Тёмный

Is Roald Dahl the latest victim of the culture war? 

Times Radio
Подписаться 885 тыс.
Просмотров 16 тыс.
50% 1

“This is definitely an overreaction and an overstep. And the response to that is not to go back and rewrite what has already been written, but to see it in a new light.”
Laura Hackett talks about the changes to Roald Dahl novels on #TimesRadio
---
Times Radio brings you the latest breaking news, expert analysis and well-informed discussion on the biggest stories of the day.
📻 Listen now - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
Follow Times Radio on social:
🔵 Facebook
/ thetimesradio
🔵 Twitter
/ timesradio
🔵 Instagram
/ timesradio
Subscribe here: / @listentotimesradio

Опубликовано:

 

18 фев 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 137   
@bobosmith8012
@bobosmith8012 Год назад
Rather than re-write Dahl, perhaps the Publishers should re-read Orwell?
@jsmith498
@jsmith498 Год назад
Good point. That was actually Winston Smith's job.
@radicalbyte
@radicalbyte Год назад
He who forgets the failures past is doomed to repeat them. We shouldn't be changing ANY books, period.
@20quid
@20quid Год назад
If you never change any books ever then how can you possibly hope to make Chaucer relevant for modern children?
@VFella
@VFella Год назад
@@20quid Or the Necronomicon!!!
@radicalbyte
@radicalbyte Год назад
@@20quid you make a derivative work, call it an "interpretation" or "adaptation" (or in the case of Chaucer - translation) of the original work and credit both the original artist and the person who adopted it. What you don't do is publish it as the original work.
@bobblue_west
@bobblue_west Год назад
The Bible is full of grotesque, gratuitous mass violence. Time for a ban and a re-write.
@shooster5884
@shooster5884 Год назад
@@20quid Well how do you make Chauser relevant by changing him? Either you read an author within the context of their time or don't read them..
@Travis_22
@Travis_22 Год назад
Hold on to your vintage copies of Roald Dahl, folks
@Darksjeik
@Darksjeik Год назад
The question isn't who's doing this or why, the question is who's allowing it?
@captainbuggernut9565
@captainbuggernut9565 Год назад
Censorship in effect. Puffin should be ashamed of themselves. Custodians of original works should not be butchering it to meet certain trendy sensitivities.
@Vintagevanessa99
@Vintagevanessa99 Год назад
Buy second hand books buy the original texts boycott new
@davidvasey5065
@davidvasey5065 Год назад
I happen to like the new texts
@Duckfisher0222
@Duckfisher0222 Год назад
Soon we are gonna run out of words, to describe people with...
@shooster5884
@shooster5884 Год назад
Well said..
@CesareFerrari667
@CesareFerrari667 Год назад
This is insane… do we remember who started burning books in a time not so far away? Will the Woke tyranny rewrite Odyssey too? We must stop this madness
@AthelstanEngland
@AthelstanEngland Год назад
It is because most media companies are controlled, or intimidated, by a small group of wokesters.
@gemmamunozperez5424
@gemmamunozperez5424 Год назад
¿Oh yeah so what media companies?
@AthelstanEngland
@AthelstanEngland Год назад
@@gemmamunozperez5424BBC, SKY UK, CNN, NBC, GOOGLE, FACEBOOK, TWITTER (still), WALT DISNEY, PARAMOUNT, NETFLIX, AMAZON, PUFFIN, RANDOM HOUSE that's just as a start, add in universities and schools adding 'trigger warnings' to authors from Shakespeare to Agatha Christie and you've got a pretty good school of indoctrination going there.
@gemmamunozperez5424
@gemmamunozperez5424 Год назад
¿¡What do you mean!?
@buddah1978egypt
@buddah1978egypt Год назад
Absolutely disgusting
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
He was a great man. Post 1945 Liberalism must destroy him.
@TheVeryLastHippy
@TheVeryLastHippy Год назад
I'm writing a new children's book, what do you think, "The person had a face, events happened in which no one was even mildly inconvenienced. All the animals were left well alone in their natural habitat and were not subjected to personification. No one spoke to anyone else or went where they felt uncomfortable. Everyone, was fine." I didn't mention the plants, do you think the plants will be upset!?
@Lt.GonvilleBromhead
@Lt.GonvilleBromhead Год назад
Stunning and brave. Disney may be interested in the movie rights.
@patriciastclair765
@patriciastclair765 Год назад
O no, my children loved Roald Dahl 😭
@davidrobertsemail
@davidrobertsemail Год назад
Dahl wasn’t a nasty man he was a gift. What a nasty woman.
