Тёмный

Low vs. High Trail Bikes? What is Bicycle Trail? 

Path Less Pedaled
Подписаться 178 тыс.
Просмотров 19 тыс.
50% 1

In this episode of #bikewhisperer I do a deep dive into the concept of "bicycle trail". What does it mean? How does it affect handling?
Book a BikeWhisperer Session: pathlesspedaled.bigcartel.com...
www.analogcycles.com/debunkin...
Help support independent reviews: / pathlesspedaled
www.paypal.me/pathlesspedaled
SUPPLE PATCHES pathlesspedaled.bigcartel.com/
PATREON: / pathlesspedaled
SUPPLE SHIRTS: pathlesspedaled.spreadshirt.com
**NEW ROUTE GUIDE** www.pathlesspedaled.com/routes/
INSTAGRAM: pathlesspedaled #thesupplelife #gravelbike #biketouring #bikepacking

Опубликовано:

 

3 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 66   
@BikeInsights
@BikeInsights 4 года назад
Love the video, Russ! That trail chart is also up on our Cyclopedia if anyone wants to get a closer look. We agree that Trail is one of the most important specs for determining a bike's handling, so we calculate it on Bike Insights for every bike we can. We even calculate the trail number for different wheel/tire configurations. Look for the "Configure" button (wrench icon) on our site to play around with this. A cool new trend we're seeing take off this year is configurable-offset forks (especially for gravel, all-road, and off-road touring bikes that can accommodate both 650b and 700c wheels). This means you can adjust the amount of fork offset to maintain the same trail figure when running two different wheelsets. I'm optimistic that this technology can eventually be used to correct for the issue you point out where smaller bikes are being forced into higher trail numbers by way of head tube angle manipulation.
@mnw1871
@mnw1871 4 года назад
Absolutely love the fact that you're delving in to the mysterious world of Trail. Every article or blog always talks about the standard formulas for calculating or measuring trail, with little more than "Slow" or "Quick" to describe how it affects handling. I didn't really start to "get it" until I started building bikes. Then, when you start to actually see and feel what wheel-flop is, or steering with your body vs your hands....makes a huge difference. Most folks don't have the luxury of building bikes, or testing as many different rides as you do. Keep up the good work, man. At this rate, you may end up enticing the bike manufacturing community into adopting some form of your "color wheel" descriptor.
@pinonoir7287
@pinonoir7287 4 года назад
That's some great info again and stuff that I never really thought much about actually. Would like to see the bicycle flavour wheel as a fridge magnet or something similar.
@forresthendricks6818
@forresthendricks6818 4 года назад
Thanks for this Russ! This was the content I needed.
@moreypc
@moreypc 4 года назад
another great video and really solid insight. I've been a bike trail (steering) junkie for a long time and your video makes one think about what they actually need and want. Very high trail (80-90mm) with a mid length stem (90ish mm) and drop bars may not be ideal for steep and slow grinding climbs which I seem to ride on a pretty regular basis and was what I was looking at... So much info! thanks again
@Tomalahno
@Tomalahno 4 года назад
Thanks, Russ! This is a really helpful consideration for my next ride!
@mjenk20236
@mjenk20236 4 года назад
Good discussion. I had a low-trail fork made for a bike that was around 65 mm trail. The new fork was about 30 mm trail. The high trail fork was unstable at low speeds as you say. It was also very exciting in a gusty cross-wind. Wide tires and front mounted weight both reduce the twitchiness. My low trail MAP never goes anywhere without at least a heavy lock in the front rando bag.
@pottery1950
@pottery1950 2 года назад
Excellent and helpful, thanks Russ.
@Dee-Ell
@Dee-Ell 3 года назад
Best video on the topic!
@jordanburke1534
@jordanburke1534 2 года назад
This was fantastic, thank you.
@simplefilms9100
@simplefilms9100 2 года назад
Thanks for that explanation. Yet it really took me some time to not confuse trail and steering tube angle anymore.
@jimrichards7014
@jimrichards7014 4 года назад
I was just looking this up. Bike trail is hard to google 😂
@BikeInsights
@BikeInsights 4 года назад
I propose new terminology: Goatiness
@KellyS_77
@KellyS_77 4 года назад
Rolling resistance?
@3232groundhog
@3232groundhog 3 года назад
@@BikeInsights Goat Sobriety Factor (measured in “times the legal limit”)
@kaffeemitcola6506
@kaffeemitcola6506 4 года назад
This is a thing that has to be consumed slowly, especially for me not hearing my motherlanguage. Very informative and the comparison of different framesizes is such an interesting thing, and it is one thing that the most people never think about and so far out of the awareness if people make decisions. Here in Germany, Canyon builds (some models) the same bike with different wheel-sizes depending on the framesize to prevent different angles to change from size to size and not to change the whole geometrie to prevent toe-overlap for example.
