Just Stop Oil's Phoebe Plummer argues 'people are DYING' in net zero clash with Jacob Rees-Mogg 

Absolutely bang on, it does.

Everything is because of the oil industry.

As do her plastic earrings.

Her entire life exists because of the oil industry...these people are brainwashed and deluded.

this is what i love about these 'Phoebe' type's....they piss and moan about the very things they contribute too. The middle class gave birth to silver spooned hippies, and now we have to suffer their privilege's.

She has a 20 year old girl as her Climate God.

No repeat assertions she has heard from scientists.

Watch it again, she actually says who she is quoting.

To be fair she cited august establishment bodies, not activist bodies. Still, as a sceptic, don't you think it's the slightest bit fishy that the fossil fuel aligned media only ever seem to platform hysterical, pink haired student types to discuss this existential issue?

​@@clive373 In the real world, Clive, do you really imagine you could find 153 genuine people stupid enough to thumbs up an idiotic comment like this one, even among an idiot demographic like this one? Their business model lies in the manufacture of your consent, and they don't care how they achieve it.

yussss

They definately know exactly who to recruit. This approach works at shutting down otherwise intelligent people, so fearful of appearing uncaring. She even outed herself in this interview as a know nothing ranter

Its a cult. Look at the people in these protests. They look glossy I'd and not in touch with reality. I've seen people who are activists. These people look like droids. Completely out to lunch. I think they should do a deep dive and have someone go inside

People will really start dying if there's no food in Tesco any more.

Exactly right. People are dying , all the time , we always have done for as long as I can remember and I’m sure even before that too ? She reminded me of myself when I was 13 and just beginning to look at things beyond my playground .,I would only see blame , injustice and wrong, , history , context , the right and good just didn’t seem interesting enough when it was far easier to sound like I knew what I was talking about by slinging around sound bites read in a book or seen in a documentary, thinking I would confound everyone else with a good phrase “ like they do so easily on the tv “ . Naive inexperienced people always think they know the answers and always assign bad intentions to everything gone before them being born , because were always rediscovering the world around us , the young and naive seem to see it in a very one dimensional way . They seem unable to conceive of how and why we are where we are now , with massive health benefits , life expectancy extended , greater wealth , security and education for millions who otherwise would be poverty stricken , confined to their small world , starving, illiterate and dead before they reached 35 . They can’t conceive of people acting for the good of all , cannot understand context , only negative motives for every one of the world problems . Her words here are always hysterical hyperbole , the language of slanderous extremes that reasonable people just cannot debate seriously .possibly because question her and her peers further on anything they claim and they immediately switch to another topic . They can’t debate further because like a 14 year old they’ve only thought to use the sensational language of effect and no substance , expecting listeners to be wowed by the power of their slogans . When questioned further they resort to insult and breathless exaggerations their voices getting higher and higher all the time as they panic ! We’ve seen it in every single interview with whichever spokesperson they put on tv, a hysterical , neurotic slogan shouter who disintegrates in seconds when asked a simple logical question , just like a 14 year old caught out by teacher or parents . The shocking thing is many of these activists interviewed are retired people one hopes would be able to string a sentence together without an attack of hysteria , sadly not it seems . Have they all perhaps met at a group meeting for neurotics and hysterics anonymous ? Forgive my going off on one , I’ll stop now , they do seem to do this to me and others !

@@saudade369it was a long rant which could have been worded more concisely but otherwise, you made your points well and clear. I’m inclined to agree.

@@qwut9544 yes I plead guilty To enjoying a well thought out piece of rhetoric and loving the written word , I enjoy writing if I can occasionally become a bit self indulgent . Thank you for the critique

They always put out these propaganda statistics "A million babies have been killed in Iraq" etc "people are dying", "Britons are freezing in their homes" but without any evidence of anything they spout. It's propaganda repeated to them and their young immature minds mold into it and this is the result you get. Then they dye their hair to stand out more as the weirdos they are.

How would the lorries get your food to the stores answer I'm not a science.

Well, I'm not young enough to know everything.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

She admits that she has no solutions though - she has said several times that she is 'not a scientist', so she's basically there to rant and moan.

