The concept of the film is similar to Dangal. While Dangal justifies the dream of a father who trains his daughters for wrestling in natinal level which he had already accomplished in his youth. But in this movie Rajkumar Rao didn't achieve anything in cricket related field nor his wife had any prior cricketing experience. Its just too stupid of an idea to think the wife would leave her carrer in Medical to pursue her husband's dream of wanting her to play cricket. Unbelievable in this day and age.
@@mtk3755 true..imagine if he had a yiunger sibling who was inspired and determined to fufill his brother's dream..much more believable and heartwarming
I don't know what's wrong with the comment section but nobody really discussing the movie. Some section asking for another movie review, another section spammin mushkil se mushkil chants..i mean show some respect and support to the video. He worked hard to write the script. So at least discuss ,debate and raise questions or points if you agree or disagree with his opinion
Kya sahi toh bola.. Ek doctor topper banna kitna mushkil hain, yaha pe janhavi leaves that profession for husband's dream...this is illogical first of all... Baseless movie
@@Moumitasahasunshine isse pata chalta h indian audience movies ko kitna seriously leti h ye log sirf hero worship and entertainment value pe dhyan dete baki inko kuch ata pata nhi h
Janhavi and Sara are far far far far far away from acting talent …. We could see the useless acting in the trailer itself feeling bad for Rajkumar Rao for getting such useless actors opposite to him
I could guess it was complete nonsense from the trailer itself. If it was the girl's dream to become a cricketer, it wouldn't be so bad but she leaves a really good job that she wasn't even forced into just because her husband wanted to be a cricketer but he couldn't become one so he wanted his wife to be it instead?? Wtf.. seems like manipulation to me. And if it seemed like they were going to get separated because of his demand, it'd be even better and more realistic but they stay together and she achieve his dream for him??? I didn't find any reason to watch this movie at all
Do you guys think Janhvi's recent interview with curly tales was a PR stunt? She was potrayed as a very grounded and homely person. I mean as audience we have already established the fact that she cannot act very well but I was under the impression that she atleast doesn't fake her personality like her other contemporaries. But I'm so done with celeb's PRs at this point that I don't know what to believe??
Yeh sab pr stunts sein picture ki.collection nahi badh ti...audience mobile mein uski pr stunt dekh legi, but ussi audience cinema hall ki ticket k liye 150 rs bhi waste nahi karegi, phir cinema hall Mei aane Jane ka kharcha alag😂
Salim-Javed were well aware of the ground realities in the country and inserted them in their screenplays wherever suitable. That is why in zanjeer movie Sher Khan says at one point, "Waise bhi humaare mulk mein sher kaafi kam ho gaya hai. Suna hai, ab toh sarkaar ne bhi sher ka shikaar pe paabandi lagaaya hai." This refers to the ban on tiger hunting which had come in force only the previous year.
Very well reviewed Shan. Its rare to find an honest review these days, in a world filed with paid bootlickers. You have appreciated the acting of leads and critised the poor story screenplay. It clearly shows how good actors can get trapped in weak scripts & screen play. Keep up the good work of honest independent reviews. You will make a mark....
Finally, you are not paid...the movie is below average... Dangal aur abhimaan ka story lia, aur mahi ka naam...kuch bhi dikha dena hain dharma ko...matlab govt college ka doctor hain topper hain, woh achanak sein cricket kyun kheligi??
Could've tweaked this to that she was an u-17 cricketer, but left it for MBBS, and that she wanted to play further, but succumbed to family pressure. And it is her choice to get back to the game, after hitting the balls in park, realizing she has still got it instead of her husband putting the burden on her. Then he could've played role of a coach and mentor. I feel in India it's not an option that you can play cricket actively and also pursue a degree, so that was the choice the protagonist has to make.
@@mtk3755 oh yeah. Absolutely exceptions apply. But the norm is definitely different. Varun Chakravarthy also left cricket and came back. And that is why I feel she couldn't have done both especially when she is raw and probably requires more training.
@@mtk3755😂😂😂 you are seriously comparing a dude who did an mba from a random college to someone who cracked neet Ug and completed mbbs . Not to take anything away from Venky Iyer but he used to play cricket while doing his studies the same is not possible while studying mbbs . Maybe if you have a friend who had done mbbs you would know this
The way they are promoting Janvi's cricket, but in actual it could have been anything.. Though I liked Rajkumar Rao's grey shade character here, his performance was good..I would suggest to watch 'Dear Comrade' on the same type of concept but far better with an actual social message and great chemistry between leads..Dharma could have just remake that as Karan Johar already have the remake rights of Dear Comrade..
