Тёмный

Is The Op Amp Really THAT Important In An Overdrive Pedal? Testing The JRC 4558, 5532 And Many More 

Arito Suzuki
Подписаться 3,2 тыс.
Просмотров 12 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

30 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 52   
@arito
@arito 24 дня назад
(almost) EVERY 4558 ever made! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-n30-hlBKAYE.html More Shootout Videos: ru-vid.com/group/PLuGyFi1zEmqbyeXcyZgBuAb3NBJP4mzTH
@HugoDeFainia
@HugoDeFainia 3 года назад
5532D sounds like the best of all I am looking for. Slightly crunchy yet not harsh. I ordered a few based don't his video. Great video! Thanks for doing this work with this quality!
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! Glad to hear that the video helped in your decision making. I'll be making more geeky videos in the future, so stay tuned!
@neilghosh7148
@neilghosh7148 3 года назад
Excellent comparison vid, thank you for putting this together
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! Great to hear that you enjoyed the comparison, hope it was helpful or informative to some extent. It was definitely a really interesting experiment for me!
@nucleararmeddogg568
@nucleararmeddogg568 2 года назад
2:01 - JRC4558 2:43 - CA3260 3:24 - TL082 4:05 - JRC5532 4:47 - TA75358
@andrewwong6158
@andrewwong6158 3 года назад
great video. thanks. i didn't think they would be so similar. I liked the 5532D the best in this test. maybe different in different conditions like driving a high gain amp
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! I totally felt the same way, I didn't expect them to be so similar. I'm still undecided on my favorite, but I plan to make another test with a slightly different circuit, so we'll see if that can highlight the differences...
@PATRIK67KALLBACK
@PATRIK67KALLBACK 2 года назад
Super interesting comparison! In my ears the 1st is JRC4558, 2nd TL082, 3d CA3260, 4th JRC5532, and finally on 5th place TA75358.
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! It's great to hear which op amps other people liked. I've accumulated several more op amps since I made this video and hope to do and updated shootout one of these days!
@thefactorycollective
@thefactorycollective 2 года назад
Extremely helpful. Thank you!
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! Great to hear you enjoyed the video!
@goranvuletic8873
@goranvuletic8873 8 месяцев назад
With good PICKUPS, fresh strings and a well tuned guitar everything sounds good, more or less. This would all be "meh..." with my stock pickups.
@arito
@arito 8 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching! And thank you for sharing your thoughts and impressions!
@alexjenner1108
@alexjenner1108 2 года назад
Did you connect an oscilloscope to the output, or have any other way of checking for oscillation, something that some op amps are prone to do? You might not hear the high frequency oscillation, but it can have an impact on distortion. I'm wondering if that could have been an issue with the TA75358, which from my understanding is the Toshiba version of the LM358, so still an op amp that can be used for audio. In my experience, in some applications such as two way radio equipment, the LM358 can also be quite easily be affected by RF interference. Better circuit design e.g. shielding, bypass can help reduce both oscillation and RF sensitivity problems and swapping an LM358 with a TL082 or similar helped reduce RF interference problems in at least one application I've worked with. In this video the TL082 might have the best sound too. Thanks for the video.
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! And thanks for a detailed analysis of the tones from the TA75358. I don't own an oscilloscope, so this comparison is just by ear. But, that said, I have tried putting the TA75358 in other non-breadboard pedals like my Boss OS-2, and the results were similar, with that fizz at the end of the note. But, I don't have any means to measure RF interference, so as you mention, that can very well be the cause of that fizz tone.
@andyeldridge4748
@andyeldridge4748 2 года назад
Thanks for this video! It is exactly what I was looking to hear!! I use the boost side of a Super Signa Drive. I love the top boost and the other spread of frequencies, but it has an annoying fizz at the moment. Think I might change the 4558 to a CA3260. Might get a selection to experiment. Thanks again. 🙏
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! Thank you for your kind words, so glad to hear my video was able to provide some insight or help. Buying a bunch of op amps to compare and experiment would probably be best and a lot of fun as well!
@EmotionsTV1
@EmotionsTV1 7 месяцев назад
Good afternoon. Is there a difference between JRC5532D and JRC5532DD? To me in the sound card.
@arito
@arito 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching! The DD has better noise performance.
@syntheffects
@syntheffects 2 года назад
Great video!! The AC one would be usable for an experimental fuzz.
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! Yes, I was thinking the same thing! The TA 75358 has a great lo-fi fizz/velcro tone, it would be interesting to max out the gain even further and make a lo-fi fuzz with it. Maybe I'll get around to trying that one of these days.
@Thecando
