Тёмный

Jodha Akbar Was Incorrect - Medha Bhaskaran Explains Why Akbar Wasn't That Great 

TRS Clips
Подписаться 1,8 млн
Просмотров 829 тыс.
50% 1

Watch The Full Episode Here: • Aurangzeb & Shivaji Ma...
Listen To The Full Episode On Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/1GMb...
🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
open.spotify.com/show/6ZcvVBP...
Check out my Meditation app: Level SuperMind
Get Android - bit.ly/AndroidApp_Link
Get iOS - apple.co/3SyiPcE
Know more about Level :
bit.ly/levellinktree
Follow Medha Bhaskaran's Social Media Handles:-
Instagram: / medha.deshmukh.bhaskaran
Facebook: / medha.bhaskaran
Twitter: / medhadb
LinkedIn: / medha-bhaskaran-467ba2139
✅ Subscribe To Our Other RU-vid Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
BigBrainco. :
/ @raaazofficial
BigBrainco. Shorts :
/ @raaazclips
Welcome to the 3-part special on the story of Shivaji Maharaj, always waited to present this to the audience. Our guest today is Medha Bhaskaran, a microbiologist, an author, and another all-star of The Ranveer Show. The wealth of knowledge she has is truly incredible, honoured to host Medha ma'am at our space for such fantastic episodes we created with her. In this episode, we go into the depths of the Mughal empire, before the Shivaji Maharaj era, and what was the country's socio-economic status back then, what was the reality of the kings and the emperors who ruled our land mass. REAL Stories Of Indian History Uncovered - Watch out.
Medha Bhaskaran, from the year 2000 onwards, started studying Mughal Maratha history as she felt passionate about it. More than a hundred books were referred to, forts visited, and discussions with historians, weapon experts and other people involved in the subjects continued. She is the author of Shivaji's bestselling biography, Challenging Destiny. Amazon Link: www.amazon.in/Challenging-Des...
This episode is a 3-part conversation starting from the rule of the Mughal Empire, before the Shivaji Maharaj era, then part 2 where we talk about the times when India saw the rise of Shivaji Maharaj, and then comes part 3 where we talk about his final vision. Stay Tuned as Part 2 and Part 3 of this series will be released in the following two Tuesdays of the Month of October.
#akbar #1633
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.

Опубликовано:

 

18 окт 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,6 тыс.   
@TheRanveerShowClips
@TheRanveerShowClips Год назад
Check out my Meditation app: Level SuperMind Get Android - bit.ly/AndroidApp_Link Get iOS - apple.co/3SyiPcE Know more about Level : bit.ly/levellinktree
@tradingforliving8264
@tradingforliving8264 Год назад
he is not cruel.
@kalpparashar5017
@kalpparashar5017 Год назад
No ranveer this is also a fiction. The truth is that except britishers and portuguese nobody from outside including the so-called islamists mongol turks crossbreed mughals has ruled us. They ruled mostly delhi . And delhi wasn't of that much importance back then . It's only later after kolkata delhi became the capital. And no muslims has ruled us it's a myth lie created by leftists distortions in service of congress.
@shilpisingh4844
@shilpisingh4844 Год назад
Plz ye video hindi me bhi banaiye because ekta ke akabar show ke lover up state me hai
@poojas8269
@poojas8269 Год назад
A 9
@Bullseye108
@Bullseye108 Месяц назад
Understanding about Akhbar from Urduwood movies like Mughale Azam and Jodha Akhbar is like understanding about Mouse from cartoon mickey mouse and Ratatouille 😂😂
@barkhaagarwalla
@barkhaagarwalla Год назад
This always made me wonder. Why Akbar was shown so empathetic and kind in modern day cinema and television. When we know reading history that he was not. Thankfully, finally, someone is speaking about it. I never understood why Bollywood liked to whitewash him as this Mr. Nice guy.
@adwatt357
@adwatt357 Год назад
Because every jihadi criminal is their hero and its not bollywood its karachiwood run my Porkistan!!
@vinaytalluri
@vinaytalluri Год назад
Bollywood is financed predominantly by the Underworld and BI forces
@tivky
@tivky Год назад
he also looked like central asian and was very short in height.
@barkhaagarwalla
@barkhaagarwalla Год назад
@@tivky Projecting certain kinds of body types as ideal has always been Bollywood's forte. It is really sad as to what Bollywood has done to the standards of Indian cinema.
@vickyray6042
@vickyray6042 Год назад
That's what liberalism and too much leftist ideology does to history...
@cyan3692
@cyan3692 Год назад
The Real Dark side of Bollywood...hitting now as Karma...
@feniljariwala1738
@feniljariwala1738 Год назад
Gutterwood
@muzungchimr3527
@muzungchimr3527 Год назад
No need to bring Bollywood drama here. Its not twitter!!
@cyan3692
@cyan3692 Год назад
@@muzungchimr3527 Jodha Akbar, a product of Bollywood is already here in this video idiot. No one is "bringing" it...
@RojaJaneman
@RojaJaneman Год назад
It’s just the beginning. They won’t learn and will keep losing wealth.
@sergemerto256
@sergemerto256 Год назад
Go comment on Hollywood movies also then 😂😂😂
@virajnaik102
@virajnaik102 Год назад
As per V. D. Savarkar "Akbar was kind means actually he was less cruel than other Mughal emperor"
@Alephbaypay
@Alephbaypay Год назад
yeah like own local ones were any sweeter.. Shiva Bhosle killed 400K Shivites from Hyderabad - men women and children! razed temples and didn't even spare the cattle!
@ashutoshraut2893
@ashutoshraut2893 Год назад
@@ritikkumar1250 correct..madrassa ka topper
@user-dw9hc5jh3t
@user-dw9hc5jh3t Год назад
Not less cruel , actually in Savarkar's time it was not very well known and also Before 1920s i think Savarkar was kind of secular man. They knew about the i$lamic cruelity but not very precisely. I don't actually remember when did savarkar wrote this but yea the Akbarnama and other books became available completely in english after 1930 and so , i guess.
