Тёмный

Mongolia caught between global powers 

CaspianReport
Подписаться 1,5 млн
Просмотров 519 тыс.
50% 1

Thanks to Curiosity Stream for sponsoring today’s video. Go to curiositystream.thld.co/caspi... and use code CASPIAN to save 25% off today, that’s only $14.99 a year.
Being sandwiched between #China and #Russia makes for tricky policymaking. Distance is what #Mongolia wants more than anything, but its extensive deposits of minerals make it a target for foreign exploitation.
Support CaspianReport
✔ RU-vid membership ► / @caspianreport
✔ Patreon ► / caspianreport
✔ PayPal ► www.paypal.me/caspianreport
✔ Merchandise ►teespring.com/stores/caspianr...
Crypto endorsement
✔ Bitcoin ► 1MwRNXWWqzbmsHova7FMW11zPftVZVUfbU
✔ Ether ► 0xfE4c310ccb6f52f9D220F25Ce76Dec0493dF9aA0
✔ Bitcoin Cash ► 1BKLti4Wq4EK9fsBnYWC91caK7NZfUhNw9
Join us on Facebook or Twitter
✔ Twitter ► / caspianreport
✔ Facebook ► / caspianreport
✔ My equipment and editing software ► www.amazon.com/shop/caspianre...
Watch CaspianReport in other languages
✔ Spanish ► / historiageopol%c3%adtica
✔ Russian ► / thecuriouscat

Опубликовано:

 

28 сен 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,5 тыс.   
@CaspianReport
@CaspianReport 2 года назад
Thanks to Curiosity Stream for sponsoring today’s video. Go to curiositystream.thld.co/caspian0921 and use code CASPIAN to save 25% off today, that’s only $14.99 a year.
@DS-bz4mz
@DS-bz4mz 2 года назад
Glad to see you getting sponsors so often :D
@youxkio
@youxkio 2 года назад
Another great video identifying the (geo and local) political and economic environment. Good job as always.
@jeremycompton3010
@jeremycompton3010 2 года назад
I have met many Mongolian people, l liked all the ones l got to know.
@sean659
@sean659 2 года назад
Skip the sponsor crap video starts at 2:00
@matpk
@matpk 2 года назад
Compare 1930s Nazi Germany Vs 2020s Communist Chinazi IN YOUR NEXT VIDEO Project. Before it's too late
@morrisse0_088
@morrisse0_088 2 года назад
Mongolia be like: if I stay perfectly still they might not notice me
@javascriptgood6944
@javascriptgood6944 2 года назад
ayo China, where did Mongolia go?
@batmu1802
@batmu1802 2 года назад
Its true tho!
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟤 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@JAG8691
@JAG8691 2 года назад
800 years everyone noticed Mongolia.
@righthandstep5
@righthandstep5 2 года назад
Jurassic Park style. Love it 😉
@Themosquito_
@Themosquito_ 2 года назад
“When money talks, there are few interruptions” Shirvan does it once again with his one-liners
@DaManBearPig
@DaManBearPig 2 года назад
That’s honestly my second favorite part about this channel. He hits ya with these zingers..
@mickey4125
@mickey4125 2 года назад
Also a good one from the end of the episode: "If you want to build high, you have to dig deep".
@kiro6119
@kiro6119 2 года назад
he just gets them from the books he reads. One time I read one of the books he references and his video was almost word for word what was written in there
@zjsz4954
@zjsz4954 2 года назад
The one at the end too “when one wants to build high one must dig deep”
@skyfeelan
@skyfeelan 2 года назад
not exactly one line, but for me it's 'Mongolia must play the bear and the dragon against one another, and itermittently pulled the eagle into the mix, just to throw anyone off their game'
@youisstupid2586
@youisstupid2586 2 года назад
I never knew mongolia was this good in politics.
@delgermuruntsagaankhuu6951
@delgermuruntsagaankhuu6951 2 года назад
Good foreign policy, poor internal development, so goes any country bordering china and Russia
@acctsys
@acctsys 2 года назад
The Khanate was quite good at it actually.
@diamondsky3787
@diamondsky3787 2 года назад
@@delgermuruntsagaankhuu6951 well if you want your country to survive its hard
@mxn1948
@mxn1948 2 года назад
its actually not that great of a feat. its stable mostly because neither china nor russia will allow the other to control it so neutral and independent it stays, regardless of its own internal politics. just like how thailand stayed independent in the colonial era, not because it was a military superpower or because its political system so incredibly good but because the french and british agreed that it would be a buffer state between their colonies. in fact, mongolia has made mistakes, for example in its "third neighbor" policy, it was fine when it wanted more economic partners and invited SK, Japanese, EU and american companies to bid on its resources and provide economic competition for the chinese and russian companies. It was NOT fine when it started to join exercises with the US/NATO, it got a little too cozy militarily with the west and forgot that it's a landlocked nation between russia and china. They had a couple of exercises for like 2 years and mongolia suddenly found itself with extra "inspections" for its goods going through chinese and russian ports(the only routes for its goods). the transit fees also skyrocketed. mongolia soon learned what the red lines are and that it shouldn't be too involved militarily with its "third neighbors". Its for this reason mongolia can never be a japan or SK, because all it takes for russia and china to keep it inline is to declare the borders closed and mongolia will find itself in a social-economic disaster that no nations can help them without russia/china giving the okay.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟢 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@freddy4603
@freddy4603 2 года назад
Quite the skilled diplomacy on the part of Mongolia! Truly a country on hardcore difficulty standing up to the challenge
@QWERTY-gp8fd
@QWERTY-gp8fd 2 года назад
mongolian adaptability. truly incredible stuff.
@baheer156
@baheer156 2 года назад
Afghanistan has to develop a similar policy as its also landlocked.