@Thecando Год назад
I think the low noise one was the best BUT I kind of liked the MOSFET one and the one from your old car. What was the make/model/year of the car? Thanks for the video!
@arito
@arito Год назад
Thanks for watching! Great to hear that you enjoyed the video! The 5532 is a great all round op amp that seems to work in any circuit. The car was a Volvo 850.
@Blaculo
@Blaculo 3 года назад
I like the TL082 best in blind listening.
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! The TL082 seems to have a nice, full sweet sounding breakup character.
@ali2ndmail
@ali2ndmail Год назад
Wow these sounded very similar, with the exception of the one out of the car. The ca3260 and Jrc4558 were the closest together and both sounded good. The 5532 was nearly as good to my ears. The TL072/082 sounded a little bit bright for my taste.
@arito
@arito Год назад
Thanks for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video, and thank you for sharing your impressions on the tones!
@weareelectricgi
@weareelectricgi Год назад
do you have a schematic diagram? i want to try it out myself
@arito
@arito Год назад
Thanks for watching! I don't have a schematic for this, but if you watch my new op amp shootout video, I show a schematic! (link in my top pinned comment)
@weareelectricgi
@weareelectricgi Год назад
@@arito Thank you very much! yeah i watched it and i like the tone of jrc 4558, it was used on a tube screamer right?
@arito
@arito Год назад
@@weareelectricgi Yes, the 4558 is used in the Tube Screamer and countless other pedals!
@miltonshred
@miltonshred 8 месяцев назад
RCA the best!!
@arito
@arito 8 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching! Please check out my other op amp shootouts! link is in the top pinned comment.
@laxmansinghchauhan1118
@laxmansinghchauhan1118 3 года назад
Sir which one you prefer
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! I'm still undecided on a favorite, as the differences are so subtle. I even like the TA75358 for a lo-fi "cranked cheap practice amp" type sound.
@trafalgarsquare9019
@trafalgarsquare9019 2 года назад
Hola muchas gracias por tus vídeos , una pregunta , NES 5532 P es igual a 5532 D ?
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! I'm guessing that you are asking about the NE5532 vs JRC/NJM5532... In theory they are the same, but they are made by different manufacturers so their manufacturing process/equipment will differ slightly. And like many things, some people say they sound completely different, and others say they are pretty similar...
@trafalgarsquare9019
@trafalgarsquare9019 2 года назад
@@arito thanks ! You are awesome!
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
@@trafalgarsquare9019 You are very welcome! Hope everything works out!
@cvanlaldingngheta1866
@cvanlaldingngheta1866 3 года назад
Please can you share circuit diagram?
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! I don't remember the exact schematic for this, but it's very similar to the DIY breadboard overdrive from my video tutorial, minus the clipping diodes.
@LanceJordan
@LanceJordan 3 года назад
Slight differences, but the 4558 has better articulation at the beginning of the 1st strum, and sounds a tad bit warmer to y ears.
@arito
@arito 3 года назад
Thanks for watching! Yes, I definitely agree, the differences are very subtle, and it probably comes down to personal preference, and how the entire circuit is designed.
@neihsangapautu9096
@neihsangapautu9096 2 года назад
Can you show the circuit schematic
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! I don't remember the exact schematic for this, but it's very similar to the DIY breadboard overdrive from my video tutorial, minus the clipping diodes.
@RozsaAmplificationLLC
@RozsaAmplificationLLC Месяц назад
Soo....what's the verdict?!??
@arito
@arito Месяц назад
Thanks for watching! There really is no verdict here, it's all about what each viewer is hearing :)
@RozsaAmplificationLLC
@RozsaAmplificationLLC Месяц назад
@@arito ok. They all sound about the same. The TA sounded horrible and too much break up. The others are close. Some are a little more hi-fi and less noise. All-in-all, the IC does marginal amount for the tone besides slew rate and sag and noise/hiss.
@arito
@arito Месяц назад
@@RozsaAmplificationLLC Thanks for sharing your tone impressions! It's really interesting to hear what each person notices, but there does seem to be a common thread throughout the comments :)
@pisotones2348
@pisotones2348 2 года назад
That JRC4558 is a modern version and thus, very simillar to any other modern 4558 variant. That is not *THE* JRC4558.
@arito
@arito 2 года назад
Thanks for watching! Yes, this 4558 along with the 5532 and TL082 are just regular chips that can be bought today.
Далее
MAGIC TIME ​⁠@Whoispelagheya
00:28
Просмотров 22 млн
skibidi army returns (skibidi toilet 77)
00:49
Просмотров 2,3 млн
1970's Op-Amp Distortion
16:43
Просмотров 430 тыс.
Busting the myth of magical op-amps and diodes...?
19:05
#1037 MORE fake op-amps from China
7:27
Просмотров 13 тыс.
How to Design a Distortion Pedal Circuit
17:21
Просмотров 37 тыс.
Your Components are probably FAKE! Soooo is that BAD?
9:32
Op-Amps  - Using Operational Amplifiers
44:21
Просмотров 292 тыс.
EQ Guitar Pedals - How do they work?
21:32
Просмотров 6 тыс.
MAGIC TIME ​⁠@Whoispelagheya
00:28
Просмотров 22 млн