Is the Quran miraculous? With Dr Mustafa Khattab 

@Mohammed Efaz Many thanks!

@@BloggingTheology Jazāk Allāhu Khayran (May Allah ﷻ reward you with goodness) br Paul.

I’m loving this new Timestamps culture 😏

​@@BloggingTheology May I ask you one simple question, Mr. Paul? Before Muhammad died in AD 632, he got the complete revelation of Quran, right? He was illiterate. Still he ensured that the Quran verses were recorded with the help of his companions (sahabis). Those ayaths were recorded on plain stones, camel bones, animal skin and palm tree leaves according to Islamic history! That was the very FIRST QURAN! THE ORIGINAL QURAN! THE REFERENCE QURAN WHICH SHOULD LAST FOREVER! THE VERY QURAN ALLAH PROMISED TO PRESERVE AND PROTECT FOREVER! NOW THE QUESTION IS: WHERE IS THAT ORIGINAL REFERENCE QURAN AS ON TODAY? WHERE IS THAT QURAN PROTECTED AND PRESERVED BY ALLAH HIMSELF AS ON TODAY? IF IT EXISTS TODAY , YES IT IS A MIRACLE AS MUSLIMS CLAIM! IF NOT, ISLAM SIMPLY COLLAPSES! You agree, Paul? However what is the real truth? 1. Most probably that Original Reference Quran recorded by the Islamic prophet was included in the Quran portions destroyed by fire on orders of Caliph Uthman. If so that Original Reference Quran is lost forever! 2. What about the present Quran available with us? a. First post Islamic prophet Quran was made after his death in AD 632. Caliph Abu Bakr was forced to compile the first post Islamic prophet Quran because of sudden death of many Quran memorizers in the subsequent wars. Did Allah or prophet commanded him to do the compilation of Quran? No, never! In fact Allah himself promised to preserve and protect his Quran forever! However sudden loss of so many Quran memorizers forced Caliph Abu Bakr to take his own decision, without seeking advice from Allah or Muhammad! That is how the Abu Bar Quran came into existence! Most Muslims will get shocked that this First Quran had no involvement of Allah or prophet! b. Thus Abu Bakr appointed a young man, Zyad Ibn Tabith, who was previously the scribe of the Islamic prophet before his death. Zyad Ibn Tabith was obviously reluctant to undertake the job, which was not commanded by Allah or prophet. However he had no other choice, but to obey the orders of the king. c. Why did Caliph Abu Baker ordered the compilation of Quran, which was not commanded by Allah or prophet when Allah himself promised to protect his Quran? Means, Abu Baker had no faith in Allah's words? And he compiled a Quran with the help of above Zyed Ibn Tabit. Obviously an unauthorized Quran! However even this unauthorized Quran was not complete! One ayath was missing in it for so many years! No one could identify or realize or point out the grave mistake! Finally Zyed Ibn Tabit while revising the Abu Baker Quran, on orders of Caliph Uthman, remembered about the grave mistake and added the ayath in the Revised Uthman's Quran! And Caliph Uthman ordered the destruction of all other Quran materials!!! d. Even the Revised Uthman's Quran had its own problems. Two solid Surahs were missing in it and also one ayath on stoning of adulterous women and verse of suckling the breast by adult men! e. Abdullah ibn Masʽood was one of the four most prominent Quran teachers appointed by Islamic prophet. He totally disapproved the Revised Uthman's Quran too! Then, what credibility Revised Uthman's Quran got ? f. Now Muslims use many different ARABIC QURANS! See the links below please. 1. Display of 26 versions of Arabic Quran @ Hyde Park , London ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EsgphL9lGcc.html 2. Why are there over 30 different Arabic Qur’ans? - Quranic Corrections Ep. 3 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EpsnXMZ5lEE.html g. Here is a solid example for totally different Arabic Qurans. FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM HAFS sihraani ... two works of magic ... 28:48 FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM WARSH saahiraani ... two magicians ... 28:48 Obviously "two works of magic" FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM HAFS cannot be exactly equal to "two magicians" FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM WARSH. Both cannot be true! When that is the ground reality, many Muslim brethren still hold on to the belief that ""Allah sent the Final Testament, the Qur'an, and unlike the previous books, has never been changed.""

جَزاكَ اللهُ خَـيْراً أخي ❤️💖 Thank you for doing this 😊 Great work 👌🏻 I was extremely busy and hence wasn't able to do it in time.

