While i do not agree with her views, she has the right to ask whatever she wants to, it's her right. Allah will judge her, & decide what to do with her, not humans. Maybe she's just misguided and doesn't have a bad heart, or maybe it's something else. Everyone has questions in their minds, and doubts about things at some point in life, so it's natural. However, the manner in which she asked her question was utterly disrespectful, arrogant, intolerant and based on emotions than sound thinking.
Mr. Ghamidi Assalamo alaikum w/w your patience is commendable and I must say you are God gifted in this regrad A true scholar must posses these qualities God Bless you.Amen I am an Ahmedi and I do differ in oppinons at some places with you but most of the times you sound very resaonable my hreart is touched by this kindness I salute you for your these qualities I wish other Muslim Scholar would be as rational as you are Jazakomullaho-khaira kaceeran kaceera wassalam
I think this woman is an extraordinary person and if she lives in Pakistan she is also a very courageous person. If she ever reads this comment, I want to congratulate her for her intelligence, courage and rational thinking
thanx for ur answer... so explain pls in quran jab hazrat essa a.s ne farmaya k "asmaan se hamaray lia khana nazil farma ta k wo din hamaray lia eid ka din ho jae" " Rabbana anzil alaena maedatan minnas samae takoonu lana eidan li awwalina wa aakhirana" aur ap s.a.w.w ne jo farmaya k friday eid ka din hai, kio hai islia k hazrat adam a.s is dunia main tashreef lae, pls explain again " eid" according to these what i hv mentioned
humbly ask the lady who asked the question to Mr. Ghamidi.;Every person is known from the place or country he/she blongs. Every book is known by its author.. Then why not Propehts and their books be called with Allah's refference? Also every person is addressed according to its status. Higher the status so is the title. His highness, her highness.His holiness ectc. Then why not Prophets be given respectful titles? Specially the Greatest of them all the Holy Prophet?
respect brother....nobody aint got no time or thought for a good debate these days.. dont they realise that allah swt created islam and the quran in a way which encourages debating..god knows best.
@itskammy sorry bhai eid is an arabic word and its emans repeatetion as Allah names is mueed meand dunia ko dobara banane wala eid ka din hamare liye her sal ata hey is liye is ko eid kaha gaya or ye sirf urdu me he arabid me nahi bohat se word hian jo diferent language se liye jate hian or urdu me us ke kuch or mani hojate hian asal wohi he jo unhon ne bataya aap urdu ya arabic lughat dkeh skate hian
Islam also presents a certain philosophy n it came to earth as a result of all history of philosophy that he is mentioning here.How can he say that Philosophy has failed.Ghamidi needs to study more
@ehsanPN Thought of a Pakistani My mother tongue is Punjabi. My national language is Urdu. I am doing business in broken English moreover, Allah has made my religion in Arabic the language more then 99.99% Pakistani even don't speak, read, write, and completely don't understand. Faisal Masood.
Faisal Masood! Religion is not based on language but conscious of mind. This mind has been made compatible with religion. Do you know Allah is ONE, Rasool is Last prophet, all prophets were righteous, system of Allah is there. This is called religion. U dont need to run here and there. That is all
@Zaydi74 Thought of a Pakistani My mother tongue is Punjabi. My national language is Urdu. I am doing business in broken English moreover, Allah has made my religion in Arabic the language more then 99.99%? Pakistani even don't speak, read, write, and completely don't understand. Faisal Masood.
@leotakesleo just because he is telling what you wants to hear, right path is always difficult to foolow. This man has his own concepts about Islam, wrong meanings...
@Zaydi74 yes she has right to ask a question ,,,but first she has to introduce themself in such kind of live tv show after that you can even abuse to muslims,,but if you dont in such kind of program which actually set to promote peace and harmony ,,then it is end hypocrisy,,she deserves for that kind of comments,because she looks me Atheist,if she is then it is another thiesim, And rusianisim (or Atheisim) actually failed very bedlly does she know that?
first i want to tell her that she has no right to tell us that i mean to muslims that why we r saying rasul and to quran qitab-e-allah i dont she is muslim or not ,when she is muslim then she said a word christ or crise when she is miuslim and used this word for isa alay salam then she must be go alim and told him that i have said she knows better ,because that was very wrong what she explained because this is the way to qufar .
He allows the Music, Beer, Interest in Islam, i can't wht they preach n which type of scholar he is??? Remeber jews eat many civilization, societies, religions by created Ghamdi, shaikh mohd, Qadyani type munafiq, like Christ, they destroy the chrisitian/hindus actual religion and insert his foul n fake, evil ideology. and destroy his moral, values from society. but ISLAM is only sword who resist against his foul tasks since last 14000 yrs. so they try his best Plz. Be aware
Ghamidi and Tahirul Qadiri, if these two would find men of their choice around themselves they would have erected new sects of their own in the name of religion. This man considers all past scholars and teachings of Islam as not realistic and tells of himself knowing the most of all. His appearance is even not upto the mark.
sawal intehayee be tuka hey bold he magar sensible nahi madam ko piyare nabi ko rasoolullah kehne pe hi kion etaraz hua eesayee log to eesa ale salam ko khuda tak bana dete hian wo bhi unko ek khaas admi nahi samjhte jesa ke in ka israr he wo bhi un ko azeem darja dete hian haan bhayee is ghar ko aag lag gayee apne charagh se yehi musalmanon ki history he.
