Тёмный

Knocking on Putin’s back door: Is NATO really threatening Russia? | To the Point 

DW News
Подписаться 5 млн
Просмотров 611 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

12 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,7 тыс.   
@ferdinandtotski622
@ferdinandtotski622 2 года назад
Putin is #1 recruiter of NATO 👍
@ОнуфрийНечепуренко
NATO is its own recruiter: 11 new members in the last 17 years alone. And wants more. A lot more. To the very borders of China.
@Z1BABOUINOS
@Z1BABOUINOS 2 года назад
*IN RAYTHEON WE TRUST !* 💰💰💰 ...and *10% held by H. for the BIG GUY !* You know.... *THE THING!* 💰👴💤
@legitbeans9078
@legitbeans9078 2 года назад
I'm not sure that's what he planned 😂😂😂
@levelazn
@levelazn 2 года назад
Cuba missile crisis never happened right ?
@EatMyShortsAU
@EatMyShortsAU 2 года назад
Turkey: "Hold my kebab".😂 No one can join without Turkey saying Yes.
@1984Phalanx
@1984Phalanx 2 года назад
Putin said the "special military operation" would achieve "noble goals." Maybe the collapse of his government is what he was referring to.
@monmixer
@monmixer 2 года назад
I doubt that but one can only hope. I have been praying for him to go away at any means.
@deepakgh7063
@deepakgh7063 2 года назад
Just lies and lies illusion
@mrcactuar8515
@mrcactuar8515 2 года назад
Why? He is one of the few leaders confrnting the rotten hegemony of the US and their allies. World needs a change. World needs a new multipolar! Deal with it.
@AK-ns4kn
@AK-ns4kn 2 года назад
that indeed would be something good not only for RUssia but also for the rest of the World.
@superstone2763
@superstone2763 2 года назад
And the collapse of western when putin launch his nuke 😁😁🤣🤣
@joerogain5025
@joerogain5025 2 года назад
Welcome 🇸🇪Sweden & 🇫🇮Finland/NATO Awaits You!
@RonaldEmerald
@RonaldEmerald 2 года назад
Im starting to think ur a bot since u comment on every dw news video
@joerogain5025
@joerogain5025 2 года назад
Charafeddine Moi Cherie : Botski's never reply back brainiac. I don't just do DW. I do CNN/MSNBC/BBC/CBC/SKY NEWS/WION/Fox Faux News & a few others, thank you!
@chitsume8913
@chitsume8913 2 года назад
They will not be nato member because turkey and hungary will say no
@TeddyKrimsony
@TeddyKrimsony 2 года назад
CIA comment squad or is it the NSA?
@joerogain5025
@joerogain5025 2 года назад
Theo I Adore Krap : No CIA or NSA here just lil ole me, Joe ROGAIN. You, KGB/NKVD/FSO/FSB/GRU/LGBTQ or STASI perhaps?
@justmr9553
@justmr9553 2 года назад
Let's get on with helping Ukraine asap! No point wasting time with people dying every day
@DianeMerriam
@DianeMerriam 2 года назад
If Russia wants to end the war, then all they have to do is to leave Ukraine. If it wants to put an end to the dying, then leave. It's that simple. But as long as Putin's hordes keep killing people, then the Ukrainians will resist in self defense, as they have every right to do.
@randycastillo4530
@randycastillo4530 2 года назад
I wouldn't call Ukrainian military as brilliant rather credit them for their courage and acceptance of NATO and western military support.
@hyu7335
@hyu7335 2 года назад
When the losing invader start playing victim..
@wilsoncolton3125
@wilsoncolton3125 2 года назад
???
@dearmas9068
@dearmas9068 2 года назад
@@davidnoelfranks1124 shhhh
@peabase
@peabase 2 года назад
Wallowing in victimhood is second nature to Russia. In their mind, Napoleon's 210-year old foray into Moscow is proof positive that everyone's out to get them. People have been committed for less severe forms of paranoia.
@IbnBahtuta
@IbnBahtuta 2 года назад
I say we send turkey off the pitch to have an early shower. Then we can bring on our substitutes, Finland and Sweden. sorted
@robertwilkinson2232
@robertwilkinson2232 2 года назад
Putin and russia the best recruiters nato ever had Moldova and georgia next and Ukraine when the war is over
@AmericanPatriotsLoveTrump
@AmericanPatriotsLoveTrump 2 года назад
You do realize that the more countries on Russia's border join nato the higher the chance for WW3
@robertwilkinson2232
@robertwilkinson2232 2 года назад
Agreed but putin is so unstable he threatened nuclear war for so many reasons since this war started. If we did what he wanted we would give him the baltics Poland anything to prevent nuclear war . We have to call his bluff at somepoint.
@dragons_hook
@dragons_hook 2 года назад
Moldova can't join. It's in conflict within its own borders.
@mikexhotmail
@mikexhotmail 2 года назад
@@AmericanPatriotsLoveTrump They don't. This people cheering for their own demise. They think Russia will easily go down with out bringing the rest with her.
@AmericanPatriotsLoveTrump
@AmericanPatriotsLoveTrump 2 года назад
@@mikexhotmail Exactly what do they think Russia has 6000s nukes for
@connectedonline1060
@connectedonline1060 2 года назад
Gosh, it's crazy that the vast majority of Russia's neighbors want nothing to do with them. I can't imagine why that is
@petraravn5421
@petraravn5421 2 года назад
I'm guessing "Russophobia"?
@nobodyknows3180
@nobodyknows3180 2 года назад
@@petraravn5421 That is what it is. Not why it is.
@sam5tue577
@sam5tue577 2 года назад
@@petraravn5421 Russia always has to be the victim doesn’t it?
@EatMyShortsAU
@EatMyShortsAU 2 года назад
Not the western neighbors, eastern and southern yes. Remember Russia is huge.
@HelloChief117
@HelloChief117 2 года назад
As a Swede, I don't want to live next to the world's most whiny self-victimizing, regressive manchild dictator who I would gladly and without regret try to kill with my bare hands if I ever got the chance, because I am tired after decades of having Putin The Half-Monkey tell my country what it should do.
@omidpourhossein
@omidpourhossein 2 года назад
“The world is in more peril from those who tolerate evil or encourage evil than from those who actually commit it.” -Dr. Albert Einstein, March 30 1953
@tuff9486
@tuff9486 2 года назад
But is building bases and turning Russia sphere nations not also encouraging evil?
@jamiethomasbooth3300
@jamiethomasbooth3300 2 года назад
In retrospect.. Nato can be evil, too.
@RiDankulous
@RiDankulous 2 года назад
I feel in the US this war might be alien but we are as much a part of it with of consumption patterns. The military, although not active in the war, has been impacted by it and the aggressor. There's a lot can be done by individuals, companies and the government.
@YalokIy
@YalokIy 2 года назад
the evil here is the agressor. People that encourage the Russia's attack on Ukraine are more peril to the world peace than the Russian soldiers fighting the war
@TommyTCGT
@TommyTCGT 2 года назад
Artillery attacks for 8 years on Donbass and 13,000 civilians murdered didn't occur.. right.
@unggrabb
@unggrabb 2 года назад
"Coexistence with psychopathic dictators is not possible". Christopher Hitchins
@antimimoniakos
@antimimoniakos 2 года назад
"When you want to destroy and loot a country call it's leader psychopathic dictator". Me.
@gluteusmaximus1657
@gluteusmaximus1657 2 года назад
Psychopatic folks need to be in a asylum. In a care home!