Muhammad Asad: rationalist and not very reliant on hadith

@@DarioHaruni and from what I've heard, borderline deviant at some points.

@@vol94 You consider him a deviant because he doesn't use the israiliyyat and the fairy tales?

@@DarioHaruni Yes, and by implications 'hadiith' are indeed irrational!

Muhsin Khan's is not just a matter of context, it's to do with if you are Wahabi / Salafi !

Dear sir may Allah swt open your heart for his Deen aameen summa aameen

What? Did you say that you are Christian? Your duty is to do everything you can to save your precious daughter from hellfire. Jesus said, 'I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father except through Me.' Muhammad was a liar, a false prophet, and exploited women. No young girl should respect such a wolf.

Ameen Bro. Ur handle name is inappropriate. Not everyone is gifyed to be born a muslim. They did jot choose to be born in an idol worshipping family. And yes the truth has to be sought and can be obvious. I hope everyone agrees that the search and change is not easy to do. Everyone has their ossues and problems in life to just stay afloat. Your handle name may insult them and chase them away when u r in any conslversation using this acct. If you think its so easy to change, why are we in such a low state of Iman? Worse some leaving Islam altogether? Lets be kind and open to them and be welcoming....and this does not mean being weak.

@@ZakirHussain-oz9su It does no one any good to be born a muslim. For as Jesus said, unless one is BORN AGAIN (spiritually regenerated), one cannot see the kingdom of God. Flesh cannot produce Spirit, no matter how hard it tries.. Animals, plants, and bacteria also reproduce according to their kind. How are muslims unique in this regard? What's this muslim obsession with 'strength'? What is wrong with being 'weak'? When people abandon their pretense to be 'big shots', to 'call the shots' as it were, God is able to use them as instruments in displaying His strength. As Jesus said, 'the meek will inherit the earth'. The apostle James quotes, 'God is opposed to the proud, but gives grace to the humble.'

Islam is a carnal religion thats why you enjoy this garbage talk

@@jared2244 Your disgustingly negative emotions and attitude are the only “carnal” thing here. And your misinformation is the only real “garbage”. Listen & learn with an open mind, remove the hate from your heart, and then perhaps you’ll be on your way out of a ‘carnal garbage’ mentality and into sincerity, truth, and enlightenment. And know that God is not the least unaware of anything that you do.

@@celestialknight2339 " ..negative emotions and attitude are the only carnal thing here" This shows that you dont understand the meaning off to be carnal. "Learn & learn with an open mind" When Muslims speak of open mind they actually mean that mind should be open toward Islam. Once that open mind does not favor Islam there is a problem. Those who demonstrate an open mind, and walk away from Islam are branded apostate and traitors.. They are humiliated, scorn, describe as fake, and all kinds of derogatory things are said about them. The issue is never addressed but the personal attacks continues relentlessly. Sometimes apostate have to flee for their lives, and face family abandonment. "..remove the hate from your heart" Speaking against the evils perpetrated by Muslims because of Islam is considered hate.

It won't be a relaxing experience when you have to account for your rejection of Christ. Better reconsider while time remains.

@@marcusonesimus3400 we are sure in our Lord, the Lord of Abraham and all the prophets. Allah is the only true God, eloh in Hebrew and Allaaha in Aramaic ( the language Jesus spoke). Jesus is the Messiah and a man and messenger. Claiming he is more than that is blasphemy and paganism. Read below if you care about God's scriptures. All prophets have preached the same thing. Worship the one God and do not attribute partners to him. Even Jesus and his deciples preached this. The only outlier was Paul who single Handley changes the religion of God to the degree that he did. Even going against James and the disciples ministry. Read the scriptures and you'll see the contridictory beliefs Paul added below. (Matthew 4:1) Jesus was tempted (James 1:13) God cannot be tempted (John 1:29) Jesus was seen (1 John 4:12) No man has ever seen God (Acts 2:22) Jesus was and is a man, sent by God (Numbers 23:19, Hosea 11:9) God is not a man (Hebrews 5:8-9) Jesus had to grow and learn (Isaiah 40:28) God doesn't ever need to learn (1 Corinthians 15: 3-4) Jesus Died (1 Timothy 1:17) God cannot die (Hebrews 5:7) Jesus needed salvation (Luke 1:37) God doesn't need salvation (John 4:6) Jesus grew weary (Isaiah 40:28) God cannot grow weary (Mark 4:38) Jesus slept (Psalm 121: 2-4) God doesn't sleep (John 5:19) Jesus wasn't all powerful (Isaiah 45: 5-7) God is all powerful (Mark 13:32) Jesus wasn't all knowing (Isaiah 46:9) God is all knowing Please re-read your scriptures properly Christians. And analyse the contradictions within. Jesus (peace and blessings be upon him) was a mighty messenger sent by God. Not God incarnate.

