At the e-waste due to modular components part I genuinely laughed out loud. What about the entire computer becoming e-waste because of the non-modular part? lol
One of those folks tried to argue with me that the socket was a point of failure and would cause more computers to be thrown in the trash. Like huh? Since when did SOCKETS fail more often than SSDs? That thread is basically 2 + 2 = 5 at this point.
@@whytho1690 They're still going at it too. They claimed Louis Rossman was a clueless conspiracy theorist having armchair opinions from his couch. Like, last I checked, Louis Rossman had a successful repair business for 15+ years, pretty sure that means he's probably not a clueless conspiracy theorist who just gets paid to write opinions from his couch.
Even in case of failure of a modular component it is so easy to change it for another with similar specifications (or if you want to be religious for one of the same) They would be as easy as disconnecting and connecting again, it even enables dual use or secondary use, It is the "R" of recycling what Apple preaches so much 🤯
"I've never been in a car accident, so cars without seatbelts or airbags are actually good. This is all because of Big Seatbelt!" Though the analogy isn't perfect, as this is more about preserving your goods than yourself in an accident.
"I've driven for 30 years speeding and never had an issue" cant count how many times I've bashed people for speeding and this was their response, one of my cousins said the same thing a few weeks before he plowed into a tree going 70, earned his darwin award
Some people literally do not get it. Louis will be happy under two conditions: 1) His shop gets the chips he needs to perform repairs which are otherwise impossible without them. 2) His shop is no longer necessary. Louis is in that awful middle-ground where he wants to help based on principle, even if it is no longer any fun for him to do so. There's no more magic in what he does, but the problems continue to amass and _somebody's gotta do it_ so why not him and his shop? Louis advocates for his obsolescence every single day of the week. Apple continues to find ways of making his shop _not_ obsolete. They'd knee-cap a lot of less-capable shops if they just made the battery replaceable for pete sake. But instead, Apple chooses violence. And the people steps behind Apple have to pick up the pieces when their violence interferes with somebody else's life, whenever it is possible to do so.
Not sure I follow your comment about Louis shop becoming not obsolete. Apple is succeeding in achieving the exact opposite by making shite non repairable ⚠️
If something is a conspiracy theory, that doesn't make it false. I think the dumbest conspiracy theories are spread on purpose to discredit the true ones. It's like "What do you mean you think the government is lying about the JFK assassination? Do you also think the moon landing is fake too?"
I do miss the motherboard soldering videos where you'd talk about whatever. Watching you repair motherboards was lik watching an ASMR video, I found it therapeutic and interresting.
I found his channel not long ago, and i love listening to him, because he thinks very fast, without "uh"s or stutters, and very accurately also helps he has a pleasant voice, a great mic, and incredible amounts of experience, and very good problem solving skills
Not really any different than wearing a brand name t shirt etc. Free advertising for a corporation for a cheap ass product. Simping for Apple, Musk is just an extension of wearing the gear.
I never thought linking your video to the forums would blow up like that. I even got accused of creating a new account to pimp your channel, even though I've had a macrumors account since 2008. I actually loved macbooks back in the day, and I wish Apple would stop doing crap like the SSD soldering.
Welcome to what I like to call "Internet bravery". Folks love to insult folks from the safety of their armchairs, comfortable knowing they will never have to actually face the person or persons they are insulting.
This, and the thing is it is extremely common now. In fact, it is more rare to find people who don’t tie their identity to brands. Consumerism is a hell of a drug.
@@ElJosher I am sure a consumer zombie, but I don't care about brands. I'll buy whatever is the best that I can and want to afford. Which is why I have a MacBook (it's the most power efficient) and a PC with a RTX3090 and an Intel-based old NAS.
My favorite part is how many accuse Louis of being a conspiracy theorist while conspiracy theorizing themselves that he is in it only to make money as a parasite. Keep up the great work, Louis, you're a good dude.
Only tangentially relevant but Nissan quoted me £900 to repair the touchscreen in my car. I did it myself for £15 + 40 mins of my time. Just telling everyone coz I'm rather pleased with myself and self-repair rocks.
Dealerships are some of the worst in the game. At least the stuff is repairable by consumers but they make a lot of their money on repair nowadays rather than actual car sales
Suzuki wanted to charge my uncle like 150 bucks for a replacement of the main windows controller on his Vitara which wasn't working properly, I fixed it for 0$ with a contact cleaner and a tooth brush, it now works like a charm, it just had dirty contacts.
American in a nutshell (yeah that's me generalising, I know). A brand that provide zero value like SUPREME has no place outside US. European would buy a good quality Chinese EV without a second look at the most valuable car brand, Tesla.
There is no successful person in history that did not have haters. If only the haters had valid points. Most just hurl insults,invalidating their opinions further.
This is just sad! These comments are just brand loyalty for the sake of it at best all the way down to unhinged at worst! Keep doing what you are doing, Louis! I personally appreciate your honesty and educational content!