But jahnvi Kapoor's character is shown to love playing criket as child par uske papa bolte hai "Dr Banna hai cricket khelke nahi banogi " like apni choice thopta hai uska baap
Muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se muskil se 😂😅
Totally agree with the review. I think we need to have good scriptwriters. The story and screenplay could have been different with the same cast. The wife could have played a supporting role in making/reviving husband cricketing career, or husband could have trained someone else like a young cricketing girl, which would have brought conflict b/w husband and wife. But the story was written in a very superficial level and not heart touching.
Movie is predictable and so is janhvi. It's like janhvi walked from the set of gunjan saxena to this movie and repeated the same performance. That being said, this movie and gunjan saxena is where her performance is ok. However, janhvi should have someone tell her now is the time to evaluate her career.
Doctors themselves say that without Nurses the hospital will not work. Not only is Nurses's education and training hard, but their everyday duty is hard too. When I was admitted in the hospital, the nurses took very good care of every patient. Now I know that there are bad Nurses too, there are good and bad people in all professions, but comeon, no need to insult essential healthcare providers or workers
I watched this movie and was so furious about the story line it has. Waste of your time and money. Not even a single scene where I felt worth watching this movie. Absolutely rubbish and cringeworthy movie. Idk how other so called reviewers liked this movie. Thanks to you for calling out this stupid movie and being honest.
I alws tell my wife to watch ur reviews n not anupama chopra ...she tried this review today n ur comment 'kahin receptionist nee lagi hui woh' ve slightly offended her ...cos she manages an office reception desk n ops herself 😆
Interesting fact both Shan and Pratik have given similar review about the movie and bashed it. The much awaited Shan-Pratik podcast seems to be getting close
Shantanu bhai naya trailer aaya hai "Tippsy" film ka , directed by Deepak Tijori.. full chhaapaa of Hangover1, khaali cast mahilaayein hain. Kuchh ho jaaye thoda taaza roast wost trailer ka. To be honest, it doesn't look bad (4moresh!ts se to kuchh bhi achchha hai).. just that we have seen it before.
2:29 kal dekhi yeh movie. Agreed ki Rajkumar Rao aur Jahanvi kapoor ne bahut achi acting ki. But after a point script dhili ho gai bahut zyada. However, i felt ki koshish ki director ne bhi (ek example hai) but script hi itni dhili thi ki chali nahi. Example yeh tha ki after point yeh establish ho jata hai ki RR ko cricketer nahi banna tha usko ek star banna tha. Uski mother wali scene jahan woh samjhati hai ki rishta thik kar wife k sath. Uske bad ek point aya jahan RR retrospect kar raha tha. Aur apne bhai k poster ko dekh k usko maa ki yeh bat yad ai ki bhai life mein macha jarur raha hai but khush nahi hai. Isse yeh mujhe laga ki chalo director ko itna zarur pata tha ki woh kya character banaya hai bas script bekar thi
3:27 yahi mujhe bhi laga ki bc yeh movie follow ur dreams ko galat tarah se push kar raha hai. Matlab jahanvi ka character doctor tha isme! Padhne mein shuru se acha tha. Aur through out the movie woh mushkil se mushkil state player bani (end mein bhale india call aya). Toh bhai ek set career ko aise thuka ki “bas patwal k sath reh k suiyan lagate reh jaogi” aur uncertainty mein dhakel diya. Ek point pe toh yeh bhi laga ki RR MLM k liye recruit kar raha hai. Uske dialogues sun lo - job wob mein kuch nahi rakha. 2 saal bad jab tum cricketer banke aogi tab dekhna. Msg galat tha is movie mein
