Prayer circle that Spotfur's personality recovers from "I am nice mother" syndrome and that she goads her kids into annoying their mentors or bringing her snacks from their hunts
I want her to be Squirrelflight's Squirrelflight. I mean, she should go against some of Squirrelflight's orders because they go against her own moral code some time. And influencing her kids to her political opinions would also be great.
The concept of double heaven is the only consolation for the fandom since a Light in the Mist came out. (We all know Spottedleaf’s double death would and will never hit as hard. I don’t care if they decanonize Spottedleaf’s heart, no one will ever forget it.
Hello I’m not updated on the current books but what do you mean by Bristlefrost speaking to Spottedleaf??? Spottedleaf is still alive??? There’s another StarClan heaven ?
I like squilf because she basically went through the most of any cat. She was an apprentice when she made the expedition to midnight, but unlike Crowpaw, she actually chose to go on a death defying journey to save the clans. The two toms she liked were both bad in their own ways and Brambleclaw yelled at her constantly because she was trying to tell him that his brother was evil. She was coerced into taking in her sisters kits, raised them as her own, lied to her mate, father, mother and the entire clan. And what did she get for it? Her ex threatens her niece and nephews and reveals that he tried to kill her father because she didnt like him. And then her niece reveals her lie to every cat at the gathering and now her niece is presumed dead, her sister lost her job and her cat husband hates her because she prioritized her sisters safety over him knowing who the parents of the kits he was raising were. then it is revealed that cat hell is gonna try to kill the clans and theres a huge fight and then her niece is dead and her dad is dead and other cats she cared about are dead. I dont get how you can hate a character that has gone through that much. Like, does she need more problems?
I can't say who my top favorite cats are (since I'm indecisive) but my number 1 has to be Crookedstar. He went through so much but still didn't turn 'evil'
I would have loved if starflower went from casual villain to the type of "redeemed good guy" that just, does villainous things for the good guys. "Oh you wanna mess with my kits? My clan mates? Hm, a bold decision, how bout i shove you out of a tree?" Would have been a hilarious and in character turn for her. ETA: jayfeather reminds me a lot of 2 of the best cats ive ever own so im hella biased, but after him, and squilf, cause squilf, i adore not just dovewing and ivypool, but their relationship, especially in the dark forest arc. Its a very realistic strained suster relationship, ine that i can see myself in from bith sides. I dont pick a favorite, but these are all in the "favorite" tier lol
For Star Flower I still prefer her to turn out to be a player like Clear Sky was, who ends up backstabbing him which would be very ironic because of how often he underestimates his girlfriends. She should betray him and take over SkyClan, revealing she was always planning on doing so as revenge...
@@Anne-wf1vo i would also be down with this specifically because fuck clearsky, he's SUCH an asshole. Like yes, please let the cat he backstabbed his kid over turn around and backstab him. I would be down with that
THIS. I completely agree, and on the ivypool Dovewing thing. I. Hate. It. when people are ranting about one being a bad character (I mean obviously ivypool did do bad things but that doesn’t make a bad character) like it’s interesting to see sisters with a talent imbalance and how they deal with it. It not doves fault shes good at things and things and it’s not ivys fault that she has to work harder! (Although i do blame the mentors/adults in the clan for not nipping it in the bud, like if her sister is going on a special mission is it really so hard try and make ivy feel special too?! Like just try and give her more attention and fun tasks and stuff instead of punishing her for being jealous, how hard is that!? Not to mention letting a child go be traumatized by beavers.) it’s also relatable to see them both struggling with how easily dove does things and learns things ivy struggles with and how ivy feels lesser than even if she does well!
Now that you pointed it out there might be some truth in that "attached to one of the sisters" thing with Squirrel Leaf and Dove Ivy, i got more attached to the other two. Leaf probably because of how she tries to hold things together and wants to help everyone but it all just causes stress. And Ivy because she really wanted to fit in, belong somewhere, she felt like she was being left out and that drew her into a worse situation.
