Atleast jonghyun is in a better place now. We dont deserve him. Never did and will never do. Let's hope that hes happy wherever he is. We love you jonghyun
The way he chose to answer the question was so heartwarming- instead of saying he passed away or why he died, he knew exactly how to word it when talking about it to a child and instead went with “he’s not well.” Even for someone like me who doesn’t really follow their music much at all, that definitely got me…
9:31 when she innocently asked one person is missing, you can see in Minho’s eyes that’s so sad, yet he protected her from the world’s complication at that moment
I saw how he still smiled when she asked who he was, and although I think it was a bittersweet smile, the fact that he seemed to be looking back at the memories like he was happy to have them made me feel better. I hope that makes sense
When I hear the questions about Jonghyun I was worried about our SHINee members, like... "What would happen if they ask about him? or How will they react or think about that questions? I really almost cry when I hear our Minho answers... +PS. I'm not good writting in English so I hope You understand what I'm saying...
The moment when minho told her that "he's not well" and "He's not a bad uncle, he's good uncle" just left me in tears and heartbroken😭💔 And the moment when she asked "One person is missing though" at that time Minho's eyes were just heartbreaking😭😔
I see many comments about Minho, but did anyone else notice that Key looked really sad when saying it was their first time as a four and looked kinda sad when watching the footage? My heart goes out to them all.
Actually, the 4 of them looked sad. They all look like choked up and their smiles stiffened. The subtle eye twitch and the hard swallow they tried to hide. I rewatched this video as I got lost in the SHINee RU-vid hole again so this time I see more details about how they talked and their gestures. As a Shawol, this will always be something heartbreaking, even now, sobbing like a child is a norm because the pain remains.
The way that Minho said "he's not a bad uncle" make me think that childrens in Korea thinks that every people who left the group is because they're problematic and this considered bad :(
My heart almost melted with the way Onew, Minho, Key and Taemin talk to the children. When the girl noticed that they were 4... the way Minho answered was so sweet, as if JJ is still alive. Actually JJ is still living in our hearts and his voice will be forever with us.
"he's not doing well. he's not a bad uncle." the way i started crying.. that was such a good way of addressing it. they all did so well, i can imagine how hard looking back at their stuff can be.
A better translation than the one in the video would be "he was unwell health-wise", that whole exchange made me absolutely bawl, I think minho put what happened in the best way he could. Looking back at everything is always bittersweet but SHINee was 5 and always will be 5.
Girl: "Whos' this?" Mino: "That's one of our members, Uncle Jonghyun" I really miss him, and I cant even imagine how hard it is for the other members. The way he said it just shows that he's still a part of them and that made me tear up.
He really had that sad look on his face, of course they miss him, but I love how he pronounces his name even with joy and pride. And the way he explains why 'Uncle Jonghyun' wasn't there is priceless, with so much respect. Like I said, they really miss him, but they continue to make it amazing even without him (a really important part of the group)
It’s funny coz he’s 31 and that kid must be like 12? So it’s a bit of a stretch to be her Dad but technically yes he could. The kid settled with “uncle”. Then you have Taemin who decided he was the 9 year olds “Oppa”. 😂
you can see the sadness in Minho's eyes when he talks about Jonghyun... He's trying to hide it soo well😭 I swear I ain't crying but it's just soo sweet. 'he is not a bad uncle, he is a great uncle"
Minho is so strong, and responded in a perfectly appropriate way. I'm glad he didn't say Jonghyun was gone, just not well to not worry the girl. As soon as she said one is missing my eyes started watering..
초5때부터 샤이니 노래들었고 그리고 6학년때 링딩동 컴백하는날 다음날 반친구들끼리 샤이니 진짜 중독성 강한노래 들고나왔다 해서 이야기 하고 그랬는데 벌써 시간이 이렇게 흘렀구나 ㅠㅠ 그리고 민호님이 한명없다고 이야기했을때 아이에게 그냥 몸이아파서 나갔다고 돌려 말했는것을 들었을때 굉장히 맘이 아팠음 종현님 진짜 노래도 잘하고 작사 작곡도 잘했는데 군생활할때 갑자기 사지방에서 종현 사망이라는 뉴스 봤을때 깜짝 놀란기억이 아직도 가시지 않는다 ㅠㅠ 종현님 항상 기억하고 있을게요
9:27 Kid: Someone's missing Minho: Yes, someone's missing Kid: Why? He left the group? Minho: Uncle Jonghyun, he wasn't feeling well.. Kid: Oh so he isn't a bad uncle then. Minho: No, he is not. He is a good uncle. Kid: Good uncle. "Who is he?" "that's one of our members, Uncle Jonghyun" I'm crying, Minho's face says it all. We love you and you will always be remembered, Jonghyun. 😭
This really made me feel uncomfortable. Yes, his face says it all. He wanted to cry but he just couldn't. Also Onew too. He literally broke down inside when he saw Jonghyun crying. That gave a damage to members for sure and I can't accept that. Channel could explain this to kids in a way they could understand. I think the channel owes an apology to both members and fans. This video is good but when you see those parts, it really affects people who love him. I had a really tough time that day and this video took me to that day again. I really think this is wrong and to make sure that this won't happen again anywhere, I want an apology.
