I love both of the sweaters! I live in Arizona where it is around 110° this week. I also work in a school. I keep a few styles of sweaters that I love around for cold office days and the very few days I can wear them outside. We work hard and I think those sweaters are solid, classic styles you will have fir a long time! Get what makes you feel good. I've recently lost about 65 pounds so some of my sweaters are looser this year but I think sweaters are flexible! Love what you found!
Some days I want to feel like a luau, on vacay or whatever. I use my clothes for a pick me up. I don't do well under the hammer of weight loss. I do better when I keep only what I want to wear tomorrow. I don't want or need a "collection" of clothes. Everyone is different. I liked both sweaters.
How good is their return policy? If you can return for up to 90 days or more, go buy the smaller size in the cardigans…then decide later. The floral top makes you smile; wear it!