@Brandonhayhew
@Brandonhayhew 2 года назад
Smaller countries often have to develop a shady diplomacy in order to stay neutral as possible
@harshjain3122
@harshjain3122 2 года назад
@@baheer156 yeah sure. We can see how it's playing out.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟦 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@trekkienzl2862
@trekkienzl2862 2 года назад
*🇲🇳 Mongol Empire:* We will conquer the world 🌎 *🇲🇳 Modern day Mongolia:* Stop looking at me like I'm 🇵🇱 Poland
@FilosSofo
@FilosSofo 2 года назад
"modern mongolia: you know I like horses" -- Jim Gaffigan
@Brandonhayhew
@Brandonhayhew 2 года назад
Ukraine: your not the only one with problems. Nepal: we are all in a dangerous position
@harshjain3122
@harshjain3122 2 года назад
@@Brandonhayhew nepal?
@gideonmele1556
@gideonmele1556 2 года назад
@@harshjain3122 Since it’s caught between the hostility between of India and China
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟧 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@Mr_M_History
@Mr_M_History 2 года назад
As a teacher, it's so good to have you producing such quality content. It allows student to visualise things and gives them an entry point into a criminally undertaught subject in the West!
@WellBehavedForeigner
@WellBehavedForeigner 2 года назад
In Pakistan they still think the chinggis capital is the current capital of Mongolia (it's only a historical site today) and everyone's last name is Khan ...it's like an American civil war reenactment especially when you find out what a Quran is when it fits into the reenactment paradigm rather than the reenactment fitting into the Quran paradigm
@WellBehavedForeigner
@WellBehavedForeigner 2 года назад
Do you think it's possible that the illegalization of using water to clean stuff during mongol rule was actually enforced? Or that it was only enforced on prisoners, like the way north Korean "laws" are enforced on prisoners only (though we say they're being enforced on the entire population)?
@ivarbrouwer197
@ivarbrouwer197 2 года назад
So true, the only international news agency that is easily accessible and does cover some wider topics then what the west is interested in seems Al Jazeera. CNN and even the BBC have a huge western bias, and only cover topics that are geopolitically interesting to the west. It’s a far bigger world out there, and in the west, we see very little of it.
@Smulpaap123
@Smulpaap123 2 года назад
@@ivarbrouwer197 You only see so little if you're not interested.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟢 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@sociedadnortena9514
@sociedadnortena9514 2 года назад
What ever you do, don’t give them horses
@paperitgel98
@paperitgel98 2 года назад
We already have plenty dw.
@user-rz9vb8vj5u
@user-rz9vb8vj5u 2 года назад
Worse don't give them Corolla cars
@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx
@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx 2 года назад
@@user-rz9vb8vj5u Modified Hiluxes
@yolemae6580
@yolemae6580 2 года назад
most of the descendents of the raiding Mongols would be in the areas they conquered, not Mongolia.
@youxkio
@youxkio 2 года назад
@@yolemae6580 Good point of view. But you know that the Mongols always took care of their own motherland. Although many inherited customs or beliefs may be identified in other regions from the times of Ghenghis Khan. The Mongolian Diaspora.
@hugoleonardoamaral586
@hugoleonardoamaral586 2 года назад
"When money talks, there are few interruptions" You should write a novel. All your videos are full of genius phrases like that. That's some pro writing right there.
@momo-cchi5978
@momo-cchi5978 2 года назад
Could it be that he's just directly translating Azeri proverbs? 🤔
@MenRot
@MenRot 2 года назад
Majority of them are quite famous quotes
@prometheus7387
@prometheus7387 2 года назад
When caught between two great powers, you know you're going to have a tough life.
@paperitgel98
@paperitgel98 2 года назад
Unless the two want a buffer zone indefinitely.
@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx
@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx 2 года назад
@@paperitgel98 This! for now at least until you guys get a new Khan which will conqure both 😂
@TheLukasDirector
@TheLukasDirector 2 года назад
Just ask Poland
@matpk
@matpk 2 года назад
@@TheLukasDirector Compare 1930s Nazi Germany Vs 2020s Communist Chinazi IN YOUR NEXT VIDEO Project. Before it's too late
@stevenbaksh5545
@stevenbaksh5545 2 года назад
Yeah you can say that about Korea
@dragosstanciu9866
@dragosstanciu9866 2 года назад
The foreign corporations get Mongolian minerals, but the population itself doesn't profit too much.
@DFPercush
@DFPercush 2 года назад
@Not RickRoII👇🅥 ^ it's an ASMR video about soap...
@jamakasis18
@jamakasis18 2 года назад
Lets say a local corporation gets the minerals. Will the population profit much? xD
@harshjain3122
@harshjain3122 2 года назад
@@jamakasis18 does the local corp have the tech to extract them in the first place? Exactly.
@citizenofterra
@citizenofterra 2 года назад
@@harshjain3122 No, but that doesnt help the local pop. Trickle down effect is a convenient but unrealistic explanation
@Lyle-xc9pg
@Lyle-xc9pg 2 года назад
@@citizenofterra did cnn tell you that? "trickle down" (fake term anyway) is the only way that wealth builds withen a country, for everyone even if you dont know better
@terramater
@terramater 2 года назад
Amazing map animations, as always! Every time when we're creating a new video, we experience hands one how much work those kinds of maps are. Kudos to you, Shirvan! 👏🏽
@Darshanvd
@Darshanvd 2 года назад
Yes
@SidMajors
@SidMajors 2 года назад
Love you channel a lot as well mate!
