What a sadness of Tchaikovsky when he composed this waltz, can feel it, it is a sentimental voice of loneliness... He suffered a lot, it was too much for the envious without talent homophobic and conservative men surrounding him that creation gave him all the talent to be the greatest composer of Russia being a homosexual man... they could put up with this until they obligue him to committing suicide...so cruel, sad and ironic for the great composer...They just kill his physical body, but Tchaikownski was already inmortal... his lives every day somebody plays his music I or listen to it.... who remember or talk about the asesinas? Nobody., they are dead and forgotten.
Actually Tchaikovsky was also a conservative even for his time, and he was quite open with his homosexuality. And how do you know he commited suicide ? Yes Tchaikovsky was sad and yes his struggle with his sexuality has to do with it, but he was also depressed due to his siter's death and many other issues. Don't use him for your agenda.
@@sophiashakti5638 Bro i've seen like 2 comments of yours, he interpretated it perfectly, rhythm, notes, beat everything is on point, what u going on abt
@@sophiashakti5638 People when someone doesn't get the Piece exactly the same: 😡😡😡😡 Like bro why are you so mad, he's interpreting how he wants, it's music, and it's free expression, he doesn't exactly have to play it like Tchaikovsky
@@sophiashakti5638 i agree, you are free to express your opinion, but that doesn't mean hating on the dude's interpretation off the bat. You were turning people away from what they liked, for example, someone said how it was heartfelt, or whatever, but it's something they found fond of, so you don't have to go on and say how it's not a good interpretation or how it's "Nauseating" to you.
@@sophiashakti5638 What😭😭 It lit was kinda hateful, you're dedicating ur time to hating on this dude in the comment sections, just keep it to yourself my love, its really not that complicated to respect if other people find it heartleft!
@@sophiashakti5638 you just said you dont care if I liked it or not because it's my "opinion" and now youre saying im a cancel culture nauseating person?💀 Just pick a damn side
Debargue...not Debarge...fantastic player. Despite very good and enchanting, is to me too free and out of the original intention of Ciaikovsky with this extreme rubato instead of a simple, plain rendition. But the contrast between sections is really effective. So it looks great!
I absolutely loved this interpretation, I don't know why but this rubato seems so fit...it just describes all the pain Caikovsky had inside. I guess all is in the ears of a listener. Perhaps my soul that is from that region feels this more.
Hello Lap Lepski, please be kind enough to post the entire recital at Mariinsky, it was without a doubt the best performance ever. I would and many others who listen to RU-vid appreciate it very much. Thank you very much!!!!
@@Delicatamente Hello Mr. Leski, This video is not the full performance of the entire concert at Mariinsky. Please find it and post it again, I would appreciate it very much. Lena
Too much rubato. Let the music of the Russian Waltz King speak its own way without losing the power of a consistent tempo that may be danced to by a willing couple, uninebriated to relish the elegance in their partnership suggested by Tchaikovsky's miniature masterpiece.
Malgré toute l' admiration que je puisse avoir pour Lucas Debarges , cette interprétation est beaucoup trop lente ... Une "valse corse" en quelque sorte ... De plus il en " fait des tonnes " au niveau gestuel pour un thème léger , aérien qui ne nécessite pas autant de simagrées . Je suis d' autant plus intraitable ici que la "valse sentimentale" est ma préférée avec deux ou trois de Chopin ...
@@saturday83 Holà ! doucement ... Il existe des interprètes ( pour Chopin en particulier ) qui se couchent littéralement sur le clavier alors que d' autres ont une attitude sobre . je pense à Alexandre Tharaud , entr' autres ... Désolé mais on est pas au cirque ! ce qui n' enlève evidemment pas la qualité de l' interprète . Trop de "romantisme" tuant le romantisme , c' est connu ...
@@saturday83 Je vous signale que je n' ai dit nulle part qu' il se couchait sur le clavier ! Si vous me relisez vous verrez que je parle d' autres pianistes qui en général en font "des tonnes" visuellement dans le répertoire romantique ... je ne jugeais pas ici la qualité de l' artiste mais soulignais simplement un jeu TRES lent ( c' est tout de même une valse ! ) et un maniérisme agaçant . Alexandre Tharaud est un contre- exemple question sobriété gestuelle . En fait dans votre aveuglement vous n' avez lu que ce qu vous souhaitiez voir ...et après tout , mon point de vue en vaut bien un autre ...
Je ne connais pas de pianistes qui se couchent sur le clavier. Vos propos sont délbérément désobligeants pour Lucas Debargue qu'à l'évidence vous n'aimez pas. @@yvesgerard1308
