Seeing her dad’s precious smile brought me to 😭. Of course, hearing her sing ‘somewhere over the rainbow’ moved me beyond ‘wow’! David Foster, you’re a lucky man
How did she not win? She’s amazing and the best! All that worked with her including Simon, felt she was in a league of her own! I wish her and David Foster much happiness and many years of love!
How in Heaven did a bumpkin like Tayler Hicks ever beat her? Impossible - still - to believe. He's running a bar now in bumpkinville - she is singing with Bocelli and others all over the world. Incredible talent.
I thought Constantine had a better voice than Bo Bice sometimes it is song selection on a particular night, sometimes I don't know, just whatever taste of viewers on a particular night were I guess.
This was when the Country voters started tuning in and messing up the votes, that's how u get Taylor Hicks to win. I'm not a Country music hater I love some country songs it's just it's a known fact that the Country audience has a big pull when it comes to votes on these singing shows compared to the other genre of music ppl out there.
Every couple years, "God Bless the Child" will go through my mind and I find myself coming back to watch her audition again. What a perfect choice for Kat's voice! She is absolutely beautiful has one of the most lovely voices I've ever heard. She absolutely should have won American Idol! I wish nothing but the best for her!
Sad there are some negative posts referring to her marriage. She has a brilliant voice, lots of personality and a great actress. You can marry who you want (disappointed it wasn't me) your private life is your business, just hope you have an amazing life together. Love and luck...
@Michael Martin young men might have the stamina but us older guys know tricks they will probably never know. Viagra might keep it up longer but it doesn't come with a manual on what to do. That is called experience. There is a massive difference between just fucking and making love
@Michael Martin She’s been with several men near her age. I think by now she’s experienced enough to make a decision on whether she wants to be with someone she loves and has so much in common with, or someone she meets on a TV set. And that’s not me knocking her. She sees through his age is what I’m trying to say.
I can't decide whether her performance of Someone to Watch Over Me or Somewhere Over the Rainbow is my all time favorite of hers. They're both magnificent
@@benzmusiczone Well when you say "It doesn't come anywhere close to Kathern's version".....what that tells me as a professional musician of 55 years is that you simply are not a good judge. Because no matter who you might like as having the best version...They are in the same class period. Sorry, just saying!
@@benzmusiczone let me put this in perspective for you: Carly is overall superior because her range takes her from pop to blues and Jazz, Kathern cannot cannot do that... I doubt that you have ever seen or heard Carly in another musical setting and one of the judges on AGT, the black gentleman was heard to say about Carly that she had "Insane Talent" Try to be more open. Carly never married the conductor.
I'm from Québec, French province of Canada. I remember that season 5, specially Katharine that made a strong impression. Supertalented, likable like no one and sooo beautiful! I could easily fall in love for her. I watched the tv series "Scorpion" and she's good actress too. I hope that her life is going the way she want it. I adore her
To this day... I still have McPhever! I agree with Rod Stewart... she is born to sing the standards.I still get goosebumps every time I hear her sing Over the Rainbow. LOVE her latest album and her singing Night & Day. Thanks for this video down memory lane :)
@@suzannecurran6009 Where is she? In the mist of a Global pandemic, 10 months of Pregnancy and just delivering a child less than a week ago. On every minor and major newspaper, television, Social Media platforms in the free world. I have no freaking idea where she is. Do you?
Amo su reacción en el casting, tan talentosa, ese gusto exquisito para frasear. Estuvo perfecta siempre. Es una de mis favoritas de ese reality siempre la escucho, es un placer para mis oídos.
Classy lady with an awesome control of her musical instrument. Her live version of Somewhere Over the Rainbow is my all time favorite and yes Rod Stewart was right, I would listen to her sing the classics all night long. Also her presentation is just as good, as she can pull off sultry in a way that many modern singers simply can not.
You are a winner to the world..American Idols loss!! You are a beautiful girl with a beautiful voice...P.S. Congratulations on baby boy...you will be a fantastic Mom❤
This is what i called beauty inside out 😍😍 gosh i love her so much. Hope she can come to Malaysia again ❤❤❤ you can tell she's a great singer when she smile while singing 😍😍
She was in Whitney and Mariah's league from the start. No doubt Simon thought she should have won. Rod Stewart and Andrea Bocelli were very impressed with her, love their reaction.
I watched the entire season. Katharine had me from her first audition and put me over the top with "Over The Rainbow". How is it that she finished second to a second rate Elvis wannabe, Taylor Hicks. SMH
wow !!!! what a voice.... I saw her on Netflix Country Comfort, i had no idea who she was. What a voice ! i love the show , its an innocent , nice show and love the fact that she sings on it.
She is so pretty.I agree with the people who love her. So what she loves an older man who happens to love her very much. He has the means to give her anything she wants. She doesn’t have to have anybody’s permission. I love to see her happiness on stage and off.
Wow, four years ago. I recall Andrea Bocelli was stunned when she just started singing opera in Italian in a get together, his reaction was a meaningful wow. When you get that reaction from this man, no award can equal that response, you have arrived. Funny, I just completed this comment and that clip was included.
@@mr.balloffur Fine, I’m not the one you should fight against. I’m on her side, and was just commenting that winning the show doesn’t mean that much as far as a future career, that if you are extremely talented, you will prevail, even if they did not judge you fairly.
I just realized that she is the same Katharine McPhee who is the wife of David Foster, the 17 Grammy award-winning music composer and producer. What a beautiful face and a singing voice that has so many octaves of range. A true and super polished of an entertainer. David is lucky to have her as his wife.
I liked her on Scorpion, I never knew she was on American Idol. Before my wife died we never watched AI. So this is all new to me this year. Same goes for AGT, I never watched it until this year. My wife was very jealous so I didn't get to see a lot of stuff. Being able to finally see what I missed is like the world opening up for me. I really missed a lot. I feel like a new person.