You are a blessing, Dr. Paul. Kindly send the info re purchase. Dr. Mustapha Khattab, may Allah SWT reward your efforts. Jazak Allah! 🤲🏽❤🤲🏽🇹🇹

Aameen

Aameen aameen yarabbal aalameen

Your god does not exist. The God of Isrel reated the universe, chose the nation Israel to bear His Name, and sent His Son Jesus into the world to save the lost.

@@marcusonesimus3400 are you sure you do know that any jew or christian who can speak arabic refers to God as Allah?

May Allah grant him paradise.

@@munirahmadqalam-mal5927 So he's missing for some hours and you assume he's dead? 😅🤦😅

Assalamualaikum everyone I was extremely busy as i had an important work to do. Hence the I missed doing the timestamps for this one. Another brother has completed the Timestamps 👍🏻 PS: I've completed the timestamps on the recent video of Daniel Haqiqatou vs Muslim Feminist You can check that out جَزاكَ اللهُ خَـيْراً ❤️

@@asadullahsaaid3794 JazakAllahu khairann,

@Faith Eternal its a halal Muslim joke, akhi. I know what he meant :)

All the best read with an open mind and open heart. Good luck

If you have one now, burn it quickly and replace it with the Bible. Better to burn a wicked book than to have your soul burn in hell.

​@@marcusonesimus3400 hhhh poor one what a petty

​@@marcusonesimus3400lol truth hurts

@Can a swallow swallow? Even that one doesn't go into the linguistics, although it contains a wealth of good information alhamdulillah

I feel like Nouman Ali Khan would do amazing job at that if he worked on a translation. *For Example:* When Allah kicks Satan out of paradise, Satan says to Allah: "…فبما أغوويتني” which is translated as “Because You left me to go astray…” and then Satan makes a promise to mislead the people. But the word "غوا" from “أغوويتني” means that the person was tempted/seduced/enticed into doing something wrong. So it adds another dimension: Satan is saying that Allah set him up to fail. He’s basically accusing Allah of entrapment. He’s implicitly saying: “You knew this was gonna happen all along - yet You allowed everything to be setup in a way that would make me commit the sin.” Does that ring a bell? It’s because it sounds like Atheist logic. And it’s amazing how Allah captures the entire attitude in just three Arabic words.

If u really want to learn first fear Allah then the blessings starts .

