Israelis: Shouldn't you give Palestinians citizenship? 

The land of Israel belongs to the Jewish people, historically,religiously and legally. Settlements are the reclamation of our ancestral homeland as the indegenous people of the land.

@@Linda43 Very respectfully Ms Steckel.. Does God give you the right to impose land and poltical restrictions on the people residing in the territory that 'god gave to you via the bible'? Is a Palestinian different than a jew? should he/she be treated differently? Does he/have the same political rights as you?

@@danrashed Two million Arabs chose Israeli citizenship for its political and social freedoms. The rest are permanent residents who have the same rights except for voting. If you are looking at political restrictions, look at the PA and Hamas. They both exploit and oppress their "citizens "

@@danrashed I'm afraid it's all very sad. They keep demanding a state of their own, rather than citizenship of Israel, and then turn their noses up whenever it is offered.

The folks that tried and keep trying to annihilate the jewish people shouldnt live in a jewish state. 22 arab states are available.

Yes it is Being sarcastic but kinda is in a way

Its actually a beehive. there is also alot of honey...

I dont know about (revelation 2:9)- do you have any suggestions of your own? As for (Ezekiel 36:5) I speaks his language and can explain you his words: all the nations that took the land of the lord from Israel, and did it only to disgrace Israel, not because they realy wanted it for themself, would be disgraced themself foriously by god. personally, I think the people who started to call themself palestinians at 1964, to form a new and uniqe nationality tied specifically to this land, 16 years after opening a war aimed to divide this land between Egypt Lebanon and syria, matching very well to the description of people who wans this land only to disgrace Israel. Of course I am talking about the people who led the palestinian ethos, the common arabs who followed them are their victims who pays the price.

@Isaiah israel do you even knows how many blood dirties the Interpretation you just gave to (revelation 2:9)? you need to be realy clueless to get it out of darkest boxes of history. you can belive whatever you want- but if you dont like the ppl in the land, you better just reject the whole story about jews being chosen, rather than atealling their story and than call them imposters- here is a phrase inspired by the story of Naboth- "whould you both murder and inherite?" P.S. In fact they did "went into bondage all around the globe", so how did you thought to make this into a point?

@Isaiah israel I already told you... believe whatever you want- no one can even prove you that the world wasn't created today with all the data of fake history in our minds. but to me your theories seems unlikely and unrespectful and also the base of crimes that just like all history, you can deny if you dumb enough.

If you want shocking go see what the Palestinians think about living next to Jews

@@theendurance yea i'll come to your house and eat in your fridge...we will see what you think of me.

@@Lior255 fear God

@@Mercurystars4202 Define "given the opportunity" and define "Israel doesn't want to" please.

@@theendurance I think that we have to look at the situations from both sides..

You can do that to MOST zionist's arguement. You'll start to notice a pattern where they judge people in a higher standard that they themselves could never attain. God's "chosen people" i guess.

@@johnjowari7128 If anything, it's the other way around. And yes, everywhere in the world living somewhere doesn't make it your country. For that, you need citizenship. I can't simply buy a plain ticket to Canada, buy a house and settle there. I need to apply for citizenship in order to be able to do that. Same goes for Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Britain, and, of course, the USA.

@@acemcjack Ridiculous false equivalence, the Palestinians didn't buy a plane ticket anywhere. They're not migrants to their own homes, their lack of statehood has been decided for them. Your whole comment can be applied to the zoinists and ironically supports Palestine. "Buy a house and settle there".. you mean like in the Westbank?

Military superiority. That's how it's been throughout history. Conquer or be conquered. Nobody has the inherent right to any piece of land.

@@hillal8105 You know what else history is full of? Slavery. When are we going to learn that just because something happens a lot does not make it "natural", and something being "natural" doesn't make it right

I absolutely wonder which version of history does Israel teach their children in school

Jews were there way before Arabs though historically

@@ryanlaci14 and they welcomed Jews just fine when they first migrated into the land due to holocaust. What's interesting is that even some Israeli Jews themselves do believe that the Palestinians today might actually be ancient Israelites who converted into Islam (ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-SOEHnE0ngys.html&lc=Ugw2Y64h9tfxcSo7zDF4AaABAg.9NbiSKwS91F9NjnKcccpLr). This means that historically, the Palestinians have as much claim to the land. Yes, this is debatable, but it also means that *only* Jews of ancient Israeli descendants can live in the Palestinian lands, no? However, in reality, it seems that anyone who is a Jew (even though they might just converted yesterday), regardless of their heritage (since Israel citizenship doesn't require DNA test), are deemed more worthy of staying in the land compared to Palestinians who've been living there for generations. I think that's quite unfair. If you just wanna come and live there, do so. They already welcomed you in the first place. I don't think it's necessary to build a State and remove people who are already there, restrict their access of water, freedom of movement, steal their homes, and destabilize their economy. Now that's apartheid.