As someone whose workflow compliments Apple products and simply prefers macOS in general, everything Louis has been talking about is still 100% valid. I left a comment like this a few years back but I’ll say it again, I’d you’re deep in the Apple ecosystem you should be MORE aligned with what Louis is talking about, because you have so much more to gain from changes, and so much more to lose from things continuing as they are. I use a lot of Apple stuff for my own reasons, so I definitely am in favor of Apple making better products, so I can have better products to do my work on in the future. It seems so cut and dry I don’t understand why anyone using this stuff on the daily would protest someone advocating for a better design.
msot people anti-RtR, myself included, aren't advocating on the basis of design at all. Most people are just on the defensive because government agenices keep using the pathos of repairability to push legislation. (of course I doubt many of the Apple Fanbois actually recognize why it is their arguing and would happily go on for hours about the design, but I don't think their actual reasoning has to do with it at all) I was all for early RtR when it was about consumer education and empowerment, encouraging you to look at the devices you buy and decide whether they respected you or not, etc. but now it's just an excuse to jack off Uncle Sam. (or I guess John Bull given it's mainly the EU) It's no longer "Apple is fucking you over, here's proof, don't accept it" it's "you're powerless, you just HAVE to keep buying their products! You simply don't have a choice! You're too fucking stupid to pick products that you actually want and are happy with, don't worry little baby, we'll pass more legislation, it's just a little bit more, what are you some kind of corporate bootlicker?". In fact, there is even a quote I remember from one of those earlier videos (I believe it was in his "think different" video years ago that went over the chronic issues Apple has had with their computers that routinely lead to them killing themselves) where he outright said "I've seen other companies do this, and the consumer is always furious and says 'I'm never buying from this company again how could they do something like this' but for Apple they just shrug and leave". That quote perfectly exemplifies what early RtR actually was, pointing at that and going "hey you uh, you don't seem to be looking out for your best interests here". Meanwhile, again, modern RtR is just "big companies bad, give government more power." I'd rather have a company that makes products I can CHOOSE to let fuck me over willingly, than a government that WILL fuck me over whether I want it to or not. I don't care whether Apple's products are shit because I don't use them, and despite what *_some_* individuals say "everyone" does not copy Apple. The big players do because, surprise surprise, consumers don't give a shit and buy the newest Apple crap the moment it comes out, but there are always smaller competitors and, even among the big players, they often have more accessible alternatives too. RtR stopped being about consumer empowerment and became about government empowerment.
Big agree here. I’ve got a workflow that, for better or worse, is dependent on tools that are mac exclusive or just better on MacOS (looking at you, Scrivener). I’m forever frustrated how my M1 Pro is less serviceable than my 2015 pro, that’s less serviceable than the 2012 pro I got given recently. Stuff should be repairable and easy to work on. So what if it adds a few MM to a design or a few pennies in the long run? It will be.l vastly cheaper overall both for my pocket and for the planet in the long run because I can keep old machines in service (see my 2015 pro) longer.
Hey Lewis I think I came up with a pretty good analogy about the SSD Issue. the bios SSD it's kind of like putting the main supporrt beam of your house on a bookshelf. if the bookshelf breaks then the entire house comes crumbling down and you have to build a new house. Rather than replacing the bookshelf or getting another bookshelf. also the bookshelf is made of sub par material meaning it's not a question of if the bookshelf is going to break but when.
Mac “rumors”, complaining about “conspiracy” while pushing conspiracy. This is a very classic example of cognitive dissonance and psychological projection.
@@johndoh5182 That whole thread is filled with ad hominem after ad hominem after ad hominem. Even after being directly called out multiple times, they still double down. There are some reasonable ones in there too, but most of them are just turning it into a dumpster disaster of logical fallacies. It’s almost on the edge of being a tad bit cult like tbh. 😂
@@johndoh5182 there’s a really good example of MSM saying Russia is running out of ammo for the last 500 days while Russia has launched the largest attacks of the Ukraine War in the last month while WSJ admits the US is out of artillery shells. I do agree that China projects a lot though, the US and China do copy eachother a lot.
Wait, so they go through all the mental gymnastics to justyfy soldered SSDs as a security feature to prevent hackers getting access and intercepting data, yet when questioned about data loss their solution is that everyone should backup their data to external ssds and cloud storage? so removable external SSDs are safe enough for an exact copy but not the original?
Just try and remember it is all marketing. Look at the "Bit Wars" of the 1980's and 1990's. The marketing was phenomenal. It was all smoke and mirrors, and it worked. Same thing today with apple vs whoever.
In a 30+ year IT career I've been a purchasing officer for Govt and NGOs many times. This is a job that was required in Australia to do ethically and consider many options. Apple always fell off the list by round 2 for various reasons.
nah, fake news. Consumers can't educate themselves and weight their purchases based on relevant features that they value like repairability, freedom, etc. After all, If they could, how could I justify why I keep buying the newest Apple shit while constantly whinging about it to get the EU to pass more legislation? I'm a victim doncha know! I just couldn't help but buy the newest iPhone, I didn't have a choice you see! I need protections!
Someone called you a huxter?! I've been orking in manufacturing for over 20 years. I can confirm you give solid repair advice that goes beyond the training I've had over the years. You're a very good repair guy.
