Тёмный
No video :(

Multitasking Is a Myth, and to Attempt It Comes at a Neurobiological Cost | Big Think 

Big Think
Подписаться 7 млн
Просмотров 165 тыс.
50% 1

Multitasking Is a Myth, and to Attempt It Comes at a Neurobiological Cost
Watch the newest video from Big Think: bigth.ink/NewV...
Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: bigth.ink/Edge
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Multitasking is a myth, says McGill University Psychology Professor Daniel Levitin. Switching concentration across tasks comes at a neurological cost, depleting chemicals we need to concentrate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DANIEL LEVITIN:
Daniel Levitin is an award-winning neuroscientist, musician, author and record producer. He is the author of three consecutive #1 bestselling books: This Is Your Brain on Music, The World in Six Songs and The Organized Mind. He is also the James McGill Professor of Psychology and Behavioural Neuroscience at McGill University in Montreal, where he runs the Laboratory for Music Cognition, Perception and Expertise.
Before becoming a neuroscientist, Levitin worked as a session musician, sound engineer, and record producer working with artists such as Stevie Wonder and Blue Öyster Cult. He has published extensively in scientific journals as well as music magazines such as Grammy and Billboard. Recent musical performances include playing guitar and saxophone with Sting, Bobby McFerrin, Rosanne Cash, David Byrne, Cris Williamson, Victor Wooten, and Rodney Crowell.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TRANSCRIPT:
Daniel Levitin: It turns out that multitasking is a myth. We think that we're doing a whole bunch of things at once. But we're not actually because the brain doesn't work that way. In a number of studies now have shown from Earl Miller's lab at MIT and others that what we're really doing is we're paying attention to one thing for a little bit of time and then another and then another and then we come back around to the first. And all of these are separate projects that are occurring in separate parts of the brain, they require a separate start time, a separate monitoring process. And you end up fractionating your attention into little bits and pieces, not really engaging fully in any one thing. All that switching across tasks comes with a neurobiological cost. It depletes resources. So after an hour or two of attempting to multitask, if we find that we're tired and we can't focus, it's because those very neural chemicals we needed to focus are now gone.
There are some jobs that require, not multitasking because we know it doesn't exist but this kind of a rapid switching, I'm an air traffic controller, simultaneous translator at the UN, journalists, monitoring all these different things at once. And we can take a tip from the air traffic controllers who, as part of their duty cycle, are required after every hour and a half or two hours of work it's mandated that they take a 15 to 30 minute break. And that means an unplugged disconnected break where they go for a walk or listen to music, they exercise, something to restore all of the burned up neurochemicals.
You might ask during this period of our evolution when there's all this information is the brain adapting and changing? And yes it is. The brain adapts and changes all the time. Evolution is happening all the time. Unfortunately it's rather sluggish. We talk about it in terms of evolutionary lag and generally speaking it takes about 20,000 years for the brain to catch up with the way the environment is in terms of how it's encoded in the genome. So 20,000 years from now our brains may have evolved to deal with it. In the meantime we have to employee strategies, just a little bit more self-disciplined then we currently use to filter out unwanted or unnecessary input. I'm not talking about never letting something frivolous or fun in, but I'm talking about adopting a kind of a habit of allowing yourself to focus on one thing at a time for at least a few hours a day.

Опубликовано:

 

25 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 235   
@dickhamilton3517
@dickhamilton3517 8 лет назад
multitasking: how to do five things badly, all at the same time.
@OmniphonProductions
@OmniphonProductions 8 лет назад
I've spent fifteen years (so far) as an Emergency Telecommunicator (AKA: Dispatcher), and this assessment is right on the money. I always tell people, "I don't multitask; I constantly update and adjust my priority list." I can also attest to the fact doing so makes this "cushy desk job" both mentally and physically exhausting. Nice to hear the biochemical science behind it.
@amberotl5276
@amberotl5276 2 года назад
My manager told me "you're not a multitasker..." It made me feel insecure in that moment, but then I realized I rather take my time and make sure I do a decent job. I also have stress related autoimmune conditions. If you can multitask and do good than that's great. But not everyone functions the same. Im just a person. Not a machine.
@DrNaviMD
@DrNaviMD 8 лет назад
As I was watching this I was multitasking, cause I like to live on the edge.
@roborebelz2301
@roborebelz2301 5 лет назад
Gay
@Leadeshipcoach
@Leadeshipcoach 3 года назад
🤣🤣
@theodoretwombly154
@theodoretwombly154 2 года назад
legend
@216trixie
@216trixie 8 лет назад
This is why it's unsafe to drive while talking, on the phone especially. Even hands-free, your attention is miles from the car and the road every few moments.
