Neil deGrasse Tyson on God (Response) 

*##$ Brothers, I am your sister from Palestine, Gaza. We need the requirements of the month of Ramadan, including food and drink. May God protect you with my personal photo.

May Allah s.w.t. bless you with His Noor (light) in this World as well as Hereafter.

Pakistan stop attack and blast in Mosque, and stop killed innocent family😔 May Allah protect our Muslim Brothers sisters in Pakistan

In Islamic belief, Allah tests people in various ways to see who will remain faithful to Him and who will turn away. The concept of trials and tribulations is mentioned throughout the Quran, and there are various verses that discuss how Allah tests His servants. One verse in the Quran that addresses this concept is Surah Al-Baqarah, Verse 155, which states: "And We will surely test you with something of fear and hunger and a loss of wealth and lives and fruits, but give good tidings to the patient." This verse emphasizes that Allah may test His servants with difficult situations such as fear, hunger, loss of wealth, and even loss of life. However, the verse also urges believers to remain patient and steadfast in their faith during such trials, as Allah will reward them for their perseverance. Another verse that addresses the concept of trials is Surah Al-Ankabut, Verse 2, which states: "Do people think that they will be left alone because they say: 'We believe,' and will not be tested." This verse indicates that belief alone is not sufficient to escape the trials of life, and that Allah may test His servants regardless of their level of faith. Overall, Islamic belief holds that Allah tests His servants in various ways, including through difficult and trying circumstances. However, believers are encouraged to remain patient and steadfast in their faith during such trials, as Allah will reward them for their perseverance.

Thank you for this reminder ustad Mohammed! May Allah bless you and your family with the very best in both lives and keep you safe and secure from all harm!

Morality is subjective in athiesm...because nothing matters remember

@@maddogbasil isn't this ironically hypocritical. Atheist say to us. "Oh you are bad because u think we will go to hell." But mate you don't even believe in hell. What's the problem here u donkey 😂?

Or Evil exist.

Satan one of God's children? Does god have children?

As weird as this counter question is, we still have more evidence of the concept of justice than we do for God.

Exactly

Amazing well said mash Allah

💯

If we all know existing of Good than we acting like robots. 🙏

@Peggy Todd you think those children are dead? 🙂

No one likes someone who pretends to be smart. Especially someone who tries to be right. The biggest myth athiests make is the fact that science belongs to athiesm. As if Believing in nothing boosts in your math grade.

You are obviously only able to detect arrogance in your enemy.

@@belialpig3567 to be fair even his supporters have called him that, look at the JRE podcast

@@sharkyh7327 Yes. He sure is. But so is Muhammed Hijab.

👍👍👍

Yeah. An all-knowing being testing things (which is when you seek new knowledge). What nonsense you speak.

@@crypt8919 an all-knowing testing you for two reasons: 1- because he's God, he does what he wants to do because he wants it not because he needs it, he doesn't need your or anybody else's permission, he's the highest authority in existence and non-existence. 2- he's testing you to be a witness on your own self.

When God tests us, in fact he tests himself since he created us the way we are. If he designates someone as someone skeptical by nature and another as someone gullible or naive, inevitably the skeptic will be in a critical thinking concerning the existence of God and the gullible will swallow all the fantasies that are told to him. So this test story is a vast hoax.

@@dzpol566 Yes, in your view he may do what he wants. Then it just so happens that God wants a baby born with a severe disease and watches with popcorn as they're molested for a decade. It's vaguely understandable that you'd bow to this being in fear. But, loving such a monster? That would be truly freakish.

@Crypt89 now you are imposing what your subjective beliefs of pain and suffering, which as mentioned above was already addressed

Typical athiets They always pretend to be the smartest person in the room, especially when they're by themselves in the room

Yeah it never grows old. A true classic.

@@maddogbasil the kingpins of echo chambers

Such a boring and uninteresting argument these atheists present again and again.

​@@speedking7224 A muslim is being bullied in my school daily.He is kicked and punched, many times he also cried.This is happening for years.Lol where is his God.Also terrorists exist in islam.You and stupid religion, go and waste your life for less do I care.

Why wouldn't it be just luck?

@@I_hu85ghjo there comes a point where “luck” is stretched out so much that it as an explanation simply doesn’t satisfy our question. It is a HUGE coincidence that hyper aware beings (aware of things on both large and microscopic) like us capable of higher thinking compared to other animals who have lived besides us exist, and that there is literally NO life discovered yet on other planets despite some actually being reasonably habitable is a very strange coincidence indeed.

@@I_hu85ghjo because the chance of luck resulting in all of this is such a small chance it requires more faith to believe that happened then to believe god created the universe and everything in it.