Before Muhammad died in AD 632, he got the complete revelation of Quran, right? He was illiterate. Still he ensured that the Quran verses were recorded with the help of his companions (sahabis). Those ayaths were recorded on plain stones, camel bones, animal skin and palm tree leaves according to Islamic history! That was the very FIRST QURAN! THE ORIGINAL QURAN! THE REFERENCE QURAN WHICH SHOULD LAST FOREVER! THE VERY QURAN ALLAH PROMISED TO PRESERVE AND PROTECT FOREVER! NOW THE QUESTION IS: WHERE IS THAT ORIGINAL REFERENCE QURAN AS ON TODAY? WHERE IS THAT QURAN PROTECTED AND PRESERVED BY ALLAH HIMSELF AS ON TODAY? IF IT EXISTS TODAY , YES IT IS A MIRACLE AS MUSLIMS CLAIM! IF NOT, ISLAM SIMPLY COLLAPSES! You agree, Paul? However what is the real truth? 1. Most probably that Original Reference Quran recorded by the Islamic prophet was included in the Quran portions destroyed by fire on orders of Caliph Uthman. If so that Original Reference Quran is lost forever! 2. What about the present Quran available with us? a. First post Islamic prophet Quran was made after his death in AD 632. Caliph Abu Bakr was forced to compile the first post Islamic prophet Quran because of sudden death of many Quran memorizers in the subsequent wars. Did Allah or prophet commanded him to do the compilation of Quran? No, never! In fact Allah himself promised to preserve and protect his Quran forever! However sudden loss of so many Quran memorizers forced Caliph Abu Bakr to take his own decision, without seeking advice from Allah or Muhammad! That is how the Abu Bar Quran came into existence! Most Muslims will get shocked that this First Quran had no involvement of Allah or prophet! b. Thus Abu Bakr appointed a young man, Zyad Ibn Tabith, who was previously the scribe of the Islamic prophet before his death. Zyad Ibn Tabith was obviously reluctant to undertake the job, which was not commanded by Allah or prophet. However he had no other choice, but to obey the orders of the king. c. Why did Caliph Abu Baker ordered the compilation of Quran, which was not commanded by Allah or prophet when Allah himself promised to protect his Quran? Means, Abu Baker had no faith in Allah's words? And he compiled a Quran with the help of above Zyed Ibn Tabit. Obviously an unauthorized Quran! However even this unauthorized Quran was not complete! One ayath was missing in it for so many years! No one could identify or realize or point out the grave mistake! Finally Zyed Ibn Tabit while revising the Abu Baker Quran, on orders of Caliph Uthman, remembered about the grave mistake and added the ayath in the Revised Uthman's Quran! And Caliph Uthman ordered the destruction of all other Quran materials!!! d. Even the Revised Uthman's Quran had its own problems. Two solid Surahs were missing in it and also one ayath on stoning of adulterous women and verse of suckling the breast by adult men! e. Abdullah ibn Masʽood was one of the four most prominent Quran teachers appointed by Islamic prophet. He totally disapproved the Revised Uthman's Quran too! Then, what credibility Revised Uthman's Quran got ? f. Now Muslims use many different ARABIC QURANS! See the links below please. 1. Display of 26 versions of Arabic Quran @ Hyde Park , London ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EsgphL9lGcc.html 2. Why are there over 30 different Arabic Qur’ans? - Quranic Corrections Ep. 3 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EpsnXMZ5lEE.html g. Here is a solid example for totally different Arabic Qurans. FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM HAFS sihraani ... two works of magic ... 28:48 FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM WARSH saahiraani ... two magicians ... 28:48 Obviously "two works of magic" FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM HAFS cannot be exactly equal to "two magicians" FROM THE QUR'AN ACCORDING TO IMAM WARSH. Both cannot be true! When that is the ground reality, many Muslim brethren still hold on to the belief that ""Allah sent the Final Testament, the Qur'an, and unlike the previous books, has never been changed.""

@@yahya2925 Your information is very interesting but I don't quite understand what you mean by " the linguistic miracle of the Quranic Arabic..." I've never read any Quran although I'm learning slowly about Islam. I'm a Christian believer. Thanks and peace of God to you... from Florida

Asalamu alaikum. I'm still in Mississauga, at Anatolia Masjid :) we can meet insha Allah.

that book is exactly what I need!!! A few years ago I was motivated to learn the Arabic for Quran and that was my exact method...I thought I should just learn the words in the Quran instead of the whole arabic language. So I found a list of commonly repeated words in the Qu'ran and printed them off. But doing it all myself was a bit too overwhelming for me and although i stuck with it for a week, i ended up giving up. Definitely going to get this book and learn those 2000 root words!

@@mrm1712 alhamdullilah, that is good news brother, we are on the same goal, 👍inshaAllah we will achieve our goal. 👍

'Smarts' do not gain one admittance into heaven. Humility is more important. The Bible says, 'Do not be wise in your own estimation.' It also says that 'the foolishness of God is wiser than men.'

Islam ideology with death penalty for apostasy you a re fascist

he is not the author. he is the translator.

@@opheliaforgetmenots Allah allows sxx with 5y olds ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-OfYbUsNMlng.html

Islam ideology with death penalty for apostasy you are a fascist

Toronto is in desperate trouble because (a) the rich have become so greedy, and (b) so many of its people have rejected the way of Christ to serve 'other gods'. Notable among those 'other gods' is the abstract theory which muhammad concocted to replace the God of Israel-----------as though that were actually possible. Yes, Ishmael the bastard son persecuted Isaac the legitimate son, and not much has changed since.

You should have more doubts. Expand those doubts until you discover Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. After that you will have no good reason to doubt, because He is not just a messenger. He is the MESSAGE itself. Paul betrayed Christ and is now trying desperately to justify himself.. But I don't believe that he really became a Christian. His own account leads me to believe that he was searching for 'religious experiences'. Who knows how this adventure will turn out?

Glad you enjoyed it!

I've never read the Quran and I only know the English language. So do you recommend this Quran by Dr. Mustafa ?

@@johnbrzykcy3076 I do :)

@@dr.mustafakhattab1322 Sir should I study in Al Azhar Or Madinah University.. What do you recommend?