@kvarun88
@kvarun88 Год назад
Exactly. Please put things in perspective.. there are cruel leaders in Non Mughal emperor's too..
@kvarun88
@kvarun88 Год назад
She is jus delusional, like the Ranveer guy.
@juhichaturvedi591
@juhichaturvedi591 Год назад
Honestly I don't think people fell for Akbar's character. Guess it was Hritik's looks and the poise with which he presented the character that people fell in love with. I was 12 year old too back when the movie was released, this brought back memories of good school days and the discussion in classrooms that how the movie and books are different
@rao433
@rao433 Год назад
That's exactly what bullyweed does. Employs good looking/handsome faces to twist history and white washes the gory truth.
@kushagragurnani3730
@kushagragurnani3730 Год назад
@A to Z Everything.. which history have you read bro. persian sources or left wing ones. like literally if mughals had won all wars why is it that our country is still completely hindu. forget hindu sources even english, portugese and dutch sources praise indian resistance to islam.
@soch1110
@soch1110 11 месяцев назад
It was to support love jihad, supported by underworld of bullywood.
@joltheosas9565
@joltheosas9565 7 месяцев назад
​@@kushagragurnani3730because mughals were indianized pretty quickly under akbar bruh jahangir was half rajput shah jahan was 75% rajput they had rajput generals, mughal armies bulk was made up by hindus its not away a religious war like which is presented in media
@flickhunter8900
@flickhunter8900 Год назад
this lady is badass. I loved the way she spilled out truth
@binod7623
@binod7623 Год назад
she is a microbiologist😆
@ifrahasim392
@ifrahasim392 Год назад
I see, and how you know she is right? India is trying to mask history to feel good. She is not even historian .
@wasis001
@wasis001 Год назад
😂😂 microbiologist as historian
@HKG432
@HKG432 Год назад
How the hell is she spilling the truth LOL? She's just an egomaniac sounding like she knows everything
@tanweeransari2132
@tanweeransari2132 Год назад
"The truth is there is no truth, anyone can be god for someone and devil for another" -Eren Kruger (Attack On Titan)
@dhirajheliya6090
@dhirajheliya6090 Год назад
Thanks alot brother for this podcast. I wish someone in Bollywood makes the movie on reality
@spectrum1548
@spectrum1548 Год назад
Yeah the same Bollywood should make a movie on Modi again and show how he paved the way to killing Thousands of muslims.
@abhrajitpaul6057
@abhrajitpaul6057 Год назад
I don't think anyone will. People wants money now days.
@Hershal13
@Hershal13 Год назад
If they do that movie will be boring and no one will be watching it.
@prashantkhodecha7622
@prashantkhodecha7622 Год назад
can you mess with your boss? if not, how can you think that Bollywood will show reality of these Islamic Invaders when major money comes from D-wood.
@EvaraOnline
@EvaraOnline Год назад
🤣🤣🤣acha joke tha
@rgodase
@rgodase Год назад
This interview was needed and thank god it happened.
@SiyaRaama
@SiyaRaama Год назад
Godse ji aap idar .....??? 😂
@rgodase
@rgodase Год назад
@@SiyaRaama 😀 idhar to ana hi padega
@ashishnatraj
@ashishnatraj Год назад
@@SiyaRaama jaha insaaf krna hota hai aur schhai ki baat ho to GODSE JI aate hi hai🙏
@SiyaRaama
@SiyaRaama Год назад
@@ashishnatraj aanahi hai na😂
@msriram9884
@msriram9884 Год назад
The Moghuls were outsiders to India who claimed Mongolian ancestry from Tamerlane and Genghis Khan. Not just in India, in many places when their are outside rulers, they tend to be cruel and uncaring of local indigenous cultures and peoples. The Moghuls, like most outside colonizers, ran an extractive economy that took from the local people. Contrast that to indigenous empires like Ahom, Chola or Vijayanagara where living conditions for the average person benefitted.
@AdityaKapur96
@AdityaKapur96 Год назад
Obviously, when the administration is from the people and the administrators are connected with the public, it would lead to a booming economy and better living standards
@spectrum1548
@spectrum1548 Год назад
Yes that's why we still have Hindu Dynasties and not even a few Mughal dynasties exist.🤣
@PaulAllen6304
@PaulAllen6304 Год назад
Zahiruddin Babur is a heroic figure in Uzbekistan. In Farghana, there is a huge statue of Babur and the park is called Babur square. Uzbeks celebrate him as, "This is the guy who f**ked India hahaha" Irony is, even we Indians celebrate our f**ker We should celebrate Shershaah and Hemu if at all. Shershaah was a Bihari pathan who loved India, and Hemu was his brave general. They really gave Mughals(foreigners) hard time😂😂
@Dhruv_Dogra
@Dhruv_Dogra Год назад
Excellent points...
@Poseiden786
@Poseiden786 Год назад
Mughals were not the descendants of Mongols. The mongols were from today's Mongolia and north-eastern china. The Mughals were turks!
@chaitanyatuckley4666
@chaitanyatuckley4666 Год назад
Thanks Ranveer for bringing these topics up.
@WarriorDeb
@WarriorDeb Год назад
Just visit Rajasthan and you'll know how cruel was Akbar...
@vartikashukla4693
@vartikashukla4693 Год назад
How??
@WarriorDeb
@WarriorDeb Год назад
@@vartikashukla4693 I've visited the place where Jauhar occurred and Queen sacrificed her life with other girls just to save them from the brute cruel forces of Akbar who personally brought hell for the Hindus of Rajasthan
@vartikashukla4693
@vartikashukla4693 Год назад
@@WarriorDeb okay okay....thanks for sharing.....🙏....why bollywood didn't search for these facts before romanticism of Jodha Akbar?? ..........I too believed for more than a decade that inspite of being Mughal and invader he was kind and great...🥲🥲
@WarriorDeb
@WarriorDeb Год назад
@@vartikashukla4693 Bollywood is full of propaganda, but you should visit Rajasthan once to know more, I've visited almost entire India and I've seen places, have known histories which depicts the plight of the Hindus. You'll cry when you'll listen to stories of Kashmiri Hindus, One Hindu caretaker who is now converted to Islam, told us the stories, which I can't tell you here.
