Тёмный

Mcintosh and Audio Research, which is better? 

Thomas & Stereo
Подписаться 81 тыс.
Просмотров 138 тыс.
50% 1

Gear used in this video:
Mcintosh C2300 tube preamp
Mcintosh MC275 tube poweramp
Audio Research LS25 tube preamp
Audio Research Reference 75 tube amp
Focal Sopra 2 speakers
Topping D90 DAC
------------------------------
Track: Left Alone - Airixis [Audio Library Release]
Music provided by Audio Library Plus
Watch: • Left Alone - Airixis |...
Free Download / Stream: alplus.io/left...
------------------------------

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 608   
@lbamusic
@lbamusic Год назад
Thanks much for taking the time to make this vid. I just came across your channel. I heard my first Mac system in the 1960s when I was stationed in the Military near Seattle, Wa. I never forgot the sound and how it made me feel. Everytime I went to an Audio store I would always listen to their Macs and compare with other brands (Accuphase, Luxman etc). Finally in the early 90s I purchased the Mac Amp and Pre-amp that I still have and enjoy almost daily. I am now almost 82 yrs old, I know there are many good sounding brands out there that are loved by their owners, but Macs are still my favs. Im still on the Mac mailing list and just yesterday I received news of their new Hybrids of solid state and tubes. I will have to find a dealer and have a listen. Maybe you can review one of these models - thanks again for your vid.
@mpp9964
@mpp9964 2 года назад
Thomas - congrats, your ability to deliver and convey your thoughts on audio has progressed to the point where I really believe you are the best out there right now. Has been amazing to watch your journey. Please keep sharing your insights with us who share your interest in the hobby.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Wow, thank you!
@CP-oe3kt
@CP-oe3kt 2 года назад
100% agree. I am a subscriber of most of the good reviewers and Thomas is my favourite. He always talks about the things I want to know when purchasing new gear. Great video as always Thomas!
@kindface
@kindface 4 месяца назад
Totally agree. I first stumbled upon Thomas' cross-town fellow reviewer who owns an audio shop and was first captivated by his reviews. At first, I found that reviewer quite illuminating. Very soon, I discerned a pattern there: his reviews are always clothed in so much vague and circuitous language and always ends without much clarity over what his preference really was. Even his "dislikes" are soft cop-outs (almost always nothing to do with the sound of the gear) as if he didn't want to offend the brands he was selling. Thomas, on the other hand, cuts right to the nuances and always ends with very incisive conclusions supporting his preferences.
@davidstein9129
@davidstein9129 4 месяца назад
I agree. Thomas is wonderful. Our audio community continues to benefit from his great videos, most of his preferences and points of views. Thanks Thomas & keep up the good work.
@denniswaske
@denniswaske 2 года назад
got my mac's used in the late 70's. they were recommended by a friend that is a electrical engineer. he said that they were built to near military standard. still enjoy them. took them to a mac service center to have them recapped couple years ago. technician told me not to bother. 50 years without being serviced. have gone thru many speakers, turntables etc, but these are still the foundation of my main system.
@gil3green
@gil3green 2 года назад
While upgrading my system, I was looking and reading about everything but Mcintosh. Then I realized over the years I had been hearing great systems driven by Mcintosh amps. Ended up with Mcintosh MC462. No regrets I love it!
@garytoddvolquardts126
@garytoddvolquardts126 7 месяцев назад
This old but I love My mc462
@leeloopatsy
@leeloopatsy 2 года назад
I would say it depends on what you’re looking for. If you want a “live” sound then go for the AR, it feels like the band is in your living room. If you want HiFi then go for the McIntosh, it’s real high end and you’ll get a perfect sound. Both are absolutely great and fantastic.
@saphiregin
@saphiregin 2 года назад
"We do stuff just for fun"! I absolutely agree that a big part of listening to music & equipment should be fun!
@michaelcollins2473
@michaelcollins2473 2 года назад
That Audio Research setup is straight-up awesome. Fantastic!
@timali4976
@timali4976 2 года назад
I really appreciate this kind of vid and totally enjoyed seeing the gear and the mcintosh startup. It's very unlikely I'll ever see gear like this in person so for me it was very enjoyable.
@jianboo
@jianboo 2 года назад
Hey Thomas, I wanted to send my thanks to you for adding a/b demo at the end of your video. Most people who wanted to sell something on their channel would invalidate this video making thousands of excuses, but the videos / sounds do translate the content's point of view. Kudos to you and your buddies.
@philthomas8351
@philthomas8351 2 года назад
On a side note, I have a Conrad-Johnson tube pre-amp 20 years old. It sounds great. Smoothed out the solid state amp I use with it. No problems. Cost me $795 bucks.
@jeremiahchamberlin4499
@jeremiahchamberlin4499 2 года назад
I appreciated the comparison of two relatively high-end tube amps. I looked longingly at McIntosh’s offerings, and I especially like the models with dual Vu meters. Everyone says they hold their value. But they also have configurations that integrate more functions than I want (like DACs), or proprietary connections (like their own transports). If I do find the configuration I want, the price is through the roof. I’m not saying their systems don’t offer value for money, especially in light of the company’s support and customer’s experience of long and trouble-free service; I’m just saying I couldn’t find what I was looking for at a price I was willing (or able) to pay. A critic might say I brought my trouble on myself by trying to use gear from different manufacturers in the same system. If you opt for McIntosh, I can certainly see why people go all in with them. They make upgrading within their own offerings very easy. 🙂
@raphaelmeillat8527
@raphaelmeillat8527 2 года назад
Great video Thomas. Love hearing your stories. Nice to see mini videos of your friends' systems integrated in here! Cheers from France.
