Тёмный

Ngcukaitobi slams Ramaphosa's closing ANC conference speech 

Newzroom Afrika
Подписаться 427 тыс.
Просмотров 44 тыс.
50% 1

Senior counsel Tembeka Ngcukaitobi has critisised President Cyril
Ramaphosa's closing speech at the 55th ANC national conference at
Nasrec in Johannesburg.
The constitutional law expert is concerned with the manner in which
Ramaphosa addressed the land question.
He explains further.
Tune into Newzroom Afrika channel 405 for more details.

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

19 дек 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 108   
@thembanimgenu190
@thembanimgenu190 Год назад
Time is never enough to tap into the brains of the honourable advocate.
@ramasodimalete2699
@ramasodimalete2699 Год назад
Soo true.
@tmi530
@tmi530 Год назад
wow! we need the whole day with Advocate, there's a lot to learn from him...
@ramasodimalete2699
@ramasodimalete2699 Год назад
Wow this man is soo learned with regard to land reform!
@vamangcobo7344
@vamangcobo7344 Год назад
We will protect Ingonyama trust until we know for sure that we safe from ANC POLITICS of selling out.. Since CODESA ANC is selling out
@lawrenceletlhatlhe8525
@lawrenceletlhatlhe8525 Год назад
Zulu thinks they r best shm . Ai .
@mzwandileyende5589
@mzwandileyende5589 Год назад
We must. Ignore fools who don't see it and resort to tribalism!
@davidmmahlangu3720
@davidmmahlangu3720 Год назад
This is too deep for a common Zulu to understand because even Zuma is leasing the land from the Zwelithini Family not Zulu Kingdom. Should Zuma fail or his disrespecting children in future be unruly to the King, they will be expelled from Nkandla with immediate effect. Inkatha doesn't want native South African Zulus to atleast occupy land instead they want them to lease it and be submissive to the Zwelithini family as long as you leave.
@dineodipela1484
@dineodipela1484 Год назад
@@lawrenceletlhatlhe8525 they think they owe South Africa . Flip flops that’s why they failed with their president Zweli because they didn’t have Plan B
@londiwemthabela9037
@londiwemthabela9037 Год назад
What are you benefitting from Ingonyama trust? Please see bigger picture
@luckyshabangu9511
@luckyshabangu9511 Год назад
One of the best ligal mind
@mandlenkosishabalala8890
@mandlenkosishabalala8890 Год назад
Ngcukaitobi is well conversent with the land issue.
@kebuengmvungama3998
@kebuengmvungama3998 Год назад
Agree with the analysis by SC
@zuzemoyo7696
@zuzemoyo7696 Год назад
South Africa must accept that it is afraid to take the necessary steps needed to take responsibility for itself and the Black people.
@trustingnobody628
@trustingnobody628 Год назад
How far did you go with this matter in your country? Why are you inundating our country as you weren't afraid to take the necessary steps in your country ZIMBABWE. In South Africa we have a Constitution and other pieces of legislation that we have to observe in any thing we are doing. We are not barbaric and act as hooligans. Afraid!!!
@sandymachaba9936
@sandymachaba9936 Год назад
Not bye a long mile.Very brittle to say the least.No spine to tru the pain of land reform.No wonder the govt hasn't taken steps to address the land reform issue.
@vimbiv3133
@vimbiv3133 Год назад
@@trustingnobody628 That's all You Good at, giving Mandela speeches. White people have you under their thumb with your flawed constitution and your Dutch Roman legislative law. Barbarism is supporting the oppression of Blacks by a minority under the guise of civilization
@juniormolefe3046
@juniormolefe3046 Год назад
ANC has elected 3 potential convicts in Ramadollar Mantashing Mokonyane according to Zondos Rbln novel 🙄🙄
@enricodipasquale113
@enricodipasquale113 Год назад
Just shows the anc is corrupt to the core.
@juniormolefe3046
@juniormolefe3046 Год назад
Jooste Wiese Steinhoff Glencore are the biggest winners of the ANC conference 🙄
@hleskomlan4817
@hleskomlan4817 Год назад
His lawyer slamming him? Wow!