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
If you thought with a critical mindset you'd understand rus must act to defend itself... nato is predominantly influenced by the EU who from their conception openly desires a one world gov with them at the helm thus a Serious security risk to every nation not just Rus... nato (eu) pathetic policies help lead to the rawanda gen and countless other atrocities while thinking they are doing good for ppl... so who is the psychopathic dictators as the three ppl here all want to control the world for their personal desires? Nato and it's supporters openly state they want to decide ukr fate not the ukr ppl
@unggrabb
@unggrabb 2 года назад
@@antimimoniakos no one wants anything to do with russia. All NATO countries made the choice to go west, not east. Because they knew what avaited them Shut russia out. Doors closed. Enjoy the cabbage soup
@antimimoniakos
@antimimoniakos 2 года назад
@@unggrabb I don't figure out why you answer to me.
@mandhojbudhamagar7234
@mandhojbudhamagar7234 2 года назад
We are not fools. Actions speaks louder than words. Who is a threat to whom is seen by their actions in past by their destructions done to others.
@Sr.ChilePepper
@Sr.ChilePepper 2 года назад
So direct and to the point. Glad you're not being vague. 🙄
@TMM-N
@TMM-N 2 года назад
Libya iraq and african nations
@moggpiano8043
@moggpiano8043 2 года назад
Try using your first language and let YT translate.
@gluteusmaximus1657
@gluteusmaximus1657 2 года назад
@@TMM-N Georgia, Afghanistan,Moldova, Ukraine, Kasachstan, Chechenya ??? Before them it was Hungary and Czechoslovakia. Want some more, Comrade?
@andreeabucur9067
@andreeabucur9067 2 года назад
@@gluteusmaximus1657 Romania also.
@camlorincz5073
@camlorincz5073 2 года назад
NATO Threatening Russia……?? Seriously! NATO is a defensive alliance, end of story. As we can clearly see, a country which is not a part of this alliance is at risk. Let’s do a story on, “ Is Russia a threat to sovereign nations which are not a part of the NATO Alliance “
@ОнуфрийНечепуренко
Russia has always threatened Spain, Portugal and especially Iceland. It is understandable why these countries want to defend themselves against Russia by joining an anti-Russian alliance.
@ganvch230
@ganvch230 2 года назад
NATO original Ideas is defensive alliance against USSR Russia.
@NinjaBehindTheScene
@NinjaBehindTheScene 2 года назад
@@Alanom2007 asians and africans understand nato is a defensive alliance i asked. My wife is chinese and her brother is high up in the government and i work with many africans. Only a fool would think otherwise.
@ОнуфрийНечепуренко
@@ganvch230 NATO bombed Yugoslavia, Iraq and Afghanistan to protect Europe from Russia. This is so cute.
@NinjaBehindTheScene
@NinjaBehindTheScene 2 года назад
@paper plane libya wasnt nato kid and kosvo was to stop a genocide in europe. Next.
@JJ-xi1iv
@JJ-xi1iv 2 года назад
I love how Putin is teaching the west about having double standards.
@Americal1970
@Americal1970 2 года назад
It's like he is the only one who has a brain. Emperor of the world. Attitude
@Jamie-Z
@Jamie-Z 2 года назад
@@Americal1970 It far too often seems that way.
@seth_sesu
@seth_sesu 2 года назад
Jessica is spot on as usual. A clear logical voice.
@edwardsianski725
@edwardsianski725 2 года назад
May God continue to bless Ukraine as it fights for a just peace.
@markbeames7852
@markbeames7852 2 года назад
"god" has nothing to do with anything.
@markbeames7852
@markbeames7852 2 года назад
@@bishopofsahs your god is a collegiate football fan fanboy? I rest my case.
@НатальяБыкова-у2с
@НатальяБыкова-у2с 2 года назад
Then Ukraine will definitely lose this battle! Мы русские! С нами Бог!
@markbeames7852
@markbeames7852 2 года назад
@@НатальяБыкова-у2с bit not the war. You're as ignorant of military logistics as Putin.
@avtarsingh4355
@avtarsingh4355 2 года назад
Ukraine need to negotiate now 🤣🤣🤣 NOW UKRAINE LEARN GOOD LESSION WESTERNS ARE BACKSTABBER NEVER BELIEVE ON USA USA did the same with Pakistan in 1971 indo pak war After seeing the soviet warships USA runs away 😂😂😂 People of Ukraine should learn the lession from now .just stay away from superpowers We already took the taste of colonialism Ukrainians should made their countries economically stable or independent
@doverivermedia3937
@doverivermedia3937 2 года назад
Excellent debate with high calibre professionals. First class job DW. 👏. 🇬🇧...🇺🇦
@hhhnhhy0078
@hhhnhhy0078 2 года назад
This is not a debate. They all have agreed on this issue before this show
@allnightlongg
@allnightlongg 2 года назад
@@hhhnhhy0078 it does not need no agreement. It’s just facts
@hhhnhhy0078
@hhhnhhy0078 2 года назад
@@allnightlongg Do you call telling facts as debate?
@hhhnhhy0078
@hhhnhhy0078 2 года назад
@@allnightlongg Is Germany an independent nation? This can be debatable.😀
@thomascolbert2687
@thomascolbert2687 2 года назад
@@hhhnhhy0078 Do they go to prison if they call it a war?
@KrazyJ52
@KrazyJ52 2 года назад
Excellent talk!
@legitbeans9078
@legitbeans9078 2 года назад
DW Dwelivering the real facts. As well as having well spoken and well informed guests most of the time. Quickly becoming my go to news outlet 👍
@Tadpoletofrogs
@Tadpoletofrogs 2 года назад
Not facts. One sided opinion. They think Russia is losing. They have no idea of Russian war tactics.
@andyzx9682
@andyzx9682 2 года назад
same here
@mikea3219
@mikea3219 2 года назад
@@andyzx9682 ì9i9ì9i⁹ii⁹8⁸ùì8887
@paulwally9007
@paulwally9007 2 года назад
The facts?!?! They don't make even the slightest attempt to see the situation from Russia's perspective.
@andyzx9682
@andyzx9682 2 года назад
@@paulwally9007 da , comrade
@judysmith8725
@judysmith8725 2 года назад
Big ups to Sweden and Finland
@publikjuli
@publikjuli 2 года назад
Oh yeah, they are spectacularly shooting in their own legs. 👏
@lanadebos8897
@lanadebos8897 2 года назад
I am watching this program every week. I like it thank you
@paulvandal4444
@paulvandal4444 2 года назад
They are not fighting for Europe or the EU or anyone but for their homeland and their lives. You would do the same or will do if faced with the same situation.
@scottyd3138
@scottyd3138 2 года назад
You're right but they are directly helping Europe, Moldova was next to be invaded for sure if ukraine didn't stop them and probably the Baltic states
@paulvandal4444
@paulvandal4444 2 года назад
@@scottyd3138 Mine was a reaction to the opening statement by the young woman sitting to left of the host speaker. But I fully recognize the benefit to the nations for which we should be thankful. There is some need and urgence that this war be won. Unfortunately that can not be achieved fighting defensively.
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
True but they also provoked this incident forcing rus to finally act defensively and preemptively against nato encroachment... ukr has a right to fight but so does rus... Also census reports show only half of ukr ppl claimed they would fight for their country... ukr ppl had months to leave conflict areas but many refused and were used as human shields in hopes enough die that the west gives mil aid... ukr is a mini rus who brought this conflict on themselves thus I don't know why ppl support it
@scottyd3138
@scottyd3138 2 года назад
@@jaybelle1909 they didn't provoke this , Russia invaded cuz the people are brainwashed and putin wants more land and power
@scottyd3138
@scottyd3138 2 года назад
@@paulvandal4444 ah makes sense
@nutzeeer
@nutzeeer 2 года назад
if putin doesnt want nato at its borders he shouldnt wage war in its direction
@ebrim5013
@ebrim5013 2 года назад
It really is that simple.
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
Rus gave up buffer nations in a peace agreement that nato would dissolve and not encroach any further but as expected nato not only refused but has been ever encroaching closer to Rus thus able to hold a knife to rus throat and saying do as I say or else... nato and ukr caused this conflict over decades of forcing Russia to finally act as it should as nato must be put in check
@dknight25
@dknight25 2 года назад
The forner came first though. lol
@andrewjenkinson7052
@andrewjenkinson7052 2 года назад
It is pronounced POO TIN as in a tin of poo.