@jfarlandutube
@jfarlandutube 2 года назад
Wow you can really hear the difference between those two set ups on your songs at the end. I have to agree with your assessment of the difference between the two sounds signatures. I have a lot of old Macintosh equipment and I tend to like that sound.
@djfirestormx
@djfirestormx 2 года назад
I love audio research more myself, because I use to record in a studio and I by nature avoid artificial tonality. But that being said it is nothing bad to say about adding colour. Simply by making it neutral actually enables people to add colour easier. It is easier to add than take away!
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
My friend Mr. Vintage believes the same.
@adaboy4z
@adaboy4z 2 года назад
Definitely review the high end gear! You present content very well like the amp that demands your attention!!
@brianvportugal1155
@brianvportugal1155 2 года назад
I love your videos and would be really interested in hearing more system reviews. Synergy is so important and I’m not good at figuring that out. When you combine cables it’s very complicated .
@baycchief3785
@baycchief3785 2 года назад
I have listened and auditioned many high-end systems for both music and movie (especially music) and will always be resorting back to the Mcintosh gears.
@nancright1352
@nancright1352 2 года назад
In the early 90s I went into my 1st high end audio shop over in Pasadena ca. I herd the AR gear and was HOOKED for life. My jaw dropped and knew I was wrecked :).
@MDVEEJAZZ
@MDVEEJAZZ Год назад
You probably went to GNP on Colorado Blvd. I had the exact same experience and have been hooked for life as well. I'd go there at least twice a month, sit for hours at a time listening to different configurations. I found that in the 90's, Transparent interconnects and speaker runs, coupled with Theil speakers was a hard sound to beat. Most of my ARC gear is from that era.
@jeffkalina7727
@jeffkalina7727 2 года назад
Would love to see you add the Pass Labs INT25 to the mix next time. Get a new ARC I-50 and have some fun!!
@repairfreak
@repairfreak 2 года назад
Hello, it has always been a dream of mine to own a Mcintosh audio amp of any type. Unfortunately marriage to a widow with 6 children put many things as a priority before a sound system. I’m 55 years old now and I still hope and dream to someday get a Macintosh Labs product. Even if it is broken, I have the ability to fix such things. I have been fixing gear for over 30 years now, but it is always somebody else’s. Thanks for the wonderful video, your equipment sounds and looks amazing!
@anthonyhopkin
@anthonyhopkin 2 года назад
Thanks Thomas for another excellent share. Yes - please - I vote for more ARC and McIntosh discussions. Greetings to you and yours
@HD-su9sq
@HD-su9sq 2 года назад
Wise words as always, Thomas! I can’t afford either, but now that you showed the McIntosh powering up, I’d have to buy that. I would spend all day turning it off and on, to see the tubes light up and change colour!
@stanstanly3812
@stanstanly3812 Год назад
Thank you for your thoughts. I decided on a McIntosh and bought a MC5300 intergraded amp. Very, very happy with it. Please keep posting your insightful videos.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo Год назад
Good choice!
@user-od9iz9cv1w
@user-od9iz9cv1w 2 года назад
Really enjoyed this discussion. I appreciate the discussion of high end audio, and these are two great brands to compare. I'd love to hear the comparison now of AR vs Pass Labs. To me both have a sound that catches my attention in a good way. I always love the look of the 275, but when I heard it at an audio show, I was very disappointed in the sound. It seemed colored and vailed. So it was interesting to hear that they have changed since the 70's. Your description of the AR system suggests to me that it passes more low level information. That is a positive thing for me especially on very well recorded music without a lot of trickery in the mastering. Keep this up. I'll enjoy it and you will get to rediscover your own gear.
@ac81017
@ac81017 2 года назад
I have the ARC ls17 pre together with a Mcintosh mc302, a match made in heaven,best of both worlds.
@davidrusso4750
@davidrusso4750 2 года назад
I rather enjoy direct comparisons. One rarely sees this type of review. Good job and thank you.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Glad you liked it!
@davidmusoke
@davidmusoke Год назад
I'm amazed I could tell the difference. The AR system is more open and the highs are very visible versus the warmish muted sound of the McIntosh system.
@emerycomputer
@emerycomputer 4 месяца назад
Ditto. Same sentiments here. I was considering getting Mac for the prestige and looks but have gradually moved away from that notion, in favor of other brands. AR is one of my top choices now.
@ryankmusic
@ryankmusic 2 года назад
Awesome. Yes I’d love to hear some reviews of the 275, 3200, and the AR gear. I would also love to see reviews of Vintage Mac, because a lot of us own them (like me) and don’t have a real reference point with modern day reviewing. I’d tune in all day to that!
@akeeperofoddknowledge4956
@akeeperofoddknowledge4956 2 года назад
I really enjoyed this conversation about two iconic name brands I could never afford! Love the looks of the Audio Research. I'm still enjoying my entry-level 250 watts/channel Acurrus A250 power amp and P10 preamp I bought new in 1994. That's about as close to high-end gear I'll probably get. I just get better speakers every 10 years or so. But I love learning about all the other hi-end gear that's out there! Thanks for sharing!