@WarriorDeb
@WarriorDeb Год назад
@@vartikashukla4693 My present profile picture is captured by me, it's the picture of the monument of Maharana Pratap with his horse Chetak in Rajasthan...
@manishkarnik
@manishkarnik Год назад
Her book Challeging Destiny was an eye opener, it also helps with building fortitude.
@giris5962
@giris5962 Год назад
Literally i feel terrible when the history of Peshawa Bajirao Rao 's is twisted by these Bollywood insane people 😠
@milind8783
@milind8783 Год назад
That intimate scenes - so embarrassing to watch our Hiro like that. 😏😏
@ghaniakhan1697
@ghaniakhan1697 Год назад
@@milind8783 absolutely right
@mehh9364
@mehh9364 Год назад
Can you please educate me on this please? I was wondering how accurate that movie was after getting to know the dark history or akbar!
@milind8783
@milind8783 Год назад
@@mehh9364 his army attack chittorgarh - birth place of Maharana Prataap and after victory, his army killed almost 10,000 innocent Hindus. He had 3000 concubines and around 200+ boyfriend. Today's terrorist are nothing in front of him.
@mehh9364
@mehh9364 Год назад
@@milind8783 I'm sorry but who are you talking about?
@jayakrushnasahoo4403
@jayakrushnasahoo4403 Год назад
"Do you think all of the history's characters are great?" - that's a deeply rooted good question.. Kudos 👍👍
@bapparawal2457
@bapparawal2457 Год назад
Is all human beings good?? Seriously . No . Then how can all historical figures be great?
@kianim8344
@kianim8344 Год назад
Who asks this stupid question ? Of course not every character were great because they were humans and every human is not same and I mean random human not fate-selected celestial humans
@sarfarazjelil7080
@sarfarazjelil7080 Год назад
That’s the stupidest question of all time.
@sugakookies1710
@sugakookies1710 Год назад
Good people would never be able to raise to that level of power
@thetalltree2855
@thetalltree2855 Год назад
Deeply rooted? Haha... That's so shallow and stupid. To rise to a level of power even in civilised world of today involves being downright cruel and ruthless. Back then wars, invasions annexation was the norm.
@satyamvijayvargiya8616
@satyamvijayvargiya8616 Год назад
This is y i love your Podcast Ranveer.. you show us some fact which are also dark secrets
@anishakakkar6358
@anishakakkar6358 Год назад
As history major, I definitely get what she means by " not watching historical movies or dramas" .. these movies are messed up ngl
@summaiyaamir5709
@summaiyaamir5709 11 месяцев назад
Strage, she mentioned multiple times that the movie was incorrect without pointing out what was incorrect in the movie. She isn't being specific and said "I would rather not talk about it".
@akshat7055
@akshat7055 Год назад
"Akbar-The Great" that was he title of the chapter about akbar in my 4th class history ook so not just movie but when we are taught the same in in school too both of them togeather creates that image of akbar,a kind and a gentle one which is far away from the reality
@gia42472
@gia42472 Год назад
He is called the great not because he was innocent or cruel but because of his policies, warfare techniques etc. Alexander is called the great. He is considered cruelest king ever. But he conquered the world. That's why he is called great not because of him being good king. There's nothing like good king. Broaden your horizon.
@rggonsalves6516
@rggonsalves6516 Год назад
It was fascinating to learn about history from a highly qualified microbiologist and entrepreneur! Absolute nonsense!
@WhatisDeath
@WhatisDeath Год назад
@@gia42472 that's foolishness, imagine conquering the world, taking so many lives, sadness pain sorrow of families, then they died :D they played an important role in teaching the world what not to do. They are not great, they were fools. Look at RAM he always thought about his people, his wife his brothers and his teaching are still remembered, this is greatness
@gia42472
@gia42472 Год назад
@@WhatisDeath bro, ram is God while these others aren't. Understand the difference.
@JamesBond-dj3wo
@JamesBond-dj3wo Год назад
@Gia N Ya the greatness is not all about king it's about what contribution he gave to state. . He killed his brother like Adam Khan because he attacked malwa and misbehave queen Rupmati.
@ratnachaudhary03
@ratnachaudhary03 Год назад
Yes , this needs to come out 💯
@mansi6831
@mansi6831 Год назад
actually ranveer really todoing appreciable job by called that person on his podcast who really know values of sanatan and india .... and show the reality of our kind, merciful, intelligent (as per our textbook) mughals king ........good job ranveer ❤
@trinacoco8047
@trinacoco8047 Год назад
I think in this case the famous tv serial Jodhaa Akbar did some justice ,because neither it showed only the "pious" side of Akbar it was something worth watching..I feel so
@Yogi_The_Bitter_Truth_2408
@Yogi_The_Bitter_Truth_2408 Год назад
utter nonsense. a jihadi terrorist was converted into a kind man in these 2 kaudi ke dramas. it's like saying hitler is a kind man.
@aashtha_21
@aashtha_21 Год назад
Agreed 💯
@rd_HIND
@rd_HIND Год назад
Akbar had a pious side only in leftist textbooks , nowhere in reality.
@mohanaraga6477
@mohanaraga6477 Год назад
😂😂😂 they didn't show that he killed his subordinates to have their wives and satisfy his lust..
@travel.music.food.5403
@travel.music.food.5403 Год назад
@@mohanaraga6477 Then why did he stop the practice of haram?