@@annisahayatunnufus8603 I hope you’re joking when you say they « welcomed jews » after 1929 Hebron Massacre, all the terrorist attacks even before the creation of Israel state. Not mentioning that they launched a war with all the border arab countries and the mufti of Jerusalem worked with Hitler, palestinians were in a SS division called Handschar. And btw the Palestinians is a pure invention from the Romans, these people belong to Jordan and never had control on their land historically

@@ryanlaci14 Oh apologies, I got the timing mixed up and I meant the early Aliyahs which was obviously far before holocaust happened. Hebrom Massacre happened after Balfour Declaration, no? There is also the march of Jewish nationalist as well that increased the tension. Everything else was a snowball from the creation of State of Israel. Regarding which one was there first, I was referring far way back to ancient times of Israelites and Canaanites. My opinion is firm in that simply residing would be fine, but not creating a State nor displacing the previous population.

The egyptian border is closed hermetically.

Hamas

EGYBT OF COURSE. THEIR BORDERES ARE ALWAYS CLOSED BUT FOR FOREIGN PEOPLE. SUCH A SHAME

Hamas. Any deny of that would be pure delusion.

@@debateme8955 how did hamas come to be? Who supported them?

Why wouldnt they want to give citizenship to a group that shouts day and night it will annihilate them ? I really dont get it. Annihilate just means giving baklawa and kissing in their language..... right?

@@dogbert52 I love the whole "us vs them" belief you and your whole gang harbor. 'Tis healthy. #buildthewall. its hilarious the group who is deciding whether to give citizenship or not illegally took a place, destroyed its land and its people and restrict its people behind fences like caged animals, then if the animal shouts they call the animal an extreme terrorist. funny people with diseased hearts. "the chosen ones" the whole manifest destiny crap that was used as a justification to slaughter over 99% of the Native American population of North America. same shit different times.

@@snekjuce i am sure mass voting for genicidal jihadonazi hamas was just an "oopsie" :)

@@snekjuce 84% of “Palestinians” want Sharia law. Could you imagine if they became the majority?

@@GideonDavis Ah yes, oppressing people because you don't like their opinions. I wonder where that happened before.

Ah, they couldn't even name a Palestinian leader from 70 years ago much less traces roots to anyone. Go see that video on this channel.

@@stud6414 Because the young people there were displaced and fought to return and had many wars My grandparents got kicked out in 1948 and so I'm not concerned with the internal politics there anymore. For example, if I want to survive as a refugee I learn the politics of the country Im in You people are so funny like you banish and expel and kill and displace all the Palestinians then you say wow they're not developed and as educated as us

@@___________2204 we didn't expelled or killed we won the wars and therefore y'all had to leave just like every other war stop blaming everything on us we won you lost.

@@naturalbreed3745 lol You are Very Uneducated person The age of war is no more That way according to UN and international laws Isreal took illegal lands after World wars World made international laws Agreements which don't allow any country to Conquer other lands or country that's WHY you don't see nations and kings going killings and Taking lands etc( few still do that directly or indirectly like Isreal,China,US) this world views is less than 100 years old Which helped the world for development and Co Exist

@@deathnote4171 we need to still do it in order to survive you don't need do be educated about what happens in real world.

@TheLavlishus what country bases citizenship based off of religious beliefs? Even the Islamic countries provide citizenship to indivuals working and living there.

@@suhailrahman7369 that's not the point, we fought for this country after WW2 and won it fair and square and for peace we gave back some land back and when you give some land back they want more and more,and someone need to step into the plate, giving them citizens won't solve the problem it will just create war down the line.

@@naturalbreed3745 invading and colonizing is not “winning fair and square”

@@betrayal6231 we returned to our homeland therefore we did not invaded nor colonized.

@@naturalbreed3745i am a Coptic from Egypt, you are telling me I can walk into some Arab’s house and take their home and it would be okay because the Arabs took over my country over a thousand years ago?? I believe we are in the same boat actually and you are the ones who are acting against gods wishes by enslaving a people and taking their land. The actions of our forefathers are not the actions of us unless you make it like that which is what Israel and the IDF is doing to the people of Gaza. Not to mention my Christian brothers and sisters that live in Palestine that are directly affected by Israel’s hate

@FastFox Basel Qawasmi 0 proof? Not the tons of archeological evidence? The historical records? The fact that the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem (who helped Hitler) admitted that Israel was the land of the Israelites. Zero evidence really? You might wanna read a book.

Forget religion and live as a human

@@cl9615 Modern Israelis has nothing to do with the ancient Jews.

@@docorwhatever2168 Except for their lineage!! LOL.

How is suggesting they have their own country not wanting peace? Most Palestinians would never agree to become Israelis.

@@anna-jh7zy Would the settlers in the Westbank agree to become Palestinian citizens?

Consider that he could easily be cherry-picking who we see in these interviews

@@rolandboerhof9391 of course not, but how is that not beside the point?

@@Dannelrandal in order to assume that, we would need statistics or at least similar interviews that show another picture. My experience in Israel shows this to be pretty accurate.

You only hear that as an argument from Israel.

@@Botie2 that's just false, both sides use that argument and both sides are natives to that slither of land.

@@Potjenjks2988 If we will speak truth... Both are not so natives... Jews conquered it, then Rome conquered Jews and forced them to leave after rebellion. Than Arabs conquered it, with significant enforcement of assimilation. Then Turkey... But even than At the end of 1800 only fraction of Jews AND Arabs lived there. Both are immigrants. But as there was no country existing there at the time, Arabs cannot say anything after land owner decision.