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🏐 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@skyhappy
@skyhappy 2 года назад
He's literally just panning over the same highlighted map on a globe
@spongebobsucks12
@spongebobsucks12 2 года назад
@@skyhappy his maps are selected for a purpose. He uses elevation maps, topographic maps, population maps, and even maps of rail or transport lines. The fact you don't notice it usually is why it's so fukn good. Shirvan, put simply..."He's slick asf"
@zer0cool1909
@zer0cool1909 2 года назад
When money talks, there are few interruptions SHAKESPEARE of Politics, or Goethe
@me0101001000
@me0101001000 2 года назад
@Not RickRoII👇🅥 stop plugging your crappy video
@Musman-vr2mu
@Musman-vr2mu 2 года назад
u nailed it!
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🔴 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@waliwali3690
@waliwali3690 2 года назад
Sound quality of this last video is mediocre.🕵is it a sign of Caspian Crisis between Youtubia 📺and Soundistan📢 😷 ?
@L0_V
@L0_V 2 года назад
And interruptions can make money silent.
@geraldmeehan8942
@geraldmeehan8942 2 года назад
"To build high we must dig deep". Thank you for another wonderful video. From Indiana in USA wishing all in Mongolia, and everywhere else well
@alexrider2597
@alexrider2597 2 года назад
Please don’t invade for oil
@BassGoThump
@BassGoThump 2 года назад
@@alexrider2597 Yeah because it’s up to Gerry over in Indiana if we invade.
@buu4045
@buu4045 2 года назад
Thanks man, we are doing ok.
@geraldmeehan8942
@geraldmeehan8942 2 года назад
@@alexrider2597 Lol, I opposed both invasions in 2001
@geraldmeehan8942
@geraldmeehan8942 2 года назад
@@BassGoThump Lol, I have 0 military ties
@farhanhyder6378
@farhanhyder6378 2 года назад
The line about playing the bear and dragon against each other with the eagle in between sometimes was genius.
@cyclonicleo
@cyclonicleo 2 года назад
Mongolia is being very savvy with their geopolitics, mostly out of necessity but also out of fears stemming from the past. Its not the way to short term riches but it is the way to longer term, deeply ingrained prosperity and independence.
@L0_V
@L0_V 2 года назад
The Sounds of Khans are honoured
@realtalk6195
@realtalk6195 2 года назад
You're minimizing the gravity kind of. Majority of Mongolians follow Tibetan Buddhism but obviously can't speak in support of their own religious leader nor for the Tibetans. Ethnic Mongolians ("Southern Mongolians") are also increasingly persecuted in China, and Mongolia can't speak out or make any demands about that either. Mongolia is completely economically dependent on Russia and China, much like the Central Asia states. The only positive it has going for it is that it's democratic, but the negative is that they don't even share a land border with neighboring Kazakhstan because Russia/China falls in between obstructing it. Otherwise, it would have given them a land corridor to the rest of Asia. So it's not even a question of independence and prosperity, they're genuinely concerned and pissed off but don't express it publicly. It's a similar public sentiment in Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan and Tajikistan but the governments in Central Asia are completely captured.
@Testingthisname
@Testingthisname Год назад
@@realtalk6195 "The only positive it has going for it is that it's democratic" That isnt a positive you tool
@QWERTY-gp8fd
@QWERTY-gp8fd Год назад
@@Testingthisname it is positive tool. i can shit talk about china without getting killed.
@kronkrian100
@kronkrian100 2 года назад
Mongolia is that one country everyone forgets about until someone mentions Genghis Khan
@temuulenjargalbayar796
@temuulenjargalbayar796 2 года назад
Where are you from?
@user-jj6mx3tc1g
@user-jj6mx3tc1g 2 года назад
To give you a hint, Genghis Khan's identity in 90% of his life is Chinese !He was the ruler who founded the Mongol Empire and made it independent from 800 years of Chinese rule ~
@user-jj6mx3tc1g
@user-jj6mx3tc1g 2 года назад
In fact, the biggest reason for the rise of the Mongolian people is that China's north and south are in the midst of civil war, and there is no mind to manage the grasslands !The Mongols conquered the Middle East and Europe with the advanced armor and firearms of the Han people, But back to attack China is very difficult! Until the defeat of mongo, the Mongol empire was destroyed! Kublai Khan took the initiative to sinicize and unite the northern Han warlords to bury the Mongolian Empire and the Southern Song Dynasty ~
@enkhzayazundui1063
@enkhzayazundui1063 2 года назад
@@user-jj6mx3tc1g take your guessing somewhere else, will you? We don't interested listening your propaganda.
@user-jj6mx3tc1g
@user-jj6mx3tc1g 2 года назад
@@enkhzayazundui1063 This comes from the real history!
@Taurineg
@Taurineg 2 года назад
Mongolia: I'm not stuck here with you, you're stuck here with me. *LOUD CAVALRY NOISES*
@avolto4822
@avolto4822 2 года назад
I do like the irony that the Mongols are the ones caught between global powers instead of global powers being caught in front of them. Much love to my Mongolian friends,
@Jake-dh9qk
@Jake-dh9qk 2 года назад
The Mongols as a nation historically never had much staying power. They primarily relied on capturing already-developed nations and taking over the governments. Most of the territories Mongols held were just empty lands and the only worthwhile nations they occupied was China, India and some parts of Middle east but that didn't last long too.