@janemcilroy3289
@janemcilroy3289 Год назад
His book revolting rhymes is the absolute best
@ruppollock4392
@ruppollock4392 Год назад
I think it is to make it more palatable to woke Netflix, which is becoming almost unwatchable with its diversity and inclusion bs.
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
There is life outside of Netflix. You don't have to watch things you don't want to, it's not compulsory.
@abrahamlupis9354
@abrahamlupis9354 Год назад
What's next? Lady Marian being stronger than Robin Hood? Little John being renamed? the lost Boys having now lost girls? Othello getting the girl and a happy ending? Paddington being adopted by a same sex couple? Watership Down without deaths and blood? Romeo & Juliet having 28 years? Time to turn the UK into New China
@peetky8645
@peetky8645 Год назад
Little john is perfect as is. Maid marian will be changed to Ladyboss Marian her girlpowerness. All your other ideas are in the pipeline already by the woke at Disney.
@Saggin11
@Saggin11 Год назад
Soon we may never laugh again 😢
@ruppollock4392
@ruppollock4392 Год назад
Who asked, or was offended by these books.? I will not be buying any changed or edited books, ever.
@s1nb4d59
@s1nb4d59 Год назад
The stupidity of the levels of "pc" to save us from offensive things needs to stop.
@heathen-greaser
@heathen-greaser Год назад
What makes me laugh is the fact these people trying to change everything because they feel offended probably go out every year buying the newest iPhone or what ever with no care in the world that in 2022 alone there were 40.000 enslaved children going to as young as 7 years old working down in cobalt mines in the Congo in terrible conditions so we can all have the battery's for our mobile phones. That is still going on right now and we never here these people say right I will not own a mobile phone while we allow children to be enslaved so we can have the battery's made.
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
Depends what you think PC is. It's usually about not being offensive. I suppose if you want children's books to be offensive that is a perspective. Teach impressionable children tropes they hold for life.
@s1nb4d59
@s1nb4d59 Год назад
@@dondoodat Reading about things first then understanding what could be wrong about them is a part of learning,burning books basically like the nazis did because they didnt like their bent is wrong for many reasons,children grow into adults and we can make those choices ourselves.
@Berry-fr5wj
@Berry-fr5wj Год назад
@@dondoodat PC has morphed into woke
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
@@s1nb4d59 But haven't you then allowed children to be conditioned into believing wrongful stereotypes or tropes which then stay with them for life ? Children should surely be protected from material that could lead them to bully others for reasons that wouldn't be acceptable to any adult ? If someone wrote a childrens book that had racism, misogyny, antisemitism and homophobia as it's storyline you'd be happy a child read that without the child being given any context about right and wrong ?
@lg5819
@lg5819 Год назад
I just cannot understand how a man called Roald Dahl, who was imaginative, and a genius to write those books was racist and antisemitic. To be blessed with creativity, comes from the heart, the human soul. Perhaps, he lived in an isolated world, and feared what was different, compared to what he grew up with. No excuses made, but just trying to understand the man. A man who had a famous daughter called Sophie Dahl. And she doesn’t come across to me as racist and antisemitic, and if her father was, how come she was raised to think differently? I just wonder, how much of Roald Dahl character traits are based on fact, or what has been spread about him, through gossip, speculating, and making assumptions.
@fenixvolt2777
@fenixvolt2777 Год назад
Love roald Dahl and I am Black!
@lg5819
@lg5819 Год назад
@@fenixvolt2777 When I read a comment like yours, it restores my faith in common sense and humanity.
@mrsjanhannah
@mrsjanhannah Год назад
F.F.S.
@heatrayzvideo3007
@heatrayzvideo3007 Год назад
The future is humourless and lacking irony, the Puritans will rule the world with their intolerance.
@PharisaerWatch
@PharisaerWatch Год назад
The Amish people have the last laugh it seems....lol
@Sophiedorian0535
@Sophiedorian0535 Год назад
I am 60 years old. Even as a kid, if found Roald Dahl’s books a bit ‘dated’. Why not allow his work to retire into history quietly, as so much of the work of other dead authors has been allowed to? The decision of the publishers to mess with text has to do with little else than money. It is always more profitable to renovate the work of the defenceless dead authors, than to risk entering into a publisher-author relationship with the all too lively young creatives of today. Roald Dahl’s work comes with the context of the time in which it was written, and with context of the personality of who wrote it. Change the text, and you betray not only the author, but history and humanity, as well.
@toi_techno
@toi_techno Год назад
As you said publishers exist to make money and they know that modern parents don't want their kids to become like the outraged, nasty, right-wing morons of their generation so won't buy them books with nasty stuff in them. Western society is getting kinder and more tolerant and there's nothing the anti-woke, traditionalist, neo-fascists can do about it.