@@dmitrizaslavski8480 that is why I'll never understand all this "I came first" thing

@@diegoyuiop My issue there is that jews bought the land from Arabs, built cities etc. The only Jewish wish was to have there country with Jewish majority. So asked to select land where they are majority in Palestine and found there Israel. Arabs did not like it and in 1948 started a war. Some Arabs left Israeli territory as requested LAN, so they would be able to eradicate those zionists. Some made active efforts to make it happen. And both of those groups are considered traitor by Israel and not allowed to return. The people who stayed there are still able to live in Israel as full fledged citizens unlike what jews had in all Muslim countries. Then there is hamas who has only one goal - destruction of Israel and the world still supporting it despite every bad thing that Palestinians did to Jews just because idea of loosing Muslim control is unacceptable.... Yeah, I write under effect of current incident...

Israel is a Jewish state in the same way Armenia is an Armenian state, Ireland is an Irish state, Denmark is Danish state, etc. All countries have their own minorities and the ethnic identity of the state doesn't change (and shouldn't change) the rights of the minorities, who should be equal.

@@ForeverRepublic Israeli isn’t an ethnic group it’s just a group of European expats and their children occupying land that has been Arab for millennia.

@@thetigerking2613 See you're just an antisemite.

@@notcosmiclobsternoooo118 No I’m not, most Jews don’t live in Israel.

@@thetigerking2613 Funny since their DNA says otherwise...

How are things in Iran?

@@solvingpolitics3172 actually, despite the sanctions, that we can not easily have economical relationship with other countries, everything is ok, conditions are not so bad that it is said in news networks, it's hard, but we do not suffer from the lack of something, overall, it is just OK

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet why i can not reply on him?, yes it is censored in iran, but i have my vpn, i use that.

@@solvingpolitics3172 and i forgot to mention that US doesn't allow iran to import vaccine, but we are trying to buy from other countries like russia, china and ..., actually we have 3 or 4 vaccines that are developing in iran, up to this day those vaccines showed good results on humans, our scientists believe that we can have a good vaccine around 5 or 6 month later to use on our citizens, and at the end i just wanna say something about Blood packages with AIDS that france give it to iran some years ago, i think about 7 or 8 years ago, those packages effected many iranian people, even if we could buy vaccines from countries like usa, france, germany and ..., we do not, they are not trustworthy

@Masmethetime HuluLoulou ha?, what are you talking about?, which people?.

Giving up on the claim does not mean it cannot be revived as part of a solution, given that the PLO rejected everything ever offered. Be careful what you wish for though as a large state can be more difficult to manage than a smaller one. The problem is the Jordan valley which is seen as Israel's best defensive border to the East, as well as Jordan's best to the west. It is the topography which makes it so.

Just for your knowledge. 1. The area pf the kingdom of Jordan was given to them by the British as well and about the same time that Israel was given its small area of Israel. It was a token of gratitude for the help of both of them to the British in WW1. 2. In the six days war Israel didn't fight the PA. They did it against the Jordanians who ruled there and Joined the war with Egypt and Syria. The PA didn't demand independence from the Jordanians for 19 years. Why didn't they do it then? Why are they demanding it from Israel?

Because they don't have liberalism and western countries while exploiting these values for jihad in Europe and America, but they take their time and plan their moves, like taking over U.N.councils and governments and carefully twisting the stories for your cause. But Jews are suspicious enough to confront this threat ahead, while slowly disconnecting from the west and take side by the Shia/Sunni conflict which is much much bigger, and much less covered on media.

Yeah and you know everything. Fucking idiot.

It's not a matter of the 2 state solution being dead...the reality is, that there are currently 2 states; Israel, and the fractured Palestinian ones (which comprise of the Occupied Palestinian Territories). Furthermore, it's clear that this 2 state reality is not working. The only solutions are to grant Palestinians a sovereign territory, or to annex all the OPT into Israel. Chances of either happening are very narrow.

Vv

@@az6802 They were given sovereign territory by the British - it is called Jordan.

Only it wasn't a country called palestine , It was a name used by the british mandate (based on history it was called after the philistines which in Hebrew their names come from the wors "polshim" or invaders , and they were from the islands surrounding Greece of today ) only after 67 that the arab leadership decided to invent the term palestinians and the connection to the arabs of the region with the philistines .

@@DickTator6969 i thought you should knew before establishment of Israel all the jews migrated to palestine need to have the immigration pass by Palestine government. Its in the israel archive can easily search... (which clearly stated in the name of god, i will be loyal to the government of Palestine). Before the massive migration, more than 90% of the people in the palestine are muslims

@@pendiam7617 There was no "Palestine government", it was the British government and the ottoman government before that

You can't colonize your own homeland.

@@fafolaw hi. It has been called Palestine. Where palestinian lived. But the ruler are colonizer like the ottoman and British. Just during ottoman empire, the whole arab is under the rule of ottoman but during british, only Palestine is not liberated. At the time, Palestinian people of different religion coexisted together. But the jews (from europe if i wasn't mistaken) make an agreement with the colonizer british to gain Palestine for only jews. That's when oppression of the palestinians begin.

No, that's survivalism. Plain and simple.

@@acemcjack The Boers in South Africa felt the same, if the Native Africans were given rights, they would be in danger. It's pure racism.

@@NoMoreMeNoMoreBelief The Boers had where to return to. Jews don't.

