🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:15 📜 Early Christian Bishop Ignatius of Antioch wrote about some first-century Christians who believed Jesus was not crucified, which aligns with a belief in Islam. 03:03 🕊️ Ignatius' writings provide evidence that some first-century Christians disagreed about whether Jesus was crucified, even though Ignatius condemned these beliefs. 05:29 🤯 There's an irony in early Christianity where some leaders, like Ignatius, rejected Jewish practices and beliefs, despite Jesus himself upholding Jewish laws. 09:48 🏛️ The head of the early Church in Jerusalem, James (Jesus' brother), and the believers there were zealous for the Jewish Torah, emphasizing a connection between early Christianity and Judaism. 17:45 📖 The Quran's belief in the non-crucifixion of Jesus aligns with the views of some early Christians, as testified by Ignatius, providing an early Christian perspective on the matter. 18:13 🌐 Early Christianity discusses the belief in Jesus' non-crucifixion, which is also found in the Quran.
What's you didnt cover @TheMuslimApologist is that the people Ignatius of Antioch was responding were Docetists, they didn't believe jesus has a physical body and was only a Spirit. Since you can't crucify a Spirit they denied Jesus was crucified. They also denied Mary gave birth to Jesus for the same reason. Stop practicing Taqiyya🙄
@@BloggingTheology We all need to learn about imam hossain and lady zainab and the events of karbala and the aftermath. Prophet Muhammad PBUH predicted this. Prior to his death prophet Muhammad PBUH told us to follow 2 things. The holy quran and hos ahlul bayt. His family. His progeny.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
I agree with a lot of the things this man said however he takes Augustine out of context: When he said “though some deny it” there is no reference that those who deny it were Christian’s notice how this man adds that part in. He also talks about Judaism following Christianity is Contradicting Jesus. This is not true Augustine is talking about where your priority im should be he’s not saying that the law doesn’t matter in fact the law is better followed when Christian’s follow Jesus.
Allah does not exist !!! He didn’t suffer, die and resurrect to satisfy Jesus’ Heavenly Father against sin !! Jesus suffered, died and resurrected to save us from eternal damnation !!!!
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
˹Jesus˺ declared, “I am truly a servant of Allah. He has destined me to be given the Scripture and to be a prophet. He has made me a blessing wherever I go, and bid me to establish prayer and give alms-tax as long as I live, and to be kind to my mother. He has not made me arrogant or defiant. Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” - Surah Maryam 19:30-33[8]
Uncle Paul, Alhamdulillah! You have reached 300k subs! Subhaan Allah I've been following your work for nearly three years and have seen this channel grow. Congratulations!
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
@@BloggingTheology You will regret for saying falsehood ! Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
I agree with a lot of the things this man said however he takes Augustine out of context: When he said “though some deny it” there is no reference that those who deny it were Christian’s notice how this man adds that part in. He also talks about Judaism following Christianity is Contradicting Jesus. This is not true Augustine is talking about where your priority im should be he’s not saying that the law doesn’t matter in fact the law is better followed when Christian’s follow Jesus.
I had so many questions growing up as a christian. Many of them you are covering and Im glad. It makes me feel my questions were legitimate. I’m was at times ostracized because I had questions. The biggest one was regarding the question of why Christians split from Judaism when Jesus himself said that he upheld the law and we should not forsake it. I couldn’t get past that dichotomy. Eventually - 69 years later I walked away from Christianity because the questions kept coming with no real answers. Thank you for your voice of reason.
@@jige1225 - I have been studying the ‘old’ religions. Specifically Animism which is not a religion but a way of living spiritually as the Creator created us to be. But that is for me. Each must find their own oath. I don’t know where I will end up.
Be careful following his channel. I realize he only quote things that support his new faith in Islam and would ignore the same sources that contradict his arguments. You should get this books and read yourself and do extensive research.
@@cc-cy instead of talking nonsense, maybe it is time to follow the early Christian practising Jew who were on the right track ? Islam is the only logical path after that weither you like it or not.
@EmperorDawn Islam is all lies, if allah made to appear to the Jews that Jesus was crucified but in reality he didn't, all has deceived the Jews, hence allah is a deceiver... why do allah has to put an innocent person who look like Jesus on the cross,,, who was that innocent person allah pit on the cross.. allah is not all merciful,, he is a murderer.
@@cc-cy of course, because whom God sent must be truth just like all previous prophets. But what do the bible tell you? That prophets commit sins. How come can prophets commits sins if they are the epitome of moral. Don't argue if you don't even look into Islam sincerely.
New to your channel, found it very enrapting and educational, without the monotony that has infiltrated the clergy these days, basically what I believe a proper sermon should be. Keep it up and I'll continue to follow.
Let's do a bit of history here. Flavius Josephus (AD 37-100) recorded Pilate's condemnation of Jesus to be crucified. Lucian (AD 125-180) found it amusing that Christians worshipped a crucified man. Celsus (2nd century) described Jesus proclaiming himself God and being nailed to a cross. Thallus (AD 50) referred to the darkness during the crucifixion as an eclipse. Pliny the Younger (AD 61-113) mentioned Christians worshipping Christ as God. The Babylonian Talmud (5th century) stated Jesus practiced sorcery, was hanged before Passover, and his body couldn't be found after resurrection.
@@markhalpin9711 No I don't think so we can't even get our secular history right and recently they've made so much advancement in science they are even rewriting the science books or at lesst they admit they should but what good would that do in a few decades they'll probably have to revise it again Getting so you don't know who to belivie.
Aisha: "But, I'm _only_ nine." Allah's Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him): "You're just _FINE!"_ Roses are red, violets are blue, Aisha was 9 and Allah's Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) was 52. *Sahih al-Bukhari vol 5 bk 58:236* “Allah's Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) married Aisha when she was 6 years old, and _consummated_ when she was 9” *Qur'an 65:1, 4* "When divorcing women, know their waiting period. For women past the age of menstruation, their waiting period is 3 months - and those who have _NOT_ menstruated yet as well." *Sahih al-Bukhari vol 7 book 62 number 64:* “Allah's Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) married her when she was 6 years old and he _consummated_ his marriage when she was 9 years old” *Sahih Bukhari Vol 7, Book 62, Nr 16* "The Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) said, 'Did you marry a virgin or a matron?' I replied, 'A matron.' He said, “Why didn’t you marry a young girl so that you may play with her and she with you?'"
˹Jesus˺ declared, “I am truly a servant of Allah. He has destined me to be given the Scripture and to be a prophet. He has made me a blessing wherever I go, and bid me to establish prayer and give alms-tax as long as I live, and to be kind to my mother. He has not made me arrogant or defiant. Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” - Surah Maryam 19:30-33[8]
Ignatius of Antioch, an early Christian writer and bishop, wrote seven letters (also known as the Ignatian Epistles) that are considered some of the earliest Christian writings outside the New Testament. In his letters, Ignatius refers to Jesus and various aspects of Christian theology. Regarding the crucifixion of Jesus, Ignatius alludes to it in his letter to the Trallians. In his Letter to the Trallians, Ignatius writes in Chapter 9: "I give glory to Jesus Christ the God who bestowed such wisdom upon you; for I have perceived that ye are established in faith immovable, being as it were nailed to the cross of the Lord Jesus Christ, in flesh and in spirit, and firmly grounded in love in the blood of Christ..."
Isaiah 45:23 Philipians 2:10-11 Romans 14:11 Hebrews 6:13 "For it is written,As I live,says the Lord,every knee shall bow to me,and every tongue shall confess to God [acknowledge Him to His honour and to His praise].
Yes , and the people who bow down and even prostrate themselves before God are the Muslims so what is your point ? Jesus himself said God is one & that the Father is greater than him. But you Christians says otherwise , God is a Trinity & the three are co equal. So who's telling the truth , you or Jesus ???