@@chrishart8548 yep yes i, no scientist is her defence yeqh

Those who don't have jobs, raise families or pay their own bills - amazingly they know it all!!

''Look, Dad, yeah. I've been getting spannered drunk every day for 4 years at Uni, I scraped my sociology degree with copy pasting wikipedia and Twitter rants. I think I know what I'm talking about, I have 412 followers for a reason''

😅

thats good 🍻

Ha ha that’s funny.

When what she really needs is a firm hand, liberally applied.

yas

Quite frankly im not a scientist im just listing to what the experts are saying..enough said.. By the way those experts are RU-vidrs who look just like her.😂😂

1966: Oil Gone in Ten Years 1968: Overpopulation - humanity starves. 1970: Natural resources gone within 10 years 1972: Oil depleted in 20 Years 1971: Nitrogen build-up will make all land unusable 1970: Killer Bees will make areas of US no-go zones 1971: Insecticides will kill all birds and insects 1972: New Ice Age By 2070 1974: Ozone Depletion a ‘Great Peril to Life’ 1978: Planet cooling, mass famines imminent 1980: Acid Rain will kill all life on Earth 1987: Ozone layer destroyed 1988: Maldives underwater by 2018 1989: Rising sea levels will obliterate nations 2002: Famine In 10 Years If we keep eating meat. 2004: Britain will be like Siberia by 2024 2008: Arctic will be ice free by 2018 2008: Al Gore predicts ice-free arctic by 2013 2009: 50 days to ‘Save The Planet From Catastrophe’ 2013: Arctic ice-free by 2015 2014: 500 days before ‘Climate Chaos’ 2018: Climate expert Greta Thundergob says 5 years left until climate change kills us all 2021: John Kerry (and Hollywood virtue signallers) fly around the world on private jets to warn us about climate change

Hmm yes... Bit like the Brexiteers/ GBeebies/ Daily Fail readers then!

@@Phippsta Yes, both side have dumb fucks on the extremes, whats your point?

Remember… She’s NOT a scientist…no shit Sherlock😂

@@gingerturtle4229 And neither is Mogg.

​@@Phippsta spanner!

Would you prefer if she was naked?

Yup! Being able to afford all of that totally makes her the arbiter of what impoverished families need and to reprimand JRM for not being poor..... the money that was used to buy that hair dye totally couldn't have contributed to buying a meal.......

It reminds me of the Life of Brian sketch about the Romans.

Good observation.

Could be thrifted. Her clothes look vintage.

Exactly. And her 9 times cheaper BS is just that BS. You cant force electric companies to invest the enormous amounts of money to change their entire infrastructure and create battery storage large enough without passing on all of those costs directly to the consumer, so cost per kilowatt hour will go up not down.

"I'm not a scientist." This is no at all problem. But...However, the problem is that even though she is 21 years old Lady does not know that the material of her clothes are acrylic "synthetic fiber".

So did David Attenborough 45 years ago

She did, and she's deleted her tweet, as you probably know.

have you got a link to that?

😂😂😂

@@greenandpleasant5523 didn't you get a screenshot?

Yes he person from the Tories party

He pays no tax as his profits go into an offshore account plus before brevity he moved his offices to Ireland an EU country!

Absolutely!

@@razkhan2958 A Hero. who is sensible!!

@@kevlacy5306 Nope, he hasn't moved his offices to Ireland and pays all taxes due…. The left don't like him, so instead of debating him, they lie about him.

atleast lunatics still have a bit of human decency and don't glue their hands onto the road 🤣

spoilt little brat

Don't talk about Jacob that way.

Did she go there to train to be a scientist ?

Just hope they didn't pay for her to be a scientist hey ;)

She has pink hair to show that despite her private education, she is a victim

Notice she. Like.many jso, make it sound as if oil drilling isn't stopped, that we are all going to die tomorrow.

​@@davidshore3523hahaha that is absolute fact🤣👍

😂 all made from fossil fuels!

😂

I'm going to screen shot your comment it's priceless, and will definitely be my favourite comment of the day,maybe even the week. :-)

Reminds of a group of punk rockers all dressed the same because they were different.