People around the world don't have the history of persecution that the Jews have, there are 20+ Arab countries, and nobody questions their right to be Arab, but Jews, who are a minority in every single country in the world, can't have one country so they can defend themselves?

every country on earth is like that especially when the majority gonna be a minority.

If you’re neutral you slide with the oppressor

it was a minor experiment overseen by the british during the first half of the 20th century, when they took over governing palestine from the turks. after WWII and the holocaust the formation of israel was the easiest course of action for the West to commit to.

@@flacko92 I was only neutral cz I didn't know what the whole situation was but after the past week, I'm definitely not anymore. Praying for Palestine🇦🇪

@@serena5249 really glad to hear that❤️🙌

If you're being exterminated, you're going to take that land regardless of whether you have the right or not, also, the Jews were the ones who accepted the partition plan, the Arabs didn't and started the wars

Israel is a religious ethnostate; as long as the Zionist Israeli government stands, they won't accept any solution.

the only side trying to make it a religious war is the state of Israel trying to claim all the land as jewish. that is not true. the land is jewish, muslim, christian, roman, british, ottoman and most recently it was palestinian. you dont go anywhere around the world and say this land is mine 3000 years ago! they were exiled and never even fought back to the roman empire. how is this our fault we have been here for hundreds of years

Funny thing, they are secular, and many are atheists.

@@___________2204 You're making it sound as if Jews have only just arrived and are asking for their land back. Dude, the state of Israel was created over 70 years ago, after a majority of the UN voted in favor of the creation of a Jewish state in Israel. You can argue whether it is just of fair or legal or whatnot for as long as you like, but it won't change the fact that Israel is here and its' here to stay. We may negotiate on where the borders of Israel start and end, but what's done is done. As a secular Israeli citizen of Jewish descent, I couldn't care less about religion. I'm very much in favor of separating between religion and state. As you probably no, there are about 2 million Arabs living in Israel, who have full citizenship (That isn't to say there is zero racism, but strictly speaking, they have all the rights by law as any Jewish citizen). The Arabs who live in the West Bank and Gaza, who identify as Palestinian have only begun identifying themselves as such since 1964 (I, for one, don't dispute their right to self Identify themselves as such). Nationally speaking, they do not and will never see themselves as Israeli, and while a significant portion of Israeli Arabs also choose to identify themselves as Palestinian (in part out of solidarity with the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza, who they're related to ethnically), as long as they don't give up their Israeli passport and ID card, they are within their right to do so, and Israel can't and won't do anything about that. So the bottom line is, that debating who was here first, and who has the better claim for the land is a very interesting academic debate, but you cannot undo the creation of Israel. If you wish to solve the problem you need to compromise and realize that if you want to play an "All or nothing" game with Israel, then in the end you'll get nothing.

@@acemcjack This is nonsense. Israel's current policy makes zero sense. The Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank aren't going anywhere, the settlement policy is intended to fragment the Palestinian territories and make it that much more difficult for a Palestinian state to exist. Like South Africa, the world will eventually decide enough is enough, and that the apartheid has to end. Israel can work towards a solution now, or have a solution imposed on them in the future, and they probably won't like it very much.

100%

Ar abia is in ar ab hands.

@Sylvie Olin it was Palestine but occupied by israel

there is only ONE Jewish country in this planet. and 22 Arab countries. this conflict cant be solve because of the Palestinian pride

actually yes

What is peace in your culture? What does it mean? Honestly curious

@عبد الرحمن خريسات Your an idiot.

@rabbi fried he’s just a troll, problably far right from America, the Christian Right in America believe that if only Jews are in the holy land (no Christians or Muslims) then Jesus will come down and turn all the Jews into Christians lmao like wtf

@rabbi fried not trying to be hostile, i’m totally uninvolved geographically so please consider this a genuine question: wasn’t the palestinians there first? and then jews invaded the place because it’s their expectation of a safe place where they can rest from being persecuted, especially after WWII? and that’s how the conflict started, roughly? and another thing, you sent the link to the video, but isn’t it very easy (in comparison) to put a smiling face when being in the position of the stronger one? i hope you are honest and don’t get offended because where i live (germany) it’s kind of hard to get honest opinions, because most people are really careful to say anything criticising towards jews, for obvious reasons. best regards

@rabbi fried i’ll watch it when i have the time but i‘d love an answer to some of my questions if possible thanks for the compliment btw

@Starhopper Gaza is not a state, and Jordan is not going to give them citizenship, nor will they move to Jordan. The responsibility of them belongs to Israel as long as we control the land they live in. We can’t force them to leave. They are going to live in the land of Israel. That’s just reality. Either we give them citizenship and become a binational state, or we give them another state. Otherwise it is apartheid...

@@stf502 These lunatics talking about Jordan or Egypt live in an alternate reality. I guess it's the way in which they try to assimilate that they have been played really good by the arabs 😂

@@stf502 Nonsense. Israel doesn't owe them anything. (And their pop can be modified)

@@starhopper408 listen to yourself, “they’re population can be modified”.....that’s ridiculous. They are a pain and the cause much of the problems here but we have to fix it for our own good. They aren’t going anywhere, and if we want Judea and Samaria as part of the state we have to recognize that. personally, I don’t at the cost of a Jewish state but that’s just me......

@@stf502 The problem is that the israelis counted that 5 million yank-jus like the inc3l commenting here were going to move to Israel. Big mistake. Instead, they have 5 million Palestinians. That some of them talk about Jordan or Egypt shows that they know they were played by the arabs.

