of musicians I'd google occasionally to see if there were any concerts near me. But if he had stopped touring when he was say 65, or decided not to come to America after 65, I never would have seen him as he was in his 70s or near 70s both times I saw him. So yes, when these older musicians tour, they still can put on a really good show and give fans like me memories of seeing them live.
My daughter and husband were going to fly out to Seattle for that opening show. I discouraged it bc of how he’s singing. I prefer to remember the Paul McCartney who was the finest all-around singer I’ve ever heard. I’ve seen him twice in concert (‘90, Chicago, ‘10, SLC), and both times were awesome.
@@sg-yq8pm I took my family to see him in 2010, when his voice was still strong. She already loves his music and knows he’s a legend. I didn’t force her to not see him. She decided that she’d rather remember him in better form. Plus, since her husband doesn’t really know much about McCartney, she didn’t want him to have an impression of someone whose singing abilities are probably 20% of what they once were. It’s a bit difficult to hear him sing now. If you watch Wings Over America, you’ll see that his voice carried the other band members. Now, with his current band, it’s the opposite.
Sir Paul is still good enough for my ears and eyes . The complainers should leave him be . You don't mess with a Beatle , it's a natural Law . Whenever he should pass , I will be done with music and feel like I was robbed .:(
I saw the Rolling Stones last tour. It was not the Jagger of 1983, however, he was not shaky, did not break, ran around so much I got tired watching. Yes, the level of fun on stage was infectious. Great time. After the show, people still whinged. Challenge accepted. The real Presley, Morrison, McCartney, Domino and Buddy Rich and the Shade of Robert Johnson run a juke joint deep in the Mississippi Delta. (imagine bulging bloodshot eyes and spittle, yeah and a can of PBR, Russia's finest.) Agreed, by the way.
You are so right about these "Paul is Dead" idiots. I won't name names, but there's a RU-vid channel who is living off of this lie. I used to tune in occasionally for amusement. But now it just aggravates me beyond reason. He's been saying that the Beatles didn't write their own songs because no one could possibly be that prolific. And he convened a panel of "experts" to prove it! These are the same people who believe in Flat Earth. It takes all kinds, I guess.
Nowadays I think many old artists was revitalize again. Chicago, Bill Champlin, Bob James, Robert Tepper released new stuff that's very good and sound fresh like age is only a number 🙂
Should people spend over $100 to see a man one month away from 80 singing his old hits? That's up to them. Should a man that age be touring knowing that there are fans who have to see him every chance they get, and him knowing that at his age he won't have the energy to sound good on every song of every show? I'm pretty sure this is Paul's last big tour and he probably would have liked to have done it two years ago. But here he is and he can still sound good at times. If some shows don't sound great I'm sure most of the fans won't care.
I think that giving any thought to negative comments about Paul Mccartney is laughable. In my opinion, he is the king of rock and roll. I don't give two shits about the naysayers. What an amazingly gifted musician. Oh yeah. Rock on, Sir Paul. Thank you, sir, for your contribution to the world of music
I read a story of a concert pianist who lived to about 93 years. And he gave a concert at 92 years, despite suffering from crippling arthroses in his hands. He would wake up every morning and sit at the piano and start playing. It sounded like a 4 year old pounding the keyboard. But as his fingers freed up, he would play scales, then chords, then arpeggios, and only after several hours would he practice his more difficult pieces. He willed his hands to maintain their suppleness. And his would perform in the evenings. And the next day he'd start his routine again. A voice? That's different. Would I go see Paul McCartney? Yes. I'd also go see Roger Waters, but his voice has gotten stronger with the years. Not for singing, but for his actions. He has shouted out for all the injustices in the world and I appreciate him for it. I remember Susan Tedeschi and that guy she married had a concert and played some singers (sorry, I forgot their names) who were probably in their 70s and didn't want to sing. She insisted that there was more to music than hitting the notes perfectly, and it was the person and the history behind the song. Great concert. There is a video and it's well worth the view. Bon courage with your son.