@@dr.mustafakhattab1322 Hahaha... okay. By the way, I'm a Christian believer but I do try to respect those who follow Islam. Even though we have different theological worldviews, we all need to be respectful and open-minded because only God is All-Knowing. Right? Peace of God be with you... from Florida

@@kissmybeard2378 both are good, check the requirements for both to see which one will most likely accept you. You can also study at Al-Azhar online.

Glad you enjoyed it!

...oh yesssss..the original H'Airybic

@@anarchorepublican5954 Meanwhile, theres not even a single original Hebrew manuscript of Torah and original Aramaic manuscript of Gospel that can be carbon dated back to the time of Moses and Jesus. Alhamdulillah Quran is still preserved in Arabic and the original manuscript can be carbon dated back to the time of Prophet Muhammad.

@@Emsyaz ...📜Indeed?..congratulations...A historical treasure to be sure ... no wonder you boast..it is justified...I would love to lay me eyes upon it...what Feast?..and do you know of the azure "blue Quran?" written in gold... But.... I still fail to understand how such excellent and pure, original H'airybic Quran Manuscript evidence, can in any way provide spiritual sustenance to any poor soul who cannot speak he original H'Ariybic...dialect of the Prophet(pbuh)... as the Quran can only be truly understood in the Original H'Airybic...quite unlike any other language on the planet...rather odd..considering... ...as Dr. Khattab here so painfully explains in detail.... apparently 💯accurate translation is not possible, with the Quran...so in he's work he employs a more sociological approach..in his translation work ...apparently this sheikh senses "the Clear sense and spirit of the age" and clearly translates accordingly...the "Clear Quran"-is Clear like see thru Islamic 7up soda is "Clear'..lite-ly sweetened for western tastes and sensitive secular ears...his rendering of Sura al-Nisa 34(Q 4:34) is a fine example....."discipline her (lightly)" ...of such transparent and "Clear" Translation... Do you speak The "original H'Airybic?"...is it not the language of Adam?

@Faith Eternal ...o' indeed ...For behold my "disease within" stems from questions regarding Islam ..and these disease ridden doubts stem from my kafiryun ignorance of the Original H"Airybic... do you have knowledge of Arabic?... For instance what does يَدَيۡهِ {"yadayh"] mean?...

Glad you enjoyed it

Wa alaykumu s-salam

As those stories of Jesus came from late gospels they are more probably legendary, as confirmed in a recent interview with Bart Ehrman.

Many thanks khan!

Yup. Same Learn Islam, Quran plus English ...

Wa alaykumu s-salam

@Faith Eternal ameen

Even wicked men may produce remarkable Art. Symmetry is not proof of legitimate spiritual authority. We know that muhammad was either woefully ignorant of sacred history or distorted it to blasphemous ends. In fact one story gos that muhammad was unsure of the origin of his visions, whether they were from the heavenly realm or the demonic realm, but Khadija persuaded him of their legitimacy. he should have retained his doubts.

@@marcusonesimus3400 so how did he make a symmetrical book while never claiming it? Nor did any scholars claim that because they didn’t notice it until we had computers.

@@DarioHaruni Mysterious mathematical patterns have been detected in the Bible. So if you have different texts to which scholars ascribe a similar attributes, yet which contradict each other in essentials, is that attribute ther deciding factor in choosing between them? Obviously not. The content and meaning are deciding factors. If you have read the Old Testament account of Israel's exodus from Egypt, you will know that the pagan Egyptian magicians were able to match some of Moses' miracles, but not all. The devil has real spiitual power, albeit 'stolen' power, for only God has true creative power. It is not for nothing that witchcraft, spiritism, and mediumship were forbidden to the Israelites, although the disobedient among them did indulge in these evils, like their neighbors. So it is possible to imagine a counterfeit text from the demonic realm which MIMICS certain features of the Word of God, yet is clearly not rom God because it changes Biblical doctrine or alters Biblical facts. This is how reports of 'supernatural' inspiration in anti-Biblical texts ought to be regarded. Then there is the question of what human Art can achieve. It is sometimes remarkable to see how by training, experience, and intuition a master of musical composition can create a work perfectly proportioned to the analyst or theoretician; yet the composer himself was not fully aware why he wrote what he did. This creative process remains within the bounds of Nature. Well, not necessarily. Some Christian composers did pray for guidance, or had some awareness that God was helping them generate ideas.