It's pointless to respond to these people. They aren't actually listening, they hear negative things being said about product/a company they like, they slap the keyboard in a fit. They aren't actually watching or listening to the video, you provide pretty solid evidence to these problems and reasons why it's bad and if someone is saying it's just hate- but has NO reasoning to follow that up with? They're not listening. They're just upset that you're calling the product flawed. They're not going to watch this vid and if they do? They'll click through it and make more pointless rage comments without the context because they didn't watch it. They don't care about what you're saying, so don't give them a reply they're not going to listen to anyway. This is an open and closed case with the SSD, there's nothing to even argue about. What benefit does a soldered on SSD have for the customer? Why would someone want this? Is it cheaper? No. Is it better built? No it's the same. Does it go against universal standards? Yes. Is it harder to repair? Yes. Will this effect every customer? No- but the fact that it can effect you and that a defect or just using the device means the entire mobo is fried means it's objectively worse as a design regardless of anything else. Your entire mobo must be replaced instead of swapping out a single part- there's NOTHING GOOD in this design change. There's nothing beneficial, how is this even something someone is going to defend? Again- it's brand loyalty. I don't care what brand I bought- if they did something that makes the product worse? It's a bad idea and it's not something we should support.
I think it is clear they are not ready to accept the help, so any attempts to help them are impossible. They need to overcome the challenges which lead them to identify so strongly with a company which deserves most of the criticism it gets.
I agree that a lot of the people shown in this video aren’t actually listening. They are essentially hell bent on opposing Rossmann/the Right to Repair movement for whatever reason and their arguments clearly work backwards from that premise. However, I think responding to them serves a very important purpose. It’s not so much about trying to change their minds, they’ve shown through their disingenuous arguments that they aren’t open to that. Rather, it’s about trying to prevent those who are less knowledgeable about the topic from falling for said disingenuous arguments. The falsity of their arguments might be obvious to you or me, but some of them may actually sound convincing to someone new to the space who doesn’t know much about Rossmann or the Right to Repair movement. Here is a personal example; I had an exchange on Reddit with someone who was trying to assassinate Rossmann’s character by claiming he is a Trump supporter and has horrible takes on abortion. My role in that exchange wasn’t to try to change that person’s mind, there was clearly a very low chance of that happening considering he was outright spreading misinformation about Rossmann. My role was to press him to back up his claims and point out that he can’t because Rossmann has never publicly stated his opinion on abortion and has made multiple comments suggesting he isn’t a fan of Trump. To me, it was obvious that person was trying to spread misinformation, but it might not be obvious to someone who doesn’t know much about Rossmann. If my comments encouraged even one person not to take that misinformation at face value and look up what Rossmann actually stands for, than I consider it a win.
Something that has not been mentioned by anyone I don't think: I am a recently retired software engineer that actually started a career in electronics in the early 1980s. I have worked for companies like Hewlett Packard, Micron, Microsoft and others. Each time I found that "engineers" in the company became "knowledge silos" nothing was properly documented and you had to try and get them to release information to you if and when they felt this was to their advantage. They were political animals that wanted to ensure foremost that they would be unreplaceable and they would exercise their power by nixing subordinate employees that may have a good idea if it did not work in with their ploys. In this environment things happen based on the greed of the company that is only concerned with making maximum profits building in obsolescence and political issues within the organization and the consumers are only thought of when the advertisements are created in marketing the product. Making them repairable will be far removed from the designers of the product. Right now the situation with most consumer electronics is that if it lasts a few years that is good enough and they can just buy a new one. In fact if left to their own devices they will even be tempted to ensure a product will fail in a year or two to maximize profits...
3:43 I see repairability this way; If it's an actual step forward for the user (breaks less, uses less power, allows for a less cumbersome form factor, etc...) but is also more difficult to repair, that's fine. The technicians will just have to get good. If it serves no reasonable purpose and makes it more difficult to repair (like curved edge phone screens and glued batteries [yes, I know it makes the phone thinner, but they didn't really need to be as thin as they are so the purpose is barely even cosmetic]) then it should be advocated against. Basically, the increased difficulty needs to serve some kind of positive purpose for the end customer for me to not be annoyed at it.
@@genericscottishchannel1603 potentially but then you have to think about where those tabs are going to attach and how strong that will be and what else is there in the way. It's not impossible, but also not the point. The removable battery smart phones had decent life and were not thick to the point of being unusable. How thin smartphones are now doesn't really serve any practical purpose
Glued batteries does not make it thinner It's more or less because they don't want it friction fitted like the older phones, or it'll be like that one samsung phone that blew up
@@CreativityNull not potentially, it is absolutely the fucking case. where would they attach? well most batteries are set on one side or across the majority of a phones width, Im sure you can fill in the rest
When i first found out that SSD was soldered, i knew right away this was a bad choice. After researching various articles and repair review videos, it only confirmed how much worst is actually is. Security is important but it's not an excuse. After taking a look at Lenovo website i learned that they are also doing soldered SSD storage and soldered ram.
I loved apple computers before they became glorified iPhones. I can not, for the life of me, understand why people are so anxious to bend over and spread their cheeks for Apple. Thousands of dollars for a non repairable computer.
