Тёмный

John Mearsheimer on Ukraine, Gaza & escalation dominance | SpectatorTV 

The Spectator
Подписаться 360 тыс.
Просмотров 427 тыс.
50% 1

John Mearsheimer joins Freddy Gray for the Spectator's Americano podcast. On the show they explore the powder keg situation in Eastern Europe, why Putin is possibly the least hawkish of possible Russian leaders and why Israel has lost escalation dominance.
00:01:30 How could Putin respond to Ukraine strikes inside Russia?
00:05:40 Conflict escalation explained
00:13:54 What could happen if Netanyahu is ousted?
00:18:00 The West's position on the colour revolutions
00:28:00 The nuclear threat
00:32:14 Israel's return to Gaza has put it in 'deep trouble'
00:37:00 Israel v Iran
00:44:00 The rise of China and Russia
// SUBSCRIBE TO THE SPECTATOR
Get 12 issues for £12, plus a free £20 John Lewis/Waitrose voucher
www.spectator.co.uk/tvoffer
// FREE PODCASTS FROM THE SPECTATOR
Hear more from The Spectator's journalists on their podcasts, covering everything from the politics of the UK, US and China, to religion, literature, lifestyle and more.
www.spectator.co.uk/podcasts/
// FOLLOW US
/ spectator
/ officialspectator
/ the-spectator
/ spectator1828
/ thespectatormagazine
Theme song written and performed by Jon Barker © 2020 Jonathan Stewart Barker
Publisher Jonathan Stewart Barker 100%, administered by prsformusic.com
Recording © 2020 Jonathan Stewart Barker 100%, administered by ppl.com

Опубликовано:

 

28 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,3 тыс.   
@SpectatorTV
@SpectatorTV 19 дней назад
Is Mearsheimer correct to predict that Russia is going to win in Ukraine?
@adm58
@adm58 19 дней назад
Russia has already won. It's obvious. We need to negotiate peace, not escalate.
@Wybowazza
@Wybowazza 19 дней назад
Of course.
@99xstallerthanmost
@99xstallerthanmost 19 дней назад
I am guessing that he would also predict that Sunak will not be PM on 5th July?
@dann5480
@dann5480 19 дней назад
He is always right regarding analysis of strategic developments and international relations. He is the world's leading scholar in those fields.
@In-hoc-signo-vinces
@In-hoc-signo-vinces 19 дней назад
They effectively won it after the Ukraine's summer offensive failure. They've also destroyed NATO.
@jessiejb4684
@jessiejb4684 19 дней назад
One of my very few disagreements with mearshiemer is that the u.s. doesn’t overthrow gov’s to make the liberal democracies. We overthrow democratically elected gov’s and install incredibly corupt leaders. We do so most often to gain influence, cut out influence of another, and/or to gain geographic presence/control in a region. We are currently trying to destabilize Georgia and it’s ugly. The president of Georgia is literally a ‘foreign agent’ from France so this time our problem is with the majority party in parliament. We have Georgian youth in the streets protesting against transparency. WTF? The NED had some harsh words for Georgia and spoke about harming their possible future nato membership… here we go again…
@In-hoc-signo-vinces
@In-hoc-signo-vinces 19 дней назад
Was going to say , look what USA is doing in Georgia right now
@khunmikeon858
@khunmikeon858 19 дней назад
100% agree with your sentiments. I’m Irish and abhor what the nefarious Washington regime has been openly doing for decades with its assignations, coups, invasions, sanctions, etc. Millions killed by the USA. Despicable. I stand with Russia and I stand with Palestine against American imperialism.
@tmaxyb
@tmaxyb 18 дней назад
You took the words out of my mouth.
@rebelmango2141
@rebelmango2141 18 дней назад
No you have Georgian youth protesting against laws similar to Russia used to crackdown on criticism. Any evidence about that president claim
@rebelmango2141
@rebelmango2141 18 дней назад
​@@In-hoc-signo-vincesThey're doing nothing that's the Georgian people don't take away their agency
@user-dw3hl4sh2w
@user-dw3hl4sh2w 19 дней назад
I have read two of Mearsheimer's books on geopolitics. As a Brit with US citizenship, he does a great job of explaining American foreign policy. It is not what we are told in Britain. Most British commentators either have no idea what is going on in the world or they are just peddling CIA propaganda. Times Radio is a perfect example most of their guests are clueless. Living in the US it was obvious that Ukraine could not win, but the US aim was to weaken Russia, and not get drawn into a nuclear war. Senators Romney and Blumenthal admitted it. If France wants to get into a nuclear war with Russia, that is Its choice. My concern is that the British public has been fed so much BS it may opt for oblivion out of ignorance.
@richardcarr3172
@richardcarr3172 19 дней назад
Times Radio is a f*cking joke
@aaronsmyth7943
@aaronsmyth7943 19 дней назад
Have you actually thought about Putin and his generals deciding to end themselves and their families over Ukraine? Have you any idea how ridiculous that is?
@turbolevo8703
@turbolevo8703 19 дней назад
Times Radio is shocking. Some of their headlines are preposterous.
@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304
@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 19 дней назад
Judging by his naivety and ignorance over the war in Ukraine, and his stubborn refusal to change his narrative long after the facts prove him wrong, I don't imagine Mearsheimer's kooky analysis of geopolitics are worth a whole lot - There is a reason why he's so popular with Russian nationalists, after all.
@turbolevo8703
@turbolevo8703 19 дней назад
@@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Yet more assertions without evidence. Is this the best you can do?
@johnrichmond8978
@johnrichmond8978 18 дней назад
The interviewer reminded me why I had to stop buying The Spectator magazine. Young Americans might not know, but it used to be an intelligent right wing magazine. Incredible, I know.
@myla6135
@myla6135 17 дней назад
Yes, I gave up on it too...... many years ago. And found it very easy to resist the offers of gifts and discounts galore to resubscribe. Terrible rag.
@johnrichmond8978
@johnrichmond8978 17 дней назад
@@myla6135 All off a sudden it dis-guarded it's political values. What a bore.
@JohnPretty1
@JohnPretty1 16 дней назад
Bizarre comment. Who do you think booked John Mearsheimer?
@myla6135
@myla6135 16 дней назад
@@JohnPretty1 One sensible booking versus numerous unintelligent articles for some years. And you think John Richmond and I might not have a valid point? That's what bizarre John P. I only clicked on this because it was Meisheimer. Not because it was the Speccie.
@johnrichmond8978
@johnrichmond8978 16 дней назад
@@JohnPretty1 Nonsensical. Mershimer is in great demand all over the world. Now I have to stop buying your magazine :)
@keirozj
@keirozj 16 дней назад
Whoever is behind this have sent men to the battlefield with huge casualties including death and they are basically from the lower social classes. Professor Mearsheimer gave an extraordinary lecture on this conflict, including NATO and national security, existential issues to Russia.
@flamboyentpromotions3471
@flamboyentpromotions3471 19 дней назад
Funniest part is when the interviewer pretends that he doesn't understand the Guardian story😂
@retrocool
@retrocool 17 дней назад
Probably doesn't want to get a visit himself...
@ahsanjahangir8834
@ahsanjahangir8834 16 дней назад
Exactly. How come a journalist doesn’t understand a news story 😅
@Io-Io-Io
@Io-Io-Io 19 дней назад
Fico is alive not dead
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
Did you see boris's nazi thugs at our parliament - check out their flag!
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
Another neocon cock-up!
@mladendjukic1061
@mladendjukic1061 19 дней назад
True, but he was assassinated and survived. How do you call it when someone survives? Attempted assassination?
