No video :(

Loops can SAVE your Interchange in Cities Skylines

Подписаться 92 тыс.

Просмотров 127 тыс.

50% 1

➤ Loops are clearly magic. Turning right to go left? It totally works, and it's used in the real world ALL THE TIME! Todays video explores the what, when, and why of loops. Enjoy!
I forgot a left turn! Please forgive me and know that loops are still awesome :)
The previous video: • The best SMALL Highway...
How to build a SPUI: • Free Your Traffic Usin...
How to build a Parclo: • Beating Traffic with t...
How to build a Cloverleaf: • Elegance and Imperfect...
How to build a Cloverstack: • The Cloverstack CRUSHE...
How to build a Diverging Diamond: • Why your Diamonds shou...
➤Patreon: / yumbltv
➤Discord Server: / discord
➤Watch Yumbl Live: / yumbltv
➤Instagram: / yumbltv
➤Twitter: / yumbltv
➤Steam Workshop Collections: tinyurl.com/y4...
➤Mod Collection: steamcommunity...
0:00 Loops may be for you
0:55 What are loops?
2:06 Where do loops work?
7:51 How to build a loop
10:35 Single loop Parclo
12:02 Interchange progression in Cities: Skylines
#citiesskylines #interchange #infrastructure
➤Music Provided by Chillhop:
Misha, Jussi Halme, El Train, goodie bags - Dreaming chll.to/259fc5e9
El Train - Kaleidoscope chll.to/e45132ae
El Train - Lavender chll.to/7269084b
El Train, Marc Mathias - Snap Back chll.to/b3a7ff0c
El Train - Slow Burn chll.to/a70bcce7
El Train, Producerboibrad. - Cosmos chll.to/e458d42f

Опубликовано:

14 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 197

@danielcues Год назад

But how does the Highway traffic turn left after the loop was added?

@YUMBL Год назад

Oh shoot… well, here we are. I can’t take it back now 🤣

@danielcues Год назад

@@YUMBL hahahha I was so confused 😂

@YUMBL Год назад

@@danielcues Maybe there's a roundabout up the way? Yea, that's it. Just out of frame...

@bazzakrak Год назад

Just say @@YUMBL that it is to confuse the invading enemy that you made it like that 😊😊 Trying to confuse Biffa I am sure

@UrbanPanic Год назад

@@YUMBLAhh. The “secret Biffa” interchange.

@TheDeadmanTT Год назад

They should've called this game Traffic Manager: President Edition!

@inyobill Год назад

I see what you did there, he he he.

@commemorative Год назад

Someone should have made a mod called Cities Skylines for it.

@KoalasAreBurrs Год назад

No lies detected.

@thebluemxxn Год назад

They should release a sequel called Mass Transit

@skippymcgroyne Год назад

The logic behind traffic movement is always interesting to me. I see it as a personal challenge to all the efficiency expert's out there and the best part is that it doesn't just end with one answer; the optimal configuration is a constantly evolving target. Great work, as always!

@inyobill Год назад

At low vloumes a roundabout might provide the best flow, at higher vloumes a light, extreme, overpass interchanges, then there is the question: Does one of the directions; volume dominate, ... . I have no issue taking through traffic on a highway interchange down to one lane when doing the lane Maths (Biffa I believe doesn't recommend), if the traffic is light on that route.

@PhaseFalcon Год назад

ever since i started using roads properly in this game (road heirarchy, interchange design, etc) ive started over analyzing the traffic and roads where i live... im not crazy im not crazy Im nOt CrAzyYyyyyY

@landofsuchbeauty Год назад

I love this!!: 'Interchanges as a journey'. I've always just workshopped my interchanges, but as I evolve as a city builder, I want to create custom interchanges that arise organically from the specific traffic demands combined with topography and a sense of place. Your quick guide really helps and motivates me to go down that road (pun not really intended).

@Marconius6 Год назад

"I'm YUMBL and this is a diamond interchange" is about the most YUMBL way to start a video.

@milton1969able Год назад

Stareted a city after a few years away from playing CS. Started with your idea of not haveing any highways, still don't have any highways just normal roads with a single roundabout and a couple of small trumpets, the rest is normal intersections. Thanks to your videos of traffic light managment and Biffas traffic managment I'm up tp 90k on the 25 tile mod and the traffic is, more or less, working perfectly.