That exchange between Minho and the little girl about jjong not being a bad uncle makes me tear up every time i see it :( They've done so well throughout the years though 🥲💖
lol very true. The inspiration for the comment was onew realizing they debuted before the kid was born and looking at the camera and going “that was a quick reality check” and he looked just so defeated and I couldn’t stop laughing 😂😂😂
As someone who is the same age as him and has been listening to SHINee for 12 years I felt this way too lmao. Every time a kid said the songs were old-fashioned or retro I felt my joints ache and my skin wrinkle 😂
허어.. 한때 엄청난 인기를 누렸던 아이돌이였는데.. 이제 요즘 애들은 모르는 아이돌이 되었다는 게 충격적이다.. 내가 나이가 많이 들었다는 것도 체감되고.. 지금 보니 다들 앳되고 힘든 시기였을텐데 엄청난 멘탈과 노력으로 극복해낸 게 멋있네.. 샤이니 오빠들, 한때 제 초등학생 시절 삶의 낙이였어요. 좋은 노래들 불러주셔서 감사합니다. 앞으로도 행복한 일만 있으시길
Everyone feeling sad when hear Minho's answer about Jonghyun, but Onew's expression when SHINee get 1 winning hit my heart so much 😭 he must be thinking so much about their memories back then 😭
@@MarinaArtDesign The small poignant moments were touching. Reading the comments got me into ugly crying. Seeing Onew's sad eyes always affects me. It says everything
"one person's missing though" "yes, one person's missing" "who? why?" "left the group?" "it's uncle jonghyun, he's not well" "ah, then he's not a bad uncle" "yes, he's not a bad uncle. he's a great uncle." my tears won't stop
The way Minho spoke of Uncle Jonghyun and the way he said he IS one of our members...My heart broke and filled at the same time. JH will never be forgotten by any of us, least of all his brothers.
she looks like a too innocent girl that aint allowed to use the internet by her mom (just blabbering sorry) at that time, when i was.. as old as her i guess idk ive already so so not innocent :(
@R. Tolmach what i tried to mention is im not sure she would check the fact what happened to jonghyun, on the internet and its normal THESE DAYS, if parents r so strict like that. i didnt say this kind of parenting is wrong.
its been a year since this was released and I am still touched by how minho explained when the girl said one person is missing and asked why.. that clip, this whole video never failed to make me cry... i swear
The kid with key was so cute. The girl with minho was not impressed in the beginning but as the discography revealed more she was clapping and she liked it. The girl with onew was mature and onew was the nervous one i feel and the kid with taemin yeah he was cute too. "My uncle is 30 and he's still single" wdym baby I'm your aunt 😂😂
Minho telling the girl “hes not well” and “hes not a bad uncle” really is when i started crying my eyes out. Also when one of the girls said “ who is that?” And minho answered “ uncle jonghyun, hes one of our members.” That really broke my heart. He will forever be a shinee member. I knew i was gonna cry when i saw shinee. Shinee is officially back. 😊
I hope the girl doesn't go back to check because she'll probably very shocked. Or even ask her parent's if he is feeling better now. Children ask a lot of questions 😢😢😢
@@kokieduoh I understand but she should know. It’s not like kids don’t know what death is. I understand why Minho wouldn’t bring it up on tv because it could have been upsetting And caused a bad reaction. But still. She’s not 3.
i love coming back to this video, especially today. it’s so healing whenever i have a rough time. their honesty and openness and kindness always warms my heart
9:27 이때 부터 종현이 얘기 하는데 민호 표정 때문에 더 맘이 아프다 진짜 아이는 순진하게 아무것도 모르니까 민호한테 물어 본거 지만 대답해 주는 민호는 진짜 저렇게 덤덤하게 말 하기 까지 얼마나 많은 시간을 슬프게 보냈을까 연습생 때부터 데뷔하고 첫1위 첫 대상 첫콘서트 첫 음악방송 무대 를 하면서 많을 시간 을 종현이와 함께 보내고 했을텐데 종현이 언급 할때 마다 민호가 덤덤하게 말하는 이유는 이제는 민호 본인 스스로가 종현이 빈 자리를 받아 드릴 준비를 하고 있어서 그런게 아닌가 싶어요
It's sad how Onew says he's bad at talking these days. He used to be so bright and bubbly on shows. I hope the love and attention he's getting these days will help with his confidence
He’s still bright and bubbly, but I think after everything that’s happened these last few years for him, he’s definitely became more cautious about himself and feels a little worried that something will come out wrong
Yes yes ive notice that. There something about onew he has changed. Im just wondering why his eye doesn't show happiness these fast days or months.he smiles but hes eyes doesn't.
