─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: .☽ . :☆ﾟ. ─── --♡੭ु Hello Somnies, how are you doing? I am a new channel dedicated to dreamcatcher :) I will upload dreamcatcher related videos and I hope that you enjoy them! ~Yuji ♡
Hello everyone~♡ How are you doing? I hope you have a great day today! ♡ :) I hope you enjoyed my video! please read ranking at 0:06 first, B grade is vocalist level! ~Yuji
Handong powerful voice is unique too, i prefer her powerful voice like in the beginning of silent night than her soft voice in deja vu, though i like it too
My opinion Siyeon: A+++ Yoohyeon: A++ (ya'll can't say that she isn't better than the average main vocalist) Jiu: A++ (same with her) Sua: A+ Gahyeon: A Handong: A Dami: B
I feel like SuA has such an underrated voice. It's really clear and she shows good vocal technique and stability when she sings. Her voice is really satisfying to listen to and she sings like it's nothing with that intense choreo.
She doesn't have proper vocal technique. She strains the most in Dreamcatcher, especially in her chest voice. Her falsetto is gorgeous though and with ease. Her lower register lacks support. A lot of support, like, she can't project any low notes. I believe part of it has to do with her sing nasally most of the time. But overall she has power and incredible stamina, that helps her with the hardcore DC choreography.
Okay, I didn`t want to do this - but you made me. I`ll be Handong`s trash and tell that I actually stanned DC because of her vocals - her line in Emotion "Oh I can`t hold you anymore" totally got me and I entered the fandom. Btw - we all know know about Dami`s, but DAMN Gahyeon`s and Handong`s low registers!!! To die for. (that Silent night goddamn)
Tbh, yall are going to drag me. Gahyeon and Handong are exceptional vocalist and deserve a high rank. Yoohyeon actually is pretty low for me, she ranks the lowest as having a high vocal range. She usually struggles to hit high notes and her voice strains a lot.
Handong has a hauntingly beautiful voice. Her lines are among the most memorable and she always stands out. She may not be the most skilled vocalist in the world, but boy does she make up for that in her delivery of the words.
Can we like everyone agree that yoohyeon would be a Main vocal if she were not in Dreamcatcher ? And im just so overwhelmed from dc like they are THE MOST ALLROUNDER GROUP? Not to mention that my Fav Main dancer and Main vocal are in the same Group 🥰 Stan dreamcatcher !
So true. For me, Yoohyeon should be main vocalist as well with Siyeon, in kpop industry many groups have 2 main vocalists or 2 main dancers. btw SuA is my bias and I love her voice. ❤️❤️
She has little to no vocal training since she’s a rapper but she was still able to sing an Adele song perfectly, which is especially hard if it’s not your native language. Her lines in deja vu, Jazz bar and daybreak really show off her vocal talents. Tbh I would have ranked her at least an A
Dreamcatcher's vocals are strong and powerful that even their main rapper can sing! Even sub vocals can hit high notes, lead vocalists can be main vocalist too, but i know everyone of us can agree that Siyeon's voice is just so god-tier and that's why she's a main vocal, no doubt! but everyone is truly amazing. We stan talented queens!
If i didnt know dreamcatcher position i will confused af telling which one is their main vocal. Yoohyeon, sua, is definetly a main vocal level, handong, gahyeon and dami surprise me with their vocal too,. But you know siyeon power is just god tier level
I went to their concert last week and I can confirm that their vocals are to die for. (I MISS THEM SO MUCH😭 I wish to all the insomnias to have this kind of opportunity) By the way I really appreciate this video ♡
I think Dami is atleast B+ or A level as a vocalist considering her voice in "and then there was no one left" and in "jazz bar" and considering she wrote vocal parts for other members before and CAN go sing pretty high is like holy crap Siyeon is just so special of a main vocalist. like it says a lot with a group with vocalists who could be main vocalists in other groups arent because DreamCatcher has Siyeon and shes that good. To me shes up there with some of the best main vocalists of all time.