@JediTev Год назад

How did you handle the extra traffic that the 6 lane highways had and is now on two lane national roads? I made a city on that reduced road map (unfortunately, I lost the city) and the traffic almost, immediately, backed up. I added an interstate highway back to the map and a couple of 4 lane national roads back to it.

@milton1969able Год назад

@@JediTev I've been slowly upgradeing the road system. National highway at first then as intersections got busier I just upgraded local nodes, Don't get me wrong some of my roads are now 6 lane main roads and are busy but its a thriveing city with lots of traffic and so in real life there will be busy intersections here and there. I'm also useing realistic pop mod and have zoned no Hi res yet so there are no mega busy hi density houseing areas to deal with.

@davidroddini1512 Год назад

If you want a small interchange, the SPUI can’t be beat. This is especially the case if the highway ramps connect on the left side of the highway using bidirectional ramps. Of course in that case there has to be enough room between the highway directions to allow for a 4 lane road (2 in each direction) so the left hand turns coming off the highway don’t block the right turns.

@tobiasalexander4491 Год назад

Welcome back, Yumbl - you've been missed!

@YUMBL Год назад

Thank you :)

@haywire4686 Год назад

At 9:12, I always used to connect my loops to the highway like that, and then used your trick of nudging the segment with Move It to fix the textures. It seems to give pretty good loops, and with some extra node controller it looks quite clean!

@HunkMine 9 месяцев назад

This logic really explains really well why diamond interchanges turned into cloverloops, just repeat this for each turn and its actually cool a video game can sim this

@loganb.1984 Год назад

“Oh, right makes perfect sense. True right to go left. Yes!” -Lightning McQueen

@amysteriousenigma Год назад

i've also heard this neat little one-loop solution referred to as a "folded diamond"

@Papershields001 Год назад

I was in Tokyo last month and some of the interchanges on the Tomei expressway were nuts.

@Papershields001 Год назад

Particularly the Yokohama-Aoba interchange

@mainlatestmirror Год назад

Also there's turn around for the highway built in it. Stay in one lane, you will turn around to go the opposite way of the highway.

@hyuntoe Год назад

in recent days I am playing Euro truck sim. and I understand the importance of interchange/junction. always thanks to Yumble for easy building interchanges.

@kgaming7599 Год назад

ETS has a lot of cloverleaf interchanges, while ATS has more diamonds, don't you agree?

@jayzo Год назад

The big cause of traffic is conflict points where traffic have to yield to cross one another. The loops eliminate that crossing point. You can also overlap the on and off ramps to two junctions that are way too close together so that in a given direction of travel, junction 1's on ramp merges _after_ junction 2's of ramp splits off, with the ramps crossing using a flyover. This eliminates that point where traffic changing lanes entering the highway at junction 1 is swapping and crossing over the traffic that is changing lanes to leave at junction 2

@HazelPlace89 Год назад

Good stuff! Informative, yet entertaining as always.

@inyobill Год назад

I often come to this channel just because I'm stressed and need some calmness.

@Jakob212 Год назад

noice, the best start for a weekend :D

@Henk8118 Год назад

I like the quarter-clo. I'll be using it. I hate left turning traffic anyways. :p

@HarvesteR21 Год назад

Good to see you again! Hope you are well!

@parentpj Год назад

Nice to have you back, will watch the video later

@thebeeselise Год назад

in reference to Cloverleaf interchanges: "The purpose is to get cars on and off the highway. Or transitioning between a major freeway or highway and a smaller local road." -Laughs in I-71 & I-75 to I-275N interchanges. -Cries in traffic jams caused by the I-71 & I-75 to I-275N interchanges

@YUMBL Год назад

That specific cloverleaf is what i was talking about. Not all cloverleafs.

@SkittleKicksPlays Год назад

One thing I did notice is the West to East off ramp does not allow a driver to get back on the freeway do to only left and right turning. In the real world if someone didn't mean to get off the freeway at that particular exit, they could use the off ramp to hop back on on the other side rather than having to do a turn around on another road. Yeah I mean it is a game, but you are going for more realism. Additionally when you added signalized intersections on the SB to NB side, how much traffic volume do you gain when this is placed in a city?

