My Baseball Card Hall of Fame Votes! More Vintage Than Modern? 

What do you think @mrjmangini thinks of my thumbnail?

You voted NO to the Cal Ripken Jr. Charlotte Os orange card? Just wait until Chris Sewell finds out!

I just don't know enough about vintage baseball cards. I could probably tell you the greats from the 50's rc's, I think Gibson was 59? Clemente 56? Aaron 54? Mays was 51? Mantle 51/52. I think Paige was 48? Kofax was 56? I don't know much about the early 60's baseball. I know Carew, Bench, Ryan, and Jackson are late 60's. Same with the 70's I can point out a Dave Winfield or Eddie Murray rookie, but couldn't tell you the year. I'm familiar with Ozzie, Young, Brett's RC. I know more from the 80's since it was my childhood.. I just don't know enough to have an opinion. I'm sure all the cards that I know are already in. My vote goes to the 1935 Lou Gehrig wheaties box card. It's low pop and started the craze of putting athletes on wheaties boxes.

I wasn't gonna click on this, because this topic doesn't interest me, but i just wanted to say how good your thumb nail pic for this video looks! Wow! Very eye catching! Good work!

Enjoyed it. I love the tip of the hat to the modern era (Jordan SP, Maddox RR) but would go more vintage on those 2.

It'll be hard with some of these picks because many of the greats already have a few in and with the max of 5 of any player, votes are precious. I see the hall of fame as iconic cards with several here that many have never heard of so hard to be iconic. My votes were very different for that reason

Learn something new every video. Thanks, Mike! The new thumb nails are funny! You should try making Geoff Wilson faces- those are LEGENDARY.

How in the hell did the 1988 Donruss Gregg Jefferies not make the cut? Junk wax hero means you're supposed to represent that era 😆 Todd Van Poppel would also like a word with you.

New thumbnails, sponsorship, newsletters..... Your channel growing is a good watch! The Jordan was the only 100%, easiest yes for me.

Great selections, Mike. I also voted for the Jordan Upper Deck, Walter Johnson Portrait, and Ted Williams 1941 Play Ball. But hope you are able to find the 41' Williams PlayBall, one to your liking, at the National!

Well I can't agree with all your picks but that's the great thing about opinions.

Hi Mike, I would pull the Maddox rookie and replace it with the 57 Topps Brooks Robinson. Thanks for the video.

Tony Gwynn’s butt 😂.

Gotta have more love for the o's no on brooks and cal. Come on good sir!

The Chpper should go in because it is the Desert Shield card - replace the Maddux I also love the 33 Jimmie Foxx

Nice Mike!

Oh! belongs for sure

Mike. I respect your picks but dismissing the 1983 topps or O-Pee-Chee Tony Gwynn card. Man!!! Come on now. 😮

Cheers 🥂

Mike… ok… we need to talk. Here is how I recommend you vote. First, all Yankees. You know you want to. Next, the 34 Hank Greenberg, as it mentions Lou Gehrig on it. After that, you have to put in Tom Seaver. Finally, I guess you can include a Ted Williams if you must…. Seriously, I was a few off from you. Of course, The Mantle and Mariano are a must.

I am so impressed with the thumbnail, Geo...um, I mean Mike.

I can't find the address where this HOF is located. I want to visit

Agreed on some. Definitely would’ve had Ichiro/Pujols and Bonds Tiffany

C. Sewell needs to sleep on his right side more often