@OMDF01
@OMDF01 2 года назад
Those Acurus/Aragon amps were built like tanks by Mondial Designs back then… (!).
@f430ferrari5
@f430ferrari5 Год назад
I have the Acurus A200 and A200x3. Love it. Still works great.
@Clint_the_Audio-Photo_Guy
@Clint_the_Audio-Photo_Guy 2 года назад
I had a customer who built a full blown reference Audio Research System. Anniversary reference 600 watt tube monoblocks, two chassis preamp, CD transport, and so on. He paired it with 600lb Duntech speakers. What a great sounding system. Though I carry McIntosh and Mark Levinson, for audio I never had anything high-end enough for him. Sadly he passed away a bit over a year ago. I did get to build his home theater though, a serious undertaking.
@greenskyrocket
@greenskyrocket Год назад
Duntech Sovereigns? I heard them once back in the early 90’s, the experience has stayed with me ever since. They were driven by a ME 750 amp as I recall.
@Clint_the_Audio-Photo_Guy
@Clint_the_Audio-Photo_Guy Год назад
@@greenskyrocket Yep, those are the ones. He wanted to upgrade to something higher end too, and I tried to tell him, it doesn't get much higher end than that.
@johngutmanis3580
@johngutmanis3580 2 года назад
Great video! I almost pulled the trigger on the McIntosh mc275 until I tried the Carver Crimson 275. Jim Clark audio in Chicago gives you 30 days to demo a new unit. If you don’t like it, send it back for a full refund. After two weeks I knew I was keeping the Carver. I love McIntosh, I have the c50 preamp, mc352 amp, Magnepan 1.7i & Klipsch Hersey IV’s, DIY Cornscala’s. I really wanted another McIntosh in the room, but when I heard the Crimson I just did not think the mc275 was worth an extra $2500! I also own a Yamaha p2200 amp that sounds just like the mc352, but I spent 3K more to get the McIntosh looks in the mc352. The yellow meters in the Yamaha just did not move me like the blue McIntosh meters do. Keep up the good work!
@stevezeidman7224
@stevezeidman7224 2 года назад
I’ve got a MC2002 from the mid 80s. It is 200 wpc direct coupled, no autoformers. This amp is not warm nor does it have slow bass. It’s clean and clear. I can say because I’ve also got an MC2155 with autoformers. It’s also from mid 80s and it is a touch warm colored. You match them with appropriate speakers and DACs and voila, you have magic.
@markscott7583
@markscott7583 2 года назад
This video is officially approved by the RU-vid Audiophile Board. :) Enjoyed this - informal experience videos are a great addition to the channel. This passion is all about sharing experiences.
@stuartblum2389
@stuartblum2389 2 года назад
My MAC6700 is my first stereo amp and it remains my one and only stereo amp. 🤘🏻
@maurice4407
@maurice4407 2 года назад
I love McIntosh gear, for the sound and for the look but more important they are made in the USA and McIntosh still supports 95% of all the equipment they've made in the past. I think that alone makes McIntosh unique in the high end audio world, right?
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
And they keep their value.
@johngutmanis3580
@johngutmanis3580 2 года назад
AR is designed and built in Maple Grove Minnesota, USA. And they also support many of their older models.
@bryanherr1093
@bryanherr1093 2 года назад
Just like AR.
@2HatHudders
@2HatHudders 2 года назад
@@ThomasAndStereo this is the.most important part to be honest.
@bikemike1118
@bikemike1118 2 года назад
@@2HatHudders are you a flipper? Or why is that more important to you than the actual sound quality?
@stimpy1226
@stimpy1226 2 года назад
Each listener has their own perceived sound in home audio equipment. We should respect their opinions about their own own systems or a new piece of gear. And they should respect our perceived listening experiences as well. I have not listened to Macintosh equipment since the 1960s and it was so overly warm I never wanted to hear their products again but now I am going to set up an appointment for a sit down. Currently I am using PASS phono and line stage preamps with an Audio Research amp driving Maggie 3.6 speakers and a carver true subwoofer. The only thing I really need to add is a second subwoofer and I am considering selling the Carver and moving over to 2 REL’s. Thanks for your balanced presentations and opinions. A breath of fresh air.
@feloniusdrunk
@feloniusdrunk 2 года назад
That audio research combo sounded much more like a fully digital system to me, which came as a complete surprise (even though you already explained about it).
@audioconnection4450
@audioconnection4450 Год назад
Don't be surprised that the dated LS 25 used had old dryer caps compared to a more current day LS 28 that should of be used then the Caps in the pre would have matched with the ARC 75 series design.
@AudiS4orce1
@AudiS4orce1 2 года назад
Very interesting comparison, on the sound comparison (with youtube compression), I can CLEARLY hear a MAJOR difference! Audio Research sounds like having MORE REVERB, more open, and sound more like live recording, while McIntosh sound more like studio recording. McIntosh sounds more "natural" to me, but it's impossible to say unless you're in the room!
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Great point!
@Darrylizer1
@Darrylizer1 2 года назад
One thing is for sure the Audio Research sounds louder.
@toddhupp
@toddhupp 2 года назад
Interesting Goliath vs Goliath commentary by Thomas. Who needs a Christmas tree with the Macintosh power amp!
@theorangeguyna6762
@theorangeguyna6762 2 года назад
I enjoy all your videos Thomas. Thank you. I think I’m learning something with each one that I watch 😀
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Glad you like them!