@vinitapannu3211
@vinitapannu3211 Год назад
Medha Bhaskaran ji , I fully agree with you..we believed what we were taught in school and college .how distorted the truth is I am getting to know now listening to factual talks based on true knowledge from you.. there are countless like me am sure..thank you for your inputs.. 🙏🇮🇳
@bhairavijagtap2526
@bhairavijagtap2526 Год назад
Really enjoyed the podcast, and appreciate the honesty and capacity of medhaji to tell us the truth about our history in simple yet strong words. Feel blessed to be able to avail this knowledge. Will surely buy your books ma'am.. May you have best of health, to research, write books and educate us.
@srsrt6979
@srsrt6979 Год назад
Ranveer bhaiya u r winning hearts by showing the reality
@samruddhipaiyawal5586
@samruddhipaiyawal5586 Год назад
Wow the way she's talking the truth is really appreciable!
@nousgj4212
@nousgj4212 Год назад
That's why there have always been controversies associated with all historical fictions made by Sanjay Leela Bhansali. Directors like him have twisted the stories in the name freedom of creativity doing gross injustice to the characters whose names and characters were based on real people who existed. There is one thing to be inspired by a historical figure create a fictional story loosely based on them. But it's another thing to take a historical figure in its entirety and completely change the intent and execution of the decisions they took in those times or to fabricate false relationship stories about them that never existed.
@yug4883
@yug4883 Год назад
Sanjay Leela Bhansali showed wrong history of Bajirao Mastani also i mean according to history it's never Bajirao Mastani means marrying more than more person was common at that time, and movie didn't highlighted bravery of Bajirao
@vrishalisonar453
@vrishalisonar453 Год назад
I personally find him overrated , less of brain n more of melodrama. Though good in aesthetics
@yug4883
@yug4883 Год назад
@@vrishalisonar453 whom?
@PramodYadav-wo4zu
@PramodYadav-wo4zu Год назад
So true. This is also the case with movie like gangubai. If u dig deeper gangubai was no social worker at all. She was a pimp and she forced woman into prostitution, so celebrate such character
@yug4883
@yug4883 Год назад
@@PramodYadav-wo4zu true 😂
@beingit916
@beingit916 Год назад
Yes I agree with you
@beingcyrus6821
@beingcyrus6821 Год назад
Defaced, broken sculptures and statues of Hindu/ Buddhist/ Jain deities show a lot about how tolerant were these Mughals towards native population. These evil worshipers left no stone unturned to destroy everything that depicted glory and magnificence of Hindu culture and traditions.
@thededro3352
@thededro3352 Год назад
She knows exactly what people want to listen 😂😂
@Orangeapple894b
@Orangeapple894b 11 месяцев назад
What can be expected from bjp agent podcast
@simranpoptanii
@simranpoptanii 10 месяцев назад
She is right. Go do some research
@Orangeapple894b
@Orangeapple894b 10 месяцев назад
@@simranpoptanii No, she isn't totally correct. She is a godi type person. I have watched some of her other videos. Even his podcast is bjp agen-da friendly.
@JustJuveeee
@JustJuveeee Год назад
If Akbar was not that great. So was allahudin khilji was not cruel as shown in padmavat. He was not barbaric, Nobody really want to learn reality. Plus nobody knows the actual reality. And kings irrespective any religion, country all wanted power and kingdom. They have done some good, some evil. That's human. That's politics. Thats world.
@JohnWick-nm6jx
@JohnWick-nm6jx Год назад
Akbar Wasn't Great, He Was Great Amongst Mughals. That's Why We Call Him Great .
@chandnisahani6289
@chandnisahani6289 Год назад
Hey go read books and then speak not by ur small mind pr choro tum jaise log jo jahangir etc all Mughal ko apna idol mante ho vo kya bolega and jakr dekhna jo galat h unhe hm k bhi bhi apna idol nhi bolte like u people,,Galt Galat hota h chahe vo koi bhi kre yeh nhi kaha ki hmare yahan sab acha hai pr bure ko hm apna idol nhi mante kyunki vo hindu hoga to samjhe pr etc ....... Bahut kuch h chahe jitna bol lo tumhare pale nhi pr ne vala so leave it .
@dparamful
@dparamful Год назад
The Mughals were all about violence.
@sreeram3247
@sreeram3247 Год назад
You can give the reference books madam mentioning in the description, it may help viewers to reach out to them and read.
@PaulAllen6304
@PaulAllen6304 Год назад
First of all, Hrithik was a more inaccurate choice for Akbar than Priyanka was for Mary Kom. Akbar was short, only 5'5, fat, pale, with a thin moustache and mongolian eyes(sources claim even his wives were taller than him) And then there is Hrithik, 6'1 inch, tanned, green eyes, chiseled face...lol. He would have been good as Shershaah Suri or Hemu, but not Akbar
@millennialmind9507
@millennialmind9507 Год назад
Not even 5.5
@anasqureshi644
@anasqureshi644 Год назад
Sounds like you have more problems with shorter people than Akbar himself 😅😅😅😅
@PaulAllen6304
@PaulAllen6304 Год назад
@@anasqureshi644 Nope...I have problem with the way Akbar is potrayed as this incredible handsome man...
@banasmitakalita7373
@banasmitakalita7373 Год назад
@@anasqureshi644 can u read the comment properly again bruh?
@banasmitakalita7373
@banasmitakalita7373 Год назад
@@PaulAllen6304 naur these bollywood directors love to cast good looking guys in their movies so that desperate audience would watch em lol
@zet99darius87
@zet99darius87 Год назад
"I m no historian" but write books about history? What?
@kunalbansal5350
@kunalbansal5350 Год назад
She said she has *read* books watch the video properly
@zet99darius87
@zet99darius87 Год назад
@@kunalbansal5350 what books?
@anonymous-uf8us
@anonymous-uf8us Год назад
She lost her argument and her true colour when she said she only watched 15 minutes of the movie
@archiem654
@archiem654 Год назад
... these people are same like the muslim fundamentalists they criticise...