@Io-Io-Io
@Io-Io-Io 18 дней назад
@@mladendjukic1061 'attempted' of course
@Io-Io-Io
@Io-Io-Io 18 дней назад
@@mladendjukic1061 assassination = murder.
@hoareg2
@hoareg2 18 дней назад
Here’s what the article in The Guardian says “They allegedly threatened her and her family, saying: “You should help us and let us take care of you. You don’t want to be getting into things that could compromise your security or that of your family.”” Freddie, you can argue that the article was wrong or not factual but saying that the threat by Israel was vague and you didn’t get it is simply dishonest.
@bitsandbobs4082
@bitsandbobs4082 17 дней назад
He has to act all innocent or he be in for a good talking to
@manofculture584
@manofculture584 17 дней назад
Those phrases are still vague
@What-kw6ox
@What-kw6ox 16 дней назад
@@manofculture584lol
@fuckbankers
@fuckbankers 16 дней назад
Mafia talk.
@fuckbankers
@fuckbankers 16 дней назад
Gangsters
@SirKeefyKeef
@SirKeefyKeef 18 дней назад
Explain EXACTLY how the vote in Georgia is ‘’Pro Russia’’. I wait with intrigue.
@robertjames7982
@robertjames7982 19 дней назад
Criminals rule this criminal nation.
@2011hwalker
@2011hwalker 18 дней назад
Literally in Trumps case. The man lies before he gets out of bed in the morning.
@ahimsainthekitchen
@ahimsainthekitchen 18 дней назад
Peace is not lucrative for the war mongers.
@GreenGoblinDK
@GreenGoblinDK 18 дней назад
Yes Im so tired of the Russian criminal. Putin should be in jail!
@rmdomainer9042
@rmdomainer9042 18 дней назад
Russia. Indeed.
@ahartify
@ahartify 18 дней назад
You mean in Russia? Quite true.
@TubeDisabuser
@TubeDisabuser 18 дней назад
Mearsheimer is wrong in his claim that the United States is a liberal democracy -- it's a façade.
@CarlMartin-hw3ev
@CarlMartin-hw3ev 17 дней назад
It's a Republic, not a Democracy, liberal or not.
@Juznik1389
@Juznik1389 17 дней назад
And also the US is a constitutional republic. It is about protecting all the people from a majority rule
@annilator3000
@annilator3000 17 дней назад
​@@CarlMartin-hw3ev bro drank the cool-aid distinguishing republic and democracy lmfao But yea, it's initially a landlord oligarchy which is still working as intended.
@DonQuickZote
@DonQuickZote 17 дней назад
So you prefer Russia?
@Juznik1389
@Juznik1389 17 дней назад
@@DonQuickZote ridiculous statement... what do you think the real governing body is of the US
@antonleimbach648
@antonleimbach648 14 дней назад
We shipped our factories, steel mills, and shipyards to China and now we can’t build the ships, planes, or tanks we need fast enough. We traded the most dynamic industrial base on the planet for cheap Walmart products and service industry jobs. China has totally outplayed us.
@carolann3249
@carolann3249 12 дней назад
Exactly my thinking
@hasan_z
@hasan_z 10 дней назад
It's because the politicians only considered the short term advantages over the long term. It was the downfall of many empires to not look far enough ahead.
@nikitos12309
@nikitos12309 9 дней назад
Because the only smell West enjoyes is the smell of money easy money
@view1st
@view1st 8 дней назад
@@hasan_z it wasn't the politicians that sold you out of was the CEO's and their shareholders: they are the ones who relocated their businesses elsewhere.
@tmengucor
@tmengucor 8 дней назад
Turbo capitalism of the last 2 decades has been a disgrace for the west
@brianmaclean2078
@brianmaclean2078 19 дней назад
I believe John is correct on most points, however, I believe he is wrong in his assertion that the United States wants other countries to be just like it is, that is a liberal democracy. The historical record shows that the United States does not want equals in the countries that they interfere with, and the countries that they overthrow, but rather they want vessel states that they can economically and politically exploit. This should be clear historically, in that the United States has overthrown many democratically elected governments and have supported the most heinous dictators on the planet. Follow the money!
@garrettyamada9821
@garrettyamada9821 19 дней назад
No disrespect or offence intended, but I think that you meant vassal, and not vessel.
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
US foreign policy - make britain a weak, chaotic and dependant target.
@marthas.4456
@marthas.4456 19 дней назад
100%
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
@@marthas.4456 trying to prop up your american pride?
@marthas.4456
@marthas.4456 19 дней назад
@@tonysherwood9619 I'm not American, I'm from a small Eastern European country... But facts are facts, regardless who says it. If my country would have done these things, I would call them out on it too.
@ad5792
@ad5792 19 дней назад
Ukraine never had nuclear weapons. Soviet Union and then Russia has nuclear weapons. All the decision centers and control of these weapons always were in Moscow. Never in Kiev. So Ukraine never could "keep" something they never had. Just like American nuclear weapons located in Europe.
@MrRoyalbeers
@MrRoyalbeers 15 дней назад
Ukraine had Nukes. Hence they transferred them to russia. Russia had no more claim to soviet union nukes than Ukraine had. Quit your attempts at semanthics. Russia was just a part of soviet union just like Ukraine and any other memberstate was.
@shamsiddinnabiev3151
@shamsiddinnabiev3151 15 дней назад
Well the USSR wasnt just russia and those nuclear weapons were not only created by russians. The country collapsed so did the "creator” of the weapons. Your point is too absolutist, the reality is not that simple
@paulflocken2730
@paulflocken2730 15 дней назад
Ukraine had physical possession of the missiles/warheads. With physical possession they would eventually rework the control capabilities necessary to make the functional weapon systems under Ukrainian control. The only element they needed was time. They didn't lack for expertise. That's why American perfidity had to act fast in the early nineties to get those weapons out of the hands of the Ukrainians.
@quandmeme9970
@quandmeme9970 14 дней назад
They had nukes physically and had great scientists, engineers and nuclear reactors.
@ad5792
@ad5792 13 дней назад
@@shamsiddinnabiev3151 My point is that in reality, Russia is a legal successor to the USSR, not Ukraine or any other former part of it. Also, every former republic now makes claims to whatever was developed in that republic under the USSR, conveniently "forgetting" the point that you are making.
@alireza.011
@alireza.011 12 дней назад
۲۰ سال دیگه خانواده کسانی که در اوکراین جنگیدند خواهند گفت فرزندان ما بخاطر هیچ جنگیدند.
@savinanencheva
@savinanencheva 16 дней назад
It’s not about politics, it’s about dominance and hegemony.
@rerite2
@rerite2 15 дней назад
"The history of the world is simply one tribe conquering another." -- Napoleon
@Anke-B747
@Anke-B747 5 дней назад
👏👏👏👍
@Zeddo2323light
@Zeddo2323light 19 дней назад
Maersheimer is one of the world's most common sense commentators. This is why he's hated by the mainstream.
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
...because he hasn't sold his soul to the devil!
@ahartify
@ahartify 19 дней назад
He is also one of the most deluded and depraved academics in the world.
@lembergnative7731
@lembergnative7731 19 дней назад
he's an idiot
@lembergnative7731
@lembergnative7731 19 дней назад
@@tonysherwood9619 he did in fact sold his soul to the devil
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
@@lembergnative7731 well you should know!
@joylarson9040
@joylarson9040 19 дней назад
No one in their right minds would assume that the color revolution were spontaneous.🤨
@MichaelSmith-ph5oe
@MichaelSmith-ph5oe 19 дней назад
Or that these defeats were not expected or planned, the ones that want to weaken us have done everything in their power to do just that, with tremendous success! We must ask qui bono?