Siyeon is amazing but you can't really compare her to other k-pop vocalists cause she is more of a rock singer and uses completely different techniques than typical k-pop main vocals
*my personal ranking* (keep in mind my biases are gahyeon and handong) disclaimer: i'm not a vocal professional or anything, just a longtime kpop fan who watches a lot of vocalist analysis videos. take all of this with a bucket load of salt. JiU- A+ She has good tone, projection, emotions, and consistency throughout performances. Her range isn't quite as wide as Yoohyeon's or Siyeon's, but that doesn't mean she is not main vocalist material. Her technique has a tiny bit to improve upon because she gets breathy often, but she is a top tier lead vocalist. Gahyeon- A- (A minus) (if that was a thing) because I personally don't think she is on the same level as Handong, but not quite a B. she's improved a LOT though over the years though and I love her vocal color especially live, but her voice is better suited for lower notes. She's very stable considering most people rank her as the least skilled vocalist in DC other than Dami. Sua- A I don't think Sua is quite yet main vocalist level, especially in comparison to other idols. She is a quite nasal (not that being nasal is always bad), but her emotion is amazing. Her vocal chords can get a bit strained, but she has good vocal projection. Dami- B The fact that a main rapper with little to no training as a vocalist could sing an ADELE SONG especially Someone Like You with no struggle shows you that she is amazing. With more training and experience she could easily be at the same level as Gahyeon, maybe even go higher. She has ok vocal projection, her tone is my personal favorite, and her breath support is ok as well. Her lower range is well developed, but she has little to no technique (which is fine because she's literally a rapper), so this makes her out of tune very often. Yoohyeon- A+ (almost A++ for me) She is higher than JiU, but not quite as good of a vocalist as Siyeon. She is similar to Sua in the sense that she is very nasal, but if she used it as a temporary vocal style, not as her whole style, it would make her an even better vocalist. Yoohyeon has good breath support, rhythm, emotion, technique, and projections. She is very stable and her cover of Secret Love Song was god tier! Her cover of 2002 was also amazing. Handong- A !!!! I'm most excited to talk about my underrated Handongie. She deserves lead vocals!! Handong is outshined by the other members, but she shouldn't be. Her tone is rich and emotional and her vocal projection and range are wonderful too. Her vocal technique could be improved upon, but I feel she just needs more experience. Siyeon- A++ Obviously the most talented vocalist of Dreamcatcher, she has good tone, projection, emotions, and versatility throughout performances. She can change her pitch from nasal to breathy and anywhere in between to suit the song, similarly to Handong. Her breath support can become weak at times, but her singing skills and talent outweigh her few problems. Ranking them as a whole: 1. Siyeon 2. Yoohyeon 3. JiU 4. Handong 5. Sua 6. Gahyeon 7. Dami
i absolutely agree, especially about handongie! i’d love to hear her beautiful voice more, i must admit. i really loved her deja-vu iconic line, she’s just so talented, but sadly doesn’t have lots of lines :(
Siyeon is among the very few KPop artists so far that has literally made me question whether I'm hearing a recording or a live version. And so effortlessly too. A++ / S tier is well-deserved for her. That said, DC is an INSANE vocal group as a whole. And, as far as Han Dong being underrated, its because the other members are THAT good vocally. She's not bad, or even average, in the slightest. I hope we can get a song featuring her in the future.
I love this, but personally I would rate Gahyeon as a B. No hate, I love her, she’s just a little weak and pitchy. She’s also younger than the other girls, so she hasn’t trained as long and can totally improve. Dami also has issues with pitch, but her tone is much fuller and stronger, personally between them I think she’s a better vocalist.
Weak and pitchy? Her vocal is not even close to weak when she's the loudest member. Pitchy? Her vocal tone is on low register/bass. You gotta get your terms right or know how to properly criticize lol
@@fremzter I feel like her voice actually is a bit weak in the sense that she cannot hold notes for long while staying stable. But yes, her voice isn't really pitchy for me. Keep in mind I am a Gahyeon bias, so under no circumstances would I hate on Gahyeon.
Fremy Gonzales I’ve been studying voice for over ten years. I know my terms. Gahyeon is not even remotely the loudest member vocally, not sure where you would get that from. “Pitchy” means she doesn’t always hit a note right in the center of the pitch. I think by low register/bass you mean she is an alto, which is not true. She is a mezzo soprano from what I can tell. Not sure why you felt the need to be so sassy about it. I don’t mean any hate to Gayheon, in fact I think both her vocals and dancing have improved immensely in this comeback.