@@I_hu85ghjo listen bro. The universe in its current state with earth, life and reality, the odds of this happening out of chance is 0.000000000000001%. Even scientists have said the universe has a fine tuning. You literally have a better chance of winning the lottery. So yes there is a possibility of all of this happening out of luck with no higher power behind this but the possibility is so minuscule, I’m not willing to risk my afterlife on it.

@@m3ga975 exactly. Atheists call us wishful thinkers but you need way more faith to believe that all of this was from sheer luck then to believe in the existence of a creator. Way more faith.

Man y’all are so brainwashed! 😂😂

The Quran is man made garbage just like the Bible!

@@thecigaremperorreviewsciga7723 🤺☦🇷🇺The only ones who are bгаוndead AND washed up, are you neгdy faceless American pagaпs. Crawl back to your mommy's basement🤣👉 🇺🇲🧟‍♂️🍔🍟🍿

What are the signs?

@@Lillysg Only Moses spoke to Allah face to face

Typical Athiests I bet they break all the mirrors in their homes and step under 1 ladder a day just to make sure they're not overly superstitious.

It would

There is such life but not here in this world, but the hereafter, God Himself said about that, so dont worry...BUT, to have that life God wants to test who deserve such pleasure & happiness, do you think everyone entitled to such life, the audacity and entitlement

@@fareezaizat8684 There is too much happiness in this world but allah says you will feel it when you truly believe in me that everything which is going on is bcoz of me and i,m testing you!

The reason that many people might think that way is because of the Christian concept of the Fall of Mankind. But Islam rejects this conception, mankind wasn't intended to have that life in this world, Allah already knew that Adam and Eve, may peace be upon them, would eat from the tree; and unlike the Christian original sin where mankind inherited their sin, Allah says He accepted their repentance and humans are born upon goodness, i.e. the fitra, not in sin. In the bible it says that God regretted, but Allah doesn't regret, He is All-Knowing, it was preplanned it would be a test for us. Quran 2:30 And [mention, O Muḥammad], when your Lord said to the angels, "Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successive authority." They said, "Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we exalt You with praise and declare Your perfection?" He [Allāh] said, "Indeed, I know that which you do not know."

thats a very good analogy, i admire that.

😂😂😂😂😂😂 good one.

Dumbest shit ever written. Youre a absolute idiot

@@nevashrambaran6631 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-30YNsPUnMqo.html

@@nsbdbsbsbdbzbz8555 You're* and *an. Learn to speak English before you call someone dumb on the internet pal.

@peggytodd5164 May Allah guide you brother. I love it when someone ask about religion. Brother your question has emotional angle. I think I can't give a satisfying answer in comment. If you are serious to find Allah the all-wise than you should check this podcast of lex fridman abd omar suleiman. I hope you will get some answer. May Allah make us knowledgeable.i would like to share you first revelation to Prophet mohmmad peace and blessing of Allah on him . First word of revelation is "iqra" Mean "Read". I know little bit arbi and i is very beautiful to ponder on how Allah the all wise uses words and grammar in quran. .“Read! in the name of your Lord who created - Created man from a clinging substance (alaq) . Read and your Lord is the most Generous - Who taught by the pen - Taught man that which he knew not.” [Quran, 96: 1-5]

Hahaha this one is good.

underrated comment xD

false. He does not have one in the first place to blow it.

@@Mokh_ta7 lol!!

It’s not lack of knowledge… it’s the sickness in the heart that makes people so irrational

He's more knowledgeable than the desert god that you worship

@@horusba2620 he knows nothing about religion dumbo

​@@horusba2620what is god called in Aramaic?

@@horusba2620 knowledge doesn’t entail wisdom. And your description of God just tells us what an ignoramus you are.

Absolutely lmao

explain it

@@senadeenseadan2702 did you not watch the video or his dumb arguments or you don't possess the ability to understand even the very basic things?

@@umhummumum I bet You listen to the hijab and believe 100% it's true without thinking, analyzing, discriminating yourself, go ahead try to figure out by yourself why Nielson's argument is stupid

​@@senadeenseadan2702 nielson has the better Argumentation.

I am curious could you elaborate

Exactly. How can someone look at DNA and deny a Creator???

@@hichemagrane7878 well no one looks at an iphone and claims it didnt have an intelligent agency behind it. Looking at the workings of the cell under a microscope is like that times 1 billion. Just google SEM images of protein transportation. Or microscope footages. I mean it s amazing how our body function from cellular level to macroscopic level... to claim that this is just randomly done is insanity manifest. And if you add thermodynamics to that, the amount of free Gibbs energy that would be required to achieve such a state is insane. So to claim that that is purely spontaneous and random, is like leaving icecream in the sun for a few million years and claiming it ll freeze back up randomly.

@@FullyAutomaticAddict410 because complexity/codes or whatever isn't a sign of creation or design? Intuition is a bad way to find truth.