These are the same dummies that would pay hundreds if not thousands of dollars for a generic looking bag with the Louie Vuitton logo on it or ugly Yeezy shoes. They are not paying for a computer, they are paying for the brand or the social flex.
100% social flex. Everyone I've ever known who liked Apple didnt know computers and most often didnt know how anything in life actually worked. One Apple nut I used to know was flabbergasted when he went to a destination wedding in South Africa and saw they had highways and infrastructure. Like he was expecting grass huts and everything made out of dirt. Completely ignorant and removed from the real world.
12:20 people need to understand that just because it didn’t happen to them doesn’t mean it’s not a wide spread issue, even if only 1 out every 100 ssds in macs fail, that’s a wide spread issue and millions of people would be effected
Two quick tips for you if you're going to be the tech support Andrew Tate: 1) Don't pick a fight with a Swedish 19-20 year old on social media. 2) Always recycle your pizza boxes.
"I can't disregard people's experiences" I can and will: Personal experience does not dictate facts.. When you're doing repairs, you have (or should have) a bit more of an objective view over durability of products... Especially when you specialise in specific brands... I have to tell myself this quite a bit when I have bad experiences with a product, but others around me don't.. Sometimes it's just down to luck.. Luck being a chance taken personal...
This is where the superior Australian Consumer Law here works so well if you know how to use it. It covers items beyond the warranty and is based on the expected life of the device. I've had items replaced after warranty had expired because of this law. Other countries need to implement laws like this. And this might push certain companies to sort out issues much faster. Australian Consumer Law far outweighs the manufacturers warranty or guarantee. Works for a phone, a car, a computer, a blender, a house or building and everything else. It all works on the expected life of the product.
or you could just encourage customers to take accountability and buy from companies that respect them. But no, keep giving Apple money, I'm sure that'll solve the problem. God forbid we NOT give the government more power and just encourage individual agency and problem solving.
@@grantleyhughesUnless you outright lied about what it does, I really don't. Consumers don't need protections, they need a fucking education. These are populations of grown functioning adults with jobs and cars and loans and houses and we are treating them like children. If your nation has such a poor education system that it produces adults who can't be trusted to look after their own interests and purchase products that are fairly priced, respect them, robust, etc. then the issue isn't the warranties it's your education system. It is not secret information that Apple products are locked down, unrepairable, and generally shitty; everyone knows it, so either A : they choose to accept those restrictions willingly and you have no right to impose shit because it's a private transaction between two informed consenting parties who understand it fully or B : they're too stupid to look after their own interests, and a government that needs to pass laws to protect it's citizens from their own stupidity has outright failed. For that matter, if you agree that it's best not to give Apple money, then uh, small question, why are you claiming it's good when a law disincentivizes people to switch away? Why would I care about repairability if, by law, I can just get a shiny brand new macbook if my current one dies? I have zero incentive to buy from Framework or System76 or any other company that gives a shit if the government has an outright mandated warranty-esque protection in place. If you agree that consumers should stop giving money to Apple, then supporting legislation which removes the penalty and risk from doing just that isn't exactly consistent.
@@robonator2945 it doesn't give the government more power, except in the sense that gov IT departments can also use that law against manufacturers selling faulty gear to get a replacement or refund.
@@Skasaha_ it literally gives the government the power to apply a legal penalty against an organization for doing a thing. That is definitionally more power. Companies can no longer say "we are making this as a product to do X, it will do X, we are ensuring only that it will do X" and consumers can no longer say "I want a device that does X, I want it to do X, and I do not care that it only does X" because if they *_do_* then the government can step in and say "nuh uh, that thing should actually do Y too!" In a purchase the consumer is agreeing to the terms of the warranty, everyone involved agrees "this is at least how long the thing should last", except now the government can step in and demand that be changed. This not only limits the options of what companies can sell and consumers can buy, but it *_also_* means that consumers have less of an incentive to buy well made products that they expect to last for a long time and have a long warranty. So what if it breaks, there are government protections! Thereby not only limiting options and giving the government more power over what you as a consumer are allowed to buy "for your own good" but actually incentivizing purchases of less reliable products. Causality doesn't die after 1 generation, every action the government takes *_will_* be reacted to. Do you seriously think Apple just isn't going to care that they're not getting royalties on lightning accessories anymore? or instead do you think they're going to try to use other methods of increasing profits to account for that, such as raising prices? I'm going to take it as a given that actually stating the answer to that question is unnecessary and stating it as if it isn't obvious is in fact a quite significant insult to the inteligence of everyone here. So, great, now Apple has raised prices (or done something else to make more money to compensate for the lost revenue) and even if you as a consumer did not care at all about the lightning port, you're suffering because the government decided they have the right to dictate what port you're allowed to have on your phone. Or, and hear me out, people who give a shit can just buy from someone else and people who don't can keep buying an iphone. Crazy idea I know, but maybe, juuuuust maybe, I think if you didn't buy an iPhone, it not having the port you like wouldn't affect you. Similarly I have a sneaking suspicion that if you simply don't buy things with short warranties, those short warranties won't affect you either. I know, I know, absolutely crazy idea, I'm not even entirely sure how it'd work, but I have a gut feeling that just not buying it might help here. Conversely, if a product has a feature or set of features you *_do_* like, buying that product might actually make your life better! Oh no wait, shit, I forgot, "voting with your wallet is a myth" damnit. Budlight, Framework, Fairphone and the entire fucking MCU right now. (along with Star Wars, AAA games studios, etc. I mean honestly how people even pretend to take this seriously with this man slow motion car crashes around them is beyond me) Oh wait how did those get there? I mean those are completely irrelevant! It's not like Framework is a brand new company that sells computers consistently above MSRP for equivalently specced competition (with their most recent 16 inch model being ~1000usd above equal-spec) yet have taken off and grown rapidly over the few years they've been around in spite of that because people like their products and the features they offer! Seriously, just stop buying shit products. You can't buy a pile of dog shit, roll around it in it, complain that you stink, and demand other people pay for some soap so you can take a shower. These are the consequences of your actions, the products *_you_* purchased. No-one else must have their choices limited or have even more money stolen from their bank accounts because you refuse to buy decent products.
