Sorry about SLASH but he's got to understand this even the people have to understand this Lucie only has 4 to 5 minutes per performance on X-Factor so that's why they had to skip his guitar solo from the beginning.
They don't do these songs to be just like the original artists. They will ALWAYS modify it for the singer's voice. ALWAYS! I thought she knocked it out of the park. Great job!
+Morgan Karmichael I do agree normally but to play devils advocate here the show is about the vocals. It's a singing competition. The guitar would have taken focus away from that especially since her vocals were actually quite weak
eddie sanders Yes which is basically what my comment should have suggested.... however it is a singing competition, when you have only around 3 minuted to do your thing you are not going to use a minute + for soloing I think I would have screamed like a girl however if Slash had walked out half way through to kick he arse
+Sir Boast-a-lot I totally agree. The guitar solo IS the song. That being said, this girl will one day be famous is she gets the righ mgr. and song. Simon always looks to the business end of singing as you should if you want to make a living at it.
+austin teutsch mmm beg to differ slightly i love this song because of the interplay between axls vocals and slashes quitar licks When axl sings slash is quiet and when slash winds up axl is quiet that is what makes that song for me (oh and the awesome bass and rythme that holds the song together)
+Brett Mciver Thank God!! Someone shares my opinions.. Axl's vocals in the original are incomparable..and the feel which comes through his screeching chorus and the outro!!! gives chills everytime...same case with almost all other song in AFD..!!
Ant B Nope not really. There are plenty of bands that can cover songs without screwing them up. But songs won't be forgotten or won't "fade away" because they are that great. Songs like 'Sweet Child O' Mine' is one of those songs.
Ohoho u r so stupid that you goin on the writing mistakes before u saying something about the message?! Haha if u would speak my language i would destroy u in any way haha biatch
I do think Simon knows talent when he sees it. I got to give it to him, he is a genius. He owns the X Factor. He is the creator, producer and judge in it. He is like god in this show. Simon left American Idol and that show is struggling now.
Congratulations, giving the world a new version of an awesome song... i dont mean to offend anyone talking ''she ruined an old classic'' and shitt its just a new version... GnR are still legends she shown good taste and shown her voice in a great way...:)..some ppl pretending they are hardcore GnR fans talking how noone can replace axl WHICH SHE DIDNT TRY.... enjoye her singing guys... LUCIE KEEP KICKING ASS!!!!
I get standing ovations at karaoke when I sing this, or should say attempt to sing this, not that I am a great singer but for having the balls to try it, I take my hat off to this chick she did a really good job on a very difficult song and trust me I am a big axl rose fan
I'm sure musicians would have loved to play the whole song but i'm pretty sure they have to cut it down to 3-4 minutes, otherwise i'd go there and play shine on you crazy diamond lol.
The competition is not about playing guitar. If she loves the song maybe must try to do a full version elsewhere, live and with a good guitar player for the solo, or a good band in general. Then we can see and judge.
It's in the paperwork you have to sign. The producers and editors can do whatever they want with you and your style once you are accepted. Which is why the contestants often get makeovers and have to sing songs that they don't really like.
Mate, listening to Guns N' Roses makes you know as much about music as the other 100 mil people that bought they've records (rofl GnR are sleaze/hard rock actually but nevertheless)
Demosthenes9999 No, making the song "her own" is stupid, I always hated when people would take the song and change the rythm and the style.. makes no sense, if the song is made that way, there's no point in changing it.
Great job of a tuff song truth be told I only watched it because I love the song Danni minogue sure knows how to get the best out of her contestants just look at this years Aussie x factor winner Dami im I mean What a Change from geek to Pop & Rock freak !
what the hell u r talking about?? its so nice to see that this song crossed generations. I remember when I played this song in for my father in his stereo. He said " its a good song. but nobody will remember this band in 5 years." here is his fucking answer. The chick did a nice job, compare her to axl rose is stupid she is paying fucking homage to the band and showing the song for today generation. I think its awesome.
that comment's old af but it's not that they can't sing,it's just that Axl's literally has a vocal range of 6 octaves aka something most humans dont have lmao
she did the song in her own style, was watching a interview on BCC America they were talking about differnt acts doing Guns & Roses songs, with Slash . Slash said he would love to do this song with Lucie Jones he thought she had a Great Voice & did it in her own way. He went on to say that Lucie & Fergie were the only 2 women he ever heard that could do justice to this song
I saw that some of u said that it's nothing without the solo, i'm a singer and a guitar player and i love this solo very much but u must understand that this is not a solo competition, it's a vocal one and this girl has covered this song in her own style and sung PERFECTLY!!!!!!! Instead of wasting your time by watching music videos if you are not a passionate of music just watch Teletubies or Spongebob etc etc............. Short minded.......
Why do musicians always feel like they have to explain to the rest of us what we like and don't like.It's arrogant of you to think that we don't understand. Music is for the people of the world as is RU-vid,not just those who have a gift of music or for those that you deem passionate. I don't feel like we are the ones short minded here.
I see so many negative comments but she sounded good. Her voice had some grit which a song like this needs and its a show with an alloted amount of time for each performance so if they included the solo there wouldnt be much for her to showcase her vocals. Her look screams rock and with the hair and everything she reminds me of avril levine. I think she did a good job and doesnt deserve all the negativity in the comments. I do realize this was years ago but when lucy was on x factor i quite liked her.
Lucie, you have a great voice, you are a good singer. But this is G n' R, it's rock, you don't have that kind of voice to cover this. Axl had, he did it fucking awesome.
people before you have any right to complain about any of these singing competitions. you need to take a short course in musical appreciation. these are covers for a reason, to allow the person show off their talents, not to be the artists that originally made the songs themselves
