My cousin has Jinafire and I have Spectra. And fun fact, this line was originally going to be called "Return to Skull Shores" and they were supposed to be deluxe dolls and each doll originally came with the Tikis from "Escape from Skull Shores".
I think Jane and Elissabat are my favorites. While Jane is very different, it's still a very natural theme for her, and she looks great. Her hair is the best quality, too. Elissabat just feels very complete and finished- I love her colors and outfit, and she's my favorite doll of hers since her first. Spectra looks great, but her accessories betray her- the headband is very poorly fitted and the sash isn't very secure. Jinafire is the worst quality-wise, with thin hair and lots of glue problems, and the look doesn't suit her well. I don't have Meowlody, but she's solid. I like that they separated the twins to make them more individual, but the doll itself is just good, not great.
I got jane today im in the uk I think she is exclusive to argos here was only £5.99 bargain. I love spectras shoes especially on her with her clear feet my favourite spectra is the power ghouls but unfortunately you can't see her clear feet. Xx
Criticisms- Spectra- Her hair is poorly executed. Otherwise everything is perfect Meowldy- She was fine not noticeable or anything but fine. Jinafire- her hair is poorly executed I do not like the doll at all Jane- ABSOULUTELY IN LOVE WITH IT OMG WHAT? She looks she is in her home environment like Jane before mh. Elissabat- JUST LIKE JANE SHE IS PERFECT UNLIKE THE NON Target exclusives. Do not witchhunt me or hate me for my opinions. These are just my opinions.