@gabrielmcginley3302
@gabrielmcginley3302 8 лет назад
i'm a chef and i can confirm that the constant changing of tasks absolutely wears you out.
@Firecul
@Firecul 8 лет назад
+Gabriel McGinley waiter here, I can confirm working in our industry can put a huge strain on people. Mental and physical.
@donkeykongisbetterthanmari7495
@donkeykongisbetterthanmari7495 3 года назад
Give me some food Chef Gabe!
@barbiegross1002
@barbiegross1002 2 года назад
No doubt especially as you age more
@eddenoy321
@eddenoy321 8 месяцев назад
Multi-tasking was just a term that came into use some 30 yrs. ago . All it meant was to squeeze more and more out of already over-worked employees. Let's keep it real.
@ZekeFreek
@ZekeFreek 8 лет назад
Try telling employers that.
@ActuatedGear
@ActuatedGear 8 лет назад
+Zeke Freek A HA! HA! Haaaaaaaa. Heh. Kill me.
@daniellewardd
@daniellewardd 3 года назад
I did, at a job interview. I didn’t get the job.
@roush26
@roush26 8 лет назад
I teacher once told me, "you can do one thing right at a time, or you can fuck up many things at the same time."
@BeeNaaa5
@BeeNaaa5 8 лет назад
Love that.
@ActuatedGear
@ActuatedGear 8 лет назад
+roush26 A girl on each hand, foot pedal powering a piston machine far like...3?...wait...oh...you meant...whoops!
@GoatzAreEpic
@GoatzAreEpic 8 лет назад
Thinking fast and slow, really breaks this down, very interesting book
@poeticnation6251
@poeticnation6251 5 лет назад
This has been a great discussion and really helped me with my study of multitasking. Thank you for sharing this information.
@janessaW
@janessaW 4 года назад
They say you can't multitask, but I can fart and sneeze at the same time...
@repairdrive
@repairdrive 8 лет назад
Need to show this video to all the "know it alls" that swear they are bad asses at multitasking.
@TodaySatan
@TodaySatan 11 месяцев назад
I work as an estimator at a body shop and I’m constantly pulled away to do this, that and the other, over and over. It’s frustrating and exhausting. When I mess up, I’m told to slow down so I can be more accurate. That doesn’t help because I’m expected to be both a tireless machine and yet ‘only human’ at the same time. Not easy..
@MarioTomicOfficial
@MarioTomicOfficial 8 лет назад
Great video!
@GoatzAreEpic
@GoatzAreEpic 8 лет назад
+Mario Tomic are you 1 account?
@UltimatePerfection
@UltimatePerfection 8 лет назад
So pretty much like a singlecore CPU. Too bad we can't buy multicore brains yet, lol.
@reubensmart1757
@reubensmart1757 8 лет назад
Computing bants
@BOBOUDA
@BOBOUDA 8 лет назад
+QVear And too bad we can't overclock it...
@sn0uzy
@sn0uzy 8 лет назад
+BOBOUDA Thats what drugs are for.
@ActuatedGear
@ActuatedGear 8 лет назад
+QVear I have heard instead that one side of the brain acts as a single core and the other works as a multi. Limitations aside, seeing each bit individually is necessary, but a the general idea is also important.
@ActuatedGear
@ActuatedGear 8 лет назад
***** There is no..."balance." There is only nutrition and rest.
@mrsuns10
@mrsuns10 8 лет назад
If your reading this it's too late
@Jaccobtw
@Jaccobtw 8 лет назад
Fuck
@sebastianbechtold2417
@sebastianbechtold2417 8 лет назад
Well played sir, well played
@dragonshinerthewyvern1597
@dragonshinerthewyvern1597 6 лет назад
I'm sorry for being that one person, but uh.... you're*
@saul5_973
@saul5_973 4 года назад
I am, it’s 3 years later
@aristotle-oy8rl
@aristotle-oy8rl 2 месяца назад
HAHAHAHAHAHAH😂😂😂😂
@sitvisjes
@sitvisjes Год назад
I'm a guitarist who sings, i know it's not multitasking but it's switching really fast and it takes a lot of training. There are still complex guitar parts i can''t play while singing and probably never will.... funny that multitasking is the thing a lot of woman throw in my face as something they are better at, actually it's the no.1 thing. I'll just show em this video lol.
@Drrck11
@Drrck11 8 лет назад
I can agree with that. I never believed multi-tasking is real.
@kyraocity
@kyraocity 2 года назад
0:40 Not really engaging fully in any one thing. When we are tired and need focus the neurochemicals needed have been used up. 1:28 Take a walk at intervals 2:15 Filtering out distractions
@TurnOntheBrightLights.
@TurnOntheBrightLights. 8 лет назад
Line cooks is definitely one of those jobs.