@fluoroproilne
@fluoroproilne 19 дней назад
Neither can you assume they are 100% instigated
@MrRight1000
@MrRight1000 19 дней назад
Color revolutions couldn't have been conducted without some elements of popular descent. But, yeah, there is always some popular descent and in any society.
@skibidi.G
@skibidi.G 18 дней назад
Literally all of them are instigated , this is the concept of a "color revolution" versus a "normal revolution" like ex: Romania @ ​@@fluoroproilne
@alie.m.1474
@alie.m.1474 18 дней назад
@@fluoroproilnethere’s audio of Victoria Neumann there instigating it and deciding the political landscape afterwards
@Pavel.Fomitchov
@Pavel.Fomitchov 16 дней назад
Very logical argumentation and clear thinking. Outstanding analytics!
@joelferguson8714
@joelferguson8714 15 дней назад
What kills me is the fact that the UK thinks it has any voice in the world anymore.. talk about self important.
@zyrrhos
@zyrrhos 5 дней назад
The same can be said about the US when it comes to "having a voice." Meaning, we don't use our words, we use our might. Like a bully.
@lazyman7505
@lazyman7505 5 дней назад
@@zyrrhos But unlike UK, US does have the largest conventional military on the planet. UK has .. SAS and SBS guys I guess?
@gintasvilkelis2544
@gintasvilkelis2544 3 дня назад
The UK does have a voice. Not the biggest, but still considerable.
@jrgensvendsen1748
@jrgensvendsen1748 19 дней назад
If Macron's point is to balance both parties, including the recent use of EU/US weapons for targets inside Russia, then consider the following: Ukraine has already hit railway lines within Russia that transport weapons to the front, set fire to weapons factories inside Russia, and targeted oil/gas depots supplying the war efforts. Similarly, in Europe and the US, there are production factories and corresponding rail and air deliveries to Ukraine. If we follow Macron's point about balance, it would imply that Russia can similarly target European supply lines and weapons production factories that supply Ukraine inside EU/US, right? That's WW3 right?
@vgames6792
@vgames6792 19 дней назад
Go to Alex Christoforou, he would explain to you macros "STRATEGIC AMBIGUITY"😅
@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304
@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 19 дней назад
Ukraine is not at war with North Korea. Or Belarus. Or Iran. And yet those states provide weapons to Russia. Ultimately, Putin is big on threats, but his ability and willingness to carry them out doesn't match his rhetoric.
@vgames6792
@vgames6792 19 дней назад
​@@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304Ukros are getting weapons from 40+ nations/client states. WHAT IS YOUR POINT? Is russia at war with nato?(that was a rhetorical question dont bother answer🤡)
@sotirmilivojevic6233
@sotirmilivojevic6233 18 дней назад
@@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Well, you're right, Putin is soft.. but attacking Moscow or St Petersburg with ATACMS and similar will force him to escalate..
@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304
@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 18 дней назад
@@sotirmilivojevic6233 He's already doing his worst in Ukraine right now. And he values his own neck (as do those who support him) enough not to provoke NATO into direct military action.
@MrRight1000
@MrRight1000 19 дней назад
On the subject of keeping nukes in Ukraine after the breakup of the Soviet Union: My understanding is that nukes on the territory of Ukraine were dumb nukes, meaning that all command and control functionality was located in Russia proper. These nukes were like dumb computer terminals, i.e. terminals without a CPU. What good could it possibly have done to keep them up there?
@robrob9050
@robrob9050 19 дней назад
Yes but the warheads were real, Ukraine at that time great industrial base, they could keep their independence real.
@Treasure_hunter_21
@Treasure_hunter_21 18 дней назад
@@robrob9050 no. they couldnt. Bc Ukraine is an oligarh rulled country. with or withot nothing wouldve changed. plus they didnt had codes.
@robrob9050
@robrob9050 18 дней назад
@@Treasure_hunter_21 in 1993 these oligars were just starting. It's failure of Ukraine to keep her independence.
@sotirmilivojevic6233
@sotirmilivojevic6233 18 дней назад
What people don't understand.. if Ukraine kept nukes - today it would be Russia's ally, there would be no USA money for banderites, there would be no color revolution, nothing of that sort(USA never messes with nuclear powers.. because they usually find the worst group of criminals to pay and support - now imagine if one of their pet projects, ISIS, got control of nukes - USA has at least that much sense). Russia would be one and only country with influence in Ukraine .. and Russia would have 1.5 more nukes than it has today, which is one of the reasons USA demanded that Ukraine joins NPT.
@timtrewyn453
@timtrewyn453 17 дней назад
The United States was quite capable of converting Soviet weapons into Ukrainian weapons. Nice of the US not to do that.
@worldcitizen5
@worldcitizen5 3 дня назад
This man is the personification of Western Academia decay.
@andrewx7806
@andrewx7806 16 дней назад
The problem with Mearsheimer’s logic is that those authoritarian regimes suppress free speech usually brutally and even when there is a strong movement for reform it is squashed. When the American colonists rose up against the British they had help from France, a foreign power. So why shouldn’t dissidents in Ukraine or Russia or Belarus or Georgia or Iran get assistance from the West. ?
@joemerino3243
@joemerino3243 15 дней назад
Sorry, this comment section is only for Russian bots, no actual humans asking reasonable questions here.
@vladimirgineyev922
@vladimirgineyev922 13 дней назад
That is called interference in the inner matters, and most countries don't like it despite vocal minority. I.e. US during RussiaGate
@andrewx7806
@andrewx7806 13 дней назад
@@vladimirgineyev922of course the ruling government doesn’t like it. Duh.
@joemerino3243
@joemerino3243 12 дней назад
@@vladimirgineyev922 Oh let's be real. The US senators may have put on a festival of hypocrisy over that, but in reality The US, Russia, Israel, and China all have agents in basically every nation, overtly or surreptitiously influencing every single election and policy decision. That's just the world today. Putting on a big show over a few facebook ads was fodder for the politically clueless. In every country, including the US, the interests of foreign agents count for more than the constituents.
@KennyG-qh8jc
@KennyG-qh8jc 2 дня назад
it is still not our job to solve it. We dont have free speech in Europe so whats your point?