@keithperry602
@keithperry602 2 года назад
Thank you very much for your analysis and opinions! I actually agree with observations. I've owned Audio Research gere for twenty years and agree with your statement of it commanding your attention. It very natural and neutral. Thanks again!
@ernestyount3061
@ernestyount3061 2 года назад
Great video, down to earth discussion of your likes. Loved it.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@stimpy1226
@stimpy1226 Год назад
I'm following up a comment that I made 10 months ago. I use Pass line stage and phono preamps with an Audio Research amplifier feeding Maggie 3.6 R's. I can honestly say that the system synergy with this combination is outstanding to my ears.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo Год назад
Nice.
@mesonto
@mesonto 2 года назад
The reason I like one over the other is the transparency... and one is easily much better than the other. This is why I crave an Audio Research and I only enjoy the Macintosh. You can even hear the difference in the RU-vid video, it's like a veil has been lifted in front of the music. It's obvious and so impactful.
@estenray6685
@estenray6685 2 года назад
Thanks Thomas for another great post! I’ve always been around McIntosh gear as that was what my father was in to. So now I too have a McIntosh power amp a MC 162 and pre amp a C39. The only Acoustic Research gear I’ve owned has been their famous old school belt drive turntable and a pair of their old (not so good) book shelve speakers. I’ve never heard or experienced any of their power or preamps! I’m now quite curious and will look for them in the future.
@immovableobjectify
@immovableobjectify 2 года назад
Audio Research is a completely different company than Acoustic Research.
@estenray6685
@estenray6685 2 года назад
@@immovableobjectify Thank you for pointing that out Brett. I have never seen or heard of Audio Research products before and I apologize for my ignorance this is the first time I have been made aware of them. I will proceed to Google where I will look them up and hopefully become better informed.
@01sapphireGTS
@01sapphireGTS 2 года назад
The very first stand-alone power amplifier I ever bought was an Audio Research D-100 (maybe the D-100B model). I liked it a lot for what it was.
@countdebleauchamp
@countdebleauchamp Год назад
I had one of those. Fabulous match with Acoustic Energy AE1's.
@rctony710
@rctony710 2 года назад
Great video Thomas yep I'm still rocken my old McIntosh amps. I love that old slow bass cause it never gets tiring. I listen to mostly jazz and it plays it so Damm well. McIntosh play jazz so well it really tames the horns and as for the slow bass it gives more definition to the acoustic bass as if you can see the strings. Yeah at times I'd like more air but you can't have everything
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Yup, you have a kick ass system.
@genez429
@genez429 2 года назад
I used to be an audio salesman back in the 70's. I grabbed up a customer trade in on first sight. It was a MC 275. It needed to be refurbished, and was upgraded slightly in the process. Now in the 70's.. I found other tube amps to be slower than the Mac. On a few recordings I found the damping to be a little weak. But, the sound with my KEF 104 AB's could be astounding.
@hvg3488
@hvg3488 Год назад
The best amplifier is the one which results in a great match with certain speaker. It is about finding system synergy.
@l.ralphmellon1716
@l.ralphmellon1716 2 года назад
My system consists of McIntosh MC352 (for the bass) and MC275 Mk VI (for the mids and highs) biamplification, and Audio Research LS28 SE preamplification, with von Schweikert Audio speakers. It's my 7th heaven!
@yvesboutin5604
@yvesboutin5604 2 года назад
Switching on the Mcintosh is like looking at a Christmas tree with all the lights blinking!
@SantanKGhey1234
@SantanKGhey1234 2 года назад
Love this Thomas! I love my MC402 & C2600 tube! I was using it with a Denafrips Ares ii.. realizing everything was too warm... then i recently moved to a D90SE.... Now with its granular detail its an incredible balance of synergy with the Macs!..... i know you had a video recently about matching and synergy... thats all it comes down to... much of the gear out there today is excellent.. its all about how each match to each other in pleasing the listeners ears
@dannyng5427
@dannyng5427 2 года назад
I own Ares II and I didn't find it lacks detail.
@SantanKGhey1234
@SantanKGhey1234 2 года назад
@@dannyng5427 i never said it lacked detail... it is a warm DAC, great depth and soundstage.... because my McIntosh gear is already warmish... the combo was too warm.... D90SE has a different neutral tone and clarity... better balancing the rest of my system
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Its all relative, put it against the D90se and there is more detail. Mind you, the Ares II has plenty of detail already.
@DirectX3
@DirectX3 Год назад
I went from the vintage McIntosh to Threshold, Mark Levison, ASR, then my ears are like old red wine today I returned to the New MA7900. I had few years into tube amps but tired of changing tubes. Anyway, my thought is McIntosh is a overall good system that I can close my eyes and forget about it.
@liangyuchen6523
@liangyuchen6523 2 года назад
Nice video, I owned one MA7200 with atc20, the mid-range is so well that you can't forget, but it is soft. I will like to try Audio research later. Thanks for your work.