@JarrydMitchell
@JarrydMitchell 8 лет назад
+RocketPawnch thank you.......damn tickets
@TurnOntheBrightLights.
@TurnOntheBrightLights. 8 лет назад
+jrod123452 I have PTSD of those damn things :(
@snoopdogie187
@snoopdogie187 8 лет назад
I agree, I do it as part of my job a little and there is always so much to pay attention to, and time. Luckily I find it exciting, so I don't mind.
@xguy_kourosh_5g889
@xguy_kourosh_5g889 5 месяцев назад
I'm a musician and i always wondered how some people are able to multitask and by that i mean something like singing and playing guitar at the same time
@user-wr4yl7tx3w
@user-wr4yl7tx3w 7 месяцев назад
Which chemical are you using up? That seems hard to comprehend. Who replenishes such chemical of focus?
@macCALICOmac
@macCALICOmac 8 лет назад
What about watching a video while reading the comments or description?
@ManInMostlyBlack
@ManInMostlyBlack 8 лет назад
+Pippa Then you are rapidly switching. You are not reading and looking at the video at the same time.
@petelamoia
@petelamoia 4 года назад
Agreed, to a point. At work it's a myth, you just context-switch. But as a musician, specifically a drummer, who sings, I'm not sure what you call it but there is no 'switching'... I have to manage all 4 limbs and a voice at the same time.
@crrodriguez
@crrodriguez 2 года назад
It is still switching, at a *trained* very high speed. takes years to develop.. Im pretty sure at the beginning when you were learning drums it was not possible for you to sing. and with practise and training you got better and better switching between.
@gptjokes814
@gptjokes814 9 месяцев назад
I think good example of multitasking would be coordinating music and trying to cook dinner at the same time. @@crrodriguez
@Freigeist20789
@Freigeist20789 8 лет назад
It is certainly true that multitasking reduces the maximum atteantion you can pay to a problem. But often multitasking helps me to stay focused on a problem, by multitasking e.g. listening to music sometimes word program at the same time , to keep my mind from wandering and fully spending the remainder of my attention on the task at hand. Only when a current problem is complex enough I switch everything else off for full attenation
@HakuCell
@HakuCell 8 лет назад
so switching between tasks takes more energy than focusing on one task
@OmniphonProductions
@OmniphonProductions 8 лет назад
+Haku In any given time period, the brain only has so much access to the chemicals required to carry out it's cognitive and motor functions. Like a cell phone...or a wifi router...the more windows you have open, the more quickly you deplete the battery and the more time it takes the "computer" to process each new command. For that matter, think of juggling. The more items you juggle, the more likely you are to drop one...and the more quickly your arms will get too tired to juggle at all.
@engineercyborg
@engineercyborg 8 месяцев назад
reading comments while the video is still playing
@dotter8
@dotter8 8 лет назад
People don't understand multitasking. Computers do it by ranking tasks. (An app is a task.) It does the first task until that needs to wait for something, then switches to the second task until the first can proceed. If the second needs to pause for something before the first is ready, the computer starts on the third task... in other words, pretty much the way we do, except that computers are good at it and we're not.
@dotter8
@dotter8 8 лет назад
Bear in mind that computers can only do what humans program them to do. If we couldn't "multitask" when we have to, we wouldn't know how to make computers do it. What mainly makes computers better at multitasking is that they don't lose track of tasks or confuse what goes where.They don't get tired or distracted, which is the exact problem pointed out in the video; our brains can sort-of multitask, but it burns us out. Computers are fine as long as they're getting electricity. And of course, they're much faster.
@joejoejoejoejoejoe4391
@joejoejoejoejoejoe4391 2 года назад
Imagine the manager of a tour de France team, sat in a car with several screens around him, on the radio, having domestic riders coming back to talk to him - in 7 different languages, at the same time the manager will be constantly changing the team tactics - WHILST driving a car with motorcycles constantly overtaking at speed, riders and spectators all over the place, THAT'S multitasking.
@LustyXenomorphMaid
@LustyXenomorphMaid 7 лет назад
All of these multitasking tests by "scientists" and "researchers" are the equivalent of bringing an average Joe to lift heavy weights, and upon failing to do so, they claim that it is impossible. Mental strength and Physical strength are both real things and generally both require a good amount of training to do efficiently, with the issue here being that training for multitasking is quite more complex as to say, lifting weights or doing pushups. Generally Physical training has been around for eons, but multitasking by all its relevancy when it comes to pushing yourself to the max is quite a new achievement and/or goal in human history, but stating that "multitasking is a myth" is beyond retarded, and I fear for anyone who takes this at face value.