Subhan Allah. An excellent documentary evidence, a letter by St Ignatius and matching references from the Bible of new religion. This phenomenon of new faiths / innovations / بدعت being made by people repeatedly is highlighted in Quran Sura 45, especially 45:28. Paul, your ‘Metacognition’ is a blessing for us. You have repeatedly brought evidence from Bible n historical documents in support of Quran’s self-referentiality! Jazak Allah.
This guy is unimpressive, and the book shelf doesn't make him look smarter. He took one simple line from Ignatius to say that early Christians didn't believe that Jesus died. Ignatius writing in the late first century/ early second century was writing during a time of Docetism and early stages or Gnosticism. In fact, the reason why John's writings are unique to the synoptics is because John was specifically battling later developing heresies such as Docetism and Gnosticism, which did not exist in the earliest days of Christianity. We know that Muhammad and the Quran was influenced by these views because exact stories are copied and brought into the Quranic material....Gnosticm was a heretical quasi-Christian movement during the late first and into the second century. The infancy gospel of Thomas was written in the mid 2nd century and someone slapped Thomas's name on it, but it's a forgery. That is where you get the clay bird story of Isa in Surah 5:110 of the Quran- and in chapter 1 of the Arabic Infancy Gospel of Thomas, we find this account: “When Jesus was five, he went out one Saturday to play with other boys. Jesus took some clay and made twelve birds out of it." This story is only found in the Gnostic gospels. The denial of the crucifixion of Isa on the cross found in Surah 4:157-158, is based off the Gnostic leader named Basilides. The late 2nd-century Christian writer Irenaeus wrote about the teachings of Basilides, who claimed: “He did not himself suffer death, but Simon, a certain man of Cyrene, being compelled, bore the cross in his stead; so that this latter being transfigured by him, that he might be thought to be Jesus..." The Nag Hammadi library is a collection of Gnostic documents that were preserved in a jar in Egypt from the 4th century AD, and Jesus's denial by death on the cross can be linked back to these. One example found has Jesus saying: “I was not afflicted at all, yet I did not die in solid reality but in what appears, in order that I not be put to shame by them,” (The Second Treatise of Great Seth). There are other examples of Jesus not dying in these late Gnostic sources as well. The Qur'an has a story about Abraham which is not found in the Bible, in Surah 37:91-98, when Abraham breaks all the idols. This is an obvious reproduction of a story found in the Midrash Rabbah, an old Jewish book containing much folklore embellishing Biblical material. There's another story about Cain and Abel in the Quran that isn't found in the Bible but in the Midrash, about how God sent a raven to help hide the body. It's obvious that Muhammad through together a bunch of stories that he had heard. One last point. Matthew 5 doesn't mean what this dude implied. In that verse, Jesus said that He came to "FULFILL" the law, not that He came to deliver or declare the law.....How does one individual FULFILL the entire requirements of the law? Early Islam acknowledged Paul as a true disciple also. Paul taught nothing different than James, and in Acts, James is pleased with Paul.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
@rudycataldo3653 "We know that Muhammad and the Quran was influenced by these views because exact stories are copied and brought into the Quranic material." > That is mere presumption on your part #without_evidence 🔬, because #correlation_does_NOT_imply_causation #LOGICAL_FALLACIES
Hi, if you are not saved, and would like to be included in the rapture of the church. Believe that Jesus's death on the cross, was enough to pay for ALL your sins , yes ALL ,(past, present and future) That is what the Gospel is about. We are saved by GOD'S amazing grace, through our faith in Jesus's sinless life, death on the cross and resurrection 3 days later . No additional works needed. It is literally that simple. Ephesians 2:8-9 Romans 10:9-10 Romans 4:5
I love the parallel between James and Abu Bakr, both were the 1st caliphs (successors) of their ummah and both having the same nickname HaTzaddiq and as-Siddiq respectively. Nice video as always Sidi Paul 🎉
@@nwelll its the church and the father's of Christianity who fooled you guys by distorting and manipulating the Bible. As you might know the errors of the Bible is clearly visible!. Now the question is after knowing and acknowledging That you guys have been fooled by Peter/Paul or the early church fathers?. Why won't you come towards a scripture that is Pur and unchanged like the Quran. That is my Sincere question to you? Unless your an illogical person and insincere to your Self.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isas said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
@@doreenfernandes2431 Bible narratives are 3rd hand account which means gotten from hearsay. They are filled with error, discrepancies, inconsistencies, contradictions. These are all signs of lies.
@@PolyglotfootballerHoly Quran said what you say. But you don't know the Holy Quran . Quran says Jesus never died on the cross But he died and Almighty God took his soul to haven.
@@AliLee-kn3vd You lie! It is said Jesus was taken up to allah! Not to heaven but why was a man taken up to allah if no man can be with Allahs presence!
In 1870, an Aramaic manuscript entitled "The Gospel of the Nazirenes" was discovered, translated and published. This ancient scripture, hidden away for centuries in a Tibetan monastery, was known as the Gospel of the Nazirenes, later to be known as "The Gospel of the Holy Twelve," The Gospel of the Holy Twelve declares that in order to achieve eternal life, "The Law" must be fully obeyed, meaning that Jesus indeed, had shown his unequivocal focus on Torah that must be obeyed. Torah of the Jews is not the Old Testament but it refers to Tanakh which is the canonical collection of Hebrew scriptures. It's interesting to note that Quran speaks about the Injeel and Torah as follows: And in their footsteps We sent Jesus the son of Mary, confirming the Law that had come before him: We sent him the Gospel: therein was guidance and light, and confirmation of the Law that had come before him: a guidance and an admonition to those who fear Allah. (Chapter 5:Verse 46)
@XanderMarshall good question. This Gospel record is the recovered document from which the Four Gospels as we have them today were built upon. It was the first formulated life of the Christ and was written by St. John about the year 70 AD., when he was imprisoned in Rome and given page by page to one whom he could trust. When the scroll was completed and after its contents had been made known to the Apostles, it was taken to Tibet by the same disciple, who left it in the care of a unnamed lama. Here, it remained until a friar, named Placidus, visited the monastery in the eighteen seventies and asked if he might show it to the Church Authorities in Rome.
So you accept a document discovered in 1870 in Tibet as accurate but reject the New Testament documents which were written within decades of Jesus' death and resurrection which contain the testimony of persons who met Jesus, witnessed his death and resurrection?
@kwamegordon1448 You have a reasonable doubt that requires detailed answer. Gospel of the Holy Twelve was written before 70AD in Aramaic, the spoken language of Jesus and his Apostles. Bible scholars believe that this is the Q-source for the Greek Gospels Mathew, Mark and Luke. In the second century AD different churches were using various Gospels including the Gospel of the Holy Twelve. Emperor Constantine created the Nicene Creed, also called Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed, in 325AD. a Christian statement of faith that defined the status of Jesus as the only begotten son and equal to the Father. Even though the 27-book New Testament were first formally canonized during the councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397) in North Africa, the council of Nicaea removed five principal "fringe" books later omitted from the canon proper. They are: the Didache (or Teaching of the Twelve Apostles), the Shepherd of Hermas, the Apocalypse of Peter, the Epistle of Barnabas and the Epistle of Clement. In the above Didache was a Greek manuscript of early Jewish Christianity somewhat closer to the Aramaic Gospel of the Holy Twelve. The major reason for the removal of above books is that they didn't conform to the Constantinopolitan Creed of Christian faith. Not only they were removed but ordered to be destroyed. It was at this time someone had taken it to Tibet for a safe custody of the manuscripts. Until it was discovered in 1870, Gospel of the Holy Twelve was known as 'Lost Gospel' by the Catholic Church. The scroll from the Tibetan monastery was translated in Latin and read to the assembly of Cardinals in Rome. At first they were impressed, but as it proceeded to reveal the contents they realised that to make it known would discredit the Church which had, during the Council of Nicea, eliminated from the Gospels the Master's teaching and it was contradictory to the established Constantinopolitan Creed so the scroll was hidden away in the archives of the Vatican, where it remains to this day. The reason this Gospel contains much that is in Matthew, Mark and Luke is because there were many Gospels written about this time containing the true teaching of Jesus, but this was the only one that escaped the pen of the `correctors', because they did not know of its existence. My apologies for such long discourse because it was a heavy subject that Catholic Church doesn't want the Christians to know about. Please feel free to ask if you need any further clarification.