How so?

That was literally one person. Are some Jews immigrants? Sure. Both my grandparents from my mother's side were born in Israel, and so was she. Even my mom's grandfather was born in Israel.

acemcjack your grand parents were born in Palestine

Good. No one wants you.

@Starhopper He's from Alaska btw

Wry happy to hear that. We don’t want them

They would as a step to destroy Israel. That's the problem

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet lol whats with all the fabricated lies dude chill out. Your medication is clearly not working, you're absolutely sick I pity you.

Do you live in Israel. Have you been?

What is the culture and history of the Palestinians before 1964? Who were their leaders? What type of government did they have? In what way were they different culturally from Syrians, Jordanians, Egyptians, Lebanese etc.?

@@acemcjack according to your thought, neither Kurdish, for example, are a national identity, but Iranians living in Turkey and Arab countries. They have their own Arabic variety and their local traditions. It's very hard finding a very well detailed national feeling in Arabic world because of the homogeny by the islamic caliphate, which affected mostly semitic people living in the area: Kurds and Iranians, for example, can't be considered arabic nations at all. And if Palestinians were just "immigrants" by other arabic countries (I can't understand they can't be descendants of Jews and other ancient peoples who just converted to christianity/islam and were "arabised"), in 1900 they were over 90% of the population and in 1948, before the war and after the strength of Jews' immigration, still remained 75% of the total population, I think that's their land first. What? Jews want a country for themselves? There's a region in Russia made just for them, here where they can go. Anyway, it's all ONU fault. If the resolution would have been fair, we wouldn't be in this situation today

Everyone's racist, that's just how it is, especially in a place like Israel where Arabs and Jews have been clashing for almost a century now. By the way, Palestinian is an identity, but the Palestinians did take that identity on themselves , before 1948 the people of Palestine were referred to as "Palestinian Arabs" and "Palestinian Jews" by other countries, but the people living in Palestine just referred to each other as Jews or Arabs. Since 1964 the Palestinians have changed their identity from "Arabs" to "Palestinians", to show that they are indigenous to the land.

"A yahood that isnt suicidal = racist"

You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it means.

@@Criticalmass96 what is palestine?

Palestine * there land

@rabbi fried Well Malcolm X and Nelson Mandela were allies of the palestinians

@rabbi fried who cares about personal life they are politicians. It's the message.

@rabbi fried lol your shitty IDF propaganda is using hieroglyphics from Assassins Creed origins.

@@Mouqawem And given the fact Malcoln X was populist and racist and you excluded one of the most known and great anti-racist figure among blacks, I can see where your views lie. You just forgot to mention Farrakham

@@dmitrizaslavski8480 If Malcolm X was racist for wanting to make a differentcountry with blacks only then jews from around the world are racist for saying they need a Jewish state.

Exactly

@@yacovezra2924 Wallah god will destroy it At least because you dont keep the torah it would be destroyed 🤣

@@Nashmi-JO Muslims have got nothing to do with Judaism. Stick to your false god, false prophet and false religion. Israel is prospering and Jews are hugely successful. Jews have won 200 plus Nobel Prizes. 57 Islamic nations are in the sewers of backwardness, dysfunction and ignorance because of falsehood.

@@yacovezra2924 Not all Islamic Countries are backward,Indonesia is a Muslim Country but it's economy is good and it's chill

@@lori8161Indonesia has a typical 3rd world economy based on oil/mineral exports and it serves as a cheap manufacturing base for household commodities. It is not a leader in science and technology nor does it have sound infrastructure nor world class universities nor cutting edge research and development nor renowned scientists...

also, the Jewish settlers in the west bank have been given citizenship and vote, crazy indeed

@@abdelrahmanr.rashad1018 You mean they are allowed to vote in the PA elections?

@@acemcjack good one

How many Jews live in Cairo ?

@@ef2718 Not that much. They all left because of Nasser. From what I know, there is still around a hundred in the whole country.

He spoke Hebrew with an Arabic accent so he was mostly likely raised in a Muslim country and speaks Arabic.

@@mzblonde2292 arab jews but they dont like it 🤣

You need to learn some history.

I wonder why his family left tunisia? Was it the food? The fashion? Lack of kiosks?

The Jews left Tunisia because they were persecuted by the local Arabs. Originally Jews are from Israel.

Because he actually lives next to the visitors from ara bia. She dosnt.

He was born in a majority Arab Muslim country. He knows how such a living arrangement is likely to end.

If you want to know how to deal with Arbz, you talk to people who know them.

@@dogbert52 Visitors from Arabia? HE just admitted that he came from an Arab country? Whereas there were Palestinians living in Akko before he arrived. So who is the visitor?

@@Thucydides1990 there were arabs. That came to visit israel since the arab invasion . Visitors from arabia :)

This is nonsense. Citizenship grants many things, and non-citizens often get welfare benefits. The reason is that we do not care for destitute people on the streets.

Citizenship also demands following rules. Taxes for example, or serving in army

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet lmao it wont be sharia law, its not a muslim country. People should ALWAYS seperate religion and state, they shouldn't go hand in hand.