I think when it comes to Dami i feel like if she was more confident her she would sound amazing! She has an impressive range and her tone is very rich and darker compared to the other members so it brings such a nice pleasant contrast. She also has a soft sweet voice sometimes and it’s so pretty
Agreed! Her vocals are personally my favorite after Siyeon, especially her parts in Deja Vu. She’s way too underrated. And she has such duality! Her low notes in diamond and the produce 101 show were beautiful
i cant believe dreamcatcher is real... strongest vocals + dance amongst girl groups now cant think of any groups at all who can compare everyone's a main/lead vocal/dancer wtf???? their live is exactly the same as their cd version???
That's crazy how good they are, Yoohyeon, Jiu and Sua could actually be the mains vocalists if they were not in Dreamcatcher... But there's that girl, Siyeon who's out of this World and handle those hiiiiiiigh notes perfectly. For me, she's the best vocalist of all times (with Jongho of Ateez)
Sorry for that, but Jiu and Siyeon can't be a main vocalist in any other group because they can't support so their techniques are weak Yoohyeon can be but in G-idle, Everglow, STAYC, Ive and maybe Loona but the others no Sorry for that but this is actually based on technique
I wanna say this is kinda biased, because based on the real technique and what I know about vocal, vocalists are like this (I will put some vocalists that I know + Dreamcatcher's vocalists) ♡Great vocalists: S (very rare to find in Kpop) ♡Good to great: A+: Seohyang (soloist) ♡Good: A: Ailee, Lina, Uji (Soloists) ♡Proficient to good: A-: ♡Proficient: B+: Wendy (Red velvet), Taeyeon (Snsd) ♡Above average to proficient: B: Solar (Mamamoo) ♡Above average: B-: ♡Average to above average: C+: Ningning (Aespa), Wheein (Mamamoo), Hwasa (Mamamoo) , Monday (Weeekly) ♡Average: C: Jihyo (Twice), Winter (Aespa),Yuri (Iz*one), Seulgi (Red velvet) C-: ♡Weak to average: D+: Jeongyeon (Twice), Yoohyeon (Dreamcatcher), Karina (Aespa) D: Nayeon (Twice), Rosé (Blackpink), Lia (Itzy), Giselle (Aespa) ♡Weak: E+: Joy (Red velvet), Miyeon (I-dle), Mina (Twice), Yuqi (I-dle), Sihyeon (Everglow) E: E-: Mia (Everglow), Siyeon (Dreamcatcher)(The difference between Siyeon and Mia is that Mia supports a lot and her support is shallow and not consistent, while Siyeon never support +Siyeon use Rock technique and maybe this technique will damage her voice) ♡Very weak: F+: Jennie (Blackpink), Jiu (Dreamcatcher), Minnie (I-dle), SuA (Dreamcatcher), Irene (Red velvet) F: Handong (Dreamcatcher), Soojin (I-dle) F-: Gahyeon&Dami (Dreamcatcher), Lisa (Blackpink), Momo (Twice)
@@woodzyoungerbrother1214 do u mean my ranking??Why?? There are some vocalists that I'm sure about their tier like Wendy,Jennie,Ning,Jeongyeon,Lia,Rosé, Lia,Karina,Miyeon, Siyeon and Minnie , and there are vocalists that I'm not sure and I guessed their tier from their supported range
@@inyochayacha548 let me fix some… Yuri is mid average, Yoohyeon below Lia is total joke, Lia is around Giselle. Jihyo is mid average, Winter is mid-high. I’m refrained from using D+/D/D- it’s quite confusing actually lol.
Handong's voice is my favourite. Not because she is the best singer in the group (that goes to Siyeon), but it's because I like her lower/huskier vocal colour. She's great supporting vocals, and I feel her missing in 'Scream' and 'Boca' because of how interesting her voice is. I'm sad they under-utilize her. I really think that outside of just giving her more centre lines in singles, she could help produce some harmonies.
