Taeyong literally sounds exactly like the recording version. In their 2nd win for Sticker, we all were amazed by Taeyong who was singing live during encore
@@heyitsrosie the performance pre recorded.. but their mics are always open and they chose to sing it live.. pre recorded doesn't hv hard breath like that..
for the people saying this is pre recorded that doesn't still invalidate the fact that they still sing this live. u can clearly hear their catching of breath 😅 so it's not lip syncing may it be pre recorded and that tells us a "talent" plus who are u kidding for here? they're an sm artist 🤣
@Daffa Hilmy thats not actually what prerecording is. what youre describing is live singing. prerecording is when they sit down and record it, usually done with convincing breaths to make it seem like its actually live. and that looks like what theyve done here. but its not a bad thing bc at least you can tell they can sing it live, just not while dancing. which is understandable when you look at rv’s queendom stages and twice’s icsm stages with those high notes in the choruses, i wouldnt wanna sing those songs while dancing either, especially not those f5s 💀
@@Caleb.Williams where did you know this from? any valid source or it is even confirmed by the broadcast station? I feel like it's just something that made up by some MR removed channel, then people it just spread out and people acknowledge it as a fact without getting to know the real fact. I never believe any pre-record vocal session that some mr removed channels spread, cause it never confirmed by the broadcast station nor the label. And it only exist in the 3rd and 4th generation. Before that, we only know that they pre-recorded the performance but the artist still singing live. And from my experienced they pre-recorded it a couple of times, and if you watch it live in the studio, you can really hear them sing live (pre-record session used to have some audience before the pandemic). After that, the broadcast station will choose the best cut from each performance, then edited it into one video performance. When they edit the video, they also edit the vocal, it gets polished, reduce the noise and get stabilized (just how the concert dvd works). But yes, there are some artist who rarely sing live and let the MR take over, so they just kinda lip synced (usually some parts). Just watch this one take clip (unedited or mashed from several recorded performance), you can clearly hear their live voices, even taeyong ad lips before the dance break part kinda a lil bit different with the recorded version. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BjKIJoZUW1E.html But if you still wants to believe the didn't sing live, then it's up to you :)
if you compare this video to their encore live stages there’s no much difference even if it’s live or prerecorded, they’re still idols who can actually sing
To all the haters who still think they are lipsync, please educate yourself and see their encores. They do it live and you can clearly see how at ease they sing 😊
This one is def live singing, it's completely different from pre-recorded vocal. Kudos to the person who made this & NCT 127 who did a very good job ❤️
I think this is live, the noise from the moving mic and their breathe are too in sync with the video especially on their own part. But yes, they kinda only rely on backtrack or MR on the chorus. Like no way they recorded the vocal separately. I mean you can hear the live vocal well, even in the non mr removed video. I think inkigayo pre-recorded the performance (with live singing) a couple times, took the best cut of each, then edited it into one whole performance.
I thought clean version means the MR removed is cleaner, like in the description of this video. Like it has less noise. And you can believe what you want, I won't forced my opinion on you. I still think they were singing live here, like their live voice is very clear, especially in the fancam version. But like I said, you can have different opinion. I never believe any pre-record vocal session that some mr removed channels annouce/spread, cause it never confirmed by the broadcast station nor the label. And it only exist in the 3rd and 4th generation. Before that, we only know that they pre-recorded the performance but the artist still singing live. And from my experienced they pre-recorded it a couple of times, and if you watch it live in the studio, you can really hear them sing live (pre-record session used to have some audience before the pandemic). After that, the broadcast station will choose the best cut from each performance, then edited it into one video performance. When they edit the video, they also edit the vocal, it gets polished, reduce the noise and get stabilized (just how the concert dvd works). But yes, there are some artist who rarely sing live and let the MR take over, so they just kinda lip synced (usually some parts). Oh, and I watched them live a couple of times, and their live really sounds good anyway. Peace out.
I thought clean version means the MR removed is cleaner, like in the description of this video. Like it has less noise. And you can believe what you want, I won't forced my opinion on you. I still think they were singing live here, like their live voice is very clear, especially in the fancam version. But like I said, you can have different opinion. I never believe any pre-record vocal session that some mr removed channels annouce/spread, cause it never confirmed by the broadcast station nor the label. And it only exist in the 3rd and 4th generation. Before that, we only know that they pre-recorded the performance but the artist still singing live. And from my experienced they pre-recorded it a couple of times, and if you watch it live in the studio, you can really hear them sing live (pre-record session used to have some audience before the pandemic). After that, the broadcast station will choose the best cut from each performance, then edited it into one video performance. When they edit the video, they also edit the vocal, it gets polished, reduce the noise and get stabilized (just how the concert dvd works). But yes, there are some artist who rarely sing live and let the MR take over, so they just kinda lip synced (usually some parts). Just watch this one take clip (like i said they recorded it a couple of times, this in one of them), you can clearly hear their live voices, even taeyong ad lips before the dance break part kinda a lil bit different with the recorded version. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BjKIJoZUW1E.html But if you still wants to believe the didn't sing live, then it's up to you :) Oh, and I watched them live a couple of times, and their live really sounds good anyway. Peace out.
It’s true the performance is pre-recorded but their vocals aren’t pre-record, they still have their mics on and sang it live, u can tell it by heard their breath and their voices
First of all I want to clarify that I’m an NCTzen and sorry to tell you this but it’s probably pre-rec. If you watch all the performances for this comeback and compare the audio you will notice that the breathing, adlibs and etc are the same. Tbh the choreo for Sticker is very intense! So I understand it can be difficult for them to sing 100% live, but I believe that NCT will slay with their live vocals otherwise bc they had already proved to us in the past💚
Everyone thought aespa's performance was lip synced too because it was so good and the performances sounded similar but it turned out they were singing live. The same thing is kinda happening to them now. When things are pre recorded don't they sing the all parts and try to make it perfect? This doesn't sound perfect(well it kinda does but yea), so wouldn't that make it more likely to be live?
@@willowsprings7588 I realized in the recent days not only for this comeback, but it’s been a while, for SM they don’t sing the pre record perfectly and include the breathing as well. I’m not sure why but in my opinion, the reason might be so when they perform it will look somehow natural. I suggest comparing the mr remove for other stages, as well as the encore stage for sbs or mcountdown where they sing 100% live.
![[MR Removed] NCT 127 - STICKER MR제거 20210919 (Clean Ver.)](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