Simple as that. The Palestinians have been playing chess for decades and the israelis were playing ping pong 😀

@@Linda43 Door to where? 😂 5 million people? 😂😂😂 Keep dreaming. I thought that the only " democracy" in the ME was not into ethnic cleansing 😂😂😂

@@matiasbrachini8741 They will leave voluntarily sooner or later. The very Arab countries that invented these people can now make room for them.

@@Linda43 Wow Linda, I feel I am hearing a white supremacist here. You sound like a white dude telling black people to go to Africa. Linda, my advice to you learn how to love others and respect them, stay away from radical ideologies.

@@Linda43 Land belongs to Jews by what, religion?

Sad?

@@sempextv9083 🤭

Well that is very true, why are you confused? It’s very clear, apart from their bluntness they have nothing else going for them as they are really quite ignorant to the past and not very clued on as to what is happening in the present and not very intelligent to understand much else or to have any compassion for other human beings, humans who just want to live freely and peacefully.... even a dog shows compassion to others 🤷🏻‍♀️

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet 👍

it's not the only thing - Israelis have credible facts and proof of their history; the only thing Arabs aka 1964 Palestinians have are their never-ending, conflicting and confusing narratives.

@rabbi fried I support integrating the Arabs of Judea and Samaria. I would rather fight them for 1,000 years than see 1 inch of our land turned into an Arab country. But I'm from the north. I grew up around Arabs all my life. If we live together in Akko I don't see why we can't in Nablus and Hebron. Yes, the Arabs in Judea and Samaria think they are "Palestinian" but if we were to annex tomorrow, their grandchildren will grow up learning Hebrew, go to university in Israel, and never drive through a single checkpoint - they will be Israelis. Look at the Golan Druze - every teenager in Majdal Shams speaks fluent Hebrew, many have Israeli citizenship, go to university in Haifa, marry Israeli Druze, etc. They don't care about Syria and don't think of themselves as Syrian (I'm speaking only of the younger generation, they are the future). Basically the intention of Israel should be this: Make all the Arabs Jews only up until the point of not converting them. They have a place in this country. And I don't support ethnically cleansing them, this is immoral in my mind. If being in the army taught me anything it's that most Arabs are regular people who just want to get on with life.

@@ForeverRepublic so you want palestinians to tear apart thete identity and become jewish ?!? it dosent work like that

Many of Kurds hate Republic if Turkey! Yesss they have problems with the state! But they're citizens and they have every right as much as me or any other RoT citizens. There are so many minority groups don't like their states in the world. Scottish people :\, Irish people already left, katalans in Spain, I don't need to remind you the Uyghurs in China and Chinese people in Malaysia. We can find so many. Are you going to say but Palestinians hate Israel a lot? What were you expecting? Although it can change with real equal rights. Then everyone wouldn't love Israel but everyone wouldn't hate it either. Man that is a basic human right in a global world. Leave your political view and empathize them.

@@HBKiran I watched a documentary about Palestine school kids singing and chanting death to Israel. They're kinda raised radical. How are the Israelis supposed to work with a generation that wants to kill them. Should they just put on their big boy pants and say ok, you can kill some of us, it's ok, we understand it's necessary for peace in the future? Palestine needs to stop teaching hate in its schools. They gotta stop being radical.

Lol true right.

...Israel does in fact want a 2 state solution. 97% of the OG lands were offered back in the Oslo Accords- Palestine said no.

They get their rights from the PA or Hamassholes. ... and the only solution the Palees are interested in is one that leads to no Israel.

@@alphonseb.931 Offered to be given away, not to be given back.

@@starhopper408 in the modern era you can't keep peopel without giving them complete citizenship. What is the status of PA? Is it a local body government within Israel? If yes then why its not part of Israel? And why Israel keep control them or hold their lands if they are not part of Israel? How Israel ruling people who doesn't elect its government?

@@yameenbin4883 None of it has ever been "Palee lands" and they aren't "keeping them". They are involved in certain areas per Oslo agreement, but it's not Israel officially, it's disputed territory , and they are managing the threa't the Arbz insist on posing. Not doing so is not an option. Unless/until formal sovereignty is applied, Israel doesn't owe them anything.

There is already a one state solution and it is called the nation state of the Jewish people, Israel.

You have it all worked out, except for one major obstacle...their charter which calls for the elimination of the State of Israel. They have rejected their own homeland for over 100 years, what makes you so sure, that they accept your offer. They have already rejected Ehud Baraks offer of 90% of their demands including East Jerusalem. They want it all, so quit imagining that they will be accepting any homeland soon.

This sounds a bit too biased to the Palestinian side tbh,I want a solution that is fair to both sides

I loved the part where you left out your "final solution". I am sure jewish folks would love a lecture about it from a foreigner.

finally an israeli who has a brain

Bingo.

And you should be given polish citizenship

In your mother's dreams 🤣🤣🤣

@@Nashmi-JO Polish huh.. 200,000 refugee Jews ( *because of the holocaust - how dare you say to them to return there* ) from Poland came to Israel. Our population is 9 million people. I'll help you with the math.... that's 2% of the Israeli population who are from Poland. Are you not embarrassed by your racism?