@albaezstudio6622
@albaezstudio6622 11 месяцев назад
Agree with you
@pdxdowntowner
@pdxdowntowner 8 лет назад
Continued mechanistic approach (body as machine) to understanding our actions. Armed with incomplete knowledge (early in knowledge curve)of how the brain works, rapid switching jobs or not, this condemnation of multi-tasking is popular wave to ride, but it may or may not go anywhere. Have confidence in the way you think and pay attention to the feedback your body gives you.
@reyh9894
@reyh9894 8 лет назад
I am tired of this. I need to ignore distractions.
@rasaja
@rasaja 3 года назад
Been thinking about finding another job lately. My current one requires me to switch between 10-12 tasks at all times. My brain is fried all the time
@PictureFit
@PictureFit 8 лет назад
Switching between tasks rapidly... Yea, if that's not multi-tasking then I don't know what is.
@androidesla
@androidesla 8 лет назад
+PictureFit If you ask someone what multitasking is, he is going to tell you that its doing few, two or more things in same time, when actually you cant do more than 1 thing, your brain can only work on one task at a time..
@PictureFit
@PictureFit 8 лет назад
Antonino Landolina Well, I'm certain some people can cook and hold a conversation at the same time. At that point, you have to factor in automaticity.
@androidesla
@androidesla 8 лет назад
cooking and talking is not multitasking, when you cook you are basicilly doing nothing...
@PictureFit
@PictureFit 8 лет назад
+sasa petrovic Don't get me wrong, I know exactly what you're trying to say about your definition of multi-tasking, but I'm more than happy to say that "rapid switching" is a fitting definition of multitasking regardless of it being inefficient.
@PictureFit
@PictureFit 8 лет назад
+Antonino Landolina Automaticity is what allows multitasking to happen. I can be driving, holding a conversation with my passenger, and at the same time process in my head what I need to be doing for the rest of my day. Sound pretty "multi" to me, and that's because I am able to automate the driving (of course not completely), recall a structured routine, and pay enough attention to what my passenger is talking about.
@sidewinder2057
@sidewinder2057 8 лет назад
when you try to concentrate on a multiple things at once for a long period of time, your brain lights up like a christmas tree, it drains you faster. And after some time you get anxiety, then depression, then panic attacks. Meditation fixes it. Since while meditating you're concentrating at one thing (breath).
@Stratsiey
@Stratsiey 8 лет назад
Wow I can vouch for this. I work at an alarm central and after one year my breath got messed up. Being a high performer I can tell it reaches these states. Guess I'll try mediation :)
@J4ckCr0w
@J4ckCr0w 8 лет назад
It does not deplete resources, most sysadmins do it for years.
@dypes26
@dypes26 8 лет назад
hogwash
@J4ckCr0w
@J4ckCr0w 8 лет назад
***** Depends of what are the people you know like.
@J4ckCr0w
@J4ckCr0w 8 лет назад
***** No this pseudoscience is hogwash, not the people that actually do it. Human brain has limitless potential, the fact the science is slow to grasp it and the people involved in that is a different matter. They said the same about ac current.
@noimnotnice
@noimnotnice 8 лет назад
+J4ckCr0w "Human brain has limitless potential" Humbug.
@asmith8673
@asmith8673 7 лет назад
yeah, it can only achieve 100% at best.
@prodigioustortuga1107
@prodigioustortuga1107 8 месяцев назад
I’ve argued for this topic with close people in my life and it’s the most frustrating thing ever. I don’t know how to change their mind. I think I may just give up.
@mememe84
@mememe84 8 лет назад
how can I increase my neuro things to get more concentration
@voiceofaliens
@voiceofaliens 8 лет назад
Fun exercise: listen to two talk radio stations at the same time and try to follow each conversation. It becomes clearly evident that our conscious brain has a single central processor as you switch your attention back and forth. :-) (_conscious_ processor that is.. of course our involuntary nerves keeps our heart beating, our unconscious and muscle memory drives the car while our mind drifts, etc.). I practiced this multi-listening for a few days and noticed my ability improve, but I can't say if it's helpful or harmful in any way.. just fun. Something else fun.. imagine what's happening in a specific part of the world at this exact moment. Put yourself there and experience it. Now imagine another place. And another. Now switch from one to another for a few seconds at a time, trying to be everywhere at once. It gives you that "matrix" feeling. :-)
@p.g.reitsma7245
@p.g.reitsma7245 8 лет назад
When did this 'we know that multitasking doesn't exist' begin? Why can't it? When I first heard the term, I recall it distinctly not coming with the promise of it being more productive than singletasking. It was as far as I knew, just a term to describe what we do every day as humans. Is it being dismissed merely because it doesn't live up to some new measure of productivity?
