Minecraft Music Disc Tier List 

When discord is faster tha yt

Pigstep don’t feel like Minecraft ,but damn it goes absolutely hard.

Cave sounds tier list next I’m calling it

I played pigstep while conquering a bastion remnant. And it was a beautiful experience.

I loved minecraft horror as a kid, it spooked me out. So disc 13 is my favorite, I remember hearing it for the first time and being so scared, it's so nostalgic.

I was glad when you included samples of each soundtrack in this video...I was THRILLED when you additionally included a slide show for "Cat" 😂

I actually really like Music Disc 13 not because I like listening to it but because the opposite. It's effective at what it wants to do. 13 is a very unnerving track with a very thick atmosphere and it never fails to make me feel at least a little bit frightened. Good shit

Pigstep goes so hard, it almost deserves its own tier.

Maybe this is an unpopular opinion but my favorite disc is mellohi, but I also love pigstep and otherside

Brings back memories to my Hardcore world, where I used my one diamond to craft a jukebox just for my pet parrot, who sadly died in a tnt blast Rest in peace, Recs

Chirp and cat nostalgically Top tier

You gotta remember the days of stamys 2012-2014 Christmas celebrations where chirp would play. Simpler times

1-Stal 2-Otherside 3-Pigstep 4-Chirp 5-Mellohi

The blocks disrespect is unreal. Always been my favorite.

Wait is my favorite OG Disc by a mile, but i do miss it's old name: "Where are We Now?" That name made it always felt good to listen to after a long journey of exploring. I always thought "Where is my place in this world? How far have i come, how far do I have left to go?" And the song felt both retro and uplifting, both matching my thoughts with the music. Plus it's just a bop

My top 5 discs: 1. Blocks 2. Far 3. Strad 4. Pigstep 5. Otherside

Top 5 For me: 1. Pigstep 2. Mellohi 3. Otherside 4. Stal 5. Wait

"Blocks isn't very interesting and basic." I just wanna talk to him.

I never realised some discs sound like the music you hear in liminal space videos

Been getting back into Minecraft lately, found your channel and it’s genuinely great content man keep it up

Cat has a point that makes me feel like I’m watching a sunset over a valley, the OG discs really make me feel some type of way, the new ones especially pig step sound more like terraria tbh

A full OST tier list would be awesome! Volume Alpha, Volume Beta, 1.13 OST, Nether Update, Caves and Cliffs and Wild Update

I'm glad someone is making a video about the music of minecraft, since it really is quite incredible.

Disk 5, 11 and 13 is a GAAAAAME THEORY

Personally, pigstep is my second favorite, my favorite is probably wait. But for a long time, pigstep was my favorite. Still I like all of the lower ones you put on here like mall or blocks. I don’t love them, but they are both good

If Sweden was on the list it deserves its own tier

As much as I love pigstep once I discovered otherside there was no going back

ward is my favorite - it gives me a massive amount of nostalgia

None of them are really bad. Some other discs such as 13, 11, and 5 aren't really made to be listened to for the same reason as the others. I feel like those ambient discs were added to create more depth and story to the game and, therefore, in my eyes would not be justifiable to be put in the trash or lacking tier

"Strad", "far", "cat" fit perfectly in Minecraft music theme especially what it was before the update aquatic Others feel off (like 20th century nostalgia music) or not as good personally for me although the new discs are fine for modern Minecraft

I love 13 just for using it to add ambiance to some builds

My top 3: 1. Otherside 2. Pigstep 3. Strad

Incredibly straightforward commentary

Chip gives me such a weird feeling when hearing it. I think it has to do with nostalgia, because it used to be my favorite. The upbeat yet eerie sound, and the crackling of the disc, it's all just... Unexplainable. It's literally the music version of liminal spaces

Far is my personal favorite because the end just sounds beautiful to me. Seriously if you haven’t heard it you should listen to it. Also great tier list My top 5 1 : Far 2 : Strad 3 : Otherside 4 : Pigstep 5 : Blocks

Mellohi always remembers me playing years ago on a online copy of minecraft but the goal were to protecting your base from hostiles mobs with traps, it was like in 2D with the OG Minecraft Textures. And Mellohi got me a bit nostalgic because it was played in this game. Idk if i was the only one playing this game but i liked it. I wonder if it still exists.

