Update regarding the events: docs.google.com/document/d/1pTm2N51Ffh_TOiQ0m6IVly0dZrGbifiBZd3eI_2lC70/edit?usp=sharing Would you be interested in seeing a longer version of this video later, once the full picture has emerged?
yep these 2 are crazy good and crzy fast this is their 3thr channel :D 1 and 2 are german ones, I've known and loved them for a long time for good reasons.
To be fair, news outlets *have* to report on this incident immediately, moments after it happens. This RU-vid channel has a few days/week to get the animation and facts done. I don't think it's fair to compare, since time plays a major factor in quality
@@User-friendlyno123They have taken in a ton of anime shows recently. Lot’s of big new shows are animated by them. So I think he just means insane overtime and speed.
We are grateful for the amazing 3D animation you produced; it's among the best and describes everything about the event, including how it went and how people responded to it.
@@Sasan-kz6tu I meant like them too. Like whoever in the future will learn about how big this was. Crazy how we're in 2024 so modern yet that still happened, I think it was intentional planned
Sure, it's good graphics, but there is literally NO info from this. We learned nothing new. Even for 3 days ago; the very first news report I watched relayed the exact same amount of info, minus the graphics.
@@slandsharkFalse. Over 30 minutes prior to the shooting, police were informed about a suspicious individual outside the fences looking in with rangefinder. It was radioed in and local PD started looking for the suspect.
Crooks was spotted on the roof 26 minutes prior to the shooting with a range finder. The PA State Police counter sniper unit were inside of the building when they should have been up on that roof. Sheer negligence, at best. He was spotted by spectators 3 minutes prior to the shooting who immediately relayed his presence to the police. Yet there wasn't a single effort to get Trump off the stage. This whole incident is highly suspicious... Incompetence and negligence on multiple fronts, at best. Saying it was a setup is, objectively, a sensible conclusion once you consider all other factors. The fbi found nothing on his phone and computer, no social media. Registered republican who donates to democrats. Had remote "packages" but nothing indicating how he learned to construct them? Ties to Blackrock and many other details that shouldn't be overlooked.
Yes. This is one of the most horrible parts of this situation, that family went to this rally trusting that they would be safe, no one would have expected this. And that he would die shielding his family. And that they would watch him die. It’s just horrific.
Everybody is talking about the amount of work. I'm over here being astounded by the unbiased recounting of an event... so, actual news. What a concept...
Thank you so much for putting this together. It’s absolutely amazing the amount of information that you put into this resource/video. You were able to answer so many more questions five days ago then.Kimberly Cheatle did today in front of Congress … apparently SS’s investigation is not as advanced as you
@@stope_nope3641except the one they just tried to kill, the only president that's tried to END the foreign wars. Fun probably unrelated fact-JFK was asked to expand Vietnam but he refused and wanted to pull out after a few advisors got killed there.
Except for they deliberately lied about the donation to a progressive group. By the time this video was made, that claim was completely debunked. It was a 64-year old Thomas Crooks living in Pennsylvania as well. It took actual journalists 10 seconds to disprove it within hours of the shooting, yet hacks like this channel deliberately repeat it so that Republicans can pin whatever violence on something other than the sickness within the conservative movement within this country.
@@djdarq6311Doubt someone would risk their life for a presidential campaign. There is no way of knowing when the bullet would reach him, so if the “scripted assassin” didn’t tell him earlier enough to turn his head, he would be dead
when there are multiple flags around and cameras from every angle there's bound to be a flag in some pictures, then it's easy task to choose one with a flag in it for the cover page.
@@southmountain111 Imagine being so extremist that caring about who guards your candidate more than your candidate's life. you should be in a list, since you might attempt the same thing he failed
@@southmountain111which one? The four white guys in the two sniper teams? Or the 5 white guys and one white woman who shielded trump? Seems to me like they were overlooking more competent applicants because they’re racist
@@GoErikTheRed stuff like this genuinely makes me think they don't even care about Trump. My country's president Erdogan also has female secret service agents and he is a very traditionalist guy
It’s eerie how normally we are watching vids just like this about things that happened decades ago- scary this time it’s only been a week and we have audio and video footage that is clear
to do this level of animation, scripting, and editing in a matter of days with more info coming out a day or two later after the shots is crazy impressive, just subbed and i dont know why i did sooner because i watch your vids all the time. great job fern!
They have operated as @simplicissimus for several years in the german language. Recently and due to piracy of their content, they decided to provide those topics to a bigger audience as fern.
@@ninjakiwigames5418It is a whole team yeah. It's a Team of Germans and Dutch people as far as I know. They also have a German channel where they talk about private things.👍
No BS. No editorializing. Just straight facts and some excellent mapping to give us visual learners a much clearer idea of what happened. Fantastic work, ladies and gents on the team that makes these videos.
No offense, but as a method-heavy scientist from the field I *have* to contradict, so please listen and repeat 😅: There is no such thing as visual learners. There is no such thing as visual learners. There is no...
