Italy vs California Zinfandel Showdown! 

So I really enjoy your infectious enthusiasm, detailed knowledge and enviable passion for wine. I too enjoy Zin, Primitivo and Nebbiolo selections. Well Done. Thanks.

I am a Zin fan. Lodi, CA has some wonderful Zins as does Russian River area. In the Sierra foothills they nice wines. All have different options for the grape. Lucky I’m 20 minutes from Napa

Wonderful presentation! And, I do love a good Zin!!!

You are like a friend that I enjoy spending time with. I like learning from you and I have my own vineyard. Very grateful that you are able to help us all enjoy wine

Love this channel. She is great!

Red Zins are my fav wine 🍷 thx for the video ❤ happy Valentine’s Day !!

Zin is my favorite. Spicy, does well in American oak, and bold.

Just purchased Wine Folly: Magnum Edition! I absolutely love it and I highly recommend that everyone get it if you're serious about learning more about wine or if you just love wine in general! Thanks Madeline and congratulations on your James Beard Award!

once again, your goofy and dorky in a real likable way. keep up the good work!

I'm pushing 80 years old and have drank a lot of vino in my life, starting with the home made stuff in a mason jar, courtesy of my grandpa (made from concord grapes).. Zinfandel is the one wine that has found its way to the pinnaicle of my wine preferences. They are big tasting wines and that is what I love about them. There are two kinds of zinfandels: Big old good ones and good ole big ones. When President Richard Nixon penetrated the Iron Curtain between the USA and China by being the first president to ever visit china, he took a case of Zinfandel to give to the Big Guy in China. What else??

Theses videos are so helpful 😍question Zinfandel low in tannin 😊

Hey Girl! I love Zin with bbq and the peppery notes~ Zin was the first red I fell in love with thanks to you in 2012 back in College! -MacGyver, Simply WINEing!

that was very informative!

I love your videos!!!! Thank you! You've made my private wine tastings for my guests so much fun and I've learned a ton from these and your books. THANK YOU! 🍷🥂 Cheers, Heidi, owner Tipsy Gypsy mobile bar service and Sommelier in training!

Bravo! Great discussion. I love Zinfandel.

Just love Sin. Thanks, Mad.

Bring the Primitivo!!! I had the pleasure to drink Sessentani. Really great wine.

We have friends coming over for BBQ ribs tomorrow and I have three different zins to try out with them. My favorite varietal!

Madeline Puckette stunning like always. Support from Croatia 🇭🇷♥️🇺🇸

Great insight! Didn't know Zin was actually Croatian!

Very nice, Zin is my all time favorite. I think central coast CA has the best...

Crushed volcanic rock - wow, havent tried that ;-) Love your stuff Madeline - keep it up!

A. Rafanelli in Dry Creek makes an amazing Zinfandel!! The winemaker is the third generation, her grandmother was the winemaker who started it all!

Girl!! You crazy!! And I love that about you... :)

gotta find one of these.

One of the best wines I have tried primitivo 😀 cheap and very good

"Get your date drunk." Ha, ha I love it! Zin for sin! Zinfandel isn't one of my favorite grape varieties - there's an awful lot of really bad Zin out there - but when it is done right, it can be smashing. I've been a fan of Primitivo for 20 years or more, long before it became fashionable. A lot of those Italian wines have a sort of dirty, earthy finish which is quite attractive. Good pizza wine.

martinelli zinfandel giuseppe & luisa is my favorite wine but pricey , do you have an opinion and comparable ones that are similiar? thanks

Beautiful Madeline forgot to mention that Peterson Winery also produces 8+ different zinfandels all tasting completely different. Check out there website! Big fan! Best KarenYoung ever! Haha gotta love spell check on wine lingo. 😋😊

I have not yet learned to drink zin. I just can't seem to develop a taste for it. However, would work if nothing else available. :)

Sipping on a Sonoma Zinfandel right now, best wine I have ever tried, Im a noob though.

Tres Sabores in Napa makes a unique and wonderful Zin.

I’ve never had an American Zinfandel, but I’ve rarely been disappointed with a Primitivo. Depending on the dish of course, in most cases I would most likely go for a Primitivo when it’s on the menu 😊

Had a Ridge Lytton springs zin 1992 yesterday. So yes, zin can age

Love Zin.

Are you in Washington? I'd love to collaborate on something.

I’m surprised you didn’t mention pepper on the finish of either Zinfandel which I find to be consistently present with this grape.

Quick question, Madeline. Can zin be drunk young?

Love me some “Black Chicken” !