@@hichemagrane7878 every strain of DNA in blood in every person, has an insanely complicated strain of mathematical equations that will blow the mind of anyone doing coding. And in between the numbers, new numbers appear which make perfect sense with the initial numbers. And 2,4,6,8 never appears no matter what person we look at. Actually, coding uses a lot of the same mathematical principles as your blood. Only coding gives 1 formula, while every person has a different formula alltogether in the blood.

Lol what?

Hahaha

Most intellectual muslim

he’s saying god is not good, therefore should not be worshiped. NATURAL disasters, birth defects, cancer, etc. “god works in mysterious ways” you say that when you question god too.

Well if God is all powerfull and perfect he should have not made that day bad right? 🤔🤔

- Francis Bacon

@@dmabdullah5340 I’ll be using this 1

He said god not religion. Nice try muslims but deism is the truth not your desert age pedophile cult. COPE

@@enlightenedvagabond3556 u better watch ur mouth with the wordings, and u'll find what's the truth. We'll all find Insha'Allah

@@dmabdullah5340 nobody is scared of Islam or your desert age pedophile false prophet. Allah isn't real

looool

There is nothing intellectual about mohamma, the fact that he follows blindly an ancient religion in the 21st century shows his lack of vision

True He's a cringe merchant

but mohammed hijab gets intellectually bullied by Quranists aka hadith rejectors

He still didnt provide any evidence though.

it doesnt matter if he cares or not, it matters that it happens.

@@immoronicisdead God never said this world is paradise , This is why it is called world for a reason , and paradise will be separate

😂😂

@@rstewart2691 That's not much of a reply. You could say this to an athiest, a hindu, or about anoy other belief.

of? Have the knowledge to understand islam is charlurancult for rum dumbs

Allah is Satan brother the biblical God is the only true God Jesus is the way

Ok buddy

@@abdulamto9324 It's the truth

@@Jesusislord4569 Jesus is the way. Just like Moses was the way, Noah was the way and Abraham was the way, peace be upon all of them. Only one messenger made it abundantly clear he came for all mankind.

Whom he wills*

😅😅😅😅😅

I never consent in a test.. 😑

Finally,a person who ACTUALLY uses their brain

You're looking at this from a Christian perspective. Since death is essentially superficial in God's eyes, it doesn't matter, and furthermore, And you can't apply morality of any kind to God anyway

@@Deeeeeeeee1 but neil didnt use the good vs evil argument like hijab used. He saying why is life made miserable by cricumstances uncontrollable by human intervension. Humans naturally show compasion in different ways. God clearly doesn't. Causing more harm to humans than good all for his "test" of life.

God attributes shouldn't be taken literally as Muslims take them. Anything which has attributes, no matter how Hijab tries to explain them, is created, not a creator. The correct explanation for attributes is that we use those descriptions only for lack of other words to describe God in our limited human understanding, so we use terms which are the closest analogies. But the fact of the matter is that God has no attributes, all of them are really the same - his pure assence, not distinguished from each other

Perfectly worded. One of the proverbs I always mention.

Sure? that was me, I got deep into science and became a believer in god, then went deeper and became an atheist again (while also getting into deeper knowledge of religion).

@@Awertnex what god did you believe in?

@@Awertnex Id like to test that knowledge. What 3 concepts which are fundamental to science and it having any say in anything, are impossible to prove by science and atheism and which two of those can religion resolve? Hint: it s why muslims invented the modern scientific method.

@@dadush4 The question itself doesn't solve anything, because a lot of things are not answered by science and are answered by religion. Science is comfortable with saying "I don't know, that is beyond my knowledge as of now", religion isn't so comfortable with that, religion says "science doesn't know, but I do" and just stops there, if religion says "I do" then science expects there to be something convincing to backup said claims, and effort to disprove claims lacking in evidence is not required from science. Even outside of science and into any other field of knowledge or even common sense; you make a claim, it is simply on you to convince me it is true or I will remain atheist.

Brian Greene thoroughly explains how increasing complexity is absolutely possible despite long term inevitable entropy

@@StickHits His theory. Millions of years defying entopy seems far fetched.

@francissweeney7318 I can see how it would seem farfetched on the surface, but consider how many other facts are just as, if not more, farfetched - black holes, the scale of the universe, the paradoxes of existence and time itself. Once you learn about it though it's pretty straightforward, imagine you are going down a mountain, there may be uneven terrain that temporarily goes upward, but keep going and you will inevitably descend. Millions of years from our perspective is just a blink in the grand scheme of things.

may Allah help him excel in life

I'm a Christian believer and I like your comments. Thanks

He definitely has a way of taking any conversation and turning it into a one-sided lecture.

beautiful!

