Тёмный

LMF Mark the Gospel #3: Packaging 

Logos Made Flesh
Подписаться 122 тыс.
Просмотров 4,6 тыс.
50% 1

Mark has this way of telling stories which appear frequently in his gospel. He begins with one story, then switches to another, before once again returning to finish the first. If you haven’t seen it yet, here’s one example:
In chapter 6, Mark recounts how Jesus instructed his disciples and sent them on a mission. He then jumps to an involved and yet seemingly unrelated flashback dealing with Herod’s beheading of John the Baptist. Only then does he return to the disciples and their mission.
This basic A-B-A pattern is known as a sandwich. And its essence can be felt in other arrangements; for instance, as we saw last time, in the bookending of Mark 8-10 with the healing of two blind men.
The sandwich is not unique to Mark. It’s a common literary device. And as such it's not something Mark derived wholly from chronology. Contrary to what you might think, Mark isn’t simply telling us what happened. He’s chosen to arrange his story this way. The question is why?
Well, that has a lot to do with how Mark thought his audience would receive and comprehend his book.
In Mark’s time, a book was considered differently than it is today. If you happen to look at a surviving first-century manuscript you might be surprised to find it devoid of things like chapter numbers, section titles, paragraph indentations, highlighted words. Not even punctuation or spaces between words! Today, such graphic signals are indispensable to written communication. We depend on them to orient ourselves to a book's structure and point.
But ancient authors and audiences couldn’t depend on such visual signals. Before printing, the copy of books was limited. Most people simply wouldn’t see the text. Besides literacy itself was a specialized skill; maybe 2 percent of the population could read. The book, consequently, wasn’t regarded as a silent and private flow between writer and reader. Instead, it was a script to extend the voice of a speaker. Authors wrote not so much to be read but heard through public reading.
Interestingly enough. Those who could read, always read out loud, even when alone. Silent reading was in fact considered something strange when it first appeared some three hundred years later.
This means that Mark told his story in such a way that a strictly listening audience could hear and comprehend it.
Think about that! You’ve never read or heard Mark and then one Sunday, your pastor opts to read the entire gospel out loud in place of a sermon. That’s a lot of events to unpack in the roughly hour and fifteen minutes it would take. How could Mark’s original audience understand it all? Could you?
Of course, you could. You do it all the time. Apart from a picture, listening to Mark isn’t that much different from watching a film. Because of the limitations of our minds, storytellers have always divided longer narratives into a hierarchy of units. In movies, scenes are bundled into sequences and sequences into acts. We call this bracketing or packaging.
In modern books, the division of units is typically found in the look of the page. But in a venue without text, organization is indicated in other ways. A preacher, for instance, might offer the blatant “first point, second point, third point, and in conclusion” in his sermon. While the filmmaker divides his story through subtle repetition and parallels. As in the same crossroads in the opening and closing in the film Cast Away - There’s that Sandwich!
Like a filmmaker, Mark divides and packages his story without using graphic signals on the page. And just as in a film, he does it through in the packaging of repetition. The Sandwich’s A-B-A pattern being the most obvious example.
Ancient authors and audiences were keenly aware of the application and use of parallels for hearing a stories organization. Repetition breaks up a linear progression and creates a beat-counterbeat effect. And the principle was used in varying ways. In Mark, for instance, we find the use of an a-b-c-a-b-c pattern. Mark, for instance, links Jesus’ calming of the storm and the healing of the woman with the issue of blood in just such a pattern. We also find a symmetric a-b-c-b-a pattern, known as a chasm, at work, for instance, in the feedings of the five thousand the feeding of the four.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