@e1123581321345589144 Год назад

13:41 I'd call it a *half diamond partial cloverleaf*

@slicksamos8334 Год назад

Junctions need lööps brother

@Anti_Woke Год назад

Welcome back. Hope you had a good holiday.

@Veridiania Год назад

Thumbnail: "turn right to turn left" me: LIGHTNING MCQUEEN

@shamcra Год назад

I wish some modder will come up with a way to do proper clothoids/cornu spirals for the off/on ramps in an interchange.

@YUMBL Год назад

Same

@UnintendedConsequence Год назад

Had the game for years on Origin. Missed out on SO MUCHHHHHHHHHHHHH(I couldn't mod on Origin) I am a vanilla mod newbie and YUMBL is my new hero holy crap I needed all of these tutorials....

@mariebcfhs9491 Год назад

If you go right hard enough, you'll find yourself going left

@adicrot Год назад

Yumbl, bring back NewMarket city build, it was epic

@bobgrey6137 Год назад

The CloverStack/Clover Turbine depends on the flyover ramps. The one you've built is a Clover Turbine because the flyover ramps are bowed out to the outer edges and form a circle kind of shape. A CloverStack has the flyover ramps more tight and over the center. They are both effectively the same interchange, but a Stack gets its name by literally stacking the flyover ramps on top of the point where the two highways cross over each other. If they don't stack, it isn't a Stack.

@YUMBL Год назад

No, I assure you I’ve built a cloverstack. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interchange_(road) Check under the “system interchange” header. If you have another source I’d love to see it!

@bobgrey6137 Год назад

Ah, yes, an informal term by how that article describes it as someone it is "sometimes" referred to as. That article does also specifically point out that design as being of Turbine, not Stack, interchanges when you read through the description of both Turbine and Stack. People do often use terms that are easier to say, though, rather than more fitting of what they are describing. I suppose "Stack" has come to mean anything with flyover ramps at this point.

@YUMBL Год назад

Yes, but “cloverturbine” remains conspicuously absent from anywhere official at all. I do a lot of research before presenting these ideas, and you’re not the first to say as much. I was hoping to see a source more legitimate than the wikipedia entry on this interchange, but alas. The elusive “cloverturbine” seems to be isolated to the names of creations within the steam workshop.

@DarkVnzla30YT Год назад

hahaha yumbl you got the same idea on the minute 1:10 of an upgraded interchange of yours early creations. thanks for show this best interchange of all times.pd: i had the same idea and i already use it in my city.

@m-yday Год назад

hmm.. I just wanted to add that decreasing a radius actually makes it a tighter turn, not gentler! so 6u to 5u means that the mid-section of the turn is the gentlest :)

@YUMBL Год назад

Did I say something to the contrary?

@m-yday Год назад

@@YUMBL you had said to decrease the amount of units to make it a gentler exit when you were building the first loop :) We all make these kinds of errors, but I saw no comments mentioning it so I wanted to say something to check!

@YUMBL Год назад

Oopsie!

@ash36230 Год назад

Me reading the title: I too have seen Cars

@t900HAWK Год назад

We have these in my city and you always see people going all the way left thinking the ramp is on that side then they just cut across 4 lanes of traffic to make it

@frenchy1224 Год назад

Just binged watched Benton and absolutely loved the series! You ended episode 8 saying you took a 2 week break and you'll announce when the series is over. It's been seven months and now new episode, is Benton still alive?

@LucasLovesTrucks 11 месяцев назад

You should try making a windmill interchange

@Daniel-sy9fe Год назад

I would wish that “traffic manager” comes to consoles. That would make it a lot easier with traffic.

@clutch44444 Год назад

The cloverleaf is better than the parclo in terms of flow, because the cloverleaf with lane maths, you can have constant flow with no traffic crossing over, therefore no need for lights, which means better flow

@YUMBL Год назад

Not at all. Cloverleafs are being switched out all for parclos all over north america. The cloverleaf has the problem of traffic weaving which the parclo does not.