Can you share the bottle names/ vintage :) would love to pick those up! And do you have an episode of Filtered VS Unfiltered wine!? Would love to hear what the difference is.

dry creek in the house!!!

You sound like you already had some glasses of wine earlier 🤣😂

1:34 can you please write the real name of that grape please?

I love Zin wines from Paso Robles.

Why is there another channel called WF-Archive with a bunch of your videos? lol

I prefer old vine zinfandels. Clos du Bois makes a very good one.

Zin are ok but give me a bolder full body red any day. good review

Probably a very dumb question but could you explain what filtered and unfiltered wine means?

Have you ever had the Caymus Zinfandel? Had it at their winery and purchased a bottle to take home. Big bold fruity with a nice long finish.

Good presentation, I prefer Primitivo.

Love your work as always! Just to confuse things even more, I read an article suggesting the real origin of the Zinfandel grape is actually Montenegro; from a grape called Kratosija! Evidence suggests that it's been grown there longer than Croatia.

Pinot is definitely more difficult/costly to grow than Zin. This is common knowledge in the NorCal wine industry.

great video, I usually like Old World Wines better but I love the big fruity jammyness of California.

You are adorable, brilliant, and such a joy to watch! My husband and I fell in love exploring Zinfandels in the Lodi area (California). Many Napa wineries purchase Lodi grapes for their wines, which makes me very proud as a native to the Central Valley. Thanks for your expertise and some historical background! We will be trying a Primitivo soon and doing our own taste comparison. 😉

0:10-0:15 ❤️❤️❤️

I love zin that smells like fresh dirt. It's hard to find. Any recommendations?

Love Zinfandel, big bold and some spice.

Can do a comparison with California and Australian Zinfandel?

this review was just zin-sational =)

I dont know why but i can smell honey when drinking primitivo

When does one decide that it's raspberry sauce vs just raspberry? I feel like I am unable to come up with the same vocabulary to associate the flavors. I don't think I would ever say "scorched blackberries" as a descriptor. Never say never, I guess.

Tarea#6

I'd love to see you put together a list of great zinfandel's that are under $35.00.

What does a crushed volcanic rock smell like?

Um if it won't age just drink it fools. People like to call me a wine snob because I know like the bare minimum to truly enjoy wine. I mean hot damn if it doesn't age just drink it when you get. Problem solved. Edit: I love Zinfandel its probably my favorite.

Zin? Oh yes. Amador County and Lodi have great ones.

One thing I don't like about Primitivo is that they tend to be sweet and have a lot of residual sugar (up to 18g/l). I'm curious if Zinfandel are as sweet or if you can find real dry wines...

Sinful but is that bad?

Passalacqua in the Dry Creek Valley makes some beautiful Zins....too many are huge oak bombs...like drinking a wine that want to be friends with scotch....

I found the Sessantanni better than the 62 because it is more extreme in that direction. If you want to be elegant, one would better leave Primitivo altogether.

i dont know about primitovo, but you are outstandingly cute

It's like Streetfighter for wines. "ready?.....FIGHT!!". In my case the Primitivo wins most of the time though, but it's not a 'PERFECT'.

ZIN ZIN ZIN! LOVE ZINFANDEL!

Superb 👏 "Get your date drunk"😂🤣 🦋 Gracias 🇨🇺 🍮 ☕️

If you live on the East Coast, there's a decent chance your California wine is cooked. If it moved by truck between May and Sept, really good chance.

Elderberry wine ruined grape wine for me (as did blackberry wine and blueberry wine), kind of like the way salt water fishing ruined fresh water fishing for me (per the saying 'One man's trophy is another man's bait'). I've been a winemaker since 2005 and I've made all kinds of wines (grape included) and in my opinion Elderberry wine is in a class all by itself (there are dozens of articles on winemaking posted online by gurus who have been making wine for decades who say the same thing). Then Blackberry. Then Blueberry. Then Cherry. Then Pear (the Romans regarded pear wine as their favorite, and there they were in the middle of one of the world's premier grape growing regions). Then apple, fig, tomato, then grape (if you don't believe it, go to some of the winemaker's forums and see how grape wine rates on the preferable wine fruit scale.

Tastes of jelly beans. Ridge is amazing

Please suggest healthy wine brand s

I'll give you a like just because you look like my grandpa, :)

Were you drunk while filming this? 🤣

Why has no one commented on the fact that she seems drunk?!

Zinfandel is Croatian, why don’t we see it sold from Croatia?

Ya no le sirvan... se tomó toda Italia y toda California...

viva weed

You need medical help!!!!