@@thomasschmidt8544I suppose you could say these animations helps those of us with poor 3d visualization visualize the shooting. Is there really no such thing as visual learning? How did psychologists figure that out? (Genuinely curious btw 🧐)
@@IndigoSierra They didn't have anything to figure out. All that visual/audial/kinetic stuff is pseudoscience with no hard backing. Though I think 'pseudoscience' is a bit broad of a category--I'd place this specifically just below Myers-Briggs.
@@SUPRIzEi Everyone does. It's not about which sense is better, it's about having multiple at once, or having the medium tailored to what's being conveyed. In this case having a 3D model is very very relevant.
Three Questions: 1) Why was an obvious target location unsecured? 2) How did the sniper know the location was unsecured? 3) Why did the police ignore the crowd when they spotted the sniper? You can't spot a guy on a roof while people are TELLING you there's a guy on the roof with a rifle? Uh-huh.....Isn't that??!!!
Not even my first set of questions. Apparently this dude was walking around looking up at the roof an hour before.. and then was SEEN by a sniper team while he was using a range finder, and also had a sniper team take a picture of him and label him as suspicious.. until they lost sight of him at least..
Mine at 2:37 because if you watch his head movement closely and think about the angle it definitely saves the former pres. Trump that he moved his head when he did. I just can't get over how close it was, like I keep wondering what it sounded like for him or how he must be feeling now.
In Europe, most of the people think this is just one big plot that's been put up to rise his popularity (to pull attention towards his ''campaign'). No one is going to start a discussion on the fact that someone missed like more than 10 bullets at a speed of 990+ m/s (3250 f/s) on purpose with a 5.56x45mm round or a .223 Remington. And even with Putin right now, it's like more the question of what his influence on the American Elections will be? We've seen it earlier, that Russia chooses the side of Trump, and that with a reason. Putin does this kind of influence because Trump has a very clear vision on NATO. Trump said that everyone should be paying their bills, 'alright we get that; indeed it's fair and square that everyone should pay their bills to stay in and get the benefits of NATO (security, ...). But this man didn't realize that making that decision is going to be the perfect chance for the Chinese/Russians/N-Koreans and so further to improve their influence in even more regions. He is the risk that our safety in general not only in Europe, but also in the US and other parts of the world is getting endangered.
What a great non-partisan breakdown. Better than anything I've seen from any other source including the MSM. I really like your approach, stating details may have already changed but this is what we know so far. To date, we continue to get just bits and pieces of information. This video looks at the entire assassination attempt in its entirety. It gives us perspective of the entire scene, including the line of sight the shooter had, as well as the layout of the two side bleachers. Even if details change this is a very important tool to help the public understand the environment in full. I hope this channel continues to follow this tragedy closely and updates the video as new information is disclosed. Thank you.
What was weird was the part "he will later say that turning over to the right(…)", which makes it sound like a subjective assessment by Trump when that is just objectively what has happened
@@Icetea-2000multiple news outlets have claimed that those were Trump's own words that Trump stated about turning over to the right. Just crazy, he was literally within an inch or less of death. Now they are saying possible multiple shooters but, that update is coming from CNN...?
@@ohohvalerie Well yes he factually did, but even with only portraying facts you can still make them sound a certain way. It’s like how Wikipedia puts everything the authors disagree with or don’t believe in in quotation marks. Like: [He then went on to claim that "extremists" dislike his stance]. In this example theoretically only facts were given if you only look at the words, but they clearly put an opinionated spin on it. Like Trump doesn’t need to say this, it is obvious that that is what would’ve happened had he not turned at that exact moment
What i can't understand is how law enforcement wasn't posted on top of that building. Its the only other structure in the vicinity. Its not like there were 50 rooftops and 1000s of windows that needed to be secured, just one.
Is classic CIA manouver, is always the same... CFK, 9/11, and on and on.. I trully feel sorry for the Northamericans they have no other choice than Republicans or Democrats, but at the end of the day they are just the same...
The local law enforcement told secret service they didn't have enough manpower to secure that building. Secret Service director said the building had a slope on it and was too dangerous for her agents. So they were inside the building. Yeah I know, crazy
I can't believe that i am near a history event and not even a month is completed since this event. Maybe in 2031 , a father says , 'hey son , do you know about the assasination attempt on Donald Trump in the year 2024?'.
What many people are overlooking is that 2 minutes had passed from the time security was alerted of a suspicious man on top of the roof to the moment shots were fired. In this this time they could have interrupted the rally politely asking Trump to step away from the microphone until they further assessed the situation. When it was safe for Trump to speak again he could have resumed. Even if they were waiting for clearance to take the shot on the sniper does mean they needed to wait to take Trump down from the stand. There are many levels of security at a presidential rally. (ground level and top ) All security is in constant communication with one another (microphones in their ears ) so they are always alerted every second.
Seems like u guys just say what u here on x how do u know all this based on the videos. Lets hear officially what was going on before saying they know and shit.
you could literally model the scene in 15 minutes. the people are easily generated with about 20 different plugins, it was pure white... Its good, not complaining, but its not like its 1994 and were taking 30 days to render 1 TREX for jurassic park...