@@nakeebissadeen1606 I have no doubts and I need no clarification when it comes to anything you have typed above. I know Islamic nonsense propaganda when I see it. Let me ask you something. Your Qur'an calls Christians people of the Book and they are required to hold firm to this Book. This Book predated the Qur'an and was in the possession of Christians at the time of Muhammad. Which Book is the Qur'an talking about?
It makes sense from biblical texts that Jesus pbuh would be saved, too. He was promised that his foot would not even dash a stone without angels coming to catch him.
Matthew 4:6 “If you are the Son of God,” he said, “throw yourself down. For it is written: “ ‘He will command his angels concerning you, and they will lift you up in their hands, so that you will not strike your foot against a stone.’ ” Matthew 4:7 Jesus answered him, “It is also written: ‘Do not put the Lord your God to the test.’ ” Devils will always try to use falsehood
@@SacredWarrior999jesus in this passage talked to not test god the father promise lmao 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 I dont know why you think jesus here is a god or meant himself
@@manofwar2354 He’s so sick they will never believe until they Die they ve been fooled by the charlatan Paul . Let them keep worshiping Idols instead of the Lord of Abraham the one ☝️.
@@kh7688 I agree that Paul seems to have a tremendous "thirst for knowledge". I don't know how he keeps up with so much reading of books and the Blogging Theology channel. I'm not Muslim but respectfully...
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Those 1st Cent. A.D. who denied the Crucifixion, Death, Resurrection, and Ascension of Christ Jesus were the AGNOSTIC (Skeptic) would-be followers of Christ Jesus... They Pretend to be Christians but never follow the WILL of His Father God/YHWH who is in Heaven... Praise be to God in Christ... Amen.
@@Nouh1216 There is no such definite pronunciation to the Name of God, it was lost in time... the Holy Scripture wrote YHWH in Hebrew-Aramaic Alphabeth, without vowels, it could be YoHeWuH, YaHoWeH, YeHoWaH, YaHWeH, etc...
@@jvlp2046 Ive researched religion for a long time now, and I know for a fact Yahweh is Baal or Satan. Jesus said no one has ever heard or seen the Father (John 6:46, John 1:18), but yet Yahweh showed his back to Moses on Mount Sinai (Exodus 33:12-23). When Jesus was talking to the pharisees (who were worshipping Yahweh at the time), he said, "You are of your father the devil, and you choose to do your father's desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks according to his own nature, for he is a liar and the father of lies" (John 8:41-45). I should also mention that Yahweh killed over 2 million people in the Bible. And not once did Jesus call God Yahweh or anything close to that. Jesus actually spoke against Yahweh. For example, the Israelites asked Yahweh for food and water, but instead, Yahweh sent snakes that killed them, (Numbers 21:5, 21:6-9). Jesus spoke about this and said, "Which of you, if your son asks for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for fish, will give him a snake?" (Matthew 7:9-12). I should also mention that Yahweh and the israelites were defeated by Chemosh, the god of the Moabites. In 2Kings 3:18-19, the prophet Elisha prophesied to the king of israel that Yahweh would help them defeat the Moabites. But 2Kings 3:26-27 says that Moab took his firstborn son and sacrificed him to the wall (Chemosh) , and then great wrath came upon israel, so they withdrew. God cannot be defeated therefore Yahweh is not God. In Hosea 13:7-8, Yahweh said, "So I will be like a lion to them, like a leapord I will lurk by the path. Like a bear robbed of her cubs. I will attack them and rip them open; like a lion I will devour them a wild animal will tear them apart." Now In Revelations 13 it says, "And I saw a beast coming out of the sea. It had 10 horns and 7 heads , with 10 crowns on its horns, and on each head a blasphemous name. The beast I saw resembled a leapord, but had feet like those of a bear and a mouth like that of a lion." I could go on for hours on how Yahweh is Satan and not God, especially the Father of Jesus, because Jesus and Yahweh are nothing alike.
@@Nouh1216 - Let's simplify the above by stating - Yahweh / Jehovah is better known as "Yaldaboath" or "Saklas" which means "blind fool." He is the head of the satanic regime and creator of the material world ruled by the Demiurge. All those who claim to be Theocrats are part of the great Satanic body oversighted by the Cabal. A Theocrat is any individual, Human or Spirit, with broken or imperfect software. This "Yaldabaoth" is not the Beast of Rev 13 - that is the Bright Morning Star - Jesus - the "SUN OF MAN" or Sun God ( whose number is 666 ) Lucifer, or Antichrist; a totally different individual to Satan.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
@@PolyglotfootballerIsa Ibn Maryam was save from being killed by the pagan Romans and still alive until today and he will come back in his second coming to defeat the Dajjal/Antichrist. وَاِنَّهٗ لَعِلْمٌ لِّلسَّاعَةِ فَلَا تَمْتَرُنَّ بِهَا وَاتَّبِعُوْنِۗ هٰذَا صِرَاطٌ مُّسْتَقِيْمٌ (Surah Az-Zuhruf 43:61) And indeed, he [i.e., Jesus] will be [a sign for] knowledge of the Hour, so be not in doubt of it, and follow Me. This is a straight path. After that, he will live the rest of his life as a human being and die just as anyone else. And when the passage says "the day I will be raised back to life", he is referring to the Day of Judgement as he and just like everybody else will being resurrected back by the Almighty Creator. اللَّهُ لَآ إِلَهَ إِلَّا هُوَ لَيَجْمَعَنَّكُمْ إِلَى يَوْمِ الْقِيَمَةِ لَا رَيْبَ فِيهِ وَمَنْ أَصْدَقُ مِنَ اللَّهِ حَدِيثاً (Surah An-Nisa 4:87) Allah, there is no god but He - He will most certainly gather you together on the Day of Resurrection, there is no doubt in it; and who is more true in word than Allah? The passage you quoted is an affirmation that he is a creature created by Allah. He will live, die and be resurrected, just like other creatures that Allah has created.
I agree with a lot of the things this man said however he takes Augustine out of context: When he said “though some deny it” there is no reference that those who deny it were Christian’s notice how this man adds that part in. He also talks about Judaism following Christianity is Contradicting Jesus. This is not true Augustine is talking about where your priority im should be he’s not saying that the law doesn’t matter in fact the law is better followed when Christian’s follow Jesus.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isas said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
Thank you for your relentless effort to bring twisted fact about Jesus!!! Because of some people, called themselves followers of Jesus, hasmd started to follow their whimes and demagogues !!! It is wake up call before the Judgement day comes !!! No joke with the sentence of God !!!
This is a video about the law, not the crucifixion. You mentioned a very short passage at the beginning that suggested Jesus didn’t die, but said nothing about the crucifixion.
That is what I noticed. He posted a title and went to talk about other things. I was really curious to hear what he would said to justify his title. It is just to deceive people. Empty talk
The truth is that Muslims have nothing convincingly to say about that. All they will say is trust me bro. Mohammed said it so let's believe 😂. The majority of the followers are Muslims so he will get the like even if he says nothing really. 😁 In Islam it's normal to divert the conversation when you can't answer.