@nishantmishra9679
@nishantmishra9679 Год назад
@@archiem654 there's no benefit in watching a movie which is 180degree opposite from the reality she knows what the reality is so why she should watch that fake portrayal of a character??? Akbar was a cruel person you should read about his conquest in Chittorgarh there he slaughtered 30000 innocent Hindus
@nishantmishra9679
@nishantmishra9679 Год назад
@@archiem654 Akbar was so cruel that he even converted birwal to Islam who was Hindu Brahmin
@archiem654
@archiem654 Год назад
@@nishantmishra9679 if that was true, we would know Birbal by his muslim name.
@mercyseeker8471
@mercyseeker8471 Год назад
@@archiem654 obviously!
@mohammad-bin-dajjal
@mohammad-bin-dajjal Год назад
Get J. Sai Deepak he is a man with a spine and doesnt mince his words, unlike the lady here who is scared of god knows what.
@shodhitgoyal6539
@shodhitgoyal6539 Год назад
He won't bring the one and only liberandu killer, he might drop too kuch truth bombs. Ranveer could not handle that
@Anjaney10
@Anjaney10 Год назад
Yeah he was cruel but in that movie they showed just his love for jodha not his kindness.......kabhi kabhi suna hua or dekha hua sach nhi hota, agr galti hi cahiye to phr galtiyan hi dikhengi it's just a movie and nothing, don't be crazy
@sinshu5269
@sinshu5269 Год назад
I love the work "Keyboard Warrior" 😂😂😂
@madhutalaari
@madhutalaari Год назад
It's a ten year old word
@satishkumar-xt5fe
@satishkumar-xt5fe Год назад
It's always difficult even with the best of the historians to cleary depict the picture of what would have happened in past as they have their limitations. It's even more difficult to interpretate the happening of the past as many tend to be biased and are guided by irrational thinking patterns.
@amishasingh6227
@amishasingh6227 Год назад
good to watch as a story not as history 😍
@SKB-fv8ze
@SKB-fv8ze Год назад
In India Ram Sethu is symbol of Love , devotion & eternal purity. How can Akbar be a true lover where he marries to every nine month? Most of His marriage happened either to fulfil his lust or political gain nothing else.
@Kunwar_Arjun
@Kunwar_Arjun Год назад
It's becoz Taj Mahal was built by Shah Jahan. But what ur saying is correct though.
@jinalvaghelabts4115
@jinalvaghelabts4115 Год назад
Tu History padh whatsApp university se gyan mat le
@jinalvaghelabts4115
@jinalvaghelabts4115 Год назад
Sab workers ko paise diye the usse enhone nayi city banayi shazahanabad yani ki old delhi
@Growth4Mindset
@Growth4Mindset Год назад
Mere bhai kisi bhi wokers ka haath ni kaata Gaya tha
@SKB-fv8ze
@SKB-fv8ze Год назад
@@jinalvaghelabts4115 U dear historian please check the Meaning of Orat this word arise from his rule. Also read what he did to his 1st wife.Meena bazar was greatly promoted during his rule where women were sell off .
@veerbhogayevasundara7720
@veerbhogayevasundara7720 Год назад
Wrong perception of India 1. Gandhiji father of India 2 . Akbar was great 3. Nehru was a greatest PM
@user-oe3hb6cs7o
@user-oe3hb6cs7o 28 дней назад
Want to ask why the 1st one is wrong,, as i beleive you must have studied about this,, so , plz do explain
@user-oe3hb6cs7o
@user-oe3hb6cs7o 28 дней назад
N plzz try not to give what's up answers
@Mr_W_9102
@Mr_W_9102 15 дней назад
4. Savarkar was Veer or freedom fighter 😂 5. Godse was patriot 😂 6. Modi was Vishwa guru 😂
@Dhruv_Dogra
@Dhruv_Dogra Год назад
Medha Bhaskaran ji is a great person. She deserves the respect of every self-aware Indian.
@midhunramachandran5131
@midhunramachandran5131 Год назад
it's simple that there are lot of funding happens from east Asian countries especially on our cinee industry.... really hatsoff to this lady to talk the truth openly and you pplz are boldly telecasting it... congrats buddy
@TheStarcrush
@TheStarcrush Год назад
Name a king that won battles with love
@sanaksanandan
@sanaksanandan Год назад
It's not about the violence in battles. It's the violence outside the battle field that they unleashed, on civilians. That's the difference between a good king, and an evil one.
@Vajrapani108
@Vajrapani108 Год назад
Killing soldiers in battle=/= killing civilans and raping women
@rgseven6557
@rgseven6557 3 месяца назад
You missed the point
@ManishSharma-yu5jh
@ManishSharma-yu5jh Год назад
I wonder why different historians differ in their opinions so much if the source of information is same, like the Akbarnama.
@seerlavenkatapriyanka
@seerlavenkatapriyanka 11 месяцев назад
Good point. It depends on how we see and understand. Everyone have their own point of view. The one statement which 3 people listen will take it in 3 different ways and understand it in 3 different ways
@thetalltree2855
@thetalltree2855 Год назад
Great video ranveer. Pls do a podcast on maratha invasions of bengal.
@AuRoRa_28
@AuRoRa_28 Год назад
This is exactly what my dad also said Thank You Ranveer for this podcast👍👍 It's high time people understand the truth and not get brainwashed by these bolly dramas
@rkrkdjdj845
@rkrkdjdj845 Год назад
Which ruler, conqueror or king wasn’t cruel ? Battles and wars were part of almost every king, it may be due to saving one’s kingdom or to expand it. If Alexander and Ashoka, despite butchering millions can be Great, why can’t be Akbar. Akbar was Great because of his tolerance and respect towards other religions. He even tried to unite all under one religion Deen e ilahi, which was failure. Rajputs flourished under his reign and so their religion.
@veerswami7175
@veerswami7175 Год назад
He forcefully convert one raja to Islam and his new name was naibat khan
@rkrkdjdj845
@rkrkdjdj845 Год назад
@@veerswami7175 brother, he was not even himself a hardcore Muslim.