3:53 dekha jae toh passion rajkumar rao ka bhi nahi dikhaya gaya cricket ki taraf. Like his coach said: tu ek average cricketer tha aur kuch nahi. Multiple points to show how he wasnt passionate: 1) pehli scene mein hi set batsmam ko janbujh k runout karwaya. Match se zyada khud pe focus. 2) jab mauka mila match jitane ka toh bowler se zyada dhyan selector pe tha. 3) bhai baap ka sports equipment ka shop hai. Tu baitha hai toh apni expertise se do char bat hi bech le. Aur dukan subah 8 - 10 chal rahi. Tu 5 baje se cricket camps kyu nahi chale jata. Kai po che (another RR movie) mein SSR ka character was very well written. Woh passion dikhata tha. Woh bhi toh state player hi tha. But sports shop khola apni marzi se coaching diya. Wahan passionate dikhta tha. 4) is bande ko jab coach ki job offer hui toh isne mana kar diya. Kyuki iska agenda tha star banna cricketer nahi. Jab iske coach ko dekha kitna fame mila woh kunal bande k selection se tab coach banna tha. 5) last, maa k sath heart to heart wale scene k bad end mein ek purana bat dikhata hai. Jisse iska flashback hota hai bachpan ka. Pehli bat flashback mein aur woh scene mein bat same nahi hai. Mera emotion meri bike se juda hai. Doesnt mean ki kisi bhi bike ko dekh k emotional ho jaunga. Secondly, puri movie mein uske bachpan ka ek scene nahi dikhaya ki banda bachpan se passionate tha. Bande ko bas ⭐️ banna tha
3:53 dekha jae toh passion rajkumar rao ka bhi nahi dikhaya gaya cricket ki taraf. Like his coach said: tu ek average cricketer tha aur kuch nahi. Multiple points to show how he wasnt passionate: 1) pehli scene mein hi set batsmam ko janbujh k runout karwaya. Match se zyada khud pe focus. 2) jab mauka mila match jitane ka toh bowler se zyada dhyan selector pe tha. 3) bhai baap ka sports equipment ka shop hai. Tu baitha hai toh apni expertise se do char bat hi bech le. Aur dukan subah 8 - 10 chal rahi. Tu 5 baje se cricket camps kyu nahi chale jata. Kai po che (another RR movie) mein SSR ka character was very well written. Woh passion dikhata tha. Woh bhi toh state player hi tha. But sports shop khola apni marzi se coaching diya. Wahan passionate dikhta tha. 4) is bande ko jab coach ki job offer hui toh isne mana kar diya. Kyuki iska agenda tha star banna cricketer nahi. Jab iske coach ko dekha kitna fame mila woh kunal bande k selection se tab coach banna tha. 5) last, maa k sath heart to heart wale scene k bad end mein ek purana bat dikhata hai. Jisse iska flashback hota hai bachpan ka. Pehli bat flashback mein aur woh scene mein bat same nahi hai. Mera emotion meri bike se juda hai. Doesnt mean ki kisi bhi bike ko dekh k emotional ho jaunga. Secondly, puri movie mein uske bachpan ka ek scene nahi dikhaya ki banda bachpan se passionate tha. Bande ko bas ⭐️ banna tha
4:11 haan yeh point sahi bola apne. Baap se toh aise ladta tha jaise pata nahi kya hai yeh. Bhai baap nahi hota toh iske khane k lale par jate. Yeh loser isliye feel karta tha kyuki tha woh movie mein loser. Uska bhai serial mein acting karta tha. Baap ne itna bada business banaya tha. Cant deny his father was a great salesman. Uski biwi doctor thi. Isse ek dukan ka tala nahi lag raha. Rebel without a cause went out of fashion in 2005 with rang de basanti. Uske bad bas ek kabir singh/arjun reddy/ adithya varma revive kar pae (imo). Nahi toh yeh genre cringe ho gaya hai
Ye sports wali movie to dekhne ka hi man ni karta , ho gaya bhai masterpiece sports movie dekh liye hain ab aur ni (bhaag Milkha bhaag, dangal, ms dhoni, chak de india)
i agree the move in its first half is too boring but if u interested in cricket so u might like the second half because there's a gameplay and jahnvi is making runs and if u r a regular cricket watcher u must have a habit of being curious agla chakka padega ki chauka , thats the only interesting part in the movie!! wait for it to come on netflix and watch those 15 minutes of gameplay and then shut the movie down cuuz its not worth ur time
Karan Johar doesn't have creativity or he has lost his edge due to his desperation for attention..whatever good movies has made are inspired by Yash and Aditya chopra or mean girls and 90s Hollywood chick flicks ..but now he has nothing good to get inspired from or copied from ..he is not original ...Instead of focusing on Alia bhatt , he should have focus little on his own talent