@matthewwiemken7293
@matthewwiemken7293 2 года назад
@@dknight25 war? yes
@uknow1994
@uknow1994 2 года назад
Yeah Sweden and Finland. You are important and an asset to every one of us in freedom. I am more than sure NATO will welcome you with open arms. I know l will
@heidi-mariadegruchy7641
@heidi-mariadegruchy7641 2 года назад
Excellent and pertinent discussion. Thank you
@goatmealcookies7421
@goatmealcookies7421 2 года назад
The only threatening rhetoric has been on the russian side.
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
How so? Nato and ukr caused this conflict over decades of forcing Russia to finally act to defend its economy and security... a nato Ukr, fin, and swe is like holding a knife to rus throat and saying do as I say or else; so who is the the threatening party? Fact is there is no side to root for as all players are bad
@levelazn
@levelazn 2 года назад
So China will militarize Solomon Islands with its new security pact and everything is fine right ? Cuba missile crisis never happened. Us didn’t threaten to invade Solomon island 3 weeks ago
@nobodyknows3180
@nobodyknows3180 2 года назад
@@jaybelle1909 Please just stop that. You are using rapist mentality. You allow yourself to rape a woman because HER short skirt provokes you. Using that logic anyone could punch your face because your stupidity provokes them.
@kebabrullen121
@kebabrullen121 2 года назад
@@jaybelle1909 Yeah just like the knife being kept to rus throat when the baltic countries joined Nato almost 20 years ago. What a threat they have been. Simply kept them from getting bombed that's all. I don't agree with alot of things the US does but to blame this on the US is just ignorant
@norberto325
@norberto325 2 года назад
@@jaybelle1909 fully agree
@DownhillAllTheWay
@DownhillAllTheWay 2 года назад
Well done, Vlad! Not only has the length of your border with NATO almost doubled, but NATO is more united than ever before. At 9:03 in the video, it is stated that this huge mistake was predicted by Russian analysts - but of course, if any of them had told you that you were making a huge mistake, they would have wound up in a Siberian jail for many years. By making it impossible for any of your advisers to give you news that was contrary to what you wanted to hear, you made it so that you are unable to respond to what is happening on the battlefield - because most of it is contrary to what you want to hear. In other words, you made yourself incompetent. Or to put it another way, you walked straight into the dictator trap.
@rogerburn5132
@rogerburn5132 2 года назад
Turkey Is blocking the membership of Sweden and Finland. That is How United NATO is. 😀😀😀😀
@linmal2242
@linmal2242 2 года назад
Yes, all that macho effort and ra-ra nationalism just achieved a lot of casualties and waste, but also sanctions at home and exclusion from the wider world. Well done Vlad .
@dion6034
@dion6034 2 года назад
he shot himself in the foot for the second time lol
@TheBravehearted33
@TheBravehearted33 2 года назад
Nato is a defense alliance is a complete joke just ask libya about it.
@mavigogun
@mavigogun 2 года назад
@@dion6034 no- he ordered his general to shoot him in the foot, who then delegated the assignment.
@villagedesigninstitute4135
@villagedesigninstitute4135 2 года назад
from the West Coast of North America - I love hearing intelligent discussions by educated Europeans!!!
@FarmerDrew
@FarmerDrew 2 года назад
Did you know there are Russians that consider the west coast of North America all the way down to San Francisco to be a Russian property?
@dieselburner4461
@dieselburner4461 2 года назад
So much class and professionalism. Makes Washington look like a circus
@adayinforever
@adayinforever 2 года назад
I think it is really interesting to listen to people talking to each other who aren't original English speakers. Especially since they are from different languages but are all united by the English language.
@Charles_Bro-son
@Charles_Bro-son 2 года назад
Besides the rather agitated channels e.g. like Fox or CNN, do the US have any sort of more unemotional bigger media outlets? MSNBC maybe?
@fradiavolo9293
@fradiavolo9293 2 года назад
@@Charles_Bro-son MSNBC; unemotional??
@emekaezeme282
@emekaezeme282 2 года назад
You guys are incredible
@MarkBarrett
@MarkBarrett 2 года назад
Turkey needs to seriously decide which side it's on. The Turkish president looks desperate.
@achraftaqi2445
@achraftaqi2445 2 года назад
on it's on side, there are lots of countries outside of europe and america that didn't pick anyside. to be honest, we just don't care about the war at all.
@jakearmstrong335
@jakearmstrong335 2 года назад
Same with Hungary
@bunzeebear2973
@bunzeebear2973 2 года назад
by denying Sweden & Finland access to NATO, the Turkish president has made it known which side it is on...as it comes out with unverifiable claims of rogue forces within each of these countries.
@laurastortoni-hager1510
@laurastortoni-hager1510 2 года назад
TURKEY IS NOT ON EUROPE. I do not even understand why they are in NATO. Historically Turkey has been the enemy of Europe. Erdogan is a TYRANT. TURKEY SHOULD NOT EVEN BE IN NATO....LET ALONE MAKE DECISIONS FOR EUROPE. NATO SHOULD PUSH TURKEY OUT. OUT OUT OUT OF NATO.
@cyizarwanda5488
@cyizarwanda5488 2 года назад
Are these debates rehearsed? If all of you agree on points, why even have a panel? Why not just have the host tells us what he thinks? I think we as non-NATO and non-Russian we would like to hear both sides. Otherwise go and get a person who is against nato expansionism for us to hear their views. You guys are starting to think we are dumb.
@kingdavid6476
@kingdavid6476 2 года назад
Just as many dumbas comments here. Nato has been destructive to many nations of the world. They cross Russia red line. Europe with its aging population cannot defeat Russia on the battlefield. Feel sorry for the ordinary Ukrainians who are dying bcos of a comedian president. America don't even have baby formulas, while they gave Ukraine 40 billion.
@peterpriadka8952
@peterpriadka8952 2 года назад
"This conflict is all about RUSSIA doesnt want Ukraine to be independent state witch is moving west" Lets go this is WHAT IS THIS WAR ALL ABOUT from PUTINS perspective.
@scepticalwalker3984
@scepticalwalker3984 2 года назад
Correct!
@M_Jono
@M_Jono 2 года назад
You watch CNN too much
@JamesSmith-ix5jd
@JamesSmith-ix5jd 2 года назад
Independent? If Russia would to appoint judges and parliament members in Mexico, and push for military cooperation against the US, would it still be considered independent?
@areis7415
@areis7415 2 года назад
Considering russia means "not being able to do whatever they want" by "threatened", then yes. As for "threatened" as in "attacking them militarily", I don't really see why that would happen. NATO, or anyone for that matter, never attacked russia during the last decades and I don't think the way Europe dealt with russia for the last 20 or 30 years signals anyone was even thinking about attacking russia. But that's just my non-specialized opinion of course.
@leoanime3002
@leoanime3002 2 года назад
Lol
@totoshaebosha7983
@totoshaebosha7983 2 года назад
"20 or 30 years" 200 or 300 years!!!! "non-specialized opinion of course." it can be seen
@liquidationofneonancys3712
@liquidationofneonancys3712 2 года назад
Wow. You really need to stop watching the news 🤣
@areis7415
@areis7415 2 года назад
@@liquidationofneonancys3712 Which ones? Please enlighten me. Would love to hear from you what news I watch.
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
You don't know how nato operates... a nato ukr, fin, and swe is like holding a knife to rus throat and saying do as I say or else; nato could decapitate Rus any moment it wants for any reason; decapitation vital life supply lines is an act of war but with nato (EU) pathetic policies they would see rus as the instigator... Rus gave up buffer nations in a peace agreement that nato would dissolve and not encroach any further but as expected nato not only refused but has been ever encroaching closer to Rus and able to be at its throat... it's like Cuban missile crisis along with subs and ships off your coast ready at a moments notice to cut you off and destroying your nation
@haplozetetic9519
@haplozetetic9519 2 года назад
I may be wrong, but I thought a single member could veto a decision to allow a country to join NATO.
