Тёмный

Lore of Middle-earth - Helm's Deep 

Arachîr Galudirithon
Подписаться 55 тыс.
Просмотров 27 тыс.
50% 1

A dive into the lore of Middle-earth presented as a (sort of) podcast.
To download the episode as a sound file, please visit Patreon below. Note, the download is free and you do not need to be a patron:
/ galudirithon
To discuss the episode in more detail, please visit Discord:
/ discord
Music provide by Adrian von Ziegler and Vindsvept:
/ adrianvonziegler
/ @vindsvept

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

29 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 55   
4 года назад
I forgot to mention that Gimli leads a small band of Dwarves to the Glittering Caves after the War of the Ring and a small enclave is established there. Their ultimate fate is supposed to be the same of all Dwarves: to fade into myth.
@jgoldberg9489
@jgoldberg9489 4 года назад
Excellent podcast , If i may , I'd very much like to listen to your old lore videos again , would you be so kind as to post me with a link to the hidden playlist ? Thank you
4 года назад
@@jgoldberg9489 ru-vid.com/group/PLesZst-z4ywZSrEMa1ybHWhNXfxZivH0W
@jgoldberg9489
@jgoldberg9489 4 года назад
@ Le athae mellon
@amatthew1231
@amatthew1231 4 года назад
Gotta admit though the Elves fighting on the Deeping wall was very cool. The music was perfect, I'm glad we got to see elves fight on screen where they are done justice. The brief clash with the Dwarves in the Hobbit was so incredibly stupid.
@saikatnaskar2266
@saikatnaskar2266 4 года назад
@ arachir galudirithon, please dont stop your middle earth lore videos....they are the best by far that we are blessed with....thank you so much!
@edragondale9222
@edragondale9222 4 года назад
I do remember reading somewhere, I'll have to find it, that while the Uruk-Hai were present at the battle/siege of Helms Deep, there weren't that many compared to the regular Orcs and Dunlandings who took up a majority of the army, it's my opinion and thought that they were the elite/heavy troops and commanders of the army, since that is what they were initially bred for. But then again it is hard to tell since Tolkien did sort of skim over the battles.
@mycaleb8
@mycaleb8 4 года назад
If I remember correctly, Tolkien just uses the term "orc" to refer both the normal breeds and the Uruk-Hai. The truth is likely that there's very little real difference. Uruks are just slightly taller, slightly stronger, and strong against the sun.
@edragondale9222
@edragondale9222 4 года назад
@@mycaleb8 That may have been the case, if I do remember correctly the Uruk-hai (or rather Uruks in general) had normal human legs compared to their orc kin who were said to have bowed legs, but it is fun to discuss this because I do like your side to it
@nikoszaxarias5200
@nikoszaxarias5200 4 года назад
You are absolutely right. Actually, Saruman masters the Orc tribes of the southern parts of Moria, accompanied with Orc breeds that he creates. So, we will be propably right to hink that Uruk-hais are the elite troops and the regular Orcs are the workhorses and the backbone of the army. That makes 10.000. As for the number, in the chapter that Merry and Pippin talk to Aragorn and Gandalf when they meet in Orthanc's walls, Merry describes how the Ents reach the Nan Curunir right in time for the departure of Saruman's army. He clearly describes the departure "ten thousand or more", who go either to the western side of the river or pass through a bridge over Isen. That's for answer to Galu's question.