Siyeon is on another level on vocals. She has it all in vocals. Yoohyeon could be easily main vocalist in almost any other group but she still even though is an amazing vocalist isn't at Siyeons level :)
@@ble1470 but you can have two main vocals in one group. d1ce (a bg from the same company as DC) has got two main vocals, is not about wich one is better (bc of siyeon is) but if yoohyeon is main vocal material, she deserves that title.
I think Dami and Gahyeon should take more singing lessons because they have great potential. Handong should be given more lines to increase her confidence in singing..Jiu should be given more lines too and songs that suits her voice more, because In terms of technique she is really good. Yoohyeon should do more breathing exercises since she's often out of breath when singing live (without choreography). Siyeon should train to control her vibrato while Sua to control her voice better and to add more colour because her vocal timbre is already good. Btw I'm saying this because I watched their concerts and heard them singing live without backup tracks that covered their voices too much. I know that singing live while dancing is difficult, these are just opinions and I have no ill intentions. I'm an InSomnia since their debut in 2017 and I have anything but love and admiration for them.
for me: siyeon: A+++ yoohyeon: A++ jiu: A+ sua: A+ handong: A gahyeon: A dami: B I have doubts about handong because to be honest, for me, I would put an A+, her vocals are good but underrated
Watching this knowing how much the girls improved with their vocals this year, specially sua and siyeon with their technique and got a little bit triggered with the comments ignoring the potential in their voices. I forgot that this was posted a year ago and was ready to throw a fist lmao 🤣
They actually had a competition in some Korean kpop-tv about who can produce the highest note. Result was 3. SIYEON, 2. DAMI, 1. SUA. Sua has the highest note - by far.
god dreamcatcher really is THAT GROUP!! like. i’d say handong and gahyeon are both underrated vocalists but the problem is they’re up against SIYEON, who is actually a vocal god. i mean honestly they have some of the hardest choreos in the game (i learned endless night recently and it’s one of the hardest i’ve ever done second only to a fucking svt song) and yet they still sing extremely difficult songs with top-notch stability???? i saw them live in december and siyeon hit several of her notes stronger and with fuller vibrato than the studio recordings had. while DANCING FULL OUT. for an ENTIRE CONCERT. like ma’am are you human???? anyways what i’m saying is stan them
I honestly think Dami getting a B is very unjustified, just because she's a rapper. She sings very well, as proven many times, especially in songs without rapping in, and why is rapping getting degraded when that's also vocals? I think Dami is at least an A, and personally, I find her to be better than Gahyeon. Gahyeon can sing well, but you can definitely hear a little instability in her voice. Dami's voice is a lot more stable, so I would definitely rank Dami a bit higher than Gahyeon.
I completely agree with you! When I first got into dc, I didn’t know their positions and Dami’s part in deja vu is what made me stan them. I just love her voice. She has little to no vocal training but she was able to sing an Adele song perfectly and I think her highlight was her lines in jazz bar. She’s just got such a beautiful voice and obviously she could use some training since she’s a main rapper but she deserves at least an A
@@ailis7777 For me, her non-rap vocals caught me in And There Was No One Left. I think the thing that bugs me the most is that she was instantly placed in B for being a rapper.
you are thinking based on emotions and you're being biased. dami's vocals are weaker than the rest of the girl's and to be honest, the person making this video was being nice. she should really be a C. her voice shakes when she's singing, and she has yet to hit a note properly. plus she was off key when singing someone like you. this is no hate to dami, I actually like her, but you need to face the facts that she's not that good of a vocalist
@@yixingsprincess4033 You're basing your argument on a foreign song, something most idols have a bit of struggle with anyway because of the language itself. "her voice shakes when she's singing, and she has yet to hit a note properly" and you're basing this off what? Emotions was only one example, many other songs where she sings and not just raps, and it's fine. Also, the video clearly lines rapping beneath singing, which is 100% unjustified. The title says "vocal ranking" and rapping is vocal unless you want to argue that rapping comes from a piano.