@puellamservumaddominum6180
@puellamservumaddominum6180 2 года назад
Yes it can. Germany and France were the big blocks against Ukraine joining . Ukraine requested membership in 2008.
@monmixer
@monmixer 2 года назад
F Putin, some needs to take him out. Great orgram, thank you for your insight. It's wise at minimum. We can only pray for piece.
@joerogain5025
@joerogain5025 2 года назад
Finland & Sweden will be welcome additions to NATO/OTAN seeing how they are a sophisticated country & people!
@dhank2242
@dhank2242 2 года назад
I don't look forward the increased threat this poses to existing NATO countries from Russia, but I am happy to have the Swedes and Fins in our alliance. Finland especially is an impressive country that punches FAR above its weight.
@hitendram
@hitendram 2 года назад
Lol, what is murica doing in NATO with all the European countries then? Serious answers only. I treat murica a elephant on a tree.
@HuplesCat
@HuplesCat 2 года назад
Whiter than Turkey you mean? Racist
@TheRangerBob
@TheRangerBob 2 года назад
Appreciate the commentary by all three panelists. Ending this war is paramount. The events that will follow wars end will be very interesting.
@wom_Bat
@wom_Bat 2 года назад
Ukraine absolutely needs a marshal type plan. Rebuild them like the west did with Japan and west Germany. No intrest payments, no charge, just get it done for the sake of stability and ukranians will likely appreciate and align closer to the west.
@pdoylemi
@pdoylemi 2 года назад
@@wom_Bat Agreed. Also one of Putin's nightmares is for his people who have close ties with Ukraine to see a prosperous, free, democratic Ukraine right on their border.
@rodtukker1904
@rodtukker1904 2 года назад
@@wom_Bat EU is not even funding enough now. Rebuilding is just a dream. US gave 56 billion USD while EU gave just 7 billion Euro in Loan. This is definitely not helping especially not much real help from Germany in spite of words and promises.
@liquidationofneonancys3712
@liquidationofneonancys3712 2 года назад
If ending the war is paramount why the need to expand nato and send $40bn to Ukraine?
@liquidationofneonancys3712
@liquidationofneonancys3712 2 года назад
@@wom_Bat you live in a fantasy world. The EU have fast tracked €9bn in LOANS to Ukraine this week because they are bankrupt and can't pay the soldiers or Pensions.
@adamp834
@adamp834 2 года назад
Its not threatening.its being safe.
@---vo7gc
@---vo7gc 2 года назад
Invading and toppling russia yo implement a puppet regime would also be "safe" that's how they see it who can guarantee nato won't it is nearing Russia’s doorstep
@TommyTCGT
@TommyTCGT 2 года назад
What no nato attack in Serbia, Libya, etc.. All friendly defense exercises?
@aliasgus
@aliasgus 2 года назад
Are you pro russian? Are you accepting the mass murder of innocent people in Ukraine right now?
@Thor.Jorgensen
@Thor.Jorgensen 2 года назад
​@@TommyTCGT Russia also attacked in Syria, Georgia, and Libya, not to mention Ukraine. Friendly defense exercise? The intervention against Serbia was also internationally recognized and permitted by the United Nations after the Srebrenica massacre. Are you not aware of the trials that took place at the International Criminal Court? Or the war criminal who drank poison in court after admitting his guilt? Even Russia and China attended that trial, recognizing the crimes committed in Bosnia.
@JohnDoesSports
@JohnDoesSports 2 года назад
@@Thor.Jorgensen I hope we see more RuZZian generals and other members of the RuZZian military in the Hauge soon. Rapists and murderers have no place in the modern world.
@temesgen754
@temesgen754 2 года назад
What's the point having 3 people with the same point of view
@harpy83
@harpy83 2 года назад
"NATO is a defensive alliance period". This shows the amount of depth in this discussion
@aluphelatontsi5229
@aluphelatontsi5229 2 года назад
They are pushing one narrative lmao we know Nato and the US do in the middle east. 😂
@WhatHappenedIn-vt3vq
@WhatHappenedIn-vt3vq 2 года назад
It does, but it isn't our fault debating about what we did 20 years ago while Putin followed up with Chechnya is a hottopic for Russia to try rally for WW3. When diplomatics are outright refused, you don't make concessions
@dreamwithinadreamfilms
@dreamwithinadreamfilms 2 года назад
I stopped listening at that mark.
@luceliacustodio9179
@luceliacustodio9179 2 года назад
I feel that deep inside she knows she's lying
@grottenolm8514
@grottenolm8514 2 года назад
@@dreamwithinadreamfilms Can you explain your comment? Were there times NATO was invading a country? I want to understand.
@alexanderhoye
@alexanderhoye 2 года назад
The main reason that Russia doesn’t like NATO is because of Yugoslavia in the late 90’s. Russian-backed Serbs were committing full-scale genocide against Albanians, and NATO stepped in to stop the atrocities. Russia’s “feelings” were hurt as a result.
@m.i.9832
@m.i.9832 2 года назад
Russia stepped to stop genocide againt russians and you can only feel hurt. Sorry.
@m.i.9832
@m.i.9832 2 года назад
Russia is going to bring full democracy to Ukraine with bomb just like nato stepped in the same russia do. Uraaaa
@abrahamhenderson3986
@abrahamhenderson3986 2 года назад
THIS BARBARIC IN HUMAN ACT MUST BE STOPPED AND THIS TIRANT MUST BE HEARD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CRIMES COMMITTED!
@НатальяБыкова-у2с
@НатальяБыкова-у2с 2 года назад
Oh, yes! and that tyrant is Zelensky!
@darlillama590
@darlillama590 2 года назад
@@НатальяБыкова-у2с You have a very loose definition of tyrant.
@nikolaichap8245
@nikolaichap8245 2 года назад
Who exactly? Bin Salman? Bolsonaro? Trudeau? Bennett? Erdogan? Xi? Macron?
@darlillama590
@darlillama590 2 года назад
@@nikolaichap8245 I believe he was referring to the dictator who's armed forces are committing ethnic cleansing and genocide in Ukraine.
@nerdnec
@nerdnec 2 года назад
@@monkpkey cry bot
@quocphu01
@quocphu01 2 года назад
Nato is a DEFENSIVE ORGANISATION, THE CHARTER SAYS THAT, if russia attack their member they will bite back, but they won't start or initiate any war, that is why it is so attractive to many free nations
@focast1825
@focast1825 2 года назад
NATO operations in Kosovo, Libya, Afghanistan, and Somalia were not defensive. They have been violating the charter 30 years.
@rolfsautter4186
@rolfsautter4186 2 года назад
On paper . NATO countrys as USA , UK, France and Turkye are the most agressiv countrys in the world.
@Luka-zb3qj
@Luka-zb3qj 2 года назад
@@rolfsautter4186 the dirtiest corrupt systems as well you can't imagine how wicked they really are
@rolfsautter4186
@rolfsautter4186 2 года назад
@@MatthewEGolden Guess you are joking
@mistermaniac3517
@mistermaniac3517 2 года назад
Great format. Nice discussion. Thank you.
@pppddd2935
@pppddd2935 2 года назад
What a bullsl$%&/ UKrainia is not fighting for Europe UKrainia is fighting for themselves. I am from Europe and I am not afraid of Russia at all.
@chadmcmullen4064
@chadmcmullen4064 2 года назад
NATO has certainly threatened Russia's opportunities to invade its neighbors, yes...that much is clear. Holding back Russia's clenched-fist does not make NATO the aggressor.