@markfischer3626
@markfischer3626 2 года назад
Once upon a time when I was young and an audiophile I'd have loved any of this equipment. In those days I couldn't possibly afford it. It's amazing what becoming an engineer does to you, how drastically it remolds your mind. Setting out to understand sound and acoustics I pretty much lost interest in the equipment. It became a means to an end, it was the system design that mattered. When I became able to afford any of it, it never entered my mind for one second to buy any of it. Instead my adventure in sound went in an entirely different direction. It is remarkable how complicated sound really is and there are so many variables to deal with. Creating something new and entirely different takes a lot of effort but you don't mind if it's a labor if love. Nearly 50 years and I'm still having fun experimenting, adjusting tweaking. I know what I want to hear and I figured out how to get it. The older equipment works just fine for my purposes. Yet I can relive my early days watching you and others who see things as I once did. I'm not being judgmental. In a way I admire your enthusiasm and enjoy watching your adventure, how you explore things and how your views change over time.
@pedrocols
@pedrocols 2 года назад
Audio is as subjective as it gets.
@markfischer3626
@markfischer3626 2 года назад
@@pedrocols The sound field that reaches your ears is a physical fact. How your brain reacts to what your ears send to it is subjective.
@pedrocols
@pedrocols 2 года назад
@@markfischer3626 Precisely! Frequencies are frequencies.
@2HatHudders
@2HatHudders 2 года назад
I would be curious to understand your tastes regarding sound signature and perhaps what's changed for you as you matured in life? 😊
@markfischer3626
@markfischer3626 2 года назад
@@2HatHudders I have listened to and enjoyed live and recorded music literally all of my life. One of my prize possessions when I was a toddler was a phonograph. There were always musical instruments being played in my house and I began attending live concerts when I was about 5 years old so the sounds of live music heard at concert venues was strongly implanted in my brain and memory. When I was about 12 years old I heard stereophonic sound for the first time and I loved it. That's when I became an audiophile. The industry promised me they were working towards ""concert hall realism" from recordings. When I was 25 and already a well educated scientist and engineer I built a quadraphonic system based on the industry's hype. It was a crushing disappointment. I set out to figure out what was wrong with it, what it needed to do and what it was doing instead.. And when after using the powerful analytical tools I'd acquired in my education I figured it out to my amazement and that's when I threw my audiophile hat in the trash never to be worn again. So I wanted a machine that would create the sound of concert hall realism from a recording in my home and I invented it. Is it easy? No. Is is complicated? Very. Was it expensive? Not by audiophile standards. My interests are mostly classical music but I listen to other genres as well. Most of what is marketed as music today has no interest for me.
@realworldaudio
@realworldaudio 2 года назад
Hi Thomas, I know that a number of serious audiophiles do not consider sound demos definitive. Yet, using the same recording method, same song, same encoding, we do get impressions which are easily comparable to each other. The system in this video with both amps do convey the scale and the clarity, my favorite two versions so far! Thank you! ; Janos
@jean-pierrethibaudeau7201
@jean-pierrethibaudeau7201 2 года назад
Since you own both amps, vintage and modern, it would be nice to see a video comparison between the old MC240 and the recent MC275; how a 50 years of evolution have changed the sound of the McIntosh gear.
@anukrw
@anukrw 2 года назад
I would love for you to review Bob Carvers relatively new gear. His crimson 350 will will give these Macs a run for its sound.. Would be amazing for you to step out of your usual zone and give these a receive.. keep up the amazing work.
@freelancer1499
@freelancer1499 2 года назад
Hi Thomas! Love such content from you! While I am more of a desktop nearfield or headphone listener, I very much appreciate such videos. This video is only possible thru lotta time and dollar spend and half a lifetime of experience. Thank you. Maybe one day I will have the space :D
@robertyoung1777
@robertyoung1777 2 года назад
Hi all - I have an AR D400 MKII solid state amp for summer listening and an AR VT100 tube amp for winter. The tubes run too hot for summer use. Thomas explained their sound qualities well. High definition with great bass. The down side is that male vocals don’t sound all there to me. A little weak in the midrange. Both amps have what Thomas called a a live sound and I like that. Great customer service from ARC.
@jamesnelson8549
@jamesnelson8549 2 года назад
I agree with the “AIR” of Audio Research!!! That is why Audio Research sounds great with Magnapan!!!!! But the modern McIntosh is fabulous!!! I have the C2700 preamp & MC312 power amp!
@mesonto
@mesonto 2 года назад
Thomas, wrote here earlier just how much more the Audio Research "lifted the vail in front of the music" vs the Macintish... the obvious increase of transparency over the venerable Macintosh. (Actually saw this video much earlier though.) Well, I watched a few more videos afterwards, did a bit of research, auditioned it and took ownership of an Audio Research 6SE. The transparency and detail is incredible. It certainly will take some time to get used to the articulation of this preamp though. Your video was the catalyst.
@DynamicAudio
@DynamicAudio 2 года назад
Can't say I have lot of experience with Audio Research gear. Few month back I tried the Ref 6 SE with my previous Plinius Reference A300 power amp. It sounded very nice indeed. Great synergy. May get it back one day to try with my current gear!
@nathans5773
@nathans5773 2 года назад
You do you, Thomas. Good stuff as always.
@JingoLoBa57
@JingoLoBa57 2 года назад
Okk The LS10 is a solid state classic from ARC, it’s super musical, and brings all the music to the soundstage, precise, clear, transparent and yet kicks butt on the low end. And the D240 MkII is a 120W/8ohm 240W/4ohm sweet and punchy amp classic. Frankly I can’t be bothered trying tube amps now, my systems have stabilized on greatness. No more Line Magnetics or even Finale a fine Canadian tube company products… nor 845 or 805 and the only sound I’d like to hear again is a good KT88.