@ArgentumEmperio
@ArgentumEmperio 8 лет назад
I know multitasking is a myth and I have thought for a very long time that if we sit down and do 'several things at once', we'd look like an octopus doing them but since we don't we would do exactly like this 'several different things in rapid succession' however... I have always found a need for something playing in the background whilst I am doing something to study. And this includes audiobooks on the subject I am studying but then I need something relatively brainless (think games that require very little effort and more muscle memory) and vice versa if I am reading, studying or working (I require music at that point). One of my teachers said 'you focus better if you stop playing games and stop listening to music as it will only distract you', where as when I was talking to someone who work as a nurse (not a neuroscientist but still) who agreed that this is not uncommon or that strange as one is using 'passive' perception and the other is using 'active' perception. I am curious what scientific evidence there could be of such a thing as I think this is 'real' multitasking - not in the sense that one is doing several things at once but more fluidly going between several managable actions. Curious what people think about this.
@1324marcus
@1324marcus 5 лет назад
i think nobody knows the definition of multitasking. back when it was "invented" it probably had a different meaning, but for the last few years the definition has been "doing multiple tasks at the same time" and "being good at switching focus" of which u can do, you can do multiple tasks at once.. heres how my brain works at least, say im cooking bacon bits and texting on my phone at the same time. what happens in my consciousness is that i would first take the task of moving the pallet back and forth within the pan´s area, push that a bit into my unconsciousness, doing it by reflex and then switching my focus onto the phones texting, all the while my arm is moving "by itself" and thats where im acturally doing PROPER AND REAL MULTITASKING ← hope this triggers someone xD - where i hit the doing multiple tasks at the same time, one of them being a consciousness decicion that is made and then put on repeat basicly, while switching the focus to the phone and text. now, were something to happen, like the pallet being pushed over the edge of the pan and falling to the stove, obviously my hand would too, i would notice and switch back to the bacon, before repeating the exact same thing. that is multitasking, thats why its not a myth, but probably an old version of multitasking which WAS a myth, but thats by far more than 2 years ago that changed which is the release of this vid and comment. im calling outdated research being researched for the creation of this vid
@neanderthal1989
@neanderthal1989 8 лет назад
I like that they left out more common jobs that have to deal with this. like a gas station attendant or a cook. I'm pretty sure they have to do more "multi-tasking" then a traffic controller or a journalist, and there are no mandatory 15 minute breaks for them, at least in my experience.
@neanderthal1989
@neanderthal1989 8 лет назад
oh , wait gas attendants don't exist anywhere other the Oregon and New Jersey.
@neanderthal1989
@neanderthal1989 8 лет назад
oh , wait gas attendants don't exist anywhere other the Oregon and New Jersey.
@ruthannamarteifio9069
@ruthannamarteifio9069 8 лет назад
Thank you!
@DenniWintyr
@DenniWintyr 8 лет назад
Playing guitar & singing, when each is doing disparate melodic, or rhythmic things, is demonstrable multitasking. Yes, it takes effort, it takes practise, but you are most definitely doing two tasks both continuously, & simultaneously.
@Altrantis
@Altrantis 8 лет назад
+Denni Bryant I don't know if it is multitasking. You're playing and singing the same song which helps a lot to make both into a single activity, and you could argue when you can do both at the same time is when you come to neurologically treat them as part of the same activity. You could say driving is multitasking.
@DenniWintyr
@DenniWintyr 8 лет назад
Altrantis That's why I specified songs where the guitar part & vocal part are disparate. Look at a song like Trust, by Megadeth, the chorus melody is rhythmically and melodically totally different from the guitar part, meaning that you have to hold both melodies & rhythms in your mind at the same time.
@ayushbaxla5807
@ayushbaxla5807 5 лет назад
Bruce Lee always did multitasking with every thing eating and doing training at the same time, sleeping and training
@martonbalassa8128
@martonbalassa8128 8 лет назад
So human multitasking is about just as real as computer multitasking. Time to evolve a multi-core brain.
@MarcoSanderCoaching
@MarcoSanderCoaching 6 лет назад
sometimes multitasking might be helpful: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-2OWHqvmOjwk.html
@michaelfish3753
@michaelfish3753 9 месяцев назад
When he talks about using up the neurotransmitters, is it specifically acetylcholine or are there others?
@stephenalishtasen1540
@stephenalishtasen1540 Месяц назад
I almost got written up at Whole Foods because I intuitively knew it was abusive to Team Members who were REQUIRED to multitask all day! Yes it is burnout but the employees are mere replaceable corporate slaves!
@rafphoreign5686
@rafphoreign5686 9 месяцев назад
You can walk and listen to music thats multitasking right?
@thinzki44
@thinzki44 7 лет назад
I tend to forget easily when I'm multitasking is this normal or I have a poor memory?