@JohnWick-nm6jx
@JohnWick-nm6jx Год назад
Akbar Wasn't Great He Was Great Amongst Other Mughal Rulers . Every King is Not Cruel , They Were The Owners Of Powers & For Their People They Used To Attack , Defend Etc . Etc . But The Other Kings Would Win The War & Dominate Their As Their New King But They Didn't Took Away Womens as Tools, Didn't Humiliated Other Religions , Didn't Broke Their Religious Places & Mughals Looted Us , Never Think They Rule & Lived Here They Just Wasted Most Of Their Money In Just Maintaining Their Luxury, in The Era Of. Mughals India's GDP Deteriorating & Not Increasing
@sugakookies1710
@sugakookies1710 Год назад
People keep forgetting Akbar the great means Akbar was a great ruler not that he was a great person
@yusufs9921
@yusufs9921 Год назад
Hindu kings mahaan the bas bakhi sab chootiya the. Ashoka great tha 1lakh logon ko maarne ke baad apne bhaion ko maardiya. Sab historian chootiya the bas aunty proper historian hain.
@mujibultanim
@mujibultanim Год назад
she watched for only 15 minutes and then came to a conclusion, how on earth she was talking about it. I am not saying that was the perfect depiction of Akbar, but come on! someone is giving opinions based on her 15 minutes of watch time.
@priyankabm3732
@priyankabm3732 Год назад
Your podcast topics are really amazing and very informative. Thank you for sharing the information and best content. Whenever I watch your podcast I always get involved . Keep going 👏👏 god bless you. My request from you is can you please invite Ms. Keerthihistory.
@expeditioner9322
@expeditioner9322 Год назад
Was there any king who ruled over large tracts and his rule did not involve any torture?
@inderguruwada1760
@inderguruwada1760 Год назад
An eye opener. Youth must watch. Do not take movies seriously 😄
@KMILIND
@KMILIND Год назад
There is a disclaimer after the film, people miss that. Besides it’s a fiction at least that mond we should apply as audience.
@nilrocks
@nilrocks Год назад
These are so knowledgeable sessions. Thanks for such wonderful lessons.
@kartikvv
@kartikvv Год назад
You should take this feedback and confront the makers of such bollywood masala historicals. That will be fun
@mmmusicmeditation999
@mmmusicmeditation999 Год назад
Mam is totally completely right.... The histories are all twisted..... Congrats Mam
@zerogravity239
@zerogravity239 Год назад
"Killing subordinates and taking their women" 🙄 Great
@erwinrommel9705
@erwinrommel9705 Год назад
Bhai ab aap improve kar rahe ho...mai pahle aapko achha host nahi samjhta tha par ab aapko dekhe achha lagta hai.
@NeerajKumar-dk1tk
@NeerajKumar-dk1tk Год назад
Invite Neeraj Atri ... he has very knowledge over history , religion and NCRT..... you will get at least 150 podcast from that person and you will become fan of that person the way and depth he talk
@KomalSingh-tu5ss
@KomalSingh-tu5ss Год назад
Ranveer sir u r the best public speaker. Thankuuu for every videos.
@kushalsubba7089
@kushalsubba7089 Год назад
Mam can you give me the reference of authors and history books you read after all your are not a historian
@armaanarmaan5013
@armaanarmaan5013 Год назад
exactly
@niteku6448
@niteku6448 Год назад
No king is saint
@anikaaaaaa2230
@anikaaaaaa2230 7 месяцев назад
Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj was one🙏🌺
@AMAN-wp8ez
@AMAN-wp8ez 2 месяца назад
except HINDU KINGS
@Kavitva
@Kavitva Год назад
Hello Mister, what about the second part of this video?
@tiscachip
@tiscachip Год назад
This episode is the most engaging one of all..infact best podcast ever
@swapnarony4085
@swapnarony4085 Год назад
90% of the kings were cruel. Kanishka and Asoka caused the bloodiest wars and after all that they did for power and with other things they went into Buddhism when they were much older. I don't see them different from our politicians today.
@veerswami7175
@veerswami7175 Год назад
Ashoka was Buddhist before Kalinga war and kaniska is very unique hybrid of vaishnvaite and Buddhism faith in his reigns Buddha also considered as 9 th avatar of visnu
@anandpandey9988
@anandpandey9988 Год назад
Ashok had embraced Buddhism much before Kaling war... Not in old-age.
@bikiron8929
@bikiron8929 Год назад
Yes , so true . Most of the Kings from our history were meant to be cruel . Even many Hindu Kings fought with each other , killing millions of people. I don't understand why people have so much fascination for Kings and Kingdoms . Concepts such as Humanity , human rights etc didn't existed back then .Killing someone was a sign of bravery and power . And yes you are right there is no difference with todays politicians . It's because Kings , politicians represent the evil mindset of masses whom they represent . People make Kings ,politicians as hero because they fight for their evil causes . You can take the example of todays world leaders .
@checkalpha
@checkalpha Год назад
You should do interview with Mr Manu S Pillai he is a young historian he can give a lot of historical facts His book the ivory throne was good to read about kings and queens of Kerala
@NidhiTalks
@NidhiTalks Год назад
Thank you for this podcast. 🌺
@saikripa1607
@saikripa1607 Год назад
Even history books depict only the historian’s side of the story, history through the historian’s eyes.. the same history would have different colours through subaltern portrayal of history. So there is no absolute truth, it is always relative.
@lazy_panda8771
@lazy_panda8771 Год назад
Fiction is different from evidence. We know half truth yeah but making something from imagination is fiction. Not even half truth
@damantimech4910
@damantimech4910 Год назад
Couldn't agree more 🙌
@nikhilyn144
@nikhilyn144 Год назад
His history reference of Akbar is Jodha Akbar and Hrithik Roshan 😌..my God
@mumalpanwar3851
@mumalpanwar3851 Год назад
Many people have a lot to say about it ... Call real " Historian " rather than a "Microbiologist".