@sifisocyprianshezi3824
@sifisocyprianshezi3824 Год назад
Our country is going somewhere ... Something big is going to happen in this country, like it or not ... Our country is going somewhere ... Let's prepare for the worst, something we have never seen before ... Our country is going somewhere !!!
@mxobhungane143
@mxobhungane143 Год назад
Loadshedding
@deadmanza
@deadmanza Год назад
Zim has done so well since they implemented EWC makes perfect sense that we do the same. Well done.
@gedenironald8635
@gedenironald8635 Год назад
Today Zimbabwe’s farmers are doing great, check the news, it must pain you.You seem to think that we don’t have black extremely successful commercial farmers, we do and I know a lot of them. Before you arrived in Africa 400 years ago, we were the farmers before your satanic forefathers took our land.
@ignatiouschikurahove7239
@ignatiouschikurahove7239 Год назад
Dead man I believe you are dead for real. Anyway I as a Christian I don't believe that the dead can talk. If you come to life one day you will see that Zimbabwe is dead the same like you
@deadmanza
@deadmanza Год назад
@@ignatiouschikurahove7239 Ignatious perhaps the nuances of sarcasm escape you. Yes, Zimbabwe is indeed dead. It is dead due to bad policy from bad leaders. Much like South Africa will be if it does the same.
@loyisomalobola687
@loyisomalobola687 Год назад
@@deadmanza So long as the issue of agrarian reform, which can't be separated from rural development (thus curbing urbanization & all that it implies) is left unresolved, it leaves the door open for a desperate populist leader in the face of popular unrest, in a bid to divert mass anger, to opt for land invasions just as Mugabe did decades ago. Don't be selective in your analysis of history.
@trustingnobody628
@trustingnobody628 Год назад
Mfm!! Keep ZIMBABWE out of our affairs. They forcefully took the land from the white farmers. Meaning, they have land that belongs to them as they always make noise about it. However, we are astonished because the Zimbabweans are giving their backs to their own land and are scattered all over other countries, especially in South Africa. So, exclude these people from our land affairs. Is not the land issue discussed in our Parliament? As far as I know is that they are busy with this matter. Therefore, let that process take its course.
@moremimatobako5044
@moremimatobako5044 Год назад
Nice style
@garethbarry3825
@garethbarry3825 Год назад
I found this speech very enlightening, educational. I would also add regarding the issue of land shortage, that apparently the majority of South Aficans DO NOT want to work the land, just look at the influx of people into the cities, in vain unfortunately because there are no jobs available because of an anti-free market ideology of thw government. This then makes the cry for land understandable, as people who have not been lucky in the cities look to something else to escape poverty.
@olwethupoto1077
@olwethupoto1077 Год назад
I would argue that they do want land but need funding and skills to work the land and skills on how to access the market local and international
@garethbarry3825
@garethbarry3825 Год назад
@@olwethupoto1077 By far the vast majority of land-claimants do not opt for the land, but prefer to take a cash payout, even when offered financial support from banks and government, so no, i am afraid that the facts dont match your argument. My comment comes across more nasty than i intended, for which i apologise
@mtetelelimrwetyana2002
@mtetelelimrwetyana2002 Год назад
Unfortunately Ramaphosa will never implement conference policies. We will never trust ANC, just noise of (we must, we will).
@AlieSonata
@AlieSonata Год назад
I like the legal historical wrongs explained and clarity,,... that has been imbedded in the property laws and privacy laws... Therefore those aspects needs to be reviewed and the whole Black Administration ACT needs to be completely declared unconstitutional and no law should be based or be reference on it.....leaseholds law also..
@oscarmakgaka4840
@oscarmakgaka4840 Год назад
Thank u Sir. Sellout SA is gone. Our last hope is EFF
@Eddie-tn2om
@Eddie-tn2om Год назад
I am still waiting for him to slam the speech. is part 2 still coming?🤔 I heard an opinion though
@ramasodimalete2699
@ramasodimalete2699 Год назад
If you listen properly you’ll hear that he, criticises the speech for not showing how much progress the ANC has made in respect of land redistribution, tenure and rights of use, post-use and occupation. & a lack of a good system.