@forexwolvestraders8435
@forexwolvestraders8435 8 месяцев назад
same to me
@ledtargaouschi5831
@ledtargaouschi5831 8 лет назад
Then how do this explains a musician singing to a guitar rhythm he also plays, let alone singing to a guitar solo (sometimes improvised) while singing like Hendrix for example and few others do ?
@unknown-mn9wo
@unknown-mn9wo Год назад
No one: Me listening to this video while the word voice dictate is on (because I have to write abt multitasking) while studying for my exam
@Geist452
@Geist452 8 лет назад
It stands to reason, that in a lot of situations we perceive our selves as preforming one task, but were actually preforming multiple tasks that serve different functions. For example you can read and learn from an article while spell checking it; because spell checking only requires imitation. It comes down to a strategy for creating new information and absorbing new information. Not everything that is useful to "absorb" is information orientated.. and there are a good number of tasks in the day that don't require you to continually apply new information. So as long as you know what functions cross what wires, then you should be ok for spiting those functions across multiple tasks; the issue then becomes sensory. Such a linear definition of multitasking and attention might not describe our evolutionary priorities... I think the most relevant questions are not of a grand evolution, but recomposing what we already possess. How about the title "Multitasking Is a not what we think it is, and to attempt it costs me money"
@alexlim3985
@alexlim3985 11 месяцев назад
i know this is 7 yrs ago. but dont you read and learn at the same time. you read and then you learn.
@Geist452
@Geist452 11 месяцев назад
@@alexlim3985 learning is a lot of different things, and it happens at a lot of different times. Elizabeth Filips has a good channel on what learning is. There is also a good Huberman Lab Podcast on learning.
@GORDO_MEX
@GORDO_MEX 8 лет назад
not sure what is the definition of multitasking is in your case. Your examples for rapid task switching seems like it should be multitasking but at the same time those tasks seems rather easy...how about studying professional gamers; specifically under the moba/strategy category. i'm pretty sure playing those game are heavier demanding than the examples that you gave and require numerous amounts of "switching" between individual performance, map awareness, team communication which require numerous individual tasks on their own and afterwards they still have to respond to the environment of the game to solve a specific problem in the most efficient way possible for hours at a time.
@pilot3605
@pilot3605 Год назад
Many people don't wanna hear this but it's just the truth
@gobstompper13
@gobstompper13 8 лет назад
Thank you.
@walboyfredo6025
@walboyfredo6025 3 года назад
Once upon a time I had a Boss whose only advice he gave when it comes to managing was "...Learn to juggle" . I always knew that was bullshit ......and now its confirmed!
@Mygoalweight
@Mygoalweight Год назад
Do t believe we evolved but the way we where created isn't to multitask. Got it
@ENFPerspectives
@ENFPerspectives Месяц назад
I never thought it was doing several things at once. Smh. What a piss poor definition for a word. It means doing them concurrently. And the way jobs expect people to work, people Have To Do It!!
@rajeshj5812
@rajeshj5812 9 дней назад
Should have watched this video 8 years ago
@ebandzekan
@ebandzekan Год назад
My shitty boss wants me to multitask. I can't do is not natural to me it. He gave 4-6 weeks. If I get fired its for my own good.
@Ashantiwarriorkaos
@Ashantiwarriorkaos 8 лет назад
Multitasking while listening to this in a separate tab
@foreigncontaminant2015
@foreigncontaminant2015 Год назад
Multitasking is probably what I would be made to suffer if I went to hell, for all eternity. I'd rather beak down and reorder my work into single-task queues. That way I can leave the impression I multitask, with much lower energy and stress toll. I think multitasking is nothing more than a myth invented by bosses who want the most bang-for-buck for the wages they pay out...
@TeXasDadBod
@TeXasDadBod 4 года назад
I was dropping a load in the toilet and making a business transaction on the phone. And felt better after not burned out or tired at all .
@PaleGhost69
@PaleGhost69 8 лет назад
They've obviously never seen starcraft played competitively.
@joejoejoejoejoejoe4391
@joejoejoejoejoejoe4391 2 года назад
I think the constant bombardment of information in the modern world, plus the complexity ( not as simple as if you want a home build it, if you're hungry pick a fruit ) isn't good for mental health. Some chess players tried to play many games at once, but it seems to fry their brains after a while.
@Michael_Lederman
@Michael_Lederman 8 лет назад
First of all no one can tell me we don't multitask. Do you not breath and blink at the same time? Do you not do all the tasks required to run the machine we call bodies and yet also put together puzzles does anyone truly believe we do one of these things than another in turn? I also love when we quote studies without telling us the facts of the study who, what, when, where, why and how they conducted it and what the results were. So you may believe this if you want but I choose to call it hogwash.