@planepower8523
@planepower8523 4 года назад
Great description! Now i understand why i prefer my fatbike to have higher trail. Makes going over poor surfaces more relaxing rather than the worry of losing the front end on an ice windrow.
@saltzmanweniger
@saltzmanweniger 3 года назад
If you want a more intuitive look at trail and head angle just pick up a caster (from a broken office chair or something) and push it along a table at different angles. The castor swivels to put the wheel behind the pivot when the pivot is vertical. This is analogous to a 90 degree head angle where the bike would be very unstable with negative trail. Eventually with the pivot at enough of an angle the wheel will stay in front. The threshold where the wheel stops wanting to around is a trail of 0.
@harrypar1
@harrypar1 2 года назад
great video, very useful info! I just checked the geometry chart of many expensive models (10k+) and it seems than many of them have just one fork for all sizes, which means that they have huge differences in trail measurements (for example pinarello f12 has 81mm for the the smallest size and 54mm the largest size). Though I've never seen a brand produce more than 2 forks for a model, so there can be a range of 11-12mm to about 20mm in trail. Smaller sized bicycles "suffer" from high trail numbers and contrariwise larger sizes have smaller trail measurments.
@davidcolinstillman5585
@davidcolinstillman5585 4 года назад
THANK YOU ! VERY INTERESTING OUTLOOK & HELPFUL ! BE SAFE ! HAVE FUN ! GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS ! ENJOYED !
@herethere2518
@herethere2518 4 года назад
Great insight! One thing I would love to know is how to calculate trail on a specific bike. Most of my bikes are parts bikes and frequently don't even have the same wheel size front to rear. I tend to just shift parts around until I find something I like. I have a few that I really enjoy, including one that I refer to as my "tomacahawk" (long live john tomac!) that started as a flat-bar 700c hybrid and now has fat tires and drop bars (perfect for the new gravel pump track in town). Perhaps one of your upcoming bike whisperer episodes can be on bike-geometry metrology? Many manufacturers don't provide complete geometry info plus, as you mentioned, modifications can change geometry. Cheers!!
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
yojimg.net/bike/web_tools/trailcalc.php
@JoshKablack
@JoshKablack 4 года назад
The low bicycle trail is the one by the river. The high bicycle trail is the one that has the great view of town. 😉
@alradhi.j3009
@alradhi.j3009 4 года назад
I remember read Jan Heine’s comment section. but I forgot which article... he write to choose very low or very high trail when considering front load carrying because mid trail will be the problem. I choose low trail because my mountain bike is already have very high fork trail. but a bike with very low fork trail comes with very high cost price.
@Jacob-cb7pj
@Jacob-cb7pj 4 года назад
The difference in feel caused by larger frames having lower trail numbers is compounded by the likelihood that riders on larger frames will have wider handlebars.
@fultonlopez7846
@fultonlopez7846 3 года назад
Hi Russ, i have been researching trail that candle high speed 30 to 40 mph and gusty winds at the same time. I do time trials, and there is a downhill section with gusty cross winds
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 3 года назад
That would be a motorcycle.
@countingcoup
@countingcoup 4 года назад
It seems as if bike stability is also a geometrical calculation of your body weight and positioning at the center fulcrum, maybe including short vs mid or long chainstay based on the bike frame too?!? Nice video piece, its all about understanding the form and function which goes far beyond nerd curiosity, and trail is a major player ~
@zbronstein3901
@zbronstein3901 4 года назад
Exactly. I'm not a framebuilder (but I'm hoping to start soon, just gotta save that $$$) but two incredibly important angles in frame design are the angles between the contact patches on the front and rear tires and the location of the saddle. This is exactly what you are talking about. At the extremes a rider too far forward will get projected upon a road bump and a rider too far backwards will have a hard time keeping the front wheel on the ground. For example, modern MTB geometry needs to have a larger front angle to keep the bike stable and predictable during descents (why they have lax head tube angles and high trail) but to keep the front tire on the ground during climbs the center of gravity needs to be pushed forward (why they have high seat tube angles).
@craigwilson118
@craigwilson118 4 года назад
@@zbronstein3901 Is there a book or something I could read about these type of considerations? I'm not looking to become a framebuilder but love to nerd out on this stuff. I can never find good info about designing around the rider.
@leif5151
@leif5151 4 года назад
Great insight as I am in the market right now. Also did I miss the review on the Swift Rove build?
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
In a few weeks.
@Radnally
@Radnally 4 года назад
Good overview. I just made a 700C frame with a 46.5cm chainstay for a long wheel base. But it has a 73.5 head angle with a 44mm rake. Also allows for 40mm tires. Decent on gravel, pretty tight cornering.