@Killzoneguy117
@Killzoneguy117 2 года назад
​@@Jake-dh9qk What a crock of shit. Empty lands? The cities of Samarqand and Bukhara were two of the wealthiest cities of the Medieval World. Larger in population than most cities in Europe. The entirety of Central Asia was the nexus of the Silk Road. Filled with cosmopolitan trading centers such as Otrar, Urgench, Merv, Kandahar, Ghazni, Kashkar and Khara Khoto. Such cities saw a convergence of Greek, Bactrian, Soghdian, Persian, Scythian, Turkic, Tibetan, Indian and Chinese culture. This region saw the mingling of a variety of religions from across the world. The Greek Pantheon, Persian Zoroastrianism, Manichaeism, Nestorian Christianity, Mahayana Buddhism, Sufi Islam, Chinese Confucianism. It was the source of all manner of religious syncretism. Beliefs like Manichaeism emerged from this mixing pot, blending aspects of Zoroastrianism, Christianity and Buddhism. To this date, the Japanese guardian deity, Nio, who is repeatedly shown to be the protector of Buddha in Japanese art and religion, is believed to have been derived from none other than Heracles himself, transmitted from Greece, across the Silk Road to Japan. Moreover, the harsh countryside of the region is exactly what made them so incredibly difficult to conquer. No sedentary army could provide the necessary logistics to support any prolonged campaign through these territories. The Persians, Greeks, Chinese, Arabs and Tibetans all tried. And they all failed. The fact that the Mongols conquered it at all is not something easily done since the apparently powerful nations of Persia and China had tried and failed for centuries. Furthermore, to say that Mongol rule was "temporary" and shortlived demonstrates a profound lack of understanding just how long empires rule. Let me put some things in perspective for you. The Mongol Empire is largely believed to have existed from approximately 1206 to 1368. However, the Golden Horde, which was a part of the Mongol Empire, lasted all the way until 1502. The Chagatai ruled all the way up to 1705 in some form or another. But for the sake of ease, we won't deal with the Chagatai. So we have a range of anywhere from 162 years to 298 years. So that's almost 300 years at its maximum. And again, we're not even counting the Chagatai or the successor states like the Timurids, or the Mughals. For reference, the British Empire, starting from the date of the formation of the United Kingdom of Great Britain in 1707 and ending at the conclusion of World War II in 1945, lasted 238 years. 238 to the Mongols' 298. Who's the short lived empire here? Even if we take a more liberal estimate of the British Empire and bump it up to 1970, to account for Britain's post-War holdings, later lost in the Wars of Decolonization, we only get to 263 years. Still less than the time the Mongols were a player on the world stage. And again, this is me being generous, since the British were hardly a major power for the first half of the 18th Century or really after 1940. The Soviet Union only lasted from 1917 to 1991. Not even 100 years. Napoleon's French Empire barely lasted 10 years. Alexander's great Hellenistic Empire fell into infighting immediately after his death. And even the successor Diadochi states were completely conquered by the Romans and Parthians within 300 years of Alexander's death. So approximately the same amount of time as the Mongols. Shall we now say that Alexander was an unsuccessful or ultimately irrelevant general? Even your American Empire has only been around for 245 years and its already starting to show its cracks and decline. 150-300 years is a pretty good range for empires. The Mongols were not shortlived. Their reign was quite average. And quite impactful.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
⚪ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@bilguuntuvshinbold8425
@bilguuntuvshinbold8425 2 года назад
@@Killzoneguy117 Brooo you be working on your replies, better than some people working on their finals exam essay
@Jake-dh9qk
@Jake-dh9qk 2 года назад
@@Killzoneguy117 You didnt even read people's comment before writing do you? I never said Mongol never had populated regions. Im talking about geopgraphically, they were empty plains. All those rich regions you were talking about belonged to OTHER nations that Mongols captured, hence my point stating that Mongols captured most of the rich cities. All these trade regions HAPPENED before Mongol empire was even formed. The Mongols just came in a captured them as was their goal of conquest to begin with. There is a reason why they wanted to conquer China and their neigbhors because they had far wealthier cities and regions than the Mongol plains. Mongolians were never starters, only conquerers.That is a simple side-effect of their tribalistic government form. Every region they took over they had to rely on the former government structure to rule to occupied lands. This is why as soon as the Mongol empire collapsed majority of the realesed-states returned back to their former culture and political structure. Mongola just don't have the capacity or manpower to rule as a solid government.
@bfera4074
@bfera4074 2 года назад
Ahhh Mongolia, the boys love mongolia...
@wuhanbiruSux
@wuhanbiruSux 2 года назад
Mongolia got some good milkshake that bring the boys to the yard
@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx
@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx 2 года назад
@@wuhanbiruSux Wut 😅
@Axeallot
@Axeallot 2 года назад
@@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx Nomad joke. The boys in this case are Nomads
@realhumphreyappleby
@realhumphreyappleby 2 года назад
Ah I thought you were talking about Clarkson, Hammond and May
@skeire1
@skeire1 2 года назад
Mongolia is chill
@Smirnaffskiy
@Smirnaffskiy 2 года назад
Fun fact, Mongolia asked USSR to annex them, but USSR refused that to keep good relations with China
@sunclonkt7839
@sunclonkt7839 2 года назад
As an Mongolian, I'm glad USSR refused.
@temuulenjargalbayar796
@temuulenjargalbayar796 2 года назад
Our grandparents would never ask USSR to annex us. We fought for our independence, many lives were lost.
@Omer1996E.C
@Omer1996E.C 2 года назад
Actually, the ussr made Mongolia it's satellite state
@Smirnaffskiy
@Smirnaffskiy 2 года назад
@@temuulenjargalbayar796 I don't know what common people thought of that, but the historical fact is that Mongolian leaders proposed USSR to become its 16th republic. But there was no point for USSR to accept this offer since Mongolia was already its puppet
@Smirnaffskiy
@Smirnaffskiy 2 года назад
@@Omer1996E.C that's true
@blackpowderuser373
@blackpowderuser373 2 года назад
China: It's time to reclaim our historical territories. The Century of Humiliation no more! Mongolia: Interesting...
@erozionzeall6371
@erozionzeall6371 2 года назад
I've been fearing a Chinese invasion for a long time now.