Learning that Moonkitty is a Starlight Glimmer supporter has watered my crops and brightened my day lol If you were ever inclined to make MLP character videos of any sort I would be SO happy
I'm so glad you show Poppyfrost some love, I've always loved her because she just felt so distinct 👍 Edit: here is my top 10 list cause why not lol: 1. Squirrelflight 2. Hollyleaf 3. Needletail 4. Brightheart 5. Ivypool 6. Jayfeather 7. Poppyfrost 8. Mothwing 9. Bristlefrost 10. Violetshine
You have good taste in warrior cats! We share multiple favorites! Here's my list, in no particular order except that Hollyleaf and Ivypool are more favoured above the rest: 1: Hollyleaf 2: Ivypool 3: Ravenpaw 4: Leafpool 5: Briarlight 6: Cinderpelt 7: Jayfeather 8: Mothflight 9: Firestar 10: Thrushpelt (Edited because I misspelled things)
My top ten before watching : 1) Puddleshine (I love how hard working and brave he is despite everything) 2)Bristlefrost (She was a really good and well written character) 3) Alderheart (I relate to his anxiety) 4) Lilyheart (Just so cute. She is sweet but totally able to stand up and yell at Bramblestar when needed) 5) Squilf (Love her) 6) Frostpaw (Poor baby) 7) Jayfeather (So iconic) 8) Dovewing (Best mom ever. Plus She is very interresting as a pov character) 9) Tallstar (❤) 10) Briarlight (Never forget , she had an adorable relation with Jay)
I like moth flight, lilyheart, yellowfang, mapleshade, squilf, jayfeather, thrushpelt, crowfeather, snowbush, and nightstar, no not that nightstar the other one
You're really right on the money with those characters who are in unfair situations. I will always root for a character whos been abused by the narrative and its so satisfying to watch them succeed
heres my top 10 !!! #10 : brokenstar. hes an og villian whos just complete maniac and evil since birth, hes just a the most evil ever and i love it. #9 : poppyfrost. shes intresting !! #8 : rosetail. hopeless romantic kitty who surprisingly didnt ever get a mate despite somehow knowing every single relationship (both romantic and platonic) in thunderclan. #7 : mothwing. her entire story is so trans coded i adore and love her #6 : scourge. he got me into emo furries. #5 : firestar. HES INTRESTING!!! idc if he turned "mary sue" but god his story is so interesting and i think one of the like handful of somewhat compelling character stories #4 : dovewing, i think shes cool and has an interesting dynamic #3 : squirrelflight
I love Poppyfrost bc i believe it's said that she looks so much like Sorreltail. Sorreltail and Leafpool had a cutr friendship so seeing Jay and Poppy having a nice friendship just mirrors their moms and i think it's sweet.
monkeystar is also in my top five and the idea of a book where she gives up leadership to fang keeps me up at night. i hope instead they give her nine lives in her very own super edition
i find myself barely able to attach to any of the characters in warrior cats (this doesnt apply for like any other show, i guess the personalities in warrior cats just arent my thing. I'm only on arc 4 though, so this could change.) but i do have a couple characters i like (in no order) ravenpaw (its ravenpaw, who doesnt like ravenpaw ?? hes nervous, sweet, gets a good little life with barely, and just an overall good character in my eyes) firestar (i unironically love him so much, like i get he's kinda basic but i love his story i love how he was the voice of reason when bluestar kinda went crazy i love how even in arc 4 hes seen to be fairly reasonable, and also hes very much a pacifist who will never result to violence in most situations unless its needed, which makes other leaders view him as weak or scared when he's really not he's just not angry and thinks violence is the only answer ever.) dovepaw (from where i am in the books she's only dovepaw, and like, she's fine. she's a decent character i like her as a protagonist, but i'm excited for how she will be later.) briarlight (i love briarlight !!! how could i not yknow, basically for the same reasons moonkitti said.) greystripe (okay ... listen. i don't like him as much in more recent books but i adored him earlier on. he went through SO much honestly, and he's still just that goofy little silly guy. i liked him for just being a laidback guy !) kestrelflight (you're probably thinking, kestrelflight ???? yes. im upset he's not a more main character, like he barely exist. but i love his personality so much. he's sweet, kind of dumb, gullible, and just an overall good person who's always willing to help. I LOVE DUMB BUT SWEET CHARACTERS WITH ALL MY HEART !!!! this is mostly seen when jay uses him for herbs and descripts him as dumb but sweet himself. kestrelflight probably wouldve handed the herbs over without question if jay just ... asked.) im updating this to say kestrelflight is my favorite character i do not care he gets a scene once in a half moon hes a silly guy UPDATE : im on arc 5 now and i really love fuzzball and fernsong (backgrounds characters forever !!!!!) that was really long oops