I was 13 when the Beatles were on Ed Sullivan (you can do the math) and loved the Beatles (still do). As people age, their physical abilities change, and most singers, particularly ones who sing like Paul or Frankie Valli, lose the ability to sing as they did, unlike singers who stay within certain dynamic parameters, like Tony Bennet or Rosemary Clooney, who can usually defy the aging process almost until the end. Speaking of sports, if Magic, Bird, Michael, Kareem etc. got together to play a game for charity at $100 a ticket, would you go expecting to see the players they used to be? As you said just being there enjoying yourself, watching some players you used to love who were once great is what makes the price of admission worth it. I enjoyed hearing your thoughts. Regards.
I had 3rd row seats in SoFI Stadium last night and Paul McCartney definitely rocked!!!! In short, it was the best concert experience of my life. Paul played NON-STOP for the entire concert - 36 f'ing songs!!!! No intermission. He switched between multiple, multiple instruments and played them all expertly. He was incredibly energetic the whole show. I was also able to see his soundcheck in the afternoon and he played a full 17 songs in their entirety. So I witnessed him perform 53 songs and he did a great job on all, had everybody rocking. Yeah, his voice isn't as strong as it used to be, but it is still serviceable and I really didn't find that it detracted from what was a great experience.
THANK YOU. I came here thinking "ugh another wannabe RU-vidr giving his opinion about Paul's voice" ... but I can't thank you enough for what you said - I share the exact same view. I'm soooo sick of all these people who don't know the first thing about being a musician. If they knew, they would know that it's almost impossible to retire from that job - because we live for it, we need it. Paul will never stop, even if he ends up playing in a club for 30 people. Thanks again. You just got yourself a new follower!
Even if he was complaining about his voice, that won't make him a 'wannabe youtuber' because he would still be a youtuber. Also even if he complained about his voice, that's fine, I agree too. It's only dumb when you tell him to stop what he loves
Well said, my friend. I'm really getting tired of all the negativity the internet has brought...and it cannot be healthy to be constantly immersed in everyone's opinions.
The best way to see Paul now is to listen with your eyes. You'll enjoy it. Yes Paul still sings but for most of the songs his band carries him and sing in unison with him to keep it sounding tight. It's a great show and of course it's one of the Beatles but don't fool yourself that he's doesn't sound rough, he does.
I just finished watching your video. Yes I'm one of those jerks. The way you put it in prospective really made me think. I'm a 70 year old big beatle fan but more than that a fan of music in general. I constantly criticized Mc Cartney. I want to thank you for opening up my eyes and you being 100% right. Rock On
We need more people in the world like us my friend. When we are presented with another way of thinking we analyze and possibly change our position on something… too many people refuse to admit that they might be wrong
Most of the rock singers from the last 60 years can't carry a tune like before! But seeing these icons is more than just their voice but their energy and presence! Now if they forget the words or their energy is zapped then it's time to retire! I would rather see an artist who sings with what they have then to have them use vocal tracks! Good vid!
He sounds better at 80 than most of his peers who are 25 years younger than him. No autotune, no lip sync and no bs. Respect to Sir Paul And he also sings a majority of the songs in the original key which isn't a good idea but c'mon the fact he does that is insane
He is a GREAT musician, artist and performer. Yes, I have noticed it in his voice from his last couple albums. I didn't enjoy them but not only his voice, but the music itself he was putting out. Egypt Station did well because it was PAUL McCARTNEY. BUT LIKE YOU SAID 2 1/2 or 3 HOURS DOES MAKE YOU FEEL WONDERFUL.
You said it, pal. Paul is like a beacon of hope in an increasingly dismal world, harkening back to the days when people had a different attitude about life. It was all about fun and creativity, then. I was born in '54, so I remember what it was like. Paul takes us back again, and lets us know that life is still worth it. And btw, his name isn't Faul.
Being on the wrong side of 60 I can somewhat sympathize with the McCartneys of the rock world. Most folks who are in the popular music world have nothing else they can do w/their lives. Since they were teens being successful in music is all they wanted. Very few are educated, few are notably intelligent. This is the only thing nearly any of them know how to do. No matter how much money Sir Paul, Pete Townsend, et.al., have they need to do something (no Macca pun intended!) and this is pretty much all they know in life.