@clutch44444 Год назад

@@YUMBL Ohhh ok

@YUMBL Год назад

Heres a good explanation I made ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-TIH37lrEMFI.html

@clutch44444 Год назад

@@YUMBL Thanks, I'll have a look Edit: Ohh I see, because the traffic has to cross over to get to the turning ramp, and because the 2 turning ramps are very close together it can cause accidents by them trying to switch lanes

@YUMBL Год назад

Exactly!

@mirailuv Год назад

oh yea about loops they should have a radius of at least 50m which already isn't a good driving experience, the radius should be more like 65m if there's space, but any smaller is just terrible to drive on like you have to slow down to around 20-30km/h for it to be comfortable, which is really annoying especially if there's a lot of traffic using the loop

@alexedjan 6 месяцев назад

What version of traffic manager compatible with cities skylines hotels and retreats

@AustinSauter 4 месяца назад

How do people turn left to go the other way on the side with the loop, Yumbl?

@zunkman1 Год назад

11:06. There is no way for your west bound highway to get to south bound arterial. Controlling traffic is easy if you don't allow turns!

@YUMBL Год назад

You’re right, its in the description and the pinned comment as well. Easily remedied.

@gagewaterhouse4323 Год назад

I might be dumb, but how do vehicles heading West turn to go South?

@mrxmry3264 Год назад

4:08 once you add the roundabouts, the loops become redundant.

@YUMBL Год назад

Absolutely not. It changes the order of the cars entering and exiting. Makes an enormous difference depending where traffic is coming from. I go into it at length here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-3dDHJZ1AWVY.html

@GiveMeMyUsernameBackPls Год назад

theres an on ramp in my town that you have to turn left to go right basically same concept as this just mirrored

@icemage21k Год назад

u need mods for these to work, game takes shortest way and will cross the road and not use the loops if they are a longer drive, a fix will be to have the right turn off the highway further down the city road so it will be a longer drive than the loop to turn left

@YUMBL Год назад

Correct. You need traffic manager to manage traffic.

@Hannodb1961 Год назад

With the mods nowadays, you can make a pretty decent looking divergent diamont interchange.

@YUMBL Год назад

Yep. See the previous vid :)

@testdriver3146 Год назад

Did I hear Biffa scream about lane mathematics in the background just now?

@achridhan Год назад

the turbin cant do turnback way (back from where its from).. I think best still 4 clover

@YUMBL Год назад

Cloverleaf is ok, but can be prone to backups.

@5BBassist4Christ Год назад

That quarter-clover you created gives me anxiety. It actually exists in St. Peters (near St. Louis) Missouri. It is where highway 79 becomes Salt Lick Road and intersects with I70. What makes this intersection so terrible is not the intersection itself, but what surrounds it. On the north side with the light (opposite from yours) is a road that connects only about 300 feet from the intersection. And because of the design of E Terra Ln's entrance ramp onto 79 highway, it makes it so the traffic has only 300 ft to merge. This takes all of 79's traffic trying to get onto the highway and forces it to merge with a side road, and all of E Terra Ln's traffic trying to get to Salt Lick Road to merge out of the one lane for both sides of the highway. All within 300 ft of the one light in the intersection. If anyone wants to see the intersection, then here is the co-ordinance on Google Maps. goo.gl/maps/tSZUPVJGMUxhZZga8

@YUMBL Год назад

The immediate parclo thing next to it is super unusual

@5BBassist4Christ Год назад

@@YUMBL It causes such bad traffic back-ups.

@NobleWolf33 Год назад

Cities Skylines might have unrealistic traffic but so does Los Angeles

@secularist1969 Год назад

Sooooooo...as an ex-Northern Virginian, all I want to know is when are you replicating the Mixing Bowl?😁

@RobertSmith-tu7rl Год назад

they are called jug handles they have them in New Jersey.

@YUMBL Год назад

No, these are not jug handles. I do have a vid about them though: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-i5v5lv0ZTcY.html

@RobertSmith-tu7rl Год назад

@@YUMBL my bad I didn't even watch the vid yet before I posted 🤦🏾‍♂️

@YUMBL Год назад

No problem :)

@CorneliusCody Год назад

Welcome to NJ! Haha

@YUMBL Год назад

Nope, not a jug handle ;)

@panhchakvothchhor5045 Год назад

Can you share you TMPE setting from the option? No matter how much I configure, my cims switch lanes back and forth like they are on steroid.