Alderheart and brightheart are tied as my favourite warrior cats characters. But i also really like squirrelflight, ravenpaw, shadowsight, dovewing, briarlight, ashfur, nightstar and and owlnose. I dont know why i got really attached to him in this newest arc though, but hes my child and also really funny. Theres probably more i really like but i struggle with memory sometimes
This has nothing to do with Warrior Cats but Moonkitti mentioning DS9 gave me so much joy MAJOR DS9 SPOILERS (SEASON 7) Glad I'm not the only one who Dovewing reminds of Ezri Dax, I made some disussinons on the character a while back and made a point saying she has "Dovewing syndrome"
honestly still catching up on the newer series i'm still on omen of the stars on my reread just about to finish it so i had to skip about half of this video but the other half i very much enjoy your takes on!!!!! i like mapleshade for the same reasons you like starflower because shes just awful and i hate her so much. poppyfrost is also weirdly high on the list for me as well because its such a unique and unexplored perspective that i feel like they definitely did on accident but its still a fun and interestng read to go "ohhh!!" at during her scenes, shes got a bit more personality because of those moments with her than so many other background characters that shes just really neat briarlight is also one of my favorites because she is HILARIOUS... oh briarlight you silly kitty you are so silly and funny. her optimism inspires me a lot and i think she's just a really cool dude i'd want to be her friend if i were a cat in thunderclan i would just hang out in the medicine den and gossip with her all day and lastly i never gave dovewing much thought as a kid, i dont think i hated her but i remember liking ivypool more because i just thought she was cooler but now as an adult i LOVE AND APPRECIATE dovewing so much and dont understand why she got/gets(?) so much hate. she has so much anxiety and PTSD from... existing, honestly, and she handles situations and her emotions in a very relatable way, i think she's really refreshing and i always like her point of view in the books because sometimes the other chracters can feel very predictable and reactionary in a bad way, but dovewing just feels so much more grounded, i like her a lot
i have always liked both dove and ivy as characters because BOTH of them are interesting. they're some of the few interesting female cats in this series with well-rounded personalities...or at least, they started out that way
My favourites : 1st. Bristlefrost (she is well written and I just love her ) 2nd . Bluestar (iconic) 3rd. Squirrelflight (she GOT to be Squirrelstar pleaseee) 4th. Ivypool (I adored her every time she appeared in a book) 5th. Alderheart ( I relate to him so much ) 6th. Leafpool ( I just love her too) 7th. Nightheart ( he is interesting) 8th. Jayfeather ( I mean it was obvious he would be here) 9th. Hollyleaf (I hate you Hawkfrost) 10th. Ravenpaw ( my poor traumatized baby) Other cats I like but couldn't include there : Tallstar Moth'Flight Frostpaw Graywing Cinderpelt Twigbranch Mappleshade Frecklewish Puddleshine Shadowsight Rootspring Mousefur Firestar Whitestorm Fringewhisker Leopardstar (Yes I really liked the Broken code lol)
@@Ph0en1x_F1re she is amazing ngl ! I mean I know some people might dislike her but in my opinion she is the definition of a good and well written character with an interesting story
OMG MOONKITTI ALSO LIKES STARLIGHT GLIMMER?!! I love this sm Starlight is like. One of my favorite characters of all time. Also. Dovewing is my favorite cat in warriors as well
My faves in no order 1. Tallstar 2. Barley 3. Daisy 4. Mothwing 5. Crookedstar 6. Sorreltail 7. Monkeystar 8. Curlfeather 9. Cody (the kittypet) 10. Squirrelflight I haven’t read anything past OOTS but the idea of Curlfeather is very interesting, and Monkeystar is just too cute and silly to not include. I think Barley is actually my favorite ever but whatever lol
Top 10 Frostpaw ( I just like that she's nice but she's also straightforward I just wish her mentor didn't torture her.) Nightheart ( he is very mean and I think that's funny and his relationship with sunbeam is cute) Shadowsight ( he's sad and cute.) Cinderpelt ( she's the most cute cat in warriors.) Shadowstar ( I just find her a complex individual because I read her novella and she seemed so miserable) Alderheart( i like how he actually appreciates what other people do for him and doesn't hate everybody who is even a bit mesn to him ) i mean idont like his actual personality that much. ) Jayfeather ( do I have to explain this?) Honorable mentions: Fuzzball ( he only turned up in like a few chapters but I just love him so much I wish he was allowed to join thunderclan if he didn't only show up in a cew books he would probably be fav because he is so cheerful and pure. We don't have any of that in warriors.) Mistystar You know what I can't decide.