This people who tried to take down Louis Rossmann on the Mac rumors forum are the same Apple fanboys that defend typical apple moves like invalidating perfectly working third party displays for newer iPhones or making the 1st gen appple pencil charge via the iPad's charging port making it look like a Popsicle stick. Apple fanboys are some of the worse consumers out there in my opinion.
This reminds me of the Tech Reviewers who were happy that "iPhones finally had ultra zoom camera". Cough cough Krystal Lora and Jonathan Morrison cough cougb
I used to be an apple fanboy... then I found out that with android I could actually have "MY" phone. Not apples phone. Have been and will be a lifelong android user. I will also say to people that if all they want is simplicity in a decent package, go with apple. If you want an absolute powerhouse, with lots of customizability go high end android.
Nobody worries about an SSD failure... until they have an SSD failure. The thing about luck is it only exists in past tense, bad luck can strike at any time.
@@simdaydreamer5239 They might, but doesn't mean they will for sure. For mechanical drives, any disk analysis tool will be able to show you issues that might indicate your drive is about to die way before you start to see any symptoms.
my SSD died but it was within warranty so they replaced it when I brought the thing to the shop, they were surprised because this was their first case of a SSD failing. they had cases of HDD failing but not SSD
What makes me laugh most when people complain about your videos… Is that even someone that could be considered an apple/Mac “fan boy” like tech reviewer Luke Miani, completely agree with your statements. So a lot of these “complaints”, If not all of them, are without basis or reason. Keep doing your thing, Louis! ❤🙌
I have a System76, but what I say is true of other laptops: SSD can be replaced in about five minutes (I have done it quite a few times as I play with different OSs). The battery is easily replaced. Takes maybe 15 minutes (there is an adhesive so the first battery replacement takes a little while). The WiFi / Bluetooth transceiver is a tiny bit fussy to replace due connectors, but it costs $8. Replacement cracked left CTRL key: free. Takes about 1 minute to replace. This is what I want.
"Mostly young men" (implied: autists in the basement). I just watched a video by an environmentalist talking about consumerism and there were people in the comments talking about right to repair. It has gone beyond the autists in the basement now. Normal people who care about the environment see how more and more stuff is being thrown away because it is harder to repair, and realize the problem.
Call me an ***hole, I don't care about the environment all that much, but I am angry at having to buy a whole damn laptop, just because the friggin onboard SSD died. I mean wtf? If I design hardware or software, I always try to ensure components can be sourced and the software is open source. The latter is important to me, because I don't trust a corporation to update their software because of errors.
Thanks for the phrasing that gives me an internal conflict between taking mild personal offense and agreeing with the overall meaning of your comment. Very cool.
@@jessicav2031 This is actually one of the best things about the Right to Repair movement. It has bipartisan support because it’s important to people across the political spectrum for different reasons. Whether your main concern is reducing e-waste or enhancing product repairability and property rights, Right to Repair helps advance all of it.
I love being able to repair my stuff. I still have my old ass dryer up and running that I bought 2nd hand for $50 over a decade ago. It is really satisfying fixing things.
Hey Louis! I have been watching your video for years and love the content. Also, congrats on getting out of that shithole known as NYC! I agree with all of your statements on Apple product repairability. That being said, I do use a Mac every day for my work (the eco system is just too good to ignore for my general workflow). Unfortunately, this just puts me in the position where I have to deal with any failures by just buying a new machine. Luckily, I personally have never had a catastrophic failure as of yet. But I know it's just a matter of time, so I must stay diligent about backing up all my important data to external drives and/or cloud storage and cannot simply rely on the machines themselves. I do know some people personally that have lost a lot of their work to Apple design failures. But keep up the good work and don't let these doubters get to you! :)
I mean there's no need to keep buying Apple unless you're a masochist, lol. You can also ditch Apple and use computers with replaceable drives. I'm sure there are ways to adjust your workflow. But backing up is a very good idea in general, so keep that up I'd say.