@siyabongandumo8921
@siyabongandumo8921 Год назад
@@ramasodimalete2699 lol maybe he doesn't understand English
@talundizkatyhopho4813
@talundizkatyhopho4813 Год назад
There is no part 2, its the issue of comprehension from your part
@khayazikhali9340
@khayazikhali9340 Год назад
I wish we could be taught about land not educated about it
@ramasodimalete2699
@ramasodimalete2699 Год назад
The ANC has no policy for land reform!
@fabinasetati8736
@fabinasetati8736 Год назад
Well articulated. Thank you SC
@siyabongakoyo238
@siyabongakoyo238 Год назад
But Ramaphosa is always vague on everything, while listening to him you never get a sense that he means what he says.
@sandymachaba9936
@sandymachaba9936 Год назад
Typical politician.Speaks with forked tongue.
@menzimngadi6793
@menzimngadi6793 Год назад
Because he is hiding something
@masibam7752
@masibam7752 Год назад
The only thing he was clear about was the lockdown levels. He says nothing basically
@dlepuno
@dlepuno Год назад
All he’s saying is that the ANC has done nothing to uplift the poor and marginalised, that economic emancipation of the people was never an ANC agenda.
@anhonestlife380
@anhonestlife380 Год назад
We are not yet interested in the land of kings. There are many benefits to that style of community. We are interested in the land that was taken by force and doesn't serve the people now
@uncleforbes4840
@uncleforbes4840 Год назад
We are interested in all land kings and ill gotten one . We are not gonna bit about the bush
@maryduplessis2510
@maryduplessis2510 Год назад
So conquest doesn't fit your narrative? Conquest is a legal means of aquiring land which is effectively what Russia is doing at this very moment and the ANC and EFF LOVE Russia. If everybody in the world said they must have their land back then there would be the biggest f'up in history dating back to when exactly??? Seems you have lost your power to reason clearly or is it that your unrealistic powers of deduction are purely based on revenge? Seems that is the case an/or you are one of those idiots that fails to recognise your own hypocrisy and wish for immediate gratification which you have not earned so that land conquered by your tribe is only valid. Dumber then dumb.
@anhonestlife380
@anhonestlife380 Год назад
@@uncleforbes4840 beat...
@beverleyuntiedt1777
@beverleyuntiedt1777 Год назад
Help! I need some clarification! Weren't homelands, Boputatswana, Zulu land given to the natives? Why do the natives want land close to industrial colonised hubs? My heart bleeds for the changes of street / city names. The hijacking of radio stations. The native does not create jobs, does not build new business hubs. The native hates the white man but wants to emulate all forms of whiteness! If van Riebeeck hadn't come to the Cape where would SA be today?
@nickbulunga8849
@nickbulunga8849 Год назад
😳😳😳
@operationshub2163
@operationshub2163 Год назад
The state allready owns majority land. 2nd to that Zulu kingdom
@hedleyfurio
@hedleyfurio Год назад
It is nearly 2023 , harping on about rural communities land , colonialism, apartheid are discussions of the 70’s and don’t take anyone forward . People have been moving into cities for years in search of education jobs and on many occasions productive farms that have been transferred have been totally broken after a few years . Historical context should not pull a nation back , but we need leaders and commenters who pull us all forward . Get a piece of land to go to the bank and get a loan and then ???? . The guest knows his stuff but I really think it does not help anyone . The Jewish won’t forget the holocaust but move forward , do not wait for handouts and free but get on with their lives . Education and industrious people is what any country needs . Those who can’t teach, and those who can DO .
@molwantwamfisa8367
@molwantwamfisa8367 Год назад
We will never move forward as long as we didn't address the land taken forcefully from other people. The British had no right to come all the way from where ever they were coming from to tell Africans what is right for them. Get over it. We are going to take this land forcefully back. You like it or not.