Lord ☠️😭😭 Humans are so dumb and evil (in pure way) 😭😭😭😭 Im not human, clearly. so dont rise up the presumption of humanism of person 😭😭😭

@@rdsa1 Are you ok

@@Layth71 aww pure human. Ur limited humanness is in presumption of humanity. Yep! Im pretty fine! no worrys sweetheart

@@Layth71 no. Your prayers 🤲🏼 Pray In prostration For all muslims and their sins yall unaware of how they need your prayers…

As if they were ascending up to the sky

This is mechanism in Islam which allows for easy discounting of counterarguments, yes? And if Allah is to punish them to hellfire for disbelief, why would he "seal their heart" from the outset, punishing them to burn for eternity through no will of their own? That is not the act of a moral deity.

@Cynops Anyone who thinks the world came into existence out of nothing and just out of the blue is psychologically sick. There is no argumentation here. Its a sickness. No sane person can believe something came into existence out of nothing.

​@@afnankhan43001 To the contrary, friend; you'll see that my above comments are well reasoned. I understand you may find the ideas and arguments upsetting, but they are true never the less. I discuss these topics not to upset you, but to discuss what is true. The natural sciences are, Islam is not.

@@cynops3885 What is the argument of the natural sciences?

The problem with that argument is that it evades the question. The one making the positive statement, "There is a God", bears the burden of proof. It is not anyone else's responsibility to disprove this poorly constructed argument. Negatives can generally not be proved logically in most cases anyway. You can't prove that Leprechauns don't exist any more then you can prove God does not exists.

@@OneTheBlue So why do you not take the Quran as evidence in and of itself?

أمين my أخي

May Allah protect our Muslim Brothers sisters in Pakistan Pakistan stop attack and blast in Mosque😔 and stop killed innocent family😔

🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

They cant

Except there's people who's born with no fear because the body born without pain receptors and fear neurons. He die fearlessly though

alhamduliJesus

@@AntiAtheismIsUnstoppable Pathetic

If God created evil just to test us, to then torture 80% of humanity in hell for eternity because 80% of men failed the test by remaining disbelievers, it means that God is much worse than in the objection of atheists, it depicts a God that is infinitely sadistic because even a great sadist would not torture someone incessantly throughout his life. Even the worst Nazis didn't do that. It makes more sense not to believe in god or to believe in another god(s) than to believe in a god who is ultimately a sadistic monster.

@@Maitatron god doesn’t create evil my friend. Its people that do. How is a natural disaster evil? Its a natural calamity and calamity doesn’t differentiate between a believer or a disbeliever. The cause for those calamities can sometimes be traced back to humanity. For example many of the disasters happening today are caused by climate changes and who created climate change? People. We over used the ecological footprint and over used ecological resources and invented fossil fuel technologies which is destroying the ecosystem and causing Air pollution.

@@Maitatron God gave you every reason to choose good and gave you encouragement to choose without taking away your free choice, how is it his fault that you listen to satan more than him ( who created you) and doomed yourself to internal hell. Its like when you tell your child that too much sugar is bad for them then they go eat that sugar despite your warnings and then blame you for their diabetes. How is that fair?

@@Mid_copper23 I have the free choice of what? The choice to believe or not believe, cause you think that it's a choice? Then i can choose to believe in unicorns for example? What a pity I can't believe that unicorns exist when I would love to choose to believe in them! You see it's not about choice, it's not about free-will, we do not choose to believe or not to believe that unicorns exist, your mind cannot decide to believe in them, it's something that imposes itself on you in spite of yourself. That's why we're not responsible for our beliefs, it's either a compulsion, something you can't control, or an indoctrination, in other words an external manipulation or pressure that ends up controlling your mind. Sociology shows that faith is not chosen, it's inherited, only 1% of people convert to another religion, so we are the victims of a determinism, it all depends on where we were born and the education we received. For example, if you are born as the Dalai Lama, you will remain the leader of the Buddhists all your life, there is 0% of chance that the Dalai Lama converts to another religion, and Allah would punish him in hell for eternity because he made him be born as a religious leader? This story that life is only a test to see if one is convinced by the existence of Allah or if one has not been convinced by Islam is a vast hoax, it makes no sense since we are not responsible for our beliefs.

@@Maitatron yes, it is a choice. If you weren’t given that then you will be asking why that wasn’t given to you. Be grateful

That it's in quotation marks proves how unoriginal this argument is.

Alhamdulilah, happy for you brother! It's so clear that anyone who still mentions the problem of eveil lacks the basic understanding of islam or even his own atheistic beliefs really lol

@@Moe.nadji5 yeah, he was basically basing everything from a Christian standpoint so it doesn’t make any sense anyways.

Did you imagine that We created you without any purpose, and that you will not be brought back to Us?" - Quran 23 - 115