@JingoLoBa57
@JingoLoBa57 2 года назад
But I’m in no rush to hear anything else… maybe I should post some of my current and past system’s recordings.
@korling99
@korling99 2 года назад
I have a MC-240 and MX-110. I’d love to see a video of your MC-240 setup and pairing!
@HiFiTurtle
@HiFiTurtle 2 года назад
That start up sequence for the MC275 VI was actually just a gimmick they made for the tradeshow debut of the amp. After feedback they got from attendees they decided to make it a real feature. Been thinking about trying tubes in my system again.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Well you Kanta are easy to drive so getting a tube amp is a good idea to experiment.
@normloo1590
@normloo1590 2 года назад
Very nice video. I too like " color" in my playback electronics, not too much but just enough. Modern Ultra High-end electronics (all those Swiss made stuff) are more like the AR sound. Clean, fast, focus, and neutral sounding. This type of presentation is very captivating. But I also find this "new sound" to be distracting from the essences of the music being played, and directs your focus on the nuances of what the electronics is capable of reproducing. A highly resolving system can be a double-edge sword. To reinforce your point, system synergy is key.
@RJ_Chicago
@RJ_Chicago 2 года назад
Thomas, thanks for the great video as usual. Please do review the McIntosh gear you have. If you are reviewing the power amp if you can give some perspective and compare it to some other high end non-McInosh tube amps you may have, that will be really insightful and perhaps demonstrate to those of us who haven’t spent time with Mac gear what makes them so special.
@DR.Detroit11
@DR.Detroit11 2 года назад
I am considering this exact mac system. Thank you Thomas would love a review.
@johnstone7697
@johnstone7697 2 года назад
McIntosh gear is as conservative as it gets. This buys you good reliability, excellent resale value, and decent sound. But it doesn't buy you the best possible sound quality. Going all the way back to the early days, Mac stuff was designed to be, first and foremost, rugged and reliable. It was really originally designed for use in commercial applications. The tube power amps run in Class B with very low idling current. This makes the tubes last a long time, but it also generates crossover distortion. McIntosh "cures" this by using gobs and gobs of negative feedback. The output stage, with its cathode coupling provides huge amounts of local feedback around the output stage, which cancels crossover distortion. On top of this, global feedback is also used. The driver stages have to swing the full output signal voltage to make up for the fact that the output stage has virtually no voltage gain. A McIntosh tube amp clips almost like a standard solid state amp. No "soft clipping" in this design. Opinions about what sounds better are just that: opinions. I've owned lots of tube gear, including McIntosh, Marantz, Dynaco, etc., and have heard lots more. I'll take a Marantz 9 over a Mac 275 any day of the week. That just my opinion, and that said, I don't think their stuff is "terrible" by any stretch. Just a bit more show than go. And I may be in a minority here, but I think the styling is downright ugly....glitzy and overdone.
@JingoLoBa57
@JingoLoBa57 2 года назад
Great topic, nothing like controversy to stir the ratings numbers up! So let’s fuel the fire 🔥 I have never liked the McIntosh look or sound. Have heard different things from my friends. I own three pieces of Audio Research gear, the Ref CD9, LS10 pre and D240 MkII power amps. They’re the best I’ve owned and beat my Esoteric and PassLabs gear. Mind you the Luxman M900u takes care of pumping out the cd direct and digital streaming via coaxial through my CD9 outputs via the LS10SE feed, its all about the synergy.
@photoipster
@photoipster 2 года назад
I’d love a review of McIntosh integrateds!
@user-od9iz9cv1w
@user-od9iz9cv1w 2 года назад
Fascinating to hear the sound clip at the end. First, this track never sounded this good on your budget gear reviews. Second, the AR system lets more low level info through. I heard stuff at the beginning that was just missing in the Mac system (and in other review systems). But the AR does not go clinical as some solid state systems do. While the Topping DAC is likely just fine, it would also be cool to hear that AR system with your reference level DAC.
@Cipollae
@Cipollae 2 года назад
Yeah - I totally agree, although I do wonder if these two systems were properly level matched. The AR rendering of the music was so much more realistic and lively that it almost made the McIntosh sound broken.
@MrButuz
@MrButuz Год назад
Even in terms of looks I much prefer Audio Research. Understated. Ive only got an LS7 but hope to get more in the future. The McIntosh is just too shouty look at me and my bright green porsche and my baseball cap. All the coloured lighting on the valves is just a gimmick, does nothing for sound, and one more thing to go wrong let's face it!
@mariopenzo
@mariopenzo 2 года назад
Should change the channel name to Thomas' Storytelling. 😂😂 Good stuff
@wilsonlow3458
@wilsonlow3458 2 года назад
Hahaha
@davidparker4984
@davidparker4984 2 года назад
I am very concerned about quality control at Audio Research. I bought a CD9se last year. After about 3 days it began to fail after playing around 30 seconds. After contacting my audio dealer and after they reviewed the issue with AR it was believed a power tube was faulty. Replacing the tube did not solve the problem AR then sent me a replacement unit. This one worked perfectly with one exception. The digital counter failed to function properly. At this point I had had enough and returned the unit and bought an Esoteric sacd player. This type of poor quality control should not happen with any products, especially a $15,000.00 unit.
