Most Well Executed Vaults (2006-2022) 

You are right, I knew she scored 15.400 but somehow I got confused and put as 9.400. So she should be in 3rd here.

To be fair in 2012 every single half decent vault scored at least a 9.1 and lots of vaults with decent landings scored in the 9.3s. A 9.766 was a huge jump from a 9.4 especially in 2012

@@colesmith7509 But 2 of Aly's vaults were from 2016

I feel like the problem with the Code is that it penalizes any deviation from perfect form in such a way that McKayla's and Simone's crossed toes receive the same deduction as Aly's crossed legs. I think other events could take a page from bars scoring, where a handstand that finishes up to 10* from vertical receives no deduction. It allows for a small window between "perfect" and "no deduction", and I think it should apply in other ways too.

@@Margo-oj5ycI agree! helicopter legs should definitely be a larger deduction than crossed feet with otherwise spotless form

@@gymnasticfan9148 I mean it's not really fair to compare vaults from different times, especially not a 2016 vault to one in 2012. I definitely agree that Aly was overscored to a degree, but it wasn't as egregious as everyone is making it out to be. Aly's scores aren't as ridiculous as Mykayla's 9.6 E for an OOB vault with a big hop

Because her actual technique is better than most gymnasts that do the Cheng.

everyone eating then there's paseka and skinner

probably the problems on WAG programs of the country. they prioritise beam and bars more, rather than balancing out for all events for the good of their team

​@@afniii7514considering the things I've heard about the coaches and the overall environment, that does check out.

they’ve only ever had her in the history of the sports though.

I don't think it's a confidence issue so much as she was a powerful twister and I don't think she ever quite mastered the control that someone like, say, Biles has. Biles has an air awareness that's nearly superhuman. Combine that with her positively explosive power, and you've got an untouchable GOAT. Tbf I think Shawn on BB and FX was more confident.

She had a -0.3 neutral deduction (only the E-Score was considered), and I think that hop had a 0.1 deduction only.

@@gymnasticfan9148 I agree but it definitely should not have been considered just a 0.1 step

It's crazy when you realize that 2 judges gave 9.6 for this vault 1:37 and also 2 judges gave 9.6 for this vault 0:02

I think the main reason for Gabby’s vault being judged lower is that Shawn and Aly had more air and height where as Gabby is a phenomenally fast twister. On vault there is more weight placed on the air and height vs being a quick twister. However, Gabby was definitely for sure an underrated vaulter. I would have like to have seen her do a tskuhara vault to try and make vault finals.

I think Jordyn should have scored higher than Gabby.

Yes. Also Me @ Anna Pavlova scoring higher than Jordan Chiles

@@Appaddict01she should have. She had WAY more amplitude

I agree.

Queen

I mean it’s only because her landings were great in 2016 and in 2012 they were typically generous with vault scores

She was so hella overscored!

Paseka being on this list is HECKIN criminal.

@@JennaLeigh Same with Jade

@@SabrinaVoineaSStolenMedal zero argument there!

Because her best E-Score with the Rudi was a 9.200 and I would have to include a vault below 9 exectuion in the list.

She flew off the vault but she also had preflight form issues, and was piked a little. No 10 for her.

maybe but her form is perfect

FINALLY! Someone said it!

@@Plaspos Agreed.

O Amanar da Rebeca em 2016 era outro comparado com agora. Tinha menos altura e era menos dinâmico do que o da Aly. Hoje em dia nunca que a Rebeca tiraria menos do que ela.

The "most well" was intentional

The form is perfect but not the height, the pike down, the little hop, I think it would receive an even lower E-Score in the recent CoPs

Gabby lacked height and distance, she was clearly deducted for it. In my opinion Shawn had one of the best forms in the air (no leg separation in the entry, pointed toes, can't se a crossed legs) but her block wasn't good and always underotated.

Gabby had no height and distance and suspect form. She was not underscored and that aa VAULT WHERE SHE TOOK 3 STEPS WAS HIGHWAY ROBBERY.

The judges loved the dynamic of Kyla's block. She had suspect form in the middle but they always gave her credit for that block.

No, they won by 5 points in 2012 and 8 points in 2016, she could score 11 on vault and they would still win.