I just ordered A34. Not an Apple product, but you also cannot remove the battery. You talk about it at the end of the video; it's a trend Apple started. I think people should get their chance to repair their own device, if they have the knowledge. If someone pays 2000 Euro for a Macbook which is not repairable in some cases, such as this with SSDs, not only do the costumers lose, but also the Earth loses because it automatically means more e-waste to manage. Great discussion Louis! You always tackle these kinds of problems with constructive, hard facts. Keep on keeping on!
"soldered SSD is more secure"If someone could open my computer and install a magical M.2 attachment that can read my SSD without me knowing they deserve those data tbh.
Exactly. Who do these people think they are, James Bond? Or maybe this is an episode of Mr. Robot? Who are they to have to worry about spies breaking into their homes and physically hacking their data in person?
@@rigen97 well you should Desolder the chip using a hot air soldering station, and you need data recovery tools, like SSD Nand Reader, if the chip is getting too hot then you're fked, and its expensive which is not for an average Joe. even apple can sell an iphone screen clamp for $1272.
@@isa_L *that's why they should've used regular nvme to begin with* Also, is it really more expensive to pay Jackson Technician to change the nand chips than buy _an entire new computer?_ Their...Studio M1 I think? Have removable nvme SSD lmao they can just use removable nvme nand without controller if they want to keep their "secure flash controller" inside their glassware that much.
Happy to have found your videos. I have been a crApple customer for three decades. They have gone downhill in so many ways over that time. They unquestionably do some things well. But in other areas, they're pure evil. I would not be surprised at all if eventually they are outed for incorporating some manner of "kill codes" in their OS software. Over the past 30 years, it has increasingly seemed that their products get buggy and stop working in frustrating ways starting in November of each year, and then those issues often magically clear up in late January or early February. I imagine a lot of new crApple products are bought within that three-month period. The crApple cult members will eventually see the light, as their products stop working. Keep fighting the good fight. Great video. Thanks. You rock.
The apple dongle has a driver that specifies that it is apple in the .inf file. I forgot what the chipset was but there was nothing fancy about it, just the DEV/VEN numbers.
The important point to understand about TPM, T1 and T2 chips is that those are supposed to be able to securely *store* secrets. It should be always possible to replace the chip and *store* the required secrets to make it work again. The problems with inabilitity to swap chips to repair the hardware are caused by inabilitity to create full backup of the system, including the data you (or your programs) stored to TPM, T1 or T2 chips, even when you *own the device* and have all the credentials to access all the data. The fact that Apple doesn't want to fix the backup problem points that they prefer to sell you new hardware instead of allowing to repair the existing hardware. Pretending that this is caused by security requirements is just a lie.
As an Onsite-IT engineer (now a software-engineer) i always advised users, even potential Apple mac buyers... to just get a custom pc build , cause in 15 years it will still be running perfectly, and the only thought you will be thinking then is ... " damn this thing is ancient! .. it's time for a new one, cause it can't run Google Chrome 2037 edition "
Actually it is a conspiracy... why? Because multiple people at Apple came together and decided to build a computer that becomes trash because a wear part fails. Conspiracy simple means, that two or more people get together and agree to do something... usually something negative.
Even if Apple were to come out with the next generation of laptops, to be fully user repairable, there's still millions upon millions of previous generation machines that need work on. Also I don't think Apple will EVER do that. ever.
No laptop will ever be fully repairable by the majority of end users. You could make one like Framework that is modular, but even there the user has to remove and throw out a chunk of the machine. An actual repair shop could repair the module. Thus even if Apple allows anyone to get the plans and parts the professionals are still going to have customers.
Hey, Louis. I just wanted to say, I appreciate you. Your content is good, I hope you don't let the haters and the uninformed get you down. Thank you for staying true to your moral compass. edit: please continue to not make short-form content, it's killing our collective attention spans
It is not the uninformed that is problematic, it is the fact that his moral compass is making a cult of follower that is arguably, even grosser than the consumer (or the sheep?) of Apple. Don't believe me, try to nudge them with giving Apple the credit, you'll be surprised how nasty the follower is, I'd say the nastiness is on par with Apple fan boy, if not worse!
i always thought too that SSD's are infinite. until i heard from a friend that her SSD died while she was making her thesis. Turns out, she made no backups and had to start again. FYI: the SSD was 10 years old when it crashed
I love the irony. The presumably most intelligent people always fail to realize, that you need to back up your data. This is especially running rampant among younger people, the older guys (40-60) somehow have a better clue about redundancy, even if they aren't tech savvy.
@@PvtAnonymous 2000s - 2010s is the age of tech savvy, anything later have been ruined by the convenience thus dumbing down the populace. Also, the 80s - 90s are the age of pioneer with crazy hacks/diy
@@PvtAnonymous rampant among all age groups, until it bites to bottom back side or where it hurts. Older one just had more time/chance to run into problems, life experience and stuff.
People becoming fanboys of companies and helping them screw them and everyone else is the worst part of this whole cituation we are in with our rights as customers
If multiple people are calling every day with the same problem, maybe it's time to partner up with a decent attorney and use this horde of customers to build a class action case. That seems like it's the only way to get Apple to actually do something about it.