@mickaelsflow6774
@mickaelsflow6774 5 месяцев назад
No difference in gender on "multi-tasking" or the ability or proficiency in context switching? Interest the research and scientist don't even mention that.
@barbiegross1002
@barbiegross1002 2 года назад
True focus aimed at achieving one's greatest potential requires a massive slowdown I of functions therefore you're often called unproductive,t oo slow even when this person creates the finest results. This world currently sacrifices quality for quantity.
@MrNoNameForYou
@MrNoNameForYou 4 года назад
If multitasking doesn't exist how is it I can walk and chew gum!
@falcon45ca
@falcon45ca 8 лет назад
Tell that to the musician playing guitar, switching footpedals, singing & dancing at the same time.
@floraposteschild4184
@floraposteschild4184 8 лет назад
+falcon45ca You could tell that to a musician who does that more than a couple hours at a time.
@Zaphod23
@Zaphod23 8 лет назад
Wait, wouldn't we have to prevent bad multitaskers from breeding to select for good multitask brains?
@NeighborhoodBasketCase
@NeighborhoodBasketCase 2 года назад
Chefs and line cooks have to multitask like beasts and a lot also don’t take break . There’s a reason why I left the industry
@Kevan808
@Kevan808 8 лет назад
That was a great...hey, squirrel!
@Hansblow12
@Hansblow12 8 лет назад
Task-switching: Anesthetists and Anesthesiologists
@pacoval4577
@pacoval4577 8 лет назад
makes sense to me.
@2454014
@2454014 8 лет назад
Good work, around the lines that Andrew Carnegie spit.
@317southpaw
@317southpaw 7 лет назад
Umm... try being a line cook, lol. My mom's husband once said, "Multitasking isn't real. You can only do one thing at once." He said that while he was driving.
@miguelmendez3236
@miguelmendez3236 8 лет назад
really nice
@Reshirami
@Reshirami 6 лет назад
Is it bad to listen to music while drawing ?
@jackknight7377
@jackknight7377 7 лет назад
I say it's spiritual exercise myself. Lets ask Neil Peart!
@homefrontftw2
@homefrontftw2 8 лет назад
Speaking as an ADD person, I can multitask, thats what I do constantly. I consistently have multiple things on my mind, I don't overwork myself without heavy pressure to get something done in a period of time. I listen, watch, write and read at the same time. Multitasking is my neurological make up, it physically feels wrong to focus on a single thing, because if I do somehow achieve that.. Tends to mean something is wrong.
@elidel3299
@elidel3299 6 лет назад
Life is multitasking
@dvklaveren
@dvklaveren 8 лет назад
Is this still true for autism? The communication between each section of the brain is slower.
@dvklaveren
@dvklaveren 8 лет назад
***** Hm, I see. What I've found is that my brain seems to already have worked out a solution to a problem even though my conscience is busy working on something else. So when I consciously become aware there is even a problem, the other side of my brain seems to hand me the solution gift-wrapped.
@tonyfava2944
@tonyfava2944 8 лет назад
ok i may be stupid but i cant see how multitasking is any different then rapidly switching, and as far as i knew that is what multitasking was. And we have known for a long time the more things you do at once the worse you do, we only have so much (i dont know a better word) attention we can give at once, some people more then others. Also for people discounting "muscle memory" 1. that is still a process of the brain and is probley the closest we can get something like breathing 2. isnt this what computers do? it is just programing we have put into use so much it almost becomes automatic (e.g.. typing) i know i can be typing stuff,listening to music, and talking to people, and ya i used to suck at doing all those but after a while like doing anything i got better at it, and if that isn't multitasking then nothing does it not even computers
@moviesmagicandmore12
@moviesmagicandmore12 8 лет назад
tony fava Multitasking=reading a book +watching a video.
@rockybalboa9182
@rockybalboa9182 7 лет назад
You don't necessarily have to force your heart to breath because it naturally pumps blood though.
@frequentflyer8866
@frequentflyer8866 2 года назад
I was on WhatsApp thru out this vid missed everything
@noormansour6311
@noormansour6311 8 лет назад
Good news , I already suck at multitasking .. : )
@mrstraiban
@mrstraiban 8 лет назад
I'm still waiting for my multicore brain.
@WhtetstoneFlunky
@WhtetstoneFlunky 8 лет назад
The brain cannot multitask but a person can. I can talk on a cellphone and drive, for example. I can eat an apple while walking down the street. But I cannot carry on a telephone conversation and at the same time add two sets of numbers together. One has to stop, if only for a few seconds, while the other gets the attention.
@nwoDekaTsyawlA
@nwoDekaTsyawlA 8 лет назад
You can talk on the phone and drive, but you shouldn't. You are either paying attention to the road and missing words, thus having a poor conversation OR you are paying attention to the conversation and your reactions are greatly diminished. The tenths of a second it takes to switch back to paying attention to the traffic can cause an accident.