Albert, its not helpful. Foremost, Palestinian Arabs in East Jerusalem / Judea-Samaria, DO have old Jordanian passports because of history, but are not allowed citizenship by Jordan! You'll never achieve Hashemite Arab rulers to re-consider, so its a moot point. Fantasy. Secondly, they do not feel connected to Amman, they feel connected and at home.... in Jerusalem, and Judea-Samaria. That's their home. I'm not saying what the solution is, because there are none. But "sending them to Jordan" is not realistic and, in my view, is not reasonable.

You make it soud like all of our money is from US tax dollars. Not even close to the truth , and yes we are a democracy

@@MaccabiHaifaVideos if you are a Democracy then give citizenship and freedom of movement to the occupied territories.

@@jamaltotah7858 Nope We are democrqcy and we don't need to get citizenships for the ones who don't see themselves as Israelis

@@jamaltotah7858 Disputed territories.

Israel does far more for the U.S. than the U.S. does for Israel. Just the intel alone would cost the U.S. over 10 billion a year. That is why Israel has been Reffered to as being worth 5 CIA’s!

When was palestine founded?

@@dogbert52 Palestine was founded in 132 AD as “Syria Palaestina” but Palestinians lived in the land before that name even existed.

@@IslenoGutierrez realllllyyyy? You mean the roman province ? So they are romans? Why dont they live in italy??

@@dogbert52 No, they are not Romans. They were conquered by Romans. They are the indigenous people of the land that have lived in the land continuously since ancient times. They were conquered by Romans, Byzantines, Arabians, Ottomans, British and now Jews. These poor people can’t get a break!

@@IslenoGutierrez google says the jew ish kingdom was occupied by rome. Why do you keep lying?

Jews come from everywhere from the world including Brazil!

@@esperanzapascacio6694 Yes 😊

We love Baile Funk!!

@@zcohent Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*

@Starhopper That is why the PA exists, despite all its faults, so that it can look after the Palestinians under its jurisdiction.

I love when lebanonese speak about apartheid lol

I was unaware of the spectrum of Israeli political identity. Right-wing conservative Zionism is very unwelcoming to the idea of globalization in Israel. However, as an American I am taught in public curriculum that Israel is a diverse democracy. To play the coin on both sides is to be expected when dealing with Jews. Moreover, I support the State of Israel and the dissolution of Palestine as De Jure sovereignty is a mockery. Let us all come together, races, cultures-creeds and strum our mortal chords in harmony. #FreeGaza

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet and what do you have in mind instead? Deportation?

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet defeat who? You have already defeated the arabs in war. Now what are you going to do with the arab population? In their "indian reservoir"? Give them a bloody citizenship and equal rights. Oh but you can't do that... and you know why? Because of the silly UN.

@@gioq4702 interesting opinion. But in this "america" , the "native americans" came back 2000 years after colombus and tried to share the land , and were repeatedly attacked for that. I dont think the society of the various tribes in gaza judea and samaria can live close to people whome they consider sub human infidels. And i am not saying it because of dislike , the individual ar abs of those area might be lovely, but they are commited to their clans.

@@dogbert52 eh? 2000 years after Columbus will be in 3492. I believe that most of the hatred between jews and "palestinians" is to be addressed to the silly policy of the UN. On both sides, Israeli zionists and arab extremers, there are people "living off" the conflict. Among those type of people, you will never find the will for peace. The only solution is 1 (Jewish but secular and democratic) state.

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet then start by giving citizenship to the "Indians" in the occupied territories

Thanks for a useless comment

@@Whatever4867 17 people disagree with you ☺👋

@@leahbendavid5722 who are those?

@@Whatever4867 People who agree with me and not thee. ☺

@@leahbendavid5722 but who are they

not all and there's is about 7000000 Palestinians was kicked out and they can't enter

If you like the figure 700,000 as you say "were kicked out " and now 2 million of them are ISRAELI CITIZENS. You do the math. I wonder what a peace treaty would do for them when they trash their charters to annihilate the State of Israel.

@@VIP1G 70 years ago they ran away. Most of them passed away , as slaves in ar ab countries which refused to give them any human rights. Tragic.

@@dogbert52 thanks you for admitting that they was there

@שני ישראל keep shitting like your face

European Jews have been leaving because of Antisemitism. Now you have only the " others" to worry about in the future. 😉

The legal and honest immigrants yes but the illegal immigrants no unless they really prove that they deserve citizenship

@@lori8161 And if we want a christian ethnic state as you want a jewish ethnic state in Israel?

@@Hn-gz5iw No I want a SECULAR state

@ Hap Sle: Israel has always been the ancient ancestral homeland of Jewish people.

#fuckstine

I believe a Palestinian country should be established and peace and support between both countried

Lol, it is their land, why would they move to another country while they have their own. Double standard

@Sylvie Olin lol, use your google

@le le It is when you are cleansing the land of other ethnicities

Hahaha right.

It's so weird that she feels embarrassed to explicitly endorse a two-state solution, when that is the assumed final goal of the framework that all the parties to the Oslo Accord still give lip service to. Is it really that controversial in Israel to say that Palestinians should have their own independent state alongside Israel?

