Who cares if she’s using a prerecorded track. This woman has been belting in 5 octaves for 36 years. Her songs, writing, tones, melodies and runs are some of the most difficult for ANY singer to hit. Let alone someone who has been extremely open about her vocal nodules. She is Mariah. A Legend who has NOTHING to prove. You look so happy and relaxed Mimi. As you should ❤
From someone who has been following MC from the start of her career, my opinion is this - when she began facing vocal challenges and unpredictability with vocal range, all she needed to do was take the much-needed vocal rest, make the adjustments to her songs into the lower keys that would better suit her current voice, and be confident in the fact that she still is and always will be one of the most creative, gifted, and talented singers of all time. Remember, she is A SKILLED VOCALIST, A REAL SINGER - not an entertainer like some they refer to as "singers" today.
@@19burghley 100% - At the end of the day, she is a human being just like the rest of us. And like I've said in other comments before - you're right - she doesn't have to prove anything to anyone. She has already done it, a million times over, and she doesn't have to do it again.
Not sure how young you all are... but being there in 1990 and hearing Vision of Love for the first time.... it was a revelation. There was nothing like it on the radio or on the charts. Im glad I was there! That's it. That's the post.
I think she's doing the pre-recorded vocals thing to sound consistent throughout the run of the residency. The only thing she has to work on now is to be convincing when she's miming, put some effort into it Mother! Haha
@@stmn7286Yeah, she shouldnt be so hard on herself. So many young artists lipsync parts of their songs just like she does. But of course people slander her for that even though shes been rawly singing throughout the 90’s to early 2000’s for decades. She had very little vocal rest back then so honestly people should be less rude about it.
To be fair I didn’t think she was lipping so blatantly here. It’s obvious to a degree but so much better than the old 90s vocals she used to wheel out for Hero and Without You. I agree with you though.
I don´t care if some of the performance is pre-recorded because it's still her voice at the end of the day (throwing a little shade in the direction of another pop-star) Mariah Carey is at least singing her own songs in the studio and we know that she can still sing. 🙂Mariah will always be one of my icons. She came from a family that did not have that much money and she made herself the superstar that we all know today. Without Mariah Carey we would not have the pop-stars that we have today. 🙂
I will be attending her last show on the 27th when I arrive into Vegas from Guam. I noticed you have been in attendance from the 12th, will you be there to see her throughout the end? It would be cool, nevertheless, I will be watching all your post on Mariah’s time in Vegas. Thanks for sharing.👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Haven’t seen an artist get so much negative comments about whether or not a vocal was live. The woman has been singing since the 80’s blowing away any vocals must of us could even attempt. Give her a break, just enjoy one of these legends are still here.
It is pre-recorded. I love Mariah and am a lamb but you will start to see that each recording from every night sounds exactly the same because she’s pre-recorded the whole thing. Literally the occasional ad-lib is live. You’ll also notice in all performances now (at least since the Xmas shows) she constantly looks down at the monitor which is telling her which bits to lip to. It’s unfortunate but that’s the way it is. Her voice is extremely unpredictable these days so I understand the need to do it. But it will also just keep giving haters something to hate about
You know what gets me about all this? The blindness of it all! Everyone that knows Mariah Carey knows that she hates going on tours and doing residencies, she has said it herself. The fact that her manager or her business partners would suggest such a thing as doing residencies or not stopping her from doing it gets me mad. She has to focus on what makes her happy; Like specials, writing songs and releasing new music. You can see from afar that she's sad and lipping her way through all the songs. Why not have her host a show? She's amazing at interviews. Part of a manager's job is trying to branch out people's sources of money. Happiness and health comes first for a legend!
Her delusional yes men adjacent fans are the reasons she keeps performing instead of resting like she should. I’m sure you’ll have one of them defending Mariah in a few minutes
She hates tours but she prefers residencies. She says it allows her more stability and disrupts her Songwriting less plus her family feels more centered.
Regardless of them suggesting it or not. She had a choice and she signed the contract and is collecting her coins, my fellow lamb. Also, I don’t think she’s sad at all.
