Logan - Every X-Men Movie Reviewed & Ranked 

When Patrick Stewart accepts the offer for dinner, it reminded me so much of my Grandfather who has had a stroke. He has a hard time walking and speaking, and going anywhere is a massive hassle, but he has these older values that he insists upon. As Patrick Stewart does, when someone offers you a homecooked meal, you accept gratefully. Even if we are the ones with the wheel chair, my grandfather makes me leave him to go open doors for people. Or if someone is stuck on the side of the road, he makes us pull over to see if we can help, even if we have frozen foods that need to be taken home. To him, those are just things you do, regardless of the circumstances, maybe even if people are chasing you down and trying to kill you. It's pretty cool how well they nailed that aspect of Xavier's character.

This is it. This is the best film in the series by a mile. Logan's not only one of the best comic book movies, but one of the best films of 2017. Like Nolan's trilogy, Rami's first two Spider-Man films, and much of the MCU movies, it's treated with the upmost love and respect. So much passion and hard work went into this, which included Jackman's best performance as an actor (right up there with Prisoners). This film is raw emotion, and you truly feel it for its entirety. Should've been nominated for several oscars IMO. Jackman and Stewart's swan song. The film that cemented the legend that is Jackman's Wolverine. For me, it's one of the last pieces of my childhood that finally came to a close. Folks in my theater cried, applauded in the end, and even gave complete strangers hugs. Truly an achievement. What a shame we'll never see the real Deadpool team up with Logan.

Absolutely love this film, definitely in my Top 5 comic book movies ever

I love when Tim said it was heavy handed in a lot of places and Kevin just turns and looks at Greg and Greg just shakes his head😂

The whole "it wasnt me charles" broke my heart man. Like what a way to go

Nick was right. In old man Logan the hulk eats Logan and he bursts out kratos style.

X-24 really reminds me of Sabertooth. The "This is how it feels" I interpreted as Logan finally knowing a family. Xavier talked earlier in the film to Logan about family.

Best Adapted Screenplay nod. Film is on a different stratosphere compared to rest of XCU and MCU

I love how they call back to the wolverine when that girl says he will die with his heart in his hand and it ends with him holding Laura's hand... cause shes his heart

logan is easily my top 3 favorite superhero movie of all time

Rewatching this 5 years later, its crazy how right Kevin is about everything. I wish I could days of the future past myself to warn Kevin he won’t be on future episodes to correct Tim. ❤

Logan is easily my number 1 in all marvel superhero movies. Only comic book movie above it is The Dark Knight. Honestly, anyone who puts other marvel movies above it is crazy. Logan is simply a phenomenal “movie” not just a great “comic book movie.” The same can’t be said for the others imo.

The only reason X-Men In Review exists.

"Andy twisted his ankle once and I was like, you want me to put you down?" LOL I almost lost my shit at work

Imagine if Dark Phoenix, probably the end of the XCU, ended with Jean having Wanda's moment saying "no more mutants" and the screen just goes black. And none of them were ever seen again. What a downer ending.

How Hugh Jackman wasn’t nominated for an Oscar is beyond me.

Nick you nailed it with the ranking. Logan blows all the MCU out of the water.

Definitely not “heavy handed” like Tim says

As someone who hadn't watched any X-men movies before watching Logan, Logan is one of my favorite movies of all time.

I think as a film Logan is better than everything in the mcu but entertainment wise I could see top 4

Andy I'm glad to hear you loved it. It's by far my favorite comic book movie and honestly one of my favorite movies in general. It sucks it took so long to get it right but Wolverine finally got the film he deserved. Damn I love this movie.

Professor X doesn't agree to go to dinner to teach Logan a lesson, he goes because he's been locked up in hiding for so long.

greg's deep breaths in the mic are top 5 marvel villains

Fyi... X-23 does not have adamantium on her bones in the comics, its explained that she escaped before the procedure could be done to her entire skeleton, she only has adamantium claws. I would assume even with the procedure in her file in the movie, like in the comics, she escaped before it was done.

Magento would be like 95 in 2029... he is either dead or senile

4:27 Technically Logan isn't in the same timeline as the other X-Men movies. There are a few touches here and there to distinguish it. Not that it really matters though. Even though they aren't connected they were still able to use the emotional connection of these characters that have built up over the years to send them off properly. And I prefer the ending of Days of Future Past to be the ending of the X-Men timeline anyway.