@drift-oninn2179
@drift-oninn2179 19 дней назад
如果只用美國人的角度,Mearsheimer無法真正了解中國。
@montrelouisebohon-harris7023
@montrelouisebohon-harris7023 18 дней назад
Well, anything coming out of the government here in the United States is bullshit and I know because I’m an American. Most real Americans who have not been imported here over the past 40 years or who have come and they really really want to work and I’m on their own business without anybody bothering them and vice versa., aren’t like Washington DC because they’re so corrupt! What Joe Bidens administration just did to Donald Trump is exactly the way they are and they say they’re a democracy and what they did the trump is nothing short of a Kremlin Soviet style Sham trial! They were doing this to President Nixon Mac in the 1970s for a couple reasons and one was because he was withdrawing troops from Vietnam because he didn’t even like them over there in the first place and second he was backing the Shah of Iran, who was the monarch to stay in place, because despite any imperfections, the people in Iran were more free, and there were people going back around behind his back in the Democrat party, and some Republican warmongers having secret talks with the ayatollah Khomeini, and the next thing I know there was Watergate scandal, but I was only six at the time. I thought Nixon was great, because even though I was really little he met with the Chinese leader.,,Mao! I remember how everything was so different in China compared to America but trying I had been through bloody hell since the 1920s because the CCP was fighting with the government going back to the 20s (1924 I think is when it started and you will have to forgive me on my Chinese history because I’m not a professional but I have read a lot about it because I want to know and understand), the communist were fighting with the government in power with the Soviet union backing, and then Japan, invaded China and committed the most atrocious disgusting war crimes!! Germans had war crimes, criminals, and granted I think out of the 38 people or 36 people that did get the death penalty may be only 26 or 28 of them did die. The rest of them were in prison for the rest of their lives, and most of the people went to prison whether it was 10 years 20 years are for the rest of their lives, depending on what they did, and especially pertaining to the Holocaust and the concentration camps. Goodness gracious, the Soviet union committed war, crimes, moving westward, and once they got to east Germany, and they wouldn’t even feed the people there either even though the United States was sending food to feed 200 million people in the Soviet Union so they wouldn’t start to death or three or four years. The USA and the UK flew out every five minutes, dropping off thousands and thousands of pounds of food and it’s been known as the East Berlin or the eastern Germany food AirDrop.. by the 1960s America I was just starting to go to hell to be honest and I was born in 1967. President Nixon had ping-pong diplomacy going on with China and I always thought it was so cool and I was a little kid didn’t know much about anything.. then a couple years later they’re trying to impeach him and get him out of office and I know he didn’t do anything worse than anybody else. It’s just they wanted him out. sad!!! American citizens don’t want war with anybody and only time American citizens and I’m talking about the true American citizens, which probably 75% of us or 80% is IF Somebody does something to us first like the attack on Pearl Harbor or September 11, 2001 etc. etc. and even the British intercepting a telegram from Germany to Mexico in 1917 was enough to make Americans declare war on Germany and finally get in the world war one, because when I first started fighting in 1914, the Americans were saying “ well, here they go again!”. That’s exactly why we had a revolutionary war and we didn’t want Britain’s tyranny, and it seems like after World War II and then NATO so many of our politicians got pretty goody-goody with western European leaders, and they started taking on their snobby elitist Socialist fascist ideologies because I thought the power was pretty good and that’s what started the rule in America here in the USA and it’s really really sad. Donald Trump became president and he didn’t want war with anybody but he’s not gonna take any shit from anybody.. he was sitting at Mar-a-Lago at his house with president Xi. The only thing he did, and wanted to do militarily in his term was take out the terrorist group, Isis, and obliterate them. They were doing stuff like the Japanese did in China and they would go to people times pull them out shoot on, etc. etc. or decapitate them and Obama didn’t do anything about it and in fact he was the one that was so incompetent over in the Middle East and that’s what caused Isis to grow. President Trump said we can go over there and make them out in about two months but Congress made him stay two years.. see?? I was so glad when we pulled out of there in 2019 and turkey was going in just to keep the area Isis free,& Turkey was supposed to keep it Isis free but then Joe Biden became president a year later. When Joe Biden became president, Turkey pulled out, and Isis has grown back again. Trump was eating chocolate cake with the president of China and they were watching the video of what was going on over in Syria and the military was the bomb in the heck out of the terrorist group and I think they miss old and 56 or 58 times and then dropped a MOAB on Isis, and that’s a mother of all bombs, and is probably one of the biggest bombs. When it was over the president of China looked right at him, and he said. “repeat!” & President Trump said he was shocked because he was not aware that the president of China knew how to speak any English.
@snowsnow4231
@snowsnow4231 17 дней назад
If you don`t now Chinese, you cannot understand China, if you do not speak Russian, you cannot understand Russia, its a simple concept western "experts" are incapable of understanding.
@dfdf-rj8jr
@dfdf-rj8jr 17 дней назад
How much they pay you, again? 50 cents?
@Wtizreal
@Wtizreal 17 дней назад
中国人比欧洲人更团结,他们能够忍受艰苦的工作和延迟满足感,但欧洲人作为罗马的继承者,天生就有一种扩张和征服的欲望,以及反抗压迫和暴政的意志。 他们中的一些人还具有马基雅维利主义,造就了拿破仑这样的人物
@plung3r
@plung3r 17 дней назад
@@dfdf-rj8jr no, Eminem
@voldemarvaglaots6690
@voldemarvaglaots6690 19 дней назад
Ukraine got it's independence from USSR. Neutrality and non joining any blocks was essential condition. Neutrality was removed from construction later. Another thing is "Ukrainian nuclear weapons". All the nuclear weapons STATIONED in Ukraine belonged to USSR. Ukrainians had no way to control it's "arsenal". Say USA is keeping it's nuclear weapons in Germany or Turkey, is it then belonged to Germans or Turks? No! Ukraine never had own nukes!
@Treasure_hunter_21
@Treasure_hunter_21 18 дней назад
exactly!
@stavroskarageorgis4804
@stavroskarageorgis4804 18 дней назад
Hear, hear!
@ianstevenson3628
@ianstevenson3628 18 дней назад
Ukraine has a right to join any bloc its govt wants. There was no possibility of joining NATO while there was a regional conflict. Joining the EU was very popular. For 30 years they have been able to travel and work in the West. The majority prefer it to the mystic Russian nationalism which denies the reality of Ukraine and the repressive regime they see. They saw democracy crushed in Belarus with Putin's full approval. There is no way any people would keep fighting against the odds if they were in favour or indifferent to being part of Russia.
@robrob9050
@robrob9050 18 дней назад
But USSR was gone in 1991.
@Azrudi
@Azrudi 18 дней назад
@@ianstevenson3628 Not all Ukrainians. Most of us who fled Ukraine came to Russia. Russia accepted the most number of Ukrainian refugees of all global countries. You may look this up to verify it.
@megsfs
@megsfs 15 дней назад
Great to hear someone talking about those topics based on facts and reason instead of beliefs and ideology
@ubernaffa
@ubernaffa 3 дня назад
What a guy. He is so straight forward with his explanations. An extremely coherent thinker.
@gintasvilkelis2544
@gintasvilkelis2544 3 дня назад
Delusions can sound coherent too.
@gillps5130
@gillps5130 18 дней назад
Very glad to see John Mearsheimer on here. Western politicians should have him on speed dial.
@albertgrant1017
@albertgrant1017 17 дней назад
Well said !
@JGalt-em4xu
@JGalt-em4xu 17 дней назад
They have AIPAC on speed dial, so they don't have Mearsheimer.
@galahadthreepwood
@galahadthreepwood 16 дней назад
And Jeffrey Sachs
@tigoutlaw1273
@tigoutlaw1273 19 дней назад
John Mearsheimer has much of this spot on. The reality is that the reason Georgia have enacted the law around external funding of NGOs is that it was US and EU funding/interference in Ukraine that contributed to the Maidan and the consequential chaos we have today. Additionally, the reason Macron is so hawkish on the Ukrainian issue is not for a love of Ukraine, but as an attempt to undermine Putin is due to the growing influence of Russia in Macron's French sphere of influence, Western Africa, specifically Niger where France rely so greatly on for their Uranium to power their nuclear industry.
@jessiejb4684
@jessiejb4684 19 дней назад
Spot on.
@blehoo1
@blehoo1 19 дней назад
Absolutely true!
@05KAR
@05KAR 19 дней назад
And how some Maidan excuses the Russian military intervention and land grabs... ten years later?
@farerolobos9382
@farerolobos9382 19 дней назад
Every country in the world should have a law like that.
@davidthompson1369
@davidthompson1369 18 дней назад
@@farerolobos9382 This is the crux of it for me as well.
@user-bi3ud6cu6m
@user-bi3ud6cu6m 11 дней назад
So what does he propose? Sit and wait until all Eastern Europe becomes russia?
@loretoecheverria926
@loretoecheverria926 15 дней назад
Mearsheimer is lucid & realistic. It´s a pity that people like him are not in power. God save this planet
@Igor-on8nm
@Igor-on8nm 13 дней назад
He well paid by ruzzians
@908Dannyboy
@908Dannyboy 13 дней назад
It's ironic you say that because he is assuming Putin and his regime is a rational party in this.