@АртемМельников-с9п
Югославия, Ливия, Афганистан Сирия ,Ирак это страны НАТО бомбили из за обороны? Явно агрессия со стороны НАТО
@MikeJones-xw3te
@MikeJones-xw3te 2 года назад
Allow Sweden and Finland to join NATO, it will continue to ensure peace. I faced the Warsaw Pact forces during the Cold War, with the outcome was made clear to us. Whilst stationed in West Berlin, we had allied forces day, with the UK, US and French displaying our units along 16Juni Strasse. We had the pleasure of having physical interaction with the Russians,. Lots of pushing and shoving.👍😁
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
How about putting yourself in rus shoes... a nato ukr, fin, and swe is like holding a knife to rus throat and saying do as I say or else. Rus gave up the buffer nations in a peace agreement that nato would dissolve and not encroach any further but as expected nato not only refused but has been ever encroaching closer to Rus thus Rus Must act to defend itself... The only member in nato that honors its agreements is the US why should the US aid two more leaches? Nato is a weak and fragile alliance and the US has been wanting out for a while now and most like will in a few years...
@JamesSmith-ix5jd
@JamesSmith-ix5jd 2 года назад
Warsaw pact was created as an answer to NATO, not the other way around. When Warsaw pact disintegrated NATO sayed and then grew rapidly. If NATO is security organization why its expansion makes all of us less secure in Europe?, and now there is a full scale war in Europe over this issue. If NATO is a defensive alliance why it destroyed a dozen of (harmless to itself) nations in recent decades? Why NATO existed when there were no threats, so logically it means that the purpose of its existence was not to deal with a threat, but to push away Russia and establish American sphere of influence over Europe.
@maxwellhiggs
@maxwellhiggs 2 года назад
I for one do not want to see anyone knocking on Putin's back door.
@boelensds
@boelensds 2 года назад
Why do you not want Chinese marching into russia? Rf has already good communist. And some one needs to defend the name of socialism and communism against criminalism.
@thewhat249
@thewhat249 2 года назад
lol that look at 1:09 😂😂what a goof
@ovidijusvoronkovas1150
@ovidijusvoronkovas1150 2 года назад
Jessica Berlin is amazing. She is always on point and express the knowledge on a matter.
@pectenmaximus231
@pectenmaximus231 2 года назад
“Knockung” is such a German typo 🙂
@SomeOneOneOne
@SomeOneOneOne 2 года назад
Why do you think its a german typo? The U is right besides the I on keyboard you know?
@nobodyknows3180
@nobodyknows3180 2 года назад
@@SomeOneOneOne he was joking because 'ung' is a common suffix in German, whereas 'ing' is not so much.
@ems7623
@ems7623 2 года назад
@@SomeOneOneOne oh come on, have a sense of humor please. I realize we're on a German news channel, but it is allowed to laugh. "-ung" is a common German word ending.
@geoffreybranstetter4466
@geoffreybranstetter4466 2 года назад
When discussing the incompetence of the Russian army it should be considered who they are fighting and their lack of desire to do so.
@jeremyhodge6216
@jeremyhodge6216 2 года назад
I certainly agree with you on this. They know this is Putin's war not theirs 🤔
@ericp1139
@ericp1139 2 года назад
So, Mariupol fell to incompetence?
@kevonlipscomb8732
@kevonlipscomb8732 2 года назад
@@ericp1139 Only for a little while,' That is, as the 🇷🇺 military is exterminated by their own captured & abandoned weapons, by the Ukrainian forces, As the sanctions take affect, preventing Putin to continue to fund his War Machine! Then Ukraine we'll have every inch of their territory from defeated 🇷🇺
@ericp1139
@ericp1139 2 года назад
@@kevonlipscomb8732 funny, I can see Russians toting captured Western weapons too. And Russia controls the gas and food, which tend to benefit in an economic war of attrition.
@wesleyallen1173
@wesleyallen1173 2 года назад
@@ericp1139 Look up the definition of Pyrrhic victory. That is what Mariupol is.
@gracie4533
@gracie4533 2 года назад
If the heavy weapons and ammunitions keep flowing Ukraine will quickly reach its goal to victory soon.
@nobodyknows3180
@nobodyknows3180 2 года назад
@BuzzinSmaug68 The U.S. Senate overwhelmingly passed the $40Bn aid package a few hours ago!
@EatMyShortsAU
@EatMyShortsAU 2 года назад
I don't know man. It it seem pretty much in the balance now. Russia has secured Mariupol and is making gains in Donbass but Ukraine is also making gains around Kharkiv. Only time will tell who will win. $40B in extra US aid is going to be help Ukraine's ability to keep fighting.
@quantummotion
@quantummotion 2 года назад
The longer the war goes on, the heavier the weapon systems will be delivered. We went from "what do we do" to send some MANPADS, to send tanks and heavy artillery, to US pres authorized to send UKR from a huge laundry list via Lend/Lease in 3 months. As NATO takes possession of F35s, where do you think all the F16s and F18s are going to end up? UKR will become a NATO compatible country simply by the weapons systems and training they are receiving. Putin has singlehandedly reinvigorated NATO, caused neutral/nonaligned countries to apply for membership, and revealed the kind and quality of military that sits to the East of NATO.
@mfh6982
@mfh6982 2 года назад
Knock, knock it's Ronald McDonald ready or not we're coming in.
@asan1050
@asan1050 2 года назад
thank you
@forgottenmusic1
@forgottenmusic1 2 года назад
There is nearly no Russian troops between the current NATO border and St. Petersburg, as they have been moved to fertilize Ukrainian ground. That should give an answer, if Russia actually feels threatened.
@singlewhitefemale1707
@singlewhitefemale1707 2 года назад
NATO is NOT a threat to anyone that RESPECTS it's neighbor. This is the 3rd war Russia has started. Aggression at it's finest. It's why NATO was formed. NATO defends, it doesn't attack. Finland and Sweden are smart to join. They could be next on Putin's list.
@aliasgus
@aliasgus 2 года назад
NATO is a defence alliance. They would never attack Russian ground, only defend our own borders.
@mrcactuar8515
@mrcactuar8515 2 года назад
Yes, they are fertilinzg ukranian ground with the defeated ukronazis. They control the east and south of the country right now
@toby9999
@toby9999 2 года назад
What answer?
@conorwhite2066
@conorwhite2066 2 года назад
Any country is threatened when a foreign army moves close to their border Remember the Cuban missile crisis If China signed an agreement with Canada and put Chinese soldiers on the US border, think the US would not do something about it Maybe Putin has it in his heart to revive the Russian empire but Russia is a declining power and Putin knows this
@JoeyBlogs007
@JoeyBlogs007 2 года назад
If Russia attacked Finland and or Sweden, you can almost be sure that they would end up with missiles lobbed back into their own back yard. They know that and that's the deterrent of defensive strength. These two countries would be supported by NATO 100%.
@joaoMTcoelho
@joaoMTcoelho 2 года назад
You are living in a bubble. Apparently you think nuclear war is a joke.
@JoeyBlogs007
@JoeyBlogs007 2 года назад
@@joaoMTcoelho LOL. You would prefer to just sit back and let them invade and reek total destruction, like they have in Ukraine ?. Everyone will fight back, otherwise they will steamroll over you. That's what totalitarian communist regimes do. Perhaps you are one of them? A spy ?
@andyyygane4713
@andyyygane4713 2 года назад
Back in the 1990s, whenever I suggested to Germans and other Central Europeans (Czechs, Poles and Hungarians) that EU expansion should include Russia, their reaction was negative to say the least. For this reason, I don't think Russians are solely to blame for their 'isolation' or 'marginalization' in Europe. In a sense, post-Soviet Russia has been denied a roadmap to true integration in Europe. And for that we, as Europeans, are all to blame. This is not to condone Russia's current actions in Ukraine, but there will never be a lasting solution until what is now the EU learns to live (co-exist) with Russia for mutual benefit. I see too many zero-summers in the DW studios and in general in the Western media and among the political elite in Brussels.