I agree with you that it’s probably not a good idea to keep touring/doing residencies because her vocals are so unpredictable these days. But the way the music industry is now - it’s the best way to make money. She can say no if she wants to but she’s choosing to do so - even though she doesn’t need the money
You are ON POINT, EXCEPT CLAIMING TO BE AN ARTIST WHEN YOU ARE CLEARLY NOT MEANS YOU ARE TRYING TO HAVE IT BOTH WAYS.......BY KEEP LIP SYNCING YOUR WAY THROUGH. Mariah Carey has been at this fake and phony/manufactured commercial POP FEMALE WANNABE ARTIST from day one. LONG ENOUGH TO SAY I J U S T C A N N O T F A K E. IT A NY. L O N G E R......SO WHAT IS REALLY GOING ON IS POLITICAL HANDLING. SHE DID COME ON MTV SOMETIME BACK WITH A SURPRISE VISIT ADMITTING THAT THE ELATION ABOUT HER AND..... INCLUDING SALES AND BANK ACCOUNT IS NOT SOMETHING SHE KNOWS ABOUT. ALL DRAW QUESTIONS ⁉️ ABOUT HER HAVING A MENTAL BREAKDOWN.
this new arrrangement slays to be honest. I love the whistles. I know she could show out if she decided to really sing live. The little part she does sing live shows her tone is just still there!
@@mayangquia7128 I am probably one of the lambs who is most disappointed in her singing this song lipped. I take pride in Mariah singing this song live forever (never lipped since 1990), this would mean no one I mean no one can touch this song but her. Like I would tell, anyone who argues who's the greatest singer, I would reply , can so and so sing Vision of love live? Now Mariah does not even sing it live. So sad.
Sangat di sayangkan memang, sejak tahun 2023 dia udah lip sync hampir di setiap bagian lagu dan era baru di mulai dia lip sync di semua lagu nya 😢 show 2024 ini her live vocals moment only 2% dibanding tahun sebelumnya masih ada beberapa bagian live vocalnya 50%
@@varenryandi1019 Iya apalagi org² mau liat perform dia nyanyi live tapi malah di kasih rekaman suara dan mariah pun kurang bersemangat tampil akhir² ini apa karna di bosan ama lipSync dia sendiri jadi gak bisa improv kayak dulu² ga usah terlalu jauh deh minimal 2010's masih byk moment suara dia yg bagus bgt dan worth it di nikmati
@@alexandersezgin5186 Banyak banget delusional lamb yang aku lihat di komen justru itu gak baik bikin dia terlena dalam lipsync aku khawatir aja ya namanya malfunction sound system bisa aja terjadi dan bakalan ketahuan bgt dia lipsync seluruh lagu 😌 dan aku jadi yakin kenapa mariah jarang bgt di undang utk nyanyi lagi di event gede karna dia gak bisa nyanyi tanpa band dan engineer sound team nyaaa sedih bgt semoga ada perubahan deh 🥹
@@varenryandi1019 banget, banyak yg delulu jg bilang ini live lah itu lah, padahal true lamb pasti BISA BANGET bedain pas dia nge live sama engga, energy nya beda, ini bener bener PLOH aja ga ada excited”nya dia Dari tahun 2022 jg udah makin worse, tapi peeknya “boring” performance ya 2023 kemarin, banyak nunduk liat monitor, i mean it’s impossible mimi ga hafal lirik lagi VOL
@@alexandersezgin5186 duh 2010 - 2016 tu banyak banget moment suara dia yg masih magical, tonenya jg bagus banget masih Udah hopeless ga sih sekarang tu, kek yang “ya udah lah” yg penting mimi masih mau tampil walau ya itu persentase “live” nya makin lama makin dikit
Live live live, even if it wasnt its still her. A guy studying BA Music once said to look at the neck, not lips, to see if it's live cos there's so much technology going on before you hear it.
I don't know why people hate Mariah so much just because at 55 her voice is not as strong as it was at 25! Don't you know that literally every part of our body slowly deteriorates as we age including the vocal cords? And on top of that she has vocal nodules. This woman has worked her ass off, been to hell and back, written produced and sung original songs, influenced the music industry during her more than 30 years career and pushed her voice to the extreme to give us some of the best vocal performances in music history during the Vision of Love to the Daydream era. Today's tiktok insta-fame generation will never understand that once upon a time you actually had to hustle, work and pray for a break like walking the streets of New York with a cassette tape of your personal collection of original songs knocking on doors of record companies trying to get them to listen to your music. What is your claim to fame, hater?