Havent watched the video yet so i dont know if the question have been answered but - Do we watch the Super Duper cut of Deadpool 2 or just the normal cut

#YoureWrong X-23 has adamantium claws, but a regular skeleton, which, iirc, gives her a better healing factor than Logan in the comics since it isn't constantly trying to deal with adamantium poisoning to the same degree.

The violent/serious movie that wolverine deserved and such a great send off for Hugh Jackman. Also I'm excited for spiderman-in-review purely for Greg's plot summaries, even if it is more marvel

This is hands down the best Super hero movie ever made. Dark Knights amazing but rewatching it its honestly a tad boring, Heath carries that movie so hard, it's so boring when he's not on screen.

God this movie. So many beautiful things I noticed on this second viewing. Now that Professor X has kind of let go, Patrick Stewart channels James Macavoy’s young Professor X so subtly. Logan literally has to fight himself, a self reminiscent of his past. He keeps an adamantium bullet because he wants to kill himself... and he kind of does? The struggle to get Laura to safety is evocative of Logan’s own legacy: his powers have always preserved him, but now what he leaves behind in/with Laura will preserve him. The interpolation of the gang watching the western foreshadows the movie’s end, duh, but it also echoes the superhero genre, as both that film and this film are desconstructions, “end of the genre” type movies. Professor X has been chilling in a pseudo Cerebro looking thang. Logan finally founding out what “this feels like” can both refer to death and finding family.

Great review for a masterpiece film IMO. You guys should definitely review The Dark Knight trilogy! Do it!

"I'm hard of hearing, if you know what I mean"...what the hell else could this mean, Greg?

Nice Vid Keep It Up :)

Tim was straight up pulling a greg when he said Andy would edit the video lol

Don't get me wrong, I love you guys and all your in review content. BUT Your review style with all this confuses me, this film has sooo much more substance than some of the fun MCU films (which I like a lot btw) but it seems you judge films on humour and fun rather than substance and character at times. I think if you stressed often that you prefer popcorn films compared to deeper films, you get less backlash in comments. They are your opinions of course and I respect that, just don't understand some of the critique at times 👍

I wish you'd done the Black & White version but great show as always

There was actually a lot of VFX in Logan! It was done very, very well and smartly. The chain link fence stuff for example was all VFX!

This movie is so god damn heartbreaking and thoughtful. What a film, only second to The Dark Knight in regards to comic book adaptations

I like certain MCU movies more but as a film it’s better than all the other MCU movies

Tim. The drinks don’t kill mutants. It stops them from spreading the mutant gene. This is explained in depth in the movie.

I like that these episodes are the run time of an actual movie.

Logan was such a great movie!

7:27 I think Magneto should have been in the story but I don't think he should have removed the adamantium. It could have been explained away like he was too weak to do that at that point. There should have been a scene where Logan calls him to tell him that Xavier died. He calls him, tells him and then hangs up the phone. Short sweet and to the point.

Wow, timing, was just thinking what to watch whilst eating my dinner, boom, it's Thursday! Thanks guys, still loving these, long may they please continue!!

I know that this is a strech because there's so many movies, but with XCU in review coming to an end I think it'd be dope as hell to see a pixar in review.

This movie is amazing and if i were to rank it in the mcu defiantly in the top 5 mcu movies but man i didn't want to re watch this because its so sad and kinda depressing.

This is on par with The Dark Knight

rewatched it recently, definitely in the echelon just below Nolan's Batman and in the echelon above every other comic book movie. though Winter Soldier is pretty close.

I love this movie, it’s my second favorite comic book movie behind The Dark Knight

1:16:02 but did Laura kill the fisherman?

Just re-watched Logan in preparation for this, I'm stoked for Spider-Man!

Kev: I dont understand why the kids didnt just stand up and fight the soldiers initially Kev 30 seconds later: Didnt the kids didnt want to fight so bad they would kill themselves before doing so I'm surprised no one picked up on that lol

unfortunately, I haven't been able to rewatch the X-Men movies, so... not getting the plot right off that bat makes it REALLY hard to follow all the commentary. That being said, I still love everything you guys do! You know what to do with that chicken.