@SvetlanaRakhim
@SvetlanaRakhim 13 дней назад
@@Igor-on8nmand Chinese. He even said he is more liked in China than in the USA
@SvetlanaRakhim
@SvetlanaRakhim 13 дней назад
@@El_Camino_Que_Recorres_Solono
@JulietteTux
@JulietteTux 12 дней назад
The planet is fine(C)
@georgeapostol4285
@georgeapostol4285 19 дней назад
The interviewer seems placed to be among ones who see non anti-russians as pro-russians.
@aiolosdaftsis
@aiolosdaftsis 19 дней назад
His name is not Piutin its Putin, its really hard to ignore...
@AndreyMedvedev
@AndreyMedvedev 19 дней назад
Thank you! Finally, someone said it. Also, they are not "newkewlar" weapons, but nuclear (comes from the word "nucleus")
@susanbalog8355
@susanbalog8355 19 дней назад
@@AndreyMedvedev pet peeve of mine when people mispronounce nuclear
@Olegstuff21986
@Olegstuff21986 19 дней назад
The Brits do that in purpose, to make his name sound like the word "puke".
@brothercaleb
@brothercaleb 19 дней назад
Pootin
@mogurumoguru
@mogurumoguru 18 дней назад
They do it on purpose. Every little evil counts for these idiots...
@LEDSMANIA
@LEDSMANIA 14 дней назад
With all the respect to mr. Mearshimer nuclear weapons in SSSR were Russian and controlled by Russian.
@richardaylward70
@richardaylward70 12 дней назад
I more worried about people on the INSIDE interfering with our electoral process….
@jorgeponce5512
@jorgeponce5512 19 дней назад
I am an opponent of liberal democracy. I prefer plutocracy and that's why I live in the US.
@vgames6792
@vgames6792 19 дней назад
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 Uniparty regime, which censors opposite narratives, force you into experimental injections, trying to jail its main opposition leader, is in constant wars or proxy war. USA regime is pretty much regime of economicFscm
@tonysherwood9619
@tonysherwood9619 19 дней назад
A kleptocracy now!
@rexiioper6920
@rexiioper6920 18 дней назад
this owns the comment section
@eldragon4076
@eldragon4076 18 дней назад
😂👍
@skibidi.G
@skibidi.G 18 дней назад
😂
@stavroskarageorgis4804
@stavroskarageorgis4804 18 дней назад
Ukraine never had its own nuclear weapons. Nuclear weapons of the USSR were sited in the territory of Ukraine SSR. The Russian Federation became the "successor state" to the USSR for all Treaty purposes. There was zero chance of Ukraine qua independent state to inherit part of the USSR's nuclear arsenal. Mearsheimer was wrong in 1993 on this and remains wrong today. 29:00
@stavroskarageorgis4804
@stavroskarageorgis4804 18 дней назад
When the USSR was declared "no more", there were components of the USSR's nuclear arsenal located in multiple erstwhile SSRs outside of the erstwhile Russian SSR. Zero basis for anything other than either all of them severally becoming nuclear states or only one of them. NB. Russia did not have its own separate U.N. seat while the USSR was in existence. Ukraine and Belarus did! "Ultimately, at the Yalta Conference a compromise was made in which two Soviet republics (Ukrainian SSR and Byelorussian SSR) were admitted as full members of the United Nations. As such, between 1945 and 1991, the Soviet Union was represented by three seats in the United Nations."
@paulflocken2730
@paulflocken2730 15 дней назад
Ukraine had physical possession of the missiles/warheads. With physical possession they would eventually rework the control capabilities necessary to make the functional weapon systems under Ukrainian control. The only element they needed was time. They didn't lack for expertise. That's why American perfidity had to act fast in the early nineties to get those weapons out of the hands of the Ukrainians.
@alanrobertson9790
@alanrobertson9790 12 дней назад
The important point is that following independence Ukraine had control of the nuclear weapons within Ukraine. If that wasn't the case Russia could simply have transported them to Russia and indeed a treaty would not have been necessary.
@user-lg5vy3ko3w
@user-lg5vy3ko3w 17 дней назад
Спасибо, профессор Миршаймер. Спасибо, мистер Грей.
@milanpavlica5478
@milanpavlica5478 6 дней назад
How would sanctions work if half of the world including China and India are not part of them?
@davidleeconnellys1027
@davidleeconnellys1027 19 дней назад
Have you ever spoken with Putin?
@whowhy9023
@whowhy9023 16 дней назад
He’s indirectly paid by Putin.
@irinaoleinikova5235
@irinaoleinikova5235 19 дней назад
It was Russian nuclear weapons the territory of Ukraine, they never had their own nuclear weapons
@rexiioper6920
@rexiioper6920 18 дней назад
well soviet weapons- but there were concerns about how ukraine could manage them alone
@Treasure_hunter_21
@Treasure_hunter_21 18 дней назад
@@rexiioper6920 Ukraine didnt had acceses to them nor had their codes.
@natalieblack1698
@natalieblack1698 18 дней назад
@@rexiioper6920 and rightfully so, Ukraine is one of the most corrupt countries in the world. They would’ve sold off that nuclear arsenal for 10k USD a missile to any shady warlord who brought cash.
@stavroskarageorgis4804
@stavroskarageorgis4804 18 дней назад
USSR nuclear arsenal. Not Russian until the USSR was no more, and the Russian Federation became its successor state wrt to all Treaties, etc. .
@robrob9050
@robrob9050 18 дней назад
So you will argue that Ukraine was occupied during USSR?
@alexsteinbrink5671
@alexsteinbrink5671 16 дней назад
very interesting to listen to such highly intelligent people... thanks to John Mearsheimer!
@brucemcmanaman5364
@brucemcmanaman5364 18 дней назад
This man is the perfect embodiment of appeasement.
@Maruwasa
@Maruwasa 16 дней назад
Most troubling is the persistent idea that the west or the east are influencing and must influence others - what about just respecting the right of all men and women to choose what government they want. Whether you like it or not. It’s really simple
@marscruz
@marscruz 16 дней назад
That's the difference between being motivated by morals or being motivated by greed.
@gintasvilkelis2544
@gintasvilkelis2544 3 дня назад
Yeh, tell that to Putin!
@marie-laure.
@marie-laure. 18 дней назад
His analysis is truly deep and interesting, but like everyone else he shows bias. For instance the English empire, which is effectively the American empire (unless they are one thing), is constantly washed away from the picture to blame the French who have decolonised without hesitation and what he dares call s French influence pales in comparison to the millions killed in the name of the Anglo American empire or hegemony, whatever. Isn't it nice to blame the innocent, so that you can pretend you are the god guy whilst stealing and killing indiscriminately
@blindeye3809
@blindeye3809 12 дней назад
Let's start talking about peace, interview about making peace, make peace, and peace will come.
@chris8949
@chris8949 10 дней назад
This Proxy war needs to stop now !!
@maxthemagition
@maxthemagition 19 дней назад
John Mearsheimer is one that speaks volumes of sense today. Everything in these wars says that another World war is more than likely. Giving Ukraine long range missiles will make the possibility of WW3 likely and with Ukraine most likely to lose this war then the provision of long range missiles means that a desperate Zelensky could fire a missiles towards Poland for example to get NATO directly involved. This war is madness led by madmen.
@cindybogart6062
@cindybogart6062 19 дней назад
I could not agree with you more, I believe Zelensky is a dangerous & desperate man!
@ahartify
@ahartify 19 дней назад
You are right that Putin is a madman, but Zelensky is as sane as sane can be!
@ahartify
@ahartify 19 дней назад
@@cindybogart6062 But Putin is a nice guy then?