I don’t know if this comment will make it visible but I was shocked and elated to see Hawkwing on your top favorite list. He is my top favorite warrior character because I only want good things for him and I see myself in him. He’s gone through things I strongly relate to and I loved seeing this dumb, awkward, grieving, angry boy try to recover from his mistakes and have this constant whiplash of being in the right or wrong. It’s agonizing and crushing for me that he can essentially never get what he wants and because of that I root for him to have or see happiness in his life. It’s silly he gets put into deputy position but I do think it came down to well this boy has problems to work through but has potential and is loyal to his clan that has been similar to some of my own experiences. I also admire that he never really gives up. He keeps trying and that’s really motivating to me who has life beat me up a little.
ASHFUR IS SUCHHH A GOOD VILLAIN HE'S THE MAIN REASON TBC IS MY FAVE ARC! I will never understand people who hate him and that arc he's such a GOOD VILLAIN.
my top ten favorite characters! (Don’t slaughter me if you don’t like these characters this is MY OPINION.) *1. SandStorm* She’s sassy and scary and strong and honestly just a really likable character! Despite most of her time in the books is just being FireStar’s mate she still shows that sarcastic personality that I LOVE!! *2. BristleFrost* Do I even need to say? She’s a well written character and she KILLED ASHFUR! *3. CloudTail* He’s just a really likable character! a dead mother and siblings and an injured mate doesn’t stop him from shining through with his own personality! And fluff. *4. BriarLight* I don’t even need to say *5. BlossomFall* Lesbian Jat- *6. CrowFeather* He’s the type of character that’s hated by most of the fandom and that’s a major reason why I love him *7. SquirrelFlight* Like moonkitti said she does what she thinks is right! She doesn’t care about leaving a legacy as big as FireStar’s! She just cares about being herself! *8. HollyLeaf* Come on I HAD to add her into the list she’s amazing *9. BrindleFace* I love her, I love her, and I love her again. I would’ve put her higher if there wasn’t a bunch more characters that I love. *10. OneEye* Yes. Just yes. Rude, sassy, everything that I love in a character.
Yes, Yes, Yes! Especially with you on ✨Sandstorm our sassy queen✨! They should start calling her Sass storm 🩷 and ofc hollyleaf, duh. All the other cats are awesome
My personal top ten 1. Dovewing , relating to her struggle of wanting to be her OWN cat . Not just involved in some prophecy against her will. 2. Jayfeather. Hes just so angsty, and doesnt like anybody . Hes my teenage angst in a character 3.Squilf i just love squilf okay shes her own person and she has a strong sense of right and wrong and i just rlly liked her sassiness . 6. Briarlight she just brings light to any scene and makes it interesting or she just idk i just love every scene shes in 7. Firestar hes just a generic main guy, but for this reason i love him . Hes just a standard hero type . 8. Sorreltail . I just like her . Shes a neat friend to leafpool 9. Mothwing easy its mothwing. Again just like her i like her whole dynamic and that shes like a medicine cat who doesnt commune with starclan 10. Breezepelt. He is an awful person. I like that he is an awful person. I like that he stays loyal to the dark forest while everyone else doesnt . Hes a pretty terrible dude . Honorable mention to Mapleshade, Thrushpelt Tallstar, Ravenpaw, and Barley. I dont rememeber Jake much bc its been years since i read tallstars revenege but it is next on my list but what i can remember, he is a neat guy . Saw someone else do dishinorable mentions and i just wanted to mention i despise Raggedstar with a passion , i hate him , i hate him yellowfangs secret , i just despise him . Atleast with every direct villain or antagonist they have something i like , he doesnt i despise him.