And she didn't Vault at 2012 OG TF

@@gymnasticfan9148 Yeah, it's kind of an absurd statement when you see the margins by which the US team won. A single vaulter having an inflated score on one event would make absolutely no difference in the final results. All three of the American vaulters could have fallen and still won the team gold.

@@gymnasticfan9148 no the score was always inflated on vault and floor!!!! That’s why US always won the team finals. And even then shes in 3 events and she’s always over-scored the hell out. Don’t even pretend she’s not overscored on bars as well!!!! Please let’s not pretend. Russian always was a point or 5 points away on wining but they always over scored raisman lol.

@@captainbryce1 you’re really going to tell me that aly raisman will score a damn 15.5 on a damn Unevenbars Lmfaoo or boost her teams score on balance beam??? Please!!!! Her whole form is all for floor and not on any apparatus!! She’s always overscored and always the heavy favorite. Emphasizing heavy?!!! On everything lol

She didn't have much power (and had a 0.3 step in Varna EF). Now that she is phisically stronger (2021+), she only performed once in the Olympics final, but the landing wasn't good. If she performs next year, with a good landing, she can score 9.5+

Because they get way more height and distance than her. It’s not all about how tight you are in the air and the landing.

@@PhenixJoe I don't think that either Aly nor Shawn get more "height" than Gabby. Shawn gets more "distance" and has equally good form. But Gabby's looks higher to me. Shawn also has such an obvious execution deduction on the landing that it should amount to a bigger deduction than Gabby's lack of distance. As far as Aly Raisman goes, yes hers is slightly higher than Gabby's, but her form is way worse and deserves a higher deduction. It's the same reason why Aliya Mustafina is ranked so low on the DTY despite having good landings. They're basically doing exactly the same thing with their legs, only Aly is doing a more difficult vault. If anything Aly's leg form is even more egregious. Yet her execution score is higher than Mustafina for some reason. One of the problems I have with the height and distance rules is that they are so subjective that there is no standard for how high or how far a vault is supposed to be. I remember some years back (probably over 10 years ago) seeing lines painted on the floor where the gymnast got a deduction if they landed behind a certain line and a bonus if they cleared the second or third line. But they took that away for some reason. Yet it was a more transparent metric to use when judging distance. Similarly, a vertical yard stick with line marking the minimum required height would also be useful. As it stands now, it's all the judges "guessing" about how high or far someone landed with no actual measurement. They also should be more transparent about just how much of a deduction they are taking. Is it .05, .1, or more? At least with the landing rules, they came up with a clear way of distinguishing between a .1 step/hop and a .3 step/hop. But that was after Shawn Johnson competed. If she was being judged under this CoP, I believe her execution score would be lower than Gabby Douglas based on her landings.

The first one is Back To You - Tobu

@@gymnasticfan9148 Thank you very very much!!

It's not a high enough value for gymnasts to risk tenths instead of sticking to a cleaner DTY. If you can get a 9.5E score like Chiles, why upgrade and risk injury or lower scores?

@@chewiegym2765 Yes, tem years ago it was 0.7 higher than the DTY, now it's 0.4

So the FiG is fucking It Up. As a gymnast you'd want to push your own limits, and not be tamed down by the judging system

She is a legend on floor!! But come on.... There's no way her vaults were close to mckayla or even Gabby in execution...

Except Gabby got like no height m/distance and Aly did

She is just American! Htf Jades Barbosa scored less thant hers??? Absurdity

She scored very high at worlds but I think her third best score was 14.166, so her average was around 14.333

@@gymnasticfan9148 that’s unlucky

Who else did it other than Simone who herself has not competed it since 2018?

It’s not though. And lines and extension? Maroney can’t even extend her knees😂 Just say white and lean/lacks muscular definition.

@@tambam6744 lol of course because I think someone has a better amanar than Biles I have to be racist 🙄

@@welium123 Never said you were racist? You said it! 😂 And could you please elaborate on your “lines and extension [are] better” statement?

Simone lands with her arms down by her legs? 0:03... Are you sure?

@@tambam6744 'just say white and lean'. What has her skin color got to do with anything???