@reetikasidana3784
@reetikasidana3784 Год назад
I would like to read the book which she is talking about . Pls share the details
@jf1341
@jf1341 Год назад
0:48 does not cite which book
@punjikara
@punjikara Год назад
Watching a movie expecting that it's true story is kind of funny, that's why the disclaimer is given at the start of all movies...am not saying movies won't influence ppl, it will influence that's the fact, but art is art, the creator has some freedom he can twist and turn it...the movie is evaluated not by its exact minute depiction of facts only it's about the art form, acting, techniques and if it's not distorting the facts completely then it should be okay. Now what is the truth, no one really knows... Everyone are good for someone and bad for someothers, all kings with some ambition were cruel to many masses, they used to conquer, kill, rape and use ppl. They ruled as they seemed fit...many raided other territories including the Marathas, Tippu, Cholas, Guptas, everyone...that was the way of Life then. What is treated as greatness or what defined greatness in those times were whether they ruled a massive territory or whether they were feared and respected by the majority... whether they commissioned great art and architecture during their reign...whether their Cities were renowned and multi cultural and that was the norm...in that aspect India had many great kings and Akbar was one of them. So if u say some king was cruel then including Ashoka they were all cruel to someone at some point...and no one is great...anyone with power over masses tend to use it.. against them...that's the fact. Depiction should not be biased that's true, and to an extent i can understand what's she sayn but i think she is also biased...
@Canseefornewchange
@Canseefornewchange Год назад
Thanks for bringing the truth to light 🔥❤️ bollywood deserves boycott
@KaranSharma-rd2yr
@KaranSharma-rd2yr Год назад
as a student of history I am able to understand what are you saying...
@chiragkumar9929
@chiragkumar9929 Год назад
This woman sounded very ignorant. She just wanted to say her point and get it over without any facts.
@sandeepraman4469
@sandeepraman4469 Год назад
The films she named were not claimed as "Based on true story" it was just a movie. See people are real sensitive about such factors and can't appreciate art. This movie is just a story, and a story is completely one's perception. The movie makers made this film based on thier perceptions, never on the facts and never claimed. If you miss judged this, and if Akbar for you is Hrithik Roshan, you should probably blame your history teacher for it.
@mAviralbhanu
@mAviralbhanu Год назад
As she said, for viewers a fiction presented as history will become real history for the viewer who is unaware. This is because viewer will not be able to filter what is real and what is fiction. So since it sets rhetorics and changes people's idea of reality, hence can not be called art for sure. Can be called a propoganda though.
@Dennis56781000
@Dennis56781000 Год назад
​@@mAviralbhanu Agreed, a normal Joe in India subconsciously accepts whatever shown on the TV as the plain truth. The idea that they are being played doesn't even strike their mind. After watching Prithviraj I told my grandfather that it was fake. He didn't believe me Lol. And he was a senior officer in the govt in his heyday. That's why films need to be countered with utmost religiosity.
@mAviralbhanu
@mAviralbhanu Год назад
@@Dennis56781000 viewers can be foreigners as well. This confuses people abroad, because they can't reason out why Indians are romanticising invaders. I mean, nobody romanticise hitler or stalin in name of art.
@Dennis56781000
@Dennis56781000 Год назад
@@mAviralbhanu I don't think foreigners pay that much attention to us tbh. They'd properly start noticing us when we have solid hard power, just like they're noticing China right now. Maybe in the future! I see Bollywood as a primarily tool to control domestic narratives. The usual trope being sterilize the majority community by challenging their faith, practices etc and glorify only the minority abrahamic faiths. Minority Indic faiths like Buddhism and Jainism are not even mentioned at all and Sikh characters are stereotyped and used for comic relief.
@sandeepraman4469
@sandeepraman4469 Год назад
@@mAviralbhanu that's true. The message sometimes is not clear. But there are many movie makers who successfully announced indirectly that it's thier perception of the whole event.
@HumayunMohammed
@HumayunMohammed Год назад
there were instances of Hindu kings destroying Buddhist temples and monuments in ancient India. In the past, there were occasional conflicts and tensions between Hinduism and Buddhism, which led to instances of temple destruction and desecration. One of the most significant instances of temple destruction by a Hindu king was during the reign of King Shashanka in the 7th century CE. King Shashanka is said to have destroyed several Buddhist temples and monuments in present-day Bangladesh, including the famous Mahavihara monastery in Nalanda. There were also instances of temple destruction and desecration by other rulers and empires, including the Mughal Empire. For example, during the reign of Emperor Aurangzeb, several Buddhist temples and monuments, including the famous Sarnath stupa, were destroyed or damaged.
@Vikas-gz4ov
@Vikas-gz4ov 10 месяцев назад
Adipurush is the best example of Bollywood people's Research..😂😂
@mediwana
@mediwana Год назад
2:15 Hiatory ke bare me ham poora sach kabhi nhi mil sakta.... Kabhi nhi ..... Yha ek din ki incident par hajoro concipracy creat kr di jati hai.... Akabar jodha to kitne saal ho gyw.... So simple.... Kuch bhi pure nhi hai.....
@newsjunkieish
@newsjunkieish Год назад
Problem with biopics in India is that they need a big hero or actor to helm the project and then paint the subject as a hero as well. No one is willing to engage with a no holds barred, all shades depiction of truth and reality. But I don't blame the filmmakers also because someone somewhere always takes offence.
@k.s.9400
@k.s.9400 Год назад
Literally every historical drama makes the person seem less terrible than they were in real life.
@magnisky
@magnisky Год назад
Can she explain who the real Akbhar and jodha were? That would enlighten us way more than just saying movie isn’t accurate.
@Makeupbyshaiesta
@Makeupbyshaiesta Год назад
I don’t agree with her. Being a ruler , they had to do so many things NOT only Mughals but every king. In our country only we had so many cruel kings we should name them as well.