@YUMBL Год назад

Thats fairly normal behavior. You may have the “advanced lane selection” slider turned up too high though.

@Gazer75 Год назад

My issues with Cities Skylines have always been how the AI handle merging and lane use. I got so frustrated that I pretty much quit. Having a 2-3 lane highway each direction and all traffic using one lane. Then traffic entering backs up because they have no clue how to merge.

@YUMBL Год назад

If you can get traffic manager turn on “highway merging and splitting rules”

@macmedic892 Год назад

Two wrongs don’t make a right, but three rights make a left.

@bbbenj Год назад

Thanks

@tobix8982 Год назад

Have you got a working mod to remove any markings from the roads? I want to make my own like they are in Austria. (6/9m; 6/12m; 3/3m; 1/2m; 6/1.5m; 4/2m)

@YUMBL Год назад

There are blank roads in the workshop. Use intersection marking tool to create the markings.

@tobix8982 Год назад

@@YUMBL Thank you! I didn't think of that.

@katiefrisk980 Год назад

“visually interesting” unless you look at the intersection from the ground perspective (as most people would), then you see a huge patch of weeds and/or dead grass on the inside of the loop. the land value around the cloverleaf is usually depreciated too, so its surrounded by gas stations, junkyards, and so-called “parks” that nobody visits

@YUMBL Год назад

This is for players of cities skylines to enrich their experience. Players who are largely viewing their city from above, and are often prone to using similar interchanges repeatedly. This is for them :)

@pixelatedtoast Год назад

How does one do this on vanilla, no expansions citites skylines Edit: on console

@Bradley_UA Год назад

6*8 "im not gonna do the math" Imagine having to "do the math" on basic multiplicaion, instead of having the table memorised.

@YUMBL Год назад

Imagine bothering to leave this comment.

@maxhodge7149 Год назад

Nice.

@citiesplanner Год назад

how many cars can handle this interchange?

@bluefox5934 Год назад

i will use this interchanges in sc4 with nam 😉

@BLZN_Sn1ck Год назад

Wish we could get a few new things with lane control on console

@Dallas1460 Год назад

🔥👍👍👍

@Pogueconductor 11 месяцев назад

having flashbacks to new jersey!

@foodforthegods Год назад

good lord, that cloverstack is *hot* 🥵

@YUMBL Год назад

Its in my steam workshop if you need!

@loudradialem5233 Год назад

What's the most pedestrian friendly intersection, interchange or roundabout?

@YUMBL Год назад

AB Parclo is really good for peds

@loudradialem5233 Год назад

@@YUMBL but they are trash

@YUMBL Год назад

Eh, everything is relative. It just happens that the free flowing ramps that are good for cars are the worst to encounter as a ped. For the most part things that aid auto traffic are bad for peds.

@loudradialem5233 Год назад

That "cursed" over and under pass you did, with a little modification, would be great for pedestrians.

@YUMBL Год назад

I agree :)

@Dallas1460 Год назад

Коли продовження летсплеїв ?

@user-eq6te1mw8e Год назад

Hey Yumble how about an interchange where the roads are not perpendicular?

@YUMBL Год назад

I build like that on the maps I’ve released, but not for my premade interchanges.

@user-eq6te1mw8e Год назад

@@YUMBL It could be a nice video idea and we will all have an amazing Yumble interchange on top of it :)

@LuizFernando-me7cp Год назад

what is the mod that you use on 9:51 that makes the roads on menu appears on 2 lines? not just one line of roads?

@YUMBL Год назад

“Yet another toolbar”

@LuizFernando-me7cp Год назад

@@YUMBL tnks

@vadenummela9353 Год назад

Any place where you have traffic getting on a road before traffic gets off is a place where cars will stop and cause city-wide gridlock. I dont trust any type of interchange where its possible for cars to get "crossed" going from left to right. I dont understand why Cities drivers stop in the middle of a highway to change lane...