@MartinSerdar
@MartinSerdar 2 года назад
Putin reached out several times, even advertised for good cooperation in German language in German parliament. The problem is not Russia, it's the Western arrogance and supremacism! And I say it as a German... I see the general people's mentality and I exactly know this is it! Few even know what real justice and equality means, all are egoistic in the West.
@majedalkhoury1855
@majedalkhoury1855 2 года назад
that is because in America if there is no enemy to wary about , then the arms dealers and manufactures will go out of business, next on the list to scare people with is china. what a shame that this world is driven by the greed of bad people.
@dutchman7623
@dutchman7623 2 года назад
Nonsense! There was trade with Russia, there was cultural exchange, there was a lot of tourism from and to Russia. In spite of US warnings, the EU even became energy dependent on Russia. And Russia became rich because of this. But instead of using this wealth for its people, it disappeared in the pockets of Putin's friends. Disengaged from reality the Russian top has, fully voluntary, decided to start a war and put Russia in isolation. And the Russian people will suffer once more, seems they never learn!
@DianeMerriam
@DianeMerriam 2 года назад
The vast majority of Russia is in Asia.
@andyyygane4713
@andyyygane4713 2 года назад
@@DianeMerriam 75 percent of Russia's population live in Europe.
@gloriabort8422
@gloriabort8422 2 года назад
Very true! I noticed many older Germans , from age 55 or 60 do not speak English and listen only to German news. That is definitely not enough . This interview should be interpreted also in German and must be shown on Germany’s public TV! This panel SHOULD go on Germany‘s public TV .
@MikeVeracity
@MikeVeracity 2 года назад
Europe bans Russian media! Why?
@andrewkift6746
@andrewkift6746 2 года назад
The UK trained the Ukranian army from 2014 and we armed them from the beginning out of conviction. Germany waited to see how the wind was blowing first. Poor indeed.
@scottyd3138
@scottyd3138 2 года назад
UK has been smart and brave throughout all this. Blessings from Canada!
@danielwilson3671
@danielwilson3671 2 года назад
Agreed!
@trishawilson1436
@trishawilson1436 2 года назад
Agreed! 🇬🇧
@feeedom
@feeedom 2 года назад
UK also support killing civilian in afghan, iraq,ibya, syria and palestine....
@cuculan1978
@cuculan1978 2 года назад
@@scottyd3138 London is a playground for the Oligarchs and Putin, Borris Johson is number one fan ! Dont believe me go look at Led by Donkeys reports.
@AbhayKumar-bf2ed
@AbhayKumar-bf2ed 2 года назад
From where you bring these experts having prejudice against russia.. No neutral view only myopic view.
@ebrim5013
@ebrim5013 2 года назад
I dunno, I’d say having a prejudice against murderers is pretty warranted. If Russia wants a different international reputation, it needs to change its behavior. Because all its doing now is confirming everyone’s worst fears.
@realnapster1522
@realnapster1522 2 года назад
@@ebrim5013 you think NATO has a good reputation? They are colonizers.
@DianeMerriam
@DianeMerriam 2 года назад
Everyone I've heard from the Russian simply parrots the same words as they hear on the news, from the random person on the street to the officials of the government. Word for word, all the same. You hear it once, you just hear the exact same, over and over. And what they are saying is BS.
@paulgibbon5991
@paulgibbon5991 2 года назад
Reality has an anti-Russian bias, tis true.
@julianrdwinter
@julianrdwinter 2 года назад
Absolutely agree with the three panellists, Russia must be decisively and rapidly beaten in Ukraine, not only for the sake of the Ukrainian people but to emphasise and reinforce NATO's military deterrence of Russian aggression. This position is almost universal among people I talk to here in London, UK. Despite Brexit, the feeling here is that if Europe can act effectively together on security we are all much safer than if we each acted independently. I think this is probably now a commonplace amongst all Europeans. The idea of "The West" and what that stands for has become, to some extent, more important to us than the idea of the nation state.
2 года назад
This is a very good discussion. The journalist and the panel altogether.
@grahamsawyer831
@grahamsawyer831 2 года назад
unbelievably simplistic. how anyone can say that Russia could not possibly see NATO's expansion as a threat is beyond me. either deliberately misleading or terminally ignorant.
@veenam.2168
@veenam.2168 2 года назад
Knockung great!
@fooo2241
@fooo2241 2 года назад
You're f*ckung right it is!
@ruhicompaniya3422
@ruhicompaniya3422 2 года назад
Very brilliant discourse 👍
@cronosx6174
@cronosx6174 2 года назад
Smart move by Sweden and Finland wanting to be part of NATO.
@patrickbonterre3267
@patrickbonterre3267 2 года назад
Yes this war has to stopped.
@silasdelobo4385
@silasdelobo4385 2 года назад
Alarming the lack of objectivity of this people...
@pepsee0
@pepsee0 2 года назад
The world has no longer a place for dictators as it shows that the death and destruction caused by one single man are beyond comprehension, Period!
@daniell1483
@daniell1483 2 года назад
"We are moving at the speed of war." Wise words. The bane of every army across time is speed. Armies can only move so fast and no amount of willpower can change that element.
@howmathematicianscreatemat9226
@howmathematicianscreatemat9226 2 года назад
The thing most “leaders” in power don’t seem to understand is that it isn’t if nato threatens Russia or not which is relevant… the relevant question is if Putin feels threatened by nato and if, then why ? Why is this much more important ? Because the other leader could have hallucinations or lost trust from lies like Iraq weapons of mass destructions…
@EnzoBonelli56
@EnzoBonelli56 2 года назад
Even if Nato is a defense alliance Putin sees it as a ”threat to Russian integrity”
@charlesscott4722
@charlesscott4722 2 года назад
Or Libya situation just 8 years later after Gadhafi agreed to cancel his weapon of mass destruction program
@christopherdaffron8115
@christopherdaffron8115 2 года назад
Well NATO was formed in the first place to counter the Soviet Union which gave way to the Russian Federation. So, it would not be unreasonable for Russia to view NATO as an adversary even though NATO has not been the aggressor.
@knocksensor3203
@knocksensor3203 2 года назад
@@christopherdaffron8115 NATO was born out of paranoia..
@superstone2763
@superstone2763 2 года назад
@@christopherdaffron8115 Nato not agresor, are u delusional?? Ask iraq, syria, libia, Afganistan then.. Typical hypocrite western and murican🤪🤪😁😁
@alchapman4621
@alchapman4621 2 года назад
Yes!!!
@chrisburdza6056
@chrisburdza6056 2 года назад
I think it was the first time I heard on major media "Ukrainian victory " danke
@goatmealcookies7421
@goatmealcookies7421 2 года назад
I worry about the instability of the world food situation with Ukraine imports and crops eliminated ... and the crops are going to be restricted for several years, as is fertilizer. How many of the worlds children are going to die because of putins ego? What's happening to Ukraine is reprehensible, but the effects are far more widespread.
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
Nato and Ukraine caused this conflict forcing Russia to act not the other way around... rus gave up buffer nations in a peace agreement that nato would dissolve and not encroach any further but as expected nato not only refused but has been ever encroaching closer to Rus able to put a knife to rus throat and saying do as I say or else... this war could've been prevented and could've been stopped at any point if nato said we are going to encroach any further... ukr is a mini rus, it's corrupt, not free, also commits crimes sides from using its ppl as human shields in hopes enough die that the west gives mil aid... The excessive amount of money wasted supporting the corrupt gov of ukr could've been used to help nation produce their own food... fact is nobody care as they just see rus as the bad guy so they want this war to drag on inspite of how many ukr lives are lost in the process
@EatMyShortsAU
@EatMyShortsAU 2 года назад
You are correct it looks like high food, fuel and fertilizer is leading to high inflation and is making life very difficult for poorer people.