@@1984musicmanI know right I've listened to every version of this song and literally have never heard her sing it like this in studio or on stage so in my Opinion this is 100% LIVE
Objective Assessment OR Wishful thinking FOR HER....... Mariah must have done what you suggest pertaining to a vocal coach.......BUT FOR HER EVER BEING A GREAT VOICE SINGER AND SONGWRITER IS NOT SOMETHING EXPECTED TO EVER HAPPEN. A WORD OR TWO ADDED TO SOMEONE ELSE WRITING DOES NOT ALLOE HER TO CLAIM SHE IS A SONG WRITER. WOULD BE INTERESTING TO SEE THE ACTUAL WRITER AND VOCALIST WE HEAR ON THE PRE-RECORDED TAPES AND THOSE SHE IS TRYINK TO SING OVER DURING LIVR PERFORMANCE WOULD STEP OUT FRONT AND CLAIM THEIR BRAGGING RIGHTS. AND IF SHE IS THAT GREAT OF A PERSON AND CAN HOLD HER OWN AS A SOLO ARTIST....WHY HAS SHE HAD SO MANY TURMOIL RELATIONSHIPS. WEIRD TO SAY THE LEAST.
@@mavrickhentsibayan395 truthfully, it might not be lol BUT!! Ever since they’ve been broken up there’s been an obvious change in how she looks nowadays. It’s either the break up or it could be meds for her bipolar disorder. Who knows.
@@JD-xd4sy awww she has to toughen up then. She’s loved because of her songs and her voice, more than her personality and looks. okay She’s Mariah because she’s the greatest SINGER VOCALIST
Lip-synced and totally lackluster. Why go on a residency when you hate live events??? I will never understand that... Does she need the money?? She seems to be so rich.
THE WAY SHE KEEPS LOOKING DOWN IN EVERY SONG TO READ THE LYRICS WTF!!!!!!!!!!! I love her but man she's just lost the spark. Boring concert, I'd rather listen to her at home.
Blerg!!! Shes lipping ALL that songs and barelly can Sing. RIP Mariah. 2024 Its her worst year. I wont spend my money to see her in rock in rio. She moves like a robot
She looks fantastic but she’s obviously lip syncing. Either way, she looks great, and at this point, she has nothing to prove to anyone. She’s already a legend.
She has nothing to prove? she has lots of things to prove to people who spent their hard earned money to go to her shows. She needs to prove that she sings live
To those saying that this is live, just watch the video below ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-NglEHmozxDc.htmlsi=1K_3Pyfp4MILPDbQ Then compare Mariah's body language, movements, mouth angles,etc. with this video. It should be clear that she was singing VOL fully live way back in 2016. Unfortunately, she clearly lipped this performance now in 2024.Watching both videos back and forth should give you all some kind of clarity.
*lipped.. there's a disconnect.. and it just not believable anymore..even her starting note she lipped it awkwardly timed... she doesn't even try any more.. is this all thats left?*
Ppl are gonna hate and say is lipped because she sounds better than their favorite artist. This is night two and she sang it different, the whistle note at the end was even shorter than the first show. Just give the girl her credit. She sounds amazing and looks amazing.🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷
“Sounds better than your favorite artist” is a very ignorant go to. Especially when we know Mariah has declined, she is lip syncing, and there’s several artist of the past 20 years that sing better than her. It’s ok to be a fan of someone and be open minded and up front about them at the same time.
Its live people. She has being doing vocal rehab. She is ysing her front resonators instead, she is singing closer to the climax of We belong tigether BET Bluprint where you could feel the squeals in the nose, her larynx is a nit higher and it does not sound pre-recorded at all, I dont know why people are getting confused she is releasing that chestier sound as she has done in the past she is learning again to sing in a different voice and that whistle is as luve as it can be. I mean she pulls her lips back completely showing her teeth, the movement of the jaw is very exact, she is shortening the vocal tract because higher brighter notes need shorter tracts, thats why in her very lows she purses her lips, is called technique, when lipping a whistle sometimes she only open her mouth but not here (FYI the run in the whistle does not require movement fron the mouth because whistle is a guttural sound) and listen to the last whistle she moves from the mic and volume is completely changed
Please stop - every single night sounds exactly the same. Note for note. She has recorded new versions of all songs for this residency. Her voice is too unpredictable so she lips
She lipped literally 98% of the entire show stop writing delusional fabrications here and keep it real! I’ve been a lamb for over a decade and can instantly tell when she’s lipping and when it’s live