@Sophiedorian0535
@Sophiedorian0535 Год назад
@@toi_techno Really, I don’t care. Not about woke, not about traditionalists, not about ideology, and not about offensive words. I care about authenticity: leave the text alone.
@The_Greedy_Orphan
@The_Greedy_Orphan Год назад
You say retire, but i think it's an important role art of British culture and history and something to be proud of, offensive humour has always been a British tradition. The thing I most despise abiut this are those who wish to make that choice for us because it doesn't align with their personal political leanings, sorry, but they can go F themselves.
@Sophiedorian0535
@Sophiedorian0535 Год назад
@@The_Greedy_Orphan I agree. But I don’t believe politics is to blame. It’s a barbaric disdain for the integrity of a work of art. Like the fitting of Hellenic marbles with fig leaves in the 19th Century, so as to avoid offending the bourgeoisie prepared to pay through the nose for having them displayed in their parlours. I believe it is like I said earlier: Roald Dahl still has got a lot of profit in him, but in order to be able to milk his legacy any further, some publishers apparently choose to mutilate it. Money, not politics, is the motive. I don’t care about the motive though. You don’t butcher works of art. You just don’t.
@peetky8645
@peetky8645 Год назад
well said
@stardustpink7915
@stardustpink7915 Год назад
THANK YOU! I am glad to see so many people have a brain to be honest, this is all, ridiculous! Oversenstive, it makes no sense.
@shooster5884
@shooster5884 Год назад
This is ridiculous!! A person who wrote a book wrote a book. Ridiculous to rewrite it... What idiotic wimps are we becoming... People read crime novels all the time. I don't see victims of crime saying anyone who does so is offending them... and crime novels should be altered The world's gone mad.
@gmailvfone
@gmailvfone Год назад
Maybe woke brigade should just write and publish their own books under their own creative licence style and leave the rest alone!
@sebinohoo2979
@sebinohoo2979 Год назад
tbf it seems even the woke brigade think this is nonsense
@gmailvfone
@gmailvfone Год назад
@@sebinohoo2979 Interesting. 🤔 Thanks. 👌
@nevermindmeijustinjectedaw9988
lololololol the second lady completely discredited everything the first one said in her entire monologue "censoring is bad if others do it, but if we do it it's good" what a joke
@JimNicholls
@JimNicholls Год назад
There are so many offensive things in the Bible, and I look forward to seeing a fully expurgated version soon!
@havaguday
@havaguday Год назад
Will anyone get excited when they go after the Merchant of Venice?
@aethellstan
@aethellstan Год назад
gordon bennett, what is the world coming to?
@davidcoleman757
@davidcoleman757 Год назад
If we are to tread such a perilous road, who gets to be the arbiter and editor of things written in the past, and what qualifies them for the task? I would suggest that no-one has, or should be afforded, the right to amend our literary heritage, however distasteful individual works may be to some modern sensibilities. We ignore Orwell at our peril.
@emom358
@emom358 Год назад
Stupidity recognizes no borders
@planetphil3456
@planetphil3456 Год назад
Are they going to do this to mein kampf and turn it Into a children's book too
@ewu77
@ewu77 Год назад
I would love to see a children's version of Mein Kampf
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
No.
@VFella
@VFella Год назад
@@ewu77 So you would finally be able to read it!!
@bill1602
@bill1602 Год назад
context in books has been totally forgotten... they just crtl+F and replaced just the word.... sick
@t_albino
@t_albino Год назад
Anything and everything for children could be considered offensive. Spot the Dog, Pingu, Mr Ben, Maisie Rabbit... I could spend hours showing you why and how they could be banned. Meanwhile, no one saying a word about platforms like Tiktok filling kids heads with misinformation. Ah well.
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
Spot The Dog ? Go on then. People are very much complaining about tik tok, maybe you spend too much time watching Pingu to have noticed ?
@t_albino
@t_albino Год назад
@Don Doodat alright. Spot the Dog forces the world of human relations onto a canine family, who do not relate to each other in the ways that members of a human family would. It is confusing and highly inappropriate to be teaching children about a 'family' of dogs that carry out human behaviour. That worked didn't it 😄
@Toracube
@Toracube Год назад
Rudyard Kipling next. Then someone else…
@peetky8645
@peetky8645 Год назад
corporate capture by woke warriors is gonna get worse before it gets better.
@ruppollock4392
@ruppollock4392 Год назад
My safe space is my home. When I read or see a movie, I want the opposite of that , no some bland, amoebic tripe that dosent offend anyone. Please , I want to be offended, ridiculed...a guilty pleasure.