@andyzacek9760
@andyzacek9760 Год назад
if you read Jan Heine's BQ articles he makes a convincing point that the tire size and pressure ("pneumatic trail") can often totally counteract the supposed effects of low/high trail in the fork. So a super low trail bike with high pneumatic trail (low pressure wide tires) might handle pretty similarly in some respects to a mid trail bike with high pressure 25s. But throw 25s on the same low trail bike and it will suddenly handle like garbage without the wide tires lending stability to the otherwise "twitchy/nervous" low trail front end.
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV Год назад
I agree with JH on that point and have definitely experienced pneumatic trail effects.
@thomaswhitmore5095
@thomaswhitmore5095 4 года назад
Also larger frames tend to have shorter trail numbers, just to keep the other dimensions balanced.
@klunker289
@klunker289 4 года назад
Russ, did you buy the Bombora? I see the new setup you got going on there. I want one. Keep up the great work✌😄👍
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
Yep bought one.
@JuicyFruitSkank
@JuicyFruitSkank 3 года назад
I'm currently designing a mullet dh bike and the trail has came out at 139, how will that relate to handling in terms of a dh bike?
@danvee4523
@danvee4523 4 года назад
yeah I'm interested how trail numbers jive with different handle bar set ups. for example you got a 70mm of trail on the same bike lets say and one person sets it up with wider flat bars swept back to the head tube and one person has a 70mm. stem with drops.
@danvee4523
@danvee4523 4 года назад
I know you mentioned it just curious for more info on that.
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
Hard to say. Could be worse or better handling depending on the bike. Generally if you unweight the front of the bike it should steer lighter.
@jamiecox2506
@jamiecox2506 4 года назад
Great explanation, cheers. So if I understand correctly, in the diagrams used both by cyclingabout and analog, show a road/racing looking fork, described as high trail and the touring bike looking fork as low trail. This is incorrect, right? It causes some confusion as the diagrams could've been drawn more accurately. Maybe it's just me...
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
You can’t judge trail by how a fork looks since it is affected by head tube angle and tire size. Most touring bikes actually aren’t low trail. Your best bet is to input the numbers into a trail calculator.
@NinthwaveThe
@NinthwaveThe 2 года назад
@@PathLessPedaledTV Have you ever tried the Romanceur or the Lightning Bolt from Crust? You seem to prefer higher trail like the Bombora.
@dusanmal
@dusanmal 4 года назад
Excellent instructional. Raising one Q that maybe should be addressed in terminology: "What is stable?". In this particular case what is "stable" in Physics conflicts with bicycling terminology. Worse, there are uses of "stable" in cycling that are equivalent to the Physics meaning, ex. longer wheelbase is stable in Physical sense and is used as such term in cycling. Hence confusion. Physically stable cycle is NOT good for lumpy fast MTB downhills... That is why MTBs are typically not long wheelbase. But, they have long trail... I would use term "controllability" for property increasing (to a point!, see later...) as trail increases. Test of the Physical term stability applied to a bike: On a smooth, flat area push a bike (with nobody on it) to be tested with known fixed momentum. How far will it go before falling? Now do the same with same momentum with a different bike (ex. different trail number). How far will it go? Further->more Physically stable. Now to the limits of the benefits from increased trail: Install a bike fork with SMALL trail in the reverse (front to back). You'll get a bike with enormous trail. Try to ride it... Really, try to ride it... ;) Do the stability test as defined above, ... great learning opportunity. Thank for the great content, comment is not about your expertise which is greatly appreciated but about cycling terminology that everyone uses and which maybe needs a tweak or two.
@nj-zl7ot
@nj-zl7ot 4 года назад
Mountain bikes have a much longer wheelbases than road bikes. Combined with lots of trail up front and they are super stable at speed. This is definitely a good thing. I'm not sure what mountain bikes you're referring to. Here's a comparison between a 56cm road bike and size large mountain bike, both of which I'd ride: bikeinsights.com/compare?geometries[]=5ceaf6ed75107b00172f9852&geometries[]=5d5a5155a612530017c07436&builds[]=&builds[]= The wheelbase on the mountain bike is 235mm (9.25") longer!
@Jthe5th
@Jthe5th 4 года назад
"MTBs are typically not long wheelbase", this has some troll smell to it.
@Ey_up
@Ey_up 4 года назад
@@Jthe5th plenty of 2019-20 mtbs - especially enduro/ trail bikes have become quite stretched out in reach and wheelbase. Just sayin'.
@davebarksdale
@davebarksdale 4 года назад
Hammer pants....I think I still have mine. ;)
@sethmcfarland1083
@sethmcfarland1083 4 года назад
Have you seen bikedigger.com yet? Its been made by some MTB focused guys, but I would guess you could adapt it and apply your flavor wheel to its rankings system.