@homeycdawg
@homeycdawg 8 лет назад
I don't get it. He says multitasking is a myth, then goes on to explain exactly how we multitask. Task switching between multiple things is multitasking. The fact that splitting your attention between different things is less efficient than tunnel-visioning in one one thing is simply an obvious side effect of focusing on multiple things. I don't see how that in any way makes multitasking a "myth". It sounds like he's suggesting that you can't "really" multitask without a multi-core brain, like a computer CPU. That's putting the term "multitasking" into a smaller box than it belongs in.
@cortster12
@cortster12 8 лет назад
+homeycdawg He means you cannot multitask while having the same efficient on each task as focusing on a single task.
@Stratsiey
@Stratsiey 8 лет назад
It's a myth in the sense we can't handle it. It's not like we give 20% capacity to five things but some things slip by when we do multitasking. That's why people crash cars when they get to caught up in a phone call
@homeycdawg
@homeycdawg 8 лет назад
+cortster12 Right, and I agree with him that it's less efficient, but that hardly means it's a myth. It would be more accurate to label the video "Multitasking drastically reduces mental efficiency".
@cortster12
@cortster12 8 лет назад
homeycdawg But when people think of multitasking, they assume they can do each task with the same efficiency as individually.
@homeycdawg
@homeycdawg 8 лет назад
cortster12 It's a bit presumptuous to assert that people make such an assumption, don't you think? Neither me nor anybody I know has ever thought that splitting you attention doesn't impact efficiency.
@Crown95s
@Crown95s 8 лет назад
Will humanity evolve the brain traits? The way it is currently, we as a people have decided to pretty much raise the quality of life high enough for most everyone to be old enough to express their genes. How will these pro brain traits be dominant in the human gene?
@Crown95s
@Crown95s 8 лет назад
+Joe Mills So some people don't want to have children, how are positive brain traits going to be isolated? It's not like you have to be the best suited to the environment as with the progression of technology we make our environments suit us.
@XKillertofuX
@XKillertofuX 8 лет назад
interesting that means we should work shorter i guess, I'm up for that
@OfoeNelson
@OfoeNelson 2 года назад
If we're going to have biggerf brains in 20k years what does that do to women's birth canals
@Vietnam_Chr0nicles
@Vietnam_Chr0nicles 6 лет назад
IUPUI
@philipmorise7970
@philipmorise7970 8 лет назад
I shit shower and shave simultaneously each morning, saving 4 to 6 minuets on my morning commute, depending on how long my beard or the shit is. Myth my ass!
@notjustwarwick4432
@notjustwarwick4432 8 лет назад
+Philip Morise Shit and shower wtf?
@philipmorise7970
@philipmorise7970 8 лет назад
I've got a hectic schedule!
@mathew633man
@mathew633man 8 лет назад
So you shit in a bucket in shower? or you spray water on yourself while on toilet?
@liljim2221
@liljim2221 7 лет назад
So is starcraft bad for ur brain?
@skellybelly6972
@skellybelly6972 8 лет назад
Dont multitask when ur on the toilet.
@emilianotapia6004
@emilianotapia6004 8 лет назад
How about musicians who play an instrument (or more than two) at the same time while singing? Seems like multitasking to me.
@Stratsiey
@Stratsiey 8 лет назад
It's not the same thing. Playing an instrument becomes muscle memory. Multitasking refers to you reacting to different things at the same time.
@ActuatedGear
@ActuatedGear 8 лет назад
+PROven sKILL Depends on how you play it, and ultimately it still is under every "style" of play. Whether you "sing" through the instrument, read music, or just play by rote, it still qualifies because your brain is doing that. The ambulatory parts of the brain take over some of the work, but they have limits too.
@Stratsiey
@Stratsiey 8 лет назад
i would argue that learning to play something like a symphony orchestra does take tremendous practice but is ultimately not reactionary the way i think multitasking is referring to be. of course you can improvise, and keep track on changes in tempo and what not. Ultimately i think logging something your listening someone say and talking to them at the same time and reading something else at the same time is what make multitasking imo. Its more predictable playing an instrument
Далее
Stop Multitasking, Try THIS Instead | Jim Kwik
9:38
Просмотров 48 тыс.
WILL IT BURST?
00:31
Просмотров 15 млн
skibidi toilet multiverse 041
06:01
Просмотров 5 млн
5 Habits that Destroy Your Productivity
25:43
Просмотров 417 тыс.
The Myth of Multitasking | Dave Crenshaw
19:57
Просмотров 17 тыс.
Can You Really Multitask?
4:40
Просмотров 186 тыс.