These people are even sadder than vatniks sitting in an office building in saint petersburg posting russian government propaganda on the Internet. At least the vatniks get a paycheck at the end of the month.
I used to think you were an Apple hater Loius, but your thoughts are actually quite fair and valid and you actually have praised / acknowledged Apple when they've done good or neutral things over the years too. Enjoyed the video on Purism too, as someone who was interested in breaking into that whole area of tech. Thanks , keep it up
Louis Rossmann is probably the most honest electronics repair person in the whole industry! When I had a problem with my MacBook Air I would have absolutely taken it to him for the board level repair it needed (after my mother spilled wine over it) and if it wasn’t for the fact that I live in Scotland. I was however able to locate a person in Edinburgh (Edin Burra) here in Scotland through a local computer repair company in my hometown of Oban. Had I lived in the U.S.A, I would have absolutely sent it or taken it to Louis Rossmann to be repaired as I really do think is one of, if not the most honest electronic repair/engineer that exists! I’m an electronic engineer so I can appreciate his work and his outlook (the only reasons I didn’t fix my MacBook myself is that A. I do not have the required equipment at home and B. I’m nowhere as good as he (Louis Rossmann) is with a soldering iron or how actually skilled he is! There will be actual surgeons out there that wish they had his dexterity! I’m more into the theory side of things/design rather that physical side of repairs but I really do think he has more knowledge than most (95%-99%) of electronic engineers.
I really don't get it. I've been an Apple customer for a long time now, love the experience I get with macOS and iOS. So far I considered their designs to be quite solid. And where they weren't, I was treated amazingly well by their customer support, got a delaminated A1502 screen replaced for free, also they've done my iPhone battery replacement for cheap when the CPU downclocking scandal was happening. This was a better time for Apple. They seemed also repairable enough, I was able to replace the screens off of numerous iPhones, both mine and for friends, swapped a MacBook keyboard and battery (luckily I had to do it at the same time), and it was all quite straight forward. It's sad to see the lengths that they go to in ensuring their hardware is less repairable and more likely to end up in a landfill, while they keep touting how much more environment friendly and carbon neutral they are, supposedly. It's also really sad seeing Apple fanboys defend every decision they take, no matter how wrong and consumer hostile. I probably used to do that too, without realising. It's hard to wean myself off of 'the ecosystem', but I might be forced out of it.
You are the REAL apple fan! And i mean it in the right way. Because you dont hate on him, you are sad because the company changes stuff and dont hate on other people. You have not lost your brain unlike the other apple fans who only support their company and hate on everyone :) i hope you the best. My friend is also a nice apple fan who does not hate on others and also hates some changes and also cant realy escape the apple system, but it does not matter, as long as you stay how you are now
I’ve been enjoying Apple products too for some time and it really is frustrating how apple products can work like near magic when they work, especially as a ecosystem but if you try to go against the way big fruit intended for you to use them or if something doesn’t work it becomes a nightmare to deal with real fast.
I can relate. I largely grew up as an Apple fan, using their products a lot as a kid in the 90s and 2000s and as a student in the mid to late 2000s. But throughout the 2010s I got increasing frustrated by anti-consumer and anti-repair decisions. It's like my Macbook air that needs a new keyboard, I would have happily used it longer but the effort to do it myself and the price it would have cost apple to do it was off-putting and the computer to this days just sits in a box collecting dust. I also got frustrated with some other Apple fans who would get super defensive when I'd point out things that Apple does that frustrated me. I was criticizing Apple because I liked their products and wanted them to do better or treat their customers better, not because I wanted to smear their name or criticize other Mac owner's decisions. Apple owners not calling out Apple is a frustrating problem and I think if Apple fans who truly cared about Apple products called Apple out it'd result in better products for all of us. It's a shame that for some people any criticism of Apple is seen as anti-Apple, when a lot of people just wants Apple to do better. At this point I still have some classic Macs from the 80s to 2000s that I keep around for the novelty or for running old software, but Apple's policies and decisions in the last 15 years has largely meant that I haven't bought a new Mac computer since 2011. In some ways I feel like a fan that was pushed out of the Apple ecosystem because of Apple's decisions.
Sadly there's your answer. A lot of people don't care about honesty and will rather embrace pretty lies that suit them. What is left of their decency sometimes perks up when one of these lies is pointed out which makes them lash out, defending their indefensible position, doubling down when called out, becoming ever more riled and stuck.
I just spent today loading new OSes on a dozen used Dell Latitudes donated to my work. One had a bad SSD, and one didn't have a drive at all, but unlike a Mac: I could still boot them, and if we want, can spend ~$60 on each for new SSDs and not throw away a still functional laptop.
People without facts and an actual argument tend to aim for ad hominems, it's all they have. Also, if they shout and rage loud enough it tends to work.
These things are also massive money-makers for Apple when it comes to business consumers. I worked as an engineer on a site that had 1000+ Apple devices, and so we were all trained to replace RAM and disks in all the Macbooks and iMacs, obviously for when they break, but also to upgrade the machine. As more components have become irreplaceable, it's become less viable to upgrade these machines - Where an apple device with RAM/disk upgrades used to last at least 10 years, it's now almost a MAXIMUM 10 years before the machine becomes completely obsolete and there's no viable upgrade path, so it has to be replaced entirely. What was a couple hundred quid/decade in repair costs is becoming a couple thousand quid/decade in replacement costs.