Crikey charlie she's a kid vicious.....

We created these monsters

I'm only 18 in a few months, and even I'm more educated than this clown. Climate change is a big hoax anyway

So why have they even given her the time of day

​@@MonstaTrapz I suppose it exposes their idiocies.

I've done all the above, fed a family, paid a mortgage, paid off a mortgage, nursed the sick and dying, taught for 36 years. Retrofitted, renovated Edwardian house - now a lovely warm home ( one of locally open-homed Greener Homes) with solar PV, solar thermal, air source heat pump, EV charger for visitors, tricycle to take cats to the vets, bus pass, wildlife friendly garden, resources constraint -including water-and Tesla battery storage. 100 Gigafactories could transition us all away from deadly extinction fuels, sadly and corruptly mis-sold to humanity for 50 years. Renewables are now cheaper than gas and nuclear. Storage of clean energy is also possible using industrial batteries and we have interconnecters from other countries to help. Environmental ignorance and the lies of the CFC industry nearly led to the loss of our ozone layer (hence Montreal Protocol 1987). Luckily the British Antarctic Survey drew attention to the ozone holes which are still recovering! And it's thanks to Greenpeace stopping the cruelty of industrial whaling we still have oxygen in our oceans. There's a symbiotic relationship between whale excreta, krill and the phytoplankton that makes up to 70% of Earth's oxygen. Nothing like a nice bit of fresh air for the lungs! Unless we all get a grip and restore Earth's dying ecosystems we'll be just as toasted as the victims of previous mass extinctions. We deserve a Public Information Programme of Environmental Literacy which could have been delivered by Sir Patrick Vallance and Sir Chris Whitty at the same time as covid. Late though it is and carbon now at dangerous historic levels please ask your representatives for such a programme and to take seriously the well-being of everyone and everything you love and value. We should not be backing anachronistic Broadmoor policies of overconsumption or reliance on dirty energies, now gas-chambering our only home. We can all help and do our best to hang on to a habitable planet, before triggering disastrous global tipping points from which there is no return. I don't know about you but I like having shoes on my feet and a nice bit of lunch. Resource wars, starvation and mass migrations lie ahead unless we plan properly, helping each other to decarbonise at speed and scale, restoring the crippled natural world. All the best to you and to Phoebe.

I hope somebody plays this to her.

This is the mental disorder we have in our youth today, we've these thick people that are narcissistic. Mummy, daddy and their teacher have told them they're special and they're winners a their lives. So when they read a couple of flim flam sheets of biased information, and sit in a drum circle, they think they're a bloody genius's. Arrogance and Ignorance are a dangerous couple that should never go hand in hand.

No, she will be able to watch it, with her lovely pink hair! lol 😂 😂

But she won't be alive in twenty years, as according to her, the world will have ended.

No she won't because according to her we will all be dead hahaha 😂 idiots with pink hair ps she didn't grow up where I come from (ordinary people) hahaha 😂

Not me. I’m looking forward to when she glues here face on the mainline to Scotland.

Self righteous zealotry of youth

A little humility would've gone a long way

They raised her, they’re likely proud of the young lady she’s grown into, as they say, the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.

I've met teachers from all over the world. They all agree on one thing. Regarding the behaviour of children, the parents are always the problem.

Well intentioned but misguided.

I'm angry that she was even born!

I think it's the dyed hair and Doc Martin boots that push it beyond the ridiculous. Isn't all that hair dye bad for the environment?

She’s after attention, Monkey see Monkey do, she wants to be like Greta, c’mon man.

If she'd been born into a deprived area she'd be too busy trying to get by, day by day.

@Mega Xenu Try as she may she will never be able to shake that condescending public school inflection. And all the hair dye and Doc Martins in the world won't cover up the intense loathing of her own lineage

I forgive her, her sins in the name of our lord Jesus Christ, now I hope she will go forth and trespass no more 😕👍

That hair. Why would anyone do that to themselves? "My God, she's got pink hair. We've got to take her seriously." She gives brainwashing a whole new meaning. "People are dying!!!" That's been happening for quite some time, darling.

Nice hair.

I blame her middle class parents.

probably all her references are from armageddon type movies

Follow the science !