You are committing the unforgivable sin. Speaking against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven. I pray, before you agree with this blasphemy, that you will reject the teaching of a false religion.
And what did Jesus say to the educated religious leaders of His day? Matthew 22:29 “Jesus answered and said unto them, Ye do err, not knowing the scriptures, nor the power of God.”
The disciples ran when Jesus was arrested. But something happened, just as Jesus said it would happen. They walked with him for three years, the believed that he was the Messiah, but they ran. why? How can a bunch of scared men become this roaring Lion that no persecution can silence ? How? Why? They saw the resurrected Jesus who was crucified on the cross of calvary, died, and was buried, only to leave a now empty tomb. John 03:16 -17 Praise God !
@@Thirdday71 They ran because it was the plan. He prayed for none of them to be lost that had been given to Him. Therefore, Had they not ran, they could have been put to death as well, and only The Messiah could do the work required to become the once for all offering. He worked while everyone else was resting. That is a good part of what the Sabbath was designed to be pointing to, and why Scripture says He is the Lord of the Sabbath.
@@charliewhon6548 Well; yes that much is true. The whole story was prophesied. And it came to pass just as Jesus and the Old Testament prophets said that it would. " I will smite the shepherd, and the sheep shall scatter" My point was that" Jesus said "not one dot nor tittle shall by no means will pass from the law until all is fulfilled. Jesus totally fulfilled the law. If we say that he was never crucified, then we Blaspheme God by calling him a liar, thus saying that the Bible is not true, and that God does not exist...
@@Thirdday71 There is only one God. His name is Allah. He is the God of all the Prophets including Jesus (peace be upon him) who said, “The Father is greater than I” (John 14:28). And in John 17:3 in the Jesus himself states, "And this is eternal life, that they know you, the only true God," He also states in John 5:30, "I can do nothing on my own." Clearly, Jesus is not God and he was sent for a very specific people, the lost sheep of Israel, not you. If you don't believe me, please look up Jesus' encounter with the Canaanite woman with the demon-possessed daughter in Matthew 15:21-28 and Mark 7:25-30. In Gethsemane, his prayers to God were rejected by God and according to Christianity, he was crucified. His will is subservient to the will of God. Matthew 6:9-10: Jesus said, "Our Father which art in heaven, hallowed be thy name. Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done in earth, as it is in heaven". In fact, the Bible condemns him as a curse for dying on the cross. Galatians 3:13 says, "Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us, for it is written, 'Cursed is everyone who is hung on a pole'". God cannot be a curse. Who is cursing God? Finally if indeed he died on the cross, then Jesus is not God because God according to the Bible is immortal. First Timothy 6:16 says, "Who alone has immortality, dwells in unapproachable light, whom no one has ever seen or can see; to him be honor and eternal dominion. Amen". In Islam, our Prophet Jesus is revered and is not considered a curse. If indeed God is cursing Jesus, that would not be fair since he was an innocent Prophet (p).
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
Lev. 19:2 ‘You shall be holy, for I the Lord your God am holy.' Rom. 3:23-26 'for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, 24 being justified [g]freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, 25 whom God set forth as a [h]propitiation by His blood, through faith, to demonstrate His righteousness, because in His forbearance God had passed over the sins that were previously committed, 26 to demonstrate at the present time His righteousness, that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus. Jesus came to the law of God. He is the only one capable of that. Some early 'christians' may started to doubt (and wrote about it?), that does not make the crucifixion a myth.
Cornelius Tacitus who live at same time of jesus also Record about it 115 AD . he not even christian. the truth is hard to swallow mate. Crucifixion what symbolise as reborn of the dead and union with God and symbol of the dead save by grace of God in order to be born again . muhammad missunderstood it as the crucifixion was fake.
The epistles of John speaks of the gnostics. Paul wrote to the Galatians and Corinthians warning them of preachers who rejected the death and resurrection of Jesus.
@jessicaras4540 They don't mean Jesus, ask a Rabbi? Jesus isn't the Jewish Messiah so why on earth would they mean Jesus? It's simply shameful that Christians would appropriate the Torah.
😊 I BELIEVE THE BIBLE. THE BIBLE IS THE TRUTH .👍👍👍 ANYONE CAN SAY ANYTHING. THEY ARE ANTICHRIST AND ARE GUIDED BY SATAN WHO IS ACTIVE TO WIN SOULS FOR HIS KINGDOM OF DARKNESS. 😮 BUT IT IS UP TO US BYTHE INSPIRATION AND ENLIGHTENMENT OF THE HOLY SPIRIT TO BELIEVE THE TRUTH OF THE.BIBLE . MAY GOD OPEN BLIND EYES I PRAY IN THE MATCHLESS NAME OF JESUS. AMEN.
What discovery? The church has known from the beginning there were heretics that came into the church. All the Apostles, Apostolic Fathers, Church Fathers, Saints of the Church, all taught Christ crucified. The heretics like Arian, Nestorius, Gnostics and others were anathematized from the church but then reappeared in Islam, Jehovah Witnesses, Mormons and others. As the saying goes ‘there’s nothing new under the sun’.
Ah like the sun setting in a muddy pool, yeah and allah saying he is the greatest of deceivers this means allah is satan for satan is the greatest of deceivers for he is the father of lies
Rubbish.. Jesus was the son of God and not a prophet, one day all you who follow the Quran will be before The God Of Israel, Jesus Christ and The Holy Spirit and be judged.. Don't say you weren't warned.. 👍
I just watched the first minutes of your video, and from what I was able to hear from your reading of the book you had in your hand, I came to the conclusion that the title you gave your video is incorrect, and therefore unfortunately misleading. Instead of saying: 'Jesus was not crucified according to 1st Century Christians', you should say: 'Jesus was not crucified according to SOME 1st Century Christians' Or am I wrong? I hope you correct it. Greetings (Google translated from Spanish)
19. Maryam Mary 98 Verses With the name of Allâh, the Most Gracious, the Ever Merciful, 1Kâf Hâ Yâ `Ain Sâd - Allâh is sufficient for all, and He is the True Guide, Bestower of mercy and security and blessings, the All-Knowing, the Supermost, Truthful. 2(This is) an account of the mercy of your Lord (shown) to His servant Zachariah, 3When he called upon his God, crying aloud (in humble supplication). 4He said (praying), `My Lord! now the very bones within me have waxed feeble and the hair of (my) head are all gray and hoary, my Lord! never have I been (hitherto) deprived of a favourable response to my prayer to You. 5`I fear (for the unrighteousness of) my kinsfolk after me, and my wife is barren. Grant me by Your (special) grace a (pious and righteous) successor, 6`Who may be an heir to me and inherit (the divine blessings promised to) the House of Jacob and make him, my Lord! well-pleasing (to You).´ 7(God accepted his prayer and said,) `Zachariah! We give you the glad tidings of (the birth of) a son, named Yahyâ (- John, - who will live long). We have made none like him (in your house) before this.´ 8He (- Zachariah) said, `My Lord! how shall I beget a son when my wife is barren and I have (already) reached the extreme (limit of) old age?´ 9(The Lord) said, `So shall it be,´ and (the angel bearing the revelation) said, `Your Lord says, "It is easy for Me, and behold, I have created you before this whereas you (too) were nothing".´ 10He (- Zachariah) said, `My Lord! appoint for me a commandment.´ (The Lord) said, `The commandment for you is that you shall not speak to people for three successive (days and) nights, being in sound health. 11Then he (- Zachariah) went forth to his people from the Sanctuary and told them in a low voice and by signs, to glorify (their Lord) morning and evening. 12(We said to John,) `Yahyâ! hold fast the (divine) Book.´ And while he was yet a child We gave him wisdom, 13And tenderheartedness and purity by Our (special) grace. He was one who carefully guarded against evil. 14And (he was) dutiful towards his parents and he was neither arrogant nor rebellious. 15Blessed was he the day he was born and the day he died and (peace will be upon him) the day he will be raised to life (again). 16And give an account of Mary in this Book when she withdrew from her people to an eastern spacious place (of the temple). 17Then she screened herself off from them. Then We sent to her Our (angel of) revelation and he presented himself to her in the form of a perfect and well-proportioned man. 18Mary said, `I invoke the Most Gracious (God) to defend me from you. If you guard the least against evil (leave me alone).´ 19He said, `I am but a messenger of your Lord. I give you (glad tidings of) a most pure son.´ 20She said, `How can I bear a son while no man (has married me and) has yet touched me, nor have I been unchaste.´ 21(The angel) said, `So the fact is (just as you describe). Your Lord has said, "It is easy for Me. (We shall do it) so that We make him a sign and a (source of) blessing from Us for the people. It is a matter ordained".´ 22She (- Mary) conceived him (- the child) and withdrew with him to a remote place. 23(At the time of the delivery of the child) the throes of child birth drove her to the trunk of the palm-tree. She said, `Oh! would that I had become unconscious before this and had become a thing gone and forgotten.´ 24Then a voice called her from the side of the slope by her (saying), `Do not grieve, your Lord has placed a rivulet on the side of the slope by you (and a chief of the nation has born to you).