@TusharSharma-cy9xo
@TusharSharma-cy9xo 2 года назад
@@erozionzeall6371 the world will respond to any invasion by china, dont worry
@thelastofthehitachi972
@thelastofthehitachi972 2 года назад
@@TusharSharma-cy9xo Tibet: oh really?
@leihtory7423
@leihtory7423 2 года назад
When Mongolia conquered China, China became part of Mongolia. But eventually Chinese People out breed the conquerors. Then Mongolia became part of China. Tibet also conquered China, China became part of Tibet. Again eventually Chinese People out breed the conquerors Then Tibet became part of China. Mongolia: Interesting... 👈🤣
@unifiedhorizons2663
@unifiedhorizons2663 2 года назад
@@leihtory7423 out breed them? China has almost always had a population well over 800 million in the 10000 year wars over 200M died making it the deadliest war in history man power don’t mean anything, ask Vietnam who make it into main land China 🇨🇳 during a 2 front war
@mohammadgalihputra4081
@mohammadgalihputra4081 2 года назад
When you went from conquering almost the entire Asia and all the way to Europe, into being nestled between two world superpower countries…
@user-jj6mx3tc1g
@user-jj6mx3tc1g 2 года назад
@Regular dude on internet. Just a hint, the Mongols were ruled by the Han for 800 years before Genghis Khan! Genghis khan regime is the first thing to recruit han literati become prime minister, when all the Mongolian government orders are written in Chinese characters! 80% of Genghis Khan's life time is the identity of the Chinese people ~
@skylancerv3877
@skylancerv3877 2 года назад
@@user-jj6mx3tc1g that not true. Mongolia had their own characters and they used it. However your saying might be true before Mongols created their own characters. Fun fact: Mongolian had 4 kind of different characters to write throught the history except for cyrillic that modern mongolia is using.
@khadbat1196
@khadbat1196 2 года назад
@@user-jj6mx3tc1g lie! Mongols united ancient chinese 5 dynastie s to collect taxes which created todays china! Same to russia who paid tax to Mongolia 300 years!!! Your ccp feels shame to reveal the true history!!!
@nooobbbox
@nooobbbox 2 года назад
@@user-jj6mx3tc1g 动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门
@Genso326
@Genso326 2 года назад
All countries have its own peak and fall.
@avantelvsitania3359
@avantelvsitania3359 2 года назад
“Basically I am a badass and a manipulator of this game.” Mongolia, probably
@realtalk6195
@realtalk6195 2 года назад
Huh? Did you watch the alternate-reality version of this video or something? Majority of Mongolians follow Tibetan Buddhism but obviously can't speak in support of their own religious leader nor for the Tibetans. Ethnic Mongolians ("Southern Mongolians") are also increasingly persecuted in China, and Mongolia can't speak out or make any demands about that either. Mongolia is completely economically dependent on Russia and China, much like the Central Asia states. The only positive it has going for it is that it's democratic, but the negative is that they don't even share a land border with neighboring Kazakhstan because Russia and China falls in-between obstructing it. Otherwise, it would have given them a land corridor to the rest of Asia. Mongolia is on the receiving end of manipulation.
@concept5631
@concept5631 2 года назад
@@realtalk6195 Despite being on the end of said manipulation they're doing pretty well with the cards they were dealt.
@Testingthisname
@Testingthisname Год назад
@@realtalk6195 "The only positive it has going for it is that it's democratic," That's not a positive you dunce
@archipiratta
@archipiratta 2 года назад
"To build high one must dig deep." Shirvan dropping those nuggets!
@redcorruption4561
@redcorruption4561 2 года назад
Genghis Khan: look how they massacred my boy
@unlimited8410
@unlimited8410 2 года назад
@@user-jj6mx3tc1g If you want to be a more convincing, it'll do good for your 50 cent army, if you learnt more coherent english
@Nmdve
@Nmdve 2 года назад
​@@user-jj6mx3tc1g I think the fact that you were born was an accident too. Don`t say bullshits like you know everything.
@nehcooahnait7827
@nehcooahnait7827 2 года назад
Well he massacred plenty of bois and gals across Eurasia quite literally lol
@nehcooahnait7827
@nehcooahnait7827 2 года назад
@@unlimited8410 don’t what he said. Could he be Japanese?
@enkhkhulegoidov5774
@enkhkhulegoidov5774 2 года назад
@@nehcooahnait7827 looking at his replies on other comments, I think he's very likely a chinese shill. Might have a japanese name either as an alias, or he's just a weeb.
@brickbastardly
@brickbastardly 2 года назад
Been following Mongolia for a while and can’t wait to visit it. I was super happy to see you guys do an episode on them.
@patrickcloutier6801
@patrickcloutier6801 2 года назад
I have acquaintances, who once upon a time, served in the Soviet military. The Mongolians left a very good impression on them, both ethically and as soldiers.
@deathrouter3443
@deathrouter3443 2 года назад
Mongolia in the 14th century: I have ruled the whole of Eurasia. the world shall bow to our great khan. Mongolia in the 21st century: well shit
@nehcooahnait7827
@nehcooahnait7827 2 года назад
It was the 12-13th century. Mongol’s Yuan Dynasty and its Centro Asian khanates in the 14th century were a chaos and fell apart lol.
@joeywall4657
@joeywall4657 2 года назад
I've always been a fanboy of Mongolia. Such a fantastic and mysterious place with amazing natural beauty. Ever since I was a little kid in the early 80s, I've been interested in learning everything I can about the people and culture. I'm glad to see that they are expertly navigating their precarious situation and maintain their democratic and free system.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🔶 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@adhocluya
@adhocluya 2 года назад
Much love!
@G1ennbeckismyher0
@G1ennbeckismyher0 2 года назад
Dude, me too! For me it was the game age of empires that got me curious.