7:30 So glad Moonkitti is blessing us with a warrior cats rendition of “Monkeystar the idea vs Monkeystar the cat”. This is truly a life changing event. Perchance.
Okay i never thought about it in any way but there are my top faves and they are- 1. Hawkfrost 2. Squirrelflight 3. Tawnypelt 4. Jayfeather 5. Ivypool 6. Crowfeather 7. Hollyleaf 8. Bristlefrost 9. Fernsong 10. Breezepelt (for some reason idk)
I love your top ten! I only watched this because I knew Squilf would be first or second. I haven’t been reading the books for a while, so my memory might be off. Here’s mine: 1. Squirrelflight 🐿️ (I love her. I just do. I never knew why, I never knew how, I never knew when. Squilf was, to me, the best character that I could ever have and I just want to give her a big hug. -gives baby squirrel- She looks cute and super fluffy. Red Squirrel Queen = Squirrelflight.) 2. Dovewing 🕊️ (She’s really cute, and I liked her even in PoT, which she’s not even in. I got very spoiled and I’m currently reading AVoS while knowing Squilf is probably leader now. Dovewing’s power seems cool, she has cool powers and a cool lover. I Lovewing Dovewing.) 3. Twigbranch 🪵 (As you can tell, I like the main characters 👍. I knew about her ever since I knew about Dovewing, which was late PoT. Her separation from Violetshine immediately in AVoS and her relationship with Alderheart and the medicine den is what I mostly remember from the books. She just leaves TC and comes back with her love interest -i think- ) 4. Hollyleaf 🌿 (I read Hollyleaf’s story immediately after Into the Wild, so that’s probably why I love her lol. The whole situation with her double moms and fake death is just wonderful. I like her as an aroace Hollyleaf rather than an I-love-Fallen-Leaves-without-loving-him. I never actually detected any romance between them, but that’s probably not why they started the ship. 5. Ivypool 🌿 (Same emoji as Hollyleaf just because it looks like ivy. Maybe. I only really like her because she’s Dovewing’s sister. She was also in Hollyleaf’s Story, and I knew her since around the beginning. Love her and love OotS.) 6. Bluestar 🔷 (Failed blue star 😢. Bluestar just defying StarClan and being like “Oh their not real because if they were real Snowkit would be alive.” Her sudden redemption when she’s dying with her kids and Firestar seems stupid. I hate it, really. I understand why it happened, one last encounter with the children and Firestar. 7. Cinderpelt 🌫️ -looks for a smoky emoji- (I like Cinderpelt because at least I remember her now 😅. If I was thinking properly it would not be Cinderpelt, probably someone like Sparkpelt. 8. Moonlight 🌙 (I love the Sisters so much, they were treated terribly by the other Clans, and only Squilf seemed to see how she and the Sisters were alike. Leading with no toms like how Hylla leads the Amazons with only a few male representatives in her government.) 9. Tall Shadow / Shadowstar 🌒 (I relate with Tall Shadow through one thing, I’m terrible at leading. Tall Shadow tries and fails at leading the Tribe cats, resulting in Gray Wing to do it for her.) 10. Yellowfang 🟨 (Yellowfang = Prophecy cat. Most of the prophecies are given by her, not the ones before her time obviously. That’s not a real reason, but I’m tired of typing. Btw, she’s yellow.) Honorable Mentions: Violetshine Lionblaze Jayfeather Leafpool Sunrise Spottedleaf Mistyfoot Feathertail Harestar
I have an intensely soft spot for insecure/afraid characters who cope in objectively terrible ways- like aggression. So I love the entirety of PoT- particularly crowfeather’s mess of a family.