@nishugowda6172
@nishugowda6172 Год назад
We had cruel kings but not cruel as mughals. Ashoka was a cruel king in terms of war but he made great work towards his kingdom and respected women. He married many but with consent for political reason. But akbar had 1000 women in h8s haram apart from 300 wives. He used to capture ladies in war. Killed lakhs of hindus because they didnt convert
@kdjimmy103
@kdjimmy103 Год назад
Hope we don't get all the sides to see of a king other side too not much but little in movie will do
@thefoodpriest6614
@thefoodpriest6614 Год назад
Also paying real attention to the concept of half-truth by Medha
@jordanthepeoplessinger7845
@jordanthepeoplessinger7845 Год назад
Interview should be mostly in Hindi soo many people from various parts of our country understand these reality in a better way
@shubhampahurkar00
@shubhampahurkar00 Год назад
We have a tendency to look at historical figures from the modern lens of rationalism and humanism . Akbar was considered as a liberal king because of his actions that were contrary to what was considered common in that era. IDK if she’s historian or what but she fails to historicise and contextualise history while studying it !
@sayanchatterjee355
@sayanchatterjee355 Год назад
Unfortunately, none of these alternate versions of history are backed by any certified evidence, citations, or solid research methodology, whether archival, archeological, or anthropological. I would love to know about Medha Bhaskararan's sources.
@YASHWANTH25691
@YASHWANTH25691 Год назад
you are certifying without giving any evidence and this is bullshit
@anonymousboy8802
@anonymousboy8802 Год назад
shes a microbiologist not a historian.😂
@sayanchatterjee355
@sayanchatterjee355 Год назад
@@anonymousboy8802 I guess Ranveer gets all his history lessons from microbiologists, physicists, doctors, engineers, conspiracy theorists.. pretty much everyone except legitimate university-employed historians
@austin426512
@austin426512 Год назад
@@sayanchatterjee355 yea like JNU professors, who only commies love for their anti Hindu bias
@msriram9884
@msriram9884 Год назад
Please refer to Meenakshi Jain’s talks on the Moghuls. She gives plenty of citations for her work. And also the comment, that only people who professionally studied “history” in Western style are qualified to discuss it, is erroneous. It is a very subjective topic. It is not like science or engineering or medicine.
@ibrahimgadli2583
@ibrahimgadli2583 Год назад
Now it's hard to believe in all the historical character
@saif9765
@saif9765 Год назад
Please give the references !!!
@KAHLAN54
@KAHLAN54 Год назад
I stand unbiased. I am not taking sides. But whenever, some opinions are made it ought to be backed by appropriate proof.
@arnabmitra11
@arnabmitra11 Год назад
Ranveer is doing a commendable job getting people from different spectrum of life to the fore. But often Ranveers total lack of any knowledge of the subject matter or any preparation for the interview makes these interviews quite often quite shallow and superficial. I don’t know about Ranveer’s educational background but it is pretty obvious that Ranveer is not well read , as a well wisher my advice would be to prepare for an interview, read some of the books or artefacts that the interviewee has written.
@srvbhmk265
@srvbhmk265 Год назад
true i felt that too that the host was cringe
@drshahmina6412
@drshahmina6412 Год назад
He is just following the western influence of conducting a podcast
@sangeetabansal8175
@sangeetabansal8175 Год назад
I would like to listen more from Medha ji. I m from South Mumbai
@Mn-px2ji
@Mn-px2ji Год назад
Can u plz make a podcast on bhoota kola which is based on Manglorean culture and recent movie KANTARA
@chaitanyatuckley4666
@chaitanyatuckley4666 Год назад
Winners of war? Seriously?
@siddhantbhanot6850
@siddhantbhanot6850 Год назад
really a dumb argument by Ranveer
@vartikashukla4693
@vartikashukla4693 Год назад
And some peacefuls beleive Mughals were their ancestors and treat them as ideals.....🥴🥴🥵🥵
@rmr5381
@rmr5381 Год назад
Even the gods in the puranas or any religious trxts are not great..then why humans? No one is all good thats the truth 😊
@HKG432
@HKG432 Год назад
I have won an award so I know everything, you don't know? What's this bias statement?
@JAXX-wm6vr
@JAXX-wm6vr Год назад
Many people say Akbar was very great , but he was not great . He was just a self obsessed and cruel Mughal king like his ancestors. If you don't know , during Akbar's conquest on chittorgarh. He massacred about 30,000 -40, 000 innocent civilians in the fort and made a skull tower from their heads to spread fear among the peoples. He was not great in any way . It's all truth.
@vp98215
@vp98215 Год назад
That's how things worked during that time. Do you think a kind hearted person can be a king during that time. Even ashoka was ruthless before he turned to Buddhism and when he turned into a kind guy his kingdom fell. It was the starting of the fall of the maurya empire. Kings have to be ruthless and make decisions that won't be in public interest to stay in power.
@JAXX-wm6vr
@JAXX-wm6vr Год назад
@@vp98215 Abe logo ko maarna kaha ka public interest hai kya bakvas karraha.
@JAXX-wm6vr
@JAXX-wm6vr Год назад
@@vp98215 If you think killing is the only way to become great then go search about Emperor Kanishka, may your way about seeing things get changed.
@vp98215
@vp98215 Год назад
@@JAXX-wm6vr every king went to war and killed people. That's how things worked during that time. The times change and along with that the way a king rules. Even kanishka went to war. Some kings made the people of the place they conquered slaves and some didn't.
@JAXX-wm6vr
@JAXX-wm6vr Год назад
@@vp98215 Are you a Historian really??
Далее
Palki Sharma: My Honest Experience In Israel
19:01
Просмотров 3,9 тыс.
These Ravaana Theories Will BEND YOUR MIND
10:20
Просмотров 421 тыс.
The Mahabharat Mystery: What Archaeologists Discovered
12:16
Shocking, Dark Reality Of India Before Shivaji Maharaj
10:35