Best comment by far laughing love it 😂😂😂😂😂💕💕💕👍👍👍🇬🇧

Is that Doris the bog trotter?

She said it twice because, you know, who would not have thought that she was not a scientist!

I thought she might have been one of the BogTrotting play boys Mark and Lard , but I was sadly wrong

Or the lifespan?

Or the slave labour involved?

Are the factories that produce the parts to make them all doing their bit for the environment?

Solar panels are make from doped silicon usually but there are also other methods, see: RU-vid channel “Just Have A Think”, there's a program about their recycling.

And that it we have two things called night and winter.

Yes but my yappy dog makes more sense.

Actually I get more sense from my cat

That's when you know she has nothing of substance to empart!

Rainbow hair and hysteria is always worth avoiding and ignoring.

Yeah, good innit 😝

shes an actress. a puppet of the elite. you are watching a staged debate. why are you still asleep?

Period, guaranteed

Absolutely none of the millennials have any real answers.

Well duh man of course she doesn't the scientists need to fix this and she said many times she isn't a scientist.

Criticism implies some kind of analysis or judgement. She seems to just be spouting the same old talking points.

Bet she's never picked up litter, that's beneath her.

@@Adam-sd2ow only "ordinary" people do that sort of thing.

She never paid a bill on her life and lives in university accommodation. She said it so herself in return to a question from Katie Hopkins

Agree 100%

But she has purple h air,

I am 73, she has purple hair, multiple piercings, is in college being programed by socialists, and wants me to take her serious!

Correct….a useful idiot and a dangerous one

Her only answers to questions is to shout the same slogans over and over. It's like trying to tell your q2 year old that she can't go to an all night party "but this is the party of the year if I don't go you're ruining my life and destroying my future why do you hate me?" roll eyes slam doors and sulk until your parents change their mind

makes me shudder

Indeed.

I take no notice of these rich crackpots, it just shows you what kids are being taught in schools, I would close all schools in England, and sack all the teachers.

Lied

It's the Communist subversion technique of Demoralisation. Yuri Bezmenov the KGB defector going viral again warned of all of us. Little Gremlin Thunberg is also a victim of this. Watch New Discourses as well , the best anti Woke channel on here.

Yet he'll never be prime minister-although he might make a good one-and instead at some point we'll probably end up with someone like her in No. 10. Stop the country, I want to get off.

Yes. It wasn't going well for her, and even though she is passionate, granted, she lost control and started being abusive. She didn't offer any short term solutions to our energy needs, as Jacob spoke about how we need to live NOW. There has to be a solution long term, but in the short term, NOW, it's not practical to go gung ho on renewables.

Just a thought but maybe they should have invited an actual climate scientist on? See this is the problem I have with GB News and their climate coverage, they invite these fringe, activist kids on who are operating largely on emotion and these more media savvy presenters expose the gaps in their knowledge to enforce their narrative that, "see, it's all green loonies who don't know what they're talking about". I don't mind a good debate but it's not as if there are no climate scientists or green energy specialists who couldn't adequately answer Mogg's questions. The solution to the wind not blowing or the sun not shining is a more expansive, pan-European green grid along with storage (battery, tidal, gravity etc.) and the use of SMR's (small modular reactors). Believe it or not, we will soon have solar panels which can generate power at night, using a process called radiative cooling. So there are answers to these questions but you do need to speak to somebody familiar with the industry to properly address them. Of course it's a lot easier to shake the curtains and talk about how the WHO is going to put us all in hobbit homes and make us eat bugs for tea.

If someone said that, then you should never trust them.

mate, i just cracked up when she said that

She also said "I'm not an expert" It's the same as saying "I'm a parrot". She says "renewables are 9 times cheaper" where I live we have solar panels and wind mills, but power company doesn't charge less, they sell that energy for same price as that which comes from oil or gas. Do things work differently in the UK? She also says "people are dying". That's true, about 50 to 60 million a year but, weather related deaths have dropped dramatically over the 100 years or so . . . because we have adorable energy to heat and cool our homes for nearly everyone on this planet! If want my ear for your cause you need to provide the hard evidence that CO2 drives the climate! I've been waiting for more than 50 years for it. I've lived through all of the erroneous predictions of the climate alarmist since the late 60s and not one of them has come true!