I really love wait and pigstep lol

I think anyone who grew up in the 90s , digging for records, messing with turntables , samplers and drum machines all minecraft music is extremely relatable

3:30 lol you showing the mall

the "wait" was the real masterpiece for me

I didn't particularly have a favorite music disc before 1.16 but Pigstep definitely changed that for me. It easily became my favorite... until Otherside came out lol

My tier list: 1. Blocks 2. Mellohi 3. Cat 4. Otherside 5. A tie between 5, 11 and 13 because of the lore

I absolutely love 13 as it achieves what it aims for perfectly, i remember playing the alphas when i was young and being terrified of 13, and personally i found that it works a lot more effectively than 11

Mellohi is a masterpiece. Always used to play it while making offers my friends cannot possibly refuse. Seriously though, we even put on accents, it was brilliant. Stal was the song to play in our bowling alley and casino. Strad was the music for my zoo. Cat and chirp were both vibe songs Ward was played during our court cases. Pigstep was reserved for special events only. Other side, is like a credits scene, both in how it sounds and how it marks the end of my minecraft era and the beginning of a whole other generations era.

I really think cat should be top tier along with pigstep and otherside as well as chirp. Stal will always be that one meme song. Its that song that you play when you make your build. Then it turns out to be asymmetrical.

Disc "13" sounds like bells ringing for me

this might be the first tier list to ever be 100% correct i am very impressed by your taste dude

mellohi is my favorite disc the simplest way i can describe it is "mood" it sort of resembles the music from don't starve aswell

I find it so funny that all the music disks sound so cool and amazing, And then stal is just funky kazoo music. That being said, it's still one of my favorites.

04:56 The stal one make me remember my memory again, It's like 2-3 years ago I play fun games. 06:04 this music is one of my favorite one because it always makes me happy when I hear it. My favorite: 1st=strad 2nd=mall 3rd=ward 4th=samuel aberg - 5 5th=pigstep

Lol you're reading my mind, I wanted to see you ranking music discs literally today, and then I see the notification xD

For me personally I like all the music disk. Maybe not 11, 13, 5. They still really good for horror element. My favorite it's probably with most people cat

My Opinion in this video: 1. Chirp: It is one of the first Minecraft disc in the game, where you show your respect for your grandma. 2. Wait: So much nostalgia that upbeats your infastructure projects 3 Mellohi: ItzJhief told his videos that Minecraft was crashing sales because of player chat report, and this is a perfect evil theme for both Mojang and Microsoft. 4. Pigstep: The only disc that made everyone party, especially for the Piglins. 5. Cat: A sweet upbeat tune that C418 makes in 2009. I wouldn't be proud if he add cat noises before 1.14 6. Otherside: 50/50 chance of this not bringing back those memories on cave oasis. 7. Mall: Needs a way to compare itself with Lena Raine's song: Firebugs 8. Stal: Clearly this a Minecraft background music for memes about villagers 9. Strad: Wait a minute, did C418 went to Hawaii before Minecraft Beta got released. 10. Blocks: A perfect music disc to do Allay Duplication twice! 11. Ward: C418 almost played Tetris when making this disc, did he? 12. Far: Sure this is really decent and underrated, but it almost sounds as if it was a good luck charm. 13. 13: The sound is most cave noises, but your brain could start to panic because you keep doing heavy breathing. 14: 11: The disc itself looks a lot like Stal, but 1 piece broken. It is clearly ASMR, but clearly it is cursed and corrupted. 15: 5: Less cursed than 11, but what kind of disc reminds of your grandma giving your memories before cave noises when you fell a cliff. In Conclusion: Disc 5's relaxing counterpart could be better if it is lofi music, Samuel Aberg was inspired by C418's 13 and 11, but adding the relaxing music is still missing even its full version.