@edragondale9222
@edragondale9222 4 года назад
@@nikoszaxarias5200 But then there is also the question of how many were at Helm's Deep before Erkenbrand and Gandalf arrive, it's been a awhile since I read the books but i do believe all together there were around 3000 maybe 3500 men of Rohan at Helm's deep, and if so they do a decent job against a force that's at least three times it's size, and we're talking about a Calvary based nation when it comes to warfare
@nikoszaxarias5200
@nikoszaxarias5200 4 года назад
@@edragondale9222 , the answer lies to the mathematics of sieges. It is measured that in a siege, the attacker's numerical advantage must be 4 to 1 or even 5 to 1 to achieve a good victory, because the fortifications and the ladders of the infantry cost many lives for the attacker. The rams provide only limited protection- and all this without archers, who multiply the impact in favour of the defender. So the Orcs, with their 3 to 1 numerical advantage, couldn't have a decisive advantage compared to Rohirrim, not even taking into account that Helm's Deep was a strong fort, with good and thick walls, very good supplies and a full armory for many hundreds of men. But we have to admit that Tolkien, who is linguist, has little or no knowledge concerning medieval warfare, that's why his novels show an overbalanced feature of warfare of each nation.
@Omnesomm2
@Omnesomm2 4 года назад
Amazingly informative and wonderfully presented as always!
@giovannicolombini95
@giovannicolombini95 4 года назад
It's lunch time , After the morning spent at the university . Now sit back relax and enjoy a Galu Video :)
@Rintse
@Rintse 4 года назад
Absolutely love these. Never stop.
@imperatorglaber1752
@imperatorglaber1752 4 года назад
The brief but epic charge of the elves into the breach was one of my fav moments of the film
@ciaran_mcghee_music
@ciaran_mcghee_music 4 года назад
You are the real MVP I have a long hall flight today and this is exactly what I need.
@axelhyltan
@axelhyltan 4 года назад
Gamling directly translate in swedish to old. So for a swedish person his name would be old the old.
@dehavillandvampire8397
@dehavillandvampire8397 4 года назад
Well, it would be more like 'Old man the old', as 'Gamling' is more used for describing 'Old person'. Definetly glad I'm not the only one who picked up on this though.
@justsometimber1nthelake873
@justsometimber1nthelake873 4 года назад
Divide 4 dev diary,? Eazy love your videos
@hunsler1006
@hunsler1006 4 года назад
Got to say, Rohan doesn't receive much love from DAC so I'm really enjoying this Rohan content atm in the lord videos
@cesare.lopezelll8122
@cesare.lopezelll8122 4 года назад
Great lore as always, though what about Gimil and the dwarfs that he led to the glittering cave to start a colony after the war??
@drtoastnbake8688
@drtoastnbake8688 4 года назад
The COOM
@bertsmulders1173
@bertsmulders1173 4 года назад
Epic, gimme more of those pleas sir!
@povilzem
@povilzem 4 года назад
So cavalry in the lore is just as overpowered as it is in DaC? Nice.
@samuelbostwick382
@samuelbostwick382 4 года назад
Galu! I absolutely love your lore videos and listen to them all them time as I work! Could I get the link to the old videos? Please and thank you! Keep up the awesome work!
@otwk
@otwk 4 года назад
"Helm! Helm! Helm is arisen and comes back to war! Helm for Théoden King!"
@boobacockaa
@boobacockaa 4 года назад
How in the name of Eru does this only have ~8,900 views? RU-vid's bullshit algorithm leaves much to be desired. Extremely high quality, as usual.
@sternonisoil
@sternonisoil 4 года назад
Woo-hoo, time to bask in more glorious lore. Thank you much
@BernddasBrotB7
@BernddasBrotB7 4 года назад
I would argue regarding the culvert that there was probably a metal grate that sappers either removed it in the chaos or slipped underwater through it if it had degraded and that had somehow missed attention. On the note of Théoden's charge, the gate being blown up by a second bomb at the end of Aragorn's speech is when he orders it.