I know I'm watching this late, but I wanna shout out to the void: They talk about how if the water is killing the mutants, how come Logan and Xavier are "okay".... but they're Not Okay.... The Most Powerful Mutants are barely surviving. Maybe Xavier's Degenerative Brain sickness wasn't random, or just from being old... what if it was from being slowly poisoned??

I wonder if they will have their hands on #SpiderManPS4 by the time they record the first Spider-Man In Review?

I think the augmented limbs represent how horrific the fight against mutants has been but also how humans tend to become the thing they are fighting, as the next level of human being but a bastardized version.

Logan was amazing as a stand alone but don’t try to make sense of the XCU timeline.

Andy has graphite in his hand?! I have graphite in my leg!! I thought I was the only one.

Oh boy here we go

Love Logan. I haven't seen a better movie with comic book origins.

One of my favorite western movie

X-23 has bone claws and the metal was just laced to her claws only. That's why she heal faster than Logan. The metal slows his healing factor.

I like to think this is an alternate universe because this is such a depressing end for these characters and DoFP ends on a much nicer note

I just want to shout out the fact that Logan's old face was done with CGI and it was done so well that most people didn't notice

When will they remember Origins' Stryker for RaguBagu

8:08 There hasn't been a new Mutant born in 25 years? Then why were there young mutants in Xavier's School only a few years before at the End of Days of Future Past if the universes are connected?

Dudes, I'm from Portugal and absolutely love the channel!!! Theese reviews are just the best, love them!!! Could you do one for the Harry Potter series? Fantastic Beasts 2 is coming, so that would be a great idea!!! Keep up the great work guys!!!

I'm from Chihuahua, Mexico. The state just south of El Paso, Texas. So i got really excited when I realized there were x-men hiding in my home state haha :P

I think I enjoyed this more than any mcu movie. Gotta watch infinity war again

😶 I wanted to see Nick do the camera shake trick...

Havent watched the video but i am betting that its #1

ive seen so many in reviews now that i say ragu and bagu at the proper times with them......

TAKE THE SUNGLASSES OFF!!!!!!!!!!! Is it stage fright thing?!

I really don't think they poisoned the mutants to kill them. It was more of breeding them out by destroying the mutant gene so no new ones would show up. Also Nick is right old man Logan is eaten by Hulk and he cuts his way out.

I have no qualms about putting Logan right behind The Dark Knight for best live action superhero movies ever.

does anyone kno what kind of hoodie that kevin is wearing??? please someone help!!!! ive been asking for last week to no avail :(. it looks so cool

They only give her the claws not whole skeleton because it would stunt her growth. Edit: Good job Kev.

"And then you eat it for calcium"-Andy Cortez 2018

I hope the DCEU pulls the same thing as XCU and gets better with each movie now. one day it might be in the In review series but no one wants to see a list we know wonder woman will win right now.

This is the apocalypse timeline Logan the days of future past Logan is different

Patrick Stewart was snubbed as "Best Supporting Actor."

i fucking love this movie stil

ER in Review let's fuckin gooooo

Didn't Xavier kill all the other mutants by accident?

So no one from KF knew about the Reavers?? No one had read Old Man Logan?? Looks like Greg's comic book club needs some more HW.

This movie is my favorite movie period.

These movie universe in review videos really remind me of how much I relate to Nick and how genuine his opinions seem to be.

This is probably second overall including the MCU. Infinity was such a monumental accomplishment so I think it comes just behind that. Ragnorok and Spider-Man are fun comedies but definitely average films

That Spider-Man shirt is hot af.

I’m sorry, but Logan is definitely better than Spider-Man home coming etc...

why is kevin wearing sunglasses. Or, to speak more accurately, why isn't everyone else wearing sunglasses?

Movie was quite good, but the third act it's just Wolverine kill everyone.

Surprised all you guys didn't know Narcos

Where is Ant-man and The Wasp on the MCU ranking?

Batman in review

I'd put Logan at the number 2 right under INFINITY WARS

I have 2 important questions: 1. Will there be an XCU In Review In Review? 2. Will there be a Kinda Hunnies Review the XCU?

That little tuft of hair where Tim's sideburns connects with his beard is driving me crazy. Fix that shit homie.

I feel this movie is pretty overrated to be honest, but maybe that's because I was never all that fond of Fox-men so I really didn't care all that much when he died nor the references to their completely all over the place continuity.