Why do most people expect tech to last except Apple fans? Even Apples proprietary gaming network 'Apple Arcade' is server based and the second they turn the servers off all those games are dead. People say Apple have always been the leaders in helping creatives, but I don't understand how that can be when Apple seem to love destroying art left right and centre
I found it funny that my first advert prior to watching this video contained the words. "Are you suffering with constipation?". Going by some of these replies, they could do with watching that ad.
A 2 Terabyte M.2 SSD can be bought for something like $60 new. A Macbook to have the same size SSD will cost $600, and when it does wear out, which it will then it can't be replaced. Leaving you with very expensive e-waste.
And that ewaste harms the earth and most ends up at landfills and not recycled thus saturating the earth even more from its resources.. hate it. My friends grandpa has a ton of old devices which can be uograded or repaired easily
I run a small business. 5 years ago, we needed additional workstation PC's for office applications. I purchased 5 year old refurbished (lease return) machines. Upgraded the RAM and put in SSD's. They are still working and are more than enough for what we need them for. Without the ability to upgrade the RAM and/or to SSD's, these machines would be in the landfill and I would have had to spend a lot more money on machines that would have been overkill for the needed purpose. Overall, repairable, upgradable, etc. is better in the long run.
As a residential maintenance technician it is important for me to have access to info to know how to fix : refrigerator dishwasher, stove, and your washer and dryer ext Right to repair is very important I help take care of 1000 homes could you imagine if I couldn't repair the refrigerator in said home and had to get a new refrigerator every single time one of them went bad in said 1000 homes I have access to the blueprints on the house so I know where wires are in the walls Whoops there's a water leak in your wall but drywall company won't sell me more drywall time to get you a new home that ain't an option I don't want to live in a world where up it broke and replace it Resources aren't unlimited
Planned obsolescence is not a conspiracy theory. The difference is what is market saturation looks like. When there is nobody to sell to but your own customers, the object of monetization seems pretty clear.
You should do a video on Dyson’s repair policy, they won’t even sell you the rubber band to go between the roller and the motor and will in fact tell you that this is to protect you electrocution from the high voltage 48v motor… even though we can simply unplug the vacuum and that the motor contacts are never exposed. Instead I was meant to send it to my local Dyson authorised repair centre that had a 6 week wait time
Also dyson does not even add some hv isolators between the mcu and the motor driver chip in their hot and cool fan. Had seen videos from my mate vince and from another one and had myself 5 of them with dead fried mcu chips because the motor driver shorted out and sent hv into the mcu pins
Channels like yours are what gave me the confidence to learn how to desolder and repair the bios on a laptop I was able to purchase at work for scrap pricing.
I was one of the people that had the 27" iMac that suffered from the failing HDD. I took the PC into the Genius Bar and they ran some test and claimed the drive was fine. I get the iMac home set it up and the issues with the computer kept occurring. I got fed up and tossed the machine in the closet and built a windows based machine and never touched another apple product. A couple years later Apple came out with a repair program thanks to a class action law suit to replace the hdd that they previously claimed was okay. Since I had given up on wanting to go back to MacOS and Apple products, I never bothered taking the machine back to an Apple Store to get a new hdd installed. If the system had been user accessible, I could have replaced the defective hdd and used the built-in program to download and re-install the OS. One good thing this situation did do for me is to rely on my own ability to build a computer to my specific needs and desires and with no restrictions to have what I want and replace components as necessary. Any problems can be solved by me without the extra need to seek out an outside source for a resolution.
Soldered SSDs are not suitable for pro users. I have a couple of dead Samsung SSDs: two half TB and one 1TB. They all died while I was doing my regular work with big files (AI-related database). And that was normal. Most of them reached their limit of terabytes written and the only reason my laptop is still working is because they were replaceable. And as someone who treats my laptop as a tool rather than some jewelry, I guess Macs are just not for professional use… At least not for now.
So they project that YOU are the conspiracy theorist, while most of them come up w/ conspiracies about your motivation(s)? Their behavior and mindset(S) deter me from ever being an Apple owner.. ..much moreso than "all of your negativity about Apple"
btw, the M1+ Macs do have SPI NOR. It's used for early iBoot stages. But you still need the main NAND to start the OS (as the second stage of iBoot resides there and the whole boot flow assumes the kernel is loaded from an APFS container in the internal memory). The soldered main memory is a really bad engineering decision and there isn't really any reason for it. It's not like the machine is a phone and cannot afford the space for a connector. It probably just was the 'lazy way' and happened mostly by accident. Compare that to e.g. the Mac Pro, which has NAND on modules and there is a documented - though tricky - way to replace (and even upgrade!) these.
I don't own a single apple product...owned a phone once and then saw they released a patch that slowed down older phones to encourage people to upgrade and right then they were placed on a lifetime ban from me 😂