@nathanw6159
@nathanw6159 4 года назад
I saw in a recent stream you mentions a hidden playlist of the old lore videos? Any way I could see them? Absolutely love these videos
@tremoxo
@tremoxo 4 года назад
He mentions the hidden playlist in the 40,000 Subscriber Special stream. Hope its ok for me to post the link here. I love these videos too. ru-vid.com/group/PLesZst-z4ywZSrEMa1ybHWhNXfxZivH0W
@nathanw6159
@nathanw6159 4 года назад
@@tremoxo appreciated, I just don't know of any way to contact him if he doesn't see the comment lol
@karrackhalcyon8826
@karrackhalcyon8826 4 года назад
I think the key distinctions between film and books are in the details of the uruk hai vs human soldier dichotomy. In the books human soldiers were quite capable of killing 10+ orc/uruks to a man, which isnt as scary/dramatic on film if basically every rank a file rohirrim looks like a superhero. So jackson inflated their capabilities to be more menacing, and so needed a more significant force for the good guys. Also i believe the actor who played haladir had asked if there was a way to have more screen time, and show off the elves more, because he enjoyed the role.
@devoidofvoltz2562
@devoidofvoltz2562 3 года назад
I feel like I have to disagree with you on the subject of elves: their arrival and subsequent death is highly symbolic of the Third Age in general that dosent neccesarily lessen the impact of Rohan. The elves are very clearly portrayed as fading, a shadow of the force that could once gather hosts to challenge Sauron. Its also noteworthy that the elves are only ever shown during the night time sequence, fighting under the stars and by the time that the sun rises (symbolizing a new age) that only men and orcs are left in the battlefield to in balance.
@daisygowanditchburn4844
@daisygowanditchburn4844 4 года назад
It is interesting that you mention the power of cavalry within the works of Tolkien. It reminds me of something I heard, potentially within the special features of the films, but potentially elsewhere. The story goes that Tolkien himself was much put out by the Norman conquest of 1066 (as someone who is descended from Norman knights Tolkien and I take different views on this matter). In particular Tolkien believed that it was the Norman cavalry that was the deciding factor and had the Anglo-Saxons their own cavalry they could have won. The Rohirrim are clearly derived from the Anglo-Saxons and in essence represent the very Anglo-Saxons who would have been able to win the Battle of Hastings. Now I would not go so far as to place equivalence between Isengard and the Normans. Rather than being analogous to historical events the strength of the Rohirrim cavalry is representative of Tolkien's (over)estimation of the real historical power of cavalry. Tolkien's belief that an Anglo-Saxon force with a strong cavalry component could have reversed the outcome of the Norman invasion of 1066 is reflected in the ability of Rohan to fight off the overwhelming force of Isengard. At least that's what I would put forward based on Tolkien's opinion.
@narcisoferreira9976
@narcisoferreira9976 4 года назад
You use the word over-estimation but you really shouldnt because in talkien's work the cav is used has a potent killing force yes but its more of a moral thing for example at the battle of pelenor fields the army of mordor buckles under the charge of Rohan and Imrahil because seeing what is essentially a bulke of muscle coming straight at you is really freaking scary I dont know about you but if I see a horse charging me im running the fuck away, plus if you apply this logic to the battle of helms deep where in the books the attackers are beaten back at the dyke or wall (cant remember) by a sudden volley of arrows imagine what people on horseback suddenly bursting forth from what you tought was basically a conquered fortress might damper your morale
@andreastveranger1331
@andreastveranger1331 4 года назад
To put it like this. The conflict between Rohan and Dunland started when the ancestors of Theoden drove out the dunlendings that had already settled half of the land. Of course it didn't get any better when Helm killed Freca
@gabe1597
@gabe1597 4 года назад
Yay
@Monkismo
@Monkismo 4 года назад
Also known as Helm's Holler! :-)
@geirmoen2555
@geirmoen2555 4 года назад
Fun fact: Gamling simply means "old person" in Norwegian
@gawinthegrey7667
@gawinthegrey7667 4 года назад
After this video I will start Rohan campaign in DAC :D
@deadsalmon4115
@deadsalmon4115 4 года назад
So what you are telling me is Tolkien's cavalry is med 2 cavalry.
@spamhonx56
@spamhonx56 4 года назад
no, because they can dismount.
@gnarddawg7606
@gnarddawg7606 4 года назад
*Plug the hole in the deeping wall* *the water rises* *unplug in the hole when the uruks attacks* "Break the dam! Release the river!"
