I always appreciated that the four Joshes are clearly different and have different voices. Vinnie is definitely one of the underappreciated members of the cast - possibly because Josh is such a blank character for Rebecca to project onto.
I know he's not a fan favourite, but can we get some Josh appreciation? I mean he goes through a lot and becomes a better person from that, and Vincent Rodriguez III is sooo talented!
I never liked josh as rebeccas love interest but I definitely thought he was a really well written character, went through so much character development (as did most of the main characters) and Vincent killed all of his solos (and he’s just an incredible dancer so there’s that too)
Are you planing on doing one with Daryll's best solos? I think he has a some amount (7 songs). It is not surprising that Josh stopped having solos after Rebecca became less interested in him.
my man got jilted by the writers and deserved better songs tbh 😤 he is too talented a performer to not get that. for shame! but "i've got my head in the clouds" is a forever jam and i am randomly humming it always and forever. his voice is so amazing aaaaaaaah
Josh was one of my favorite characters on the show. Especially because we're forced to see him through Rebecca's unreliable borderline perspective for most of the show. First, he's the best person ever and she's blind to his flaws. Then, after standing her up at the altar (for a somewhat justified reason too), he's the worst person who ever lived. Then Rebecca gets therapy and we slowly see that Josh is just "a guy", with good and bad traits, who is figuring out this "growing up" thing too. Hell, once he does, he and a now diagnozed Rebecca arguably could've been a fantastic couple. But that was never going to happen; not when Josh was still figuring it out and not as long as Rebecca saw him as the "solution" to all her problems, which was something even a more mature, level-headed Josh (or any person) would be able to live up to.
Sulphur and Honey I go to the zoo! Other than that, no, but I’ve had a few requests for a Nathaniel vid now so I’m thinking I will do one including duets for him
I don't like Vinnie's voice as much as the other guys in the show, but he killed Ping Pong girl and Boyband Made up for Joshes. FWIW His dancing is the best in the cast (tied with Ruiz).
In my heart ping pong girl is essentially tied with head in the clouds, I wouldn't have been able to decide. The rest of this is pitch perfect as always. I admire your taste and also willingness to make all these because I would be unable to do it
@@hanne7121 no, im pretty sure thats all there is to it. like he sung ping pong girl in the first season itself. and that was perfect, including his voice and how it fit the genre they were parodying. so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Josh isn't the best singer but a talented dancer and plays the "dummy hottie" well and i think he's actually well played by Vincent Rodriguez III Edit: I think he's a good singer but obviously not the best (Donna Lynne still for me)
It's so fun to see how others rank the songs, both in the videos and the comments! For me, I'd keep almost everything the same, but swap Head In the Clouds & Ping Pong Girl's positions. I love these videos though 😍
my two ultimate favorites Josh's songs are "Thought Bubbles" and "I've Got My Head In The Clouds", but it's really a personal preference and i super get your rank! love from a cxg fan from brazil sz