@mariopenzo
@mariopenzo 2 года назад
My MA252 is crazy good. Specially considering is nowhere near the usual Mac prices
@cirenosnor5768
@cirenosnor5768 Год назад
Audio Research amps in the past were more neutral and less colored. Thus they usually sounded more like solid state amps. Especially when compared to something like a McIntosh or Conrad Johnson where both are “warm” or “colored” in general. I remember a tech and reviewer said to me about AR back in the early 90’s “They figured out how to make a tube amp that sounds solid state”
@AusGanesh
@AusGanesh 2 года назад
Hi Thomas, thank you for the video worth watching, I hope you will be producing video’s of this calibre in the future. I do agree with you I have owned and listened to many pre amps, but Audio Research Ref3 out performed all of them. I am sorry I sold it, and a good second hand one is hard to get, so I opted to purchase Denafrips Athena. Denafrips Athena is new with warranty and fully balanced, the sound quality is as good as the Audio Research Ref3. Maybe be when you are doing video’s like this should include something like Denafrips Athena and maybe be Rogue Audio M180, so people like us have an option to purchase either second hand highend gear or comparable new one. Thank You.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Wow, Denafrips Athena is that good! My friend just bought the REF 10 and I am so excited and wanting to go listen.
@AusGanesh
@AusGanesh 2 года назад
@@ThomasAndStereo Thomas just a quick warning, I am told by my audio buddy’s that the newer version of Audio Research gear not as good as earlier one since it has been taken over by a foreign owner. Up to ref 5 is sort after by audiophile’s and I see new ones for sale as second hand quit often. Maybe there’s some truth in what my audio buddy’s are telling me. Same applies to the Mac products.
@AusGanesh
@AusGanesh 2 года назад
@@ThomasAndStereo Hi Thomas, did you go and listen to your friends REF 10? What was your opinion on the sound stage and sound quality? I am thinking about getting one so your opinion will be helpful. Thank You.
@RX_Char_01Patti
@RX_Char_01Patti 2 года назад
Loved the comparison of both iconic brands, which was hard to do without upsetting hardcore fans of these brands. :) But you nailed it. (five thumbs up) I like both brands. But when I see the meters on Mcintosh, I don't want to see anything else. I am still in the market for a good integrated amp. I am considering Mcintosh, Luxman, Accuphase and Audio Research.
@aussie8114
@aussie8114 2 года назад
Very different sounding systems. I think my ears prefer the McIntosh but something in between the two would be best. One sounds a bit under detailed, the other a bit too busy. Maybe what I already have is the best choice for me 🤔
@tomstrum6259
@tomstrum6259 2 года назад
Hey !! ...Just found your channel. !! ..Really appreciate your clear sound gear description....Keep up the great style & work..
@MusicLover-01
@MusicLover-01 2 года назад
Would love to hear more about your high end gear Thomas. Always nice to know where this rabbit hole can take you! Preferred the McIntosh sound sample, softer without losing resolution, the AR gear sounds like there is a slight tilt in the upper mids, very focused but also slightly dry to my ears. Both sound quite solid statish, the MC30/40 is sweeter sounding, slightly more up my street if you don't need the power! Still wow 👌 👏
@thunderbird66613
@thunderbird66613 2 года назад
It would be cool to have audio meetups or clubs where you take turns demoing other members equipment. Shame there is nothing like that around. Back in the 60's and 70's it was common for this. But it was more about the music then the equipment in those days
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Yeah, that would be awesome.
@mesonto
@mesonto 2 года назад
I completely agree but with all the governmental mandates in place and some even afraid to go out, now is not a great time. But as soon as people are no longer scared to live their lives again, I would join that club in a heartbeat! Sorry Thomas but the above was relevant to the issue... hahaha.
@TM-fx2pi
@TM-fx2pi 2 года назад
I’m VERY interested in McIntosh gear in general. Considering a pair of MC 611’s myself.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
I would love to get a pair too.
@danieldelgado8153
@danieldelgado8153 2 года назад
I have two of them. LOVE them. Got them for my 60th birthday. No regrets. You only live once. My son will get them when I move on..
@TM-fx2pi
@TM-fx2pi 2 года назад
@@danieldelgado8153 nice ! What pre amp are you using ? It will probably be my sixtieth by the time I save the money 💰 (two years)😂. I’m currently running PS Audio M1200’s. I’m curious if they will sound much different.
@danieldelgado8153
@danieldelgado8153 2 года назад
@@TM-fx2pi Hello my friend. I have a Antham AVM 70. My mono blocks are connected to Tekton Encores. I have 4 SVS Ultra surrounds and a B&W HTM71 center speaker The surrounds are connected to a Monoprice 7x200 Amp. Huge upgrade in sound using XLR cables versus RCA. You won’t regret getting the Mac 611’s. They will last you a lifetime. Happy Holidays. Dan
@themetatron0000
@themetatron0000 2 года назад
"The Edit" Now that's an edit. I really liked it because it had something I have been wanting to see in editing for a while, the change of clothing and kind of keeping the colour coordination within a keeping moment. You should try it more often, its all in the timing. Keep up the good work Thomas..
@fresnoman419
@fresnoman419 4 месяца назад
All that great stuff in an untreated room
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 4 месяца назад
It is treated.
@RonRivet
@RonRivet 2 года назад
As I mentioned in your other video, I have an all Rega system except for......... my prized Audio Research SP14 preamp with an excellent tube phono stage. It replaced my Rega Cursa 3 and the Cursa 3 is not missed. The SP14 in my opinion is a far better sounding preamp that still matches very well with the rest of my Rega system.