"affordable*

Reese Mogg has several little mini me's at home ... he knows just how to deal with entitled little shits

He handled her brilliantly. Her performance was awful.

She needs to learn from that encounter. Hopefully when she watches it back, she will.

Mogg’s kids will be ok they will be loaded.

The Mog calmly demonstrating how to shoot fish in a barrel;

@@steveb951 I get there’s a consensus among many to do with economic standing and moral virtue having something to do with each other. Loaded as he may be does that make what he’s saying any less true? she is shouting the same shit over and over and will not or can not give an articulated answer bearing any substance to contend with his argument? If there was one could u tell me what it was? I’m not the smartest of plebs but I’m willing to hear ideas? 😂

@@Stevewatson3 read the latest UN and IPCC reports she refers to and you might understand. Agree though she didn’t convey her message very well but what 20 student would! As for conflating economic mix standing with low moral values I would say here is a definite connection there, let’s face it there are some unpleasant rich people out there.

@@steveb951 although I agree with you! I’ve met some pretty shitty people from every standing. If we where to base the argument on this conversation alone totally unaware of either of there economic standing I would hands down say he was more civilised than her? 20s either too old to be a brat or too young to be speaking on such matters which I wouldn’t want to place a rule upon, but we can agree to disagree if you’d like. I’ve read this and don’t see how it compels the factor that what she is claiming you have to be a scientist to understand proves. You can not feed more people by stopping oil and fossil fuels, even though I don’t like it either it’s the truth. There willing to sacrifice the people today for the ones of a future Utopia? If the reports prove organic farming can keep food on the shelves more than diesel powered machine operation can I’m all for it but please show me how? copy and paste it if you must. Thanks man.

I can see her on the Labour back benches.

'course of any of us want a future, we've got to address one BIG problem . . . mass over-population of human beings!! 10 billion by 2050!!! ⬅with 3 exclamation marks.

But...THE SKY IS FALLING, THE SKY IS FALLING!

guys she's not a scientist

​@@wijny4222and in the seventies the scientists were saying we were going into a new ice age and when that didn't pan out they started claiming we were going into a period of global catastrophic warming and when that didn't pan out they started just making general claims of catastrophic climate change. Scientists change their mind about what's going on faster than they change their underwear.

he should have put her over his knee and spanked her.

And by the way, he’s lived a long and successful life, he should be worth at least a million. That’s how that works.

🐷 💩. She really is that thick.

He was very dignified to her.

Let's be real....she did not have to even say a single word... this was the point we all knew what we needed to know... 0:04

"There you have it, ladies and gentlemen, this concludes our interview and I'm indeed sorry to have wasted your time."

Is she walking as transportation and Grown her own food ? . Without Fossil fuels foods can’t walk to the Markets.

@@lethanhnguyen3368 My food absolutely can walk to markets, It's called "on the hoof".

@@stevep7346 Good on you.🤣

I keep telling that to my teenage son. I'm waiting for the looming day he "gets it"....

That’s so brilliant and so true

It took me until around age forty to start believing my father's judgement was trustworthy. I wish I'd done it earlier and would advise all young men to actually listen to their dads.

I didn’t realise how wise my dad was until I had kids of my own…and often found myself repeating his advice.

Lol well said

i would have struggled not to slap her.

JRM could out discuss anyone and he knows it.

Agree she’s a bit annoying but then most 20 years olds are.

I know . How he actually kept a straight face is truly heroic . ( Of course she is obviously deranged and they always flush their ownselves out )

I think these hysterical eco-zealots are taken far too seriously.. They need a lot more of us to laugh at their clown-like antics..

Yes, because her brain has been wired to a different wavelength of "cl;imate disaster" over climate change brought about by well, changes in the climate!

BuT doN’t yOu cAre aBouT hOw sHe and hEr siX cHildRen feeL…or something like that?

Yep she trounced him with that one🙄🙄 In her own mind🤣🤣

@@MC-nb6jx 😂😂

@@MrPants1970 trucks

@@louisbeerreviews8964 Did he say 'trucks' or are you trying to Americanise Alex?