@benjamindavidovichwaals2899
@benjamindavidovichwaals2899 2 года назад
@@irasingh2498 hello indian troll bebe
@TUkrLad
@TUkrLad 2 года назад
If you are ever in the area HMU.
@davaanyamotgonbold3589
@davaanyamotgonbold3589 2 года назад
Thanks for making quality video about our country. Keep your great work going. Always excited to watch your new uploads👍
@kirkhenry2652
@kirkhenry2652 2 года назад
This is exceptional content, as always. Caspian Report is the best channel on geopolitics I've seen. Thank you for your programs and your education, truly excellent!
@DigitalNeb
@DigitalNeb 2 года назад
As an American, I can honestly say that I've admired Mongolia from afar. A tiny nation of horsemen that conquered the world and just as quickly disappeared back into the steppe. Throughout all the intervening years they still remained a living culture, and here they are to this day, proudly holding their horse hair banners. What a great country and people.
@nickneonz3888
@nickneonz3888 2 года назад
Thank you my friend
@zoloob8839
@zoloob8839 2 года назад
exactly
@andrewgilbert6614
@andrewgilbert6614 2 года назад
yah, Mongolia is dope as hell
@AR-rg2en
@AR-rg2en 2 года назад
They didn't just conquer Asia, they caused a massive genocide unparalleled in history, worse than holocaust.
@DigitalNeb
@DigitalNeb 2 года назад
@@AR-rg2en Oh come on. You can't compare those times with the modern era. They also introduced a lot of useful things to the areas they subjugated. You should read up on it. They're a fascinating people.
@bxzidffbxzidff
@bxzidffbxzidff 2 года назад
I love these videos focusing on smaller players on the international stage. How cunning they have to be to navigate the geopolitical landscape as they can't just force their will through power is really interesting. Thank you Shirvan for teaching about the politics of such a fascinating country in an unique situation!
@zarketlarket9625
@zarketlarket9625 2 года назад
Thanks for the consistent content, I’ve actually quoted you twice now for some of the lectures I give. Keep up the good work I love your insight !
@petergorm
@petergorm 2 года назад
This is amazing on so many levels. Great upload as always! Thank you, Caspian.
@naranbaz
@naranbaz 2 года назад
As a Mongolian, it was interesting to watch this report from a neutral observer. Great stuff.
@draum8103
@draum8103 2 года назад
He's not neutral at all. Many of his videos are weirdly biased, like the ones against France.
@mello3762
@mello3762 2 года назад
@@draum8103 it's impossible to be completely neutral. Everyone and everything is biased in some way, shape or form
@NoNameAtAll2
@NoNameAtAll2 Год назад
"neutral" ha hahahaha
@bcbliss5147
@bcbliss5147 2 года назад
Your work and insight in all these videos I watch is fantastic. I can't get enough of them and I have learned so much all while being entertained! Great stuff
@HustleMasta
@HustleMasta 2 года назад
Great Video! As a Mongolian, I thank you very much for putting this video out for everyone to learn more about my country! Sure we have our own issues with corruption, poverty and whatnot but Mongolia is a bastion of democracy that needs to be protected!
@miroslavhoudek7085
@miroslavhoudek7085 2 года назад
No worries Mongolia, you are not between a dragon and a bear. You are between a paper dragon and a drunk homeless guy in a bear costume.
@TheEatraum
@TheEatraum 2 года назад
This is one of my favorite channels to feed my hunger for learning about geopolitics and global economics
@littleredbull1140
@littleredbull1140 2 года назад
Interesting and excellently produced as always.
@erka8032
@erka8032 2 года назад
Greetings from Ulaanbaatar. We play civilization at the deity level. Thanks Shirvan for another well researched video.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🔳 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@StratosphereTHAI
@StratosphereTHAI 2 года назад
Try doing neo-colonialism like Thailand did with laos It might make you an asshole but it give you enough air to breath away from china
@EarlyBirdCraft
@EarlyBirdCraft 2 года назад
Yeah? Not sure what civilization you’re talking about. The last time I checked you still have the wooden dump toilet, lmao
@timby2383
@timby2383 2 года назад
well your civilization brought great harm and devastation to many people (800 years ago). Karma is a b*tch!
@QWERTY-gp8fd
@QWERTY-gp8fd 2 года назад
@@timby2383 still better than most african countries and nk.
@oldmanMikehere
@oldmanMikehere 2 года назад
Best channel I've found on RU-vid. Keep it up mate.
@hairyhaggis7431
@hairyhaggis7431 2 года назад
Mongolia: if I don’t move, they won’t see me
@keiker2254
@keiker2254 2 года назад
As an upside we are the only country in the world that could seriously mess with the US and not fear any major retaliation. I mean: good luck getting permission to pass troops through either China or Russia lol
@eyeofthepyramid2596
@eyeofthepyramid2596 2 года назад
Yep
@unifiedhorizons2663
@unifiedhorizons2663 2 года назад
Russia: um america I’ll give you permission if you give more coal rights… from China AMERica: o god yes Russia didn’t do anything when Poland threatened war and place 50K soldiers and one tank decision on Belarus broader when Belarus threaten polish people and told the president he ain’t fighting all of Europe because he desided to harm the Polish monitory in Belarus. so I see Russia allow a full military under promise of RUSSIA getting more Chinese shares. as monilga prefers trading with Us and so it make the most sense
@John_Doe448
@John_Doe448 2 года назад
@@unifiedhorizons2663 your comparison is lacking a major weakpoint. It's the US military we're talking about. Never would Russia let them in. They've learned a lesson not to trust them
@wholesomebaker5410
@wholesomebaker5410 2 года назад
Three devil's of USA nobody can't run away from: Rockets. Drones. CIA.