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
That’s like bikeinsights but for bros :)
@Jthe5th
@Jthe5th 4 года назад
Great article. One thing I find it rather strange I got a gravel bike with 700C, 35mm tires, 430mm chainstay, with claimed trail of 71mm on size M and I find it very responsive, hard to not call it twitchy. Any thoughts on that?
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
Stem length? What bike are you coming from?
@Jthe5th
@Jthe5th 4 года назад
@@PathLessPedaledTV When I saw your article, I said let me go and check the specs on my bike, I bet it's got some low trail. Then saw 71mm, hmm, well that is no low trail. I haven't been on a bike for a long time actually, years, just got into this one. I used to ride a 90s style MTB before. Stem length is 90mm and 44mm short reach low drop handlebars. Maybe the stem is the thing and the tire width? or just not being used to this bike, I've done like 150Km on it already, even if I got it for some months, because it doesn't give me confidence to go on the road and reach some non-traffic portions to ride freely.
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
@@Jthe5th If you're coming from a mountain bike it will feel more responsive. If you're coming from a road bike it will feel less responsive. Its like scotch. If you drink highland style scotch with bright fruit notes and then drink an Isla style scotch, it will accentuate the smokiness and peatiness of it. Knowing that you are coming from a mtb which tends to be higher trail, it makes sense why it would feel more responsive to you. Also, 44 is fairly narrow as far as handlebars go on gravel bikes and that may also add to the twitch factor. 71 is still what I'd prob. consider mid-high. Still some responsiveness before getting too extreme. But it is relative what you are use to.
@Jthe5th
@Jthe5th 4 года назад
@@PathLessPedaledTV Thanks man, I thought 44cm dropbars are wide enough since many gravel bikes come with these standard
@invishand3
@invishand3 4 года назад
Interesting that the high trail numbers on full susp mtb's are from the "Slackness", not the classic curve in your pics. May be a good subject for the future?? I like slack bikes cause i have big feet but it distributes more weight to back wheel... ever do a video on slack head tube fork angles/high trail vs low trail steep heat tube angles
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
High trail is either achieved with fork rake or HTA. In mtbs it is HTA. Isn’t that what I just did in this video? :)
@invishand3
@invishand3 4 года назад
​@@PathLessPedaledTV Ya, i heard you mention in 1st min but i was waiting for diagrams. my honest interpretation from diagrams you showed with the same HTA and only a curve to change the trail, then your bike in back w curved fork, then the crazy old curved fork pic at 10:00 - my mind categorized this as a "curved vs straight forks" discussion. No big deal... i understand now. just giving you feedback on how a person with a straight forks may have been more "vested" in the discussion. BTW: the bottom right tiny diagram at 1:00 showing only a change in HTA would have been great to add in the first min of your video after the first curved fork trail comparison diagram (i didnt see this till i watched the vid again after your reply). Thanks for the reply btw
@jprelock
@jprelock 4 года назад
I don't understand the use of the terms twitchy and nervous to describe low trail handling. My experience comes from only one bike, a Kogswell P/R with a 40mm trail fork. For a given steering input it would turn less than a road race type bike. I understand high trail becomes more stable the faster you go, but I felt 40mm trail was more stable, less inclined to turn, with front load or without, than any of the many high trail bikes I've ridden. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding definitions in some way.
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
I suggest borrowing a Brompton and riding it unloaded and telling me how how you would describe it. I believe the trail of Bromptons is in the upper 20s.
@biking261
@biking261 4 года назад
Your apartment looks empty of bikes! must be months since it was like that :-)
@PathLessPedaledTV
@PathLessPedaledTV 4 года назад
Yeah. Sending back review bikes.
Далее
Bike Geometry Explained: The Bicycle Flavor Wheel!
12:25
Rivendell vs Crust! Which is Better?
9:10
Просмотров 50 тыс.
Осторожно селеба идет 😂
00:16
Просмотров 166 тыс.
Whose action is better?🥹 #filaretiki #shorts
01:00
Touring Bikes are NOT Gravel Bikes #BikeWhisperer
12:42
650b is DEAD....(Long Live 650b)
9:00
Просмотров 73 тыс.
Rivendell Sam Hillborne - Does it make sense in 2020?
10:28
Best Gearing for Gravel? 1x? 2x? Sub-Compact?
20:17
Просмотров 81 тыс.
The Best Crankset NO ONE Knows About!
8:38
Просмотров 52 тыс.
Life Is Short. Scare Yourself.
13:56
Просмотров 232 тыс.
What Fork Offset is Best? Steering Geometry 101
13:07
Bikepacking with Tumbleweed Bicycles
11:27
Просмотров 71 тыс.
Get it right! | Finding your perfect stem length
12:20
Просмотров 185 тыс.
What makes a SUPPLE Tire?
14:10
Просмотров 41 тыс.
Осторожно селеба идет 😂
00:16
Просмотров 166 тыс.