Well some people will have a laugh about how silly people were about the vaxxine too.. ohhh back in the day, how we laughed till tge jabbed pronouns became was/were .... If that's what a university education begets, I sure as hell DONT want my kids to go.

That is an understatement.

About the size of it!

It's ridiculous, just regurgitating what she's Googled with no substance or knowledge whatsoever

They all say that when asked for reasons, evidence or positive proposals. I think it means, 'I don't know'.

Which is why they took history out of the classroom

If that’s what education has come to, we are all doomed

Really ? Wow, she had Me Fooled ! 😂

You want more ? How about eat the bugs and plant "meat" and "milk"😂😂😂😂😂

Easy, he just accepted her as the trumped up little adolescent attention seeking brat she is.

He’s an old school gentleman speaking with a ‘woman’.

"Woman"....!!!!! Errr...........not yet.

You can't get Jacob worked up. It must be so frustrating for anyone arguing against him.

Calling her a woman is a bit of a stretch

Yup. I couldt stop laughing. utterly ridiculous little girl.

Students, no brains and brainless and a rich

And a psychopath

This is the production of our university system. Someone who is so brainwashed they cannot control their emotions in a debate which should be crystal clear to her and she should be able to answer the basic so called 'science' questions. My main irritation these days is being called someone who supported a certain party in Germany during the 1930s, when it is actually people like this who are. These are the same types who would be marching them onto the trains. Yes, I meant trains lol. I would like these people to go away.

Well, Mr Rees-Mogg has to keep his cool to hold onto his 50k job at GB News. Every little helps on top of his income as a top lodger in the millionaires' Tax Haven.

they can't afford heating because of people like her and her fellow activists if it wasn't for people like them we would be self sufficient in energy...net zero idiots

Great comment

Never enter into a battle of wits with an unarmed person

Intelligence and stupidity are far from mutually exclusive. She was a mathematics and computer science student at Manchester University. She is not low intelligence at all. She has been brainwashed into panicked ideological possession.

This video reminds me of one of my favourite quotes: Arguing with an idiot is like playing chess with a pigeon. It'll just knock over the pieces, shit on the board and strut about like it's won anyway.

Intelligent I think not!. She is unable to make a clear and concise argument without resorting to shouting.

😂

Made me laugh 😄

and stamp her feet until she was sick

As she runs to her bedroom cuddling her favourite teddy! 😂😂

.......and slam the door 😂

She is as thick as mince

I think id have told her to go back out and not to come back in till she’s had a word with herself and to get an attitude adjustment😂 (Thats the polite version)

Or get close to the microphone and whisper like Brandon does.

​@@causeitsthere Hair sniffing, and some creepy story about kids stroking your hairy legs or whatever, are also somehow an election winning strategy.

Not entirely true, but I support your sentiment.

She does know that, but her oil based product consumption is insignificant compared to the oil consumption for energy ises Edit: the number of people who are incapable of understanding this point genuinely is disheartening. Are you all brain-dead? Someone is trying to make a change in society, so your bar for "non-hypocrisy" is that they return to caveman dwellings until the change occurs? Are you genuinely stupid? "I want to make a change in society" "Ah🤓🤓yet you _live_ in society 🤓🤓 you HYPOCRITE!! I am so smart 😎🤓"

@@ytpanda398so she is a hypocrite then.

Leather Doc Martins

@@ytpanda398 no, its not insignificant, you have to multiply her use with 8billion. all the cloths the dies the pins the makeups the cars, that's literally 100% of our industry and transportation

@@ytpanda398 so she lives in a freezing house, never boils a kettle or takes a bath. Well..looking at her I can believe the bath bit.

She is standing on the shoulders the best scientists in the World and their evidence. For a breakdown of the information regarding storing intermittent energy see: RU-vid channel “Just Have A Think”, he also listens and reports from real scientists.

Yep, they need to employ pol pot into the higher academic institutions...

This is a good way to fuck with people tho. I like having perfectly reasonable and logical points but doing my best to appear like a mad man while getting my point across. It's pretty fun.