I love that such a prolific member of the Warrior Cats community unironically loves Ashfur. Ashfur is my favorite character, and despite his actions I relate to him a lot. Although I'm much more mellow than Ashfur is, I'm overly desperate for... not even love, just good relationships with people in general. I'm constantly alert on how other people perceive me in any given situation, so when people I'm otherwise close with reject me and no longer think I'm a good person, I just find somewhere private and break down like I majorly f'ed up. I'm in therapy and it's helping me improve, but being desperate for validation, taking rejection to heart, and letting feelings brew rather than speaking out are all big flaws of mine that have become part of who I am. The rejection is more so in the context of friendships and not romance, and I never act on my negative emotions (let alone start a fiery tantrum). At worst they become intrusive thoughts. But regardless, Ashfur's core feelings are something I relate to a lot, even if his method of coping was extreme. He's partially a learning tool and partially an "I've been there at my worst" kind of character. I have mixed feelings towards his role in The Broken Code, but he's still easily my favorite little lovesick kitty. #10 Brook Where Small Fish Swim #9 Dovewing #8 Longtail #7 Cloudtail #6 Hollyleaf #5 Tree #4 Leafpool #3 Bluestar #2 Leopardstar #1 Ashfur
Oh my StarClan, you don’t know how much I appreciate this comment. I’m fictionkin, and my fictotype/kintype is Ashfur HOLD ON WAIT… I THINK IV’E MET YOU ON REDDIT BEFORE…
This video made me laugh so hard the part about Ashford in particular your jokes are awesome cheat codes XD to manipulate star clan and his objective to obtain 1 squirrel flight that one’s so horrible so accurate and so hilarious 🤣
Yeah a lot of the fandom's opinions are pretty twisted because almost everyone hasn't read the 4th arc and beyond (especially the Broken code and beyond), so they just see what everyone else is saying and assume it's right.
These are my top 10: 1. Cinderpelt - I've loved Cinderpelt ever since she was introduced, I love her so much, not much to explain 2. Brightheart - Brightheart is so wholesome and just a great character 3. Crookedstar - I did not care for him before I read his super edition, but once I did he earned his spot on this list 4. Dovewing - Such a cinnamon roll, and I feel kinda bad for her 5. Squirrelfligjht - you gotta love Squirrleflight 6. Ivypool - I kinds relate with her whole jealousy thing 7. Hollyleaf - Idk I just like hollyleaf for some reason 8. Mapleshade - a bit overrated I feel, but still fricking cool 9. Briarlight - As you can tell from my list I tend to like the characters with traumatic injuries, also just love her 10. Willowshine - I just like her lol Don't come at me this is just my opinion
I love Ashfur and Dovewing too, but my fav is still Sandstorm:D My top 10: 1. Sandstorm 2. Firestar 3. Bluestar 4. Ashfur 5. Mapleshade 6. Tigerheart 7. Jayfeather 8. Gray Wing 9. Dustpelt 10. Cinderpelt
If anything having something to overcome and deal with builds character. It can make a good character or the fans a good jumping off point to come up with their own stories about that character. Like Luke in Star Wars hand getting cut off. I had wondered if he didn't get his hand replaced and used the force more.
please go on all the rants possible, i can speak purely for myself (the most important opinion obv) and say that the rants are so good and i want more of your opinions about cats
YESSSS STARLIGHT GLIMMER!!!! There’s honestly a lot of people who dislike her due to her not super well written backstory which is fair. BUT. I still love her lots and I can headcanon all her backstory problems away YIPEE!!!
Oof. I'm late! But, Shadowsight is definitely a favorite of mine. I don't know why. Ever since the 2nd and 3rd book of TBC (The Broken Code), I just. Fell in love with this sweet, shy potato. My poor shadow baby's gone through so much! Shadowsight is so bbg (which is weird to say about a medicine cat but here we are 🤣) Also, Crookedstar, Leafpool & Squirrelflight, Ravenpaw, Cinderpelt, Poppyfrost, Jayfeather, Dovewing, and Alderheart are also faves. :)
Starlight Glimmer being a newcomer is not one of the reasons I considered why I like her so much. But now that you mention it, I guess it's a good point. I definitely see what you're saying about enjoying the characters who have to adapt.
I cannot even count the number of times I’ve gotten into heated debates with Mudclaw haters I literally love him sm he’s just a silly boy with anger issues 🥹
This made me think of my own top ten warrior cats and why but all I did was come to the conclusion that every single cat on that list I like for reasons that are entirely within my mind. I like the fanon versions of characters but I don't care for the canon