The last chapters of the lost "Book Of Barnabas" ( Apostle Paul's offsider ) also says "Jesus did not die on the cross but Judas Iscariot did." Too many sources claim this to be a fact.
*“… his death, which some deny,”* is nebulous and sounds as tho “some” people denied either that Jesus had died at all or that their lives shone forth due to him. It doesn’t say the deniers were Christians, even considering that the letter is to Christians. One translation had “whom some deny,” meaning they deny Jesus (as savior?). Most people at the time did not think Jesus was “the savior”, so that would render the phrase superfluous.
Agree. It's easy, if you're not properly trained in empirical critical thinking to jump from thinking a speculation is a fact because it makes you feel good.
In addition it doesn't say that those people didn't believe that he was crucified, buried and rose from the tomb, only that he didn't die. Maybe because he was taken down so quickly and his legs weren't broke to asphyxiate him as the others were in order to take them down before Passover , as some still believe to this day.
@@Bryan-Paul Then you would need an explanation for why he was removed from the cross. Romans rarely let anyone go. The point of crucifixion was a drawn-out, painful death.
Dear sir, from the original text you have read, no denial of crucifixion can be drawn. "Death, though some deny it, is a mystery" may be a reference to the resurrection. You inserted a lot of meaning that cannot be inferred from the original text.
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
Exactly! If we think about the early Christian, do you think they would give their life for Jesus if they don't actually know the fact that Jesus is really dead and a rose from the dead for our Sins? Well they don't just go home and continue their daily job... (John 20:3) 'Peter and the other disciple left immediately for the tomb. They ran, neck and neck. The other disciple got to the tomb first, outrunning Peter. Stooping to look in, he saw the pieces of linen cloth lying there, but he didn’t go in. Simon Peter arrived after him, entered the tomb, observed the linen cloths lying there, and the kerchief used to cover his head not lying with the linen cloths but separate, neatly folded by itself. Then the other disciple, the one who had gotten there first, went into the tomb, took one look at the evidence, and BELIEVED. No one yet knew from the Scripture that he had to rise from the dead. The disciples then went back home. '
He is only quoting a passage from a book that clearly tells that there existed a group, heretics as they were called, who held the opinion of Jesus being not crucified and thats all. Historians have also mentioned such groups. As for the believers, those who deny believe that he was not crucified and those who do not deny beleive that he was crucified. They are both beleivers in their own sense. I sicerely invite you to go over the scriptures and convince people about your faith. I beleive Paul Williams has not only gone through the religious scriptures of various faiths but has sytematically and logically studied them as well. Moreover, he often quotes from history as well that he did not write. After reading Bart Ehrman (and I advise all to read his books), Paul Williams greatly impresses me. No less than Ehrman but with faith.
This is not true though he misquoted the text it's clearly talking about people who reject He is Messiah. I'm Orthodox we have a 2000 year history so I think I'll believe that over modern day scholars who think they know more than the people who the disciples themselves taught.@@mabika1957
IN MY 1ST DREAM I WAS ON 1 KNEE AND YESHUA WAS OFF THE CROSS. I PUT ☝️ A VIDEO SHOWING MASTER CHRIST SENDING ME A 😇 OF LIGHT. JESUS CHRIST LIVES LIVES THROUGH ME ✡️✝️
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
They were called Docetists. I attended a lecture on St. Ignatius in my church not that long ago, its viewed as an early heresy. I just looked up another excerpt from Ignatius Epistles " He truly assumed a body; for the word was made flesh" (may be alluding to John 1). "He really, and not merely in appearance, was crucified, and died, in the sight of beings in heaven, and on earth, and under the earth."
The crucifixion of Jesus is a historical event that is widely accepted by scholars and historians. The crucifixion of Jesus Christ is a central event in Christian theology and is described in the New Testament accounts, such as the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. These accounts describe Jesus being arrested, tried, and ultimately crucified on a cross. The crucifixion is considered a significant event in the Christian faith, representing Jesus' sacrifice for humanity's sins and his subsequent resurrection. While there may be varying interpretations or alternative theories about this event, the crucifixion of Jesus is a widely accepted historical fact among scholars and Christians alike.
It may be what Gospels are saying, but what Ignatius is saying that some believers did not believe in cricifixion. It implies (i) it was not in the Gospels during Ignatius's lifetime, (ii) curicifixio is a Pauline idea, and it may not be shared by others like James the just, brother of Jesus, who knew Jesus unlike Paul.
The islamic narrative adresses this too, in the qur'an it is mentioned that it was made to appear as if Jesus pbuh was killed, which can be interpreted either as some miraculous illusion, or as a case of mistaken identity, both of which result in Jesus pbuh surviving the event as well as accounts of the event appearing in historical records, Paul might have confused the words a little bit there as Ignatius was talking about the death of Jesus pbuh, not the crucifixion specifically.
@@entertainproxi9140 Yes, but historical evidence also suggests that he was not crucified. He had brothers, possibly sisters and other family members who had their own mission, and they denied Crucifixion. This is invented by Paul who was hostile to Jesus, and tasked with prosecuting them by Herod.
@@Mmkwsdjahf It looks like it. Ignatius is criticizing the Church of Jerusalem in his epistle, and crucifixion is one of the disagreement points he lists. Brother of Jesus did not believe in it. He is in a position to know much better than anyone else. Looks to me Paul's ideas evolved and crucifixion may be added to his portfolio much later than when he had his meeting with James around 60CE. Ignatius was one of his principals.
If the burden of historical evidence that we have to prove the the crucifixion of Jesus Christ is not sufficient, then no other event from antiquity can be proven. The crucifixion of Jesus Christ is by far the best documented event of ANY figure in antiquity, from kings, queens, war lords, etc…
Mention such documentation if you are truthful. Even the disciples of Jesus were not eyes witness to the so called crucifixion. The Bible at the hour of need ALL THE DISCIPLES fled.
The earliest historian saying He was crucifed was Josephus in like 95 AD, and the first Religious Motivated Texts about Him crucified are by paul in 50 AD, A NON eye witness
That doesn’t go against the Quran, it rather approves it because the Quran tells us that it was made to appear as if he was crucified, if nobody recorded that he was crucified this verse would essentially be wrong
I appreciate the scholarly approach to distinguish 1st Century Christian beliefs from one another. You only mention the 1st century believers who didn’t believe in the crucifixion briefly in your summary.