@GIGI Living the life they'd had and being the leader, Onew was always mature for his age. His tendencies for silliness and dad jokes are not a measure of his immaturity. Just like how silence does not equal maturity. The type of silence that is borne of anxiety from talking is not normal, especially when he didn't use to have it. So no, it's not a good thing.
I can’t even imagine what it must have been like for shinee when they lost a member the way they did. The look on Minho’s face when she asked about the missing member. I didn’t know shinee back then but I couldn’t even imagine what it must have been like for both the surviving members and the fandom.
Honestly, the way Minho handled the girls question was very mature. He didn’t want to make her sad and he also probably knows that with adults, the response would be something like “sorry for your loss” but with kids there would probably be a follow up question like “how?”
right, I thought the same. it was a very clever answer and he managed the situation very well. it must have been hard for him too, to answer that question all of a sudden.
@@tdelioncourt1268 well i missed the point of that joke, didn't I?! I just figured I had one more competitor for Taemin's affections... sdfsdfsd 😂 Thank you for straightening me out! 💕
샤월이였을 때 최애였던 종현이가 잠시 쉬게 된 후로부터 샤이니를 의도적으로 피하게 된 일인으로서(보면 눈물이 안 끊겨서;;) 가끔씩 우연히 관련영상을 돌려보게 될 때면 피하고 싶다가도 보게 되고 막상 보고나면 또 펑펑 울고...이 영상은 여러번 들러보게 되는데 볼 때마다 민호가 돌려말할 때 눈물이 터지면서도 한켠으로는 따스한 감정이 들고...하지만 데리러 가는 여전히 온전히 듣지 못하는 한 곡이고...아 진짜 모순되는 심리네...
This video was my true introduction to SHINee. I didn’t even know all the member’s names when I watched it. Now I’m a year and a half into being a Shawol and I can’t imagine not having any of the five of them in my life.
It always makes me so happy to hear that people continue to find out about SHINee! 😊 Although you've been a Shawol for quite some time now I'd like to say welcome to the fandom 🤗
@@tomorrowneverknows9860 thank you so much! My 24th birthday was on the 4th, and my oldest sibling gifted me a SHINee fanlight. It’s so pretty in real life, I’m really happy~
I’m glad to hear one of the kids say “ So he isn’t a bad uncle”. Because now, there are so many scandals involving idols, actors and people from the entertainment industry almost everyday that has a bad effect of kids point of view on the adults.
yes, and the kids' point of view here in sk, those who are leaving the group was involved in scandals or whatever so they see them as bad person, you see? the girl asked if he left the group and she was relieved that that's not the case, ofc, they don't have much knowledge regarding the issues surrounding the celebrities and it's not like it's time for parents to explain to them everything, those are only what kids heard
I felt like it would have been okay to touch on why he wasn't there with he because she's old enough to understand, BUT that's not why they were there. I will agree that it was a decent explanation, given the time allotted. I still cried.
“One person is missing though?” “Yea one person is missing” “Who?”why? Left the group?” “Uhh.. it’s uncle Jonghyun, he’s not well..” “Ah. Then he’s not a bad uncle.” “Yes, he’s not a bad uncle, he’s a good uncle.” “Good uncle” Minho’s face when he said that.😕 We all miss him🕊❤️
9:28 - one is missing... - oh, yes... - why? Where? Did he left? - uh, yeah... Jonghyun uncle... Hes not well... - oooh! So he is good uncle. - yes, ofc. He is a good uncle. I. CRIED.
I am in SHAMBLES. He answered in such a good way for a child to understand. And those of us who are old enough to grasp it, felt how that hurt. To be honest, I love Shinee very much. They’re one of my first favorite groups but it hurts too much to listen a lot. I listen in a very bittersweet way.
제 세대보단 조금 앞이지만 오빠가 있어서 샤이니 무대도 그렇고 많이 봤었는데 그 당시에는 이런 일이 있구나 했는데 크면서 보니 얼마나 큰 일이고 모두가 슬펐을지 상상이 안되네...항상 팬사랑 최고에 언제나 진심으로 열심히하던 샤이니이기에 아직도 활동하는 것 같고 너무 좋은 노래를 많이 들려줘서 고맙고 항상 응원하고 사랑해 샤이니😊🫶🏻🩵
The way that Minho handled the situation of the child asking for Jonghyun is something that made my heart wreck so bad, I swear. I miss him so much.. 💔