@m.9243
@m.9243 2 года назад
If we're talking 'high definition' it's day and night! Audio Research sounds so much more clean and true to the source. I would imagine, anyone who listens to accoustic music ( Jazz, Classical etc) would prefer the A.R. Perhaps for rock music the "thicker" McIntosh sound would impress. As you very well say Thomas, at the end of the day, a matter of taste. ...That sign on the front of the A.R. gear "High Definition" is not there for fun... 😎
@karlmoore6354
@karlmoore6354 2 года назад
New Audio Research ref gear smokes McIntosh, but it's so much more expensive too. I'm still trying to figure out how old McIntosh tube gear compares to older Audio Research though. For acoustic music, I prefer Naim.
@m.9243
@m.9243 2 года назад
@@karlmoore6354 Naim is taking a totally different approach to music. They leave behind all that audiophile 'jargon' about "depth", "imaging", "soundstage" etc. etc. They seek more the 'fun' part in music with their famous PRAT (Pace, Rythm and Timing) applying to how they present sound. And, if one is to judge by the loyal following they command, they must be doing something right. The philosophy of such approach is, music should be enjoyed as a _sum off_ rather than be analysed as each individual sound, instrument, noise etc. As Thomas always says, it boils down to individual taste, and he's right!
@davidstein9129
@davidstein9129 4 месяца назад
I still have & enjoying my Thomas Audio tube amp coffee mug. I need to buy another one to make a pair. lol
@cnhhnc
@cnhhnc 2 года назад
Mr. VINTAGE? Prefers neutral! Really! I never would have guessed that. I LOVE vintage gear and speakers and what I "love" about them is the "warmth" and "musicality", the smoothness! Lack of fatigue, etc. That's vintage. It's what we love in the amps and also in the speakers which, generally speaking are not as resolving as modern HiEnd gear and also why we sometime wince at that modern sound that is so antiseptic and clinical and super-resolving, super fast, and so on. Yes you can hear almost anything on that but it's just not as enjoyable or fun for me. You're in a jazz club. The lights are low. There is the occasional whisper or clinking of glasses. The band is pressed up against a corner of the room. All acoustic: piano, drums, bass, and a sax or horn. The sound floats around one and bounces softly off walls draped in fabric that soften it and make it more laid back. You have a pair of vintage floorstanders whose bass is a little soft but FULL, whose midrange sounds as though someone is singing close by. The highs? Not edgy, not overly brignt, not drawing attention to itself, but pleasing to the ear. Yes, those OLD ASS SPEAKERs sound wornderful BUT they are not audiophile? The band doesn't care, they just play and play! Vintage? Neutral! OK, I guess there is something for everyone back then! For me, the best vintage gear is that which most approximated the classic "tube" sound.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Yes, he has been in hifi for 50 years and he has owned all the vintage gear you can probably think of. Yet, he can build neutral sounding systems of them. Very interesting how he does it.
@danielesbordone1871
@danielesbordone1871 2 года назад
Audio Research seems to have less background noise too. Sounds much better.
@tietoliikenne
@tietoliikenne 2 года назад
Today's video is really amazing! I hope you do more of such video :) Feels like I have more audiophile friends haha
@Steveh817
@Steveh817 2 года назад
Definitely some differences in how these two setups presented the sound. I don’t know that I prefer one over the other which means either would work for me. The Mac system seemed that it had slightly more bass but not necessarily in a better way. The AR system seemed a little more forward in presentation with a quieter background. That whole synergy thing again. It makes me wonder how different things would sound mixing these amps and pre-amps. 🤔
@Hungho-jd9pb
@Hungho-jd9pb Год назад
Hi.. recently discovered your channel, like it very much. Regardless: Video & sound quality is good enough for me.👍
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo Год назад
Awesome, thank you!
@papapatriot
@papapatriot 2 года назад
If I had the money and could pick only one brand I'd pick Audio Research. But certainly not be unhappy with Mcintosh gear!
@vicg5323
@vicg5323 2 года назад
Cool video. Can you do a video of all your buddies systems and their impressions. And yes to a review of your equipment.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
Will try.
@robertthurston6858
@robertthurston6858 2 года назад
That's a nice Krell CD Transport player. Does your friend have the matching vintage Krell DAC ? If so I was wondering how it sounds compared to more modern DAC' s ? I was wondering because a older Krell KSA 200S from the same era.
@ThomasAndStereo
@ThomasAndStereo 2 года назад
No he does not.
@jazzmetalaudiophile
@jazzmetalaudiophile 2 года назад
"That’s my line when I review stuff" 😂 killed me
Далее
КОТЯТА НАУЧИЛИСЬ ГОВОРИТЬ#cat
00:13
PERFECT PITCH FILTER.. (CR7 EDITION) 🙈😅
00:21
Просмотров 4,5 млн
Audio Research Reference 10. Not a review. Road trip!
16:23
MCINTOSH DOESN'T WANT YOU TO KNOW THIS!
8:21
Просмотров 139 тыс.
10 BEST Loudspeakers of ALL TIME
18:57
Просмотров 1,3 млн
McIntosh MA12000 Integrated Amplifier
15:45
Просмотров 87 тыс.
AMERICAN MADE: Audio Research I/50
12:14
Просмотров 100 тыс.