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
@@babisbabinos8075This is the problem dealing with Muslims. They lie too much! Even when you try to listen with an open mind, you’d realize they are hiding the whole information. Early Christians had a lot of different arguments. But last time I checked, Ignacio’s in not a disciple of Jesus.
Christ is the Logos, the Alpha and Omega, He is the only way to eternal life. (John 14:6 KJV) If you are not saved by the blood of the lamb, please remember that He waits at your door until the very end. (Revelation 3:20 KJV) God bless!
@@davidbradberry7637 Matthew 26:28 "For this is my blood of the new testament, which is shed for many for the remission of sins." Romans 3:25 "Whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood, to declare his righteousness for the remission of sins that are past, through the forbearance of God;" Ephesians 1:7 "In whom we have redemption through his blood, the forgiveness of sins, according to the riches of his grace;" Hebrews 10:10 “By the which will we are sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.”
Regarding Paul supposedly saying that God's food laws do not need to be followed... God defines what "food" is in Leviticus 11. Not all animals are called "food". No Jew would consider bats, pig, dog, mice, reptiles, etc to be food. So when Paul says all "FOOD" is clean, he means according to God's definition. What he is speaking against are many Talmudic manmade rules regarding food worthy animals bought from certain people or places and deemed 'unclean' by man for various reasons.
The disciples said to Jesus, "We know you're going to leave us. Who will lead us then?" Jesus said to them, "Wherever you are, you'll go to James the Just, for whom heaven and earth came into being." Saying 12 | Gospel of Thomas Saul : You are saved by faith. James : Faith without action is dead.
The Gospel of Thomas is a second century Gnostic gospel, that actually influenced Muhammad and the Quran. Paul and James were not at odds with eachother. Romans 4 and James 2 are speaking both about Abraham's faith. Paul said that Abraham was justified by his faith, and James is saying that Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac was the proof that he was saved, but Abraham was justified long before that event. Deeds are the fruit of salvation, not the cause of it.
Doctor Bart Ehrman states, “One of the most certain facts of history is that Jesus was crucified by Pontius Pilate. First century Jewish historian Josephus and Roman historian Tacitus RECORDED THE CRUCIFIXION OF JESUS...
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
@@Polyglotfootballer and this proves your point... How exactly? He said peace be upon him the day he was born, the day he dies (after his second coming), and the day he gets raised back to life (i.e. the day of judgement where all humanity will be raised back to life). You've only proved his humanity with this verse you bsolute buffoon
omg, you are the random person who found out the one text in the Qur'an that no other scholar found since 14 centuries, are you joking your self???? muslims have read and memorized the quran, torah and bible over and over more than any of your false priests, of course we know what Isa said!! every human being will die and will be raised back to life on judgment day so what's your point?? @@Polyglotfootballer
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
What're you trying to bring out,hw isn't dead now, he'll come to earth to complete his mission and then he'll die also,and be resurrected to talk about how the ruled his people and make account of what God has sent him for....😂😂😂 Just keep crying @@Polyglotfootballer
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
˹Jesus˺ declared, “I am truly a servant of Allah. He has destined me to be given the Scripture and to be a prophet. He has made me a blessing wherever I go, and bid me to establish prayer and give alms-tax as long as I live, and to be kind to my mother. He has not made me arrogant or defiant. Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” - Surah Maryam 19:30-33[8]
Yup and the docetians seem to not have believed that Jesus died either and they seemed to of composed a large early Christian community. In the gospel of Peter (John Dominic Crossan dates it's passion source as early as the 40's) Jesus' cry from the cross, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" is reported in the Gospel of Peter as "My power, my power, thou hast forsaken me". Immediately after, Peter states that, "when he had said it, he was taken up", suggesting that Jesus did not actually die. This, together with the claim that on the cross Jesus "remained silent, as though he felt no pain", has led many early Christians to accuse the text of docetism. F. F. Bruce writes: The docetic note in this narrative...carefully avoids saying that he died, preferring to say that he 'was taken up', as though he - or at least his soul or spiritual self - was 'assumed' direct from the cross to the presence of God. (We shall see an echo of this idea in the Qur'an. Bruce, F.F. (1974). Jesus and Christian Origins Outside the New Testament
@@BloggingTheologyYou do realise Paul the Dosetics believed Jesus was God and that he also didn't have a physical body right? The noncanan Gospel that idiot quoted has Jesus watching the illusion of his crucifixion because he is a Spirit.
As far as keeping with the Torah with regards to eating Kosher, Jesus said it’s not what goes into a man’s mouth that defiles him but what comes out of it! Matthew 15:11 🙏🙏🙏
what is the explanation of Jesus's words: " Think not I have come to destroy the law but to fulfill it" - Does that mean the laws were applicable to Jesus himself to fulfill or for his followers? I'm a little confused as you guys keep saying Jesus fulfilled the law. If he fulfilled the law, then what law are you supposed to follow?
That's not based enough: "Allah’s Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) said 'Make use of our camels' urine.' They said 'YES!' They drank the camels’ urine . . ." *Sahih Muslim book 16 Number 4131* *Sahih al-Bukhari Volume 2 Number 577* *Sahih al-Bukhari Volume 5 Number 505* *Sahih al-Bukhari Volume 7 Number 623* *Sahih al-Bukhari Volume 8 Number 794*
But he did not say the parenthetical added in some translations stating that he thus declared all food clean and lawful! This is a reordering of priorities and eschewing of hypocrisy - say what is right and good while keeping the Commandments.
@@georgefernandez7558The Golden Compass books were banned just for that. They argued that children believe anything, but as they grow they start to mature and become adults. Adults think for themselves and take no one’s word for anything without critical thinking. The church wants their followers to stay as innocent as children. Never question the father.
Which sin exactly? Paul just wanted you to feel like you aren't in control of your own lives. God gave this life to you, and it's your sole obligation to use it to make it back to him when he is pleased with you. No mediators, no brokers needed. No one to take away your sins. And you aren't responsible for anyone else's sins, not even Adam's. It's between you and God alone.
@@electric1150 so what will happen to those people who died before Christ? Are they all going to hell? Because they all lived and died with the original sin according to you and Paul.
@@haidalibibiti3076 No because Christ died even for their sins. Only those who have rejected God will. And others who really did not have a chance to know Him will be given opportunity at the end times to make decision
@@electric1150 Ca n,a aucun sens dans ces cas la, faisons tous les péches du monde et la vie n,aurait aucun sens c est ridicule !!! Il faut méditer sur ceux qu,on prononce, pas répéter comme un perroquet, a quoi bon le libre arbitre, le bien et mal !!!
Love your research and efforts to clear the man made fabrication about crucifixion of Jesus Christ and spreading the truth to the people who are still oblivious to the fact.
fabrication? its islam fabricated when it say allah made it appear to them that he got crucified. How comes you muslims attack your own book now days just to be anti christ. 🤣😂 Its islam wrong and allah wrong when he made it appeared to be crucified?
But why do you think the crucifixion of Jesus Christ is a "man made fabrication"? I also respect Paul of Blogging Theology but I'm not going to base my understanding and faith on the research of one man ! I won't base my understanding and faith regarding Christianity on one man either! And I won't base my faith regarding the Quran on one man ! So I prefer to listen and learn from various scholars, including Christian and Muslim. And although I find it difficult to understand and learn the historical facts regarding Christianity and Islam, I want to better understand the holy books such as the New Testament Gospels and the Quran. Regarding the crucifixion, I don't find it unreasonable that some early Christians ( and Jews and others ) regarded the crucifixion of Jesus as false. Especially considering that the crucifixion happened 2,000 years ago. So people could have spread rumors by word of mouth that Jesus was not crucified. But the Jewish leaders wanted Jesus to remain buried and dead. So obviously if Jesus was dead, He must have been crucified. And the Roman soldiers were commanded by Pontius Pilate to make sure Jesus was dead on the cross ! And many people witnessed Jesus' crucifixion, including his own mother ! And also John the apostle, the Roman soldiers, and probably some of the women followers of Jesus including Mary Magdalena. So to negate the crucifixion of Jesus, we have to negate almost the entire history as written in the Gospels. If we negate the historical facts of Jesus' crucifixion, I should then become a Muslim ! I'm not trying to be rude or disrespectful to you. I try to respect Muslims because I don't know it all. I don't know all the Truth. Peace of God to you and your family..