All Paul has to do to make it easier to sing some of his songs, is to lower the key they are playing the songs in. This method is used by the Stones and other bands. Let's face it we are not twenty years old any more and our voices have changed .
as these rockers go away there is an attempt to erase their affect on the world....from 1950 to 2000 some of the best sounds were created that were the sound track to the immense societal changes that swept over the world at that time.....many spectacular events/changes occurred ....reality is a projectile that constantly changes but we are in a phase now of moronic denial of these changes....i hear the phrase "traditional family values" and snicker....nothing is traditional, it simply is what it is at that particular time....paul is changing, we are all changing...go with reality people and though i have never seen paul in person, he should be allowed to be who he is now......
Seeing McCartney in this the twilight of his career is a bit like looking at the fossil of a dinosaur. It’s amazing to simply see the fossil despite it being just a shadow of its former self.
Paul McCartney singing is like listening to your grandfather sing a few songs at a holiday family gathering; most will love it and forgive a failing voice because, after all, this is grandpa who you've known and loved your whole life. Also, he won't be around much longer so yeah-give him a break. If you really can't stand it-we need more beer from the corner store. Why don't you make yourself useful and...
I'm gonna say it…Paul McCartney is the greatest living rockstar in the world, and possibly the greatest living musician. The fact that he is still in the shape that he's in at 80 years old is amazing, and let's be real, he can stop anytime he wants, he's made quite a living for himself. But instead, he's choosing to play 2-3 hour shows every night, playing 60 years worth of historic rock n' roll and pop music. These are songs that will be remembered hundreds of years from now. Is his voice older now? Sure, I guess. But honestly, if that alone is enough to turn you away from a night that is true magic, then I feel sorry for you. And guys, be honest, how many 80-year-olds can you think of that are still doing what he's doing? To him, age doesn't matter. He'll play for as long as he wants. That, is the definition of a rockstar.
I just saw him at Fenway the other night. I saw the stones at Gillette stadium a few years back and felt robbed by their effort. 45 minutes of bum notes without an encore. Paul is not doing that he’s giving you his best but it’s almost sad. It is very very bad to the point where it’s almost uncomfortable and I’d be shocked if this tour is completed. It’s bad.
I like your work and will return to watch this episode later. But I saw the thumbnail in passing and wanted to respond. Is Paul McCartney too old to rock? Answer: Is he dead yet?
What would be so difficult for the guy to just play smaller venues? Maybe perform a couple of weeks or days in clubs located in select cities? That way he could still do his thing, enough people could be accommodated (just not all at once!), ticket prices would probably be less dear, etc. Sir Macca might even get a bigger kick out of performing in more intimate surroundings. There is nothing wrong with getting old; I'm 66, but there is something amiss with not aging gracefully.
Sir Paul is the greatest Rock legend alive and better than those who have died ! I do hope though when he headlines Glastonbury a week after his 80th birthday he leaves on a high !! He is a LEGEND !!!! Oh by the way I believe almost all of the profits go to charity from most of his tours ! And brilliant synopsis and totally agree about him being dead Ha Ha ! Total tossers !
That's what this generation needs; a Reality Check. Hiding behind their Font, spewing negativity everywhere. WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE, enjoy Every moment, your next breath is not Promised to you.
Who the f is anybody to say one way or another? You want to tour? Do it! Make new music? Why not? I'm getting to the age where I'm just about sick with people telling folks they're too old for...anything. Shit, I'm an OG punk rocker! I turn 65 in August! Am I supposed to just start listening to Kenny G and shopping for pastel flower prints at Walmart? But let me leave you with a thought: Pete Townshend, in 1965 wrote, "I hope I die before I get old". Think he changed his mind? ;)
Paul McCartney's my all-time favorite too. Easily. I don't love everything he's done. There are some songs he's recorded so bad to my liking that I've had to keep my fanhood a secret. When CDs came out, it got easier. You could program around the crap. But he's still here; still putting out good music. We backed a good horse, didn't we?
MCCARTNEY NOW 80 YEARS OLD YOU EXCEPT HIS VOICE TO WEAR OUT. OR REACH SAME WAYS 4O YEARS AGO ALBUMS LIKE RAM BAND ON THE RUN. VENUS AND MARS AND SO ON BIG. LOVER OF THOSE ALBUMS. THOUGH . TO YOUNG TO SEE HIM ANYWAY I SAY LET PAUL ENJOY THE GIGS AND THE PEOPLE THAT GOES TOO. HE'S IS AND RINGO THE LAST. OF THAT BAND THE BEATLES GETTING ON IN YEARS NOW PEACE AND LOVE CHEERS