21 янв 2016

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 14   
@avgAaron
@avgAaron 7 лет назад
I know you're doing movie analysis, but I'd love more videos like this!
@youthnation1
@youthnation1 7 лет назад
Thank you! I'm glad you getting something out of them. I'll return to this series in the future. I think it's helpful for the discussion of Mark to look at movies. Symbolic meaning in movies is easier for most people to recognize and accept. There's an interesting similarity between the ending of Mark and the ending of Inception. But a foundation needs to be laid before people are prone to believe me. :)
@GenX_Catholic
@GenX_Catholic 6 лет назад
Don't eat grandpa!!! The horrors of a misplaced comma...
@agathafry4233
@agathafry4233 7 лет назад
Awesome and timely. Just listened to a great TED talk about the Bhagavadgita as the "B" portion in the sandwich within the Mahabharata. Think I'll go read Mark now, thanks :)
@usdollar999
@usdollar999 7 лет назад
Amazing! Keep it up!
@youthnation1
@youthnation1 7 лет назад
It's been a while since I've made one. I haven't had access to the recording studio. But I think I'm going to start making them with just slides and audio. Thanks for the comments! Really appreciate it. :)
@harveylopezt
@harveylopezt 6 лет назад
This is pure gold, heartfelt thanks. This came to me just after reading Mark. What are the odds? I would heart it completely after this videos in an audio version and try to understand the packaging.
@sarahminifie8592
@sarahminifie8592 7 лет назад
I am so happy this video is exactly what it was. I am a storyteller looking to improve my craft and I was not in the mood for a sermon. This was a great class and I have always wanted to learn more about the storytelling of the bible without it requiring faith in the bible. Great work.
@youthnation1
@youthnation1 7 лет назад
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it and got something out of it! :)
@gregorywade4773
@gregorywade4773 7 лет назад
I want to hear more. I just listened to a Jordan Peterson video on "The Idea of God." He calls the bible a "hyper-linked document," referencing the internet, and he produces a graph that illustrates the referencing between verses of the bible. Your presentation confirms in many ways the point he is making. Your analysis is sharp. I look forward to future videos.
@youthnation1
@youthnation1 6 лет назад
"hyper-link" is a great metaphor for how the Bible creates meaning through allusion. I enjoy Jordan Peterson's perspective.
@kevinfrank8164
@kevinfrank8164 7 лет назад
You seem so knowledgeable of what you say. I was raised my a very religious mother and I have had my problems with the Catholic church and haven't gone to mass in 8 years, and some of these videos have made me question my decision. But I gotta say, If you make a mistake...take another take. As much as I love these vids I think "If this guy can't take the time to correct a simple mistake, how much could he really care?"
@youthnation1
@youthnation1 7 лет назад
If I gave in to my desire for perfection in everything I do, I would never upload. Hours, days, weeks and months go into these videos already as it is. At some point, I have to move on. And try to do better in the next one.
@uhyeahthisguy
@uhyeahthisguy 5 лет назад
You made a spelling error. Did you really mean to say "*my* a very religious mother" in your comment? It must mean you really don't care about everything you just said in that comment, because you didn't take the time to correct a simple mistake. Do you see the flaw in your logic? You obviously did care about what you had to say; you just made a mistake - just like the LogosMadeFlesh guy. Look, I don't mean to be a douche or anything, but there it is.
Далее
LMF Mark the Gospel #4: Power of Three
4:51
Просмотров 4,4 тыс.
LMF Mark the Gospel #5: Plot
3:58
Просмотров 827
The God Who Isn't There Part 2
24:31
Просмотров 51 тыс.
LMF Mark the Gospel #6: First Sequence
3:48
Shawshank's Hollowed-Out Bible
5:45
Просмотров 787 тыс.
Reading other Minds (Part 1)
8:40
Просмотров 24 тыс.
The Old Testament in 8 minutes
8:01
Просмотров 2,2 млн
How to Read and Understand the Bible
44:57
Просмотров 14 тыс.
The Hidden Meaning of the Shawshank Redemption
7:19
Просмотров 2,6 млн
Ex Machina's Hidden Meaning
8:19
Просмотров 1,5 млн