@@johnbrzykcy3076 Jesus cruficixion is the most known fact in history even outside bible. If you deny that, that means you deny all history all together because if you go by the historians they see it as a fact now. Im sure muslims do not care any of it anyways they go by what quran say anyways who have no witness nor anything to that event.
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
@@Polyglotfootballer thats so out of context my friend. Dying and coming back to life isnt something exclusive to jesus pbuh. İts a requirement of the muslim faith to believe in resurrection for everybody on the day of judgement
I'm glad someone pointed out the fact that Sauls conversion was actually a perversion of Jesus's teaching. This is proven in the bible yet Christians or rather Paulisians follow the words of Paul and not the words of Jesus!
Ayam Maryam 19:33 Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!” Isa said this in your Quran. Keep following demons
In the first century and the early years of Christianity, there were several sects and groups with diverse beliefs about Jesus and his crucifixion. The only reason they believe that Jesus died on the cross is cuz it's the mainstream Christianity now and the early Christians were killed and prosecuted for having a different belief. 1: Gnostic Christians were a diverse group with varying beliefs, but some Gnostic sects had distinct views on the crucifixion. Some Gnostics believed that Jesus was a purely spiritual being who did not possess a physical body and therefore could not have been crucified in a literal sense. They often saw the crucifixion as a symbolic or spiritual event rather than a historical one. 2: Docetism was a belief held by certain early Christians and Gnostics. Docetists claimed that Jesus only appeared to have a physical body and that his crucifixion was an illusion. According to this view, Jesus' physicality was not real, and his suffering on the cross was a mirage. 3: The Basilideans were followers of Basilides, an early Christian teacher. Some Basilidean beliefs included the notion that Simon of Cyrene, not Jesus, was crucified in Jesus' place. This represents a departure from the traditional Christian understanding of the crucifixion. 4: Cerinthus was an early Christian leader who held views distinct from mainstream Christianity. According to some accounts, Cerinthus believed that the divine Christ descended upon the human Jesus at his baptism but left him before the crucifixion, suggesting that it was the human Jesus who was crucified. 5: The Ebionites were a Jewish-Christian sect that had a different interpretation of Jesus. Some Ebionites rejected the divinity of Jesus and may have had alternative views about the crucifixion, although their beliefs varied among different branches of the sect.
@@johnbrzykcy3076 😊 John, do you know what Jesus said to Nicodemus in the Gospel of John ? Jesus said... that he must be BORN AGAIN to enter into the kingdom of God. 😊 My family and l were baptised in the River Jordan at Yardenit, the Baptismal Site in Israel in November 2016. 👍AND what a wonderful experience that was ! 🤔
@@doreenfernandes2431 The Ganges River is the most sacred river in Hinduism. Hindus believe that bathing in the Ganges will wash away their sins and deliver them from the cycle of birth and death. Your experience holds the same weight as a Hindus experience and that's not the only thing you guys have in common with polytheists.
@@mbahpayaman7672Virtually all of the bible was written over hundreds of years later. All the "eyewitnesses" and the original Christians were monotheistic, they were persecuted and most were killed. We, the Muslims follow the prophet they called the messiah pbuh more than than any Christian, whereas they follow Paul not the man they worship.
@@aribrahim1898 which explains why nothing in the NT mentions the deaths of Petere or Paul and nothing records 70 AD as a done deed .....very puzzling ???
The eye witness of Jesus are all unknown , the four gospels identities are all unknown . Paul never met Jesus , Jesus didn’t come with the religion called “Christianity “ I mean holy moly how can you believe in a made up religion .
Hi Paul, I’m a newly revert (this year). I’m new to your channel. God revealed something to me which why I’m now Muslim. I’m not sure if you covered it. Can I share it with you so maybe one day you can do a video about it. Thanks
@@kwamegordon1448 I’ve studied comparative religion for some time. I asked God to please guide me. During at home Bible study the veil was lifted off my eyes. God revealed to me the person who “resurrected” was Satan (the Prince of this world) 😪 I tried warning my friends and family.
@@kwamegordon1448 It hit me like a ton of bricks. Luke 10:17-18 17 The seventy-two returned with joy and said, “Lord, even the demons submit to us in your name.” 18 He replied, “I saw Satan fall like lightning ⚡️ from heaven.” Luke 24 Jesus Has Risen 24 On the first day of the week, very early in the morning, the women took the spices they had prepared and went to the tomb. 2 They found the stone rolled away from the tomb, 3 but when they entered, they did not find the body of the Lord Jesus. 4 While they were wondering about this, suddenly two men in clothes that gleamed like lightning ⚡️ stood beside them. Matthew 28 Jesus Has Risen 28 After the Sabbath, at dawn on the first day of the week, Mary Magdalene and the other Mary went to look at the tomb. 2 There was a violent earthquake, for an angel of the Lord came down from heaven and, going to the tomb, rolled back the stone and sat on it. 3 His appearance was like lightning ⚡️ , and his clothes were white as snow.
The argument is not whether or not Yahusha was executed by the method referred to as crucifiction, but that he was not hung on a CROSS (an ancient symbol of a sun diety) but that he was hung on a stake (an upright wooden pole). He was executed in this manner, died, was placed in a tomb, and 3 days after burial resurrected to life.
There were people back then (a few decades to a few centuries after Jesus's alleged death) who believed that Jesus did not die or wasn't crucified. And there were people who believed he did and that he rose again, also around the same time. So why should we take either belief as true or one more likely to be true over the other? (apart from the notion of miracles being inherently less likely than natural explanations, a notion which would probably not bode well for Islam or the Quran either)
Well we all can agree that the first ”Christians” followed the law and was abiding by the law and there is a change after Jesus passing where people stopped following the law, and it has to do with the paul doctrine people follow paul not jesus, Paul claimed he saw Jesus in a vision. But as we know Paul was a liar and not reliable!
@@funnynotfunny6984 if Paul was a "liar", why would he honestly have said that he wanted to kill Christians? I believe he did kill Christians, the first followers of Jesus? I'm just curious about your views. No disrespect intended.
@@funnynotfunny6984 We know shit about whether Paul lied or not, don't assume things simply because it is convenient for you. Remember the Jesus worship didn't get started by Paul yet was not in the old law either so don't simply pin it all on him.
@@jabbieforthetruth8757 And? Many witnesses? You mean the Gospels passages that were written decades after Yeshua supposedly died, were likely not first hand accounts, copied from each other and took from older scripture like the Talmud? These text mentioned people being witnesses within the story they tell therefore it is true that there are witnesses? The Islamic claim seems to be that Jesus didn't die from his crucifixion, something that can't be verified anyway.
Allah SWT do not let anyone TOUCH or harm HIS Prophets and Messengers. Did the self made super power of his time Pharaoh\Firoun was able to touch Musa AS, Did Musa AS went with armies or just with the verses of Allah. Was People able to hurt Ibraheem AS. Were people able to hurt Noah AS when He said do whatever you want to do with me, No one can hurt any messenger and Prophet of Allah, No one.
@@georgiacap9294 Yes two different people, Jesus fabricated by Christianity, Essa ibn Marriyum , is prophet and messenger of Allah, Two different people. Jesus was killed, while Essa ibn Marriyum , Peace upon him, is untouchable.