I love all of DC so much and i love how unique their voices are. Gahyeon has really improved this comeback and i think that's awesome considering that her and dongie only trained for a small amount of time. I think all of them can benefit from having a vocal coach on their team though. That's not me saying they can't sing. Vocal coaches are important, even if the person can sing amazingly. They are always good to have on hand ksjfsk. Anyways, for two people who have only trained for a short amount of time, Handong and Gahyeon have improved greatly. I hope HF will finally give them both their own moments to shine like they've given the 5 other girls
ok this might be sounds rude but a real vocal ranking all of them beside Yoohyeon is on F tiers ranking, ik y'all gonna be mad but listen if singers can't support her notes that singers automatically is on the F tiers because it's so important singers to have a support range while in this case non of the girls support her note beside Yoohyeon and Yoohyeon it's the REAL vocalist on Dreamcatcher since she can support up to Bb4 pretty consistent and if Siyeon doesn't try to properly support her notes she will eventually damages her voice so bad, Siyeon (+) point is that she has a wide range and nice tone but technique wise she is one of the weakest Main Vocal on the Kpop industries, i really hope y'all giving non biased ranking and stop giving a false information... and i don't know what proof this video was while they just being stable and there's no technical explain
@@slaypa oh and btw, I kinda figured something out, Somnias were kinda right about Siyeon being one of the best Vocalists in Kpop but they worded it poorly, imo it should've been "one of the best Rock singers in Korea right now", rock requires a whole lot different technique from pop and one thing I really noticed is that no pop singers has ever bothered to sing rock songs before, it doesn't mean they're bad, but they probably can't handle the technique rock singers use
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 this one i maybe agree but she still has the elements of pop song genre on her voice so it's kinda still confusing. i would not say she is a great vocalist either but a great singers.
Okay but the fact that Dami is their main rapper and is the lowest on this list but still manages to score a B in vocals? Girl, if that don’t say something about Dreamcatcher...
Okay, I’m still learning vocal knowledge and here what I thought, fair warning. It might trigger you: 1. Yoohyeon / Siyeon ( C+ ) I would start with Siyeon, although she is really is the beast vocalist for the group, I feel like she literally damaging her voice so bad. I do love her but the technique she use is unhealthy for her vocal and she need to work on breathing support too as well, however she can control her projection, wide range and super versatile. Yoohyeon, she is good vocalist as we all know she is unofficial Main Vocalist and have better support than Siyeon did. she literally what main vocalist have but still lacking in some point, her main singing is through nose, although I believe she is using for style? Which cause her sound bit fuzzy/nasal. 2. Jiu / Sua ( C ) This remind me of Tiffany and Sunny but I would pick Jiu. Jiu is good lead vocalist, I would say, she is slightly above average lead vocalist. Her technique is healthy although her range is not wide but she literally have good tuning. Her weaknesses is she tend to sound airy, doesn’t push that much power/strength to her vocal which make it sound flair (?) flat (?). She also have bit problem in both lower/upper register. Sua, I don’t know why she is also not an official lead vocalist. She have good projection and surprisingly have wide range, her technique is way above average for sub-vocalist and par with Lead Vocalist. Although she is good but she straining so bad, she sing way too nasal which can easily overworked her vocal chord. 3. Handong ( C- ) She is good, I like her head voice. I believe she is the only member that have full and rich head voice. Although she doesn’t have wider range than the one that I mention above. She is still good and the only member with least nasally present. I think that she need to work more on technique, upper register and support. She is potential lead vocalist. 6. Gahyeon ( D+ ) I would put Dami as 6 but Gahyeon snatched the place. She is good sub-vocalist, I would say average/kind of below average level. Her technique is bit under-developed but hey, she is still improving. Her range, tuning, breathing support and projection is okay. I think that she need to focus more technique style because she have narrowed-kind support, that block her resonance (?) 7. Dami ( D ) I cannot believe Dami is Main Rapper but can sing as well as the other. She have good projection, breathing support and wide range. She lack CONFIDENCE, her technique is okay for someone that train as a rapper, she just need to improve her technique and gain gain confidence. This is how I rated: A* A A- (Above Average to Competent) B+ B B- (Average to Above Average) C+ (Siyeon, Yoohyeon) C (Jiu, Sua) C- (Handong) (Weak to Average) D+ (Gahyeon) D (Dami) D-
![[NEW] Dreamcatcher vocal ranking with PROOF!](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
