No way you gave Dueling, experience, intelligence, and feats to RoTJ Luke over Knightfall Anakin 💀 Anakin at that point had been in a general in a war for several years and had been in over a dozen lightsaber fights.
Dueling is obviously Luke. Even tho, Vader was holding back a bit Luke still defeated him and we know that ROTJ > Knightfall Vader in dueling. Experience, is debatable. Intelligence is also Luke, Anakin was blinded by rage and wrath and never considered making other options except violence.. (And also the fact that he never thought about how suspicous Palpatine's actions were) He fell into Palpatine's trap. Luke didnt fell for Palpatine's trick about killing Vader and turning to the dark side. And Luke also shown more intelligence feats (IQ to Anakin tho). Feats, also Luke. Whats a better feat? Defeating the jedi order with Palps and Losing to your master, or defeating the empire by your own with no help and bringing balance to the force. Overall Luke slams.
@@Bsw_aep Anakin is smarter then Luke, He built C3-PO and a Pod racer AS A KID, the most we've seen Luke do is minor repairs to basic equipment (also IQ and intelligence are the same, basing off what you said later I think what you meant that instead of intelligence you meant wisdom, two different things) As for dueling, no, this also goes to Anakin, when Luke and Vader fought, Vader was pretty handedly beating Luke (even as he was conflicted, which in the Star Wars verse, has a tangible effect of weakening a person) UNTIL Luke brought on the power of the dark side. Luke only won because Vader was nerfed and Luke was buffed. As for Luke not falling for papa Palpatines lures to the dark side, Luke had the WISDOM (not intelligence, again, different things) of knowing that Palpatine was evil and manipulative (after all he saw what happened to his dad) Anakin wasn't afforded that wisdom, he was LITERALLY groomed since he was a child by Palpatine, someone he saw as a close friend, almost a father figure. Finally, feats, even if we ignore Clone Wars where we saw Anakin make two gods of the force bend the knee to him (among many other feats) your argument makes no sense, Luke didn't singlehandedly defeat the empire, yes he was the one who blew up the first death star, but it was ANAKIN who ultimately killed Palpatine, it was LANDO who blew up the second death star, it was HAN who took down the shield generators, it was LEIA who lead the rebellion, it was a team effort. Anakin killed a majority of the Jedi in the temple (WITHOUT Palpatine, and while yes he did have the help of the 501st, the Clones weren't really that big of a help, Anakin did a majority of the work) RoTJ Luke (even if he's amped, which he shouldn't be in the first place) still loses to Knightfall Anakin
@@Bsw_aep people like you who know the truth are the best, most people think Luke was weak and Vader was not fighting serious because off the coreography but they forget that the film was in 1978 obvious that would looks like thay
Oh yeah well if we count experience as "training experience" then yes you are right. You know i kinda did experience here based on age so yeah. Thanks for letting me know! :D
This was meant as the prime AT THAT time. So like you know like prime BOBF luke. But i know what you are trying to say and i am gonna be more careful next time. Thanks! :D
Some people say analin better, but the next gen of anakin is luke, and since ana,in had high counts of midoclorians, amd passed to luke, he got better then vader, and would win.
Ehh. Despite vader holding back and was conflicted amped luke still defeated him. ROTJ luke was stated to be equal to ROTJ vader (Prime vader). And ROTJ Vader mid-high diffs non conflicted KFV which means that luke should also wins mid-high diff but imo luke was just CLOSE to Vader in terms of power in ROTJ so that's why i gave high-extreme diff
Luke used form IV ataru which is a very athletic form In TESB (he used a mixture of form V and IV in ROTJ). Thats why he gets agility above Anakin who used form V