@debasismohanty1952
@debasismohanty1952 19 дней назад
Yes Mr. Mearsheimer supports Russia openly 😂😂😂
@user-ld9hx7eh8b
@user-ld9hx7eh8b 19 дней назад
@@ahartify When your teeth and hair begin to fall out and radioactive ash is like sand in Florida under your feet, you will remember the kind grandfather Putin...
@sergeymyasnikov736
@sergeymyasnikov736 19 дней назад
With all due respect to Prof here, but what are those "Ukranian nuclear missiles" he keeps talking about? Russia agreed to inherit USSR's international debts and obligations, while Ukraine got a clean slate. Why would strategically importatnt weaponry that just happened to be located in Ukraine at the time of Soviets dissolution be suddenly considered "theirs"?
@mxfx5000-fh2sw
@mxfx5000-fh2sw 19 дней назад
He spoke very clearly. There were nuclear missiles at modern Ukraine territory prior 91, he meant in this sense "theirs".
@vittuix7662
@vittuix7662 3 дня назад
Could Mr Mearsheimer update his map behind him? I'm getting a old senile communist vibes here!
@yhho8473
@yhho8473 11 дней назад
A very wise man.Everything he says makes total sense.the only thing i disagree with is his idea that the US must contain China in Asia.
@di_har
@di_har 18 дней назад
First and most importantly, those were never Ukraine's nuclear weapons. As the legal and sole inheritor of the USSR, Russia owns those weapons. Secondly, Ukraine never had the nuclear codes. It was actually the United States who pushed for the nukes to be given back to Russia for a myriad of reasons. Please read the agreement. Thirdly, the Budapest Memorandum stipulates that Ukraine SHOULD remain NEUTRAL. That agreement has become invalid as soon as Ukraine decided it wants to join NATO.
@piotrmalik4908
@piotrmalik4908 17 дней назад
Russia wasn't sole legal successor of the USSR. If it was, all (for example) railway infrastructure, cars, locomotives located in former Soviet republics other than Russian would be Russia propriety and not Ukrainian, Lithuanian, Estonian propriety.
@colby25
@colby25 17 дней назад
"the Budapest Memorandum stipulates that Ukraine SHOULD remain NEUTRAL" .So how about putin sticking to that agreement then? Like from the very first day he took power 25 odd years ago hes been trying to bring them back under russian control. Firstly with yanukovych politically and now by military force. Can you blame ukraine, and many other former soviet states, from wanting to join NATO.
@stevenovetsky3274
@stevenovetsky3274 17 дней назад
@colby25 Absolutely, plus to launch nuclear tactical weapons, in tandem with nuclear bombers required no such codes for Kyiv. As Ukraine designed and manufactured so much of the soviet nuclear arsenal, along with having significant uranium deposits, it could have stayed nuclear, certainly if the likes of North Korea, Pakistan etc are nuclear nations today. Ukrainians had both the know-how and engineering infrastructure to be a nuclear nation, should they have chosen so. Let's not forget the autumn of 1993 when russian tanks were firing into the russian parliament (white house) . That was just before the Budapest Memo was signed ie America was putting pressure on Ukraine to hand over weapons to russia ie it didn't register as a risk that russia was in a state of civil war, highly corrupt and fighting independence wars, like in Chechnya. It would have been better for Ukraine to have been acknowledged as a nuclear state back in the 1990s. It would have checked russian expansionism and kept the peace, certainly for Ukraine.
@captiveexile2670
@captiveexile2670 16 дней назад
The Russian ambassador had "more brains in his little finger" than that DOPE, DONALD TRUMP (his "Trojan Horse"?)
@tekinfomedi
@tekinfomedi 15 дней назад
@@colby25 Thanks for reminding viewers it was Ukraine that did not follow the Budapest Memorandum. Viktor Yuschenko back in 2005-2010 was talking about Euro-Atlantic future, not about reacting to Putin. No mention of Kyiv regime at that time being demanded to reunify with Russia. Yanukovich was democratically elected, after his earlier attempt failed. From 2014 onwards, the Maidan regime repeated Yuschenko's points, not about the Budapest Memorandum. If Kyiv held the view that it was Moscow that did not respect the Memo, the Yuschenko and the Maidan regimes would have made lots of noise about it. Where were the official declarations made by the Presidents and Legislatures that the Memo was null and void? Instead the Memo only received significant attention from the MSM AFTER Russian tanks rolled in.
@maggie8586
@maggie8586 18 дней назад
"The country is happy with an autocratic system". That's rich. A country is a monolith. And how can anyone in an autocratic system express "unhappiness"????? The realism perspective is more full of holes than Swiss cheese.
@Myohomoto
@Myohomoto 17 дней назад
Finland excels at gorilla warfare. When the snow sings Russians cry...
@samcoatham2400
@samcoatham2400 18 дней назад
Words of wisdom- shame the politicians don’t listen and pay attention
@bubbaconway4081
@bubbaconway4081 17 дней назад
Definitely not a hawk I do agree on his Gaza statement but not about Russia Guess he grew up in a Cold war and feared the bomba coming down on his head..
@user-xp7yy3py5o
@user-xp7yy3py5o День назад
Exactly my thoughts. He makes for me a perfect argument to describe the Gaza situation. Ukraine not so much as I see the war there as one of conquest, imperial restoration. Russia threatening Europe requires a collective effort to stop them in Ukraine. He seems to feel that the Ukraine war is lost without taking into account that kleptocratic Russia is fragile.
@aaronhoffman9020
@aaronhoffman9020 18 дней назад
Hate to burst yr bubbles, The US is not a 'liberal democracy' ever since the Dulles bros. made their statements, and before and after, especially since Patriot Act, etc etc. Accurate analysis requires accurate use of language, aka Wittgenstein, etc
@RelationalDatabase-us7fr
@RelationalDatabase-us7fr 11 дней назад
So why is Russia struggling for tank, Infantry fighting vehicles and artillery?
@monrow1961
@monrow1961 8 дней назад
I think the point is that they are struggling less than Ukraine, not that they are not struggling.
@geoeconomics5629
@geoeconomics5629 17 дней назад
Who rules East Europe commands the Heartland - John Halford Mackinder
@aleong.9566
@aleong.9566 4 дня назад
Ukraine wasnt able to keep "its" nuclear weapons because they were Russian nuclear weapons and without returning them back to Russia there wouldnt be a Ukraine to begin with today.
@fouadramsis1128
@fouadramsis1128 17 дней назад
Agree. The West selectively "tolerates" illiberal or autocratacies, as long as they do what they're told by the West. See Saoudi Arabia , Qatar, UAE, Egypt, Jordan etc..
@George-vf7ss
@George-vf7ss 19 дней назад
Don't let your kids get drug into this one.
@user-ne8yi1io4h
@user-ne8yi1io4h 18 дней назад
Miersheimer is allowed to say whatever he wants on YT on the US but if a viewer comments likewise, they get censored. Bizzare.
@MohdRashidMohdYusof
@MohdRashidMohdYusof 18 дней назад
Because he is a joo , and a neocon spy .
@geraldmantel4955
@geraldmantel4955 5 дней назад
Human extinction : the last "Cold" War.
@knightalexius593
@knightalexius593 19 дней назад
The reality of a liberal democracy is very different from the idea, the narrative. There is power, particularly the power of money and the power of "security" institutions and of the media.
@libertarianbydefault
@libertarianbydefault 17 дней назад
The US may have liberal democracy (or used to have) inside the US. In its foreign policy the US is a tyrant.
@piotrmalik4908
@piotrmalik4908 17 дней назад
But it is still much better to live in the "real" liberal democracy than in the Soviet-style socialist democracy. I know that because I lived in both these systems during my lifetime.