@hexusmexus6971
@hexusmexus6971 2 года назад
No your wrong Ukraine has nothing to do with the food supply of the world the problem is inflation is caused by governments being greedy and people making money from this situation for example gas companies have made over a 174billion pounds extra profit who owns these companies where does the money go ? Food companies alone made so much more I’ll tell you a little secret you might not know this but 1 company in the world could solve world hunger and still have 90% of their money left. GREED IS THE ISSUE do you think America could cough up 40 billion for Ukraine for free no it’s so they can test new weapons and learn by the war Britain borrowed 400 billion because of the pandemic who started it who makes a profit.lots of questions and no real answers.
@peterstringa3350
@peterstringa3350 2 года назад
I do not agree with the headline of this vid. NATO is not knocking at the door. Putin asked NATO to come at its frontdoor.
@youtubewatcher2
@youtubewatcher2 2 года назад
But Putin is the bloodsucking vampire. I always heard it works the other way around.
@feeedom
@feeedom 2 года назад
The fact is, nato kill civilian in afghan, libya, iraq and syria, but no sanction, europe is quiet. Europe = nato or erope under controled by US. We concluded that you can kill everythink if you stand wit NATO....
@kfhroe8262
@kfhroe8262 2 года назад
Putin asked to enter NATO.
@peterstringa3350
@peterstringa3350 2 года назад
@@kfhroe8262 And you know why? To neutralize Ukraine, Finland, Sweden, Georgia and Austria. So Putin could say those countries were a threat to Russia and then NATO had to get involved. That is not how NATO works. It is a defensive organisation; not an agressor like Russia. And next to that it was not even nessicery for Russia as head of the Military alliance of CSTO.
@peterstringa3350
@peterstringa3350 2 года назад
@@feeedom You should get your knowlegde more up to date. Then you would not write this. I am not, for the 50th time explain to a pro Russian what really was going on and what Russia did in several of those countries. All pro Russian commentators have all the same statements. Not a single one is one inch different. That gives me the idea that all of them are indoctrinated with all the same State TV crazy information which for 90 % or more is not complete, the truth or not twisted.
@rleb2007
@rleb2007 2 года назад
Knocking on Putin’s back door: Is NATO really threatening Russia? | To the Point Sweden and Finland both say they want to abandon decades of neutrality to join the NATO military alliance. The decision comes at a crucial moment in the war in Ukraine. Images of Ukrainian fighters, many horribly wounded, being evacuated from the Azov steel works in Mariupol have gone around the world. In view of Russia’s brutal onslaught on that
@jaybelle1909
@jaybelle1909 2 года назад
This conflict was started by nato expansion thus a serious economy and security risk to Rus as it's like holding a knife to rus throat and saying do as I say or else... funny how everyone condemns rus but not nato when rus gave up buffer nations in a peace agreement that nato would dissolve and not encroach any further but as expected nato not only refused but has been ever encroaching closer to Russia thus forcing its hand... ukr is like a mini rus, it's corrupt, not free, also commits crimes sides from the obvious using its ppl as human shields in effort to gain mil aid... fin and swe actions only solidifies rus justifications for invading
@levelazn
@levelazn 2 года назад
You forget that Cuban missile crisis was about exactly this type of military alliance in South America
@EatMyShortsAU
@EatMyShortsAU 2 года назад
It probably is not but russia could feel very threatened. That is often how large wars often starts one country is afraid of another and feels that it needs to attack.
@margaretcaine4219
@margaretcaine4219 2 года назад
Have a look at videos of Russian speakers being attacked by Azov thugs (Odessa massacre and Mariupol massacre) in 2014. Watch Graham Phillip's videos and Patrick Lancaster's are enlightening re the behaviour of the other side.
@rabbi120348
@rabbi120348 2 года назад
Knock, knock, knockin' on Putin's door... With apologies to Bob Dylan
@shelleystodghill4016
@shelleystodghill4016 2 года назад
Putin said NATO is not a threat. NATO has never bothered Russia.
@joycekoch5746
@joycekoch5746 2 года назад
When you want friends and don't want to be jumped first learn to smile and stop hitting people.
@A3Kr0n
@A3Kr0n 2 года назад
Tell that to Biden.
@rralves54
@rralves54 2 года назад
Excellent debate. Congratulations.
@cebombatha4596
@cebombatha4596 2 года назад
This is not a debate, just people having a conversation with a topic they all agree too.
@Tadpoletofrogs
@Tadpoletofrogs 2 года назад
@@cebombatha4596 Exactly. And they seem to have no concept of geopolitics. All emotional rhetoric. No understanding of the 2014 US coup. The Minsk agreements. The 8 year war in Donbass. The Monroe Doctrine. And the Americans openly saying they want to attack Russia. This is a US proxy war.
@TommyTCGT
@TommyTCGT 2 года назад
@@cebombatha4596 Agree on but know nothing about or dare not comment otherwise.
@Heddanofarsan
@Heddanofarsan 2 года назад
It is a simplification Sweden has been completely free of war since Napoleon. During the cold war 600 Swedish pilots died during very dangerous drills, protection and reconnoicance missiond (ie. flying only a few meters above the sea). Even very few Swedes knows this.
@RiDankulous
@RiDankulous 2 года назад
That's sad lives were lost by pilots. They kept the peace, doing their duty and we don't have anuclear scarred world because of their heroism!
@michalrosinski5251
@michalrosinski5251 2 года назад
and sweds invading poland ?
@WinterXR7
@WinterXR7 2 года назад
@@RiDankulous you are aware 600 Swedish pilots dying did not stop the course of the cold war... it could have been 10,000 and it wouldnt have made a difference. The crash of oil prices in the 1980s led to stagnant growth in the USSR and the war in Afghanistan became costly and unpopular. Those were the events that contributed to the collapse of the USSR not 600 Swedish pilots
@napoleonbonaparte1260
@napoleonbonaparte1260 2 года назад
You mention my name niggah?
@ben7510
@ben7510 2 года назад
There are decades where weeks happen, and there are weeks where decades happen. End of quote!
@willblackett4709
@willblackett4709 2 года назад
Jessica has a strong point.... Push Russia out !!! asap
@yurigansmith
@yurigansmith 2 года назад
6:51 That was one weird moment.
@AdsaAdad
@AdsaAdad 2 года назад
Start questioning why a country feels threatened by a defensive alliance
@MikeAG333
@MikeAG333 2 года назад
It doesn't. This is just a land-grab. Russia's leaders feel threatened by democracy, and the Nato thing is just a lame excuse.
@antenovtupolev7211
@antenovtupolev7211 2 года назад
Defence alliance?
@ury0005
@ury0005 2 года назад
When NATO defended it's member last time?
@realnapster1522
@realnapster1522 2 года назад
NATO is not a defensive alliance. It has nukes and offensive weapons.
@MikeAG333
@MikeAG333 2 года назад
@@realnapster1522 Again, you're proving that idiocy is alive and well on the internet. No, Nato does not have nuclear weapons. Two Nato members have nuclear weapons. They are not available to the alliance.
@jampasurprenant1794
@jampasurprenant1794 2 года назад
I am very happy and proud of Finland and Sweden for joined the NATO airlines Good luck to both of you Finland and Sweden. I am older now but would Love to visit both of the counties in the future.
@hypnokitten6450
@hypnokitten6450 2 года назад
Ok, serious topic, but whoever wrote the subject line... Well done, very well done. I'm still snickering
@Klaus0Steiner
@Klaus0Steiner 2 года назад
Agreed 100%... Maximum Support for Ukraine to beat out Russian forces out of Ukraine in 2022!
@PRIMETIMETRAPPING
@PRIMETIMETRAPPING 2 года назад
Just like Russia wasn't threatening the US when they wanted to put missiles in Cuba 🤷‍♂️
@ebrim5013
@ebrim5013 2 года назад
When NATO deploys missiles to Finland, we can have this discussion. Recently we’ve only seen Russia threatening to forward deploy missiles by changing the Belorussian constitution.