@estoniaisunderrated5120
@estoniaisunderrated5120 2 года назад
When Afghanistan tried to play the two Cold War superpowers it backfired on them. Hopefully Mongolia can play three great powers better than Afghanistan could play the two.
@CB6028
@CB6028 2 года назад
Excellent report. Your posts always leave me better informed.
@jimmie3232
@jimmie3232 2 года назад
"After all to build high one must dig deep." Deep... wow Shirvan!
@sempleinvest906
@sempleinvest906 2 года назад
I admire their efforts to being as independent as possible despite being stuck between a rock and a hard place.. must be tough.
@martanoconghaile
@martanoconghaile 2 года назад
"to build high, one must dig deep". Love it!
@MRRookie232
@MRRookie232 2 года назад
Your writing is getting better, thanks Shirvan
@historyandmilitarytraining9641
@historyandmilitarytraining9641 2 года назад
Once a superpower is now surrounded by superpowers.
@delgermuruntsagaankhuu6951
@delgermuruntsagaankhuu6951 2 года назад
Holyllylylylylyl shiiiit How this is a literal dream come true seeing my country featured
@orango9717
@orango9717 2 года назад
@President Xi Jing Ping Ok Winnie the Pooh
@thefool1086
@thefool1086 2 года назад
@President Xi Jing Ping Hi Xi, please don't steal my organs.
@benjamindavidovichwaals2899
@benjamindavidovichwaals2899 2 года назад
@President Xi Jing Ping hello indian troll bebe
@batochir
@batochir 2 года назад
Баяр хүргэе миний хөгшө :)
@Joker-yw9hl
@Joker-yw9hl 2 года назад
Respect to Mongolia from the UK
@mongol-erdenesoyombo9916
@mongol-erdenesoyombo9916 2 года назад
thanks man
@michaeljames2349
@michaeljames2349 2 года назад
The writing in this channel is so good!
@tvo3205
@tvo3205 2 года назад
earliest ive been on CaspianReport! keep up the impactful content!!!
@eurasiaacaci.-110
@eurasiaacaci.-110 2 года назад
Vlad the Impaler: son of dragon can relate to Mongolia’s situation right now
@Bilgunkhan1
@Bilgunkhan1 2 года назад
Very well researched video! Truly
@718Insomniac
@718Insomniac 2 года назад
great video man! keep up the good work. you are one of the Best channels I gotta say.
@ariarigun4840
@ariarigun4840 2 года назад
As a Mongolian, Thank you for your high quality videos, I was kind of expecting and wanted a video on our country and expected as always, excellent video and research.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
♦️ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@murilosilvavalenga5492
@murilosilvavalenga5492 2 года назад
@@irasingh2498 no
@haikaloronsentnel138
@haikaloronsentnel138 2 года назад
I H0PES M0NG0L!A ST!LL W!TH BUDDH!SM REL!G!0US AND CULTURE!!!
@alexanderking521
@alexanderking521 2 года назад
"play the bear and the dragon against eachother" what an absolute gem
@inkbold8511
@inkbold8511 2 года назад
In the end they still got stuck as 3rd world country.
@andrewbest5854
@andrewbest5854 2 года назад
Great work again Shirvan. Another important area of the world most people know little to nothing about.
@harishjain714
@harishjain714 2 года назад
As always, amazing. Never miss a single video.
@reecesmith3199
@reecesmith3199 2 года назад
love the vids keep them up. always like listening to them in the morning with my coffee.
@chrisklitou7573
@chrisklitou7573 2 года назад
Mongolia becoming the Switzerland of Asia
@adhocluya
@adhocluya 2 года назад
thanks for the HOPE! ❤️❤️❤️
@googane7755
@googane7755 2 года назад
Except they're not mountainous or rich, is wholly landlocked (i.e no navigable rivers to facilitate international trade) and borders russia and china. Not a great hand to be dealt with
@hendrikdependrik1891
@hendrikdependrik1891 2 года назад
Mongolia is a sort of Poland trying to play Switzerland.
@chrisklitou7573
@chrisklitou7573 2 года назад
@@hendrikdependrik1891 yeah China is USSR and Russia is the Nazi Germany
@evilsquizz
@evilsquizz 2 года назад
fun fact : inner mogolia gdp is 18times bigger than mogolia
@josron6088
@josron6088 2 года назад
That had to be one of the most unusual cityscapes I've seen.
@jeteun4480
@jeteun4480 2 года назад
Thank you, Shirvan!
@cristianamesmasek8420
@cristianamesmasek8420 2 года назад
Excellent video Shirvan!!
@michaelhasson7072
@michaelhasson7072 2 года назад
Yet another fascinating and informative video 👏
@The_Essential_Review
@The_Essential_Review 2 года назад
20th century Poland: "First time?"
@armandeepsingh1843
@armandeepsingh1843 2 года назад
Atleast poland had a little bit of sea coast
@googane7755
@googane7755 2 года назад
@@armandeepsingh1843 And allies... though not very reliable ones
@Brandonhayhew
@Brandonhayhew 2 года назад
History repeats, its 21th century and Mongolia might be in a poland like situation
@tennisonchristopher861
@tennisonchristopher861 2 года назад
Very good report with deep insights. Thanks.
@melulekimhayise9662
@melulekimhayise9662 2 года назад
A beautiful report. Thank you.
@MalekEllouz00
@MalekEllouz00 2 года назад
I thought he was gonna say “when money talks, bullshit walks” 😂
@benjamindavidovichwaals2899
@benjamindavidovichwaals2899 2 года назад
Lol
@suvajeetdatta1220
@suvajeetdatta1220 2 года назад
I'm really curious how you make these amazing map animations
@carlrodalegrado4104
@carlrodalegrado4104 2 года назад
He has a website on this
@gideonmele1556
@gideonmele1556 2 года назад
Always very informative and as per tradition, some excellent one liners
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟢 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@elegost2570
@elegost2570 2 года назад
Great content as always!