@timtrewyn453
@timtrewyn453 17 дней назад
It's about the morale of the populace and its productivity. US with 2.5 times Russian population but 10 times larger economy. US with 1/4 the population of China but a slightly larger economy. Autocrats just don't get it morale. They try, but they don't have the empathy to get it right. Autocrats just want to win. The people come in second and more humiliated than people in liberal democracy.
@user-gu7lv9gk8m
@user-gu7lv9gk8m 17 дней назад
This guy is insane. He thinks neo-conservatives wanna spread liberalism.
@jdotsalter910
@jdotsalter910 17 дней назад
Just like the idea of Marxism in practice was a catastrophe in the hands of madmen like Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot.
@donalkinsella4380
@donalkinsella4380 18 дней назад
Britain was the worlds superpower when Ireland kicked in out of Ireland. The fight for freedom and homeland can never be beaten. Quietened temporarily but never beaten.
@DonQuickZote
@DonQuickZote 16 дней назад
Whose freedom are you supporting in this conflict?
@BonusHole
@BonusHole 16 дней назад
Ireland never kicked Britain out of Ireland - we still own the North. Ireland just got eaten by the EU. An even bigger bunch of c***s. Next stop - The Irish Caliphate - the Mother of all c***s.
@rerite2
@rerite2 15 дней назад
Don't the British still have a chunk of Ireland under their thumb?
@donalkinsella4380
@donalkinsella4380 15 дней назад
@@rerite2 Signed away controlling interest during the Good Friday Agreement. They were desperate for the IRA bombing campaign in Britain to end. Thatcher, Major and Blair admitted the IRA could never be beaten. The British army (superpower) wanted a truce. Would you like a link??
@BonusHole
@BonusHole 15 дней назад
@@rerite2 No a chunk of Ireland wants to be in Britain.
@Mia-xw1nh
@Mia-xw1nh 4 дня назад
Great guest... some home truths that should be out there more.
@jennyperez3981
@jennyperez3981 12 дней назад
Thank you for the education in foreign affairs
@desilva300
@desilva300 18 дней назад
And how is law of Foreign agent in Georgia is pro Russian? USA has exactky the same law - are they also Pro Russia? Why have a fair to declare the money you recieve, if you are not doing anything bad? If your consious is clean.
@christophersmith3248
@christophersmith3248 17 дней назад
At last! Some factual commentary in British media.
@KennyG-qh8jc
@KennyG-qh8jc 2 дня назад
John is spot on on all of this.
@johnmccaffrey5942
@johnmccaffrey5942 15 дней назад
Mearsheimer is the most astute observer out there. I see a lot of the negative comments about him are personal attacks but not on his analysis. I wonder why
@Frederer59
@Frederer59 19 дней назад
Professor Meirsheimer is correct but very understated and ivory tower in tone. I would refer your viewers to the recent long-form Tucker Carlson/Jeffrey Sachs interview (2.5hrs) to get a more first-hand perspective from a diplomat with 40+ yrs. in the fray.
@gerry4281
@gerry4281 19 дней назад
Plus Sachs is more in favour of keeping good relations with China.
@ahartify
@ahartify 19 дней назад
I would refer you to Timothy Synder if you want an intelligent analysis. If you want to listen to a couple of mindless loonies then go ahead.
@jessiejb4684
@jessiejb4684 19 дней назад
@@ahartifyTimothy snider is a Bonafide lunatic. His reality is entirely constructed in his mind but a useful idiot for war mongering d.c. elites. I’d suggest instead do some research of your own or at very least get a mix of perspectives and use critical thinking.
@Wybowazza
@Wybowazza 19 дней назад
That interview is superb, Sachs is so frustrated with US policy.
@l3eatalphal3eatalpha
@l3eatalphal3eatalpha 19 дней назад
@@ahartify 'intelligent analysis' = 'point of view I agree with and if it is intelligent so am I '. You didn't even spell his name correctly.
@roryquarrier7337
@roryquarrier7337 19 дней назад
The only reason why I visit the spectator is Americano and maybe holy smoke
@ignatziusturret5641
@ignatziusturret5641 7 дней назад
Russia forces You! to negotiate. 😂😂😂
@luisgoncalves9498
@luisgoncalves9498 День назад
Sound mind, sound arguments. Freedom to present and counter argue. Wish theres were more comunicators like john mearsheimer. But the world of journalism and investigation is dried of money. For now.
@bitsandbobs4082
@bitsandbobs4082 17 дней назад
The poor level of Intelligence provided by the various agencies is seen in the statements made like the ruble would be rumble or Ursulas remarks that Russia was taking all the chips from washing machines and their economy was in tatters, our intel is terrible totally unrieable. Just listen to questions which are as ever all about the strawman still
@josephtany9515
@josephtany9515 17 дней назад
According to customary law and similar to execution in civil cases, the International Court of Justice is required to appoint volunteer countries to intervene and stop the genocide
@deirdrefleming9935
@deirdrefleming9935 16 дней назад
Thank you for interviewing Mearsheimer. How about Jeffrey Sachs next?
@nickolaygrigorov1475
@nickolaygrigorov1475 16 дней назад
The exchange about lost escalation dominance vs Iran was quite good.
@redaerf2b414
@redaerf2b414 18 дней назад
Ukraine had no means to maintain nuclear weapons. It had sold out 3/4 of its conventional weapons during independence because it had no money to keep it running.
@Io-Io-Io
@Io-Io-Io 19 дней назад
What's wrong with you Mearshie? Russia will never accept Ukraine becoming a part of NATO and no one can do anything about it
@cliomuse1206
@cliomuse1206 17 дней назад
The Kremlin had the same rhetoric for other Eastern European countries in the 90s, but we did join NATO despite Russia’s opinion. They need to suck it up or at the very least, ask themselves the questions why all of these countries are flocking to NATO and the EU, and want to get as further away from Russia as possible.
@ignatziusturret5641
@ignatziusturret5641 7 дней назад
What has Ukraine has in common with Poland, Hungary or the Baltic States?​@@cliomuse1206
@johnwatkin9548
@johnwatkin9548 9 дней назад
"The Russian ability to produce weapons....outstrips the West." Yet Russia had to go to North Korea of all places to replenish artillery ammunition.
@RthnVhm.o-sc5he
@RthnVhm.o-sc5he 20 часов назад
Support of democracies is not foolish. The opposite is foolish.
@middleguy840
@middleguy840 19 дней назад
Spectator your head is finally getting out of the sand! Well done in getting John Mearsheimer.
@vgames6792
@vgames6792 19 дней назад
not really?!, still spitting western BS propaganda lies, like Sergei Shoigu was fired, when he actually got promoted to Security Council. As for the Meirsheimer, he is not what he used to be, have feeling that he is getting corrupted
@SpectatorTV
@SpectatorTV 18 дней назад
Thank you!
@keepthefireburning3989
@keepthefireburning3989 19 дней назад
Ukraine did not posess the nuclear weappons, stationed on the territorry of Ukraine after the fall of the Sovjet Union. Those weappons belonged to Russia as the legal successor state of the USSR. Ukraine did not even have the nuclear code to use those weappons. The Budapest Memorandum (which was not a international treaty but just a memorandum) stated, that the nuclear weappons were transfered to Russia and that the territorial sovereignty of Ukraine was guaranteed. But, according to the Memorandum there were other crucial points. No other state or entity was allowed to intervene economically in Ukraine and, secondly, conflicts have to be settled immediately by consultations. Both of these arcitles were fullfilled by Russia but were breached by the west. First, the EU coerced Ukraine and Janukowytsch to sign the association treaty between the EU and Ukraine. This treaty would have meant the full orientation of the Ukraine economy torwards the West. (Janukowytsch refused which lead to the Maidan Coup and a new unconstitutional "government" in Kiev. ) Secondly Russia and Ukraine negotiated in Istanbul (March/April 2022) and got to an agreement but the West (Boris Johnson) sabbotaged this agreement.
