I have seen many videos from Nightwish and Floor Jansen in concert, but I have never seen her as joyful and energetic as on this one which was my first concert experience with Nightwish and Floor. And even in our own big arena Oslo Spektrum.
Please: I cannot be the only one crying at the fact Marko Hietala is not there...... :( His voice makes this song so powerful. THE FLOOR + MARKO TRIO = FOREVER GONE. MARKO WE MSIS YOU. I WANT MY TEARS BACK NOW....
@@CataldisistemasAr Yes, i would do this, you are absolutlly right. I see this 2018 live in Germany, Oberhausen and it was great to see Emppu flees.🤣🤣😂😂🥰🥰
Wonderful work. Congratulations. Greetings, M.AFONSO INNOVATION 🌍🇧🇷🦅🌞🌟💫🙏 Happy New Year with lots of love, music, health, peace and prosperity💋❣️🌹🙏 DJMA & DJ Mário Afonso
Why? Because Marko Hietala isn't there? I don't believe there is any fundamental difference between this performance and the one in, say the Decades show filmed in Buenos Aires. If in your opinion there is then kindly point it out.
Wanna be out of the crowd for once. She's awesome as always but they should simply avoid some songs without Marco. Troy is no lead singer (while he's great at EVERYTHING else included astrophysics I bet) and some songs like this NEED a distinctive voice like Marco's to stand against Floor's. Just my opinion, though, and of course it would be a hard choice.
@@cey1 Yep, he actually can. He is the bassist and back vocalist in a band called “wintersun” (Kai is also from there). But he does growling in the majority
End of an Era...Fan since 2008...Sorry but this is the end. Farewell Nightwish! Floor is amazing in concert but lacks the vocal clarity and without Marko....just doesn't work.
we all miss marko, but nightwish have passed through a worst eras (anette olzon vocals live), and they returned stronger and better, so i think and hope one day either marko will back or they will change to other vocals. but it is not troy fault, he is an d outstanding wind and guitar performer. and without him, will also be an emptyness in the songs
BS. In this song Floor is keeping it to a "normal" singing style without extra effort. But when she pulls the stops out she is by far the best Vocalist that NW ever had. Tarja = only a few impressive "operatic" high notes, for the rest 90% waiting for the next "impressive high note". Annette is not able to consistently sing on pitch. Floor on the other hand has an impressive list of vocal live highpoints: "Shoemaker", GLS (in several versions), Poet and the Pendulum , Greatest show on earth, Romanticide, Song of MySelf, Hows the Heart (live accoustic), etc. etc.. Floor is best (by far)
@@rientsdijkstra4266 The most successful albums were produced under Annette as lead singer. I believe this record will not be broken by Floor. Granted her LIVE performances are great but...album sales IMHO will forever be Annette's forte.
@@greggrimes115 Ok, that is true: allthough I think that Human || Nature is actually the best album by Nightwish, it seems a bit too far out (and Folky) for most fans of the original NW, and EFMB as an album was not really inspired (allthough there are a number of good songs on it) But I think the Nightwish with Floor make more then up for this in the live performances. Indeed Annette's forte is more in studio work there she sound good and has a style of her own, while her live work is wobbly: sometimes it is quite good, but then sometimes she fails quite painfully on stage (even in songs wich she sang OK on other occaisions) My theory is that Floor, with her classical training, knows better how to sing "efficiently", without overtaxing her vocal chords, wich enables to sing more consistently in live performances. That is why she can produce a performance like GLS at Wacken 2013, which was the 13th song in a 15 song set... (and storytime, Romanticide and Song of Myself, 3 other bangers where also at the end) or why she can comfortably do "Stargazers" in Tampere 2015 in lyrical head voice, shortly after having done the Growling of "Yours is an empty hope". Futhermore Floor is a "podium animal" by nature, she feeds of the adrenaline (as you can see in this video...) while I think Annette feels more at home in the studio. For as far as the future is concerned: they are recording a new album at the moment, so much will depend on that... And for as far the line up is concerned: I must say that as fun as this video is with Floor going all out to fill the void (literally and metaphorically), I always have a big smile on my face when I have watched this, it is also clear that she is a bit lonely on that big stage (notwithstanding the very good chemistry and fun between her and the boys..) . She could really do with a singing partner like Marco (maybe an extra male singer with vocals like Marco's?) And by the way: in such a handheld recording as this it will always be harder to hear the vocals.
WTF does that mean? Don't you get it? Let me spell it out. No male singer = Nightwish finished. Over. Dead. Gone Forever. RIP. Confined to history Floor Jansen can't do it all by herself and to replace Hietala fully they would need a top-class vocalist/bassist and there are not many of them. Get real.