@nandin-erdenebattogtokh2864
@nandin-erdenebattogtokh2864 2 года назад
I am kind of flattered to see many people discussing passionately about our nation. People have too many opinions tho 🤷‍♀️
@desert_jin6281
@desert_jin6281 2 года назад
I always wondered what Mongolia did after the dissolution of the Soviet Union and about the current geopolitical stakes. Thank you for clarifying !
@EarlyBirdCraft
@EarlyBirdCraft 2 года назад
Mongolia is slowly dissolving itself. Life is getting worse and worse everyday.
@TheTobyvancouver
@TheTobyvancouver 2 года назад
Chervan, thank you so much for what you. I learn so much from your videos.
@dernopenope2005
@dernopenope2005 2 года назад
You did a hell of a job as always, thanks
@dunnowy123
@dunnowy123 2 года назад
Mongolia is like the aging father with two highly successful kids - Russia and China - who he always has to keep an eye, to ensure they don't take advantage of him.
@ankitaharwal5886
@ankitaharwal5886 2 года назад
More like having two parents(china and Russia) and both wanna have devorce and get custody of child(Mongolia)
@dunnowy123
@dunnowy123 2 года назад
@@ankitaharwal5886 That's fair. Lol
@MrErdem95
@MrErdem95 2 года назад
Mongolia got the whole Switzerland thingy wrong. You need a mountainous country and not having a neighbour with a 1.5 bn people.
@Axeallot
@Axeallot 2 года назад
Its a hard choice, unlike Switzerland we have long way to turn into a developed nation Stay neutral and stay underdeveloped. Cater to Russia and fk up your democracy Loosen up to China and lose your identity Befriend USA and get Poland rushed
@nehcooahnait7827
@nehcooahnait7827 2 года назад
1.4bn people in 2020 consensus. Plus Russia it would be ‘TWO’ neighbors with 1.5bn people
@floso1916
@floso1916 2 года назад
Yet another great video! Keep it up
@jeroendolfyn680
@jeroendolfyn680 2 года назад
Thanks a lot for what you are doing! Your videos are very informative. I am very happy I got to know your channel. You clearly put a lot of effort into researching your videos. I LOIK IT A LOT!!!
@skyfeelan
@skyfeelan 2 года назад
'Mongolia must play the bear and the dragon against one another, and itermittently pulled the eagle into the mix, just to throw anyone off their game' - Shirvan 2021
@brentmcwilliams4332
@brentmcwilliams4332 2 года назад
To build high, one must dig deep. Love the life wisdom there when taken metaphorically.
@Alftura
@Alftura 2 года назад
Another Great video!! Love these. Thanks! :)
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🟡 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@mihalysuba9432
@mihalysuba9432 2 года назад
Great work as usual.
@sandraashton868
@sandraashton868 2 года назад
This is the ultimate example of being caught between a rock and a hard place
@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368
@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368 2 года назад
Mongolian chariots were so broken in Civ1. You could basically conquer the world before the year 2,000 BC and win the game with a ridiculously high score only using two of them.
@didierduval5472
@didierduval5472 2 года назад
Top quality as usual!
@jacob-cs5fx
@jacob-cs5fx 2 года назад
We appreciate your content Mr. Caspain.
@irasingh2498
@irasingh2498 2 года назад
🌫️ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE CASPIAN REPORT
@CountingStars333
@CountingStars333 2 года назад
Throat singing intensifies.
@Kriegter
@Kriegter 2 года назад
Don't worry Genghis Khan's descendants would fix everything! Wait a minute Genghis Khan's descendants.....? OH NO OH SHIT
@PakBallandSami
@PakBallandSami 2 года назад
hi dude
@Brandonhayhew
@Brandonhayhew 2 года назад
Nobody cares about mongolia , it’s just a poor country
@goldenproductions7831
@goldenproductions7831 2 года назад
@@Brandonhayhew we know that buddy
@siddhunkarthik
@siddhunkarthik 2 года назад
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂👆👆👆👆
@Omer1996E.C
@Omer1996E.C 2 года назад
@@Brandonhayhew yeah, this was the beginning of an empire
@benlamprecht6414
@benlamprecht6414 2 года назад
Yet another brilliant analysis and excellent presentation. Thanks
@EdeYOlorDSZs
@EdeYOlorDSZs 2 года назад
Great episode once again, keep it up!
@furn2313
@furn2313 2 года назад
Now that's a country I can respect!
@googane7755
@googane7755 2 года назад
Mongolia is like switzerland except they're not mountainous or rich, is wholly landlocked (i.e no navigable rivers to facilitate international trade) and borders russia and china. Diplomacy is the only thing they have.
@tylerriggins1252
@tylerriggins1252 2 года назад
This was one of your best
@whitefeather7529
@whitefeather7529 2 года назад
Great piece! Thanks.
Далее
Central Asia on the verge of a water war
14:46
Просмотров 514 тыс.
How Australia cheated East Timor of its oil
15:56
Просмотров 340 тыс.
Geography Now! MONGOLIA
14:38
Просмотров 2,4 млн
You Can ONLY Do This In MONGOLIA! 🐎 (#165)
28:11
Просмотров 211 тыс.
Australia’s insane plan to green the Outback
15:29
Просмотров 1,8 млн
Iraq is dying (and that is a global problem)
20:00
Просмотров 443 тыс.
Pakistan is dying (and that is a global problem)
15:19
Why Oil Doesn’t Corrupt Norway
14:12
Просмотров 1,6 млн
Why Russia's Biggest Threat is Actually China
36:21
Просмотров 10 млн
The Problem With the USA's Borders
32:53
Просмотров 3,3 млн