Look at the illustration at 4:54. The angle of the pic shows perfect line of site through the first stands, through microphone, & to back corner of stands, but shooter is to left of this line of sight. This looks more like the window behind & to his right.
Except for they deliberately lied about the donation to a progressive group. By the time this video was made, that claim was completely debunked. It was a 64-year old Thomas Crooks living in Pennsylvania as well. It took actual journalists 10 seconds to disprove it within hours of the shooting, yet hacks like this channel deliberately repeat it so that Republicans can pin whatever violence on something other than the sickness within the conservative movement within this country.
@@kuba_011 Yeah, it just the first assassination attempt on a presidential candidate in 43 years... not relevant at all, lol Get your head outta your butt kid.
@@kuba_011how in gods name do you think this??? This is the first assassination attempt since regan… and this was inches closer. Cmon brother use your head. This moment will be talked about forever and long after the election
@@jollygoodfellow3957bro wtf? He’s saying it’s sad that Trump was shot at and that this will be in the history books at all. The only person with bad intentions here is you lmao
Would be great to see a follow up as more information comes out. The illustration you made looks like bullets would be flying stage left but someone was hit behind him in the crowd to no?
@bayliss2102 You placed Thomas in the right place on the roof but you placed the tree wrong. Look at the satellite photo and you will see that SS has a clear view of Thomas.
@@Ian_Croft I agree. It won't. It will be a blip... then only be known by people who specifically follow this part of U.S. History. There are images from WWII that the average person hasn't seen even 80 years later that are more "historical" than this.
@@henrykwieniawski7233 What you did while you still alive determine how people will see you after you passed away. The fact that he said that to peoples that is suffering is just diabolical and saying he passed a way a good man is laughable. And no, the Japanese never get over it.
@@LeftOverMacNCheese if what @thatrainyboy1670 is true, then yes, I agree what he said was not good. However, let’s put that aside for now and be respectful. His family is mourning.
And the worst part is that trump has yet to reach out to the family to comfort them for what happened, fricking BIDEN reached out to the family to comfort them.
@@avasava7720 Usually, the pain strikes the heart. Losing a firefighter though... it is a guarantee that one of the best of us was stolen from our world.
What’s crazy to me is how people think this is “staged.” Each time I ask someone, have you ever shot a firearm past 25 yards? I have, 300 yards couple weekends each month with a 7-08mm round not even a 5.56x45. Let me tell you, to have him turn his head last minute with the round that close is not possible to be staged. Everything down to the millisecond (wind, breathing, timing) counts. Why the shooter wasn’t neutralized before or what were his motives is another story however his shot placement and BARELY missing his target is clearly not “staged.” Next time anybody has a chance, go to a local range and try taking an AR pattern rifle out shooting 25 yards or beyond consistently at a stationary target (let alone moving one). You’ll see just how difficult it is therefore how impractical the theory he planned to turn his head is.
Solid work here. One thing I suspect and we have not heard yet: pause the video at 3:26 I don't think the sniper team with the blue line fired. In the video, one appears to duck and the other appears to be shifting his weapon when Crooks is hit. I think it's the 2nd team on the other roof to our right. The "view" works better too, since Crooks was using the trees as cover - he knew the snipers were there, he'd scoped them earlier on the rangefinder. The other sniper team would have less foliage branches etc to see through, and these trees are all in full bloom, so with the video showing the blue line team ducking and moving, we see they would have an impossible shot through dense tree cover. That's why I think it's the guys on the right (in the pic). Best work on it I've seen too, again, good work guys.
I think the same way. If you look at the sniper closest in view to the left roof, 3:14 - 3:17 looking through the scope, pulls away from the scope and rifle is no longer trained on his target. When he goes back to the scope, the gun barrel lurches upwards, no longer sighted in on the target. It would take more time to reestablish his target to fire a shot. By that time the assassin is dead. He didn't kill the assassin , just my opinion. And yes I agree the trees in the line of sight is also an obstacle for the left snipers.
Also, the extra tripod they have set up is most likely a "Shot clock" type device that can immediately pinpoint the direction of gunfire. by the time the third round was fired they had a bearing and can immediately track on target. there's no "which way?!"
@@Azactnot republicans, no, trumpists😅he created like some kind of party within party. And Putin do hope for him to become president to solve some of his problems, but it's also naive and childish
@@Azact Republicans aren't but Trump is. He loves dictators. He wants to give Putin and Xi all they ever wanted. REAL republicans want to CRUSH dictatorship and promote democracy. Instead of bowing down to China and Russia....
Bystander: *_"There's a strange guy with a rifle on the roof. Are you going to get Trump away from the lectern and off of the podium?!"_* Police: *_"Why?"_*
Moin, bin hier in einer viel zu warmen Lagerhallte alleine und ohne deine Videos wäre der Tag irgendwann todeslangweilig. Habe dann einfach den Projektor mit dem Handy verbunden und während ich arbeite, werfe ich dich an die Wand und das macht den Tag echt viel angenehmer. Danke für die Videos, mir hilft es auf jeden durch den Tag:) lg, Philipp, Praktikant theMarkenhaus