@sibonisoerolmkhwanazi
@sibonisoerolmkhwanazi Год назад
The reason why the Jewish ppl were able dust themselves up is because they got reparations so don't compare the two.
@hedleyfurio
@hedleyfurio Год назад
@@sibonisoerolmkhwanazi I wish the ‘ victims ‘ could spell out exactly how they personally were harmed, exactly what specifically was stolen from them , by who and then what reparations they feel entitled to . They could then get paid out , and we could all move on. Broad statements like “ our land and our future , and our dignity was stolen by the British , who by the way , arrived in 1820 and not in 1652 when the Dutch followed by the French arrived. No one gave me land , no one gave me free education , no one gave me a grant . I worked for 35 years before I could stop paying rent , and BUY a small piece 900sq.m of land and am still working at 66 to put food on the table , as I have no pension or savings , BUT I have never thought I have a tough life and others should help me. A read of Nietzsche or Solzhenitsyn helps put things in perspective.
@sindiso_ndlovu
@sindiso_ndlovu Год назад
@@hedleyfurio why you talk about education when you don't sound like someone who is educated at all. Zuma that you mock is way more informed than how you sound. The fact that you are in Africa when the majority of people with your skin color are in Europe should be bothering you.
@hedleyfurio
@hedleyfurio Год назад
@@sindiso_ndlovu The only thing that bothers me is people who in 2023 still refer to skin colour . I am not bothered about anything except people who don’t add value . Yes I only have a matric , worked for 45 years and am still working at 66 , to build a business in which most employees , 95% are black ( seen as you can’t get past skin Color ) , this has allowed most of my team to raise and educate families so - what have you done ? . Talk is cheap bit what will make a difference is team work and building the country rather being a fanboy of politicians in the hopes of getting free anything .
@oscarmakgaka4840
@oscarmakgaka4840 Год назад
I still don't understand media and SA citizens celebrating Ramaphosa win in name of renewal. Second term still renewal no policy discussions yoh.
@lolongubeni1748
@lolongubeni1748 Год назад
It blows my mind that in a globalized, capitalist economy we are preoccupied with understanding mechanisms of land ownership that are misaligned with models endemic in the system. Africans love to delay. Capitalism is premised on property rights, individual aspirations, etc. Anything that doesn’t align these principles is a waste of time. Communal rights is more aligned to socialists notions of arranging the economy, what most see as communism...why are we even discussing versions of what we hv collectively rejected? Mind boggling!
@neermalapillay8016
@neermalapillay8016 Год назад
The late anc people for the struggle lived among the people they saw the people's needs unlike now politicians are far from reality
@mxobhungane143
@mxobhungane143 Год назад
... Maybe no eWallet lately 🤣
@mvuyimpithi8648
@mvuyimpithi8648 Год назад
Grey hair already 🙄
@dineodipela1484
@dineodipela1484 Год назад
Rusty brains 🧠
@siyabongajacobdlamini1764
@siyabongajacobdlamini1764 Год назад
Inkinga ikuphi ukuthi umhlaba ubuyele kubantu.
@Dzhambila
@Dzhambila Год назад
Slam is an exaggeration
@davidmmahlangu3720
@davidmmahlangu3720 Год назад
This is too deep for a common tribalistic Zulu to understand because even Zuma is leasing the land from the Zwelithini Family not Zulu Kingdom. Should Zuma fail or his disrespecting children in future be unruly to the King, they will be expelled from Nkandla with immediate effect. Inkatha doesn't want native South African Zulus to atleast occupy land instead they want them to lease it and be submissive to the Zwelithini family as long as you leave.
@garethbarry3825
@garethbarry3825 Год назад
It seems absolutely baffling to me that people in Ngonyama Trust have not been given title deeds-it seems such an obvious thing to do, and would totally transform the economy. I live in a suburb where all the normal rights of ownership etc apply. 2km away, over a hill, is ruled by the chief, with a totally different set of rules, like 2 different countries....