@DianeMerriam
@DianeMerriam 2 года назад
*Nuclear* missles. And not just "wanted" to put them there, but *did* put them there. No problem with all the other missiles and weapons that the USSR had all around the world. And this was in the days before ICBMs. Cuba is only 90 miles from the US. NATO doesn't have nukes. No NATO country is required to take nukes from those countries that do. Few even want them, so they don't get them. Finland and Sweden have already said they don't want them and so they won't have them.
@PRIMETIMETRAPPING
@PRIMETIMETRAPPING 2 года назад
@@DianeMerriam So are we gonna pretend like Turkey wasn't hosting nukes for the US prior to the Russians putting them in Cuba 🙄
@paulgibbon5991
@paulgibbon5991 2 года назад
NATO already bordered Russia. Botski reported.
@DianeMerriam
@DianeMerriam 2 года назад
@paper plane Kennedy even tried to get the missiles taken out of Turkey, but Turkey itself wanted them left there. He used the Cuban crisis to do what he wanted on them. Turkey wants nukes there again now.
@tuculanu12
@tuculanu12 2 года назад
Knockung
@Food4thought2023
@Food4thought2023 2 года назад
Wouldn't it be interesting if they included someone with an alternative viewpoint? It's pointless just having a bunch of people all sharing the same view. What's there to discuss then? Before anyone decides this is support for Putin - it's not. We need to show them why their view is wrong, rather than just shouting them down or suppression of their views.
@swapnasaritparida
@swapnasaritparida 2 года назад
Not necessarily, they are saying Russia is loosing the battle can’t take on any other country is that true. A day back with all the support of the world Ukraine last Mariupol
@Food4thought2023
@Food4thought2023 2 года назад
@North Korea Is Best Korea Yes, that's my point. Debating allows you to consider viewpoints and aspects you never considered. As long as we just keep telling people that they are wrong without engaging in debate - they won't change.
@Food4thought2023
@Food4thought2023 2 года назад
@North Korea Is Best Korea I think that you missed my point. In a debate each side presents their views to convince their opposition that they are right and to prove the opposition are wrong. People with the opposite view to you might feel just as strongly they correct. If you simply tell them they are wrong without engaging them they will not change their views.
@Food4thought2023
@Food4thought2023 2 года назад
@North Korea Is Best Korea Well we either at least attempt to do so or risk further deepening the distrust. Just saying.
@Food4thought2023
@Food4thought2023 2 года назад
@North Korea Is Best KoreaThe difference here is that a large portion of people in the West and the rest of of the world actually either support Putin or are on the fence. They can't just be told by the West that our view is right - because we say so. This attitude to developing nations is what created this distrust of the West in the first place. Your comparison is not valid.
@lesbooth2837
@lesbooth2837 2 года назад
And if you notice most of the new stations say 3.5 million subscribers, but the viewings never go over a hundred thousand,🤔
@udokonig617
@udokonig617 2 года назад
Finnland und Schweden in die Nato 💪 ist das beste für Weltfrieden in Europa 💪💯
@sschmachtel8963
@sschmachtel8963 2 года назад
Oh well Finland as a member of Nato being a threat to Russia is kind of missjudging the foreign policies of Finland. I think that even with Finland being a member of Nato it is going to continue as careful as before to interact with Russia and going a pretty long way trying not to provoke or threaten Russia. I think there is not really another country that has such a succesful foreign policy history with Russia alsthough it had been more west than east oriented and following own agendas during the cold war.
@hdj81Vlimited
@hdj81Vlimited 2 года назад
wait and see, NATO wants to put MISSILES on russian border in Finland, wait and see.... remember my words........ o wait, they already there........ as well in Estonia, estland, poland, bulgaria, romania.... why? NEver did russia 1 step to invade ANY country, but yes if you keep expanding NATO you will have a WAR.....
@theccpisaparasite8813
@theccpisaparasite8813 2 года назад
huh? no one in NATO has ever provoked Russia. it's a defensive alliance to protect against Soviet/Russian aggression ... hmmmm
@JamesSmith-ix5jd
@JamesSmith-ix5jd 2 года назад
Would Finland be able not to put NATO's infrastructure on its territory after it joins? Because if not, it is 100% certain escalation with Russia.
@theccpisaparasite8813
@theccpisaparasite8813 2 года назад
@@JamesSmith-ix5jd I'm pretty sure that NATO will be able to use existing Finnish infrastructure.
@hdj81Vlimited
@hdj81Vlimited 2 года назад
@@JamesSmith-ix5jd when they put missiles on the border THEN its a escalation..... look what USA did when the russians put missiles in Cuba, 65 years embargo, people don't even got new cars or break fluid........but when USA put missiles on eVERY border with russia its OK?????
@jessicaandersson4313
@jessicaandersson4313 2 года назад
Interestimg discussion, just one thing Finland isn't part of Scandinavia it's a Nordic country. Hearing the host talking about the 2 Scandinavian countries etc makes it seems like he wasn't briefed enough
@jessicaandersson4313
@jessicaandersson4313 2 года назад
@@fisz0017 Yeah, English and Russian are way more closely related than Swedish and Finnish.
@bunzeebear2973
@bunzeebear2973 2 года назад
looking on a MAP ...Denmark is the oddball. Norway, Sweden, Finland are in that Peninsula of land, that is divided into thirds. They are grouped as Scandinavia. On the maps in every atlas. This is the land of the Vikings...that fought each other because they did not understand each others language.
@jessicaandersson4313
@jessicaandersson4313 2 года назад
@@bunzeebear2973 Scandinavia - Sweden, Norway, Denmark Nordic countries - Scandinavia + Finland, Iceland, autonomous regions of Åland, Faroe islands and Greenland If you want to include Finland based of geography its called Fennoscandia and also includes part of Russia.. The only vikings to be foumd in Finland settled there, it's not considered a viking country. The Scandinavian languages are mutually intelligible, for the most part. They share a common past Since it's an old term there are several theories and explanations where the word Scandinavia originally came from. Scania was the name used for the area where you originally found the vikings, what is in modern times are the 3 kingdoms. Scandes is the name of the mountain range denoting the border between Norway and Sweden and it connects to Denmark under water. The Nordic countries comes more from a shared past than geography.. Unfortunately travel agencies, media producers etc are muddying the waters in English by ignoring the established definitions, but Finland is never considered part of Scandinavia. Finns are even ethnically distinct from Scandinavians and speak a language that isn't Scandinavian or even Germanic.
@cephy8102
@cephy8102 2 года назад
Looks like you guys got a typo in that title. Last I checked it's spelled "knocking" not "knockung" :p
@denizural5390
@denizural5390 2 года назад
This is called Denglish 🤣
@IMAS7X
@IMAS7X 2 года назад
I thought “knockung” was German.🤣
@DorianLS
@DorianLS 2 года назад
The historian fellow doesn't mince words about Putin and Russia. I agree with him completely.
@Yardbird68
@Yardbird68 2 года назад
How can "ONE" nation block Sweden and Finland from joining. Common sense tells me, each nation votes in NATO and if the major says yes, then they're in.
@scepticalwalker3984
@scepticalwalker3984 2 года назад
Turkey seeks concessions in unrelated matters. It will be sorted out.
@laurastortoni-hager1510
@laurastortoni-hager1510 2 года назад
TURKEY DOES NOT EVEN BELONG IN EUROPE....AND THEY WANT TO BOSS US AROUND?'?????, STICK TO YOUR SERAGLIO ERDOVAN AND MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS.
Далее
Full Video | Episode 139 | Col. Douglas Macgregor (ret.)
1:27:00
这到底是怎么做到的 #路飞#海贼王
00:10
Просмотров 3,4 млн
Russia's Catastrophic Oil & Gas Problem
39:02
Просмотров 7 млн
Where Is Everything In The Universe Going?
56:48
Просмотров 567 тыс.
Why does the US spend so much on its military?
28:24
Просмотров 1,4 млн