@otwk
@otwk 4 года назад
Well, technically Helm is a murderer - he killed Freca, which led to the whole war in the first place.
@dannyjames8894
@dannyjames8894 4 года назад
he was seen as a lad though so no one cares about that.
@salmanhyder1655
@salmanhyder1655 4 года назад
❤️😮
@David-qm2qj
@David-qm2qj 4 года назад
Could it be that Tolkin had very pessimistic spin on genetics and phenotypes ? Everytime he metions the Numenorian line in history and their Genetics its always : inbreeding = strong, noble, advanced refreshing the gene pool = weakness , watering the blood , degeneration As if all good Numenorian phenotypes would be rezessive and weak.
@otwk
@otwk 4 года назад
Firstly, I wouldn't call it "inbreeding" - there's quite a lot of Numenoreans, indeed an entire nation; and actually when Ar-Pharazon forces his cousin to marry him, that's seen as especially evil (except by his supporters of course, which admittedly are most of the Numenorians). Secondly, not all phenotypes would have to be rezessive, the "watering of the blood" happens over time. And since the Numenoreans are superhuman, they basically become normal humans over time, which is certainly bad for the most part. And lastly, it's shown at various times (especially in the story of Eldacar), that this mingling with other "races" of men has many advantages, and indeed the thought of Numenorean supremacy is what leads to their downfall.
@lowlandnobleman6746
@lowlandnobleman6746 4 года назад
Tolkien had a more humble view of genetics. He wasn’t particularly prejudiced against anyone, but he also didn’t obsess over diversity like modern people usually do. He seems to emphasize the destructive influence on one’s lineage if they mixed too much or too little.
@David-qm2qj
@David-qm2qj 4 года назад
@@otwk Excellent points dear Sir. I would would like to elaborate my postion. 1. Inbreeding: I meant the gene pool of the entire Numenorian population in contrast to Man. Where Numenorian traits can only be retained by breeding 2 Numenorians. Where a mixture results e.g. in directly lowering the lifespan. 2. Watering the Blood: lets lay out the "good" traits of the Numenorians which are observeable: -great Height -long life -capability of creating advanced society.* *e.g. building Minas thirith black wall, or Sarumans tower. trough breeding, with the "normal" Man, over time, every single of this Traits gets reduced to "normal" values. Even simple Mendel Genetics would refute this logic though. Especially if the Traits would make the phenotype very successful. 3. Numenorian supremacy I cant completly agree with you on this. The pure Numenorians from Dol Amroth are especially described noble, pure and all good. There was no sign of moral sin.
@blinkrush6101
@blinkrush6101 4 года назад
And then Helm became a ring wraith /s
@albertknabe3713
@albertknabe3713 4 года назад
Here it is today - imgur.com/gallery/AbieNCU Yes, Middle Earth is, er was, real...
Далее
Lore of Middle-earth - The Nazgûl
30:31
Просмотров 53 тыс.
Lore of Middle-earth: Legolas & Gimli
25:18
Просмотров 45 тыс.
skibidi toilet multiverse 039 (part 1)
05:29
Просмотров 3,9 млн
когда повзрослела // EVA mash
00:40
Просмотров 2,4 млн
Ummmm We "HAIR" You!
00:59
Просмотров 8 млн
Lore & DaC: Nation Histories - Bree-land & The Shire
24:23
Battle of Helm's Deep - Middle-Earth Lore DOCUMENTARY
16:47
Stories of the Nazgûl - Balak'nar Sunfire
13:49
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Lore of Middle-earth - The Shire
24:52
Просмотров 21 тыс.
Lore of Middle-earth - Isengard
35:21
Просмотров 36 тыс.
Middle-earth Lorecast - 03, Arnor, Part 1
28:27
Просмотров 25 тыс.
Stories of the Nazgûl - Shi-vuus, the Desert Sand
18:23
Stories of the Nazgûl - Gan Altan the Honoured
9:54
Было?😂
0:12
Просмотров 1,3 млн