@garyduddy1825
@garyduddy1825 Год назад
The publisher should remove the author's name from the books if its not his words and also they should still offer people the choice to buy the original uncensored versions as it would probably sell more of them.
@raginald7mars408
@raginald7mars408 Год назад
when "demos crazy" descends to Kinder Garden and 5 year olds run the world
@VFella
@VFella Год назад
Yeah, it's always better to have a Strong Man at the helm to bomb the kindergardens out of existence, right?
@davidhunt3808
@davidhunt3808 Год назад
What is happening to the world ? You can’t say this can’t say that it is madness ,it’s political correctness gone crazy ! We are becoming so soft being offended by Certain words . you can see why some are getting very fed up about it .
@MrSimonw58
@MrSimonw58 Год назад
In going solo he claims an African gentleman killed a German
@TuxedoMaskMusic
@TuxedoMaskMusic Год назад
Roald Dahl deserves better co-creators than this. 1:53 next you will say that was also true of Walt Disney or Edwin Hubble?! LOL!
@livingtribunal4110
@livingtribunal4110 Год назад
Foot-Infection Salt
@20quid
@20quid Год назад
Were you trying to type this into google?
@livingtribunal4110
@livingtribunal4110 Год назад
@@20quid Same as the new woke-appeasement book is trying not to offend tortoises, the same applies to ´verrucas´, I guess.
@martincowling6562
@martincowling6562 Год назад
These book in the 80's kids loved, And rewriting something means you can't take any part of that story from the original. And Roald Dahl family should sue now as people want to boycott and not buy puffin books or buy any remake story's of his and buy the original, And can't rewrite history, This lead to those who don't like humor being brain-dead, Demented, Completely sad in the head, And pulling someone's work down now he's sadly dies years ago and fighting in the war, All want to take a long hard look in a mirror and see what is staring back as low-life/ Woke Brigade won't win as it's only pushing people to fight and shout out louder, And there is JK Rowling too who speaks out as they don't like her thoughts, Can't wait for the biggest film ever made the Wokes vs Humor as the winner is Humor. Constellation prize. Boxes of Tissues,
@davidfoster2006
@davidfoster2006 Год назад
There sure is a lot of woke wonkers.
@fretish5425
@fretish5425 Год назад
I’m sure no publisher is creating alternative versions of stories for the purpose of selling more product (new and improved edition!). No one would do something just for the purpose of making a buck.
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
Or for a sudden rush to buy up the original versions.
@1954audrey
@1954audrey Год назад
WHATS NEXT THE BIBLICAL BIBLE
@robertasirgutz8800
@robertasirgutz8800 Год назад
A "Jewish" face. Hebrew is read backward. Figure it out?
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
I can see the good intention, but it will be used by those who want to fight culture wars to diminish real acts of discrimination down to 'hurt feelings'.
@billyponsonby
@billyponsonby Год назад
Age of the outraged easily predicted.
@toi_techno
@toi_techno Год назад
This woman loves upsetting vulnerable kids by the sound of things.
@DoxGR7934
@DoxGR7934 Год назад
I down voted this video. Even here, these people are deciding what changes are acceptable in someone's writing. I can't chime in on the negative allegations made against Dahl in this video. For the sake of argument let's say they are true. Then simply be against the book. But saying you're against one set of editing, while for another set, is missing the point.
@bobdickweed
@bobdickweed Год назад
Lets Re-write history and make it a safe space for the Dead , the world has gone mad
@Jack908r
@Jack908r Год назад
There is no culture war. There is no cancel culture. These are just buzzwords. Please stop.
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
There are both culture wars and cancel culture. They exist, why would you want to pretend they don't ?
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
@@zz-if1ic No. It's a rightwing way of ignoring anything that doesn't suit them.
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
@D D Day esq Thanks for providing an example of the sort of ignorant, empty, pointless and pathetic attempts at insults I would expect from someone with nothing else to offer. You proved my comments to be correct.
@ktmr_w
@ktmr_w Год назад
Such a shame on woke culture...
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
No, that's what you want to pretend it is. For your culture war.
@ktmr_w
@ktmr_w Год назад
@@dondoodat Sure, Jan... 😂
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
@@ktmr_w What ? You're not making any sense.
@Berry-fr5wj
@Berry-fr5wj Год назад
@@dondoodat you started it
@dondoodat
@dondoodat Год назад
@@Berry-fr5wj You're not making any sense. Try using whole sentences.
Далее
The Dark History of Roald Dahl
26:02
Просмотров 127 тыс.
МЕГА ФОКУС С КАЛЬКУЛЯТОРОМ
00:33
Roald Dahl: The Incredible Life of an Incredible Author
29:36