@YUMBL Год назад

Yes, it’s called “weaving”

@vadenummela9353 Год назад

@@YUMBL thanks. Like I was saying, I have no clue why Cities even after 7 years does weaving so bad it sometimes bankcrupts cities using TMPE hard mode

@terranious Год назад

In last intersection, there's no left turn 🤔, why?

@YUMBL Год назад

See description. And pinned comment. But its because I forgot.

@Starmanw422007 Год назад

Hi Yumbl, is this interchange in the steam worship?

@YUMBL Год назад

It is not. It needs a bit of work

@Starmanw422007 Год назад

@@YUMBL I do have your Jets that you made from the workshop, they look awesome. I also have Jets made by OE as well.

@YUMBL Год назад

Those are made by BlueThunder. He’s great :)

@JohnDoe-xl1ig Год назад

Traffic ruins my cities because I am terrible with design for traffic flow. I just quit my last game because traffic was back up for miles on a ramp.

@YUMBL Год назад

Traffic IS the game :)

@notniko6914 Год назад

3 lane into one lane math adds up...

@YUMBL Год назад

It’s called a split. Adding lanes is not a problem.

@Sky_Any Год назад

Like the German autobahn? Did i miss something?

@herbie_the_hillbillie_goat Год назад

YUMBL is always praising the PARCLO, but my favorite service interchange is YUMBL's own Single-Point Partial Cloverleaf --- SPPC. I don't know why he doesn't talk about it anymore. It combines the benefits of a parclo with a single, two-phase light. I've never had traffic flow problems with it. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1yTDIAIsVuM.html

@YUMBL Год назад

I’ve made two videos about it! Its a bit less practical, and none exist irl as a result. The A4 and B4 parclos are plenty powerful in most situations :)

@herbie_the_hillbillie_goat Год назад

@@YUMBL Well, be that as it may, I love the thing. It works like a charm in game. Maybe the real world just isn't ready for the genius that is YUMBL.😁

@sobertillnoon Год назад

Maybe call it a quarter clover?

@vernerieronen4997 Год назад

There is no way in the final parclo to go from east to south, the loop should be after the bridge.

@YUMBL Год назад

Yes and no. The loop is in the correct place. The right turn next to it should have been a two lane road connected straight into the arterial to allow a right AND a left.

@HaiFisch_TV Год назад

What about a diverging diamond with something like this

@YUMBL Год назад

The diverging diamond is in the “previous video” linked in the description.

@jeffreyweaver9854 Год назад

So why have several interchanges abandoned the cloverleaf design ?

@YUMBL Год назад

Cloverleafs bind up due to the cars having to weave on all sides. They are most often replaced by partial cloverleafs. I explain it well here. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-TIH37lrEMFI.html

@jeffreyweaver9854 Год назад

@@YUMBLI live near the I-70/I-75 interchange, which was originally configured as a cloverleaf

@OranguBANG Год назад

You should work with vdot in nova to fix the roads here 🤣

@YUMBL Год назад

I wish!

@luckylag360 Год назад

Nukes really solve my traffic problems.

@loopson6807 Год назад

Your last interchange example did not have a turn for traffic turning from east to south 🙄

@tiiredgamer7035 Год назад

That’s New Jersey

@YUMBL Год назад

Nope :)

@dach829 Год назад

Welcome to ni

@YUMBL Год назад

ni.

@oceanp4493 Год назад

"Shine like a diamond" Rihanna.

@OutdoorFreedomDk Год назад

NO sound ? : - (

@YUMBL Год назад

There absolutely is sound.

@theointhedoor Год назад

hope my video had some influence here:)

@inyobill Год назад

What video, this post tastes like SPAM.

@gi70st Год назад

@@inyobill what does spam taste like? I cant say i've ever eaten it, and I dont think I know anyone who has either

@inyobill Год назад

@@gi70st Spam, spam, spam, spam, Spam, spam, spam spam, Spammity Spam!!! (Monty Python, in the off chance you're not a fan). I've eaten it, I hear it's a thing in Canada. Yah, IMHO, you can give it a pass without missing anything.

@gi70st Год назад

@@inyobill so...not good as a food but perfect for launching at that french guy on the castle wall

@inyobill Год назад

@@gi70st LOL, just about. "Why do you think I have this outrageous accent, you silly king?"