A. Jesus showed he did not die on the cross. Three days after the crucifixion Jesus said in Gospel of John 20:17 “I have not yet ascended to the Father” meaning Jesus has not yet died because Jesus has not yet ascended to God meaning God saved the life of Jesus.
B. Jesus showed he was not resurrected from the dead. Paul said Jesus gave him the following revelation. 1 Corinthians 15:35 “How are the dead raised (resurrected) in what kind of body will they (the resurrected dead) come? . 1 Corinthians 15:44 It is raised (resurrected) a spiritual body (however 3 days after the crucifixion Jesus showed that his body was a physical body which Mary could touch and by eating food and showing nail marks on his hand and a wound on his side to his disciples meaning Jesus showed he was not a resurrected spiritual body but was saved from death on the cross by falling into sleep on the cross and waking up after 3 days in his physical body in the same way as other people who appeared to be dead were only sleeping in their physical body in Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping", Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..." and the Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping". ” … and Gospel of Luke 8:54 - 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned). . Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44 said that the resurrected come in a spiritual not a physical body meaning the physical body of Jesus 3 days after the crucifixion shows Jesus was not resurrected from death but woke up from sleep in his physical body as foreshadowed before the crucifixion in Gospel of Mark 5:39, Gospel of Matthew 9:24 and Gospel of Luke 8:52 where sleep looked like death to everyone.
C. How did God save Jesus from death when everyone saw Jesus die on the cross? Mary in Gospel of John 20:15 asks a man if he has seen the body of Jesus and she does not recognise that she is talking to Jesus which shows how God can make people see and believe whatever God wants people to see and believe and explains how God saved the life of Jesus by making everyone believe Jesus was dead on the cross To make Jesus fall asleep on the cross so that everyone believes Jesus was dead is the same thing that happened to Jonah when everyone believed Jonah was dead but Jonah was also saved by God. God saved Jesus from death like God saved Isaac from death and like God saved Jonah from death.
D. What is the message Jesus delivered after God saved Jesus from death on the cross? Jesus was saved on the cross with sleep and woke up in his physical body after 3 days to tell everyone that he has not yet ascended to God meaning he has not yet died meaning he was not sacrificed for anyone’s sins and Jesus in this same verse continues explaining that he is not God in Gospel of John 20:17 when Jesus says he will go to "my Father (The creator) and your Father (The creator); to my God (my Lord) and your God (your Lord)," meaning Jesus is teaching that he is human like every human and he is not God like every human is not God.
E. Why did God make Jesus, Jonah and Isaac believe they would die and then save them? Every human is tested by God. In the Gospel of Mark 15:34 and Gospel of Matthew 27:46 Jesus showed that he did not lose his trust in God when Jesus on the cross said “My God my God why have you forsaken me?’ and this is when God saved Jesus with sleep and woke up Jesus 3 days later to show that God does not forsake people who put their trust in God in the same way as Jonah was saved because he did not lose his trust in God and in the same way as Isaac was saved because he did not lose his trust in God.
He misquotes the text. The text never says believers deny the death of Jesus. The next sentence of the texts debunks what this guy tries to promote and he goes on to confuse the ten commandments with the mosaic law.
The teachings of Yeshua is in the New Testament if you want to read it! Paul was His loyal servant and died a terrible to death for his faith @nikowagausavou9371. Don't go to books out side of the Bible as you'll find they're mainly that authors opinion on the subject! 🙏🙏🙏
If you want to read the teachings of Yeshua, go to the New Testament. Don't rely on books outside of the Bible as often it's that authors opinion. Paul was Yeshua's faithful servant and died a terrible death for his faith in Yeshua! 🙏🙏🙏
@@maxinedeleon4357the bible even not written by jesus! I don't blve properly on it! Only injil was revealed on jesus and he didn’t write it physically by his hand or his direction! So many editing happened in the bible! Which was written by many people in many different century! And there so many version available! Many confusion!
@@ZahidHasan-tj2rlFirstly, the Gospels Yeshua left the Holy Spirit, the Helper to help the disciples remember JOHN 14:26. Its the Holy Spirit that guided the disciples with discernment and wisdom to help them to remember the events that happened and the message Yeshua wanted to deliver. It was the Holy Spirit that gave the authors of the other books in the New Testament prophesies and made them prophetic. It was the Holy Spirit that gave the authors in the Torah the same thing as in the New Testament. The prophets in the Torah were disciples of YHWH and they had a strong relationship with Him just like Yeshua had a relationship with His disciples. What amazes me and others is Muslims choose to believe a man who was attacked in a cave by a fallen angel and that entity told him to read thr literature 3 times even though he was illiterate. This entity didn't care! This man, Muhammad came 600 years after Yeshua ascended to heaven. He never knew Him or any of his disciples, he spoke a different language and was from another area hundreds of miles away from the events that took place. Furthermore, Muhammad was from a completely different culture. Its beyond belief! Your right, in one thing, there are many confusion, but not with the Bible. The confusion lays with you all. The author of confusion is satan and because non of you're protected you're open to deception and lies. We as Christians protect ourselves all the time. satan is master of the air so of course he'll confuse you! One of the problems that Muslims has is you often look in the Bible for answers or want yo pick holes in it, which a lot of you often do. Muslims always mix up the Qur'anic Jesus Isa with the Biblical Jesus Yeshua. Of course it will create confusion. We as Christians have never done that. We don't need to do that. I've seen people foolishly tried put Allah in the Bible. The Qur'anic Allah is not in the Bible. The Arabic Christian Allah, whose actually YHWH is in the Arabic Bible, which is the same as the Bible! 🙏
*Respect for those who spend time searching to realize that prophet Isa (peace been upon him) didn't die but got saved by God after he answered his prayers ❤*
Honestly sir i dont disagree with what u are saying however it is known outside the bible a man named Yeshua Ha Masi died on a cross there is a lot of proof amd paintings regarding it .❤
The crucefixion existed, no doubt. But was really Jesus the one crucified? The Quran tells us it was only made to appear that he was crucified but he wasnt really crucified and killed.
@@JibreelTheology so, who made it appear that Jesus was crucified? Sounds like the world's greatest deception which resulted in the world's biggest religion. Do you really want to attribute deception to Allah?
@@branzalleyne472 He protected Isa (as). This "deception" only saved Isa (as) and caused no harm to anyone but good only. And the crucefixion didnt necesarilly started christianity. There were multiple factors.
@@JibreelTheology this deception caused lots of "harm". It's the reason why Christians don't follow Allah. Don't you think that's harmful? The death and resurrection were vital for the Christian faith to begin spreading. Paul said it best 1 Corinthians 15:16-17 ESV [16] For if the dead are not raised, not even Christ has been raised. [17] And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins. Jesus' death and resurrection was one of the core reasons for Christianity.
@@branzalleyne472 Christians arent christians because of the curcefixion only. Christianity means to believe Jesus is God and the crucefixion doesnt prove that Isa (as) is God. The false idea that Isa (as) is God comes from other places.
@@doreenfernandes2431 Thanks for your wonderful response because I needed to read such. I've been complaining too much to Jesus. God bless from Florida USA
@@Randy-po8bk one, I’m never wrong, two there where multiple early sects of Christians that believed varying different things in regards to who Christ was, you have those like the ebionites who didn’t think He shared any divinity, you had those who didn’t even believe in the resurrection, you have The Arians who didn’t believe in any sense of a trinity. I can name a couple more if you would like. But as I said it was not a prerequisite to consider your self a Christian until well after the 4th century.
Christians were those that followed Christ’s teachings, his moral lessons about life, and that didn’t originally necessarily have anything to do with crucifixion and resurrection.
@arthurgoonie4596 I highly doubt that. Less than 1% of Christians would be aware of this & probably far far less. 😄 (Very few have even heard of the disagreements between Paul & the Jerusalem Church under James)