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet Is that how Britain should deal with Catholics in Northern Ireland - if one IRA offshoot sets off a bomb, invade again and kill all the Catholics? Is that the way that Turkey should deal with all the Kurds, or Morocco with the Sahrawi people? It's hard to see how either justice or mercy would be served in such a response. Whether Catholics in Northern Ireland, Kurds in Turkey, or Sahrawis in Western Sahara, not everyone is of the same mind about what to do with the Other. I think, if you've watched the videos on this channel, you'd see that not all Palestinians are of the same mind either. Yes, some Palestinians dream of a Palestine with no Jews. But also, some Israelis dream of an Israel with no Palestinians - you heard from some of them here in this very video. Does that mean that those Israelis, because they pose a threat to the Palestinian people, have forfeited their right to a country (whether one of their own, or alongside others)? Have forfeited their right to fully participate in their own governance, and the determination of their own society's present and future? There needs to be a better solution than mass murder or mass expulsion. I think every decent-hearted person can agree that mass murder and mass expulsion are unacceptable. Perhaps ongoing dialogue, changing minds, coming together on a mutually agreed solution, not overreacting to every splinter-group provocation, and building mutual respect and trust instead of hostility and fear on both sides, is the better way out?

@Achadsyodeahhcool Beamet So the conflict between Irish Catholics and Protestants is not merely a hundred years old, but over four hundred years old. Would it have made sense in 1990 for either the Unionists/Loyalists or Republicans/Nationalists to have said, "The majority of the other side will never change, and it's going to end up with one side having to eliminate the other"? Only eight years later, the Good Friday Agreement was signed. If you want to talk about atrocities: 1990 was coincidentally the year that proxy bombings were revived by the IRA. That's where militants would kidnap someone (usually someone connected with the RUC or the British Army in some way, however tenuously) and force them to drive a vehicle full of explosives at some target, often by threatening their families. Also, in 1998, about two months after the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, a "Real IRA" bombing killed 29 civilians, many of them children, in Omagh. The British government did not scrap the agreement. Can you imagine that? My point being, this is not the only situation where two intensely hostile groups living in the same place, both heavily armed, neither greatly outnumbering the other, not only using but celebrating the violence they inflict on the other side, equating violence with strength, and using violence to keep their own side ideologically in line, have faced the prospect of neverending war. Another way is possible.

@Isaiah israel Well the revelation 2:9 is deep. But that doesn’t pertain to all Jews. it pertains to some Jews, like some in the The Israeli government and those who embrace Satanic worship

The Jewish people chose to accept the Holy Torah at Sinai and follow its laws.

@@Linda43 What about the ones born Jewishs but do not believe in God?

@@maxbe2702 Those Jews are awesome

@gamboni100 That's good

@gamboni100 It makes them more Secular

@Starhopper First of all this is no longer your land. It was yours three thousand years ago, in the same time Iraq was persian land. But theee are both outdated history.

@@عمرالمختار-ث2م If you just take it from a century ago it's Israels. What it's never been in history is the Palee's land

@@starhopper408 What century? Muslims were here millenias ago man.

@@عمرالمختار-ث2م its very sad to hear such lack of empathy from fellow ar abs. Very sad. Its almost like you use them as an imperialistic tool :/

@Starhopper And neither did judaism.

Israel has been defined as a secular state. Judaism is a ethnoreligon. Only Jewish law and our Rabbis decide who is Jewish. All Jews have the right to obtain citizenship under the Right to Return( 1950) DNA is not a criteria.

So what? Do Israel citizens ar kicked out if they say they don't believe in anymore?

@Noah: The modern state of the was reestablished as a Jewish homeland in 1947. The Law of Return ( 1950) was created to facilitate the return of the Jewish people to their ancient ancestral homeland Israel.

@ Noah: The modern state of Israel was reestablished as a Jewish homeland, not a binational state. There are 22 Arab countries in the region. There is only one very small Jewish state. It is not relevant if you agree or not, accept or not, these are the facts on the ground.

@ Noah: 🤷‍♀️ Reality bites

No one cares if you have multiple passports. The question is why should Israel give them to those who seek to destroy them and who have been trying to for a century? The last thing Israel needs is milz more hostile Arbzz within the nation. No sane country or person would agree to that, and that's aside from the demographic issues that would also destroy the Jewish nation.

@@starhopper408 you're being so dramatic not everyone is bad.

@ Shireen: Those are real places. Palestine is not.

@@sherryidibo2304 Did I say so? But the majority are anti-Zionist. You can claim they have reason to be so, but it doesn't change that fact. No sane nation would let milz of those seeking to destroy them in as citizens. It's ridiculous to even suggest so.

@Someoneak17 Somewhere Show me its borders. Acknowledgment by the UN is akin to nothing.

@Someoneak17 Somewhere You don't have a "Palestine" to give up.

@@starhopper408 i dont i have an Israeli citizenship but i meant the others not me

@@mohamedshibli2015 Hi. I was responding to the other guy. Don't you mean you don't have a Palestinian citizenship tho? You are Israeli, right?

There is no Palestinian citizenship; the PA passports do not mention nationality and the PA is not a sovereign entity.

I hope jordan will accept them peacefully.

Exactly. Surely a Palestinian could say they renounce Islam and say they are Jewish. Then they could vote and have citizenship.

Historical facts prove that the Jews inhabited the land since 5000 years. Religion corroborates it.

Jews are the owners of the land, holy book or not and no one "invaded". You need to come to terms with reality.

@gamboni100 Jenetic testing proves 90% of Zo0s = Not real Zeus.

@@DesertVox Nonsense.

@@starhopper408 Polixh invayzers = not real Zeus.