@sibonisoerolmkhwanazi
@sibonisoerolmkhwanazi Год назад
I wonder what has the Zulu Nation got to do with the government inability to redistribute land to the natives everything that is wrong is blamed on the Zulus.We are observing this behavior being driven by Phala Phala & his grouping to blame everything on the Zulu Nation.
@sindiso_ndlovu
@sindiso_ndlovu Год назад
Why do people publicly talk about something they don't know nothing about. KZN is the only province that has preserved the biggest portion of land to be used by natives. I live in the land under Ingonyama Trust, we've never had any issues concerning ownership of land and the rules set by Ingonyama Trust makes it clear that no land will be seized from its owner or owner being expelled (ukudingiswa) unless the family is committed a serious crime and found guilty. Before you get expelled the men from the area discuss the seriousness of your crime before the Chief make a final decision. White people has never been happy with any successful blacks project they always find something to criticize
@garethbarry3825
@garethbarry3825 Год назад
@@sindiso_ndlovu Just to say, i dont intend to criticise you or the Zulu people in any way - I think any sane person only wishes the best for all South Africans. I still think that people living on the land should be given full title deeds, so that they are then free to buy, sell and take a loan out against the land. Is this a bad idea? If so can you explain why?
@davidmmahlangu3720
@davidmmahlangu3720 Год назад
@sindisondlovu You totally missed the point. People or natives need land ownership not access. Ingonyama Trust is worse than what happened in 1913 Land Act. Only one family has the title deed and the rest Leasehold (no more PTO). The Zulus don't understand these things maybe and if they were written in their native language they would understand that even their 4th generation will never have a title deed under this gift from apartheid regime under De Klerk to the Zwelithini family.
@operationshub2163
@operationshub2163 Год назад
Rural development is a myth
@lungamasuku6872
@lungamasuku6872 Год назад
Land expropriation without compensation is the only way
@sandymachaba9936
@sandymachaba9936 Год назад
That comes at heavy cost of which I doubt that locals will be willing to bear.fragile
@thembinkosifrans9513
@thembinkosifrans9513 Год назад
Viva that's the only way
@lungamasuku6872
@lungamasuku6872 Год назад
@@sandymachaba9936doubt on!
@modisemakokwe4256
@modisemakokwe4256 Год назад
I feel so sorry for KZN people yoh
@sifisodube4686
@sifisodube4686 Год назад
You are a lawyer stop getting in to politics, wash your hair
@sandymachaba9936
@sandymachaba9936 Год назад
Lol. Shut your Gob
@sifisodube4686
@sifisodube4686 Год назад
@@sandymachaba9936 you to shut yours nobert
@dipuonina2894
@dipuonina2894 Год назад
You just opening your mouth.
@Eddie-tn2om
@Eddie-tn2om Год назад
How else will he speak🤔
@kgomotsomashilane5194
@kgomotsomashilane5194 Год назад
Utter rubbish
@dineodipela1484
@dineodipela1484 Год назад
@@Eddie-tn2om shut his mouth to avoid stress and grey hair all over his body
@sandymachaba9936
@sandymachaba9936 Год назад
You rite coz all he said went over your head.dimwit
@oscarmakgaka4840
@oscarmakgaka4840 Год назад
ANC just sell out man
@oscarmakgaka4840
@oscarmakgaka4840 Год назад
SA is not the country I know. We given up we cannot fight anymore when things are not going right we seems to be given up. So unfortunate
Далее
Dr Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma sets the record straight
52:02
Gwede Mantashe reacts to the Phala Phala saga
36:36
Просмотров 67 тыс.
Как пронести Конфеты В ТЮРЬМУ
19:16
One day of three of ANC NEC unpacked
7:19
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.
Gigaba speaks out on ANC matters, Phala Phala
38:19
Просмотров 169 тыс.
DPWI probes why two government buildings remain vacant
3:39
In conversation with ANC chairperson Gwede Mantashe
32:16
Вилка для консервов 🥒
0:51
Просмотров 3,2 млн
Высокий Питер😂😄
0:52
Просмотров 1,1 млн