@vodekz1534
@vodekz1534 18 дней назад
see 1993 agreement USA, Russia and Ukraine
@server1ok
@server1ok 18 дней назад
You are basically admitting that Russia initiated an aggressive invasion of it's historical neighbor, that there was no sizeable UA separatist army without Russian support and that Russia is razing Ukrainian cities to the ground, because Yanu was ousted and Ukraine wanted to join the EU. Yes. This is exactly what's happening and this is AGAINST international law and against the conventions of war, and hence, Russia has to be stopped or there will be no laws left anywhere on the planet.
@mikamantynen2976
@mikamantynen2976 16 дней назад
"It's been an interesting conflict" - talking directly to the hearts of Ukraineans
@ady9830
@ady9830 17 дней назад
Note how mearsheimer says "we" with regard to the war ie it's a US war.
@alexdetrojan4534
@alexdetrojan4534 12 дней назад
'We' as the West...
@zoranazanoskar5400
@zoranazanoskar5400 19 дней назад
Ukraine did not have nuclear weapons. They were Soviet nuclear head, and Russia is the successor of SSSR. Whole control system for those heads was in Moscow. Had the rockets stayed in Ukraine, they would have been completely inoperable.
@shanejean5821
@shanejean5821 18 дней назад
You would think the Professor would mention that..
@zoranazanoskar5400
@zoranazanoskar5400 18 дней назад
@@shanejean5821 yes, you would think so. But deep down - he is American. He only recently figured out that Russia has a lot more people than Ukraine.
@davidap257
@davidap257 18 дней назад
As a NATO member ukraine would have them,the Russians don't want that.
@mensrea1251
@mensrea1251 18 дней назад
Apparently you’re wrong. Why all the gyrations and negotiations among the major powers to disarm Ukraine back then. Was it all just for fun? Please stop pretending to know things you do not know anything about.
@timtrewyn453
@timtrewyn453 17 дней назад
@@zoranazanoskar5400 When did Russia figure out China has a lot more people than Russia? Xi is smiling in their face.
@almapraxeda6049
@almapraxeda6049 17 дней назад
Thank you for these Statements
@BlahBlah-kb1wf
@BlahBlah-kb1wf 17 дней назад
Quite an interesting map behind Mr. Mearsheimer.
@debbie7707
@debbie7707 16 дней назад
Why are we trying to "stymie" Russia? If Russia is not hawkish, as the Professor says, if Russia is not planning to swallow up Eastern Europe and continue expanding (which is demonstrable), but is instead in Ukraine because of its perception of Western intrigue and US weapons on its borders, the real question then becomes: What believable argument does the West make for actually being entrenched there? "To defend democracy" cannot be the answer since Ukraine is not a democracy, and since we are obviously absolutely indifferent to our own crippled democratic state of chaos, rampant crime, corruption, deprivation of the suffering, and open borders--whose government welcomes the gluttonous infiltration by millions of unknowns. This war is about Western hegemony--the perverse ambition of conquering the world and greedily seizing control of more and more nations, asserting power, and illicitly gobbling up the spoils of all for itself.
@marscruz
@marscruz 16 дней назад
You have to be able to tell the difference between what they say their motives are and what their actual motives are. If you can't understand that the government constantly lies and misleads you then you won't ever understand what is really going on. You won't learn anything by watching TV or listening to the various talking heads or spokespeople. Good luck sweetie. The rabbit hole goes much deeper than you could ever imagine.
@wolfbirk8295
@wolfbirk8295 15 дней назад
You got it...,?
@1being
@1being 15 дней назад
"Open borders"? Really? I guess you want a wall. Geez learn to live with the rest of humanity. Many of those who cross the border are escaping vehemently countries the US deliberately wrecked. Stop wrecking countries and many will stay home.
@joemerino3243
@joemerino3243 15 дней назад
Pretty amazing to hear Russians calling anybody else greedy for territory.
@Denime
@Denime 14 дней назад
You’re factually incorrect in your description of Ukraine’s democracy. They have held many elections, with multiple different presidents in power since 1992. Here’s the CATO Freedom Index for 2023. Ukraine (83) far outranks Russia (121), UAE (125), Turkey (128) and India (109). Israel itself is only 59, with Greece at 57. And on “personal freedom”, Israel and Ukraine are almost identical (7.12 and 7.32) vs Russia (5.9). Ukraine loses on “economic freedom” which is not required for it to be a healthy democracy. You can be poor and free. The war is destroying Ukraine’s democracy, just like Putin wants it to, interfering with normal functions of a society. A successful Ukrainian democracy would put Putin’s regime at risk.
@Roruoni
@Roruoni 17 дней назад
The Georgian "Pro Russia" Law is modelled after the US's FARA legislation. It's only pro Russian if non-russians are funding NGOs in Georgia. Fpor that matter is also requires Russian NGOs to reveal their funding. I guess The Host knows far more western money goes into politics.
@bobhiggins4276
@bobhiggins4276 17 дней назад
Not liberal democracy in the US, but capitalism dominating, increasingly, a limited, tattered democratic system. Unchecked capitalism with a fig leaf of limited democracy is what is being exported.
@paul7bana
@paul7bana 16 дней назад
American Political Scientist John Joseph Mearsheimer Receives the Valdai Award-2019
@antndecks
@antndecks 19 дней назад
Timestamps please
@kierangreen2531
@kierangreen2531 19 дней назад
Yes!
@johnsmith1474
@johnsmith1474 19 дней назад
Use a period to end a sentence, watch a video in full, fix your hamster attention span.
@encod3123
@encod3123 18 дней назад
"fix your hamster attention span", LoL. I'm definitely using this one day.
@SpectatorTV
@SpectatorTV 18 дней назад
Of course, on their way.
@janusz5420
@janusz5420 19 дней назад
Mr Gray does not know how to pronounce Putin and Fico - shame Englishmen🧐
@Myohomoto
@Myohomoto 17 дней назад
It's a common idiom in British English due to his regional pronunciation.
@andreicreacico6327
@andreicreacico6327 17 дней назад
How can you expect Ukraine to win when your supplies of weapons are just about 10% of the russian military budget?
@ducheburatini5979
@ducheburatini5979 10 дней назад
The nuclear weapons remaining in Ukraine from the USSR had a control center in Russia, so it made no sense for Ukraine to keep them.
@jdghgh
@jdghgh 15 дней назад
I can accept Mearsheimer in terms of his realist approach to geopolitics. What I have trouble with is his whole attitude regarding Russia.
@nexxogen
@nexxogen 14 дней назад
Because the default is "Russa bad" and you cannot let go of that in any capacity?
@jdghgh
@jdghgh 14 дней назад
@@nexxogen In terms of 'default', that's not how it works for me. I let evidence speak for itself.
@nexxogen
@nexxogen 14 дней назад
@@jdghgh And what evidence is that?
@ia24645
@ia24645 14 дней назад
@@jdghghWhat evidence is that?
@raymondreddington9788
@raymondreddington9788 13 дней назад
@@nexxogen He doesnt have evidence
Далее
Anne Applebaum on Ukraine, Russia, Europe, and the US
48:07
Legendary KNOCKOUT
00:44
Просмотров 3 млн
Пранк над Катей 🤣🤣🤣
01:00
Просмотров 507 тыс.
Palestine Talks | John Mearsheimer discusses Gaza
30:14
Legendary KNOCKOUT
00:44
Просмотров 3 млн