1. Far (it's just remind me of childhood day's) 2. Mall (this disk belongs to dreamcore status, it's fells wired and calming in the same time) 3. Pigstep ( It's just good disk, it's doesn't fell like something from Minecraft but it's still kinda hot) 4. Cat (It was my first disk, so yeah) 5. Wait (fells really chill, just wait) 6. Otherside (Wierdcore, dreamcore fit's amazingly, this song interprets huge spectrum of colour's)

My top 3 1. Pigstep 2. Otherside 3. Wait

pigstep is the best disc, i totally agree

Am I the only one who completely forgot strad existed

Why is Far so underrated? It’s one of the top 3 by C418

chirp, is like of me imagining minecraft is an apocalyptic world, where all humans died bc of an zombie virus and steve was the only person left. also chirp is like giving me the sad vibes

A part of five sounds really nostalgic

POV: You love Stal jschlatt: *quaking*

I like 11, 13 and 5 too because it's the game lore

I know it’s a lot more music, but any chance we could get a game music tier list? I was gonna ask for the whole albums, but that would be a lot, plus most of the tracks from C418 aren’t even in the game.

blocks is my fav music disc, followed by strad but honestly? goated tier list

Chirp even has a better part towards the end

Minecraft music is next and this guy is gonna blow up so soon

I could literally feel chills going down my spine as I listened to 13 and 11.

I like these tier lists, they keep my on your channel 🤣

This channel underrated 😔

To be honest, I think 13 sounding so bad on a technical perspective makes it extremely interesting to me. It makes me go Dark Souls lore speculation mode, as to how the disc came to be. Has it been like that all the time? Is it some sort of encrypted disc in soe way shape or form? As much as I adore, and I mean ADORE Chirp, I have to say this one has a drastically distinct charm to it- Now that I just shot myself in the foot, allow me to just walk off holy hell Also, the sample heard in Chirp not only does appear in Minecraft, but it's also the entire motif for the LittleBigPlanet series.

i'm so glad someone else loves wait as much as i do, it's such a groovy song and for me personally i love just popping it in a jukebox while i build random shit in creative mode.

Pigstep is a song I would listen to in the deep dark. It was fricken awesome.

Great vid my personal favourite are 1.pigstep 2.stal 3.cat 4.chirp 5.ward

Do a Cat variant tier list

I may be wierd but 13 brings me so much nostalgia and a really wierd feeling that it scares me more than a horror game can do... I love it!

"if you don't like pigstep, your wrong." Bro turned into the entire twitter fanbase 💀💀

pigstep and wait r my absolute fav

Ward is personally not like the other songs, my one and only LOVED disc.

The background cat pictures showed when he played the first disc is so funny

i was so glad when you put "Wait" in masterpiece, it is my favorite disk

I like discs 13, 11 ,5 because of the lore and history

my opinion 1. Otherside 2. 5 3. Pigstep 4. Cat 5. Chirp 6. Ward

I love far. It's one of my favorites but no one else feels that way

Strad is just very nostalgic

In the first 7 seconds you made me laugh so hard

top 6 for me: Otherside wait strad pigstep Chirp Cat just my personal opinion so feel free to like and reply!

Have you done a weapons/tool tier list?

beautiful taste in music.

Pigstep feels like terraria boss music

My top: 1. cat 2.otherside 3.wait

7:25 I told one of my friends to listen to disc 11 when it was 11 PM, she is getting a mc account soon but had never heard any Minecraft music and now she said she never will listen to mc music. what have i done.

I though a Spotify ad was bout to come on on music disc 5 for a sec

As much as I like the og disks, pigstep and otherside beat them easily

Personally i think almost every og disc is top tier, mainly because of nostalgia, the new ones are also good but they aren't beating the og ones.

I agree with this tierlist 👍, really good choices 👌, a few disks I would put a tier above or a tier below but it's for maybe 2/3 of them And I'm not sure if I would put Chirp into Masterpiece because it gives me a lot of Nostalgia and sound really similar to Orb of Dreamers from the game Little Big Planet (which also gives me a lot of Nostalgia 😌), but I kinda feel like Orb of Dreamers is a better Chirp...

Tierlist 1)Pigstep it hits so hard 2)Otherside it just like you remembering all your good memories as 3)Far. This sounds like a stranded man in the space, exploring for new planet or on some sort of expedition, it fits very well for 1.8 minecraft cuz its done and empty at the same moment as a space and galaxies for us 4)Wait cuz its just cool

otherside e pigstep são dois sons maravilhosos

Top 5: 1. Stal 2. Otherside 3. Pigstep 4. Far 5. Strad

Strad was my CHILDHOOD it is the GOAT of minecraft discs

Dang those parents were dancing